Social Networking, Sexting, and YouTube: Protect Your Students, Protect Your School
4th Annual SW/WC Service Cooperative Technology Conference
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
DisclaimerThe information in this presentation is not legal
advice and is not intended as legal advice. It is intended to provide general legal information. It does not cover all issues related to the topics discussed. The specific facts that apply to your matter may make the outcome different than you might anticipate based on the material presented. Please consult with your own attorney with regard to specific issues.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Sources of Law
Constitutional law Codified law Case law Contract law (“private law”)
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
WHAT THE CONTENT CREATOR CLAIMS
WHAT OTHERS MIGHT CLAIM
Free Speech Libel Slander Harassment Invasion of privacy Unfair competition Right to publicity Free speech Negligence
Legal Claims
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Use of school resources: what may schools restrict?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Obscene, rude, and discriminatory speech
Criminal or dangerous speech Speech that could cause damage or
that presents a danger for the school or a school member
Speech that abuses or clogs the school internet system
If policy clearly declares the school system a “limited forum”: anything of a non-educational nature.
Student non-school use of the Internet: what may schools restrict?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Student speech is likely to be protected unless the content:
1. Constitutes a material disruption to class work; or
2. Involves a substantial disorder or invasion of the rights of others.
In practice, courts generally protect student speech unless it contains threats and references to violence.
Creating “private law” for the schoolPolicies . . . Prescribe rules of conduct Instruct re: privacy and personal safety
issues Identify school Internet system as a “limited
forum” Limit use of school Internet systems Address the unique circumstances of “laptop
schools” Establish “free speech” parameters for
private and parochial schools Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
What falls into the “private law” category? Acceptable use policies (for students
and staff) Classroom and project specific
guidelines Parent permission slips Student use “contracts” Age-specific access policies
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Multi-step approach
Identify the technology issue Conduct a stakeholder analysis Conduct a policy audit Draft/amend policy, if necessary Develop strategies and solutions to
maximize safety and minimize risk
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Conducting a stakeholder analysis
Who in your school community is affected by technology issues?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Who are the stakeholders? Identify all stakeholders – who is
affected by the technology issue and who will be affected by a policy?
Prioritize stakeholders – who must be won over? Who needs notice? Who can assist with the process?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
KEEP SATISFIED
MANAGE CLOSELY
MONITOR (MINIMUM EFFORT)
KEEP INFORMED
High
Low
Low High
Conducting a policy audit
What are the current issues facing your school involving technology?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Conduct a policy audit
Has your school done the following: Made an assessment of legal risks arising
from the use of classroom technology? Communicated clear expectations and
boundaries re: all uses of the technology? Enlisted student, staff, and parent input in
drafting school technology “contracts”? Established training requirements and
policy acceptance procedures prior to allowing use of technology resources?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Conduct a policy audit, cont. Incorporated parent education into your
school’s technology strategy? Established a “chain of command” for
reporting incidents? Reviewed the policies on a regular basis
since instituting them? (Ask: Are the current policies flexible enough to deal with new/emerging technologies? What new issues need to be addressed now that didn’t exist previously?)
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Social networking scenarios
Developing strategies for K-12 schools
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Imposter sites
J.S. through her parents Terry Snyder and Steven Snyder v. Blue Mountain School Dist. (Decision pending by 3rd Circuit)
Middle school student suspended for 10 days for creating derogatory imposter MySpace site portraying school principal as a pedophile and sex addict.
Parents brought suit alleging a violation of their child’s free speech rights and their rights as parents to determine how best to “raise, nurture, discipline, and educate” their child.
Most commonly appear on social networking sites.Teachers and school administrators are common targets, as are students. Related legal claims: defamation, invasion of privacy, violations of free speech.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Teacher/staff websites, and blogs
Payne v. Barrow County School Dist.
Teacher alleges she was forced to resign her position without adequate notice or due process when confronted about Facebook photo in which she is holding an alcoholic beverage and a “status update” in which she used the word “bitch.”
Off campus speech of public school teachers is scrutinized to a much greater extent than the speech of average persons. Off campus activity is a gray area for teacher free speech. Teachers also need to be aware that their on campus speech is subject to state Data Practices Acts.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Student and teacher communication
Louisiana state law effective November 2009:
Schools required to document all electronic communication between teachers and students.
Extends to personal devices, not owned by the schools.
Failure to comply may constitute a “willful neglect of duty.”
Should teachers and students text and call each other on their personal cell phones? Should students and teachers be social networking “friends”? Are there risks associated with allowing these types of casual contacts? How and to what extent teachers should use these technologies to communicate with students is a matter of much debate.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Sexting
Logan v. Sycamore High School
Allegations: School did not stop the bullying,
taunting, harassment No formal letter sent by school
to teachers or members of school community
No counseling to help the student and no action to protect her privacy.
A newly coined term used to describe the practice among teens and young adults of sending sexually explicit photos to each other on their cell phones. Legislators are scrambling to get new laws in place to decriminalize the activity.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Disciplining students
T.V. and M.K. v. Smith-Green Community School
Class action seeking declaratory and injunctive relief and damages for students suspended from extra-curricular activities and forced into “unwarranted, mental health counseling” for summertime Facebook postings that were deemed to “reflect discredit” upon the school and which “created a disruptive influence on the good order, moral, or educational environment” of the school.
A number of cases have surfaced across the country in which parents are suing schools for inappropriately harsh discipline. Court rulings are mixed. Are students exercising free speech rights? Are there limits on the discipline schools may impose?What risks do schools run when they choose not to discipline?
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Additional discipline cases Miranda Jackson v. Pearl Public School Dist.
(cheerleader sues school and coach for violation of her rights of privacy and free speech when coach demands access to private Facebook page and shares content with others at school).
J.W. v. Desoto County School Dist. (parent sues school alleging illegal search and seizure and challenging expulsion from school of her middle grade son who read a text message in class in violation of school cell phone policy).
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Drafting/amending policy
Providing community guidelines
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Drafting/amending policy Collect data. Solicit input. Draft the new/revised policy. Circulate the draft of the new/revised
policy. Approve and disseminate the
new/revised policy.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Policy development: general guidelines Amend school policies to include
prohibitions against cyber-bullying Draft school policies re: cell phones,
cameras, recording devices, and other emerging technology.
Make policies age/grade appropriate. Revisit and revise policy frequently.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
School policy re: staff/teacher social media use
MINNETONKA SCHOOL DISTRICT Policy #470 Employee Use of
Social Media Networks
http://www.bb.minnetonka.k12.mn.us/bbcswebdav/xid-775415_1
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Strategies and solutions
Maximizing safety and minimizing risk
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Make compliance easy Purchase licensed products and
services for students and staff that reduce or eliminate the need to access non-licensed works.
Purchase products and services with adequate (age-appropriate) privacy protections.
Provide detailed guidance and parameters for staff members developing online course materials.Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Keep your fingers on the pulse
Educate, disclose, seek feedback: the more input and documentation you have from students, parents, and administration, the better.
Develop an awareness of how students and staff are using technology.
Role play with students about what to do if inappropriate or suggestive comments are posted by others; role play with staff about what to do if they detect inappropriate use of technology; educate older students, in particular, about the risks of too much self disclosure.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Address ethical behavior with students and staff Communicate and educate about
ethical Internet conduct. Help students understand the long
term effects of Internet speech. Offer students an opportunity to
provide constructive, confidential feedback.
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Available from Corwin Press at www.corwinpress.com
Aimée M. Bissonette, JDLittle Buffalo Law &
Consultingwww.littlebuffalolaw.com
[email protected] 612-243-5013
Little Buffalo Law & Consulting
Top Related