KARTIK ABHISHEK NARESH AISHA RAKESH ALAGARSAMY RUJUL ZILMIL

COMPARISION BETWEEN BRTS : AMTS : AUTO-RICKSHAW

NAROL CIRCLE - SONI NI CHALI

BRTS

AUTO-RICKSHAW

AMTS

AUTO RICKSHAW

A.M.T.S.• OLD• NEW (JNNURM)

B.R.T.S.• A/C• NON A/C

STUDY STRETCH

NAROL

SONI NI CHALI

LENGTH OF THE STRETCH – 8.6 KM

NAROL CIRCLE

JASHODANAGAR

EXPRESS HIGHWAY JUNCTION

CTM FLYOVER

SONI NI CHALI

Soni ni Chali

Rameswar Park

Ramrajya Nagar

Rabari Colony

Jogeswari Society

Purvadeep Society

CTM Crossroad

Express Highway JunctionJashodanagar

Ghodasar

Isanpur

Mukesh IndustriesNarol

Geeta Gauri Cinema

600 m750 m

850 m

1.5 KM

550 m

600 m

600 m

550 m

500 m

550 m

600 m

500 m

450 m

“THE EXPERIENCE”

MOTA BHAIA service class gentleman

JIGNESHA student

HEMA BEN A Middle Aged lady.

SCENE 1: MOTA BHAI AND JIGNESH STANDING AT THE NAROLE CIRCLE.

Urgent work at Soni Ni Chali. Have to reach fast. Uncle, take an auto.

Auto is too costly, 70 Rs...!!

I think I should go in BRTS. It comes soon. Why don’t you join me?

No. I am waiting for AMTS. I have a pass.

Crosses road to take a BRTS........

Going to Catch a BRTS

Still waiting for AMTS

Comes with bags. Walking towards BRTS.

At BRTS ticket counter: Comes to know regarding extra luggage charges.

Rethinks: Crowded bus and luggage charges also, better to go in AUTO.

Returning to catch an Auto…..

Gets an auto very easily.

I AM STILL WAITING FOR AMTS.

Finally AMTS 130/2 no. arrives after waiting for long time.

PARAMETERS• Fare & Concession.• Journey Time.• Comfort.

Shelter. Way Finding. Ticket purchasing. Waiting time. Standing & Sitting space.

Condition of vehicle. Entrance and Exit.

• Cleanliness & maintenance.• Noise Level.

FARE & CONCESSIONS

Service Fare

BRTS Rs. 11

AMTS Rs. 10

Auto-Rickshaws

Rs. 70

B.R.T.S A.M.T.S AUTO RICKSHAW

Smart Card Recharge

Student’s Concession(monthly Rs 100)

No concession

Rs 110 for Rs 100 recharge.

Concession for the Handicapped

Travel as u like.Monthly pass at Rs 600

Senior citizens (above the age of 65years-50% off & free above 75 years age.)

CONCESSIONSFARE

FARE & CONCESSIONS

JOURNEY TIME

B.R.T.S A.M.T.S AUTO RICKSHAW

2+15 min 20+25min 20min

JOURNEY TIME

• This time consists of the waiting time and the time taken to reach the destination.

Commuters gave more preference to BRTS.

FREQUENCY

FREQUENCY

BRTS AMTS AUTO-RICKSHAW20 BUSES/HR 3 BUSES/HR 12O AUTOS/HR

BRTS and Auto Rickshaws are available very frequently.AMTS is not frequent as compared to the other two

modes.

INFERENCEBRTS AMTS Auto

Rickshaw

Availability

Frequency

Journey Time

Fare

FARE• Particular type of users (old aged, senior citizens & people with no time restrictions ) prefer AMTS.• Concessions promotes these users to prefer AMTS.

JOURNEY TIME & FREQUENCY• BRTS Preferred.

COMFORT

Shelter Bus Stops

Shelter less Bus Stops

AMTSBRTSSHELTER BUS

STOP

WAY FINDING

Conveys the route EFFECTIVELY.

Uneasy for NON GUJARATIS

TICKET PURCHASING

Organized & hassle free

Organized but not hassle free

STANDING & SITING SPACE

CONDITION OF VEHICLE

Handles at appropriate height

No Handles

HANDLES

BRTS

AMTS

BRTS AMTS

Spacious(73cm)

Not as spacious as BRTS(55cm)

GANG WAY

BRTS AMTS Auto-RickshawCONDITION OF VEHICLE

VEHICLE ENTRY & EXIT

AMTS - Problem due to step boarding

Broad entry & exit with level boarding

BRTS

INFERENCE-COMFORT

BRTS AMTS Auto Rickshaw

Condition of vehicle

Way finding -

Shelter -

Ticket Purchasing

Waiting Time

Standing / Sitting Availability

NOISE LEVELS

Noise levels didn’t make a significant difference on commuters preference of one mode over the other.

Service Noise

BRTS 65-70db Non A/C

50-55db A/C

AMTS 70-75db Old

70-75db New

Auto-Rickshaws 73-77db

NOISE LEVELS

CONCLUSION

After considering all the above parameters, we came to a conclusion

that except a few type of users, majority of the people prefer to travel

in BRTS.

Thank You

Thank You

AMTS bus stops narol circle cadila ware house geeta process vatwa cross roadsSamrat nagar jeevan pura 3 royal tiles cadila bridge jashodanagar cross roads saraswati nagaraSardar patel swaminarayan colony CTM cross roads 5 kailash colony ajay tenements Rabari colony ramrajya nagar 8 harbole nath rajdeep society raj ratan society gauri society soni ni chali cross road8

StationDistanc

e in meter

Fare

Narol --- ---

Mukesh Industries

600 3

Isanpur 750 3

Ghodasar 850 3

Jashodanagar

1500 5

Express Highway Junction

550 7

CTM Crossroad

600 7

Purvadeep Society

600 7

Jogeswari Society 550 7

Rabari Colony 500 7

Ramrajya Nagar 550 8

Rameswar Park 600 9

Geeta Gauri Cinema 500 9

Soni ni Chali 450 11