MOSSY FOOTplanning & outreach strategy
Every reasonable attempt has been made to identify owners of copyright.Errors or omissions will be corrected in subsequent editions.
No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in, used in any form in any means-graphic, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, taping or information storage and retrieval systems without permission of the author.
ALL IMAGES AND FIGURES NOT OTHERWISE CITED ARE PROPERTY OF GAVIN STUDER 2010.
Copyright © Gavin Studer, 2010
All rights reserved.
NewSchool of Architecture & Design
San Diego, California
Baccalaureate Program
Thesis 2009-2010
First Edition
MOSSY FOOTplanning & outreach strategyAn Undergraduate Thesis by Gavin Alfred Studer
A thesis presented to the faculty of NewSchool of Architecture & Design.
In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Architecture.
Gavin Alfred Studer
June Nineteenth, Two-Thousand and Ten
San Diego, California
Approved By:
Mitra Kannani, Arch. D, MCP., AIA
Undergraduate ChairJames Enos, M. Arch, MFA, Assoc. AIA
Thesis Studio InstructorRichard Guerena, M. Arch, AIA
Peer-Reviewer, Architectural AdvisorBruce Matthes, M. Arts
Creative Writing & Grammatical Advisor
&
“The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full.”1
“Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it.”2
To our Lord, for blessing me with a higher education in one of the most developed countries in the world, so that He may bless the less fortunate through me, using my radical knowledge and abounding life experience.
Those secretly suffering from podoconiosis in every affected corner of the world, and all recovering Mossy Foot Patients in Ethiopia.
To my parents, for their enormous support through school, in large part encouraging the amazing opportunities in front of me.
Every empowered person who has chosen to serve others selflessly. Every person who has chosen to think big for the good of the world. Every person refusing to settle for the path much traveled. To anyone who envisions a better life for themselves, their familes and those around them, acting on ideas, happy to fail and try again, knowing life is about learning.
All of my friends who have been stoked about my journey, encouraging me to dream bigger.
Windansea Beach in La Jolla, California for its beautiful water, waves, sands, and sunsets for providing the hugely needed breaks from studio. And every beach that I have ever sunk my bare feet into, its contours subdued by its grandiose master & conformer, the ocean. Into which, enlivened, I have dove.
DED
ICAT
ION
ACKN
OW
LED
GM
ENTS
1 Publishers, Z. B. (1978). John 10:10. Holy Bible: New International Version. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan.
2 Publishers, Z. B. (1978). Matthew 7:13-14. Holy Bible: New International Version. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan.
a vehicle for changeThis thesis project has been 14 months in the making. My interest with The Mossy Foot Project was initially sparked in the summer of 2007. It is now June of 2010 and my goal of creating a thesis presentation and publishable book has finally been reached. I can honestly say I have never been so committed to a single subject in my 23 short years of life. This multifaceted project has challenged me to hold client meetings, go a week straight with less than 5 hours of sleep a night, fundraise a trip half-way around the world (that’s 96 hours travel time, over 21,000 miles by foot, car, boeing 767, land rover and 3-seater bajaj taxi) and most amazingly traverse the dirt roads of rural Ethiopia. Lastly and more importantly this miniature endeavor into my passion for serving others has spurred a whole-hearted interest in international development furthering my aspiration of becoming a fully-independent humanitarian architect.
In 2009 I began developing a strategic planning initiative that improves economical sustainability and treatment outreach of the preventable elephantaisis know as podoconiosis or “Mossy Foot”. In order to address the unique as well as complex situation I have designed multiple buildings to be envisioned both within and around the rural areas of Soddo, Ethiopia. The major reasoning behind this project is to create a strategic plan that sets feasible goals for actual, physical change in such an infrastructurally deficient region.
With this thesis handbook I hope to provide insight into multiple issues both at a global scale and at a sociocultural, economic and local scale. Ironically, this disease is found in the volcanically rich soil of The Great Rift Valley, which is what also drives it’s agriculturally dependent towns and rural villages spread scattered across southern Ethiopia.
FORE
WO
RD
INTRODUCTION1.1 preface1.2 historic overview1.3 abstract1.4 problem overview1.5 thesis statement
PRE-DESIGN RESEARCH2.1 review of literature2.2 application
ARCHITECTURAL PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT
3.1 precedents3.2 contextual analysis3.3 site analysis
DESIGN DEVELOPMENT4.1 concept development4.2 programming4.3 building design
CONCLUSION5.1 learning statement5.2 self-reflection5.3 photo credits
TABL
E O
F CO
NTE
NTS 1
2
3
4
5
1INTRODUCTION
14 | Gavin Studer Introduction | 15
“Everybody wants the same thing, rich or poor,” says Samuel “Sambo“ Mockbee, founder of Rural Studio at Auburn University, “not only a warm, dry room, but a shelter for the soul.”1
The natural, elementary definition of shelter as a place that gives protection from inclement weather and danger has been broken from westernized architecture and its overinvolved affair with the privileged. “We have failed to show what we can do socially and economically” states architect Bryan Bell, founder of the non-profit known as Design Corps. 2
Shelter is needed in every corner of the world to prevent disease, provide housing, promote education and support community cohesion. Without shelter, orphans may become homeless, the sick may perish, education could be hindered, and the public may struggle to assemble. Architecture bears the weight of providing more than shelter. It intervenes strategically with highly-responsive designed spaces that address need and respond to disastrous situations. This significance found in addressing need must re-connect itself with high-design in order to intervene in the innumerable socioeconomic issues and conditions facing our developing world today. A new breed of architects and humanitarian designers is needed. People who seek assistance and the expansion of architecture (providing structures which encompass more than “shelter” from the wind and cold) via spaces designed by architects that realistically contribute to the well-being of family and community may result in functional and efficient buildings that also formfully excite the senses.
PREF
ACE
PERRY LAKES PARK PAVILION Rural Studio
Located along the Cahaba River and nearby Oxbow Lake, this plot of recreational park sat untouched for 30 years. This small
scale project provided much needed revitalization by acting as an outdoor classroom, gathering space and stage area. The park is known to flood on a regular basis, so a durable materiality was
needed. Locally sourced Cedar trees were used as the boards in the pavilion’s floor. The trees were also used as formwork for footings
and groundcover around the site, repelling mosquitoes. Sheets of aluminum wrap the roof creating an intriguing rising plane.
1.1
1.2
2 Weinstein, N. (2009, March 31). Bryan Bell asks Portland architects to become agents of change. Daily Journal of Commerce. Retrieved May 7, 2009, from http://www.djcoregon.com/articleDetail.htm/2009/03/31/Bryan-Bell-asks-local-architects-to-become-agents-of-change-North-Carolina-architect-suggests-a-desi
1 rural studio. (n.d.). College of Architecture, Design and Construction. Retrieved June 16, 2009, from http://www.cadc.auburn.edu/soa/rural-studio/mockbee.htm
shelter for the soul
1.1
16 | Gavin Studer Introduction | 17
northwest india
sri lankaethiopia
equatorial guinea
canery islands
cape verde islands
central america
south america
Podoconiosis is a non-communicable disease now found exclusively in the tropics. It is caused by the conjunction of environmental, genetic, and economic factors. Mossy Foot is predominantly found in Africa, especially in higher altitude areas of eastern and central Africa (Ethiopia, Congo, Rwanda, Cameroon, Burundi, and Tanzania).4
1.2
Mossy Foot was recognized in Ethiopia in the 1950’s by Dr. Nathan Barlow, a Christian Medical Missionary who devoted his life to helping the poor in Africa. In 1977 when the Communists took control of Ethiopia, he left – not returning until 1997. That year he began studying Mossy Foot, and in 1999 he started the Mossy Foot Project. In the southern province of Wolaita there are over 152,000 people afflicted with Mossy Foot disease. The Mossy Treatment and Prevention Association is a Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) founded by The Mossy Foot Project in Ethiopia, which currently leads the world in treatment and research of podoconiosis.5
a preventable disease that affect populations THE MOSSY FOOT PROJECT
5 Mossy Foot Project - Intro. (n.d.). Mossy Foot Project - Intro. Retrieved October 19, 2009, from http://www.mossyfoot.com
4 Davey, G. (2007). Podoconiosis: non-infectious geochemical elephantiasis. Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 101(12), 1175-1180.
