8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
1/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
Aaron Beppu Tom Griffiths
Department of PsychologyUniversity of California Berkeley
Cognitive Science, 2009
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
2/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Outline
1 The Cultural Ratchet
2 Iterated Learing and variations
3 Results
4 What does this mean?
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
3/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
What is the Cultural Ratchet?
The process of cumulative cultural evolution requires
not only creative invention but also . . . faithful social
transmission that can work as a ratchet to prevent
slippage backward so that the newly invented artifactor practice preserves its new and improved form at
least somewhat faithfully until a further modification or
improvement comes along.
Michael Tomasello, The Cultural Origins of Human Cognitionwe do this
other animals dont
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
4/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
What are some existing explanations?
We can try to explain this by focusing on individual teachers
and learners :
Were sophisticated learners (e.g. Tomasello 2001)
We learn strategies and goals from each otherWe can follow each others attentionWe can faithfully reproduce behaviors we learn from others
Were also good teachers (e.g. Gergeley & Csibra 2005)
We understand which things are hard to learnTeachers call learners attention to the most relevant partsHuman learners benefit from an enriched learningenvironment
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
5/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning
Modeling Cultural Evolution
hypothesis
data data data
hypothesis
...Learners are ordered into a sequence, and each agent learns
from the output of the previous agent
Can be used to study change in culture, (e.g. evolution oflanguage Kirby 2001), or to examine peoples biases (e.g.
Griffiths, Christian & Kalish, 2006)
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
Th C l l R h
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
6/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning
Analyzing Iterated Learning
Specifics:
Agents are Bayesian, and all have the same prior. Bayes Rule :
p(h|d) = p(h)p(d|h)h p(h
)p(d|h)
The data that a given agent passes on is sample according to
his posterior beliefs. p(di|di1) =
h
p(di|h)p(h|di1)
The pure iterated learning model converges to the prior beliefs
of its agents.
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
Th C lt l R t h t
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
7/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning
Cumulative Cultural Evolution
Cumulative cultural evolution will require constantly bringing in
new data from the world, in addition to some information
passed from one generation to the next. We vary what kind of
information is passed between agents.
...hypothesishypothesis
??? ??? ???
new data new data
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
8/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning
Observational Learning
...data datahypothesishypothesis
data...
new data new data
In the Mixed Data case, each agent receives new data from
the world, as well as data points sampled from the posterior
distribution of the previous agent. This is similar to
observational learning, achieved by observing the behavior of
another.
In this case, convergence is to
d p(h|d)p(d).
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
9/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning
Communicating Theories
...theory theoryhypothesishypothesis
theory
new data new data
In the Posterior Passing case, each agent receives new data
from the world. In addition, rather than receiving samples from
the previous persons posterior distribution, each agent nowreceives the whole posterior distribution. Communicating
theories might approximate how humans teach/learn.
This chain converges to the truth.
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
10/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Iterated Learning
Function learning is hard
Why function learning?
Strong bias towards positive linear functions; non-monotonic
functions are hard (Busemeyer, Byun, DeLosh & McDaniel,
1997)
The pure iterated learning case converges to a linear function
(Kalish, Griffiths, Lewandowsky, 2007)
We can select a function that is too difficult for a single person
to learn on their own, but which could plausibly be learned via
cumulative cultural evolution.
By using a difficult to learn parabola, we can separate out
groups of people converging to the posterior from people
converging to the prior.
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
11/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Apparatus
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
12/16
The Cultural Ratchet
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Examples from our results
Training Testing
Pure iterated learning
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
13/16
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Training Testing
Mixed data
Pure iterated learning
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
14/16
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
Training Testing
Posterior passing
Mixed data
Pure iterated learning
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
15/16
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
0 2 4 6 80
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Generation
RMSE
0 2 4 6 80
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Generation
RMSE
pure iterated learning
mixed data
posterior passing
Left : Cumulative average error (RMSE) for each chain for each
generation. Right : Same as left, but averaged by condition.
Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
The Cultural Ratchet
http://find/8/6/2019 iterated learning and the cultural ratchet - CogSci 2009
16/16
Iterated Learing and variations
Results
What does this mean?
What do we walk away with?
Merely observing behavior of those around us isnt enough to
have cumulative cultural evolution
We need to communicate theories and beliefs about the world.
Language is one way we can do this.
This gives us an idea about the uniquely human characteristics
that facilitate cultural evolution.
What next?
Can we adequately recover the posterior distributions from ourteachers merely from observing their actions?
What can we do with richer teacher/learner interactions?
How can we reconcile this inference based perspective with
other pressures on cultural evolution?Aaron Beppu, Tom Griffiths Iterated Learning and the Cultural Ratchet
http://find/Top Related