Post on 11-Jan-2016
2010 CCCSE Workshop
Students Speak – We Listen
June 1, 2010
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Arleen ArnspargerProject Manager, Initiative on Student Success512-232-6458arnsparger@ccsse.org
Sandra ShannonProject Coordinator, Initiative on Student Success512-471-6907shannon@ccsse.org
Patri O’GanAdministrative Associate, Initiative on Student Success512-232-6458ogan@ccsse.org
Center for Community College Student EngagementCommunity College Survey of Student Engagement (CCSSE)Community College Faculty Survey of Student Engagement (CCFSSE)Survey of Entering Student Engagement (SENSE)
Community College Leadership ProgramThe University of Texas at Austin
Agenda Introduction – Why focus groups?
Creating Stories -- How to use focus group findings – qualitative information -- alongside your institutional data – quantitative information
Designing, organizing, and conducting focus groups
Group work
Q&A throughout the session
What do you want to take away from this session?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Why focus groups?
Digging beneath the numbers… moving from “what” to “why”
Bringing data alive through student voices
The power of stories
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Quantitative
CCSSE
CCFSSE
SENSE
Qualitative
Initiative on Student Success / Starting Right
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Center for Community College Student Engagement
CCCSE & Starting Right Initiative
Quantitative + Qualitative Information
2002 - 2006: CCSSE + Focus groups
2007 - 2011: SENSE + Focus Groups
• 2009-10: Three colleges and two high schools in Houston area – longitudinal study
• 2010-2011: Three colleges in different locations around the country – longitudinal study
4…the least number of times students in focus groups at one college we visited returned to the college to complete the registration process.
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Center for Community College Student Engagement
My first day…
Video Removed
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Early Connections…
Video Removed
Students don’t know what they don’t know…
but we think they should…and we behave as though they do!
Center for Community College Student Engagement
The students in our focus groups who reported the best experience registering at their college had something in common.
What was it?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Discussion Qs
• Who? • Which students do you want to hear from?
• What? • What do you want to learn from them?
• Why? • What data lead you to ask those
questions?
CCSSE Benchmarks for Effective Educational Practice
Active and Collaborative Learning
Student Effort
Academic Challenge
Student-Faculty Interaction
Support for Learners
Center for Community College Student Engagement
SENSE Benchmarks of Effective Practice with Entering Students…• Early Connections
• High Expectations and Aspirations
• Clear Academic Plan and Pathway
• Effective Track to College Readiness
• Engaged Learning
• Academic and Social Support Network
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Active & Collaborative LearningWhat percentage of students said they
asked questions in class or contributed to class discussions?
• Often or Very Often
What percentage of students said they worked with other students on a project or assignment often or very often?
• During class?• Outside of class?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Active & Collaborative LearningWhat percentage of students said they
asked questions in class or contributed to class discussions?
• Often or Very Often – 65%
What percentage of students said they worked with other students on a project or assignment often or very often?
• During class? – 46%• Outside of class? – 22%
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Video Removed
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Give Me a Reason to Come to Class…
Video Removed
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Academic Challenge: What % of students said they often or very often worked harder than they thought they could to meet an instructor’s expectations?
Slightly less than half!
Center for Community College Student EngagementI
Video Removed
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Support for Learners:
What do students say is the most important college service?
Academic Advising & Planning
What entering students are telling us:During their first 3 weeks…
• Almost 30% didn’t know they could get academic advising…
47% didn’t use it.
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Please advise me…
Video Removed
Center for Community College Student Engagement
More than 70% of entering students say no college staff member talked with them about outside commitments to help them figure out how many classes to take.
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Too Many Hours…
Video Removed
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Have you asked for help?57% say Once or Never
Gone to a tutor? 84% say Never
Gone to a math, writing or other skill lab? 66% say Never
Center for Community College Student EngagementI
I Need Help, But…
Video Removed
Students don’t do optional!!
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Focus Group Toolkit
http://www.ccsse.org/resources/toolkit
Center for Community College Student Engagement
• Planning Focus Groups
• Recruiting Focus Group Participants
• Discussion Tools
• Analyzing/Reporting
Student Focus Group Toolkit can be adapted for faculty & staff
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Planning Focus Groups • Selecting a Moderator and Note-taker • Coordinator Responsibilities • Coordinator Checklist
• Room Set-Up • Videotaping Guidelines • Consent Forms
Student Focus Group Toolkit
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Recruiting Focus Group Participants • Selecting Participants
Your goal is: To gain as accurate a picture as possible of student experiences at the college. You want the good, the bad, and the ugly!
• Invitations & Maintaining Contact
Student Focus Group Toolkit
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Discussion Tools• Moderator Do’s and Don’ts
• Moderator’s Guide
• Student Profile Sheet
• Response Sheets
Student Focus Group Toolkit
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Focus Group Toolkit – Gathering Quantitative Data Along with Qualitative Information
Student Profile Form – Use to gather basic information about your participants
Additional response forms can be used to complement discussion findings. Examples:• Non-Academic Responsibilities• Finances • Technology Use• First Experiences
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Focus Group Toolkit - Selecting a Moderator
• A time to listen, not to talk.
• Choose your facilitator wisely.
• Objective
• Not known to participants
• Not particularly knowledgeable about what the college is doing
• Able to listen without showing a reaction!
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Group Activity - Create a Discussion Outline
• Select an OUTCOME. What do you want to learn from focus group participants?
• What 3 or 4 QUESTIONS could you ask to get to that outcome?
• Write OUTCOME and QUESTIONS on paper.
Select one person to share your group’s outline with session participants.
What Matters Most for Student Success?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
What Works at the Front Door?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Video Removed
What Works Before Classes Start?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Video Removed
Students use the word “mandatory” and want us to use it when we know what they need.
Center for Community College Student Engagement
What Works in Class?
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Video Removed
What do you want to learn more about? From whom? What challenges do you see in conducting focus groups at your college?
Next steps at your college?
Let’s Listen!
Center for Community College Student Engagement
Please take a few moments to complete the session evaluation.
Thank you!
Center for Community College Student Engagement