7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
1/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
2/28
Sheriff at Cupar Trial: Saying that a state is terrorist
says that everyone within the state is terrorist."
On August 23rd student Paul Donnachie was found guilty in Cupar Sheriff Court of racially
aggravated conduct after showing contempt for an Israeli flag on the wall of a two-bed student
residence shared by his friend and an American Zionist. The Sheriff took five minutes after the
closing submissions to hand down his guilty verdict and called for a social enquiry report, often
a signal to all concerned to expect a harsh, or even a custodial, sentence. Within the hour, PaulDonnachie received a letter of expulsion from St Andrews University.
Sheriff Charles MacNair based his guilty verdict partly on his characterisation of US citizen
Reitblatt as a member of Israel. MacNair earlier overturned his own previous decision,
delivered in open court, to hear the evidence of three expert witnesses called by the defence.
Academic witnesses including two leading members of Scottish Jews for a Just Peace and the
chair of Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign were left in the witness room while Sheriff
MacNair exhibited an ignorance of the subjects the witnesses would have illuminated.
Reitblatt stated in court his opposition to international law, his belief that there was no Israelioccupation of any part of Palestine, and his political commitment to Zionist Jews' right to control
the entirety of Israel and Palestine, as well as parts of Syria and Egypt.
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
3/28
SAME OLD SONG: US SUPPORTER OF ISRAELI
APARTHEID DISHONESTLY CLAIMS TO BE VICTIM OF
RACISM.By Mick Napier
The Northern Region Jewish Chaplaincy is rushing to smear opponents of Israeli terrorism andethnic cleansing as racist, hoping to build on the bizarre ruling handed down in Cupar Sheriff
Court. During deliberations, Sheriff MacNair called US citizen Chanan Reitblat a member of
Israel.
The press release by the Northern Region (i.e. Scottish) Jewish Chaplaincy claims that Chanan
Reitblat was attacked in his own bedroomHis property was abused[and] he was subjected
to serious harassment and humiliation, was jumped upon in his bed, and had his Jewish identity
questioned and insulted.
Ephraim Borowski, on behalf of SCoJeC (Scottish Council of Jewish Communities) denouncedDonnachies thuggish behaviour...[as] racist action...bullying...and intimidation and accused all
those who deny the allegation that Donnachie was motivated by racism as themselves
racist...hid[ing] their racist stereotyping and violence behind facile lip-service to anti-racism.
This is only one of a long line of unfounded accusations of racism against those
opposing Zionism, both in the UK and around the world.
The claim that Reitblat was attacked is manifestly untrue. Despite the evidence of inebriated
behaviour in poor taste, for which Donnachie rightly apologised, no assault took place, no one
was ever charged with assault and no evidence was presented in court that anyone attackedReitblat. It didnt happen. By his Jewish identity, Rabbi Wayland means his and Reitblats
support for the State of Israel, a wholly political affiliation opposed by supporters of human
rights, including many Jews, who distinguish sharply between the religion of Judaism and the
project of dispossession that is the State of Israel.
Reitblatt also claimed that the insult to the Israeli flag, a gift from his brother while serving in
Israel's Occupation Forces, an army notorious for its human rights violations, had made him
unable to sleep or eat for some days. Paul Donnachie explained that his hostility to the Israeli
flag was based on his anti-racist convictions, and anger at Israeli terrorism against the
Palestinian people. Donnachie explained to Sheriff MacNair his position that "the citizens of a
country cannot be held responsible for the actions of a state". When he had finished, Sheriff
MacNair gave his own opinion that "The state of Israel is the land and its borders and the people
in it...Saying that a state is terrorist says that everyone within the state is terrorist."
Sheriff MacNair claimed he "took no position on the rights and wrongs of the Israel-Palestine
conflict", but stressed that he "was impressed by Reitblatts testimony". MacNair rejected, and
seemed not to understand, Donnachies clear exposition of the difference between a state and
a population. His description of Reitblatt, a Lithuanian-born American citizen who has never
visited Israel/Palestine, as a "member of Israel" seemed to be a key part of his case in convicting
Donnachie on a charge of racism.
