8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
1/45
Research on Unemployment
MUHAMMAD EJAZ BALTI
QUAID E AZAM UNIVERSITY ISLAMABAD
MASTERS IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONS
SUBMITTED TO SIR DR. TAHIR SAEED
GROUP MEMBERS:
MUHAMMAD EJAZ
ASIM ASLAM
SAIRA
ANEES AYUB
AEYSHA
Research Methodology and Report Writing
1
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
2/45
Research on Unemployment
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
All prayers for Allah almighty who is the most merciful and beneficent for every
torch of guidance and knowledge for humanity. We offer humblest and sincerest
works of thank to our God Almighty who blessed us with potential and ability to
make material contribution to already existing ocean of knowledge.
Heartiest thanks to Mr. Waqar Ahmad, Mr. M Shamim, Mr.Syed Hasnat, Mrs.
Ferzana Naheed Khan, Mr. M Azam, and M. Ali Khan for their cooperation for
giving interviews. Thank to all students and employees who has filled up the
questionnaire. Thanks to the librarian and staffs of the library of PIDE.
Thanks to our Parents who have able us to get education and be here. At last we
thank our teacher Mrs. Mehnaz Khan who has made us able to complete this
research.
Muhammad Ejaz Balti
Research Methodology and Report Writing
2
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
3/45
Research on Unemployment
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Human capital is indeed a very important factor in the progress and
prosperity of a nation but unfortunately this precious resource has been
wasted in the form of unemployment. It is most serious challenge and problem
to all industrial, agricultural, developed, developing and poor countries. Some
are facing more and some are facing less.
In this research report we have discussed the unemployment causes and its
affect, through literature survey. The next step was the theoretical
framework; we have tried our best to develop a hypothesis in order to find out
the broad problem statement. After this we have made operational definition
of unemployment, in order to find out about its characteristics. In data
gathering we have conduct interviews and fill up the questioners from 30
persons. After all we have done our recommendation and conclusion in a very
logical way.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
3
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
4/45
Research on Unemployment
INTRODUCTION
Unemployment is the most serious challenge and problem to all industrial, agricultural,
developed, developing and poor countries. Yet unfortunately developing countries have
not given due importance to develop this factor of production. In most of developing
countries including Pakistan human capital has been given a secondary importance. At the
same time high growth of population and labour force with limited physical and natural
resources has proved to be a drag on development in the developing countries.
Definition of Unemployment
According to Labour Force Survey The Unemployment comprises of all persons ten
years of age and above whom during the reference period were:
a) Without work i.e. were not paid employed or self-employed;
b) Available for work i.e. were available for paid employment or self-employment
during the reference period; and
c) Seeking work.
The measure of unemployment is the number of jobless people who are available for
work and are actively seeking jobs. The unemployment rate is unemployment as a
percentage of the labor force.
Unemployment is that situation where people above ten years are seeking for work and
are able of doing the work but are not provided any job.
Unemployment is that economic interpretation and maneuvering when in a country there
are a large number of able bodied persons who are willing to work and cannot find it at
the current rate of wages. So a person will not be unemployed if he or she is not willing to
work more than the normal hours of work per day or for less than the current rates of
wages.
This term denotes the labor market status of persons 10 years and older who did not work
at all during a reference week but were available for and actively seeking work; also
Research Methodology and Report Writing
4
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
5/45
Research on Unemployment
includes those who were waiting to be called back to a job from which they had been laid
off or waiting to report to a new job scheduled to start within the next 30 days.
www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htm
A condition that exists when a labor force has workers able, ready and willing to acceptemployment and are without jobs, a statistical measure defined as a percentage of a labor
force. A tight labor market is generally indicated by a statistical reporting of less-than-3%
unemployed because there is a bottom layer of unemployed considered to be
unemployable. Events such as recent closings or layoffs or announcements of possible
closings or layoffs may not show up in statistics or labor information available from
indirect sources.
In modern economics, we think of the population as having three components:
1. Those who are employed,
2. Those who are unemployed, and the rest,
3. Who neither are working nor are seeking work.
The first two groups -- those who are employed and who are seeking work -- together
comprise the labor force.
The Labour Force
The labor force consists of all those persons who are willing to work at a market
equilibrium wage, and who either have jobs or are seeking work. In Pakistan on the basis
of the estimated population approximately of 170.00 million and the participation rate of
39.61%, as per the Labour Force Survey 2001-02, the total labour force is estimated at
45.05 million. Of this, 30.19 million or 67.03% is the rural areas and 14.85 million or
32.97% is in the urban areas. The distribution of the labour force from 1995 to 2004 by
rural urban areas is given in the following table.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
5
http://www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htmhttp://www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htmhttp://www.findmehere.com/search/dictionary/l_index.htm#Lhttp://www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htmhttp://www.findmehere.com/search/dictionary/l_index.htm#L8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
6/45
Research on Unemployment
Rural-Urban Labour Force
Labour Force Rural Urban
Year Million
No
Annual
Growth
Million
No
% Share Million
No
% Share
1995 34.18 - 23.96 70.09 10.22 29.90
1996 35.01 2.43 24.27 69.32 10.74 30.68
1997 37.46 7.0 26.02 69.46 11.44 30.54
1998 39.25 4.78 27.57 70.24 11.68 29.76
1999 40.16 2.32 28.11 70.00 12.05 30.00
2000 40.55 0.97 27.96 68.95 12.59 31.05
2001 41.39 2.07 28.44 68.71 12.95 31.29
2002 43.22 4.42 28.98 67.05 14.24 32.95
2003 (E) 44.13 2.00 29.59 67.05 14.54 32.95
2004 (E) 45.04 2.06 30.19 67.03 14.85 32.97E=Estimated
Source: Labour Force and Its rural-urban distribution calculated on the basis of Labour Force Surveys of
respective years.
