Words by Zain AbdullahPhotographs by Zain Abdullah unless stated otherwise
flickr.com/photos/mzabdullah myheritagebuildings.blogspot.my
The Influence Of Islamic Architecture On Colonial Buildings In Malaysia
The origin of the Islamic architectural influence significantly present on many colonial buildings in the major cities in Malaysia namely Kuala Lumpur, Penang and Ipoh often becomes a subject of dispute
Some refer to it as Moorish architecture while others label it as Mughal/Mogul architecture
What is actually the correct answer?
The Influence Of Islamic Architecture On Colonial Buildings In Malaysia
The correct answer is Mughal architecture or sometimes it is also spelled as Mogul architecture
Mughal architecture of India is the chief influence in the Islamic architectural style on many colonial buildings in Malaysia
However Mughal architecture is referred to the architectural style during Mughal Empire that ruled India since 1526 until 1757 when India fell under the British rule
The Islamic architectural style adopted for the colonial buildings in then Malaya from the late 19th century was the Mughal-revival architectural style movement termed as Indo-Saracenic or it is also called Indo-Gothic or Neo-Mughal orBritish Raj
This architectural style movement was made popular by the British architects in British India
Mughal architecture
Mughal architecture
Mughal architecture is the amalgamation of Islamic, Persian, Turkish and Indian architecture.
It is a distinctive style developed during the Mughal empire between the 16th and 18th centuries.
The Mughals were famous for their wealth and splendour – a fact that is reflected in the opulence of their architecture
Most famous Mughal building is the Taj Mahal
The most significant buildings are forts, palaces, mosques and tombs
Taj Mahal, Agra, India
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
Moorish architecture
Moorish architecture
Islamic architecture was developed in North Africa and south-western Europe, particularly from the Iberian Peninsula (Spain and Portugal). It was the style of architecture there during the 8th to the 15th century.
The most distinct Moorish building is the Mezquita in Cordoba, Spain.
Mezquita in Cordoba, Spain Alhambra, Granada, Andalusia, Spain
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
Indo-Saracenic architecture
Indo-Saracenic architecture
Introduced by the British colonial government and developed by the British architects since 1870 after the British Crown took over the rule from the British East India Company
The architectural style is the mixture of the original Mughal architectural elements like arches, chhatri and onion-shaped domes with traditional British architecture of Gothic revival, Victorian and Neo-Classical style.
It is often called “stylistic hybrid” architecture
Brief History of Mughal Empire & Mughal emperors (1526-1707)
Babur (Reigned 1526-1530)
Founder of Mughal Empire after defeating Ibrahim Lodi
Made a modest beginning of Mughal architecture by building a mosque
Humayun ( Reigned 1530-1556)
Babur’s son
Was once defeated by Ser Shah and lived in exile in Persia for 15 years
Developed deep understanding and love for Persian culture and instilled it in his son Akbar (next Mughal emperor) while in exile
Reconquered Mughal empire and continued the reign until his death
Akbar ( Reigned 1556-1605)
Humayun’s son
Mughal architecture was developed on a massive scale
The beginning of the glory of Mughal architecture as well as other branches of art – painting, literature, philosophy etc
Brief History of Mughal Empire & Mughal emperors (1526-1707)
Jahangir (Reigned 1605-1628)
Akbar’s son
The richest period of Mughal empire - dubbed the age of Mughal splendour
He lavishly patronized the arts: painting, architecture, philosophy, and literature, while ignoring military conquest.
