Post on 07-Apr-2018
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 1/39
77 Budget Review & RelatedBudget Review & Related
Professor M.Professor M. AsemAsem AbdulAbdul--MalakMalak
ng neer ng anagement rogramng neer ng anagement rogramFaculty of Engineering and ArchitectureFaculty of Engineering and Architecture
American Universit of BeirutAmerican Universit of Beirut
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 2/39
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 3/39
Control of budget is exercised by ensuring that generated cost’
revised figure approved by the owner.
Budget review is concerned with the initial (purchase and,
weighed against maintenance and operation costs under anyvalue engineering exercise.
, ,..of installing or incorporating work items or products in thebuilt facility. The ease with which such installations take place
.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 4/39
Illustrating the scaleand relationship of thepro ect componentsc emat c es gn
DesignDevelopment
Refinement of design;establishing scope,relationships, forms,
ConstructionDocumentation
s ze, an appearance othe project
Setting forth, in detail, therequirements for
construction of the project
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 5/39
Owner’s ConstructionOwner’s ConstructionBudgetBudget
Construction budget setby the Owner
c emat c es gn
DesignDevelopment
ConstructionDocumentation
Construction budget checks and balances by the Owner
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 6/39
Detailed/DefinitiveEstimate
c emat c es gnEngineer’s
Estimate
DesignDevelopment
PreliminaryEstimate
ConstructionDocumentation
Construction cost estimate reviews/updates by the Architect/Engineer
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 7/39
uestions to beuestions to beaddressedaddressed
c emat c es gn
DesignDevelopment1. Design Information???
ConstructionDocumentation
.
Construction cost estimate reviews/updates by the Architect/Engineer
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 8/39
SD Estimate:SD Estimate:Governing FactorsGoverning Factors’
Functions/Areas Criteria/Standards
Systems/SizingScale/Massing
Estimate’s representation characteristics
$/m2 Combined Aggregation bysystem
Aggregation byfunction
wner s cr er a o accep ance
In conjunctionwith other
Rates vs.EstimateComprehensive
Cost Estimate Confirmation
deliverables
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 9/39
DD EstimateDD Estimate::Governing FactorsGoverning Factors’
????? ???????????????
Estimate’s representation characteristics
????? ???????????????
wner s cr er a o accep ance
????? ???????????????
Cost Estimate Confirmation
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 10/39
CD Estimate:CD Estimate:Governing FactorsGoverning Factors’
????? ???????????????
Estimate’s representation characteristics
????? ???????????????
wner s cr er a o accep ance
????? ???????????????
Cost Estimate Confirmation
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 11/39
Value En ineerin :Definition
It is the process through which it can be
ensured that the delivered facility has beendesigned with an overall (life-cycle based) costeffectiveness taken into consideration in
built facility and the systems serving such
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 12/39
Project
Financial Advisors
ManagementProfessionals
Owner Legal Advisors
TechnicalStaff
A/ E Consultant
on rac or
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 13/39
’ ’
Relevant AIA terms:Relevant AIA terms:
§§ 2.1.32.1.3 The Architect shall consider theThe Architect shall consider the valuevalue
of alternative materials, building systems andof alternative materials, building systems andequipment, together with otherequipment, together with otherconsiderations based on program, budgetconsiderations based on program, budget
an aes e cs n eve op ng e es gn oran aes e cs n eve op ng e es gn orthe Project.the Project.
r
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 14/39
’ ’
Project manager is to be expected to take an active roleProject manager is to be expected to take an active rolein overseeing the performance of the Architect’sin overseeing the performance of the Architect’s
pertaining to “value engineering”.pertaining to “value engineering”.
v r :v r :
. .. . alternative materials, building systems andalternative materials, building systems andequipment, together with other considerations basedequipment, together with other considerations basedon program, u ge an aes e cs n eve op ng eon program, u ge an aes e cs n eve op ng e
design for the Project.design for the Project.r
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 15/39
’ ’
Relevant FIDIC General Conditions of Contract forRelevant FIDIC General Conditions of Contract for
13.213.2 he Contractor ma at an time submit to thehe Contractor ma at an time submit to theEngineer a written proposal which (in the Contractor’sEngineer a written proposal which (in the Contractor’sopinion) will, if adopted, (i) accelerate completion, (ii)opinion) will, if adopted, (i) accelerate completion, (ii)
,,maintaining or operating the Works, (iii) improve themaintaining or operating the Works, (iii) improve theefficiency or value to the Employer of the completedefficiency or value to the Employer of the completed
or s, or v o erw se e o ene o e mp oyeror s, or v o erw se e o ene o e mp oyer
r
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 16/39
How Are These RolesHow Are These RolesExercisedExercised
Planning
ArchitectProject Manager
Contractor
Bidding
Design
Construction
O&M
Possibilities to consider Value Engineering prevail throughout the D-B-B process
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 17/39
Planning
Bidding
Design
Construction
O&M
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 18/39
e n ons
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 19/39
-
“Buildabilit is the extent to which the desi nof the building facilitates ease of construction,subject to the overall requirements for the
comp ete u ng
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 20/39
-
“Constructability is the optimum use of
construction knowledge and experience inplanning, design, procurement, and fieldoperations to achieve overall project
”
ons ruc on n us ry ns u e, – us n
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 21/39
Definition Fer uson -1989)
“Buildabilit is the abilit to construct a buildinefficiently, economically and to agreed qualitylevels from its constituent materials,
components, an su -assem es
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 22/39
-
“Constructabilit is the extent to which thedesign of the building facilitates ease of construction, subject to the requirements of
construct on met o s
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 23/39
Design
Bi ing
Construction
O&M
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 24/39
PM/CM
Financial Advisors
Pro essiona s
Owner Legal Advisors
TechnicalStaff
A/ E Consultant
on rac or s
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 25/39
’ ’
The Architect shall be the first participant toThe Architect shall be the first participant to
observe the issue of “constructability” as theobserve the issue of “constructability” as thedesign is being conceived and rendered.design is being conceived and rendered.
