COMPARISONMODULE//Day31

COMPARISONMODULEOVERVIEW

SKILL:COMPARISON CONTENT:APWORLDC.F. KEYCONCEPT6.3

ThismodulefocusesoncomparisonthroughanexaminationofSouthandNorthKorea.Thetwoactivitiesleadtowardadocument-basedquestion(DBQ)thataddressestheeconomicimpactofdifferingideologies.

AftertheKoreanWar(1950-1953),theroleofthestateinthedomesticeconomyvaried,andnewinstitutionsofglobalassociationsemergedandcontinuedtodevelopthroughoutthetwentiethcentury.

DAY1

Whatisthestate’sroleindevelopingtheeconomy?

CLASSACTIVITY:ComparingNorthandSouthKoreathroughSourcesStudentswork collaboratively to compare the roles that the state, ideology, andhistoricaldevelopmentsplayedinthedevelopmentofNorthandSouthKorea’seconomiesafterWorldWar II until the 1980s. During the activity, students construct evidenced-basedinterpretationsusingNorthandSouthKoreansources,culminatinginathesisstatementandcontextualization.

APALIGNEDASSESSMENT:LongEssayQuestion(LEQ)Long Essay Question—Thesis and Contextualization Focus: “Develop an argument thatevaluates the extent to which the governments of North and South Korea differed indevelopingtheireconomies.”

DAY2

Howdideconomicmodels,ideologies,andpoliticalstructuresdifferbetweenNorthandSouthKoreaafter1950?

CLASSACTIVITY:EscapeRoom!!!!!ComparingNorthandSouthKoreaStudentsworkingroupstoapplycontentknowledgefrompre-assignedhomeworkreadingsaboutNorthandSouthKorea toa sequenceofpuzzles inan “escape room” scenario. Theactivity involves some advance teacher and student preparation, but the puzzlework andgroupinteractionreinforcematerialthatissometimeschallenging.

APALIGNEDASSESSMENT:LongEssayQuestion(LEQ)LongEssayQuestion—Thesiswriting:“EvaluatetheextenttowhichideologiesinfluencedtheoutcomeofeconomicorpoliticalplanninginNorthKoreaorSouthKoreaafter1951.”

DAY3 Studentscanpracticethreetargeteddocument-basedquestionskills:thesiswriting,

contextualization,andsourcing.StudentsdonotneedextensiveknowledgeofKoreanhistory.TeacherscouldalternativelyassignstudentstowritethefullAP-alignedDBQ.

APALIGNEDASSESSMENT:Document-BasedQuestion

Document-Based Question: Evaluate the extent to which political ideologiesaffectedtheeconomiesofKoreaafter1945.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day32

COMPARISONMODULESOURCES

DAY1

AUTHOR SOURCE DATE

1. MaoZedong TelegramtoFilippov(JosefStalin) 19522. KimIl-sung SpeechtotheKoreanWorkers'PartyCentralCommittee 19563. KimIl-sung Speechtothe5thCongressofKoreanWorkers'Party 19704. NorthKorea Propagandapostertargetedat“YoungHeroes” 19855. SyngmanRhee LetteronU.S.economicdevelopmentofSouthKorea 19546. ParkChung-hee Semi-autobiographicalaccountofSouthKorea'sprogress 19717. KimDae-jung SpeechaddressingSouthKorea'seconomy 19858. KwanS.Kim Workingpaperaddressing“TheKoreanMiracle” 1991

DAY2

AUTHOR SOURCE DATE1. C.Wolf,Jr.

andN.Levin ReportonattemptstomodernizeNorthKorea 20082. BruceCumings Influencesondevelopment 20053. JongwooHan Political,economic,andideologicalfeatures 20134. CIA Memorandumoneconomicdevelopment 19725. JongwooHan ArticleonKoreaneconomicdevelopment 2018

DAY3

AUTHOR SOURCE DATE

1. SyngmanRheePresidentialInauguralAddress 19482. KimIl-Sung Speech,“OnEliminatingDogmatism…” 19553. YiSujong“DeclarationoftheSeoulNationalUn.Students'Assoc.” 19604. ParkChung-hee ToBuildaNation 19715. Anonymous Studentfliersandslogans 1980s6. KimDae-jung PresidentialInauguralAddress 19987. NorthKorea Publicityposter,50thanniversary 1998

COMPARISONMODULE//Day33

DAY 3 BASEDONA60-MINUTECLASS

LessonQuestion:Howdopoliticalideologiesaffecteconomicdevelopment?

