Is sea level rise larger near the coast? Remko Scharroo Altimetrics LLC, Cornish, New Hampshire Eric...

Post on 13-Jan-2016

222 views 2 download

Tags:

Transcript of Is sea level rise larger near the coast? Remko Scharroo Altimetrics LLC, Cornish, New Hampshire Eric...

Is sea level rise larger near the coast?Is sea level rise larger near the coast?

Remko ScharrooAltimetrics LLC, Cornish, New Hampshire

Eric Leuliette and Laury MillerNOAA / Laboratory for Satellite Altimetry, Silver Spring, Maryland

2Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Is sea level rise larger near the coast?

• Not an arbitrary question ...– Sea level rise in the middle of the ocean is rather academic– Coastal sea level rise is most important to our society

3Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Is sea level rise larger near the coast?

• In support of the affirmative– Sea surface temperature near the coast rises faster– Tide gauges show a rate larger than altimeters

• In support of the contrary– Drop in sea level expected around Greenland and Antarctica

Sea surface temperature change (2002-2009)

4Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Is sea level rise larger near the coast?

• Probably YES– Jason-1 (2002-2009)– Coastal sea level rise clearly and significantly larger

3.0

4.8 mm/yr

5Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Is sea level rise larger near the coast?

• Probably …Pierre Prandi et al. (2009):– TOPEX/Jason-1 (1993-2007), GIA corrected

6Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Is sea level rise larger near the coast?

• Probably NO

Global and coastal sea level rise from satellite altimetry and tide gauges (Prandi et al., 2009). 12-month running average. GIA corrected. Values in mm/yr.

1993-2002 1993-2007

Global 3.4 ± 0.2 3.4 ± 0.1

Coastal (<200 km) 4.4 ± 1.0 3.3 ± 0.5

Be wary of claims of a 0.1 mm/yr error bar!

7Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

EOFs of sea level rise

• Jason-1 (2002-2009) EOF 1 (15% of variance)– Annual variation– High energy currents and tropical oscillation

8Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

EOFs of sea level rise

• Jason-1 (2002-2009) EOF 2 (9% of variance)– Annual variation, 3 months out of phase with EOF 1– Tropical and subtropical oscillation

9Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

EOFs of sea level rise

• Jason-1 (2002-2009) EOF 3 (7% of variance)– Interannual variation, overall rise– Strong rise in Western Pacific = Coastal and ENSO

10Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Results from 7 altimeters

• Global sea level trend (1992-2009)– No GIA correction (~0.3 mm/yr)– 5 mm annual amplitude– Overall trend 2.75 ± 0.2 mm/yr

11Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Results from 7 altimeters

• Coastal (<200 km) sea level trend (1992-2009)– No GIA correction (~0.2 mm/yr)– Significantly larger annual amplitude (heating mostly?)– Slightly but not significantly larger trend (2.90 mm/yr)

12Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Conclusion?

• Is sea level rise (significantly) larger near the coast?– NO– But it isn’t smaller either!– And … was it really useful to ask the question in the first place?– Don’t we have to worry most about places with a lot of people

living near a shallow coast?

13Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Question rephrased…

• What’s the sea level rise in “my backyard”?

Mediterranean North Sea

Gulf of Mexico S. China Sea

GIA: +0.3 GIA: +0.0

GIA: +1.9 GIA: -0.4

14Remko Scharroo — Is sea level rise larger near the coast? — AGU Fall Meeting, 18 December 2009

Or rephrased again …

• Where don’t I want to plant my backyard?

• Where is the largest impact of sea level rise?

GIA: +1.9 GIA: +0.0