Actively promoted Persian culture because of his Persian Empress, Nur Jahan
Shah Jahan (Reigned 1628-1658)
Jahangir's son
During his reign architecture was characterized by its monumental scale
The most important architectural change was the use of marble instead of sandstone
Shah Jahan’s magnificent architectural achievements are represented by two important buildings; the Taj Mahal (1630-1653), and the Jama Masjid in Delhi (1648)
Ousted by his own son, Aurangzeb
Brief History of Mughal Empire & Mughal emperors (1526-1707)
Aurangzeb (Reigned 1658-1707)
Declared his father, Emperor Shah Jahan, incompetent to rule and confined him at Agra Fort but did not mistreat him. Shah Jahan died in 1666
Under Aurangzeb the empire was expanded and he ruled over most of the Indian subcontinent
A pious muslim but his religious conservatism and intolerance undermined the stability of Mughal society
He was a strong and effective ruler, but with his death the great period of the Mughal Empire came to an end, and central control of the sub-continent declined rapidly
Brief History of Mughal Empire (1526-1707)
Babur• (1526-30)
• Founder of Mughal Empire
• Made the modest beginning of Mughalarchitecture
Humayan• (1530-1556)
Akbar• (1556-1605)
• Started building on massive scale
• Beginning of the great period of Mughalarchitecture
Jahangir• (1605-28)
• Richest period of Mughal empire
Shah Jahan• (1628-1658)
• Built Taj Mahal & JamaMosque in Delhi
Aurangzeb• (1658-1707)
• Ousted his father and confined him in Agra Fort
• Ruled over most of Indian Subcontinent
The walled city of Fatehpur Sikri – Built by Akbar
Mughal Structure during Akbar’s reign
The Jama Mosque in Fatehpur Sikri – Built by Akbar Humayun’s Tomb – Built by Akbar
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
Mughal structure during Jahangir’s reign
Itimad-ud-DaulaCompleted in 1628 – Built by Jahangir
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
Mughal structures during Shah Jahan’s reign
Wazir Khan Mosque
Taj Mahal, Agra, India
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
Red Fort (Delhi Fort), Delhi
Mughal structures during Shah Jahan’s reign
Jama’ Mosque, Delhi
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
Mughal structures during Aurangzeb’s reign
Badhashi Mosque, Lahore
Pictures lifted from wikipedia.org
The end of Mughal Empire great period
The demise of Aurangzeb ended the great period of Mughal Empire
Aurangzeb was replaced by his son Bahadur Shah
After the demise of Bahadur Shah, Mughal Empire sank into chaos and violent feuds
Mughal Empire was decentralized and disintegrated when many territories declared independence
The British, at first established themselves in India as traders at the beginning of the 17th century, have developed into a power through the British East India Company controlling 3 principal ports of India – Bombay, Calcutta and Madras by the end of the 17th century.
The British Raj
BEFORE 1857
The British started its rule or dominion in India through East India Company based in Calcutta since 1757.
Architectural style: the European classical style (incorporating Greek and Roman Features such as columns, triangular pediments) or Gothic and British Victorian
Applied to the public and other buildings during earlier period of colonial rule to reflect their self image as the holders of power and status and to distance themselves from the natives.
AFTER REVOLT OF 1857
After the Indian Rebellion of 1857 , the British Government officially took over the rule from East India Company in 1858. It marked the beginning of the British Raj in India.
In trying to avoid another rebellion and to please the natives, the British decided to incorporate the India’s glorious past image of Mughal architectural style into their new buildings by combining it with the elements of British Victorian, Neo-classical and Gothic revival architecture.
This resulted in the birth of Indo-Saracenic architectural style
Indo-Saracenic architecture
An architectural style movement by British architects in the late 19th century British India which drew elements from native Indo-Islamic (Mughal) and Indian architecture and combined it with the Gothic revival and Neo-Classical styles favoured in Victorian Britain
Indo-Saracenic architectural style began in the 1870s and lasted, despite competing revivalist ideologies, until Independence in 1947
The style was adopted mostly for Major government owned institutional buildings such as administrative and Collector’s offices, law courts, municipal headquarters, railway stations and universities.
Indo-Saracenic architecture
The British attempted to strike a balance between keeping the elements of British architecture and the past image of Mughal/Indian elements.
“In the public buildings put up by the Raj it was essential always to make visible Britain’s imperial position as ruler, for these structures were charged with the explicit purpose of representing empire itself. Since they wanted to legitimatize their rule, they decided to justify their presence by relating themselves to the previous rulers, the Mughals. The British deliberately kept Mughal princes in power so as to not provoke Indian contempt and to further establish their connection to the Mughals. These princes were a vision of the future, but the British also needed them to be a representation of the past. And it worked.”
“the British sought to incorporate their view of India’s past into their own building, and so represent Britain’s Raj as legitimately Indian, while at the same time constructing a modern India of railways, colleges, and law courts”
– Sir Thomas Metcalf (an expert in Indo-Saracenic architecture)
Indo-Saracenic architecture
Not all buildings constructed by the British during British Raj were designed with Indo-Saracenic architecture though
Most of the Indo-Saracenic buildings are located in Madras (Chennai) According to Dr. Gavin Stamp, T. Roger Smith (architect of European
General Hospital in Bombay) his answer to the question: “What sort of architecture ought we to employ in India?” was firm: “We ought, like the Romans and the Mohammedans, to take our national style with us. Our buildings ought to hold up a high standard of European art. They ought to be European, both as a rallying point for ourselves, and as raising a distinctive symbol of our presence to be beheld with respect and even admiration by the natives of the country".