APCURRICULUMFRAMEWORKREFERENCE

CenteredonThematicLearningObjectiveCUL-2—Explainhowreligions,beliefsystems,philosophies,andideologiesaffectedpolitical,economic,andsocialdevelopmentsovertime.KeyConcept6.3—AftertheKoreanWar(1950-1953),theroleofthestateinthedomesticeconomyvaried,andnewinstitutionsofglobalassociationsemergedandcontinuedtodevelopthroughoutthetwentiethcentury.

I. Statesrespondedinavarietyofwaystotheeconomicchallengesofthe20thcentury.

A. Incommuniststates,suchastheSovietUnionandChina,governmentscontrolledtheirnationaleconomies,oftenthroughrepressivepoliciesandwithnegativerepercussionsfortheirpopulations.[NorthKorea]

C. InnewindependentstatesafterWorldWarII,governmentsoftentookonastrongeconomicroleinguidingeconomiclifetopromotedevelopment[largerdevelopment]

D. InatrendacceleratedbytheendoftheColdWar,manygovernmentsencouragedfree-marketeconomicpoliciesandpromotedeconomicliberalizationinthelate20thcentury[SouthKorea]

HistoricalReasoningSkills:COMPARISON,CAUSATION

OVERVIEW

Thisactivityisdesignedtoengagestudentsinthreeparticularskills involvedinwritingadocument-basedquestion:thesisstatement,contextualization,andsourcing.StudentsdonotneedtohaveextensiveknowledgeofKoreanhistory,althoughtheactivitiesforDay1andDay2provideusefulcontentintroductiontothisDBQactivity.Studentswill havetheentireclassperiodtoengagewiththreeskills involvedinwritingandevaluatingthedocument-basedquestion,whichcomprises25%oftheirAPWorldHistoryexamscore.Teachersshouldnotethattheycanexpandthislessontohavestudentswriteafull DBQiftimepermits.

MATERIALSNEEDEDFOR:

Homework• Copiesofthedocument-basedquestionforeverystudent

InClassActivity• GalleryWalkinstructionsdocumentforbreakdownandanalysisofprompt• Markers• Butcherpaper• Graphicorganizerforcontextualizationoftheargumentandthesisrefinement• Handoutsforsourcingthedocuments

COMPARISONMODULE//Day34

SEQUENCEOFINSTRUCTION

HOMEWORKOVERVIEW HOMEWORK(30MINUTES):

HomeworkDocument: Document-BasedQuestion(p.8)Studentswillreadthedocuments(teachersmightchoosetoincludethepromptorsimplyallowstudentstofocusonthedocuments)addressingthepoliticalideologiesthataffectedtheeconomiesofKoreaafter1950.Thepurposeofthehomeworkisto:

a. PreparestudentstounderstandthepromptanddocumentsforthisDBQ. b. HavestudentsgainpracticeinthreeoftheessentialtasksfortheDBQ.

Teacher Notes IfteachersarenotabletoassigntheDBQashomework,studentscantaketimeinclasstoreadovertheDBQinordertoprepareforreadingthesampleessays.Withthisapproach,studentswillnothavetimetowritetheirownthesisandcontextualizationstatementsunlessthislessoniscarriedovermorethanoneclassperiod.Onealternativeistoassignthethesisstatementashomeworkforthenextday.

Teaching Tip TeachersmaywanttheirstudentstopracticewritingthefullDBQratherthanjustprovidingcontextualization,sourcingthedocuments,andwritingthethesisstatement.Teachersmightchoosetousetwoclassperiodsinordertoallow

studentstowriteafullDBQ.Thislessonhasbeendesignedforflexibilitysothatteacherscanmakedecisionsbasedonthespecificneedsoftheirstudents.

