1
An Analysis of Dynamic Strategies during the Lifecycle
of Software Ecosystems
Rodolfo Vasconcelos C. L. de Andrade Carina Frota Alves
George Augusto Valença Santos
• A set of interacting businesses that work as a unit – Common goals
– Customer demands
– Customer base
– Shared costs, risks and knowledge
• A decentralized approach for software supply activities
• Ecosystem Health: comprised by Productivity, Niche Creation and Robustness.
• Roles: Keystone, Niche Player and Dominator.
2
Software Ecosystems (SECOs)
• Warren proposes a framework – Dynamic Resource System View of Strategy (DRSV) - to explore companies performance throughout time adopting a visual approach.
• He highlights the importance of company resources as performance boosters.
• His proposal is highly concerned with business sustainability (long-term profitability). 3
Strategy Dynamics by Warren
• A model that makes use of concepts from Business Ecosystems as well as biological analogies to evaluate ecosystem performance through SECO Health.
• The model focuses on strategic issues. DRSV serves as a conceptual basis for the model. – Sustainable advantage
– Strategy communication
– Dynamic and temporal
4
The Dynamic Strategies for Software Ecosystems (DS-SECO) model
5
The DS-SECO model
6
The phases of the DS-SECO model
• Represent the performance of SECO health elements.
• Use ecosystem stages as time scale.
• Graphs should be reviewed at each iteration.
7
Phase 1 - Time-Path Definition
• Resources identification – Main relevant resources for the SECO must be identified to form the
resources list
– Example: expertise on mobile development, capital availability, a solid platform (provided by the keystone), etc.
• Resources flow analysis – Identify key forces and exogenous items that influence resources flow.
• Example of key forces: investments, mutualism, etc.
• Exogenous items: biological concepts – emergence, competition, etc.
• How resources, key forces and exogenous items relate to each other in terms of resources gain or losses?
8
Phase 2 – Resources Identification and Phase 3 – Resources Flow Analysis
• Dynamic questions
– Based on time-paths and on resources flow analysis, the three basic dynamic questions (why, where, how) shall be answered for each health element.
9
Phase 4 - Dynamic Questions
• Strategy assessment
– Business model, orchestration techniques, demand estimation, architectural issues, environmental analysis
– Based on the answers to dynamic questions.
– Changes in strategy may be needed to guarantee sustainable performance
– The outcomes of changes will be reassessed in the next iteration
10
Phase 5 - Strategy Assessment
• In the beginning of birth, strategic definitions must be made
• The DS-SECO phases shall be executed at the end of each stage
• During self-renewal, the phases will be executed several times
• As a SECO leader, the keystone is committed for model application 11
How to apply the model
12
The iPhone SECO
13
Self-renewal – main facts
• iOS 4 with multitasking support and iOS 5 with iCloud
• Android as a threatening competitor
• iPhone 4 as the “thinnest smartphone at that time”
• iPhone 4S
14
Self-renewal Phase 1 – time-path definition
• Resources list
– Potential user base
– Capital
– Know-how on mobile market
15
Self-renewal Phase 2 – resources identification
• Key Forces
– Investments on R&D
– Investments on marketing
– Mutualistic partnerships
– Market differentials on iPhone
– Customer loyalty
• Exogenous items
– Emergence
– Competition
16
Self-renewal Phase 3 – resources flow analysis
• fo
17
Self-renewal Phase 4 – dynamic questions
Productivity Robustness Niche creation
Why
question
• Relevant launches led to high
productivity: iOS 4, iOS 5,
iPhone 4, iPhone 4S, iAD
• Application development was
highly active
• Despite competition,
iPhone still had a vast
potential user base;
• Mutualist partnerships
were strong among
SECO participants
• Hardware and software
improvements boosted niche
creation;
• The rising number of
downloads on Apple Store
also boosted niche creation;
• iPhone sales were motivating
Where
question
• New versions of iOS and
iPhone are expected for
defending against competition
• New applications are
expected at Apple Store
• Trend: productivity on the top
• Customer loyalty,
cooperations and capital
tend to provide the
SECO with very high
robustness.
• Users’ passion for iPhone
reinforces the potential
profitability of the SECO;
• Apple capacity to lead
innovations generates several
business opportunities
How
question
• Innovations on iPhone, iOS
and application development
must be maintained;
• iPhone superiority must
be sustained. The
Android SECO became
a real threat;
• The passion for iPhone
cannot wilt. For that,
investments on R&D and
marketing are paramount;
• The SECO needs to remain
attractive for niche players.
• Apple managed to orchestrate the SECO efficiently
• Hardware and software improvements were crucial for the SECO
• People around the world remained passionate about iPhone
• Competition became a feared threat posed mainly by the Android SECO
• Sustaining the innovation pace and monitoring competition was paramount so far and became mandatory
• iPhone value as unique cannot be lost
18
Self-renewal Phase 5 – strategy assessment
• Contributions provided by this work – Gathering SECO state-of-the-art and literature on Business Ecosystems for a
better understanding of SECOs
– Integration with topics from Management
– The proposal of the DS-SECO to address open problems in the business perspective of SECOs
• Main limitations of this research – The difficulties in obtaining data directly from Apple
– The model was not empirically validated
– The Mystrategy tool simulation was not explored
• Future work – Empirical studies in several software domains
– Exploring deeply the simulation functionality of the Mystrategy tool
– Adding technical issues in addition to strategic ones to the DS-SECO model
19
Conclusions
20
“We think too much and feel too little. More than
machinery, we need humanity.
More than cleverness, we need kindness and gentleness”
Charles Chaplin
Top Related