HIS
TORI
C O
VERI
VEW
18 | Gavin Studer
1.3
Merkineh suffered from Mossy Foot syndrome for more than
5 years. At age 15, he began receiving treatment. Below
you can see how remarkable treatment can be after only 4
months.5
ABS
TRAC
T
This thesis seeks to shed light on deeper issues concerning local conflicts such as the collision of disease, poverty and its socioeconomic influence in urban and rural areas. The thesis approaches the problem pragmatically with tandem strategies; one addressing planning and the other outreach. The planning segment is based on two open-ended programmes: the first outlines foundational principals of international development at a regional scale, and the second magnifies local intervention by fostering grassroots architecture at a local level. The outreach segment manifests itself with three architectural mediations aimed at creating a holistic response for expediting disease prevention through increased patient treatment while also providing new vocations for re-integration into skilled labor for greater self-sufficiency. Lastly, an exposition of my site visit serves to strengthen the depth and breath of such a proposal while promoting awareness of harsh realities encapsulating podoconiosis in rural Ethiopia.
summary
1.3
1.4
Introduction | 19
20 | Gavin Studer Introduction | 21
podoconiosisMossy Foot disease is caused by volcanic soil and affects agrarian people working barefoot, especially in red clay soil at altitudes of over 1000 meters (3,280 feet). This soil contains microscopic particles of volcanic glass, or silica, which penetrate through the pores into the lymphatic system. As the lymphatics are obstructed, the feet and lower legs swell, open sores and ulcers develop, and keloids grow on the feet giving them a grotesque appearance. Commonly the feet become infected with fungi and bacteria.
hardshipDue to the general lack of knowledge concerning the disease, people are treated as lepers. Children have to drop out of school. Many are disowned by family members. No one wants to employ or marry someone who has this dreaded disease. Some even starve to death.
preventionAlthough prevention through the form of shoes is the most efficient way of ending podoconiosis, the acquisition and distribution of shoes has yet to, and may never be feasible in regions where economic limitations act as a barrier to shoe distribution, thereby perpetuating the disease.
treatmentEach patient receives a kit, including a bar of soap, bleach and antifungal ointment, with instructions from the clinic health care worker as to how to use the kit. The treatment is simple yet effective in reducing the swelling and improving the condition of the skin. In the case of edema of the legs, the legs are wrapped with elastic bandages which are worn during the day time. All patients are instructed to elevate their feet at night or when they are sitting.
volcanic soil entering pores of feet
omo river
lake abaya
red soil
4.9 3.0
4.36.9
6.46.1
0.8
1.0 1.0
2.5
Marketper cent elephantiasis
soddo
treatment includes zinc oxide & honey
washing with bleach, soap and water
1.4
PRO
BLEM
OVE
RVIE
W
This area of red clay in Wolaita Zone, Ethiopia is at an altitude of 1500m and on volcanic parent-rocks. A total market count of 43,573 adults was made in the market centers indicated. Of these 1,781 had elephantiasis of a leg (4.1%). Similar correlations have been made in other tropical areas of Africa.6
WOLAITA ZONE AETIOLOGYCorrelation of elephantiasis with local red clay
6 Price, E. W. (1991). 7. Podoconiosis: Non-filarial Elephantiasis (Oxford medical publications) (p. 51). New York: Oxford University Press, USA.
22 | Gavin Studer Introduction | 23
To formulate a strategic planning initiative engaging the geochemical disease known as podoconiosis through the implementation of a multitudinous development project in the form of a phased on-site headquarters construction project in Soddo, Ethiopia as well as multiple small-scale clinic interventions in rural areas surrounding Soddo.
critical positionThis thesis proposes a headquarters construction programme as well as intermodal outreach clinics that investigate health clinic interdependence and new rural outreach strategies through the arms of an existing humanitarian outreach organization. This framework will ultimately engage a translation of improved health care and well-being with an emphasis on bringing volunteer health workers to the field and generating economic activity through the return of field-workers to contemporaneous productive means.
proposalTITLE Mossy Foot: Planning & Outreach StrategyCOMMISSIONED BY The Mossy Foot Project USA FINANCIER Multiple Private US DonorsCOUNTRY Ethiopia LEAD ExECUTING AGENCY Local Contractor, Sub-Contractor & Builders in Wolaita Zone, SoddoOVERALL TERM 2007-2013
contentThe lack of modern means of access to acceptable health care and treatment facilities in Ethiopian towns and rural areas has resulted in increased disease and decreased life-quality. When looking through the lens of humanitarian outreach in such a complex region, the fact that there is virtually no infrastructure makes access to affected persons in rural areas an arduous task, slowing any attempts at treatment to literally a walking pace. Facilities management is basically non-existent, while the rest of the outreach area remains unreached. The need for trained health workers and
THREE LEVELS OF ARCHITECTURAL INTERVENTION
economically sustainable, accessible clinics is critical to addressing treatment in rural areas. Providing new solutions for intervention would be beneficial, which is further explained in the following objective. Woalita Zone alone needs as many as 75 additional clinics. Exacerbating the situation is the country’s annual population growth of 6-8 percent, (Citation) while the majority of currently affected persons are in serious need.
The Mossy Foot Protection and Treatment Association (MFPTA) has responded to this situation by proposing an international research headquarters to be the base of all operations, education, research, and production. It is the goal of this thesis to expand the service area of MFPTA through a planning and outreach strategy. The headquarters is the first of three new modes of outreach proposed in the proceeding chapters.
objectiveThis thesis proposes a series of strategies for implementation in the field in order to reduce the number of people affected by podoconiosis. Clinics in rural areas are to become affordable, efficient, and easily erectable, while awareness (reducing stigma etc.) is increased in villages still unreached by clinics with a mobile presentation package. The headquarters programme focuses on providing a central communication and service base to all health clinics and vocational sites in the outer lying region. The field clinic and mobile presentation operate using the current infrastructural constraints.
1.5
THES
IS S
TATE
MEN
T
24 | Gavin Studer Introduction | 25
approachMFPTA had treated patients many years earlier and establishment in 1999 led to the records keeping in a one room headquarters. MFPTA, garnering increasing support from The Mossy Foot Project, has created potential for rapid expansion in light of current patient application and treatment techniques. Currently, MFPTA occupies 4 buildings consisting of 10 rooms in Soddo, Ethiopia. They also are renting and staffing 10 clinics within the Wolaita Zone. It is the goal that once new planning strategies have been implemented and approved, 75 more clinics can be allocated within 10 years. Finally, using research gathered, a handbook can be created outlining how the same methodology for outreach and treatment can be used in other regions of Ethiopia, Africa as well as other blighted regions of the world.
An economically feasible planning and outreach strategy construction programme would proceed with the utilization of simple technology in the form of prefabricated components through inclusion of natural building elements (such as milled eucalyptus and corrugated iron). People wishing to support the inclusion of a health clinic on their property would be compensated; the disruption of the sites ecology would be very minimal. The construction processes carried out would be elementary enough for any man or woman who has built their own home in the surrounding region (which is the majority of Ethiopians) with the possible addition of more contemporary techniques & technologies.
CURRENT OUTREACH2010 - 20 clinics2015 - 25 clinics2020 - 30 clinics
PROPOSED OUTREACH2010 – 202015 – 452020 – 75+
Since job opportunities in these rural areas are meager, residents could also be compensated for the maintaining of the health clinic within their lands. Alternatively, in an area where locally integrated gospel and/or health workers would be present, their knowledge of the areas residents could be harnessed to responsible staff health clinics in order to secure them. By the end of 2020, with the reuse of deployable clinics, chances of eliminating podoconiosis in Wolaita Zone of is very promising.
Finally, the headquarters construction creates jobs for over 100 unemployed, mostly youth, while promoting small and medium-sized construction companies. Through the process of building the school, local craftsmen are able to train other local workers, eventually leading to improved standards of construction. This training of construction workers would become one of MFPTA’s new vocational programs, while possibilities for urban development facilitation lay in new construction techniques and building codes.
The Mossy Foot Treatment & Protection Agency team as of March, 2010
Loading the Landcruiser up with
shoes & treatment supplies
successDo these facilities & clinics remain? Do they change their use/function? Days with podoconiosis are numbered, all facilities and clinics provide an open layout when it comes to space allowing for basically anyone to come in and retrofit any building to their needs, even residential.
26 | Gavin Studer Introduction | 27
1
123
2
strategic outreach planThis plan shows the reach of MFPTA by the year 2015.