CLASSACTIVITY:WARMUP/INTRODUCTION

WARMUP/INTRODUCTION(10MINUTES):

ACTIVITY1: BRAINSTORMORGANIZATION(5MINUTES)

Studentswilldiscussthepromptandbrainstormseveralpossiblewaystoorganizethedocumentsinresponsetotheprompt.Ingroupsofthreeorfour,studentswillusethewarm-uppartoftheclassroomorganizertodiscusspossiblewaystoorganizeanargument.TheywillidentifypossiblecomponentstoorganizeintoaworkingthesisandwriteitatthetopofapieceofbutcherpaperthatwilldevelopintoaGalleryWalkdocument(p.13)bytheendofclass,butitshouldbemadeclearthatthecomponentsaretentativeatthispoint.Studentgroupswilldiscusstheorganizationoptionsandtentativethesiscomponentsinordertochooseonesystemoforganizationtousefortheotheractivities.

ACTIVITY2: BRAINSTORMCONTEXT(5MINUTES)

Studentswillbrainstormcontextualizationoptionstousefortheargumentchosenbytheirgroup.Thegraphicorganizerwilldirectthemtodiscussions,butitshouldbemadeclearthattheircontextualizationistentativeandwilldependonthefinalthesisdecision.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day35

Teacher Notes Thewarm-upactivitiesaredesignedtoprovideafirstpassthroughtheargument-organizationprocess.TeachersshouldencouragestudentstoexploretheoptionsinashortamountoftimeinordertohelpthemadjusttotimeconstraintsinarealDBQsetting.

Teaching Tip Teachersalsohavetheoptionofaskingstudentstoworkonthepromptanalysis

andcontextualizationactivitiesaspartofthehomework,butstudentsmaybelessintimidatedwhenallowedtocompletethoseactivitiesingroups.Sincethegoalof

thelessonistohavestudentsbetterorganizetheirargumentsinpreparationforwritingtheDBQ,teachersmightbebetteroffaskingstudentstoconsideranargumentstructureandcontextualizationduringthehomeworkreading,buttheyshouldclarifythattimewillbegivenforgroupworkduringtheclassroomwarm-up.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day36

CLASSACTIVITYPART1:DOCUMENTSOURCING,CONTEXTUALIZATION,ANDTHESISREFINEMENT

CLASSACTIVITY(35MINUTES):

ACTIVITY1:DOCUMENTSOURCING(22MINUTES)

StudentswillworkintheirgroupstoanalyzethedocumentsoftheDBQusingtheDocumentSourcingforDBQhandout(p.14).Studentswilldiscussandwritepossiblewaystoevaluatetheuseofeachdocumentincraftingaresponsetotheprompt.Eachstudentcantakenotesonseparatehandouts.Thentheycancomparetheirindividualsourcingideasastheyanalyzethehistoricalsituation,intendedaudience,purpose,andpointofview(HIPP)foreachdocument.GroupswillchoosethebestresponsesforeachdocumentandcompleteonecopypergroupoftheGroupCopyofDocumentSourcingforDBQhandout(p.18)topresenttotheclassforthegallerywalk.Theycaneitherwritethesourcingchoicesbyhand,orpastethesourcinghandoutdirectlyontotheGalleryWalkdocument(p.13).

Teaching Tip

TeachersmaywanttoassigntheHIPPhandoutaspartofthehomeworkassignmentsothatstudentscanspendmoreofthetimeinclassidentifyingstrongexamplesofeachcomponentfromtheirgroupmembers’responses.

Teaching Tip TeachersmaywanttohavestudentscopytheirHIPPresponsesontoasheetofbutcherpaper,ortheycantapeorpastetheirgroupcopyontothebutcherpaperastheycombinetheactivitiesforthegallerywalk.

Teaching Tip Teacherswillwanttocirculateamongthegroupstoprovidehintsforsourcing,remindgroupsthatmaterialalreadyprovidedinthedocumentsdoesnotcountforsourcing,andkeepworkmovingforward.Timeremindersarekey.Studentsshould

cometounderstandtheimportanceofdevelopingafastpacewhenanalyzingdocuments.TeacherscanremindstudentsthatonlyonecomponentoftheHIPPsourcingisrequiredperdocument,butthatpracticinganalyzingdifferentpartsofHIPPhelpsbuildskillandspeed.