To measure the importance of unemployment in a nation's work force, we use the
unemployment rate: The unemployment rate is a ratio, obtained by dividing the number of
unemployed persons by the number of persons in the labor force. Thus, the rate of
unemployment is a fraction, less than one. It is usually expressed as a percent.
Unemployment Rate = No. of Unemployed Persons * 100
Total Labor Force
If we are interesting to know the Unemployment Rate of Pakistan for 2004 so by applying
the figures of the same year we can calculate it as
Unemployment Rate = 3.72 * 100
45.04
Research Methodology and Report Writing
6
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
7/45
Research on Unemployment
= 8.26 %(Govt. of Pakistan figures)
The Concepts of Unemployment and Underemployment
The above two concept are different from each others. A worker is clearly unemployed
when he is involuntarily out of work. This is the man who is stranding in a relief line or a
bread line or waiting to pick up his unemployment compensation check. This is a case of
apparent unemployment or simply unemployment; the worker obviously has no job
connection. On the other hand, a worker may have a job but still be in a sense
unemployed. For example, a worker who is harvesting wheat by hand or cutting a lawn
with a pair of scissors is partially unemployed. In this case, however, it is a matter of
Disguised Unemployment or, more simply, Underemployment. Here the worker has a job
but simply is not being employed efficiently.
Types of Unemployment
Unemployment may be of any of the following kinds.
1. Transitional or Frictional Unemployment:
Transitional or Frictional unemployment occurs when people move from one job to other
requiring similar skills. It is caused by normal shifts in the supply of and demand for
products. It is generally temporary, lasting a few days to a few days to a few weeks.
2. Cyclical or Deficient-Demand Unemployment:
Cyclical or Deficient-demand unemployment arises from downswings of the business
cycle that is, by a broad-based reduction in the overall level of spending in the economy.
It generally lasts for a period of weeks or months, until an increase in business activity
raises national output and increases demand for labor.
3. Structural Unemployment:
Structural unemployment is caused by major changes in the skills needed by workers,
because of technological innovation or changes in the relative competitiveness of an
Research Methodology and Report Writing
7
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
8/45
Research on Unemployment
industry. Structural unemployment can last for years, until workers are retrained for new
jobs.
Problem Statement of the Research
Research is the process of finding solutions to a specific problem of our interest after a
thorough study and analysis of the situational factors. In case of our research the problem
of our interest is Unemployment. The purpose of our research is to ascertain the causes of
unemployment which is done through finding various variables affecting it. It should be
noted that this research only identifies the variable affecting the Unemployment not other
things like Underemployment, Economic inefficiency etc
Literature Review
A person is not to be (Azmat Wazir 2002) regarded as unemployed, if he or she desires to
work but is prevented from doing so by sickness or chronic disease. But mere engagement
Research Methodology and Report Writing
8
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
9/45
Research on Unemployment
in some occupation also does not mean the absence of unemployment. Some persons may
be partially employed or may have to do inferior jobs. Persons who are, of course, unfit
on physical, mental or moral grounds or who have no desire to be employed are excluded
from the category of the unemployed are the following:
1. In almost all industries, there are sudden fluctuations of economic activity. So causal
employment arises because of the maladjustment between the demand for and supply of
labour because during the busy period of economic maneuvering, employers call for the
employment of new hands to meet the increased demand of the consumers. But the
reverse will happen during a slump.
2. Many economic activities are seasonal in character. In agricultural countries,
cultivators are engaged for some months of a year; for the rest of the year, they remain
almost idle or jobless. In some industries also workers get jobs only for a certain period of
time. Climatic and social factors are mainly responsible for this type of seasonal
unemployment. Suitable and convenient climate of an area or country favors and
contributes to the economic development of that area or country. Extreme hotness or
extreme cold opposes economic development. The best counter action to resolve the
seasonal job issue by establishing small scale and cottage industries.
3. There are many ups and downs and cyclical fluctuations in industry and alternative
periods of booms and depressions. There trade cycles have a great influence on the
volume of unemployment, which decreases when trade is good and increases when it is
bad.
4. Unemployment may result from changes in industrial techniques, in the methods of
production, or from the growth of new trades and the decline of old ones. Modem
businesses are dynamic and the entrepreneur adopts new inventions and tries to create
new fashions in order to increase his or her profits, but others can copy. So competition
maintains a proper profit balance. Thus technological unemployment arises when hew
machinery and inventions are adopted to replace manual labour.
5. Some laborers will always remain unemployed, because of the inefficiency of the
organization of the labour market and the inadaptability of managements and labour to
Research Methodology and Report Writing
9
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
10/45
Research on Unemployment
changing circumstances. This frictional unemployment may be due to the absence of
proper contact between those who want work and those who want workers and to the
immobility of laborers between different occupations. Unemployment which refers to the
state of persons changing from one job to another or person who are Frictional
unemployment which refers to the state of persons who are waiting to be retrained for a
different occupation is quite compatible with full-employment.
6. High wages demanded by trade unions during a depression may result in
unemployment; employers may find it impossible to absorb the whole labour supply. in
other words, if the trade unions enforce a level of wages, which is not justified by the
marginal productivity of the laborers, unemployment must result because employers will
find it unprofitable to employ any new hands at an artificially high level maintained by
trade union pressure.
