Download - WPS Shootout

Web Processing ServiceShootout

Execute Process Posse panel discussion

Friday, 16 September 11

Welcome to the West

•Web Map Server is for Artists

•Web Process Service is for Real Work

•Deal with it


Welcome to the West

•Web Map Server is for Artists

•Web Process Service is for Real Work

•Deal with it

Howdy


Howdy Partner(Who the heck are you anyways)


DENVER EXECUTE POSEa group of men assembled to assist in law enforcement

Simone Giannecchini

VincentHeurteaux

BastianSchäffer

MarkusSchneider

JachymCepicky

GéraldFenoy


What group you be riding out with?


Zoo Project• April 2010 Version 1.0

July 2011 Version 1.2

• International development team with 6 core developer backed by five organisations

•Developers: Program in the language of your choice! C, Python, Java, PHP, Perl, Fortran, JavaScript using any library you can get your hands on

•Docs: website with pictures!

•Number of Processes: many!grass bridge: many testedR stats (3 examples!)GDAL 6 (maybe more :) )OGR 10 (maybe more :) )

•Download and install fromhttp://www.zoo-project.org/


http://www.zoo-project.org







52 North• June 2008 (Version 1.0)

May 2011(Version 2.0 RC 7)

• 25 contributors200+ on the mailing list

•Developers: Java, Python, R developers welcome(with GeoTools, JTS, R, GRASS, ArcGIS)

•Docs: yes!

•Number of Processes:(unknown)

• Install fromhttp://52north.org/downloads/geoprocessing


http://52north.org/downloads/geoprocessing

http://52north.org/downloads/geoprocessing

deegree•Nov 2010 (version 3.0.0)

May 2011 (version 3.0.4)

• 3 full time, 5 contributors

•Developers: Java developers well supported with deegree library GeoTools and JTS

•Docs: yes!

•Number of Processes:(unknown)

• 5 min WAR install fromhttp://wiki.deegree.org/deegreeWiki/DownloadPage


http://wiki.deegree.org/deegreeWiki/DownloadPage

http://wiki.deegree.org/deegreeWiki/DownloadPage

PyWPS•Nov 2006 (Version 1.0)

June 2011 (Version 3.2.0)

• 1-2 active developers! 7 contributors

•Developers: Implement buffer in 3 lines + 50 boilerplate, python, pypy, jython and anything from the command line

•Docs: API, Workshop, Wiki

•Number of Processes: n/a(not included by design)

• Seconds to install from:http://pywps.wald.intevation.org/download


http://pywps.wald.intevation.org/download

http://pywps.wald.intevation.org/download

GeoServer•May 2008 (Version 1.7)

June 2011 (Version 2.1.1)

• 3 contributors on WPS(53 committers!)

•Developers: Buffer in 5 lines of code (10 lines of config) using Java with GeoTools and JTS

•Docs: yes

•Number of Processes: 83JTS Geometry 45Raster 10Vector 20Conversion 3Stats 2

• 15 mins to install and confighttp://geoserver.org/display/GEOS/GeoServer+2.1.1

(download the wps-plugin.zip extension)


http://geoserver.org/display/GEOS/GeoServer+2.1.1

http://geoserver.org/display/GEOS/GeoServer+2.1.1

constellation• Released later this year

• 15 developers; 3 on WPS

•Developers: Supports Java with the GeoToolkit library and the latest GeoAPI

•Docs: not yet

•Number of Processes:10 included out of the box, Math: 24, JTS: 20, Vector: 23, Coverage: 2

•Drop in a WAR fromhttp://hudson.geomatys.com/job/Constellation/


http://hudson.geomatys.com/job/Constellation/

http://hudson.geomatys.com/job/Constellation/

What impressed you aboutWeb Processing Service?


So what you folks do?(Tell us a story, impress us)


Them’s fighting words(Results of WPS Shootout)


ZOO-ProjectInteroperabilityInteroperability

52°North WPS OpenLayers Client

CCSS WPS Client

QGIS WPS Client

uDig 52N Client Plugin

2/3 tests

Success

ConformanceConformance

GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

checked !

checked !

checked !

checked !

Bonus!Bonus!

Writing the Test Script

Animial Theme

Thank you!

Mooo!

100% ValidTest Interoperability!


http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testing/resultZoo.html

http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testing/resultZoo.html

52° NorthInteroperabilityInteroperability


CCSS WPS Client

QGIS WPS Client


Success


GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

checked

checked

checked

checked

Bonus!Bonus!


Running XML Spy

Thank you!

Brave!

100% ValidTest Interoperability


http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testing52n/result52n.html

http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testing52n/result52n.html

deegreeInteroperabilityInteroperability


CCSS WPS Client

QGIS WPS Client


1/3 tests


GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

checked

checked

checked

checked

Bonus!Bonus!

Not able to be here

Helping anyways

Sympathy Vote

Thank you!

100% ValidTest Interoperability


http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testingDeegree/resultDeegree.html

http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testingDeegree/resultDeegree.html

PyWPSInteroperabilityInteroperability


CCSS WPS Client

QGIS WPS Client


1/3 tests

Success

Success


GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

checked!

xml

checked!

xml

checked!

xml

checked!

Bonus!Bonus!

CCSS WPS Client

First Across the Line

Thank you!

Impressive

100% Valid*Best Interoperability!


http://zoo-project.org/WPS-ShootOut/testingPyWPS/resultPyWPS.html


GeoServerInteroperabilityInteroperability


CCSS WPS Client

QGIS WPS Client


1/3 tests

Success

2/3 tests


GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

checked

checked

checked

n/a

Bonus!Bonus!

Horse Pulled up Lame

Showing up anyways

Sympathy Vote

Brave!

100% ValidPoor client support


Constellation (no test possible at all !!!)

InteroperabilityInteroperability52°North WPS

OpenLayers Client

CCSS WPS Client

QGIS WPS Client


n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a


GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Bonus!Bonus!

Showing up at the last minute! Brave!


Q: Who Won?


A: We all did!

• Zoo WPS Team was very kind in collecting the test results and gathering them up on a website for review

• Jody also took the opportunity to present the “Sherif ” badge to Jachym for being the first team to provide test results.

• Along with the responsibility of organising this for next year(Jachym was unavailable for comment)


Q: Where are the Test Results!



GetCapabilities

DescribeProcess

Execute

Async Execute

checked!

xml

checked!

xml

checked!

xml

checked!

A: Click on Conformance

FixMe

Click Link to Open Result Page

Thanks to Gérald

Fenoy for Testing and collecting Results




Q: What does 2/3 mean?


A: Interoperability SuccessResult GetCapabilites Describe

ProcessExecuteProcess

Success

2/3 tests

1/3 tests

Fail

client was able to list process

Show a user input form

Execute and Display Result


Show a user input form

FAIL


FAIL untested

FAIL untested untested

untested untested untested


Riding into the Sunset(what does the future hold)