Observing “constructability” shall be made aObserving “constructability” shall be made arequirement in the Owner/Architect Agreement.requirement in the Owner/Architect Agreement.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 26/39
’ ’
Project manager is to be expected to take an activeProject manager is to be expected to take an active
role in overseein the erformance of the Architect’srole in overseein the erformance of the Architect’sservices and in enforcing those agreement termsservices and in enforcing those agreement termspertaining to “Constructability”.pertaining to “Constructability”.
reviews, starting as early as possible into the projectreviews, starting as early as possible into the projectimplementation schedule.implementation schedule.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 27/39
’ ’
instrumental in judging the degree to which theinstrumental in judging the degree to which the
desi n has been conceived withdesi n has been conceived with “constructability” in mind. “constructability” in mind.
he drawback lies in the mechanism throughhe drawback lies in the mechanism throughwhich the judgment of the Contractor may bewhich the judgment of the Contractor may be
..
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 28/39
Where Are These RolesWhere Are These RolesExercisedExercised
Planning
Architect
Project ManagerContractor
Bidding
Design
Construction
O&M
Possibilities to consider Constructability prevail throughout the D-B-B process
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 29/39
Considerations durinConsiderations durinPlanningPlanning
Constructability program is an integral part of project execution.
Project planning involves construction knowledge andexperience.
Early construction involvement is considered in development of contracting strategy.
Project schedules are construction-sensitive. Basic design approaches consider major construction methods. . Project team participants responsible for constructability are
identified early on. Advanced information technolo ies are a lied throu hout
project.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 30/39
Considerations durinConsiderations durinDesign and ProcurementDesign and Procurement
Design and procurement schedules are construction sensitive.
es gns are con gure o ena e e c en cons ruc on.
Design elements are standardized.
Construction efficiency is considered in specification.
Module/preassembly designs are prepared to facilitatefabrication, transport, and installation.
,
material, and equipment. Designs facilitate construction under adverse weather
conditions.
Design and construction sequencing should facilitate system
turnover and start-up.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 31/39
Desi n and rocurement schedules areconstruction sensitive
Procurement, other than for lead times, has moderate
segment of the overall schedule. Design is a complexand demanding process, but frequently is the most
ruit u area in optimizing t e entire project sc e u e.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 32/39
Desi ns are confi ured to enable efficientconstruction
Simplicity is a desirable element of any constructabledesign. Flexibility for the field construction forces to
highly desirable. Sequencing of installation is as mucha design consideration as it is a procurement and
.skills should be minimized in all cases, along with onesthat are highly labor intensive.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 33/39
Specific advantages of standardization include:
(1) increased productivity from repetitive fieldoperations,
,
(3) simplified material procurement,
4 sim lified materials mana ement
(5) reduced design time, and
(6) greater interchangeability of spare parts duringmaintenance operations.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 34/39
Construction efficienc is considered inspecification development
Sufficient time is allowed to develop complete,cons s en , an error- ree spec ca ons. ar y ssought as one of the prime characteristics of a good
specification. A single construction specification coversall appropriate aspects of a single subject orcomponent. The cost saving potential of “or equal”
.
Specifications are maintained in order to include themost current cost-effective state-of-the-practiceec n ques an ma er a s.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 35/39
Module/ pre-assembly designs are
,transport , and installat ion
Once the decision has been made to use modularization,
addressed during design and procurement to ensure theirsuccessful implementation. Designers should first consider where
the fabrication is to be performed. If the vendor’s shop is undercontrolled conditions, tolerances can be more stringent.Module/preassembly designs add requirements for transportingand handling large assemblies. These activities form a revised
scope for the project and introduce key physical or schedulerestraints based on the availability of transportation and handlingequipment. Finally, the installation method of modules must be
, ,and design of underground services and foundations.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 36/39
Designs promote construction
, ,equipment
Specific issues that should be considered include:(1) sequencing of work,
(2) delivery schedules for major pieces of equipment,
(3) laydown areas on congested sites,
(4) e very rou es,
(5) use of permanent elevators for personnel lifts,
traversed later by heavy equipment, and
(7) type, location, and required opening size forequipment.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 37/39
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 38/39
Design and construction sequencing
start-up
it is important that the overall start-up planningprocess begin early in the facility delivery process. The
-up problems that result in increased costs and delays.
The longer the overlap between the start-up phase andthe construction phase, the more important earlyintegration of start-up into the overall project planbecomes. Of e ual im ortance to inte rated ro ect
planning is the need to identify start-up requirementsthat have a direct impact on design, such as: special
, ,electrical power requirements.
8/3/2019 7 - Budget Review and Related Practices - Mdfsp09
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-budget-review-and-related-practices-mdfsp09 39/39
Considerations durinConsiderations durinField OperationsField Operations
Constructability is enhanced w hen innovativeconstruction methods are utilized, which
(1)(1) the sequencing of field tasks,the sequencing of field tasks,
(3)(3) use of hand tools,use of hand tools,
(4)(4) use of construction equipment,use of construction equipment,
(5)(5) constructorconstructor--optional preoptional pre--assembly, andassembly, and(6)(6) postpost--bid constructor preferences relevant to thebid constructor preferences relevant to the
ayou , es gn, an se ec on o permanenayou , es gn, an se ec on o permanenmaterials.materials.