Post on 18-Dec-2015
1
The Entrepreneurial League SystemThe Entrepreneurial League System®®: : A New Approach to Developing EntrepreneursA New Approach to Developing Entrepreneurs
By:
Gregg A. Lichtenstein, Ph.D.President, Collaborative Strategies, LLC
Presentation to:Presentation to:
WIRED West Michigan Quarterly Meeting WIRED West Michigan Quarterly Meeting
Thursday, June 15th, 20061:30 p.m. – 3:30 p.m.
Location: Alumni House, GVSU Allendale Campus
2© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The objective of today’s presentation The objective of today’s presentation is to discuss: is to discuss:
1. The “Pipeline of Entrepreneurs and Enterprises”
2. The Entrepreneurial League System® design
3. The Articulation Study to adapt ELS to local needs
4. Links between ELS and other WIRED projects
5. Next Steps
3© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
I. Managing the Community’s I. Managing the Community’s Pipeline of Entrepreneurs and Pipeline of Entrepreneurs and
Enterprises: Introducing a New Way Enterprises: Introducing a New Way of Looking at your Business Assetsof Looking at your Business Assets
4© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Entrepreneurs are people Entrepreneurs are people whowho……
Create value or wealth by capturing market opportunities and converting them into business assets;
Are the “engines” of economic development in a community
5© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Three key assumptions about Three key assumptions about entrepreneurs:entrepreneurs:
1. Entrepreneurs are successful to the extent that they have the necessary skills;
2. Entrepreneurs come to entrepreneurship at different levels of skill; and,
3. Entrepreneurial skills can be developed.
6© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
If we want to create greater individual and If we want to create greater individual and community wealth, then as a community, community wealth, then as a community,
we collectively need to assume we collectively need to assume responsibility for...responsibility for...
Developing a supply of highly skilled entrepreneurs that are capable of building
successful companies in sufficient numbers to transform our economy.
7© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Before we can answer the question Before we can answer the question of how to develop a supply of highly of how to develop a supply of highly
skilled entrepreneurs, we must… skilled entrepreneurs, we must…
Explore a way to “see” what business assets we have in our community.
8© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
We recommend a new set of “lens” that We recommend a new set of “lens” that allows us to shift from seeing an allows us to shift from seeing an
undifferentiated undifferentiated pool pool to seeing a to seeing a pipelinepipeline consisting of variegated stocks and consisting of variegated stocks and
flows…flows…
9© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
A A pipeline pipeline offers us a way to map the supply offers us a way to map the supply of entrepreneurs and enterprisesof entrepreneurs and enterprises within our within our
communities. It consists of two key concepts:communities. It consists of two key concepts:
1. Entrepreneurial skills
2. Stages in the development of the business
10
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Differentiating among Differentiating among entrepreneurial skill levels entrepreneurial skill levels
11
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The four dimensions of entrepreneurial The four dimensions of entrepreneurial skill:skill:
Technical Skills – ability to perform key operations of the business
Managerial Skills – ability to organize and manage the operations
Entrepreneurial Skills – ability to identify market opportunities and create solutions
Personal Maturity Skills – self-awareness, accountability, emotional and creative
development
12
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Entrepreneurial Levels by Degree of Entrepreneurial Levels by Degree of Skill:Skill:
Technical Managerial Entrepre. Personal
Maturity
Major
League:
Outstand./
Exceptional
Outstanding Outstanding Outstanding
AAA: High High High High
AA: High Medium Medium Medium
A: High/
Medium
Low Low Low
Rookie Low/No Low/No Low/No Low/No
13
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Critical Insight: moving from one Critical Insight: moving from one skill level to another requires… skill level to another requires…
A transformation on the part of the entrepreneur – a fundamental change in
their abilities.
14
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Why do we need to know an Why do we need to know an entrepreneur’s skill level? entrepreneur’s skill level?