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
4/28
Paul Donnachie and Reitblat knew each other well; the two had socialised extensively in St
Andrews' smallest University hall, as part of a close friendship group, would eat together every
day and had even attended a lecture on the "Economy of the Occupation" by Israeli economist
and activist Shir Hever, organised by the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign. This despite
Reitblat being on the extremist fringe of supporters of Israel, as evidenced by his courtroom
statement that he considers Israel to encompass all the areas it conquered in 1948, 1967, and
1973, i.e. the whole of Palestine plus parts of Egypt, Syria and Lebanon.
The testimony of Matt Cunningham, a witness in the case, stood directly against Reitblat's
uncorroborated claim, accepted by Sheriff MacNair in a clear violation of Scottish legal norms,
that Paul said to Reitblat, "You are a terrorist". It was clear to those who sat through the
proceedings that Sheriff MacNair wanted to accept Reitblats accusation in court that Sam
Colchester Donnachie's fellow accused - had said the same thing. However, given that
Reitblat had admitted at the time of the incident that Sam had done nothing in the room, a fact
known to the investigating police officers and firmly highlighted in court by the Assistant Warden
of the halls of residence, MacNair was unable to disagree when Sams lawyers asserted that
Reitblats testimony was not only uncorroborated, but clearly unreliable and incredible. For theuninitiated, that is lawyer-speak for Reitblat has clearly lied either in court or in his earlier
statements. This will be one of the issues addressed in Paul Donnachies forthcoming appeal.
Even the unreliable and incredible testimony of Reitblatt, however, never at any time included
the claim that he was assaulted by Donnachie.
By the following morning after the incident, almost certainly egged on by Zionist comrades,
Reitblat was claiming that he was unable to eat or sleep. He would later testify in court that he
had had to get out of St Andrews in his fear of Palestinian organisations linked to terrorist
atrocities and seek sanctuary in the Jewish Chaplaincy in Glasgow. He would claim he hadbeen so traumatised that he almost failed important exams. All this trauma because someone
touched his Israeli flag! Truly, this American citizen suffers from the familiar "Israel syndrome":
simultaneously arrogant and prone to violence, whilst at the same time claiming to be terrified
for his safety.
A Zionist political agenda is evident on the part of both SCoJeC and the Jewish Chaplaincy
(whose moral guidance never includes condemnation of Israel burning hundreds of Palestinian
civilians with white phosphorous). The Jewish Chaplaincy press statement is a political one: it
asserts the rights of students to express theiridentification with the State of Israel and
continues, We believe that Israel being singled out for demonizationgoes beyond legitimate
debate. SCoJeC Board member Paul Morron is pleased that Sheriff MacNair has ruled that
because a Jewish person's identity is associated with Israel that criticism can, as in this case,
constitute racialist aggravated behaviour."
support for the State of Israel, a wholly political affiliation
opposed by supporters of human rights, including many
Jews, who distinguish sharply between the religion ofJudaism and the project of dispossession that is the State
of Israel.
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
5/28
The desire to inhibit and limit criticism of Israel couldnt be clearer; SCoJeC and the Jewish
Chaplaincy aim to put ever larger areas of condemnation of Israel "beyond legitimate debate" as
"racialist aggravated behaviour". The potential effect is clear, when the Palestinian people are
fighting for their existence, facing Israels ruthless programme of ethnic cleansing.
Opponents of Israel's brutal racist system will continue to single out Israel for its abuses ofhuman rights and crimes against humanity, horrors meticulously documented across Palestine
and over decades by, for example, the Goldstone Report. For many Zionists even noting that
Israel is responsible for the killing of hundreds of Palestinian children is judged to be an
anti-Semitic accusation. Its not. Its the well-attested truth. We will continue to promote this
and other truths.
Israel is an important part of my religious belief, said Reitblat. They attacked my beliefs. Now,
George Bush and Tony Blair are Christians, but their very public religiosity doesnt wash away
the blood of their victims or protect them from the contempt of millions. Against the likes of Bush,
Blair, the pro-Buddhist junta in Burma, the Hindu chauvinist BJP in India, the brutal Saudi regimeand its corrupt Ulema, and Zionist Jew Reitblat, a supporter of colonialism, ethnic cleansing and
burning Palestinian civilians with white phosphorous, we can do no better than commend the
words of the courageous American, Fr. Berrigan, "If they come for the innocent without walking
over your body and mine, then a curse on our life and a curse on our religion." We honour all
men and women who fight for justice, from either a secular or religious impulse, and damn all
those who support oppression.