Teaching Tip TeacherscanfindthefullhandoutwithsourcetextembeddedinthefollowinglinkforDocumenttoSourceforDBQ.

ACTIVITY2:CONTEXTUALIZATION(6MINUTES)

Studentswillworkintheirgroupstofurtherdevelopthecontextualizationtheybrainstormedinthewarmup.Studentswillextendtheirbrainstormedideasandwritethreetofivesentencesofcontextfortheirworkingthesisandthedocumentstheyhavesourced.TheywillusetheContextualizationandThesisRevisionhandout(p.20)tocompiletheirexamplesandchoosetheonethatbestalignswiththegroup’sworkingthesis.Theywilltransferthatexampleontothegallerywalkbutcherpaper.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day37

ACTIVITY3:THESISREFINEMENT(7MINUTES)StudentswillusetheContextualizationandThesisRevisionhandout(p.20)toreviewtheprompt,documentsourcing,andcontextualizationtorefinethethesistheirgroupwillusetostatetheirargument.TheywillwritetherevisedthesisontheGalleryWalkdocument(p.13).

CLASSACTIVITYPART2:GALLERYWALKANDDEBRIEF

CLASSACTIVITY(15MINUTES):

ACTIVITY1:GALLERYWALK(15MINUTES)Studentswillpastetheirbutcherpaperandgallerywalkdocumentworkontotheclassroomwalls.Studentswilltakeagallerywalktoreviewatleasttwootherpostersandevaluatedifferentstructurescreatedbyothergroups.

ACTIVITY2:OPTIONALDEBRIEFStudentswillanalyzeanddiscussthecomponentsofeachgroup’sDBQpracticework.Teacherscandirectthediscussionthroughthefollowingpossiblequestions:• Howmanydifferentargumentorganizationsdidyounoticeinthegallerywalk?• Wouldyouchangeanythingaboutthecontextualizationandthesisyouandyourgroupcreated?

COMPARISONMODULE//Day38

IN-CLASSACTIVITYMATERIALS

Document-BasedQuestionSuggestedreadingandwritingtime:1hour

Youshouldspend15minutesreadingthedocumentsand45minuteswritingyourresponse.

Note:Youmaybeginwritingyourresponsebeforethereadingperiodisover.

Directions

Question1isbasedontheaccompanyingdocuments.Thedocumentshavebeeneditedforthepurposeofthisexercise.

Inyourresponse,youshoulddothefollowing.

• Respondtothepromptwithahistoricallydefensiblethesisorclaimthatestablishesalineofreasoning.• Describeabroaderhistoricalcontextrelevanttotheprompt.• Supportanargumentinresponsetothepromptusingspecificandrelevantexamplesofevidencefrom

atleastsixdocuments.• Foratleastthreedocuments,explainhowtheauthor’spointofview,author’spurpose,historical

situation,and/oraudienceisrelevanttoanargument.• Explainhowatleastoneadditionalpieceofhistoricalevidencebeyondthosefoundinthedocuments

relatestoanargumentaboutthequestion.• Useevidencetocorroborate,qualify,ormodifyanargumentthataddressestheprompt.

1. EvaluatetheextenttowhichpoliticalideologiesaffectedtheeconomiesofKoreaafter1945.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day39

DOCUMENT1

SOURCE:SyngmanRhee,PresidentofSouthKorea1948-1960,PresidentialInauguralAddress,15August1948,http://syngmanrhee.kr/20/?q=YToxOntzOjEyOiJrZXl3b3JkX3R5cGUiO3M6MzoiYWxsIjt9&bmode=view&idx=263903&t=board.

Amongourpeopletherearethosewhobelievethatwithoutadictatorshipthereisnowaytomoveforwardfromthesedifficulttimesorthosewhothinkthatthereisnomethodotherthandictatorshipbecausetheyholdtheviewwelackthewisdomandabilitytosolvetheseriousproblemcreatedbythedestructivecommunistmovement.Butweallthinkthisisregrettable.

