8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
1/15
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
2/15
01-23 4'%*56 47$%3
*"+ ,-.+#%(%/+ -1 !"#$%&(2+ 3$)"$% ( 45#-6+(% 7-%)+8)
J@K C+;+(#/" @#-L+/)D F(A MNNO )- 96#$? MNPM
0&65-89":;"7"53#
!"#$%& !'(#) $; ( 45#-6+(% C+;+(#/" @#-L+/) 1$%(%/$(??A ;566-#)+: =A )"+ 45#-6+(% 7-''$;;$-%Q;
K)" J#('+3-#& @#-2#(''+D *"+'+ R S!-/$(? !/$+%/+; (%: E5'(%$)$+;TU /-%)#(/) %-V MMWPOX
*"+ (5)"-#; 3$;" )- )"(%& )"+ /-%;-#)$5' '+'=+#; 7"#$; 7-5/"D F())"+3 7-/&;D Y?(: FA&"%+%&-D
9?=+#)- Y$-?(%)+D 7()+#$%( 7-#)+;+D @(-?- 7(?Z( G$%$D G-2:(%[(:-?5D F+?$%:( B$%/(D B(% \5/"+;D
\(#A;( H5Z'+%&-D B'$)#$ F+:3+:L+3D @+)# C5'6+?D ].( *$/"^D _%:+L !?(/"D ]3-%( H(%)-#`
@$+)#(2(D C-=+#) H#ZA;Z)-1$& (%: a+#ZA C5%2+ 1-# /-%)#$=5)$%2 )- )"$; #+;+(#/" =#$+1V
%*53
4:$)$-% 3$%)+#3-#&
333V+:$)$-%`3$%)+#3-#&V:+b
>'-3-;%$?'= @%":*3#
c 9%%+2#+) E((;+D J+?$8 ,#5=+#D B$+)+# C$ %&D 9?=+#)- Y$-?(%)+
!"&-77"5:": &*3$3*-5 +-%7$3
B$+)+# C$%&D 9%%+2#+) E((;+D F())"$(; G+#%) (%: H()#$% ,#-I'(%% dMNPNef
9::#+;;$%2 ( )*.% *.
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
3/15
MV j"- (%: 3"() $; !EC][H !F9C*k
]) $; )"+ ($' -1 !"#$%& !'(#) )- #32:= 3'" %-9" -+ ?-9*&*"# $5:
;-A"%5$5&" #=#3"7# *5 :*++"%"53 3=?"# -+ #'%*56*5; 2%1$5 %";*-5#V
!"#$%& !'(#) $; =(;+: -% /-'6(#()$.+ /(;+ ;)5:$+; 1#-' ;+.+% 5#=(%
#+2$-%; )"#-52"-5) 45#-6+ 3$)" ( 1-/5; -% :$;(:.(%)(2+: 5#=(% #+2$-%;
$% 4(;)+#% (%: !-5)"+#% 45#-6+V
7(;+ ;)5:$+; 6#-.$:+ ( =(/&2#-5%: 1-# +86?-#$%2 :$11+#+%) )#(L+/)-#$+; -1
;"#$%&(2+D 5%:+#;)(%:$%2 )"+ '($% /"(??+%2+; 1-# 5#=(% 6?(%%$%2 (%:
+?(=-#()$%2 (?)+#%()$.+; 1-# 5#=(% 2-.+#%(%/+V
PV j"A ?--& () 5#=(% ;"#$%&(2+k
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
4/15
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
5/15
!"#$%
!"#$% '(")%*$+,&'($ ($*(+'%,-. /,/01'%(,$ *#+1($#
!"#$%&'%#(%$ )"* '*+,# .%/%0"12%#3
23'$4# ($/,/01'%(,$5
6(1(#077,+('1 7#-"(+#7
7,+('1 +,3#7(,$
8#+1($# ($
($"#7%6#$%51'9,0- :,-+# '$*
;,9 ,::#-7
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
6/15
!)++?3-#&; $% B-%+);& !5=5#=(%$Z()$-% $% *$'$-(#(