States are not people. Paul Donnachie explained to Sheriff MacNair in simple language his
position that, "The citizens of a country cannot be held responsible for the actions of a state".
Later, Sheriff MacNair gave his own ignorant opinion that, "The state of Israel is the land and its
borders and the people in it... Saying that a state is terrorist says that everyone within the state
is terrorist." All British citizens who opposed the aggressive wars in Iraq and Afghanistan should
ponder on the idiotic and dangerous effusions of the Cupar Sheriff.
This is only one of a long line of unfounded accusations
of racism against those opposing Zionism, both in the UK
and around the world.
The desire to inhibit and limit criticism of Israel couldntbe clearer; SCoJeC and the Jewish Chaplaincy aim to put
ever larger areas of condemnation of Israel "beyond
legitimate debate" as "racialist aggravated behaviour".
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
6/28
Far from SPSC promoting racist stereotyping and violence behind facile lip-service to
anti-racism, we work tirelessly against Israeli criminality as endorsed by Borowski and Reitblat.
Thankfully, public opinion is swinging strongly against Israeli violations of international law and
the type of racist manifesto for Greater Israel promoted unchallenged in open court by Reitblat.
SCoJeC and the Jewish Chaplaincy accuse SPSC of strident support for bullying, intimidation,
and racist stereotyping. In fact, we oppose their never-ending attempts to conflate
anti-Semitism with anti-Zionism, itself a dangerous and racist campaign to implicate all Jews inIsraels crimes against the Palestinian people, crimes on which these nauseating hypocrites are
utterly silent. The intent is clear - to change the subject as far as possible from the crimes of the
State of Israel, increasingly a polecat State in world opinion in the words of Ronnie Kasrils. It
is, frankly, rather sickening, to hear the defenders of the mass murder of Palestinians in Gaza
during Operation Cast Lead lying that they are the victims of a wholly invented assault, and
these same supporters of Israels rigorous State-enforced ethnic residential segregation claim
to be victims of racism when their support for crimes is challenged.
The above are extracts from articles first published on the SPSC website
An A-Z of Solidarity with Palestine B Is for BDS - in 2005, Palestinian civil society issued a call for a campaign of boycotts,
divestment and sanctions (BDS) against Israel until it complies with international
law and Palestinian rights. A truly global movement against Israeli Apartheid israpidly emerging in response to this call. In Scotland there are campaigns to
boycott companies such as Veolia which cooperate with Israeli oppression of
Palestinians. City councils and organsiations such as the Cooperative society are
being lobbied to boycott Israeli goods and the Scottish Trades Union Congress
has already voted in favour of BDS. These non-violent punitive measures should
be maintained until Israel meets its obligation to recognize the Palestinian
peoples inalienable right to self-determination and fully complies with the
precepts of international law by:
1. Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands and dismantling the
Wall
2. Recognizing the fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel to
full equality; and
3. Respecting, protecting and promoting the rights of Palestinian refugees toreturn to their homes and properties as stipulated in UN resolution 194.
http://www.bdsmovement.net/call
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
7/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
8/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
9/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
10/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
11/28
prestigious universities seizing campus buildings in support and solidarity with them they know
they are not alone despite our government's shameful inaction and complicity.
Many of these brilliant and conscientious students are still around and active in recent student
movement against austerity cuts and the cruel consequences of 9000 fees for those down
south. In the midst of this, Palestine was not forgotten. Over the last term conferences were held
in Edinburgh and Dundee bringing together students from Glasgows universities and those
from Edinburgh, St Andrews and Dundee under the umbrella name of Action PalestineScotland, which for many years has worked closely with Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign.
In March 2011 students from around the country met in London for a BDS conference
representing 24 universities and 2 colleges from across the UK and every last one fully
committed to BDS. A BDS committee was formed and as we go into the new term we will take
the lead from the BNC (Boycott National Committee) in Palestine on coordinated days of action
such as Right to Education week and Israeli Apartheid week. Campaigns specific to each
campus will be taken-up, and information and good practice shared between each university.