Wewillneverpermitourdemocraticprinciples,whichgiveuspermanentbenefits,tobeinvalidatedbecauseoftemporaryobstacles.Ithasbeenprovenbyhistorythatdictatorshipcannotbringaboutfreedomorprogress.

T r a n s l a t e d b y G r e g g B r a z i n s k y

DOCUMENT2

SOURCE:KimIl-sung,leaderofNorthKorea1948-1994,speech,“OnEliminatingDogmatismandFormalismandEstablishingJucheinIdeologicalWork,”1955.

Itisofparamountimportancetostudy,andwidelypublicizeamongtheworkingpeople,thehistoryofourcountryandofourpeople'sstruggle,beforeanythingelse.

Thisisnotthefirsttimewehaveraisedthisquestion.Asfarbackastheautumnof1945,thatis,immediatelyafterliberation,weemphasizedtheneedtostudythehistoryofournation'sstruggleandtoinherititsfinetraditions.Onlywhenourpeopleareeducatedinthehistoryoftheirownstruggleanditstraditions,cantheirnationalpridebestimulatedandthebroadmassesbearousedtotherevolutionarystruggle.

Yet,manyofourfunctionariesareignorantofourcountry'shistory,andsodonotstrivetodiscoverandcarryforwarditsfinetraditions.Unlessthisiscorrected,itwilllead,inthelongrun,tothenegationofKoreanhistory.….

Itisimportantinourworktograsprevolutionarytruth,Marxist-Leninisttruth,andapplyitcorrectlytotheactualconditionsofourcountry.TherecanbenosetprinciplethatwemustfollowtheSovietpattern.SomeadvocatetheSovietwayandotherstheChinese,butitisnothightimetoworkoutourown?

ThepointisthatweshouldnotmechanicallycopyformsandmethodsoftheSovietUnion,butshouldlearnfromitsexperienceinstruggleandMarxist-Leninisttruth.So,whilelearningfromtheexperienceoftheSovietUnion,wemustputstressnotontheformsbutonlearningtheessenceofitsexperience.

S o u r c e : M a r x i s t s I n t e r n e t A r c h i v e

COMPARISONMODULE//Day310

DOCUMENT3

SOURCE:YiSujong,studentleader,“DeclarationoftheSeoulNationalUniversityStudentsAssociation,”April1960.

Wehavesteppedoutfromtheivorytowerintothestreets[totakepartinthedemonstration]againstSyngmanRhee[’s]regime.Byparticipatinginthewhirlwindofhistoricalcurrents,wewanttoplanttheseedsofreason,truth,freedom,andthespiritoftheuniversityinthebarrensoilofourcountry.

Inthenameofreasonandconscience,weherebyindicttheregimeinpowerforcreatingthepresentmiseryandevilanddemandtherectificationofthecurrentintolerablesituation.Wefirmlybelievethatthebleakrealityfacingourcountryiscausedbytheabuseofdespoticpowerbythepresentregime,whichfalselypretendstofollowdemocracyandfreedom.Thepoliticalhistoryofdemocracyhasbeenahistoryofthestruggleforfreedom.Ithastaughtusthatdespotism,whateverformitmaytaketodominatethepeople,isnothingmorethanapapertiger.

JustasweareveryproudofthecourageousstruggleouruniversitywagedagainstthedespotismofCommunisminitsshorthistory,wetakegreatprideinresistingthedespotismoftheextremeright-wingpoliticalgroup,whichhasputashamfacadeondemocracy.Thefoundationofmoderndemocracyisfreedom.Andyet,wearenowwitnessingourfreedombeingtakenaway—nay,ourfreedomisbeingeradicatedintotalbythedespoticregime.

P e t e r H . L e e , W i l l i a m T h e o d o r e d e B a r y , a n d Y ô n g h o C h ' o e . S o u r c e s o f K o r e a n T r a d i t i o n , V o l . 2 : F r o m t h e S i x t e e n t h t o t h e T w e n t i e t h C e n t u r i e s , C o l u m b i a U n i v e r s i t y

P r e s s , 2 0 0 0 . U s e d w i t h p e r m i s s i o n o f C o l u m b i a U n i v e r s i t y P r e s s .