7. people are unemployed due to lack of investment opportunities because the current
demand for goods and services is not sufficient to absorb all available labour .people are
unemployed because investment and consumption expenditures are comparatively small.
You must be conscientiously seeking, but unable to find, full-time employment. If you are
receiving unemployment benefits that will automatically qualify you for the
unemployment deferment. When a previously employed worker is laid off or
involuntarily not in gainful employment, he or she is considered unemployed and
possibly eligible for certain state and federal compensation and benefits. No form is
required but you need to call your lender.
www.idapp.org/faqs/glossary.htm
The greatest work-related (Papalia & Wendkos 2001) stressor is sudden, unexpected loss
of a job. Research on unemployment since 1930s has linked it to mental and physical
illness and to problems in family functioning. when people are unemployed, two major
sources of stress are the loss of income and the effect of this loss on their feelings about
themselves workers who drive their identity from their work, men who define manhood as
supporting a family, and people who define their worth in terms of their works dollar
Research Methodology and Report Writing
10
http://www.idapp.org/faqs/glossary.htmhttp://www.idapp.org/faqs/glossary.htm8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
11/45
Research on Unemployment
value lose more than their paychecks when they lose their jobs. They lose a piece of
themselves and their self-esteem.
It is interesting to point (Sabur 1999) out that the least unemployment, 1.2% to 2.8%, is
found in the age group of 30-44 years, while the highest, 8.9%, is prevailing amongst theage group of 16-19 years see Table given below. It is, however, distressing to note that
8.6% of the senior citizens, 60 years and above, are also found unemployed. The
unemployment rate in this age group for women is as high as 26.4%. This clearly
indicates non-availability of formal social security and/or a source of livelihood for the
senior citizens, and the fast diminishing traditional social safety networks available earlier
in the form of families, kinships, friends and even local communities.
Unemployment Rate by Age and Sex as % 1999-2000
Age-group (years) Male Female
16-19 7.9 13.6
20-24 5.8 9.0
25-29 2.7 8.4
30-34 1.5 7.0
35-39 0.9 2.2
40-44 1.2 5.8
45-49 1.6 11.1
50-54 2.5 14.4
55-59 2.9 16.5
60 & above 6.6 26.4
Economic efficiency (Campbell 1999) requires, first, that available resources be actually
utilized in the production of goods and services rather than allowed to lie idle. An unused
locomotive is of zero efficiency. The same can be said for unemployed resources.
Unutilized resources-both human and property-obviously mean waste and inefficiency.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
11
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
12/45
Research on Unemployment
Unemployment is the height of economic inefficiency; when society fails to put its
available resources into the productive process, it obviously realizes no output at all.
Long-term structural unemployment (Reynolds & Masters 1999) usually occurs because
the wage rate for a certain kind of labor (for example, dishwashers or steelworkers) is setabove the equilibrium level where demand is equal to supply. At a wage rate of Wo,
supply equals demand. At a higher wage, like Wi, supply exceeds demand. When the
wage is Wi, employment is Ei the number of Workers that firms are willing to employ
at this wage; but at Wi, Eii workers want such work. Eii Ei, the difference between the
supply and demand for labour at the going wage rate, represents structural unemployment.
Unemployment means lost output (McKenzie 1998) as well as personal hardship for those
who are out of work. Besides reducing output, unemployment triggers higher government
expenditures on unemployment compensation and welfare programs. Eventually those
expenditures are translated into higher taxes for the reduced working population-a
problem in itself.
Unemployment is nothing (Saeed 2003) but wastage of human resources. The non-
utilization of labour resources; the condition in which members of the labour force are
without jobs. Sometimes used more broadly to refer to the waste of resources when the
economy is operating at less than its full potential. The full employment is and has always
been desirable by the societies. The classical economists were of the view that full-
employment is always automatically achieved. This had been true if there would have
been perfect markets but it is not he case. Because of imperfections and government
intervention, the markets are disturbed. When the wage rate is determined by any factor
other than demand for and supply of labour the unemployment will exist in the economy.
At this moment government intervention is desirable to achieve the goal of full
employment.
Unemployment is defined as all persons (Labour Force Survey Pakistan 2003-04) ten
years of age and above who during the period under reference were, a) without work i.e.
were not in paid employment or self-employed, b) currently available for work i.e. were
available for paid employment self-employment and c) seeking work i.e. had taken
Research Methodology and Report Writing
12
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
13/45
Research on Unemployment
specific steps in a specified period to seek paid employment or self-employment.
According to this definition, about 3.72 million people in the labour force were estimated
to be unemployed in 2004 compared to 3.65 million in 2003. The unemployed labour
force by urban/rural areas from 1995 to 2004 is given in the following table.