Field Clinics would be disassembled and reassembled
in new areas depending on need documented by
mobile units gathering information at unreached
villages.
neighborhood map showing headquarters
clinics & mobile units in sodo zuria
D a le
K u c h a
B
a a
ed
a
ka G
e
B a d a w a c h ole k oK /B ir a
H a d
soddo
lake abaya
hosaena
alaba kulito
negele
shashemene
hawassa
jimma
dilla
humbo
ofa
k/koysha
b/sore
d/gail
d/weyda
0 40km20
�eld clinicsexisting clinicsmobile units
30km
18km15km
gununo
areka
boditi + shanto
goyagasuba
2PRE-DESIGN RESEARCH
2.1
30 | Gavin Studer Pre-Design Research | 31
“The developed world with its leaps in science and technology, continues to live in severe contrast to the majority of the world’s population which suffers from poverty, illiteracy, injustice and social isolation.The key to providing freedom, education, and a longer, higher quality of life for poor, marginalized people is to genuinely include them in the process of development.” 1
health & poverty1 billion people live in poverty, which is every second child. The link between poverty and disease is inseparable and in many countries is are tied to issues that diminish and discourage any type of positive development. Poor people, who also tend to be malnourished, tend to become sicker, which leads to pre-mature mortality. Conversely, ill health is found to have a hand in causing poverty. Unfortunately, people who become ill are more likely to become impoverished and remain poor as opposed to healthier people because debilitating diseases prevent adults from being productive and having an income. Sadly, many children are unable to go to school if they have an illness, diminishing their future likelihood of productivity during adulthood. 2,3
The World Health Organizations Commission on Macroeconomics and Health (CMH) in 2000 examined links between health and poverty and found that those in poverty carry a more sizable burden of preventable deaths. The Report showed that the poor are less likely to have access to medical care, including emergency care. Serious illness can impoverish entire families for years while they lose crucial income and sell assets in order to meet the cost of treatment. This commission revealed the fact that current response systems for life-saving and preventative measures, as well as access to necessary medicines, do not reach the poor.
ethiopia, infrastructure &
agricultureIn addition to being one of the poorest countries in the world, Ethiopia suffers from the lack of infrastructure and from an disproportionate reliance on agriculture.
“In the highlands of Ethiopia there are two rainy seasons. This causes many roads to be unusable for weeks at a time since only 15 percent of roads are paved.” 4
Ethiopia’s lack of road infrastructure and transport service is said to affect access to emergency care service. Appropriate transportation services and regularly maintained roads are one of the largest challenges facing people’s ability to access health care services. It is easy to see how poverty and disease greatly hinder the economy and development of a country suffering from an entire slew of other challenges, such as debt and political instability.
Practically half of all of Ethiopia’s debilitated economy (GDP) comes from the agricultural sector which employs over three quarters of the employed labor force. It is increasingly apparent that areas such as these are in need of development. 5
“Africa is at a large disadvantage when dealing with sustainable development. It contends with globalization, unfavorable terms of trade, increasing debt, declining agricultural production with the seasons, political instability, and civil strife. African agricultural income has declined greatly due to these challenges plus the woes of desertification, a small market for agricultural goods, and minimal access to capital.“ 6
Although this weak agricultural sector is subject to periodic drought, and poor infrastructure constrains the production and marketing of Ethiopia’s products, Ethiopia still garners a vast agricultural potential found within it’s still enormous amounts of fertile land.
podoconiosisResulting from the conjunction of poverty and an
REVI
EW O
F LI
TERA
TURE
2.1
bicycle ambulance
medical stretches found in rural areas
typical unpaved roadin populated areas
2.2
2.3
1 Participatory Content Creation for Development: Principles and Practices. (2008). New Delhi, India: UNESCO House.
4 Culture of Ethiopia. Countries and Their Cultures. Retrieved January 23, 2010, from http://www.everyculture.com/Cr-Ga/Ethiopia.html2 Shah, A. (n.d.).
Poverty Facts and Stats and Global Issues. Global Issues : social, political, economic and environmental issues that affect us all Global Issues. Retrieved December 2, 2009, from http://www.globalissues.org/article/26/poverty-facts-and-stats
5 The World Factbook: Ethiopia. (n.d.). Central Intelligence Agency. Retrieved December 3, 2009, from https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/et.html
3 Macroeconomics and Health. (n.d.). World Health Organizations. Retrieved February 14, 2010, from www.who.int/macrohealth/en/
6 Busch, J. (2001). Socially Responsible Design: Act Globally. USA: VNU Business Publications.
32 | Gavin Studer Pre-Design Research | 33
agriculturally driven economy, and aggravated by lacking healthcare services along-side virtually nonexistent infrastructure, the preventable disease known as podoconiosis or “mossy foot” continues to exist. In the case of this thesis, a preventable, non-communicable disease stands in the way of economic generation, inducing extreme poverty and even lower life quality. The fine particles in the soil inhibit lymph flow of the lower extremities, causing extreme inflammation, debilitation, and inability to continue agricultural practices, labor etc. The reality is that these families are impoverished to the point of not owning a single pair of shoes, yet subsistence agriculture is the only income keeping their children from starving. Farming activities and walking barefoot through volcanic areas causes exposure, yet this cycle continues to the point that one million are affected or debilitated because the impoverished cannot afford shoes, but must work in order that their families survive another month. Poverty and disease in this situation are in direct relation. Shoes could easily stomp out this disease, but the circumstances surrounding rural areas of southern Ethiopia affected by podoconiosis are exceedingly complex. This means that as treatment, education, misconceptions, and infrastructure fluctuate,v so too will a designed response.
“The Mossy Foot Prevention and Treatment Association, a local non-governmental organization (NGO), has made surprisingly effective efforts in prevention, treatment, and rehabilitation in Wolaita Zone. This NGO reaches out to more than 30,000 patients per year in a sustainable community-based manner.” 7
In this unique case, where poverty and volcanic-silca rich soil collide – community-based treatment, training of locals, dissemination of information along with vocational training skills training, microcredit schemes and distribution of subsidized shoes (also made by treated patients) to the neediest is shining a light on a disease cloaked in misconception. Furthermore, expansions of these grassroots techniques may lead the way to the creation of an
expandable form of outreach, easily disseminated to the highly affected areas of the country and world in the form of a handbook. The Mossy Foot Project is a successful local NGO is paving the way for a road out of poverty for millions without shoes also in need of new job-skill training.
social awareness in architecture, design & developmentPhilanthropic architecture, socially responsible architecture and design activism are not new ideas. “Since the last 1940’s traditional and socially minded architecture has tended towards the form of a development project, a largely post-colonial phenomenon.“ the prevailing model in the development era usually features a ground of engineering and architecture professionals looking to deliver a project aimed at an underdeveloped target population. The majority of the development projects that took place during the fifty years, including the projects where architectural design was a principal component, were failures. 8
Design projects & proposals over the past decades have featured an overbearing 1st world mentality and top-down ignorance that is still continuing to force itself upon some of the oldest settlements in the world. Philanthropic architects, engineers and design students failed to see their designs as foreign and socially detached from the historically and culturally rich societies they were addressing.
Largely, architects have been closely involved in the processes that surround the role of “expert” on development projects both at home and abroad. Being wrapped up in a humanitarian social agenda and a professional designation in western society meant to serve the public interest. Though many architecture served in these development decades (still in transition to this day) following the establishment of the United Nations, slowly realized that being well-trained and well-intentioned were not enough to respond to such realistically complex situations - complexities only understood when investing real
woman and child awaiting treatment
kirinda rehabilitation housing by shigeru ban
7 Davey, G. (2007). Podoconiosis: non-infectious geochemical elephantiasis. Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 101(12), 1175-1180.
8 Smillie, I. (1991). Mastering the Machine: Poverty, Aid and Technology. London: Intermediate Technology Publications.
2.4
34 | Gavin Studer Pre-Design Research | 35
time in a place, seeing the need, experiencing the historically vibrant cultures.
These strategies took on the form of mobile health clinics or re-purposed containers in the form of shipping containers full of prefab health clinics and a mass-production of component houses shipped from across the world. Coming in with no knowledge, plopping down a masterplan and a couple shiny new buildings and then leaving. One building, a single master plan, could never provide the means for a community acceptance, fully integrating these projects in the deep cultures in which they reside, currently abandoned, or re-appropriated by indigenous for more lucrative means. Above all, these design proposals were void of any sense of tradition or cultural sensitivity. Furthermore, an expansive use of outsourced, overly technological materials, which were not found in local material flows increased the separation from actual acceptance because of the foreign nature of these structures, unable to be understood or repaired by local craftsmen. They failed to take into account the role that Non-Governmental organizations serve in culturally sensitive areas as local ambassadors of education, health care, new technologies. They fail to see how long-term effects of implementation take sensitive strategies in order to affect a far away and foreign region for the better.