And according to Dr. Gavin Stamp, in the ensuing argument William Emerson, another architect who had designed buildings in India (in Indo-Saracenic style), begged to differ. He did not think the conquerors should carry a new style of architecture into the conquered nations; rather, he thought we should follow the Mohammedans who adapted their style to Indian conditions.
Indo-Saracenic architecture
The leading Architects of Indo-Saracenic Buildings in India were
Robert Fellowes Chisholm - Pioneer of Indo-Saracenic architecture and consulting architect to the government
JW Brassington – successor to Robert Chisholm as consulting architect to the government
Henry Irwin – successor to JW Brassington as consulting architect to the government
Major Charles Mant
William Emerson
George Wittet
Frederick W. Stevens
Features of Indo-Saracenic architecture
FEATURES OF INDO-SARACENIC
ARCHITECTURE
Bulbous (Onion-Shaped) Dome
Arches
• horseshoe, pointed, ogee, scalloped, keyhole
Delicate Ornamentation
• Nonfigurative
• Quranic script
Chhatri
• Pavillion with dome
Jharokha
• Overhanging balcony
Chajja
• overhanging eaveson large carved brackets.
Jali
• Perforated stone or latticed screen
Towers or minarets
Pinnacles or spires
Indo-Saracenic buildings
The Chepauk Palace
Built in the year 1768 in Chennai and designed by Paul Benfield
Said to be the first Indo-Saracenic building in modern India. Indo-Saracenic architecture represents a synthesis of Islamic designs and Indian materials developed by British architects in India during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
It is referred to as licentious ‘eclectic” incorporating synthesis of Islamic designs and Indian elements and motifs. The architectural elements include the cusped arches, domes, spires, tracery, minarets and stained glass.
Madras High Court | Completed in 1892 Designed by JW Brassington and Henry Irwin
Indo-Saracenic buildings
Picture source: thehindu.com
Indo-Saracenic buildings
Picture source: thehindu.com
Victoria Memorial HallCompleted in 1921
Designed by William EmersonMayo College
Completed in 1885Designed by Major Charles Mant
Indo-Saracenic buildings
Picture source: thehindu.com
Senate House of University of MadrasCompleted in 1879
Designed by Robert Chisholm General Post Office in Chennai (Madras)Completed in 1879
Designed by Robert Chisholm
Indo-Saracenic architecture in Malaya
For some strange reasons Indo-Saracenic architecture was exported to then Malaya or at that time was referred to as FMS (Federated Malay States)
The likeliest reason was because the natives of Malaya were muslims or dubbed Mohammedans by the British
According to JM Gullick in his journal titled Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad it was William Maxwell (then Resident of Selangor since 1889) who was first instrumental in introducing Indo-Saracenic architecture to the Federated Malay States (FMS). He brought in CE Spooner from Ceylon to overhaul PWD as state engineer. Spooner remained in Malaya until his death in 1909.
Spooner “didn’t like the design” provided by AC Norman and RAJ Bidwell in Classic Renaissance for the Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad. He then decided on what he termed Mahometan (sic) style. The detailed drawing was then done by RAJ Bidwell and assisted by AB Hubback who also made many alterations and additions.
JM Gullick also strongly suspected that CE Spooner designed the Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad based on the drawing of The Muir College, Allahabad, India designed by William Emerson published in Building News (British technical journal)
Indo-Saracenic building
Muir CollegeCompleted in 1886
Designed by William Emerson
Pictures lifted from thehindu.com
Indo-Saracenic architecture in Malaya
According to JM Gullick no explanation was given by Spooner why he chose “Mahometan style” but JM Gullick believed “there can be no doubt that he (Spooner) was adopting as his model a style which British architects had evolved for public buildings in India”.
Spooner served in Ceylon (1897-92) and he must have been familiar with Indo-Saracenic style which was widespread especially in Madras at that time.
This was also encouraged by W.E.Maxwell as he thought Kuala Lumpur much needed a prestige as a new capital of FMS.
Spooner in his opening speech at the opening ceremony of Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad announced he drew in an able architect, AB Hubback.