Unemployment Labour Force by Rural/Urban Areas (No. in Million)
Unemployment Labour Force Unemployment Rate (%)
Years Total Rural Urban Total Rural Urban
1995 1.84 1.14 0.72 5.37 4.80 6.90
1996 1.88 1.16 0.72 5.37 4.80 6.90
1997 2.29 1.47 0.82 6.12 5.65 7.17
1998 2.31 1.37 0.94 5.89 4.98 7.95
1999 2.36 1.40 0.96 5.89 4.98 7.95
2000 3.17 1.94 1.23 7.82 6.94 9.92
2001 3.24 1.94 1.27 7.82 6.94 9.92
2002 3.57 2.19 1.38 8.27 7.55 9.80
2003 3.65 2.23 1.42 8.27 7.55 9.80
2004 3.72 2.28 1.44 8.26 7.55 9.80
The state of being without work; a form of instability in an economy occurring when
aggregate supply exceeds aggregate demand or resulting from a variety of social,
locational, technological, and specific market factors
www.noacsc.org/auglaize/wk/cos/socialst/glossary.htm
Cyclical - workers gain and lose jobs according to the boom and bust cycles of the
economy. For example, the oil workers have lots of work when the price of oil is up;
when prices fall, workers are out of work. Frictional - usually for a short duration, people
who are between jobs by choice because the last job was unfulfilling, didn't pay enough,
Research Methodology and Report Writing
13
http://www.noacsc.org/auglaize/wk/cos/socialst/glossary.htmhttp://www.noacsc.org/auglaize/wk/cos/socialst/glossary.htm8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
14/45
Research on Unemployment
they wanted to change jobs or for other reasons. Seasonal - people not working due to
regular fluctuations in demand, e.g., crop harvesters are only in demand for part of the
year, and demand for construction work diminishes greatly in winter climates. Structural -
job vacancies that require different skills than the workers have, either due to a lack of
training or to geography. For example, a hockey player who can no longer play the game
and has no skills to match employer needs or, the need for tool-and-die makers is great in
Calgary but the unemployed tool-and-die makers are in Windsor.
www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTM
Theoretical Framework
Research Methodology and Report Writing
14
http://www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTMhttp://www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTMhttp://www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTM8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
15/45
Research on Unemployment
A Theoretical Framework is a conceptual model of how one theorizes or makes logical
since of the relationships among the several factors that have been identified as important
to the problem. It is the foundation on which the entire research project is based. It is a
logically developed, described, and elaborated network of associations among the
variables deemed relevant to the problem situation and identified through such processes
as interviews, observations, and literature survey. Experience and intuition also guide in
developing the theoretical framework.
After analyzing the literature survey and the whole problem the following variables are
found that are considered as important for the topic i.e. Unemployment.
Technological Advancement
Investment
Seasonal Jobs
Immobility of Workers
Stress
Wastage of Human Resources
Wages
Booms in Economy
Slumps
Increase in Demands of Consumers
Depressions
Unemployment Allowances
Govt. Expenditures
Taxes
Skills
Self-Esteem
Number of Small Scale Industries
Loss of Job
Research Methodology and Report Writing
15
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
16/45
Research on Unemployment
Loss of Income
Mental and Physical Illness
High Demands of Trade Unions
Privatization
Political Instability
Population
In the below paragraphs the variables are defined that how they are related to
unemployment.
Technological Advancement:
Whenever there will be technological advancements in any developing country like
Pakistan so it will always face unemployment. It is due to the fact that when advance
machinery comes so it can work instead of more than 10 workers. It means that
technological advancement is an independent variable and unemployment depends upon
it. Unemployment is direct proportionate to technological advancement because when
technology increases so it increases the unemployment.
Investment:
Investment activities are considered so vital for development. Whenever there will be
high investment in any country so it will generate employment and when reduce
unemployment. On the stated basis it can be said that there is inverse relationship between
investment and unemployment because when investment increases so it reduces that
unemployment.
Seasonal Jobs:
Research Methodology and Report Writing
16
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
17/45
Research on Unemployment
It is observed by the researchers that wherever there are seasonal jobs so there will be
high unemployment. For example, in agrarian society where people are only busy on
cultivating their land so there people are seen unemployed after the harvesting process. It
means where there will be seasonal jobs so there will be more unemployment. Now it can
be said that there is direct relationship between seasonal jobs and unemployment because
increase in one leads to increase in the other variable.
Immobility of Workers:
In the developing countries like Pakistan there is collectivism and joint family system
which is hurdle for the mobility of workers. When workers do not go for work outside
their villages, towns, and cities so they will remain unemployed. It means that there is
direct relationship between unemployment and immobility of workers. Here
unemployment depends upon the mobility of workers.
Stress:
Stress is an unstable state of mind which is due to some bad event. Whenever a person is
get out of the work so he/she will always involve in stress. It means that unemployment
causes the stress. Here stress is dependent variable and unemployment is independent
variable. There is direct relationship between unemployment and stress.
Waste of Human Resources:
When people are without any work so it means that they are unutilized and lie idle. When
there will be unemployment so it means that there is waste of human resources. The
people are not used. Here direct relationship exists between the two variables.
Unemployment here is as independent variable and the other is dependent one.
Privatization:
Now a days the biggest threat to the employees is job security that is, due to privatization.
As most of public sector organizations are overloaded with employees so whenever such
public sector organizations are being privatized so they get out the employees which lead
Research Methodology and Report Writing
17
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
18/45
Research on Unemployment
to unemployment. Therefore, privatization has direct link with unemployment as increase
in one leads to increase in the other.
Political Instability:
The impact of Political Instability on the economy can not be ignored by anyone. We can
see that the countries with political stability attract greater foreign investment as
compared to those with less political stability. The low investment leads to generate less
employment as a result there will be greater unemployment. So there is direct relationship
between political instability and unemployment.
Population:
Population is the number of people living in a specific geographical area. Whenever it is
high in any area so it means that there is greater number of hands for receiving any job.
The greater the number of job receivers the greater will be unemployed. It means that
there is direct relationship between population and unemployment.
Depression:
Depression means when there is few economic activities. It is a period when there is little
economic activities and many people are without any job. Whenever there is depression in
any country so it is seen that greater number of people are without job. It means there is
direct relationship between depression and unemployment. As one increases so the other
also increases.