Strategies and planning methodologies may evolve as actual fieldwork is done and connections are made in rural areas of any developing country. There is a huge responsibility attached to ensuring that community support is gained. The importance for a community to see, value and embrace the importance and incorporation of projects without overbearing western colonialist mentalities is the first priority to any humanitarian building or development project.The editor of Building Community: A Third World Case Book, Bertha Turner, states that “It is not our intention to suggest an alternative to capitalism nor to expunge Western intervention, but rather to explore creative applications of the design arts at the
INTERVOLVE Making Blocks From Earthhttp://www.inter-
volve.org/en
GTZ Cobblestone Roads for Ethiopia‘s
Cities and Citizenshttp://www.gtz.de/en/weltweit/
afrika/576.htm
service of development with a social conscience.” 9
grassroots initiative vs. “development projects”The importance of cultural connection, site specificity, local materiality and workforce engagement. Capitalism and globalization are the means, empowering locals is the end.
The founder of Architecture for Humanity, Cameron Sinclair, says that “when you speak to a community the number one thing that they want is not a house; it is a job. The big question to be solved is how to create employment and financial stability. Then people can think beyond just a roof over their heads and begin to plan for school and medical systems.”6
Egyptian architect Ismail Serageldin writes in “The Architecture of Empowerment,” that close collaboration with the community is the most effective way to provide shelter and infrastructure from concept design through to construction.”10
Henry Sanoff argues that a new pragmatic approach to participation has emerged in the last ten years that no longer views participation as ‘‘citizen power.’’ Participation, he suggests, has been defined more modestly to include information exchange, conflict resolution, and design and planning input. With this type of participation in mind, we describe a new model of participation that involves the local community in creating buildings that both embody aesthetic sensitivity and meet peoples’ needs. ”11
a military helicopter drops in building
supplies for a health clinic (inconceivable to their construction
technology)
10 Serageldin, I. (1997). The Arcitecture of Empowerment: People, Shelter and Liveable Cities. London: Academy Editions.
9 Jann, M., & Platt, S. (2009). Philanthropic Architecture. Journal of Architectural Education, 82-91.
11 Sanoff, H. (2000). Community Participation Methods in Design and Planning. New York: John Wiley.
2.5
2.6
2.7
36 | Gavin Studer Pre-Design Research | 37
GUIDELINES FOR A LOCAL PROGRAMME DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY
SustainabilityPlanning and its benefits lead to true sustainability: Contacting and becoming informed by a currently established NGO (who know the issues at play) in the region or area and proceeding to set long term goals is crucial. All while performing site assessment with continual NGO feedback. Local Engagement, Employment & EmpowermentPresenting in order to establish a connection with the community there needs to be culturally and economically sustainable support created through interaction and presentation. Promoting discussions and having conversations where community group members take on content creation responsibilities according to their capacities and interests lead to a community sense of ownership.
01
03
02
Participation & Socio-Economic ImplementationProducing through vocational training and construction projects. Involving community leaders into the creative design process and creating local interest and supporting local ownership. Possibly creating opportunities for new building codes to take shape and for policies to begin reform.
Adapted from (philanthropic architecture)
PRINCIPLES FOR A GRASSROOTS HUMANITARIAN ARCHITECTURE RESPONSENon-Governmental Organization & Western Designer, Architect InteractionThere may be a large gap between the design team and local client group, especially when needs, cultural context and expertise are in question. Grassroots projects should take steps to identify a responsible, designer-friendly middleman to foster an effective and collaborative environment. This may also bring up the composition and demarcation of roles between local representatives and the design team.
Successful Fundraising & Grant-WritingSuccessful fundraising and support will always determine how feasible & viable a project will become. The scope of the mission and the scale of the project need to match available resources. A source of donations, governmental relations and/or grant-writing skills will be needed.
01
02
2.2
APP
LIC
ATIO
N
Construction Knowledge & AdministrationKnowing the labor division i.e. contractors and subcontractors as well as creating a realistic connection via communication (possible need of translator). also, understanding and being understood so that builders and craftsmen are competent with the technicalities of construction.
Incorporating Indigenous ResourcesSince the clients involved in these kinds of projects typically represent the poorest segments of the world’s population, resources are undoubtedly limited, the ability to recognize the need to adapt to and respect local culture and customs is the crucial factor in success.
Adapted from (participatory content creation for development)
03
04
educating next generation humanitarian architects“Lastly, there are even greater advantages to the non-profit sector through opportunities with architecture students. Academic involvement in humanitarian architecture as an alternative practice model, teaming students up with clients abroad through a studio based curriculum. Not just building projects for the poor, but going beyond by realistically educating the next generation of humanitarian designers. A university practicum model program allow’s faculty to remain active in practice and provide early ‘‘in the field’’ hands-on experience for students while reaching out to the desperately poor, assisting and involving them in the design process that holds the potential to improve their lives.” 9
conclusionIn combining two community-based “grassroots” development techniques with a socio-economic component, this development project and its eventual design can be effective in its utilization of local community members, labor force and materials in order to provide realistic, sustainable (environmentally aware, economically conscious and socially engaging) and experiential architecture & design. To both Ethiopian people and those suffering from podoconiosis.
3ARCHITECTURAL PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT
40 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 41
PREC
EDEN
TS 3.1
3.1
3.2
3.3
TYIN Tegnestue
Safehaven Library and Bathroom
BASEhabitatDipshikha Electrical
Skill Improvement (DESI) Vocational
School
DEBEDO FRANCIS
KEREPrimary School for
Gando
Architectural Program Development | 43
A non-profit organization, TYIN tegnestue provides humanitarian design in the form of architecture. TYIN is made up of five architecture students from NTNU, their projects are financed by over 60 Norwegian companies, as well as private contributions.
Over the course of 2009, TYIN has been working in Thailand on planning and has constructed small scale projects. Their strategies seek to improve lives of the less fortunate. TYIN promotes exhaustive collaboration and shared learning and looks for an impact beyond the physical structures. The new bathhouse covers basic needs like toilets, personal hygiene and laundry. A simple structure was already built and became the framework for the project.
SAFEHAVEN library & bathhouse
architect TYIN Tegnestuelocation Ban Tha Song Yang, Thailand
project team Andreas Grøntvedt Gjertsen, Yashar Hanstad
client Safe Haven Orphanagebudget Library 29.000 (Approx. 3,500 USD)
Bathhouse 22.500 NOK (Approx. 3,300 USD)project year January 2009
42 | Gavin Studer
3.5
3.4
3.6
light filters through the facade, giving pleasant effects
44 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 45
3.7
3.8
3.9
3.10
front elevation of bathhouse
perspective view of library
floorplan of bathhouse
floorplan of library
46 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 47
Dipshikha Electrical Skill Improvement (DESI)
vocational school
architect BASEhabitatlocation Bangladesh, Dinajpur
project team Anna Heringer together with BASEhabitat and BRAC University Dhaka
client villagers of Dinajpurbudget DESI – Approx. USD 30,000
project year December, 2008
The project aims to improve living conditions while maintaining the current level of sustainability and to strengthen local identity. It achieves this by building model houses for peasant families and by training local craftsmen as well as young architects.
After a 4 month workshop (students from bangledesh and austria, NGO’s & locals) 5 strategies for sustainable development were instituted.
1. Most Bangladeshis live in one story, build two to save land. set free large amounts of land2. Use local materials to save energy3. Combine low-tech with high-tech4. Raise comfort5. Strengthen local identity: architecture is not just shelter. create a new style using traditional construction techniques
The Dipshikha Electrical Skill Improvement (DESI) development program comprises a new interpretation of a traditional Bangladeshi homestead. Usually in rural Bangladesh each of the varying household functions: eating, sleeping, and washing, etc. are performed in separate structures built around a central courtyard. The building design & layout attempts to incorporate all of the functions of working and living into a single structure. The design is geared toward a lifestyle that is no longer linked with agriculture, but still linked to the rural context and culture. “It is very difficult to find educated peoples who like to live in rural areas.“ (Paul Tigga, Executive director of Dipshikha) DESI is an experiment that looks into finding satisfactory solutions that act to enhance rural living while additionally expressing the next level of building development.
The biggest move in the development program is the uncommon step from low-income to middle class houses. The standard arrangement in Bangladesh shows an obvious shift from earth to fired brick in typical building materials. The DESI building is an exposition of the largest differences between the basic traditional dwelling and developed architecture, which lies in increased construction skills and craftsman involvement, on technical knowledge and originality & innovation. This process includes a balanced way of development that circumvents the obvious gaps typically created between poor and rich, old and modern. This push for enhanced craftsmanship, translates into support on local
3.11
3.12
3.13
cow hooves churn the mud and straw for walls
colorful facade and students
48 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 49
3.15
3.14
markets and also an investment & increase in cultural pride along with a strengthened sense of identity.