The ability to use technical and financial assistance is a function of entrepreneurs’ skill and level of development
Entrepreneurs at each skill level must be worked with differently
15
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Differentiating among enterprises at Differentiating among enterprises at various stages of development of the various stages of development of the
business business
16
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
There are six stages in the development There are six stages in the development of a business:of a business:
Stage 0 – Pre-venture Stage 1 – Existence or Infancy Stage 2 – Early Growth Stage 3 – Expansion or Sustained Growth Stage 4 – Maturity Stage 5 – Decline
17
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Observations about stages in the Observations about stages in the development of a business: development of a business:
Lifecycle stages are independent of the entrepreneur’s skill level
Stages of development are not identical with the age of the firm
Movement to the next stage of development of the business requires a transformation to a different operating structure
The real wealth creation stages are 3 (expansion) and 4 (maturity)
18
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
We put these two variables – skills We put these two variables – skills and stages in the development of the and stages in the development of the
business – together to form…business – together to form…
A pipeline.
19
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The Pipeline of Entrepreneurs and EnterprisesThe Pipeline of Entrepreneurs and Enterprises
Lifecycle
Skill Level
Stage 0Pre-venture
Stage 1Existence
Stage 2Early
Growth
Stage 3Expansion
Stage 4Maturity
Stage 5Decline
AAA
AA
A
Rookie
20
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Observations about the Pipeline:Observations about the Pipeline:
There are a variety of possible outcomes: movement to another section of the pipeline, stagnation/arrested development, exit or death.
Movement to the next stage in the business lifecycle depends on the skill of the entrepreneur and/or his or her “team.”
Movement to any other segment of the pipeline (i.e., cell in the map) requires a transformation.
21
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Our goal in managing the pipeline is to enhance the Our goal in managing the pipeline is to enhance the performance in each segment and to increase the performance in each segment and to increase the
movement or flow of entrepreneurs and enterprisesmovement or flow of entrepreneurs and enterprises
Lifecycle
Skill Level
Stage 0Pre-venture
Stage 1Existence
Stage 2Early
Growth
Stage 3Expansion
Stage 4Maturity
Stage 5Decline
AAA
AA
A
Rookie
22
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Two IMPORTANT Points: Two IMPORTANT Points:
1. Entrepreneurship and innovation is an issue at every cell in the pipeline
2. The needs of entrepreneurs and enterprises at EACH segment of the pipeline are different as is the services and infrastructure necessary to support them
23
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
We can broaden our notion of the “business We can broaden our notion of the “business assets” in our communities to include…assets” in our communities to include…
Business Lifecycle Stage Type of Clients
Stage 0 – Pre-venture Aspiring entrepreneurs, potential entrepreneurs, entrepreneurs in search of ideas
Stage 1 – Existence Existing Entrepreneurs
Stage 2 – Early Growth Existing Entrepreneurs
Stage 3 – Late Growth Existing Entrepreneurs, Product Extension
Stage 4 – Maturity Intra-preneuers or Spin-out Ventures from Existing Companies, Strategic alliances bet. firms
Stage 5 – Decline Entr. attempting to reinvent their companies, e.g., 2nd or 3rd generation family members
24
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Important MessageImportant Message
We are missing valuable opportunities to expand our clientele – for example, by failing to include intrapreneurs (internal corporate entrepreneurs) and “managers” of strategic alliances between companies
25
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Given this map of the community’s business Given this map of the community’s business assets – where would assets – where would youyou invest scarce invest scarce
resources?resources? Lifecycle
Skill Level
Stage 0Pre-venture
Stage 1Existence
Stage 2Early
Growth
Stage 3Expansion
Stage 4Maturity
Stage 5Decline
AAA 12 ent. 36 enterprises
45 27 60 12
AA 30 69 96 24 42 12
A 45 53 150 6 4 3
Rookie 12 45 30 0 0 7
26
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
What does the process of mapping your What does the process of mapping your pipeline of entrepreneurs and enterprises pipeline of entrepreneurs and enterprises
mean to a community?mean to a community?