DOCUMENT4

SOURCE:ParkChung-hee,PresidentofSouthKorea1963-1979,ToBuildaNation,1971.

WhenItookoverpowerastheleaderoftherevolutionarygroupon16May1961,Ifelt,honestlyspeaking,asifIhadbeengivenapilferedhouseholdorabankruptfirmtomanage.AroundmeIcouldfindlittlehopeorencouragement.Theoutlookwasbleak.

Toachievethisstability,themilitaryrevolutionarygovernmenttemporarilysuspendedpoliticalactivitiesofstudents,thepress,laborunions,andothersocialandpoliticalorganizations,whichhadcausedpoliticalcrisesandsocialunrestduringtheruleoftheDemocraticPartyregime.Wealsomadeitclearthatciviliangovernmentwouldberestoredin1963.

Meanwhile,weorganizedaplanningcommitteeofcollegeprofessorsandexpertswithspecializedknowledgeinmanyfields.Bymobilizingthemaximumavailableexpertiseforgovernmentadministrationandpolicymaking,weintendedtoholdincheckthearbitrarinessandrashnessofthemilitaryofficers.Theestablishmentofthiscommitteeservedasaturningpoint.Koreanprofessorsbegantoshowpositiveinterestintherealitiesofthecountryandtopresentpolicyrecommendationsonthebasisofscientificanalysesofthecountry’ssituation.Eventhoughnotalloftheserecommendationscouldbejustifiedintermsofefficiencyandrationality,theiradvicewasofgreathelptotherevolutionarygovernment.ThustheConfuciantraditionofYiKorea,inwhichscholarsplayedapositivepartingovernmentaffairs,seemstohavebeenrevived.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day311

DOCUMENT5

SOURCE:AnonymousquotationsfromSouthKoreanstudentfliersandslogans,1980s.

“Ourtargetisthecompradorchaebolthatexploitsthemasses’laborwhileremainingblindtotheiravariciousness.”

“Let’sdismantlethecompradorchaebolsthatfilltheirbelliesbysellingthenation!”

“Teardownthethieving,swindling,monopolisticchaebol!”

DOCUMENT6

SOURCE:KimDae-jung,PresidentofSouthKorea1998-2003,PresidentialInauguralAddress,February1998.

MyFellowCitizens:Youhavedemonstratedremarkablepatriotismandpowerevenintoday’sdifficulties.WehaveaccomplishedapeacefultransitionofpowereveninthemidstoftheIMF[InternationalMonetaryFund]Crisis.Youhavegatheredgoldtoovercomethenationalcrisisandhavealreadycollectedover$2billioningold.Iamveryproudofyourpatriotism,whichismorevaluablethangold.

Ourworkerssharetheburdenandagreetonoraises,despitethechallengestheyfaceeveryday.Businesseshavebuiltasurplusforthepastthreemonthsbyfocusingonincreasedexports.ThispatrioticcommitmentandtheresilienceoftheKoreanpeopleisearningwidespreadrecognitionacrosstheglobe…

T r a n s l a t e d b y Y o u n g e u n K i m

COMPARISONMODULE//Day312

DOCUMENT7

SOURCE:OfficialNorthKoreangovernmentpublicitypostercommemoratingthe50thanniversaryofthefoundingofthegovernment,displayedinPyongyangandotherareasinNorthKorea,1998.

PosterfeaturesPresidentKimIl-sung(left)andhiswifeKimJeong-suk.Translation:“Let’shaveaharvestfulloffruitsandmeat!”