Later the potent combination of these two capable public servants that produced a large number of elegant public buildings with Indo-Saracenic style in Malaya
CE Spooner & AB Hubback
Two gentlemen instrumental in introducing and adopting Mughal/Indo-Saracenic architectural style for many public buildings in then Malaya
Sultan Abdul Samad Building
Sultan Abdul Samad Building
First building designed with Mughal / Indo-Saracenic style in Malaya
Built in 1897
Architect: RAJ Bidwell and AB Hubback
Earlier design in Neo-Classical by AC Norman was rejected by CE Spooner as State Engineer
CE Spooner who served in Sri Lanka before coming to Selangor preferred Indo-Saracenicarchitecture for Malay-Islam majority Malaya
The clock mechanism was imported from South Croydon, Surrey in England and manufactured by Gillett & Johnston (Croydon) Ltd.
The clock tower was built to replicate the famous Big Ben of London.
Its clock chimed for the first time in 1897 to coincide with Queen Victoria’s Diamond Jubilee parade.
Known simply as the Government Office
In 1974 it was renamed Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad
Sultan Abdul Samad Building
Contractor: Towkay Ang SengMooi
A megaproject back then which cost $152,000 Straits Dollars
Once the icon of Malaysian Court of Law due to some high-profile cases tried here. The building became the centre of attention worldwide
Featured as the site of Malaysian court in the 1992 Hong Kong box-office film, Police Story 3: Super Cop featuring Jackie Chan and Michelle Yeoh
City Theatre
City Theatre
Built in 1902 and completed in 1904
Architect: AB Hubback
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
In 1904, this building originally housed the Kuala Lumpur Town Hall including the Auditorium, Municipal Offices and Sanitary Board which acted like a town council, each with its own entrance.
Two imposing porte-cochère, each with big black dome at the top
A major fire in 1992 destroyed the entire interior of the theatre but City Hall’s designers and builders restored it soon after
The National Textile Museum
The National Textile Museum
Completed in 1905 First built to accommodate the Federated
Malay States Railways Central Offices Located at the Market Street - Damansara
Road junction Main features: Alternate red brick facing
and white plaster band on exterior walls, with cupolas and chatris
Designed by Arthur Benison Hubback (AB Hubback) in 1902
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Built by contractor Towkay Ang Seng Mooiat a cost of $116,122 Straits Dollars
1917 - 1919: It was occupied by FMS Public Works Department
1959 - 1971: First Headquarters of Malaysian Central Bank (Bank Negara)
It currently houses the National Textile Museum
The former General Post Office Building
The former General Post Office Building
Built to accommodate the General Post Office
Located at the Market Street - Jalan Raja junction
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic The only Mughal-style building without any
domes Featuring rooftop leaf design flat decorative
pediments, chatri pinnacles, polygonal corner stair towers
Architect: Arthur Benison Hubback (AB Hubback) in 1902
Contract was awarded to Towkay Choo TeckLim who unfortunately was unable to deliver the building.
Construction was continued by Singaporean Contractor Messrs. Walter Pallister in August 1904
Building completed in 1907 at the cost of $100,000.00 Straits Dollars
Masjid Jamek
Masjid Jamek
Completed in 1909
Architecture: Mughal/Indo-Saracenic
Architect: Arthur Benison Hubback
Sultan Alauddin Sulaiman Shah laid its foundation stone on 23 March 1908 and officially opened it on 23 Dec 1909
Features: 3 onion-shaped large domes, 2 identical minarets and cinquefoil arches
The site was originally muslimcemetery which was relocated to Gombak cemetery
The mosque was unofficially the Malaysian main mosque before the status was taken over by the National Mosque in 1965
The former Session & Magistrate Court Building
The former Session & Magistrate Court Building
Built in 1910
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Architect: Arthur Benison Hubback
Originally housed FMS Survey Department
Main feature: 400ft (121.9m) long arcade with two entrances
At both ends of this building are octagonal towers topped with onion-shaped domes
Along the 400ft long arcade are the distinctive cinquefoil arches that creates a powerful geometric rhythm along the street
Used to house Sessions and Magistrate Court
It is now left vacant
The Old Kuala Lumpur Railway Station
The Old Kuala Lumpur Railway Station
Completed in 1910
Station was opened on 1 July 1911
Hotel operation began on 11 Aug 1911
450ft x 150ft wide with three railway platforms
A two-storey station building with mezzanine and 16 hotel bedrooms on the second floor
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-saracenic
Architect: AB Hubback