DESI is a rurally situated vocational school for electrical training. The DESI building program is comprised of two classrooms, two offices, and two residences for the school instructors. There is a separate bathroom with two showers and two toilets for the teachers and a bathroom facility with toilets and sinks on the ground floor for the students.
A simple solar panel system provides all of the building’s year-round energy needs, they also directly power a motor which pumps water from a well into the water tank. Solar thermal heating system provides warm water. In addition to on-site septic tanks, the toilets have their own two-chamber septic tank. This is the first time that sanitary units have been built into earth houses in Bangladesh, showing that mud and bamboo are easily able to accommodate contemporary lifestyle & living quality.
The building is an exemplary balance of high tech and low tech. Because the building is passively
heated and cooled as well as designed to optimize natural lighting and ventilation, extremely basic building methods are seamlessly met with modern, alternative energy systems.
PRIMARY SCHOOL FOR GANDOarchitect Debedo Francis Kere
location Gando, Bougou, Burkino Faso project team Wénéyda Kéré, Issa Moné, technical
officer, LOCOMATclient The community of Gando Village
budget CFA Francs 22,750,000 (US$ 29,830) project year 2000
The project aims to improve living conditions while maintaining the current level of sustainability and to strengthen local identity. It achieves this by building model houses for peasant families and by training local craftsmen as well as young architects.
After a 4 month workshop (students from Bangledesh and Austria, NGO’s & locals) 5 strategies for sustainable development were instituted.
Architectural Program Development | 5150 | Gavin Studer
3.16
3.17
52 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 53
3.18
3.19
transverse section
longitudinal section through classroom
interior classroom perspective showing indirect lighting
54 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 55
Highland boundaries
River systems
Sun path
Main roads
CON
TEXT
UA
L A
NA
LYSI
S
3.2
Popluation density
3.25
3.20
-25
56 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 57
Tigray
Amhara
Beni.Gumuz
Gabella
Addis Ababa
Oromiya
Somali
Dire DawaHarari
Afar
SNNP
aba
Somali
Addis Ababa
Oromiya
AfarAmhara
aba
Tigray
SNNP
s As A
Beni.Gumuz
GabellaETHIOPIA & REGIONSEthiopian political border & Southern Nations, Nationalities and People’s Region (SNNP)
58 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 59
Dizi
Sheko
Kuraz
Bena
Surma
Hamer
Meanit
Gazer
Selamgo
Decha
Gesha
BenchTelo
Dale
Chena
Kucha
Ela(Konta)
Gimbo
Goro
Melekoza
Zala
Gofa Zuria
Soro
Isara Tocha
Sodo
Kemba
Yeki
Gelila
Limu
Bonke
Awasa
Bensa
Gibe
Menjiwo
Hulla
Selti
A oresa
Misha
Duna
Gumer
Dita
Dalocha
Boricha
Mareko
Dara
Loma Bosa
Arba Minch Zuria
Bore
da
MashaAnderacha
Cheha
Lanf
ero
Kochere
Mar
eka
Gena
Bule
Enemorina Eaner
EzhanaWelene
M/A
baya
Badawacho
Aleta Wendo
Angacha
Che
ncha
ArbeGona
Meskana
Shebedino
Ubad/tsehay
Daramalo
Omo Sheleko
Shash
ogo
Yirgachefe
Wen
ago
K/Bira
Kokir Gedbano Gutazer
K/Gamela
G urage
S elti
S idama
Hadiya
K T
Alaba
Yem
Hadiya
Wolaita
Gamo Gofa Gedeo
Amaro
South Omo
Bench Maji
Sheka
Dawro
Basketo
Konso
BurjiDirashe
legendworeda boundary
zonal boundary
lake
regional boundary
site
SNNP REGION & WOREDASAdministrative Zone divisions are grouped into Woredas (Wore-Aid-Uh) & Kebeles (Kah-Bay-Lay) which are neighborhoods (shown in gray).
60 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 61
soddo
hosaena
alaba kulitonegele
shashemene
hawassa
jimma
dillahumbo
ofa
k/koysha
b/sore
d/gail
d/weyda
sodozuria
0 50 100mi
WOLAITA ZONE & KEBELESThe Wolaita Zone is located within a topographically diverse area of The Great Rift Valley. It is broken up into Kebeles or “neighborhoods.”
62 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 63
SODDO
soddo
hosaena
alaba kulitonegele
shashemene
hawassa
jimma
dillahumbo
ofa
k/koysha
b/sore
d/gail
d/weyda
sodozuria
SODO ZURIA KEBELEA Kebele of Wolaita Zone has the city of Soddo acting as its administrative hub. Soddo is among the few cities in the region with increased access to introductory infrastructure. Soddo has networked roads, hydro-electric power & cleaned pipe water supply, modern telephone, banking, educational and health facilities. The town lacks paved roads connecting it with its neighboring towns, fundamental to transportation access. There is a main highway that stretches from Addis to Jinka that passes through Soddo.
0 8mi4
64 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 65
tonacomplex
soddo hospital
currentheadquarters
markethotel
bus stop
wolaitasoddo university
mt. damota
SODDO
privateschool
publicschool
powerstation
BUILDING SITE
CONTEXT238 miles (383km) from Addis Ababa on paved roads.80 miles (130 km) west of the regional administrative capital of Awassa.Elevation: 5,000-6,500 feet (1,600 - 2,000 meters)
SCALEworeda population - 297,576City Population (urban dwellers): 22% or 65,737 of Total Population (greater than the zone average of 8.5%)
CLIMATEOctober to April - driest & hottest season (52-80 degrees)May through September is moderate, with temperatures near 70 degreesTwo rainy seasons occur: January to March & May to October.
INDUSTRYIndustries common to the area include coffee roasting & packaging, sugar factory, hides & meats processing.
AGRICULTUREThe local agricultural production of the Wolaita Zone consists of tobacco, cotton, fruits, ginger, pepper, sugar cane, animal farming, fattening & diary farming.
ROADSIn 2004 Sodo Zuria had 22 kilometers of asphalt roads, 104 kilometers of all-weather roads (gravel) and 48 kilometers of dry-weather (earth/volcanic track) roads, totaling 182kmm for an average road density of 380 kilometers per 1000 square kilometers.
In 2006 the Woreda Agriculture and Rural Development Office Announced that they had begun development projects that included the creation or maintenance of 105 meters of road in 34 kebeles of Sodo Zuria woreda. This will cost 2.5 million Birr.
SOD
DO
TO
WN
AGRI
CULT
URA
LLY
DRI
VEN
3.25
-30
.6mi1km
stayed at addis kadan guesthouse in addis ababa
made the trip south to soddo town, stopping in butajira for lunch
headed south for a day trip to a village for church, then to arba minch for the crocodile farm and lunch in the town
stopped by mossy foot headquarters to see shoemaking, then out to gununo clinic site
headed to two clinic sites and a hairdressers shop
visited kale hewot church compound as well as the nearby building site
spent the day exploring soddo with my friend kebede and met architect working on wolaita soddo univeristyattended church in the morning, walked around streets residential areas and learned how to ride a motorcycle
01day
02day
03day
04day
05day
06day
07day
08day
visi
t: ht
tp://
ww
w.m
ossy
foot
.com
/#/g
avin
-s-b
ookl
et/
300KM TO SODDOIn March of 2010 I was fortunate enough to visit my site located halfway around the world. The experience was incredibly eye-opening. During my stay in Soddo, Ethiopia it was a huge shock to see how limited building materials were, how simpleton construction techniques could be just as well called hodgepodge even on high-rises, with eucalyptus pole scaffolding you can forget railings! Any hopes for creating any kind of grandiose monumental architecture was quickly crushed under the weight of obvious poverty, and a virtually non-existent building sector lacking access to construction materials, equipment, skilled labor, vocational training opportunities etc.
SITE
AN
ALY
SIS
3.3
Architectural Program Development | 6766 | Gavin Studer
SITE ASSESSMENTstreet hierarchy & transportation in soddo town is vehicular circulation & pedestrian accessneighborhood morphologyspace relationships & urban precedentsphysical features
SOD
DO
IMAG
ERY
.6mi1km
tonacomplex
buildingsite
soddo hospital
currentheadquarters
markethotel
bus stop
wolaitasoddo university
mt. damota
SODDO
privateschool
publicschool
powerstation
Looking south across Soddo
town, with Lake Abaya to the left
Northern Soddo town with Mt. Damota in the
distance
Architectural Program Development | 6968 | Gavin Studer
tree lined street in village
small farms in countryside
countryside south of addis ababa gerry on road to arba minch
small village street scene
mud and straw ‘chica’ for making walls
REG
ION
AL
IMAG
ERY
village community square
a well in the front yard of a countryside home construction storage at soddo hospital
gazebo’s on the waterfront of lake abaya on the road to arba mich in gamo gofa zone
cobblestone’s for use at wolaita soddo university
making cobblestone for soddo christian hospital
Architectural Program Development | 7170 | Gavin Studer
http://www.dartmouth.edu/~hopoutreach/images/camera%20icon.1.jpg
02The walls are filled with closely placed upright poles which are in the ground. Rope is used to tie supports to the wall. Green wood is used because of its ease in bending. The roof supports are attached 1 foot form the top of the center pole and extend 2 feet past the top of the wall.