You now have a concrete basis for making strategic decisions about how and where to invest your resources – and for how long.
27
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
II. The Entrepreneurial League II. The Entrepreneurial League SystemSystem®®: Transforming Community : Transforming Community
Economies by Building Entrepreneurial Economies by Building Entrepreneurial SkillsSkills
28
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Enterprise development has four Enterprise development has four measurable objectives:measurable objectives:
1. To increase the rate of new business formation2. To increase the rate of survival and success of new
enterprises3. To increase the rate of development of entrepreneurs
and their new enterprises4. To increase the efficiency of the dissolution process if
a firm fails
29
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The function of developing The function of developing entrepreneurs and managing the entrepreneurs and managing the
pipeline of entrepreneurs and pipeline of entrepreneurs and enterprises in our region is enterprises in our region is
missingmissing!!
30
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
We have developed a new approach to We have developed a new approach to developing entrepreneurial talent and developing entrepreneurial talent and
building successful companies on a large-building successful companies on a large-scale and a sustainable basis.scale and a sustainable basis.
We call it the Entrepreneurial League System®
(ELS)
31
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The successful implementation of the The successful implementation of the Entrepreneurial League SystemEntrepreneurial League System®® in a in a
region involves:region involves:1. The creation of a community of entrepreneurs and a
farm system for continuously developing entrepreneurial talent;
2. The development of a service provider system to meet the technical and financial assistance needs of those entrepreneurs; and
3. The development of community or civic leaders capable of building an entrepreneurial community or region
32
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Developing the region’s pipeline of Developing the region’s pipeline of entrepreneurs and enterprises involves 3 major entrepreneurs and enterprises involves 3 major
activities or strategies:activities or strategies:
1. Performance Coaching and Success Teams
2. Talent Scouting and Pre-venture activities
3. Opportunity Scouts and Market Development Service
33
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The ELS The ELS ®® Coaching System: Coaching System:
• Classifies entrepreneurs into different “league” levels according to their skill in starting and operating a new business
• Clusters entrepreneurs into Success Teams
• Establishes individualized “game plans”
• Provides entrepreneurs with performance coaches who work with them on a one-on-one basis and as a group
• Helps them focus on execution
• Facilitates their transformation as entrepreneurs up the ladder by helping them develop their skills
34
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Implementing the ladder of skill development Implementing the ladder of skill development (i.e., pipeline) by creating Success Teams(i.e., pipeline) by creating Success Teams
Ramp-up in ELS Participation Rates:
Year 1: 24 entrepreneurs or 2 teamsYear 2: 60 entrepreneurs or 5 teams
35
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Talent Scouts and Pre-venture ActivitiesTalent Scouts and Pre-venture Activities
Recruiting aspiring and talented individuals to become entrepreneurs and participate in the ELS – just like in sports
Orienting them to entrepreneurship and the ELS Helping them with the pre-venture activities of
identifying a market opportunity, developing an offering and preparing to launch a venture
36
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Opportunity Scouting and the Market Opportunity Scouting and the Market Development Function ActivitiesDevelopment Function Activities
Opportunity scouts are responsible for identifying market opportunities that can be capitalized on by local entrepreneurs (multiple sources)
Developing and maintaining an “opportunity register” Matching to potential entrepreneurs with the
appropriate skill set Structuring the “deal” Pursuing opportunities for strategic alliance among
startups to capture new business as a group
37
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The ELS benefits entrepreneurs by The ELS benefits entrepreneurs by providing:providing:
A map to know what fundamentals of success to focus on and when (i.e., way of setting priorities and managing time)
A structure of support and disciplined performance A set of reference points by which to benchmark their
performance and to expand their vision about other possibilities
Financial and technical assistance that is integrated and customized according to level of skill
A way of developing skills and a ladder of progression
38
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Regional Entrepreneurial League SystemRegional Entrepreneurial League System®® Performance Scorecard - 2010 Performance Scorecard - 2010
League Level:
No. of Participating Companies
Change in
Particip-ation
Annual Growth Rate (in revenue)
Annual Growth
Rate (in
jobs)
Profitability (Net Profit Margin)
Growth in Profitability
Growth in No. of
Customers
Change in Skill Level
Special Outcomes
Majors
25 10% 300% 200% 15% 55% 150% 50% Patents, JVs, new CEO
AAA
45 15% 200% 125% 12% 35% 120% 45% Global sales, merger
AA
75 25% 100% 75% 5% 45% 100% 35% Certified supplier
A
95 35% 50% 35% 3% 65% 75% 35% Franchises granted
Rookies
60 20% 25% 10% 0% 0% 55% 0% Rookie of the year
Total
300 Weighted Average
Weighted Average
Weighted Average
Weighted Average