Booms in Economy:
Booms in economy means that there is sudden increase in economic activities which
result in high investment and other positive economic activities. This situation leads theeconomy to generate more and more employment opportunities. It means that booms in
economy and unemployment are inverse proportionate to each others. Here booms in the
economy play the role of moderating variable between depression and unemployment.
Demands of Consumers:
Research Methodology and Report Writing
18
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
19/45
Research on Unemployment
Sometimes there is sudden increase in the demands of consumers. It forces the
manufacturer to produce more and more products. Producing more goods require more
workers so the manufacturers hire more workers which leads to low unemployment. It
means that there is inverse relationship between increase demands of consumers and
unemployment. Here it is taken as Independent variable.
Slumps:
Slump is an economic term which means sudden fall in the demands of consumers due to
any reason. Whenever there is slump so it will disturb the relationship of increase
demands of consumers and unemployment. Slump is taken here as moderating variable.
Unemployment Allowances, Govt. Expenditure and Taxes:
Whenever there is high unemployment in any country so there Govt. gives unemployment
allowances to unemployed persons which increase the Govt. expenditures. Govt. recovers
its high expenditures by imposing taxes of different kinds. It means that when there is
high unemployment in any country so it will lead to high unemployment allowances
which lead to high Govt. expenditures and finally it increases the tax rates. Here
unemployment allowances and Govt. expenditure are taken as intervening variables, taxes
as dependent variable and unemployment as independent variable.
High Demands of Trade Unions and Wages:
Almost in every organization there are trade unions which claim to be the protector of
employees rights. They sometimes demands for higher wages from the employers. In this
case the employer increases the wages of employees but due to increase in the production
cost thereafter he/she gets out some employees. This increases the unemployment. It
means that there are direct relationships between high demands of trade unions for wages
and unemployment.
Loss of Job and Low Self-Esteem:
Whenever any person is having job so it is a pride for him/her. In this case he/she has
higher level of self-esteem. But when a person is suspended from the job so his/her self-
Research Methodology and Report Writing
19
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
20/45
Research on Unemployment
esteem decreases. It means unemployment leads to loss of job and which leads to low
self-esteem. Here self-esteem is taken as dependent variable and loss of job plays the role
of intervening variable.
Lack of Skills:
In todays modern world almost every job requires any kind of skill. In societies where
there people do not have any skill so there will be greater unemployment. It means that
lack of skill is directly proportionate to unemployment. Here lack of skills is taken as
independent variable and unemployment as dependent variable.
Unemployment as Dependent Variable or Causes of
Unemployment:
Research Methodology and Report Writing
20
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
21/45
Research on Unemployment
Below is the theoretical framework which shows that all independent variables are the
causes of unemployment.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
21
Unem
ploym
ent
TechnologicalAdvancement
Immobility
of Workers
Lack of
Investment
Privatization
Political
Instability
Independent Variables
DependentVariable
Seasonal Jobs
Lack of Skills
Un
em
plo
ym
ent
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
22/45
Research on Unemployment
Unemployment as Independent Variable:
When any variable is taken as dependent variable so it shows that it is the effects of theindependent variable. Below are the dependent variables which are the effects of the
independent variable Unemployment.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
22
Un
emp
loy
me
nt
Increase inPopulation
High Stress
Wastage ofHuman Resource
Mental andPhysical Illness
UnemploymentAllowances
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
23/45
Research on Unemployment
Some other Possible Independent, Dependent, and Moderating
Variables:
Research Methodology and Report Writing
23
Independen
t Variable
Dependent
Variables
Decrease in
Demands
Unemployment
Decrease in
Productions
Depression
Booms inEconomy
Unemployment
Seasonal Jobs
Small ScaleIndustries
Unemployment
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
24/45
Research on Unemployment
The Complete Theoretical Framework
Research Methodology and Report Writing
24
Unemployment
Allowances
Govt.Expenditur
e
High
Taxes
Unemploy
-ment
Unemploy-
mentLoss of Job
Low Self -Esteem
Unemploy-
mentLow income High Stress
Decrease
in demands
Technologi
cal
Advancement
Loss of
IncomeHigh Stress
Decrease
in
Production
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
25/45
Research on Unemployment
Hypothesis
A Hypothesis can be defined as a logically conjectured relationship between two or more
variables expressed in the form of a testable statement. It is considered as a testable
Research Methodology and Report Writing
25
Depression
Immobility
of Workers
Demands
of Trade
Unions
Lack of
Investment
Seasonal
Jobs
Lack of
Skills
Privatizatio
n
PoliticalInstability
Unemploym
ent
Booms in
Economy
High
Wages
Small
ScaleIndustries
Wastage of
HumanResources
High Taxes
Govt.
Expenditure
Unemploy
ment
Allowances
Low Self
EsteemLoss of Job
Increase in
Population
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
26/45
Research on Unemployment
statement of the relationship among variables. Relationships are conjectured on the basis
of the network of associations established in the theoretical framework formulated for the
research study.
Null and Alternative Hypotheses:
The Null hypothesis is a proposition that states a definitive, exact relationship between
two variables. It is a statement which states that there is no (significant) relationship
between two variables or no (significant) difference between two groups.
On the other hand Alternative Hypothesis, which is the opposite of the null, is a statement
expressing a relationship between two variables or indicating differences between groups.
The hypothesis that has been developed from the above theoretical framework is given
below.
Hypotheses 1:If there is more investment then there will be less unemployment.