01A 9 to 20 foot in diameter circle is drawn on a flat site. Eucalyptus poles are placed in the ground at one yard intervals around the circumference. The perimeter wall should be 7- feet above ground. The center pole is set, giving a roof angle of 50 degrees or more.
03Additional supports are added to the roof structure. Also with green wood and tied with rope. The roofing material is Sumbalit, a straw grass. It is carefully thatched or tied from the top down. A pottery jar is set atop the center pole to help shed water from the roof’s center
04An adobe plaster made of straw and mud is placed on the walls. A door is built and placed along with two small holes to let in sunlight.
05With the exterior finished, the inside is ready to be built. Depending on the use, it could be used as a living quarters, kitchen, stable, or storage. The majority are used for all for and are partitioned.
GRASS HOUSE CONSTRUCTION AS FOUND IN THE HIGH PLATEAU REGIONS OF ETHIOPIATraditional straw huts, or “tukuls” are constructed of walls filled with closely placed upright poles or “wall posts” which are secured via being placed in the ground. Rope like wood is used to tie supports to the walls, greener wood is used because of its ability to easily bend. The roof supports are attached 1 foot from the top of the center “ridge” pole and extend 2 feet past the top of the wall.
TRA
DIT
ION
AL
CON
STRU
CTI
ON
Architectural Program Development | 7372 | Gavin Studer
3.31
government clinic painted mud school
rough hewn stone foundation upper-class rural residence
lower-class rural residencelower-class wall and opening
TRA
DIT
ION
AL
VERN
ACU
LAR
RURAL BUILDING Contemporary vernacular consists of rectangular shaped concrete masonry units (CMU) buildings with gable roofs made from wood eucalyptus poles. These roofs are lashed and cladded in corrugated sheet meta. Typical foundations are made of rough hewn stone and mortar.
Architectural Program Development | 7574 | Gavin Studer
well-established storefronts past generation office building
rentable government building
middle to higher-class residence typical wall and opening
scaffolding on modern wolaita soddo university
URBAN BUILDINGContemporary vernacular consists of rectangular shaped concrete masonry units (CMU) buildings with gable roofs made from wood eucalyptus poles. These roofs are lashed and cladded in corrugated sheet meta. Typical foundations are made of rough hewn stone and mortar.
LOCA
L VE
RNAC
ULA
R
Architectural Program Development | 7776 | Gavin Studer
corrugated sheet metal well-hewn stone wall and finished grout
eucalytus tree barkred volcanic soil
typical eucalyptus strip weave pattern (used for privacy, fencing, baskets & furniture)
well made concrete block & detailed grout work
TEXT
URE
S
CLOSE-UPThese were the most prominent textures found in and around the places I visited during my visit to the city and surrounding regions.
a eucalyptus wall & mud filling cementitious (mortar) wall coating
rudimentary concrete masonry units & mortar grout “chica” mud mixed with straw to cover timber walls
Architectural Program Development | 7978 | Gavin Studer
80 | Gavin Studer Architectural Program Development | 81
looking east across the site from the center
in front of the site, access road looking north from the center
looking south from the centercurrent footpath entrance (looking west)
SITE
PH
OTO
S
looking west from the site over soddo
Architectural Program Development | 8382 | Gavin Studer
4 4.1
DESIGN DEVELOPMENT
86 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 87
001this design proposed the use of recycled containers raised up one story on rammed earth pillars. the diagram on the left shows sunshades covering the entrance balcony, the diagram on the right shows the operable path and coverage of the shades.
002the first of the deployable clinics, these we’re inspired by wes jones primitive huts, they utilize 4-point rammed earth tire foundations and various passive systems such as rainwater collection.
003these clinic towers were an exploration into decreasing footprint, in order to avoid large slopes. there were found to be unacceptable because of the debilitating disease & patients struggling to climb stairs.
004 more prefabricated in nature, a separate structure evolved in this design, allowing for a more customizable approach to programming spaces. this variation includes a clinic and a classroom.
005the schematic elevation leading up to my final field clinic design
4.1
CON
CEPT
DEV
ELO
PMEN
T00
100
200
300
4
005
88 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 89
orm
EARTH BENCH WAYSTATIONThis concept was originally envisioned as a shuttle station where patients could be picked up on a regular basis. They would then be transported to the nearest clinic and/or headquarters for treatment and rehabilitation. The design features simple construction techniques, with a kit of parts assembly able to be transported to the site with nothing more than a trailer full of supplies. This model was not used because picking up each individual with mossy foot in a large region would prove to be extremely inefficient both with energy use and travel time.
rainwater collection
wood or steel structure
catchment + retention basin
water + shoe storage
CON
CEPT
DEV
ELO
PMEN
T
easily transportable (atv/truck) simple assemble & disassemble (nails/lashing)
front elevation
90 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 91
POP-UP CLINICThis clinic experimented with rammed earth in the field. The concept was to separate spaces via earth walls with simple shade canopies providing shelter during treatment. This coupled with a cylindrical center earth component with multiple uses including storage and rainwater cistern. This model proved to be inappropriate because of the skill and time it takes to created rammed earth.
corrugated iron component
rammed earth cylindrical core+ secure medical storage+ possible rainwater cistern+ batteries+ clean water
tensioned rope securing shade canopyplan
elevation
materials + framework
transported via flatbed truck, components
fabricated on site
92 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 93
01WORKSHOP
02OFFICES
03DORMS
04CLASSROOMS
06CHAPEL
05GUESTHOUSE
500+ sq. ft.
1,000+ sq. ft.
1,500+ sq. ft.
2,000+ sq. ft.
2,500+ sq. ft.
total building area: 10,200 square feet
PRO
GRA
MM
ING
4.2
NEEDS BASED PROGRAMThis program has been derived from multiple one-on-one client meeting’s with The Mossy Foot Project. Their straightforward needs are a result of 10 years of testing, treatment, and integrating new job-placement programs. The spatial context explored was completely realized when I was able to visit the current headquarters operations and create relationships with actual employees working for The Mossy Foot Treatment & Prevention Association. Secondly, I was able to see, taste, hear and feel the joy and sadness of Mossy Foot patients after many rural clinic visits, which informed me of current conditions. These circumstances became the causation for my current views on incorporating vernacular design, and creating healing & communal spaces. Additionally, experiencing the building landscape of Ethiopia helped shaped a new interpretation of their traditional & local vernacular as well as the social interworkings of their informal gathering spaces.
94 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 95
SKET
CHIN
G
001the sketches shows the old, orthanginal plan beginning to morph to newly sought after site boundaries, it seeks to privatize dormitories on the bottom right, adjacent to the garden.
002this layout begins to explore the combination of two vernaculars building types found in ethiopia, contemporary rectangular buildings and traditional round huts.
003this plan solidifies program adjacencies (see the dorms take place in three offset regtangles) the lower half of the drawing presents itself as a large gathering place with decking, shading, chapel and spillover room.
004one of the last sketches before taking the design into 3D modeling, showing decking and trees as an integral part of the layout.
96 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 97
a multi-faceted operations hubTYPE 01 HEADQUARTERS
BUIL
DIN
G D
ESIG
N
4.3
98 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 99
Self-Creation & Production01. Using on-site eucalyptus trees, which grow back in a matter of months.02. Compressed Earth Block (CEB) making facilities03. Local re-sale of CEB
Job-Creation (Vocational)ShoemakingMechanicalCarpentryHairdressing/BarberEarth Construction
SUMMARYThis scheme features a design response to place, people and their development. It’s strength’s are found in re-creation and innovation using of local materials, simple (yet easily implementable) construction methods, relatable in both plan and elevation. The masterplan is also unique and intriguing in it’s take on Ethiopian vernacular.
HEA
DQ
UA
RTER
S O
VERV
IEW
The plan considers the site and it’s ephemeral as well as physical qualities, promoting a linearity and expansive roof plan that provides shelter from the driving rains which occur 3/4’s of the year. The playing field and teaching courtyard was included because of the prevalence of large assembly in Ethiopian culture as well as the nature of any open space becoming a soccer field.