“ K i m J o n g I l ’ s s u s h i c h e f r e t u r n s a f t e r f l e e i n g f o r l i f e , " b y P a u l a H a n c o c k s , C N N , S e p t e m b e r 1 9 , 2 0 1 2 , f r o m I m p e r i a l C h i n e s e R e g e n c y : A d v o c a c y v i a R e g e n c y f o r

C o n s t i t u t i o n a l M o n a r c h y i n C h i n a

COMPARISONMODULE//Day313

GalleryWalkInstructionsforDBQSkillsPractice

Directions

1. Writeafirstdraftforthethreesectionsbelow.2. ReviseyourThesisinsection43. Transferyouranswerstothebutcherpaperusingmarkersandthebutcherpaperprovided.Giveeach

sectiononefourthofthepage.

1.WorkingThesis:Writethisatthetopofyourgroup’sbutcherpapertouseasyourroadmapthroughdiscussionsaboutsourcingandcontextualization.

2.HIPPSourcing:Choosethebestsourcingforeachdocumentbasedontheworkingthesisstatement.Youmayhandwritethesourcingorpastethegroup’sdocumentdirectlyontothebutcherpaper.

3.Contextualization:Choosethebestcontextualizationfortheworkingthesisandwriteitclearlybelowthesourcing.

4.ThesisRevision:Reviewtheprompt,sourcing,andcontextualizationtodetermineanychangesthatmightneedtobemadetothethesisstatement.Oncethegrouphasdecidedonanychanges,revisethethesisstatementandtransferontothebutcherpaper.

Whenallgroupshaveputtheirgallerywalkpapersondisplay,eachgroupshouldexaminetheresponsesofothergroupsandcomparethem.Bereadytodiscussstrengthsofthegallerywalkpages.

COMPARISONMODULE//Day314

DocumentSourcingforDBQDirections UsetheHIPPtechniquetoanalyzesourcingforthefollowingdocuments.Asyousourceeachdocument,considerhowitwouldoperateinthecontextofwritingadocument-basedquestion.Inwhatoverallcontextcanthedocumentsbeplaced?Willthesourcingdescriptionyoucreatefitintoanoverallargumentthatrespondstotheprompt?Writeoneortwosentencesdevelopingyoursourceanalysisforeachofthecomponentsandbereadytodiscussthiswithyourgroupmembers.

Historicalcontext:

Whateventsweredevelopingintheplaceandthetimeperiodinwhichthedocumentwasproduced?Howdothoseeventsapplytothecreationofthedocument?Towhatbroadhistoricaltheme(s)doesthesourcerelate?

Intendedaudience:

Forwhomwasthesourcecreated?Wastheintendedaudiencebroaderthanthestatedaddressee?

Purposeofdocument:

Whatwastheauthorhopingtoachievebyproducingthesource?

Pointofviewofauthor:

Basedontheauthor’sidentity,howdoestheauthorviewthetopic?Don’tjustrestatethedocument’scontent.Discusstheauthor’ssupport,opposition,and/orconcernsaboutthetopicbeingaddressed.Rememberthateachauthorhasmultiplecomponentstoher/hisidentity,suchasgender,socialbackground,economicstatus,politicalpersuasion,ethnicity,nationality,religion,andrace.Whichpartoftheauthor’sidentityinformsthecreationofthedocument?

DOCUMENT1

SOURCE:SyngmanRhee,PresidentofSouthKorea1948-1960,PresidentialInauguralAddress,15August1948.

H

I

P

P

COMPARISONMODULE//Day315

DOCUMENT2

SOURCE:KimIl-sung,leaderofNorthKorea1948-1994,speech,“OnEliminatingDogmatismandFormalismandEstablishingJucheinIdeologicalWork,”1955.

H

I

P

P

DOCUMENT3

SOURCE:YiSujong,studentleader,“DeclarationoftheSeoulNationalUniversityStudents’Association,”April1960.

H

I

P

P

COMPARISONMODULE//Day316

DOCUMENT4

SOURCE:ParkChung-hee,PresidentofSouthKorea1963-1979,ToBuildaNation,1971.

H

I

P

P

DOCUMENT5

SOURCE:AnonymousquotationsfromSouthKoreanstudentfliersandslogans,1980s.

H

I

P

P

COMPARISONMODULE//Day317

DOCUMENT6

SOURCE:KimDae-jung,PresidentofSouthKorea1998-2003,PresidentialInauguralAddress,February1998.