This close cooperation is already bearing fruit with boycott Israel motions being passed at
Edinburgh Uni and the SOAS in London. In the summer months many trips to Palestine were
organised from this new exciting network with Goldsmiths in London successfully takingstudents to Gaza. The Scottish student delegation toured the West Bank and met with the
Popular Committees and other groups resisting the occupation, not least of those, the brilliant
Jordan Valley Solidarity. At Glasgow University the longest running student occupation in UK
history (February 1st-August 31st) saw many speakers and events on Palestine and a renewed
campaign against the Eden Springs contract was launched from it.
There have of course been attempts by Zionists and their apologists to silence this huge wave
of Palestine activism on UK campuses an example being the denouncement of Edinburgh
Universitys brilliant Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) in the Westminster Parliament.
Students at both Birmingham and Nottingham have come under considerable attack but areunwavering in their support for Palestine. In the same week that an Israeli government
spokesperson called UK universities hotbeds of Anti-Israeli sentiment we saw the disgraceful
conviction of a young St Andrew's student with a proud history of anti-racist activism for the
absurd charge of racially motivated breach of the peace. Because of this ruling a drunken
gesture in bad taste has given those who want to silence student voices for Palestinian human
rights the classic Zionist stick that criticism of Israel is tantamount to anti-Semitism. Needless to
say, students who campaign for Palestine do so upon solid principles of universal human rights
and anti-racism and will continue to do so vigilantly against the attacks facing us, but without
fear of them. As we go into this term Scottish students will work with our partners here such as
Scottish PSC, our fellow students across the UK, and campaigners around the world in joining
with our Palestinian brothers and sisters in their inspiring resistance. We will stand together until
the occupation is over, the apartheid wall comes down, there are equal rights in Israel, and
refugees are finally granted their inalienable right of return. International and human rights law
are on our side; justice is on our side; history is on our side.
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
12/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
13/28
The male prisoners chose a (French-speaking) committee to negotiate with the authorities.
Visiting lawyers initially suggested we appeal against our detention. This idea, probably futile andseeking permission for a perfectly legitimate visit to Palestine, did not take among the male
prisoners. The older men got an offer - a humanitarian gesture - to proceed to Bethlehem as
intended. The offer, if accepted, was also open to the older women. We would have to agree to
avoid areas of conflict however defined by the Israel army. We refused; accepting would divide
us from our younger colleagues in particular, we would have left behind one of our group and all
the Arab-descended French and Belgians.
We demanded that we all get to Bethlehem or receive documents explaining our detention.
Otherwise we would go on hunger strike. We were told immigration officials would bring such
documents, but they came empty-handed.
We went on hunger strike. We were now offered phone calls home if we ate. Some prisoners
were taken to the airport, including two of our group, whod been falsely told the rest of us would
follow and be put on the same plane. Those left in jail loudly protested about being refused phone
calls. Guards photographed our protest.
The hunger strike continued but with fewer prisoners. Travel to Bethlehem was offered again to
a remaining hunger-striker. An argument between cellmates about eating led to one of them
smashing the prison furniture another photo opportunity for our jailers. More prisoners left,
including eight (men and women) of our group who, at the airport, heard yet another offer(refused) to go to Bethlehem. On the plane there were diverse reactions from other passengers:
one apologised for what had happened, another called us Jew-haters. Following discussion with
the UK ambassador, the remaining four (all women) in our group stayed at the prison to pursue an
appeal against detention.
day
2
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
14/28
Three left on day 6 and one on day 7. The idea of appeal was finally abandoned after a German
prisoners appeal failed.
Conclusions
We had visitors in jail, but our hosts in Bethlehem could not receive us as visitors. Hence they are
prisoners less fortunate than us. It is not only Gaza that is a prison.
Israel can jail without reason. If we had broken any Israeli law, we never heard what it was.
Five weeks later, we still dont know what representations, if any, the British government made onour behalf.
Our passports were stamped Entry denied. We never technically entered Israel so technically
we werent deported. We dont know if, on a future visit, we would be allowed in.
