MC3 Libraries
Finding GoodWebsites
with Google
MC3 Libraries
First, let’s conduct an experiment
Say, you’re doing research on Martin Luther King Jr.
Will Google help you find good information? Let’s find out!
Found at http://seattletimes.com/special/mlk/
MC3 Libraries
Searching for a Martin Luther King Jr. biography
You type in “martin luther king” thinking you’ll be able to find tons of information on him
Lets look at the results…
MC3 Libraries
Results for “martin luther king”
The first hit, Wikipedia, is okay but it’s not a good source to cite in a paper.
The second hit on Nobel prize winners might be good, but it may not have enough info.
Wait… the third link looks really good…
MC3 Libraries
This is a .org site and even has his name in the web address.
Seems perfect… right?
martinlutherking.org
MC3 Libraries
Once you look at the page, several items suddenly look suspicious and you realize the site provides blatantly false information.
Who made this site and how did it show up in our search?!?
Wrong!
MC3 Libraries
Who is behind the site?
Sometimes it is not easy to know.
Look for an “About Us” or similar link on the page.
If that does not provide enough information, try a “WhoIs” search.
Go to networksolutions.com/whois and type in the web address.
MC3 Libraries
Who is behind the site? Scroll through the
information, you will see the site is owned by Don Black, a member of an organization named Stormfront.
Google both and you will find that this site was created by white supremacists!
How does Google allow such an inaccurate site to show up so high?
MC3 Libraries
How Google Ranks Its Results
Google’s PageRank system- measures the number of links to a single site
Older sites often have more sites that link to them, which ranks them higher, even if their information is outdated or inaccurate
There are other tools Google uses, but we don’t know much about them
Graphic from http://www.zdnet.com/blog/security/researchers-borrow-from-google-pagerank-for-network-defense-service/1540
Google uses several things to rank their results…
So how can I use Google to find good sources?
MC3 Libraries
Better Google results
Let’s find sites written by experts. Use “site:” to narrow results just to
the type of website you want to search.
MC3 Libraries
Using ‘martin luther king’ as our search keywords, search for types of sites.
Some good results are:
governmental sites (site:.gov)
educational sites (site:.edu)
organizational sites (site:.org)
MC3 Libraries
Exact phrase
And
Search an exact phrase by putting words in quotes. “martin luther king”
In many databases you can search for material with two or more ideas in common with the word “and.” Google assumes the word ‘and’ between words
Use Boolean tools to refine your search…Part One
MC3 Libraries
OR
Synonyms
Put a tilde before the word such as “~stress.” The tilde key is at the top left corner of the keyboard.
Or in a search provides options. In Google the word ‘OR’ must be in all caps.
Use Boolean tools to refine your search…Part 2
Not
Not eliminates an idea from a search. The ‘not’ in Google is a minus sign with no space before the word… “-earthquakes”
MC3 Libraries
Can I Use Wikipedia?
Wikipedia Can be Used For: Finding general information
about a topic Picking up ideas and terms
about the topic Finding other sources from the
Reference list at the bottom
http://ohinternet.com/Wikipedia
Wikipedia can be helpful with your research, if used in the right way.
MC3 Libraries
Wikipedia Should NOT be Used for…
Citing in a scholarly research paper
Factual data as the main source in your paper
A source of unbiased information
http://ohinternet.com/Wikipedia
MC3 Libraries
Where can I find the References in
Wikipedia?
Not all of these will be reliable, but there will be a lot of good sources here.
MC3 Libraries
4 Tips to Evaluate Websites
1.Look for the person or organization who created the site.
Source: http://www.hacktabs.com/tips-to-plan-for-a-custom-website-design/
Research the author to see if they may have a bias toward this topic
MC3 Libraries
2. See if the website expresses only one side of an argument.
4 Tips to Evaluate Websites…
MC3 Libraries
Biased information will not give all viewpoints and sometimes may not be accurate
MC3 Libraries
3. Look to see if the website cites any other sources.
Source: http://blog.thinkwell.com/2011/07/citing-online-sources.html
If no sources are cited, the information on the site may be the author’s opinions, not facts.
4 Tips to Evaluate Websites…
MC3 Libraries
4. Look for a date of publication or an update
Source: http://www.noodletools.com/guide/showme/web_site_advanced/8.html
MC3 Libraries
Outdated information may be inaccurate or incorrect
4 Tips to Evaluate Websites…
MC3 Libraries
Reliable alternatives to Google…
• ipl2.org: Internet Public Library only presents sites selected by experts.
• GoDuckGo.com: New search engine with fewer ads and better results. You can use “site:” here too.
• WolframAlpha.org: Use this site to find statistics and facts.
MC3 Libraries
Need photos, audio or video for your presentation or projects
Try search.creativecommons.org where you can freely use the materials resulting from your search. Keep an eye on the license. Many creators want their name listed or may limit commercial use and that’s only fair!
MC3 Libraries
Don’t Forget!
Through your MC3 Libraries website you can access to hundreds of reliable, scholarly
resources!
MC3 Libraries
Let’s Review!Please click on the correct answer to move to the next page:
Question #1: What is NOT one way to verify if a site is reliable?
Check to see if the site cites other sources
Check the title of the site Check the date the site was published
Check the author of the site
MC3 Libraries
Correct!
Move to Question 2
A title may not truly match the content of a site. It is best to read through the actual content and look at the bias, author, citations of other sources and
recent updates in order to determine whether it is valuable or not.
MC3 Libraries MC3 Libraries
IncorrectReturn to Question 1
MC3 Libraries
Let’s Review!Please click on the correct answer to move to the next page:
Question #2: What is something that Wikipedia CAN be used for?
A resource to cite in a scholarly paper
A source of unbiased informationThe main source of factual data in a
paper
Finding citations of scholarly resources on the topic
MC3 Libraries
Correct!
Move to Question 3
Wikipedia is great for finding other scholarly resources on a topic, but it should not be cited as a scholarly resource in a paper.
MC3 Libraries MC3 Libraries
IncorrectReturn to Question 2
MC3 Libraries
Let’s Review!Please click on the correct answer to move to the next page:
Question #3: Which of the following IS a boolean operator?
And
Plus
True
MC3 Libraries
Correct!
Move to Question 4
And, Or, and Not are the boolean operators to help you combine terms, choose one of several terms, or exclude terms respectively.
MC3 Libraries
IncorrectReturn to Question 3
MC3 Libraries
Let’s Review!Please click on the correct answer to move to the next page:
Question #4: Your MC3 Library resources are more reliable than Google.
True False
MC3 Libraries
Correct!Finish
Your MC3 Library is the best place to find reliable, scholarly resources you can trust to help you with your research!
MC3 Libraries
IncorrectReturn to Question 4
MC3 Libraries
Need Help?Visit, Call,
IM or EmailBrendlinger Library
(215) 641-6594West Campus Library
(610) 718-1864IM a [email protected]
Top Related