Y(/(%) ?-) (1)+# :+'-?$)$-%
$% \+$6Z$2`,#p%(5
XV j"A :- /$)$+; ;"#$%&k
!"#$%&(2+ $; %-) ( ;$%2?+ 6#-/+;; $% $);+?1 =5) #()"+#
( /-'=$%()$-% -1 )"#++ '(/#-`:+.+?-6'+%);
d+/-%-'$/ /"(%2+;D :+'-2#(6"$/ :+.+?-6'+%);D
/"(%2$%2 ;+))?+'+%) ;)#5/)5#+e )"() $'6(/) 56-% /$)$+;
$% ( .+#A )$'+` (%: 6?(/+`;6+/$1$/ '(%%+#D ?+(:$%2 )-
6-65?()$-% ?-;;+;V
j+ "(.+ $:+%)$1$+: )"+ 1-??-3$%2 )"#++ '(L-# /(5;+;-1
5#=(% ;"#$%&(2+ 3$)" #+;6+/) )- )"+ /(;+ ;)5:A /$)$+;/-%/+#%+:f
+/-%-'$/ :+/?$%+ (%: L-=`#+?()+: -5)`'$2#()$-%D
;5=5#=(%$Z()$-% (%: ( /"(%2+ $% )"+ ;+))?+'+%)
;A;)+'D (%:
:+'-2#(6"$/ /"(%2+ d%()5#(? :+/#+(;+ $% 6-65?()$-%
(%: (2+$%2eV
*"+;+ :+)+#'$%$%2 /(5;+; (#+ $%1?5+%/+: $% )"+$# :A%('$/;
=A -)"+# $%)+#.+%$%2 1(/)-#; ;5/" (; )"+ 6-?$)$/(? ;A;)+' (%:
$); $'6(/); () :$11+#+%) ;6()$(? ?+.+?; d%()$-%(?D #+2$-%(?D
5#=(%D (%: ?-/(?eD )"+ ;"(6+ -1 #+2+%+#()$-% 6-?$/$+;D
)"+ 6"A;$/(? ;)#5/)5#+ -1 )"+ /$)AD +/-?-2$/(? /-%:$)$-%; -#
/5?)5#(? 1(/)-#;V
,$.+% )"() 5#=(% ;"#$%&(2+:+6+%:; 56-% (% $%)+#6?(A -1 ?-/(?D
%()$-%(? (%: 2?-=(? 6#-/+;;+;D $):$11+#; $% )+#'; -1 ;/-6+ (%:
;6++: (; 3+?? (; $% :A%('$/; -.+# )$'+V @-65?()$-% :+/?$%+ /(%
"(66+% 2#(:5(??A -.+# ( ?-%2 6+#$-: -# /$)$+; /(% ?--;+
6-65?()$-% #(6$:?AV 9::$)$-%(??AD (?? (%(?AZ+: /$)$+; .(#A $% "-3
)"+$# /(;+ -1 ;"#$%&(2+ #+?()+; )- )"+$# %()$-%(? /-%)+8)V
B4.&):&)1 5&(&0' 5%) 7#""#< 3&770.0)( (.%;05(#.&0'8C40(40. '4.&):%10 5%-'0' 2%;#. /.#$"02' 7#. % 5&(=
30/0)3' -/#) (40 '5#/0 %)3 '/003 #7 /#/-"%() "#''8
9'-%2 )"+ !"#$%& !'(#) /(;+ ;)5:$+;D '-;) /$)$+; "(.+ =++%
;"#$%&$%2 :5+ )- +/-%-'$/ :+/?$%+ (%:b-# )"+ ;A;)+'$/ /"(%2+ $%
+(;)+#% 45#-6+ (1)+# POROV *"+#+ (#+ +8('6?+; -1 ?-%2`)+#'
;"#$%&$%2 /$)$+;D (; 3+?? (; /(;+; 3"$/" "(.+ +86+#$+%/+: #(6$:
;"#$%&(2+V *"+#+ (#+ (?;- /$)$+; 3$)"$% -5# ;('6?+ )"() '(%(2+:
)- ;)(=$?$Z+ )"+$# 6-65?()$-% :5#$%2 )"+ MNNN;V G5) )"+A (#+ ;)$??
"(.$%2 )- /-6+ 3$)" )"+ /-%;+l5+%/+; -1 ;"#$%&(2+ (%: )"+
6-;;$=$?$)A -1 (% (66#-(/"$%2 1#+;" 6+#$-: -1 ;"#$%&(2+V
7 0
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
7/15
J-# +8('6?+f \$.+#6--?
