Post on 16-Jul-2015
Networked journalism and the Arab
Spring#mac201@rob_jewitt
1
John Gilmore
“The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it”
TIME magazine (6 Dec 1993)
2
Outline1. Networked journalism
2. The Twitter revolution?
Lessons from Iran
3. The Arab Spring and
activism
3
Transformation of journalism“In the 20th Century making the news was almost entirely the province of journalists… The economics of publishing and broadcasting created large, arrogant institutions – call it Big Media…
Big media … treated the news as a lecture. We told you what the news was…. Tomorrow’s news reporting and production will be more of a conversation, or a seminar…” (2004: xiii)
4
5
Asian Tsunami 2004
London 7/7 2005
Mumbai 2008
US Airways #1549 2009
Networked journalism A term that has been floating around for some
time…
Jeff Jarvis (2006)
Journalism professor at CUNY Graduate School of Journalism; blogger; writer
Charlie Beckett (2008)
Director of Polis, at the London School of Economics; writer; former broadcast editor at BBC, ITN & C4
6
Networked journalism
Jeff Jarvis (2006)
“Networked journalism” takes into account the
collaborative nature of journalism now: professionals
and amateurs working together to get the real story,
linking to each other across brands and old
boundaries to share facts, questions, answers, ideas,
perspectives. It recognizes the complex relationships
that will make news. And it focuses on the process
more than the product.
7
Networked journalism Charlie Beckett (2008)
The idea that traditional journalism opens itself up to the public. It shares the production process from start to finish. It uses new technologies to include the citizen in every aspect of news-gathering, production and publication. It means using a lot of jargon like crowd-sourcing, social networking, wikisand Twittering. Many of these techniques build on existing journalism methods and are already out there. But it will also require a participatory revolution in the way we make the news.
8
Networked journalism
Charlie Beckett (2010)
By ‘Networked Journalism’ I mean a synthesis of
traditional news journalism and the emerging forms
of participatory media enabled by Web 2.0
technologies such as mobile phones, email,
websites, blogs, micro-blogging, and social networks
9
Social media revolutions?
10
revolution
revolution
#iranelection
A disparate series of events, reports, protests, accounts, links, stories, etc across multiple media
platforms by social agents seeking to redress a
perceived and actual danger
11
Top Twitter Trends of 2009
“The terms #iranelection, Iran and Tehran were all in the top-21 of Trending Topics, and
#iranelection finished in a close second behind
the regular weekly favorite #musicmonday.”
Abdur, Dec 15 2009
12
13
10th Iranian election, aka:
Green Revolution
Sea of Green
Twitter Revolution
Persian Awakening
14
June 12: The Election Official (disputed!) results:
Ahmadinejad = 24.5 million votes (62.6%)
Mousavi = 13.2 million votes (33.7%)
Over 80% voter turnout
Both claimed they had secured majority of (58-60%) vote
15
16
Other social media
Wikipedia
YouTube
Flickr
17
June 13-14: Protests Mainstream media fingered for poor coverage =
#CNNFail
Al Jazeera English charges Iranian government of direct censorship
Al Arabiya’s Tehran office shut down
NBC News in Tehran raided
BBC World Service claim signal jammed
18
Twitter Search #IranElection
19
Other social media
Wikipedia
YouTube
Flickr
20
June 15-18: Escalation Rumours of Mousavi’s arrest flood the web
Supreme Ayatolla Khomeini initiates partial recount of votes
Iranian football team wear green armbands in game vsSouth Korea
US Govt asks Twitter to postpone its scheduled downtime
Ministry of Culture issues a directive banning foreign media from leaving their offices
21
Other social media
Wikipedia
YouTube
Flickr
22
June 19-21: Violence Bloodiest days of violence across the weekend
Social media becomes the main way for citizens to communicate and organise in face of media censorship
Shooting of Neda Soltani by Basij forces becomes a rallying cry against the government
State run television reports 10 killed in Tehran over the weekend
23
June13-20th: Censorship
24
Twitter Search #IranElection
25
Other social media
Wikipedia
YouTube
Flickr
26
Some dangers for users
Twitter being used for misinformation
Twitter being monitored by state authorities
(retweet function)
27
Remediation = retweet?
28
The Arab Spring
29
Revolutionary
wave of protests
throughout the
MENA region,
beginning on 18th
Dec 2010 following
self-immolation of
Mohamed Bouazizi
Tunisia
Corrupt officials under rule of President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali
High unemployment, inflation, police brutality,
and lack of free speech
Mainstream media censorship
30
Sidi Bouzid
31
Mohammed Bouazizi
Sidi Bouzid
32
Mohammed Bouazizi
Tunisia
17th Dec 2010 – Mohamed Bouazizi’s self-immolation in Sidi Bouzid
33
The role of Facebook
34
John Gilmore
“The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it”
TIME magazine (6 Dec 1993)
35
Tunisia
17th Dec 2010 – Mohamed Bouazizi’s self-immolation in Sidi Bouzid
18th-24th street protests result in public being shot
in Bouziane
Protests spread nationally, engulfing Tunis by 27th
14th Jan 2011 – President Ben Ali flees into exile
36
Egypt
Jan 25th 2011 - Popular uprising began
37
Egypt
38
Net neutrality?
Small team of engineers from Twitter and SayNow created a voice-to-tweet
service
@speak2tweet
39
Egypt Jan 25th 2011 - Popular uprising began
26th Jan – Internet and mobile services shut down
28th Jan – Hundreds of thousands protest across Egypt after Friday prayers
29th Jan – Military presence in Cairo increased
2nd Feb – “Battle of the Camel” in Tahrir Square
11th Feb – Mubarak resigns, Armed Forces take over
40
Revolutions were tweeted On Sunspace
Focus on Tunisa and Egpyt protests
Analyses different ‘information flows’
Measuring different actors impact and influence
“news on Twitter is being co-constructed by bloggers and activists alongside journalists”
41
Conclusion
Civic activism can be supported by coordinated internet activism
Internet “revolutions” may be somewhat
problematic
Depending on circumstances, social media and
networked journalism contributes to a hybrid and
dynamic flow of information.
42
In seminars
1. Identify an example whereby networks have been used to break a news story before the
mainstream news media (it doesn't have to be
about the Arab Spring!)
2. Identify any advantages or disadvantages of
information bypassing mainstream media
channels
43
In seminars “One possible reading of the current situation on the
ground in Tehran is that, despite all the political mobilisation facilitated by social media, the Iranian government has not only survived, but has, in fact, become even more authoritarian”
Evgeny Morozov, 2010, Prospect Magazine
1. Listen to the interview (link) with Evgeny Morozov (from 7 mins)
To what extent is he right (or wrong) to be skeptical about the power of social media?
44