Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

27
Making Sense of Smells Discussing Odors with Diverse Audiences Another Laboratory Exercise Douglas W. Hamilton Waste Management Specialist Biosystems and Agricultural Engineering

description

Proceedings available at: http://www.extension.org/67597 Smell is perhaps the least understood of our five senses. Yet, the human perception of odor may mean the difference between war and peace for a livestock farmer and his neighbors. Because the science of smells is complex, there is a tendency to run straight for the organic chemistry book when we try to describe farmstead odors. This approach goes right over the heads of most people. There must be a better way to communicate odors to diverse audiences. Come to this workshop and find out how.

Transcript of Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Page 1: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Making Sense of SmellsDiscussing Odors with Diverse Audiences

Another Laboratory Exercise

Douglas W. HamiltonWaste Management SpecialistBiosystems and Agricultural Engineering

Page 2: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Rate Mystery Liquids

Intensity

Offensiveness

Page 3: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Mystery Liquids Tested

Tap Water

Cologne

Raw Swine Wastewater

Facultative Lagoon Wastewater

Covered Anaerobic Lagoon Wastewater

Aerobic Lagoon Wastewater

Page 4: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2
Page 5: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Sniff Test

#1 #2 #3 #4

How Strong?

How Bad?

IntensityScale = 0 to 6

OffensivenessScale = 0 to 6

Page 6: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Intensity Scale

0 = no odor

1 = very faint

2 = faint

3 = distinct

4 = strong

5 = very strong

6 = extremely strong

Page 7: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Offensiveness Scale

0 = Inoffensive

1 = Very faintly Offensive

2 = Faintly Offensive

3 = Definitely Offensive

4 = Strongly Offensive

5 = Very Strongly Offensive

6 = Extremely Offensive

Page 8: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Cologne

Results from Spring 2010 Class

Page 9: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Cologne

Results from 2003-2010

0.00

0.25

0.50

0.75

1.00

0 1 2 3 4 5 60.00

0.25

0.50

0.75

1.00

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Intensity Offensiveness

Page 10: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Manure

Results from 2003-2010

Intensity Offensiveness

0.00

0.25

0.50

0.75

1.00

0 1 2 3 4 5 60.00

0.25

0.50

0.75

1.00

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Page 11: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Cologne

Results from Spring 2010 Class

Page 12: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Cologne

Results from 2003-2010

Page 13: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Mystery Liquids Tested

Raw Swine Wastewater

Facultative Lagoon Wastewater

Covered Anaerobic Lagoon Wastewater

Aerobic Lagoon Wastewater

Page 14: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2
Page 15: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

p

LiftStation 2

Open AerobicLagoon

Buildings

pLift

Station 1Splitter Box1

Splitter Box 2

Equalization Tank

ASBR

p

Covered AnaerobicLagoon

Subsurface Irrigation System

Collection Sewer

Page 16: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

p

LiftStation 2

Open AerobicLagoon

Buildings

pLift

Station 1Splitter Box1

Splitter Box 2

Equalization Tank

ASBR

p

Covered AnaerobicLagoon

Subsurface Irrigation System

Collection Sewer

Raw Manure

Page 17: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Raw Manure

Results from 2006-2010

Page 18: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Raw Manure

Results from 2006-2010

Page 19: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Results from 2003-2010

Raw Manure

Page 20: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

p

LiftStation 2

Open AerobicLagoon

Buildings

pLift

Station 1Splitter Box1

Splitter Box 2

Equalization Tank

ASBR

p

Covered AnaerobicLagoon

Subsurface Irrigation System

Collection Sewer

Covered Lagoon

Page 21: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2
Page 22: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Results from 2006-2010

Raw Manure

Covered Lagoon

Page 23: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

p

LiftStation 2

Open AerobicLagoon

Buildings

pLift

Station 1Splitter Box1

Splitter Box 2

Equalization Tank

ASBR

p

Covered AnaerobicLagoon

Subsurface Irrigation System

Collection Sewer

Aerobic Lagoon

Page 24: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2
Page 25: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Results from 2003-2010

Raw Manure

Covered Lagoon

Aerobic Lagoon

Page 26: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2
Page 27: Making Sense of Smells – Communicating Odors to Diverse Audiences - Part 2

Results from 2003-2010

Raw Manure

Covered Lagoon

Aerobic Lagoon