D&60./##" .0/.0'0)(' #)0 #7 (40 2#'( /.#2&)0)(
0A%2/"0' #7 "#)1E(0.2 '4.&):%10 &) ,-.#/08
>40 5&(= '(%.(03 "#'&)1 /#/-"%() %".0%3= &) (40 FGHI'
%)3 &( 4%' #)"= '(%$&"&J03 &) .050)( =0%.'8
B5#$%2 )"+ POKN; (%: PORN; )"+ /-%5#=()$-% +86+#$+%/+: '(;;$.+
:+$%:5;)#$(?$;()$-% (%: +/-%-'$/ #+;)#5/)5#$%2V j"+% )"+ #+'($%$%2
6-65?()$-% :$;6+#;+: (3(A 1#-' )"+ 5#=(% /-#+ -1 )"+ /-%5#=()$-%
)"#-52" ;5=5#=(%$;()$-% (%: ;6#(3? )-3(#:; )"+ 6+#$6"+#A -1 )"+
/-%5#=()$-%D \$.+#6--? ;(3 ( 6+#$-: -1 #(6$: 6-65?()$-% :+/?$%+V
B5+ )- ( /-'=$%()$-% -1 "-5;$%2 6-?$/$+; (%: (% -5)3(#: '-.+'+%)-1 L-=;D 6-65?()$-% %5'=+#; $% )"+ /-#+ /$)A :+/?$%+: +.+% 1(;)+# )"(%
$% )"+ 6+#$6"+#A -1 )"+ /-%5#=()$-%V *"+ 6-65?()$-% -1 )"+ /-#+ /$)AD
\$.+#6--?D 1+?? 1#-' qPNDNNN $% POKP )- iXWDNNN $% MNNRV
*"+ '($% /-%;+l5+%/+;-1 6-65?()$-% :+/?$%+ /-%/+#% )"+ "-5;$%2
;A;)+'V J#-' POKP )- POOPD "-5;$%2 ;"-#)(2+ )5#%+: $%)- ;566?A
;5#6?5;V *"+ 5%+'6?-A'+%) #()+ ;)--: (=-.+ MNh
$% )"+ /-#+ /$)A )"#-52"-5) )"+ PORN; (%: )"+ 5#=(% ;6(/+ ;(3
( #$;$%2 %5'=+# -1 =#-3%1$+?:; (%: (#+(; -1 (=(%:-%+: ?(%:
(/#-;; )"+ /$)An; )+##$)-#AV
J-# +8('6?+f GA)-' (%: E(??+GA)-' (%: E(??+ (#+ +8('6?+; -1 #(6$: ;"-#)`)+#' ;"#$%&(2+V
9?)"-52" )"+ )3- /$)$+; "(: (?#+(:A =+25% )- ?-;+ 6-65?()$-%
(?#+(:A $% )"+ PORN;D )"+A 3$)%+;;+: )"+ '-;) #(6$: 6+#$-:
-1 ;"#$%&(2+ -%?A 1#-' )"+ =+2$%%$%2 -1 )"+ 6-;);-/$(?$;) )#(%;$)$-%
$% PORObON -%3(#:;V GA)-'Q; 6-65?()$-% :+/#+(;+: 1#-'
MiNDNNN $% PORK)- PRXDNNN $% MNNO (%: E(??+Q; 1#-' XXNDNNN $% PORq
)- MXPDNNN $% MNNRV
B4.&):%10 #55-..03 &) K=(#2 %)3 L%""0 %( % (&20
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
8/15
4)"%$/ # +)($? $ % ,+%-( !5=5#=(%$Z()$-% % +(# *$ '$-(#(
@+#1-#()$-% $% \+$6Z$2
K#(4 !0)#% %)3 >&2%.% 4%60 (# 2%&)(%&) %)3 7&)%)50* 7#.
0A%2/"0* (40 (.%)'/#.( &)7.%'(.-5(-.0 (4%( &' -'03 $-( )#(
/%&3 7#. $= '-$-.$%)&(0'8
]% )"+ /(;+ -1 ,+%-(D $%)+#%()$-%(? $''$2#()$-% "(; =+/-'+ (
/-5%)+# 6#-/+;; )- -5)`'$2#()$-% /-%)#$=5)$%2 )- #+L5.+%()$-%
(%: 1$??$%2 %$/"+; $% )"+ ?(=-5# '(#&+)V
iV j"() $; )"+ 6#-=?+' 3$)" ;"#$%&(2+k
*"+ '($% 6#-=?+' 3$)" ;"#$%&(2+ $; )"() ( #+:5/+: 6-65?()$-% ;$Z+
?+(:; )- ( :+/?$%$%2 :+'(%: 1-# "-5;+;D ?(%:D 3()+#`#+?()+: %+)3-#&;D
65=?$/ )#(%;6-#)D ;/"--?; (%: -)"+# $%1#(;)#5/)5#+ =5:2+);V 7$)$+; "(.+ )-
:+(? 3$)" /5); $% "-5;$%2 (%: $%1#(;)#5/)5#+V
9) )"+ ;('+ )$'+ (; )"+ ;-/$(? (%: :+'-2#(6"$/ /-'6-;$)$-% -1 )"+
5#=(% 6-65?()$-% /"(%2+; ?+(:$%2 )- (2+$%2D Q=#($% :#($%nD "$2"+# #()+; -1
$''$2#(%); +)/VD %+3 %++:; (#+ (#$;$%2V _1)+%D .(#$-5; 6(#); -1 ( /$)A (#+
(11+/)+: $% ( :$;)$%/) 3(AV
*"5;D /$)$+; )"() ?-;+ 6-65?()$-% -1)+% %++: ( /-%;$:+#(=?+ #+;)#5/)5#$%2
-1 (?? ;-#); -1 5#=(% ('+%$)$+;V
J-# +8('6?+f ,+%-( (%: *$'$-(#(
,+%-( (%: *$'$-(#( (#+ )3- +8('6?+; -1 5#=(% ;"#$%&(2+ (; ( #+;5?)