A constant Israeli tactic was to divide us with offers to some of travel to Bethlehem.
They were always looking for any evidence that we were the hooligans wed been branded as
before we travelled.
The Israelis consistently lied to us e.g. promising an explanation that never came for our deten-
tion, that all the Brits were to leave on Day 4, etc. It was beneficial for the prisoners to get organ-
ised for negotiations with the authorities. Negotiating with prison staff was complicated because
they were, in effect, intermediaries for authorities elsewhere.
It was good to know that the outside world would know what was happening, although only later
did we have direct knowledge of this.
A hunger strike can produce results from authorities but strikers need to be managed - perhapsstarting with a few strikers prepared to last a while with support from non-strikers.
Our spell in prison was predictably short. Our experience, although unpleasant, was nothing like
as bad as that of Palestinians in Israeli jails.
We had visitors in jail, but
our hosts in Bethlehem could
not receive us as visitors.
Hence they are prisoners less
fortunate than us
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
15/28
Welcome to Palestine 2012
Last year hundreds of human rights activists signed up to Welcome to Palestine 2011 to assert their right to
enter occupied Palestine openly and peacefully at the invitation of Palestinian hosts. In that rst open
effort, over 100 ended up being attacked by Israeli soldiers, imprisoned by the Israeli authorities without
charge, and barred from peacefully proceeding to Bethlehem. Hundreds of others were illegally prevented
from even boarding their ights in a number of European capitals at the behest of the Israeli Government.
Scottish PSC joined in an international organising meeting in Paris, involving both those jailed in 2011 and
new groups joining next year for the rst time. The organisers issued a fresh call for Welcome to Palestine
2012, the next round of the campaign to be allowed to enter Palestine peacefully and openly.
Welcome to Palestine 2011 planned to help Palestinians replant some of the million olive trees destroyed
by Israeli authorities since 1967. Participants in Welcome to Palestine 2012 aim to contribute their skills
towards the building of a Palestinian school. We call on you to join and support our peaceful action to
secure this fundamental right to freedom of travel: Israels failure to concede this minimum right will mean
t has publicly crossed another red line in its denial of Palestinian human rights.
Join Welcome to Palestine 2012, which begins on Sunday April 15th with ights from many international
airports to Occupied Palestine, by necessity via Tel Aviv Airport in Israel. * Join us on April 15th ying into
Palestine via Tel Aviv: email [email protected]
* Add your name and that of your organisation, trade union, campaign group, church, etc., to list of
signatories endorsing the attached appeal. Forward the Appeal to other human rights supporters
* Demand your MPs and MEPs support the right to freedom of movement into and out of the OccupiedPalestine Territories (OPT)
* Make a nancial donation to assist someone else to participate.
Welcome to Palestine Initiative 2012 Letter
"We, the undersigned, endorse the call from the Welcome to Palestine 2012 initiative for supporters of Palestinian
human and national rights around the world to openly visit Palestine during Easter 2012. There is no way into
Palestine other than through Israeli control points. Israel has turned Palestine into a giant prison, but prisonershave a right to receive visitors. Welcome to Palestine 2012 will again challenge Israel's policy of isolating the West
Bank while the settler paramilitaries and army commit brutal crimes against a virtually defenceless Palestinian
civilian population. We call on governments to support the right of Palestinians to receive visitors and the right of
their own citizens to visit Palestine openly. The participants in Welcome to Palestine 2012 ask to be allowed to
pass through Tel Aviv airport without hindrance and to proceed to the West Bank to take part in a project there
for children to benet from the right to education."
SIGNED:
Tony Benn Noam Chomsky
Ronnie Kasrils John Pilger
Nawal Al Sadaawi Desmond Tutu
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
16/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
17/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
18/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
19/28
The Housing Situation in East
Jerusalem and Occupied
Palestinian Territories The International Court of Justice has stated that the 4th Geneva Convention for the
Protection of Civilian persons in Times of War applies to the Occupied Palestinian
Territories, including East Jerusalem.
At least 24,813 houses have been demolished in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and
Gaza since 1967, in complete violation of the 4th Geneva Convention
From 1967 2003, 90,000 housing units were built in East Jerusalem settlements for
Jews, most with government subsidies. Not one home was built for Palestinians with
public funding.