The above is a Hypotheses statement from which we have to make Null (Ho) and
Alternative (Hi) Hypotheses.
Ho = There is no relationship between the investment and unemployment.
Statistically we can write it as
Ho: r = 0
Where r denote the correlation between the investment and unemployment. Here r is
equal to zero so therefore we can say that there is no relationship between investment and
unemployment.
Hi = There is relationship between the investment and unemployment and when
investment increases so unemployment decreases.
Statistically we can write it as
Hi: r < 0 (because correlation is negative)
It means that the more is the investment the less will be unemployment.
Hypotheses 2:The greater the technological advancement the more will be
unemployment.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
26
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
27/45
Research on Unemployment
Null Hypotheses for the H # 2:
Ho = There exist no relationships between technological advancement and
unemployment.
Statistically we can write it as
Ho: r = 0
Alternative Hypotheses for H # 2
Hi = There is relationship between the technological advancement and unemploymentbecause when technological advancement come to the unemployment increases.
Statistically it can be written as
Hi: r > 0 (correlation is positive)
It means that there is direct relationship between technological advancement and
unemployment because when one increases so it causes the other one to increase.
Hypotheses 3:There is a relationship between unemployment and an individual stress.
(Nondirectional hypotheses)
Null Hypotheses for H # 3
Ho = There is no relationship between unemployment and stress.
Ho: r = 0
Alternative hypotheses for H # 3
Hi = There is a relationship between the unemployment and stress.
Hi: r # 0
It means that there is relationship between unemployment and stress therefore r the
correlation is not equal to zero.
Hypotheses 4:The greater is the quality of education and skilled worker the lower will
be unemployment
Null Hypotheses for H # 4
Research Methodology and Report Writing
27
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
28/45
Research on Unemployment
Ho = There is no relationship between unemployment and quality of education and skilled
workers.
Ho: r = 0
Alternative hypotheses for H # 4
Hi = There is relationship between unemployment and quality of education and skilled
workers.
Hi: r > 0
Hypotheses 5:If there is greater immobility of workers (workers are not moving for
getting jobs from one place to another and leaving their families) then there will be
greater unemployment
Null Hypotheses for H # 5:
Ho = There is no relationship between the immobility of workers and unemployment.
Ho: r = 0
Alternative Hypotheses for H # 5:
Hi = The greater the immobility of workers the more will be unemployment.
Hi: r > 0
Research Design
Research design is a series of rational decision-making where the purpose of the research,
type of investigation, extent of researcher interference, study setting, unit of analysis and
time horizon of research is identified.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
28
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
29/45
Research on Unemployment
1. Purpose of the Study:
The Purpose of the research is to study the nature of the study whether it is exploratory,
descriptive, or hypothesis testing. It depends on the stage to which knowledge about the
research topic has advanced. In the discussing topic we are trying to know the cause and
effect relationship means that which variables increases the unemployment and which arethe consequences of unemployment. Whenever we want to know the relationship among
variables so it is said that this study is hypothesis testing. On this basis we can say that
this study of unemployment isHypothesis testing.
2. Type of Investigation:
There are two types of investigations 1). Causal, 2). Correlational.
The study in which the researcher wants to delineate the cause of one or more problem is
called a Causal study whereas when the researcher is interested in describing theimportant variables associated with the problem, the study is called Correlational study. In
case of our research about unemployment we are finding the all variables associated withit so therefore we can say that this study is a Correlational Study.
3. The Extent of Researcher Interference with the Study:
A Correlational study is conducted in the natural environment with minimum interferenceby the researcher. As our study is a Correlational study and we collect our data in the field
through questionnaire, interviews and literature survey therefore it can be said that this
study has not been manipulated by the researcher and there is Minimum interference by
the researcher.
4. Study Setting: Contrived and Noncontrived:
Research can be conducted in the natural environment where work proceed normally (that
is, in Noncontrived settings) or in artificial or contrived settings. Correlational studies areinvariably conducted in Noncontrived settings i.e. Natural Environment. We conducted
the research in the field. Now it can be said that this study being Correlational and Field
study is done inNoncontrived settings.
5. Unit of Analysis:
The unit of analysis refers to the level of aggregation of the data collected during thesubsequent data analysis stage. In case of our research the unit of analysis are Individual
and country. In our research process we collected our data from individuals and asking
them that what the causes of unemployment are. We also were concern about the overall
Research Methodology and Report Writing
29
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
30/45
Research on Unemployment
position of the countrys employment. So on this basis we can say that in this research the
unit of analysis is Individual and country.
6. Time Horizon:
The researcher might want to study people or phenomena at more than one point in timein order to answer the research question. This is the case of longitudinal studies. When a
study is done in such a way that data are gathered just once, perhaps over a period of days
or weeks or months, in order to answer a research question. Such studies are called One-Shot or Cross-Sectional or Horizontal Studies. The research we have conducted is the
case of Cross-Sectional study because here we collected data just once over a period of
weeks.
MEASUREMENT OF VARIABLES
Measurement of the variables in the theoretical framework is an integral part of research
and an important aspect of research design. Unless the variables are measured in someway, we will not able to test our hypotheses and find answers to complex research issues.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
30
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
31/45
Research on Unemployment
One technique to measure and define subjective variables like motivation, satisfaction,
unemployment etc. is to reduce these abstract notions or concepts to observable
characteristics and behaviors by those who possess these abstract qualities. This is donethrough Operational definition.