The program was composed under an umbrella of vocation-based programs that exist to promote self-sustainability both in building creation and user life-quality through skills application and subsequential job-creation.
FORMThe design takes into account a plan for the future of the neighborhood known as Otona. Providing a prominent form that stands atop a cliff, seen from the city below. It promotes a reinforced
community through architectural integrity. Finally, an improvement in economic-generation on a local scale. The largest design consideration takes advantage of the large view overlooking the city of Soddo to the west.
CONSTRUCTIONThe building is made completely of local materials, using typical regional construction techniques. The use of natural materials and construction techniques makes this scheme extremely cost effective.
100 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 101
1
3
45
6
9
2
SITE
PLA
N
MOSSY FOOT HEADQUARTERS, SODDOLEGEND
1 ENTRY ROAD2 WORKSHOP3 SHOEMAKING4 CLASSROOMS5 DORMITORIES6 GUESTHOUSE7 CHAPEL8 OFFICES9 PLAYING FIELD
100 FT50250
7
8
102 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 103
01
02
03
FIVE
YEA
R PH
ASI
NG
PLA
N YEAR 2010-2015COST ESTIMATE [$220,000 - $280,000]
PHASE ONE YEAR 0-1 [$30,000 - $40,000]Volcanic rock road + Drainage planWorkshop [1,000 sq. ft.]
- A road will provide the means for access to the entire site for expediated construction.- The workshop will house tools, vehicles, and various repair/building based vocations.
PHASE TWO YEAR 1-2 [$80,000 - $100,000]Shoemaking [1,500 sq. ft.]Administration + storage [1,000 + 500 sq. ft.]
- The shoemaking building facilitates the prevention part of the outreach program.- The administration building will allow desk space for up to 9 full or part-time employees.
PHASE THREE YEAR 2-3 [$30,000 - $40,000]Dormitories [500 sq. ft. (150) each]Vocational classrooms [1,000 sq. ft.]
- Dormitories will act as housing for up to 8 patients.- Classrooms provide shelter from rain & sun while providing indoor-outdoor spillover space for teaching.
104 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 105
PHASE FOUR YEAR 3-4 [$40,000 - $50,000]Guesthouse [4,000 sq. ft.]Chapel [700 sq. ft.]
- The guesthouse will be lodging for up to 40 short-term & long-term researchers and volunteers.- Chapel for Christian worship seats up to 50 people.
PHASE FIVE YEAR 4-5 [$40,000 - $50,000]Garden [6,500 sq. ft.]Playing field [12,000 sq. ft.]Chapel plaza [2,000 sq. ft.]Teaching courtyard 1,200 sq. ft. Decking & optional security wall
- Garden will provide food & jobs for volunteers & guests.- Playing field open to local children for soccer & various games.- Teaching courtyard oriented towards classroom spillover shoe giveaway.
Rammed earth or rough-hewn stone wall + woven rebar
04
05
06
106 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 107
GRO
UN
D P
LAN
SHO
EMA
KIN
G P
ROCE
SS
�nishing application of sole and heel
04
lastingmolding leather to shape of foot using theappropriate last
03
closingsewing the upper
02
cutting leather upper is made using metal strip knives
01
tools
(left to right)awlfullerstamprounding hammerpairing knife
raw materials drop
shoe giveaway
storage
storage
workstations
workstations
sewing
1
2
3
4
108 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 109
LON
GIT
UD
INA
L SE
CTI
ON
110 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 111
SOLAR PANELSRAINWATER HARVESTING
COLLECTIONFILTRATIONGREYWATER CISTERN
NATURAL VENTILATION
BUIL
DIN
G S
YSTE
MS
Utilities & ServicesWATER SUPPLY - Rainfall collection into cistern & well. (Connection to city water, with storage tower on site)
ELECTRICAL GENERATION - Solar Power generation & back-up diesel generator
WASTEWATER TREATMENT - A Two-chamber septic tank system and on-site composting toilets.
TRASH INCINERATIONHidden & protected by earth berm
112 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 113
04 STONE & MORTAR[footing + foundation]rough hewn stone footing made by hand.
05 PLANKS [decking]milled eucalyptus
06 VEGETATION[existing plants + relocated trees]naturally occuring plants such as coffee, eucalyptus and other trees
07 BOUNDARIES[driveway + playing field + garden]cobblestone drivewaysmall garden for growing edibles used tires to frame playing field, for use as benches.
EXPL
OD
ED A
XON
01 SHELTER [roofing + structure]corrugated sheet metal, canvas shade canopy, eucalyptus poles & milled eucalyptus trusses.
02 EARTH [structure]compressed earth block made from nearby quarry.
03 TIMBER [partition + walls + doors] harvested locally & on-site.
114 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 115
00soil testing & test mould
03600 compressed stabalizedearth bricks (CSEB) per day
02pour earth into civa-ram manual press
01properly mix earth, sand and cement
earth blocktoolsshovelwheel barrowmanual (civa-ram) or hydraulic presssoil preparation equipment
02gather natural materials
01utilize local material source
04corrugated metal & thachedbuilding components
03construct woven thatch wall
roo�ng &wallshammer & nails
COMPRESSED EARTH BLOCK
CON
STRU
CTI
ON
TEC
HN
IQU
ES
EUCALYPTUS & SPLIT CEDAR
116 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 117
Perspective axonometric detailed
wall module
wire mesh
compressed block
mortarchica (mud + straw)
WA
LL S
ECTI
ON
/DET
AIL
laying of reinforced clay bricks at FAREstudio’s
Women’s Center in Burkina Faso
COMPRESSED EARTH BLOCKThe choice of CEB is based on its use of existing resources natural dirt found on site, providing a completely sustainable building system. It is more aesthetically pleasing than CMU block as well as cost and energy efficient, fire and pest resistant, virtually soundproof, durable and structurally sound. Finally, it accessibility and simplicity is empowering to the people of the community
rough hewn stone foundation
concrete floor slab
moisture weep
mortar4.
1
118 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 119
REN
DER
ING
S
120 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 121
122 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 123
124 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 125
126 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 127
128 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 129
PHYS
ICA
L M
OD
EL
North elevation
130 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 131
shoemaking facade
132 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 133
Overlooking dorms, shoemaking building, and workshop in the distance
134 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 135
Chapel Facade & Overlook Patio
136 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 137
Dormitories
138 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 139
a rapidly deployable and highly efficient treatment centerTYPE 02 FIELD CLINIC
140 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 141
FIEL
D C
LIN
IC
Ideal for expediting treatment in areas
where walking long distances is
common
OVERVIEWThe implementation of field clinics in and around small towns and villages would be ideal for treating small populations quickly and effectively. The structure, made entirely of locally harvested materials is versatile in a diverse range of terrain so it can be located on or near typically and/or impassable infrastructure. Depending on the severity of the surrounding lands volcanic makeup and the number of affected located within a certain walking distance, the clinic will be located up to 250 miles away from the headquarters.
4.2
142 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 143
FRONT ELEVATION
FINANCINGProposed co-dependancy contract between local land owners and MFPTA:01. rural landowner provides piece of land and security watch of building.02. MFPTA provides maitenance, set-up & removal.
COST25 pieces of corrugated sheet metal ($100)34 eucalyptus (2 inch dia.) poles ($0)10 used tires ($25)8 bags of cement ($25)5 recycled axles from locally fabricated gerry’s ($25)total estimated cost: $175 - $200
SIDE ELEVATION
144 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 145
corrugated sheet metal roof
eucalyptus branch walls
eucalyptus pole structure
prefabricated wooden sectional
floorplates
recycled metal axels set in re-claimed
rammed earth tire footings
RAPID DEPLOYMENT & ASSEMBLYOutfitted Toyota Landcruiser
CONSTRUCTION [8-24 hours]- Off-road Vehicle (x2)- Supply Trailer (x2)- 6-10 people with construction experience- Standard construction tools (hammer, nails etc.)
MATERIALSCement & earth mix, tires, recycled steel axles, eucalyptus branches, prefabricated triangle floor units, and corrugated sheet metal
OPTIONALRamping entrance, types of cladding (natural weave, corrugated etc.), rainwater collection, solar panels
FIEL
D C
LIN
IC
146 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 147
easily transportable and deployableTYPE 03 MOBILE UNIT
148 | Gavin Studer Design Development | 149
OVERVIEWLocated in disconnected & small villages anywhere from 5 to 20 miles intervals from headquarters or clinic. Raising awareness and giving hope to the unreached & ostracized in rural areas through community awareness seminars & gatherings of local officials
Standard Water Canister
Simple Fabrication
MO
BILE
PRE
SEN
TATI
ON
UN
IT
01
02
03
04
CONTENTS
Battery Powered Projector
Laptop Computer
Treatment Information
Organizational Folders
4.3
5 5.1
CONCLUSION
152 | Gavin Studer Conclusion | 153
final presentationjurors right to left
(james enos, jorge orzono and avery
caldwell)
semi-final trial presentation
second quarter presentation
Choose something you are passionate about or are particularly interested in.