15% of Israel's housing budget is spent on settlement construction and expansion,
which serves just 6% of the population of Israel.
Claiming that a protest is not concerned with 'politics' but with 'social justice' is a blatant refusal to acknowledge the
suffering of Palestinians living in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT). A protest which addresses
issues of class, economics and welfare is, irrefutably, a political protest.
A protest of this nature which does not display any level of regard for the daily human rights violations to which
Palestinians are subjected is not an example of 'people power' or 'democracy', but is merely another example of a
fundamental lack of concern for Palestinians living under an apartheid state under threat of ethnic cleansing.
The irony of Israelis choosing to live in tents not too far from the safety of their homes, upon land from which
Palestinians were expelled is extremely uncomfortable. For the 750,000 Palestinians who were ethnically cleansed
in 1948, living in tents was not a choice. These Palestinians still do not have the option of returning to their homes.
There are now 6.7 million Palestinian refugees who, for more than 6 decades have lived in foreign countries as
second class citizens.
Democracy and social justice should be for all; based not on the I.D card held, but on a basic principle of human rights.
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
20/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
21/28
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
22/28
PATRICK OHAREInterview with:
Patrick OHare was elected president of the
Students Association at St Andrews University in
May of 2011. A student of Spanish, he was also
involved in the Left Society and the PalestineSociety. He was one of the organisers of the
protests and occupation in the wake of the Israeli
bombing of Gaza at the end of 2009. In the
summer of 2011, he visited Palestine for the first
time.
SPSC: why did you decide to go to Palestine?
Patrick: I was part of the campaigning that kick-started the Palestine solidarity work on campus
after the massacre in Gaza, and Id been looking for an opportunity to go there ever since. It so
happened that my brother was organising a trip to Jerusalem and the West Bank, the dates
fitted as I could go between exams and graduation, and I thought it would be a graduation trip
with a difference. My brother has links with the organisers of visits from Goldsmiths College in
London and the university in Edinburgh. This time the group included students from here, St
Andrews and Glasgow. We stayed in a hostel frequently used by other students and had the
same translator but it was really quite a mix solidarity activists, students of world religions, orArabic, but not really a big organized tour. In fact, it wasnt really an activists tour and we were
aware of different peoples interests and their nervousness about being there.
SPSC: Would you recommend other people go on a trip like this if they have the
opportunity?
Patrick: Definitely. In Edinburgh there wasnt much activism in the Palestinian solidarity group
but after going out there, people came back really interested in getting involved. The first hand
witness experience seems to have really changed them. For me it brought home how urgent the
Palestine solidarity work is. We saw, this was the most shocking for me in some ways, how the
Israelis are chipping away, literally in some cases, at the Palestinian community in East
Jerusalem. For example, we saw the tunnels being dug linking settlements to the King David
archeology site and houses being cleared andI realised theyre taking this city house by
house.
SPSC: Did you make contact with Palestinian activists there that you hope to estab-
lish stronger links with?
Patrick: certainly, Id like to maintain links with Bir Zeit University in Ramallah and
Najah in Nablus. And Id particularly like to work with Palestinian students at theHebrew University. Obviously theyre Israeli Arab citizens and are often used as
evidence that Israel provides education for Palestinians. It was really interesting to
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
23/28
Jim is a councillor in West Dunbartonshire. He is a
member of the Scottish Socialist Party (SSP), and
is at present its only elected representative. In2007 West Dunbartonshire Council adopted a
motion by Jim to boycott all Israel goods. Jim is a
strong advocate a policy of Boycott, Disinvestment
and Sanctions (BDS) against Israel, to be adopted
by other councils and Scottish Government
hear from them about the way, during the war on Gaza, their Israeli classmates were
pulled out to go and fight, how they organized protest demonstrations and how the
authorities organised counter demonstrations which ended up as physical clashes. So
Id like to see Palestinian students coming over here to visit and talk about their lives.
We also met up with Bustan committee, the Israeli Committee against House
Demolitions and Stop the Wall. These gave us not only first hand experience of tear
gas but also more academic experiences, learning about the reasons, the processes
that are at work.