OPERATIONAL DEFINITION:
Operationalizing or operationally defining a concept so that it becomes measurable is
achieved by looking at the behavioral dimensions, facets, or properties denoted by theconcept, and categorizing these into observable and measurable elements.
In case of this research we are to define Unemployment operationally.
OPERATIONALIZING THE CONCEPT OF UNEMPLOYMENT:In the operational definition of unemployment we have divided it into followingdimensions and elements.
Dimension No.1 Health of EconomyIts the key indicator of the unemployment. Health of economy refers to the position and
growth of economy. If it is in strong position than it means that there will be more
employment and if it is in wake position than there will be low employment.
Dimension No.2 Low OpportunitiesIn any country when there is less opportunities so the people will be more unemployed.
There will be every less number of jobs for people.
Dimension No.3 Weak Industrial SectorUnemployment is also characterized by weak industrial sector. In most of the countrieswhere there is agrarian society strong so there are always seasonal jobs which results in
higher unemployment.
Dimension No.4 Instable Law and Order SituationIn any society when there is higher unemployment so there is always the problem of law
and order. People being not involved and employed will tend to go for illegal actions.Terrorism will be increasing as unemployed people will be the focus of terrorist groups
which will results in instable society.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
31
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
32/45
Research on Unemployment
Operationalizing the Concept of Unemployment
Research Methodology and Report Writing
Per Capita Income No Eligibility for
Job
Weak Industrial
Sector
LowOpportunities Instable Lawand Order
No. of dependent persons
on an individual
No. of people working in a family
No. of applicants
for a single job
Less No. of
new jobs
Low Productivity Working not
profitably
No. of
people
involve incrimes
No. of Robberies
and Theft
Lack ofEducation
and skills
Age problem
No. of closed
industries
Unemployment
C
E
D1 D3
D2D4
D5
E
E
E
E
EE
EE
E
E
Financial
Problem
Higher
DropoutRate
32
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
33/45
Research on Unemployment
Operationalizing the concept of Investment
Research Methodology and Report Writing
Industrial Growth Low Living
StandardLower Education
Level
Les No. of new industrial
units establishment
Lower No. of people employed inindustry
Less No. of
GraduatesLow No. of Qualified
researchers
No. of people living
below poverty line
Lower income ofpeople
Lack of Investment
C
33
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
34/45
Research on Unemployment
Operationalizing the concept of Stress
Research Methodology and Report Writing
Nervous Hesitate to take
ResponsibilityWork Under
pressure
Facial expressions and
gestures
Unable to stay calm
Increase in mistakes Unable to complete
work on time
Not Initiator
Fear of loss
Stress
C
34
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
35/45
Research on Unemployment
SAMPLING
The kind of sampling which we are using is convenience sampling (non probability). Wehave look out at our convenience for data collection means the people who have easilyaccess to us, we contact them and get the information. For this purpose we have
approached the students of QAU and Ministry of Labour and Manpower.
Students of QAU:Out of thirty questionnaires we filled up 15 from the university. This was done to get
responses from those who are going to be employed in the near future. So ascertainingtheir views were important. We filled these questionnaires in the Central Library of the
university. It was done so to get responses from all students irrespective of their
departments.
Ministry of Labour and Manpower:Fifteen questionnaires were filled up from the employees of Ministry of labour andmanpower. There we filled up these questionnaires in the following
departments/organizations of the ministry.
Institute of Manpower:
We filled some questionnaires from this institute which works under this ministry which
is near to Zero Point.
Overseas Pakistan Foundation for Manpower:This foundation also works under the same ministry. Here as well we filled up some of
the questionnaires.
Ministry of Labour and Manpower B Block:
We also filled up some questionnaires in the main building of the ministry.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
35
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
36/45
Research on Unemployment
METHODS OF DATA COLLECTIONThere are several methods for data collection. We have used two methods for date
collection.
1. Interviews:
One method of collecting data is to interview respondents to obtain information on the
issues of interest. Interviews could be unstructured or structured, and conducted eitherface to face or by telephone or online. In case of this research we have conducted
unstructured face to face interviews. The following interviews were conducted for this
research which is summarized below.
a). The first interviewee was Mr. Waqar Ahmad, Section Officer in Overseas Pakistan
Foundation for Manpower. He said that unemployment is that condition where people arewilling to work but are not provided work. He said that people are usually looking for
White Coaler job rather than Blue Coaler jobs. He said that due to poor investment by the
natives and foreign investment unemployment has increased in Pakistan. He blames Govt.that due to no consistency in its policies unemployment has increased. He stressed on
political instability to be the cause of unemployment. He said that terrorism has led to
unemployment and vice verse. He said that Govt should give incentives to the investors so
that they can invest in the country without any fear and provide peaceful environment for
investment.
b). The second interview was taken by Mr. M. Shamim, Section Officer in OverseasPakistan Foundation for Manpower. He said that lack of quality education i.e. skills is the
main cause for unemployment. He also blames the Govt. to be responsible for
unemployment. He said stressed on the poor investment policies of the Govt. and said thatthey should be of improved one. He said that Govt. should maintain law and order
situation peaceful.
c). The third interview was taken from Mr. Azam, Assistant Director Institute ofManpower Ministry of Labour and Manpower. He defines unemployment as a situation
where jobs are less and people are able, willing and seeking for job. He said that due to noexpansion of economic sectors like agriculture, industry etc. unemployment has increased.He said that unemployment has led to intension and stress in the society. He said that
geographical location of any area has also contributed in the unemployment of that area.