Cost: $742,980 Straits Dollars (Construction involved straightening some portions of the Klang River, building of temporary station and dismantling the staff quarters and re-erecting them in Brickfields)
Voted as one of the 28 most beautiful railway stations in the world by Architectural Digest
It now still serves as Kuala Lumpur station for KTM Komuter Train
The Old Supreme Court Building
The Old Supreme Court Building
Built in 1915
Replaced the old Supreme Court on Court Hill
Architect: AB Hubback
Architecture style: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Contractor: Towkay Ang Seng Mooi
Cost $208,500 Straits Dollars
Features: Decorative cupolas with buttresses
Ubudiah Mosque
Ubudiah Mosque
Foundation stone was laid by Sultan IdrisMurshidul'adzam Shah on 26 Sept 1913
The construction was commissioned on the orders of the Sultan, who vowed that he would build a mosque of great beauty as thanksgiving for recovery from an illness which plagued him in those early days
Completed in late 1917
Cost: $200,000.00 – astronomical figures for a mosque those days
Standing on the octagonal base of 96ft in diameter
Built entirely in concrete and finishing with Italian marble
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Architect: Arthur Benison Hubback
Its imposing large golden domes and minarets create spellbinding sight from near and far
Considered one of the finest mosques in the East even in this modern days
Officially opened by Sultan Abdul Jalil KaramtullahShah
KTM Headquarters
KTM Headquarters
Completed in 1917
Originally housed The FMS Railway Administration Centre
Now occupied by KTM Berhad as its headquarters
Architect: AB Hubback
Architecture: Mughal-eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Constructed by Towkay Chua Hua Tong
Cost: $587,000 Straits Dollars
It has 3 storeys and was the tallest building in the FMS
Main feature: the centre octagonal cantilever staircase – the only example at that time was found on the east of Suez
Ipoh Railway Station & Hotel
Ipoh Railway Station & Hotel
Built in 1914, completed in 1917 (some said completion was delayed until 1920)
Architecture: Mughal eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Architect: Arthur Benison Hubback The design concept: a solid Neoclassical
building embodying strict symmetry, balance and harmony while the façade and roof design was based on Mughalarchitectural style
Dubbed as the Taj Mahal of Ipoh The filming site for the Hollywood 1999
film “Anna and the King” featuring Jodie Foster and Chow Yun Fat
The automobile guide of 1925 stated that: “The railway hotel at Ipoh supplies the best accommodation to be found in Perak, nice airy rooms, up-to-date sanitary arrangements, the best of food”.
Federated Malay States Railway Station in Penang
Federated Malay States Railway Station in Penang
Built in 1907
Architecture: Mughal eclectic/Indo-Saracenic
Architect: Arthur Benison Hubback
Boasts of uniquely distinct arcades (a structure composed of a series of arches supported by columns).
Before Komtar (the state’s administrative and shopping tower) Wisma Kastam’s clock tower (which by the way is still ticking with precision) was the tallest building on the island.
Back when it was called the Federated Malay States Railway Station, the station is believed to be the only one in the world without a rail. Instead of platforms or trains, it had administrative offices, a ticketing booth and a first-class Railways Restaurant with Bar and Grill.
Passengers bought their tickets at the Penang Railway Station, walked to the Railway Jetty at the end of the China Street Ghaut and boarded the Railway Ferry Streamers to Butterworth to catch the train. Fares to and from Penang were inclusive of the ferry ride.
It now houses Royal Custom Department of Malaysia, Penang branch
Thank you
References
Carey, M. (2012). An illustrated history of islamic architecture. Leicestershire: Southwater.
Gullick, J.M. (1992). The Bangunan Sultan Abdul Samad. Journal of the Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, 65, 27-38.
Jeyaraj, G. Indo Saracenic Architecture in Channai. Retrieved from http://www.cmdachennai.gov.in/pdfs/seminar_heritage_buildings/Indo_Saracenic_Architecture_in_Chennai.pdf
Maryam Khazaee, Naziaty Yaacob, Zakaria Alcheikh Mahmoud Awad, & Zuraini Md Ali. (2015). Mughal or Moorish architecture: the origins of Malaysian mosques during colonial periods. Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum., 23 (3): 639 - 654
Metcalf, T. (2002). An Imperial Vision: Indian Architecture and Britain's Raj. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Morris, J., & Winchester, S. (1986). Stones of empire: The buildings of the Raj. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Nath, R. (2004). Indigenous characteristics of mughal architecture. New Delhi: Indian History and Culture Society.
Stamp, G. (1981). British architecture in India 1857 - 1947. Journal of the Royal Society of Arts, 357-377.
wikipedia.org
Top Related