SPSC: what plans do you have for passing on the things youve learned?
Patrick: Well, obviously Id like to do a talk for the Palestinian Society just as soon as
the students are back.
SPSC: You used the word urgency before. What do you think you can encourage
students to do?
Patrick: the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions campaign is the most obvious, well have
to see what support there is but it seems probable there could be a motion to boycott
settlement goods, especially after people have been there, seen Palestinians being
exploited in Jordan Valley settlements with the involvement of multi-nationals in some
cases. You can make a case quite convincingly for BDS
SPSC: So what can be done now that the Israeli government has brought in a law
making it difficult to distinguish between Israeli and settlement produce?
Patrick: well that fits with the call from Palestinian civil society to boycott, not justsettlement goods but those from inside Israel as well. And actually, even though the
settlers dont necessarily represent all of Israeli society, they are absolutely supported
by the government. Settlements have been built and expanded without much let up.
there hasnt really been any halt in the process of settlement building.
SPSC: and finally, would you think theres the possibility of a debate on the call for an
academic and cultural boycott of Israel much like the one imposed on Apartheid South
African during the years of Nelson Mandelas imprisonment?
Patrick: I would imagine there could certainly be a debate. UCU has quite a strong
position on support for Palestinian rights so I would expect quite a lot of staff to be
interested in hearing the arguments.
this was the most shocking for me in
some ways... I realised they're taking
this city house by house
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
24/28
Hadrian's Wall Walk
From August 3rd to 7th, the Aberdeen branch of Scottish PalestineSolidarity Campaign walked 84 miles along the path
of Hadrian's Wall. Through the slight pain of multiple blisters and the mild discomfort of rain-soaked clothes the group
completed the walk on schedule.
The idea of the walk was to highlight symbolic similarities with Israel's Separation Wall in the Occupied Territories and
Roman efforts to contain a rebellious Scots population during the Roman occupation of Britain. Emperor Hadrian
ordered the construction of the wall between Wallsend on the east coast and Bowness-on-Solway on the west coast in
122 AD. According to Aelius Spartianus, writing in the 3rd century AD, Hadrian wanted to separate barbarians and
Romans. Israel commenced the building of a separation barrier in 2002 and has continued with this project, in defiance
of the International Court of Justice's finding that it is contrary to international law. This wall cuts off Palestinian towns
and villages and destroys land and livelihoods.
The group also walked to raise money for the Plant-a-Tree in Palestine project which, in turn, raises awareness of the
work of the controversial role of the JNF and the charitable status the organisation unjustifiably enjoys in the UK.
It's not too late to donate to the cause: if you would like to sponsor the group please write a cheque made out to
Aberdeen SPSC and send it to Martin, SPSC Aberdeen, 21 Broadfold Drive, Aberdeen, AB23 8PJ, or donate online at
http://www.scottishpsc.org.uk. Alternatively write a letter a letter to your MP asking them to sign EDM 1677, challenging
the charitable status of the JNF in the UK.
An A-Z of Solidarity with Palestine B Is forBorders Israel is a state without officially declared borders, but whose defacto borders have expanded repeatedly as it occupies more and more land
by force. At first this was done with British support and through purchasing
land from absentee landlords. In 1948, mass killing was used to terrorise thelocal people into fleeing. In 1967, the defeat of Arab armies trying to win back
Palestine meant further land was lost. In the 1980s Israel formally annexed
east Jerusalem and the Golan Heights in Syria. During the last twenty years,
a policy of supporting groups of armed settlers has meant large areas of the
West Bank have become no-go areas for Palestinians. The latest move in the
Israeli land grab has been the building of a fortified fence and wall which
extends its defacto border into another 12% of the West Bank.
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
25/28
Contact
DUMFRIES & GALLOWAY
Contact
FORTH VALLEY
Contact
Contact
Contact
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
26/28
Contact
FORTH VALLEY
Contact
Contact
PERTH
ST ANDREWS Contact
FIFE Contacts
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
27/28
To purchase contact your local branch or
email [email protected]
7/29/2019 SPSC Winter 2011 newsletter
28/28
Top Related