H

I

P

P

DOCUMENT7

SOURCE:OfficialNorthKoreangovernmentpublicitypostercommemoratingthe50thanniversaryofthefoundingofthegovernment,displayedinPyongyangandotherareasinNorthKorea,1998.

H

I

P

P

COMPARISONMODULE//Day318

GroupCopyofDocumentSourcingforDBQ

Directions Asagroup,usetheHIPPsourcetechniquetoanalyzesourcingforthefollowingdocuments.Asyouandyourgroupmembersdiscussthesourcingofeachdocument,considerhowitwouldoperateinthecontextofwritingadocument-basedquestion.Whichofthesourcingpossibilitiesworksbestforeachdocument?Dotheyconnecttotheoverallargumentyourthesisdescribes?Onceyouandyourgroupmateshavechosenthesourcingforthedocument,identifywhichtypeofsourcingitisandwriteoneortwosentencesexplainingitssignificanceintheboxesbelow.Youwillattachyoursourcingexplanationstoyourgallerywalkpresentation.

Historicalcontext:

Whateventsweredevelopingintheplaceandthetimeperiodinwhichthedocumentwasproduced?Howdothoseeventsapplytothecreationofthedocument?Towhatbroadhistoricaltheme(s)doesthesourcerelate?

Intendedaudience:

Forwhomwasthesourcecreated?Wastheintendedaudiencebroaderthanthestatedaddressee?

Purposeofdocument:

Whatwastheauthorhopingtoachievebyproducingthesource?

Pointofviewofauthor:

Basedontheauthor’sidentity,howdoestheauthorviewthetopic?Don’tjustrestatethedocument’scontent.Discusstheauthor’ssupport,opposition,and/orconcernsaboutthetopicbeingaddressed.Rememberthateachauthorhasmultiplecomponentstoher/hisidentity,suchasgender,socialbackground,economicstatus,politicalpersuasion,ethnicity,nationality,religion,andrace.Whichpartoftheauthor’sidentityinformsthecreationofthedocument?

DOCUMENT1

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

DOCUMENT2

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

COMPARISONMODULE//Day319

DOCUMENT3

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

DOCUMENT4

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

DOCUMENT5

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

DOCUMENT6

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

DOCUMENT7

TypeofSourcing(H,I,P,orPOV?):

COMPARISONMODULE//Day320

ContextualizationandThesisRevisionforDBQ

CONTEXTUALIZATION

ToearnthecontextualizationpointinaDBQ,yourresponsemustrelatethetopicoftheprompttobroaderhistoricalevents,developments,orprocessesthatoccurbefore,during,orcontinueafterthetimeframeofthequestion.Thispointisnotawardedmerelyforaphraseorreference,sotwotofivesentencesshouldbedeployedtodevelopthecontextualization.

Directions

Basedontheprompt,considerthreebroaderhistoricalevents,developments,orprocessesthatcontributedtothegeneraltopicsharedbythedocuments.Besureyourcontextualizationexamplesconnectclearlytoyourworkingthesisstatement.Onceyouhavedevelopedthreecontributingfactors,choosethestrongestexampleofcontextualizationforyourgroup’sargument.Writeitonyourgallerybutcherpaper.

Example1:

Example2:

Example3:

COMPARISONMODULE//Day321

THESISREVISION

Nowthatyouhavechosensourcinganalysisforthesevendocumentsanddevelopedcontextualizationforyourgroup’sargument,returntoyourworkingthesisstatement.Discussthefollowingquestions,makinganyrevisionstothethesisstatementthatareneededtosupportyourargumentbasedonyoursourcinganalysis.

Writetheworkingthesishere:

Question1:Doesthethesisstatementanswerallpartsoftheprompt?

Doesanythingneedtobeaddedtothethesisstatementtoaccountforallofthedocuments?

Question2:Doeseachdocumentprovideevidencethatsupportsthethesisstatement?

Foranythatdonot,dotheycontradictthethesisstatementinawaythatcanbeanalyzedandexplained?

Question3:Whatchangesshouldbemadetothethesisstatement,ifany?

Rewritethethesiswithanyappropriatechangesbelow.