Weighted Average
Weighted Average
Weighted Average
39
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Building an Entrepreneurial Culture – Building an Entrepreneurial Culture – start small, allow the change to start small, allow the change to radiateradiate out and out and
influence the entire communityinfluence the entire communityCore folks – lead by example
40
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The ELS benefits the community by:The ELS benefits the community by:
Enabling a view of the economic community as a whole, not just parts
Focusing on all levels/kinds of entrepreneurs - neither “trickle-up,” nor “trickle-down”
Connects all rungs of the skill development ladder together, so that movement is possible
Produces a continuous stream of new companies and business leaders
Operates on a large enough scale to have impact
41
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
What is the role of What is the role of Service ProvidersService Providers in the Entrepreneurial League in the Entrepreneurial League
SystemSystem®®? ?
42
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The challenges faced by entrepreneurs in The challenges faced by entrepreneurs in working with service providersworking with service providers
E’s don’t know who to go to for what– E’s often don’t know what they need– E’s don’t know who does what; cannot make the right connection (or it takes too long, or is
simply impossible to accomplish) – E’s demanding new services that happen to already exist (i.e., not visible) or can’t get access – E’s don’t know how to judge the quality of a service; many have never used assistance
agencies; quality is often uneven, breadth of offerings, but no depth; E’s often don’t trust service providers (in some cases, for good reason – we have
observed providers that will provide only what they know, not what the E needs; also mismatch in levels, will not provide it how the E needs)
E’s are often overwhelmed by the number of providers and the array of choices; as a result they either do nothing or make the wrong choices
Referrals are rarely made or not made well E’s often don’t know how to utilize the assistance they’ve received E’s sometimes do the right thing but in the wrong order – often with devastating
consequences Many E’s have no map of how to grow their business that can guide them in these
decisions Entrepreneurs don't know how and where to address their requests for new services
that don't exist.
43
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Demand side issues: problems that service Demand side issues: problems that service providers experience with entrepreneursproviders experience with entrepreneurs
There never seems to be enough E’s with whom to work (e.g., we offer “x”, but no one is interested...; more service providers at events than entrepreneurs; constant trolling for clients, etc.)
The folks that show up (or are referred for help) don’t fit with our mission
E’s just won’t listen to advice E’s blame everyone else for their failures E’s make the rounds of service providers, but never seem to
progress (don’t make use of the assistance) E’s come for help when it’s too late E’s are unwilling to pay anything or don’t appreciate the value
of the help that they receive E's unwilling to cooperate with information requests (e.g., to see
their financials); [requires a need a relationship first]
44
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Problems experienced by the Problems experienced by the community as a whole community as a whole
Unproductive competition among service providers Service provider goals do not always match the needs of the
community Ideological vs. strategic selection of client targets Inability to determine value, ROI to community as a whole Lack of data on impact of service provision; difficult to know
pattern of needs (due to balkanization). Difficulties in making wise investment decisions among a wide
array of enterprise development activities Concerns about effectiveness, efficiency, equity, sustainability
and scale (insufficient)
45
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Design principle: Separate the functions of developing Design principle: Separate the functions of developing entrepreneurs from addressing their needs for entrepreneurs from addressing their needs for
technical and financial assistancetechnical and financial assistance
The two functions have different roles and objectives, requiring different skill sets, resources and values– Explain the development function– Explain the service provision function
An integrated and effective enterprise development system requires both systems (or sub-systems, or parts)
These functions must be separated because a single organization cannot perform both effectively (except in rare cases, but one cannot design a reliable system based on unusual people)
There must be a dynamic balance between these two subsystems (explain – neither can dominate); their operation must be integrated
46
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
There must be a dynamic balance There must be a dynamic balance between these two (sub) systems:between these two (sub) systems:
One for developing One for developing entrepreneursentrepreneurs
One for providing One for providing services – meeting needs services – meeting needs entrepreneurs have for entrepreneurs have for technical and financial technical and financial
assistanceassistance
47
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The ideal service provider The ideal service provider systemsystem is is one that…one that…
Provides the entrepreneurs in our communities or regions with the right kind of help (i.e., technical and financial assistance) at the right time and at the right price – no matter where they are located in the region.
