Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... –...

Post on 29-Aug-2018

217 views 0 download

Transcript of Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... –...

Case Study: Added Value of Contaminant Mapping Using 

Capacitively Coupled Resistivity in Pseudo‐ 3D form Combined with 

Frequency‐Domain ElectromagneticsPresenter: Adam Peake, P.Geo. 

DMT Geosciences Ltd. 

In Collaboration With: Christian Lavallee, Environmental Specialist.

Precision Drilling Corporation 

Overview• Site Description• Objectives• Methods / Instruments

– Advantages and Disadvantages• Survey Design• Acquisition• Results• Challenges• Added Value for Client• Conclusions

Fence

150m

120m

EM31 Survey Extents

Well Location

Looking NW Looking NE

Looking SW Looking SE

Site Description

• Objectives– Identify and map contaminated zone

• EM31 and OhmMapper– Pseudo‐3D OhmMapper data

Methods / InstrumentsEM31  OhmMapper

• Geonics EM31 MK II Conductivity Meter• GPS integrated in real time• Average over exploration extents.

• 5‐6 metres• High data density – 1 reading / second.

GPSEM31

Tx

Rx

Image from: http://asstgroup.com/techniques.html

Advantages/Disadvantages of EM31

Advantages:• Quick• Ease of use• Site overview

Disadvantages:• Limited depth info.• Higher conductivity reduces depth of investigation. 

Conventional Resistivity

• Labour and equipment intensive.• Stationary.• Time intensive.

• Electrical Resistivity Imaging (ERI)

Geometrics OhmMapperCapacitively Coupled Resistivity

Data Acquisition• GPS linked

Many configurations• Cable lengths• Rope lengths

GPS

Weight to preventlifting cable

Rx 5Rx 4

Rx 3Rx 2Rx 1Tx

OhmMapper Vs. ERIDipole‐Dipole Array

http://geoscixyz.readthedocs.org/en/latest/content/DC_resistivity/DC_measurements_and_data.html

• Conventional ERI

• OhmMapper

Advantages/Disadvantages of OhmMapper

Advantages:• Depth information • Quick ‐ Dragged• Efficient ‐ Limited personnel • Very high horizontal resolution

– 2 readings/second

Disadvantages:• Shallower depth than ERI• Higher conductivity reduces 

ability to receive data • Only water resistant• Difficult to drag by hand 

and/or rough terrain

Survey design

• Reconnaissance style EM31– Identify targets and background

• Targeted Pseudo‐3D OhmMapper survey– Characterize target

EM31 Acquisition

• EM31 = one continuous traverse, approx. 3m apart

Short RopeLong Rope

Short Rope

Long Rope

OhmMapper Acquisition• 25 Lines ‐ 2 passes per line

– Different rope lengths• 0.625m and 2.5m

• Lines approx. 3‐5 metres apart.– Pin‐flagged.

Results• EM31 Results• Expectation Vs. Reality• OhmMapper Results

– Challenges

• Added Value for Client• Pseudo 3D

– Possible Subsurface Propagation 

EM31 Results –With Snow

EM31 Results – No Snow

EM31 Results – CompareWith Snow

No Snow

Expectation vs. RealityExample 1

Example 2

Example 3

Example 4

OhmMapper Results• 3 Attempts – 3rd was successful. 

Challenges

• Improper coupling possibility.– Thick crust– Granular snow– Air pockets?

• Increased distance from ground surface– Capacitance inversely related to distance

Air/Loose Snow?

Loose Snow?Compact/Drifted

Interconnected Snow?

Crust Surface

Added Value for Client

• Accurate borehole locations• Volume estimates• Possible subsurface propagation

• Before GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

Accurate Borehole Locations

Accurate Borehole Locations• After GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

Accurate Borehole Locations• Before GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

• After GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

Accurate Borehole Locations• After Actually Drilled

Pseudo‐3D • 75 to 325mS/m• Vertical Ex. = x3

Psuedo 3D ‐Volume Estimates• Any Conductivity (Confined depth)

Iso‐Surface Value 

Volume within Iso‐Surface (m3) – Limited to 4m depth

125 mS/m  1640m3

185 mS/m  350m3

250 mS/m 129m3

300 mS/m 52m3

Evaluation• Revisit Conductivity Iso‐surfaces• 108mS/m appears 

to closer match exceeding salinity

• Upper 0.5 to 1m stockpiled in some places?

New Iso‐Surface Value  Volume within Iso‐Surface (m3) –Limited to 4m depth

108 mS/m  3150m3

Evaluation• Stockpile material?

Looking Northwest

• 108mS/m• Vertical Ex. = x3

ckpile material?Evaluation • 108mS/m

• Vertical Ex. = x3

ssible Subsurface PropagationEM31 OhmMapper Depth Slice – Near Surface

SouthNorth X‐section

ssible Subsurface Propagation

Conclusion

QuickEasyTargeted borehole locationsPossible volume savingsAnother perspective to understand all dataMight not work correctly in certain snow situations.

Wolf

Rx 4

Rx 3

Rx 2

Rx 1

Thank you!

DMT Geosciences Ltd.Suite 415, 708-11th Ave. S.W.Calgary, Alberta,Canada, T2R 0E4403-264-9496

Suite 1030, 789 West Pender St.Vancouver, British ColumbiaCanada, V6H 1H2604-293-2800