Challenge yourself through a whole-hearted endeavor of distillation and interpretation of the big issues surrounding your topic.
Have a wicked awesome time committing yourself to a year’s production of writing, diagramming, and layout design (and quite possibly travel!)
01THESIS RECIPE
02
03
what the heck did I learn, how did my presentation go?This thesis asked me to truthfully consider my
life passion, which is serving others and further
pushing me to investigate all the twist and turns
related to podoconiosis in Ethiopia. My indifference
at becoming more associated with academia
was quickly sobered by the type of work that
was expected when adhereing to the American
Physchological Associations (APA) standards when
publishing a piece of writing. Research in this case
must include real content and concern. I had to
access and search libraries at University of California
San Diego, reading profound writing. Through
tracking down, reading, and finally regurgitating
an original comprehension of a dry peer-reviewed
articles on disease, poverty, architecture, and design
I was on my way. My metholodology stems from a
budding interpretation of contemporary approaches
to community development and I wanted my
creation of principles and guidelines concerning
development to be left open to intake and reflection
by the reader. More importantly I wanted to create a
personal journey and reflection within the pages of a
formalized (sometimes un-resolved) thesis syllabi in
order to associate knowledge of place as important,
if not more important than traditional research. It has
been proven that someone who has had no previous
experience with a place can enormously benefit from
seeing a place first hand. This process and journey
has laid the groundwork for many idea, designs,
presentations, written pieces, and books to come.
5.1
LEA
RNIN
G S
TATE
MEN
T
My process was founded in my persoanl journey,
my project challenged me to commit myself to new
ways of thinking, deciding, and interacting. It is now
responsibility to repeat this in the years to come,
sanguinely spreading truth through the current
mélange that is architecture.
5.1
5.2
5.3
154 | Gavin Studer Conclusion | 155
“How great you are, O Sovereign LORD! There is no one like you, and there is no God but you, as we have heard
with our own ears. And who is like your people Israel—the one nation on earth that God went out to redeem as
a people for himself, and to make a name for himself, and to perform great and awesome wonders by driving
out nations and their gods from before your people, whom you redeemed from Egypt? [a] You have established
your people Israel as your very own forever, and you, O LORD, have become their God.
“And now, LORD God, keep forever the promise you have made concerning your servant and his house. Do as
you promised, so that your name will be great forever. Then men will say, ‘The LORD Almighty is God over Israel!’
And the house of your servant David will be established before you.
“O LORD Almighty, God of Israel, you have revealed this to your servant, saying, ‘I will build a house for you.’
So your servant has found courage to offer you this prayer. O Sovereign LORD, you are God! Your words are
trustworthy, and you have promised these good things to your servant. Now be pleased to bless the house of
your servant, that it may continue forever in your sight; for you, O Sovereign LORD, have spoken, and with your
blessing the house of your servant will be blessed forever.”1
practicality is the philosophyBecoming an inspirtation to my classmates has been one of the greatest rewards of my journey through thesis.
Knowing what passions have been presented to me and acting on them has been the biggest lesson. I remember
the very first advanced communications class with Bruce Matthes and now it has translated itself into a full-
fledged thesis year, I am happy to have been focused on a single topic from the beginning. Announcing my plans
to travel to Ethiopia for a site visit to my friends and family brought wide eyes and dropped jaws. The fact that I
was actually working to realize my thesis project in an actual foundation on a plot of land in southern Ethiopia
was quite the aspiration to be sharing with those around me. I have always challenged fellow classmates and
friends to follow their passions, to travel to the places they want to see, to makes steps towards a more fullfilling
participation with whatever vision they have for their own lives.
Creating a strategy that pulled from organizations already at work in the complex field of humanitarian
intervention in all corners of the world and collecting their experience into my own holistic vision may hopefully
lead to a more flexible and applicable thesis that can be used to address a myriad different world issues, situations,
circumstances on both a regional and local scale.
Being open to new ideas, possibilities of greater involvement in The Mossy Foot Project and self-direction of
my thesis project has lead to an initially unimaginable assimilation of the podoconiosis endemic in southern
Ethiopia as well as its socioeconomic underpinnings. The grasp I now have of conceptual problem solving with
architectural solutions in developing areas has opened countless new doors into my future. Really, anything is
possible. And for that I will be forever thankful to those who supported my ideas and vision.
If I can summate my entire year in a sentence I would have to say that allowing God to be the center of my life,
bouncing thoughts and emotions off of the Holy Spirit and taking steps towards those opportunities set in front
of me has been 10% of the challenge, while 90% of all of the decisions I have made came to fruition because my
Sovereign Lord willed them into existence.
David’s Prayer Then King David went in and sat before the LORD, and he said:
“Who am I, O Sovereign LORD, and what is my family, that you have brought me this far? And as if this were
not enough in your sight, O Sovereign LORD, you have also spoken about the future of the house of your servant.
Is this your usual way of dealing with man, O Sovereign LORD?
“What more can David say to you? For you know your servant, O Sovereign LORD. For the sake of your word and
according to your will, you have done this great thing and made it known to your servant.
5.2
SELF
-REF
LEC
TIO
N
1 Publishers, Z. B. (1978). 2 Samuel 7:18-29. Holy Bible: New International Version. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan.
5.4
156 | Gavin Studer Conclusion | 157
Standing proudly in front of the new MFP Landcruiser, March 2010(Jim, Sharon, Me and Dawit our driver)
Gavin Alfred Studer(480) 818-META (6382)[email protected]
158 | Gavin Studer Conclusion | 159
figure 2.5 - Unknown. http://4ofseven.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/Africa_transport.jpg. 13 June. 2010.
figure 2.6 - Intervolve articlefigure 2.7 - GTZ brochure
SECTION THREE
figure 3.1figure 3.2figure 3.3figure 3.4figure 3.5figure 3.6figure 3.7figure 3.8figure 3.9figure 3.10figure 3.11figure 3.12figure 3.13figure 3.14figure 3.15figure 3.16figure 3.17figure 3.18figure 3.19figure 3.20figure 3.21figure 3.22figure 3.23figure 3.24figure 3.25
5.3
PHO
TO C
RED
ITS
SECTION ONE
figure 1.1 - Unknown. Pavilion 01. N.d. Blog, Perry Lakes Park, Alabama. Rural Studio. http://www.cadc.auburn.edu/soa/blog/wp-content/upload/images/special-programs/rural-studio/project-images/perry-county-lakes/pavilion/pavilion01.jpg. 30 Nov. 2009.
figure 1.2 - Unknown. Pavilion B. N.d. Images from Andrew, Perry Lakes Park, Alabama. Rural Studio. http://www.cadc.auburn.edu/soa/rural-studio/images_from_andrew/pavilionB.gif. 10 Dec. 2009.
SECTION TWO
figure 2.1 - Unknown. Rural Farms. N.d. Blog, Gamo Gofa Province, Ethiopia. eMap International Building Your Geospatial World. http://emap-int.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/rural_farms_gamo_gofa_province_ethiopia_qb.jpg. 16 Dec. 2009.
figure 2.2 - Unknown. http://lh5.ggpht.com/_567vrqhijt8/SV1cSHB_sbl/AAAAAAAAAUw/znM8DP48_34/Stretcher.jpg. 10 Nov. 2009.
figure 2.3 - http://zyozy.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/ambulance-bike.jpgAccessed: nov 10, 2009
figure 2.4 - http://www.yapi.com.tr/V_images/2009/haber_dosyalari/shigeru_ban/kirinda_01.jpg. 3 Aug. 2009.
figure 3.26figure 3.27figure 3.28figure 3.29figure 3.30figure 3.31 - Shelter (book) Shelter Publications P.O. Box 279, Bolinas, California 94924 isbn 0-394-70991-8 (pg.8)Published 1973
SECTION FOUR
figure 4.1figure 4.2figure 4.3 - Unknown. Water N.d. Images, Dera, Ethiopia. Hope Arising. http://www.hopearising.org/images/water.jpg. 16 June. 2010
SECTION FIVE
figure 5.1 - Scott Young. May. 2010.figure 5.2 - Rich Guerena. 24 June. 2010.figure 5.3 - Lacey Hedegard. Dec. 2009.figure 5.4 - Lacey Hedegard. May 2010.
Top Related