48
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Building a service provider system Building a service provider system meansmeans
Moving from no interaction, limited interaction or arm-lengths transactions to an integrated network of relationships among the providers, where…
The performance of the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.
49
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Example ofExample of Linkages among Service ProvidersLinkages among Service ProvidersI=Informal F=Formal
SB
DC
LC
DB
LM
BD
C
ME
TC
O
LB
RC
KM
SD
C
ND
C
Af.
Am
.Str
at.P
lann
ing
Gro
up
SC
PR
E
LW
Co.
-Min
orit
y B
usin
ess
Tea
m
May
or’s
Off
ice
of A
ffir
mat
ive
Ati
ons
Urb
an L
eagu
e
Mc
Con
n..T
ech.
Tra
ns C
enter
Af.
Am
.Ven
ture
Cap
ital
Fun
d
VA
Med
.Cen
ter
_Con
trac
ting
D
ept.
LC
DB
ent
erpr
ise
Gro
up
Cap
ital
Acc
ess
Gro
up
KY
Wor
ld T
rade
Cen
ter
LC
DC
Bu
sine
ss P
lus
Bla
ck C
ham
ber
of C
omm
erce
Hum
an R
elat
ions
Com
mit
tee
Min
orit
y B
usi
ness
Out
reac
h
Exp
ort
Ass
ista
nce
Cen
ter
SB
A
Nia
Cne
ter
* G
reat
er L
ouis
vill
e In
c.*
SBDC F F F I F F F LCDB I I I LMBDC F F F METCO LBRC F F I I KMSDC I NDC Af.Am. Srat. Plan.Group I I I I I SCORE I I I I LW Co..-Minority Business team I I Mayor’s Office of Affirmative Action I I I Urban League I F I Mc Conn. Tech.Trans.Center I I I I Af.Am.Vent.Capital Fund I I VA Med.Center –Contracting Depr. I I LCDB Enterprise Group I I I I Capital Access Corp. I I I KY World Trade Center I LCDC –Business Plus I I F I I Black Chamber of Commerce I Human Relations Committee I I Minority Business Outreach I I I I I Export Assistance Center I I I SBA F I I F F
Data taken from Study of Louisville Minority Business Development Service Providers
50
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
How do we do that? How do we do that?
1. By describing and comparing who does what
2. By identifying and filling the service gaps
3. By improving the performance of the system as a whole
51
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
What are the key ingredients or What are the key ingredients or building building blocksblocks for describing who does what? for describing who does what?
1. Type of client (i.e., which part of the pipeline – level of skill, stage in the lifecycle, type of business)
2. Entrepreneurial need (functional)3. The offering – the practices or interventions
used to address entrepreneurial needs
52
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Skill Level Targeted by Service ProvidersSkill Level Targeted by Service Providers
Entrepreneurial Skill Level Type of Enterprise Development Assistance Providers
Majors Venture capitalists, professional consulting practices, investment bankers, etc.