-1 :+'-2#(6"$/ (2+$%2 (%: ;5=5#=(%$Z()$-%V G+)3++% POKP (%: MNNPD
,+%-( ?-;) MK 6+# /+%) -1 $); 6-65?()$-%V *$'$-(#( +86+#$+%/+: (% Pi
6+# /+%) :+/?$%+ =+)3++% POON (%: MNNRV
]% =-)" /(;+;D (% +8)#+'+?A ?-3 =$#)" #()+ ?+: )- :+()" ;5#6?5;+; (%:D ()
)"+ ;('+ )$'+D )- 6-65?()$-% :+/?$%+ (%: #(6$: (2+$%2 -1 )"+
6-65?()$-%V
!$'5?)(%+-5;?AD A-5%2+# (%: 3+?? +:5/()+: $%"(=$)(%); (%: 1('$?$+;
?+1) )"+ $%%+# /$)A 1-# )"+ ;5=5#=;V *"$; ;+?+/)$.+ -5)`'$2#()$-% #+;5?)+:
$% /"(%2+; -1 )"+ (2+ (%: +:5/()$-%(? ;)#5/)5#+ -1 )"+ #+'($%$%2
6-65?()$-%V
!. 13
Gentrification
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
9/15
B+'-?$)$-% $% \+$6Z$2
G-(#:+:`56 "-5;$%2 3($)$%2 1-#
:+'-?$)$-% $% \$.+#6--?
B+2#(:+: =#-3%1$+?: $% F(&$$.&( C+5;+: =#-3%1$+?: $% !-;%-3$+/
J-# +8('6?+f E-5;$%2 .(/(%/$+;
]% '(%A /$)$+;D "-5;$%2 $; )"+ (#+( )"() $; '-;) .$;$=?A (11+/)+: =A
6-65?()$-% ?-;;+;V J(??$%2 #+%); (%: :3+??$%2 6#$/+;D /5); $% #+(?
+;)()+ $%.+;)'+%); (; 3+?? (; (% (?#+(:A +8$;)$%2 -.+#;566?A ?+(:
)- .(/(%/$+;D ( :+/?$%+ -1 +86+%:$)5#+ -% '($%)+%(%/+D
( :+.(?5()$-% (%: :$?(6$:()$-% -1 +8$;)$%2 ;$)+; (%:D $% ;-'+ /(;+;D
+.+% )- (% $%)+%;$1$+: 6+#1-#()$-% -1 )"+ 5#=(% 1(=#$/V
]% /$)$+; ?$&+ \$.+#6--?D E(??+ (%: \+$6Z$2D ;)()+`;6-%;-#+:
:+'-?$)$-% -1 .(/(%) "-5;$%2 ;)-/& "(; )(&+% 6?(/+V
J-# +8('6?+f G#-3%1$+?:;
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
10/15
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
11/15
\$.+#6--?`4.+#)-% #+2+%+#()$-% ;$)+
E-5;$%2 .(/(%/$+; $% \+$6Z$2
]%/+%)$.+; "(.+ =++%
$%;)(??+: )- '($%)($%
.(/(%) "-5;$%2 ;)-/&
(%: #+5;+ $) 1-# -)"+#
65#6-;+;V ]%)+#$' 5;+
(2#++'+%); =+)3++%
)"+ '5%$/$6(?$)AD
-3%+#; (%: 5;+#;
=#-52") .(/(%) ?-);
=(/& $%)- 5;+ (%:
/-5%)+#(/)+: 15#)"+#
:$?(6$:()$-% (%::+2#(:()$-%V
>40 5%'0 #7 D0&/J&1 '4#
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
12/15
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
13/15
\$.+#6--? _%+ !"-66$%2 7+%)#+
!)5:A$%2 2-.+#%(%/+(##(%2+'+%); 3$)"
#+;6+/) )- ;"#$%&(2+f
-5)/-'+; -1 (
;)(&+"-?:+# 3-#&;"-6
$% \+$6Z$2 $%
!+6)+'=+# MNPN
4&'
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
14/15
!)(&+"-?:+# 3-#&;"-6 $%
\+$6Z$2D !+6)+'=+# MNPNV
J-# )"+ 1$%(?
6"(;+ -1 )"+
6#-L+/)D ( 6-?$/A
$%1-#'$%2
3-#&;"-6 3$)"
#+6#+;+%)()$.+;
1#-' )"+ 4< (%:
)"+ 4
8/13/2019 Urban Shrinkage
15/15
!"#$%& !'(#) >*"+ ,-.+#%(%/+ -1 !"#$%&(2+
3$)"$% ( 45#-6+(% 7-%)+8)
Top Related