AAA Angel investors, emerging business consulting practices, university tech transfer offices
AA Manufacturing extension programs, small business development centers, small specialized venture funds, high technology incubation programs, etc.
A Microenterprise programs, small business development centers, business incubation programs, etc.
Rookie Microenterprise programs, youth entrepreneurship programs, etc.
53
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Please note: the skill level of the clients with Please note: the skill level of the clients with which you work says nothing about your own which you work says nothing about your own
skills!skills! Few organizations work with AAAs and there is nothing
shameful about that. Blessed are those that work with Rookies and Single As;
they often require the patience of a saint! AAA entrepreneurs were once entrepreneurs at lower
skill levels. It is only by working with Rookies, A and AA entrepreneurs that we can produce AAAs or Major Leaguers.
We need a distribution of service providers at all skills levels in order to have an effective ladder or pipeline.
54
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
CreatingCreating a Service Provider Network or a Service Provider Network or system involves:system involves:
Developing a common language and diagnostic process of assessing needs and understanding customers
Forming relationships of trustFrequent interaction Opportunities to learn and improve performance
55
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
In the ELS, service providers:In the ELS, service providers:
Become specialists engaged to meet specific needs, operating in clear service niches
Undertake their projects within a common diagnostic framework
Provide service “transactions” designed to support the transformation process
Are differentiated according to needs served and league level of clientele
56
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
The ELS benefits service The ELS benefits service providers by:providers by:
Creating demand for services and improving utilization Linking clients to providers and providing them with
qualified, pre-screened clients Facilitating access on a proactive vs. reactive basis Linking different kinds of services for synergistic effect Enabling services to be delivered more cost-effectively Fostering coordination among service providers
57
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Our experiences to date: Our experiences to date: Philadelphia, PA: with urban manufacturers, high tech
startups, minority businesses, etc. Louisville, KY with minority service providers Johannesburg, South Africa with micro-enterprises in
the garment industry Advantage Valley: WV/KY/OH: now more than 75
participating entrepreneurs Central Louisiana Western Michigan: WIRED grant recipient Lake Superior region: NE Minn and NE Wisconsin Lucent Technologies Corporate Incubator
58
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
How Collaborative Strategies works How Collaborative Strategies works with communities or regions: with communities or regions:
Our goal is not only to help create entrepreneurial communities and improve their economic performance, but to help communities develop their ability to achieve these outcomes for themselves.
This outcome requires: a well-designed system (which has been created, field tested and vetted), talented people to operate the system locally, and a skill-building process by which they learn the system and develop their skills to execute successfully.
Collaborative Strategies licenses the operating system as well as the tools and provides the training and on-going coaching necessary for communities to successfully operate an Entrepreneurial League System® themselves.
We collaborate with the community to form a team; we are jointly responsible for success.
59
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
Questions and Answers Questions and Answers
“This workforce solution was funded by a grant awarded under Workforce Innovation in Regional Economic Development (WIRED) as implemented by the U. S. Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration. The solution was created by the grantee and does not necessarily reflect the official position of the U. S. Department of Labor. The Department of Labor makes no guarantees,warranties, or assurances of any kind, express or implied, with respect to such information, including any information on linked sites and including, but not limited to, accuracy of the information or itscompleteness, timeliness, usefulness, adequacy, continued availability, or ownership. This solution is copyrighted by the institution that created it. Internal use by an organization and/or personal useby an individual for non-commercial purposes is permissible. All other uses require authorization of the copyright owner.”
60
© Collaborative Strategies, 2006
For further info, please contact:For further info, please contact:
Gregg A. Lichtenstein, Ph.D.PresidentCollaborative Strategies411 N. Exeter AvenueMargate, NJ 08402P: (609) 487-8488F: (609) 487-8889Email: galichten@aol.comWeb Site: www.entreleaguesystem.com – coming soon.
Please note that this material is copyrighted. Its distribution and use, which is encouraged, should be done with attribution and acknowledgement of the source.
The term “Entrepreneurial League System®” is a registered trademark of Collaborative Strategies