He stressed of maintaining law and order for investment which can than lead that countryto increased employment opportunities.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
36
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
37/45
Research on Unemployment
d). One of the interviews was taken from Mohammad Ali Khan, Research Officer
Ministry of Labour and Manpower B. Block. He said that the main cause of
unemployment is lack of investment and lack of skills. He said that people do investmentin foreign countries but not in their own country which has resulted in increased rate of
unemployment. Now what Govt has to do is to give incentives to investors and built
institutes for skill development in rural and urban areas. It has to educate the people sothat they become able to do any technical work on time. He said that terrorist act in the
country has also made in impossible for investors to invest their money. Now Govt has to
made liberal and investment developing policies so that people will invest in the country.
e). The fifth interview was taken by Mr. Syed Hasnat Staff Economist Economic
Department AERC. He said that due to structural problems. He defined structuralproblems as lack of quality education, infrastructural facilities etc. He said Frictional
unemployment is also one of the main causes for unemployment. He said that due to
dependency on one sector i.e. agriculture unemployment has increased. He said that small
scale industries must be established to promote employment. On one question he said thattrade union has no role in the promotion of employment. He said that privatization means
bringing efficiency so in case of privatization inefficient employees of get out of the
employment.
f). For the sixth interview we went to Economic Department of our own university i.e.
QAU and took interview from Mrs. Ferzana Naheed Khan, Lecturer. She definedunemployment as a condition that exist when people who are will to work but not able to
get jobs at reasonable wages. She blamed unskillness and illiteracy to be the main causes
of unemployment. She said that due to unemployment crimes and terrorist activities has
increased. She said that Govt. should bring continuity in her policies and provide facilitiesto those who are required to improve their skills. She said that privatization can not be
blamed for unemployment but she said that in short run it will reduce jobs but for long run
it is beneficent. She said that better infrastructure facilities should be provided to generateemployment opportunities in all around the country. She said that gender inequality is not
responsible for unemployment because if females are not allowed to work so then it does
not mean that it is unemployment. She said that international community should do morefor the reduction of unemployment in the developing countries.
2. Questionnaires:
The second source of our data collection was through Questionnaire. We filled up 30
questionnaire from which 15 was from students of QAU and 15 was from employees of
Ministry of Labour and Manpower, Institute of Manpower, Overseas Pakistan Foundationfor Manpower. The questionnaire was of the following pattern.
QUESTIONS
OPTIONSStrongly
Agree
(A)
Agree
(B)
Partially
(C)
Disagree
(D)
Strongly
Disagree
(E)
Research Methodology and Report Writing
37
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
38/45
Research on Unemployment
1). Government is responsible
for unemployment.
2).Technological advancement
leads to unemployment.
3). Privatization increasesunemployment.
4). Lack of Skills in individual
has led to unemployment.
5). Trade Unions are responsible
for unemployment.
6). Demands for higher wages
has increased unemployment.
7). Immobility of workers leads
to unemployment.8). Political Instability increases
the unemployment.
9). Investment can decrease the
unemployment.
10).Unemployment persists due
to seasonal jobs.
11).Agrarian society has led to
unemployment.
12).Small scale industries can
decrease the unemployment.
13).Increasing Population has
led to unemployment.
14).Due to unemployment
people are involve in stress.
15). Unemployment leads to
wastage of human resources.
16).NGOs has greatly helped the
world to reduce the
unemployment.
17).Globalization will increase
unemployment in developing
countries.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
38
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
39/45
Research on Unemployment
18).Infrastructure plays a vital
role in the reduction of
unemployment.
19).High Govt. Taxes has led to
unemployment.20).Unemployment is the result
of continuous economic
depression.
Data Analysis and Interpretation
The research questions for this research work were same for student and employees. Both
were given the same questionnaire for ascertaining the responses from them.
The responses from questionnaire can be summarized in the following way.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
39
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
40/45
Research on Unemployment
QUESTION
NO.
FREQENCY OF RESPONSES
Strongly
Agree
Agree Partially Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 13 13 4 0 0
2 3 7 3 10 83 2 5 11 10 3
4 14 12 1 2 1
5 1 8 6 9 6
6 4 8 6 9 3
7 7 5 14 4 0
8 11 8 5 6 0
9 20 3 3 4 0
10 1 7 15 6 0
11 2 5 5 16 2
12 9 14 5 2 0
13 20 6 1 3 014 16 7 4 3 0
15 12 9 7 2 0
16 3 7 18 2 0
17 10 8 5 5 2
18 16 6 8 0 0
19 14 9 6 1 0
20 12 18 0 0 0
The above are the frequency of responses from students and employees. Now we will
analyse the data with respond to our developed hypotheses.
The first Null Hypotheses which says that there is no relationship between investment and
unemployment will be rejected and the Alternative Hypotheses will be accepted. It is because of the responses about investment that 20 respondent strongly agree that
investment can decrease unemployment. So therefore we will accept the Alternative
Hypotheses.
The Second Null Hypotheses which is about Technological advancement and says that
there is no relationship between unemployment and it. Here the responses show that 18
disagree with the hypotheses that say technological advancement leads to unemployment.
Here we will accept the Null Hypotheses and reject the Alternative Hypotheses.The third Null hypothesis says that there is no relationship between unemployment and
stress. The collected data show that 23 respondents say that there is relationship betweenunemployment and stress and due to increase in unemployment, stress has increased. Here
we will accept the Alternative Hypotheses and reject the Null Hypotheses.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
40
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
41/45
Research on Unemployment
In the fourth hypotheses we will again reject our Null hypotheses and accept the
Alternative one. Here the 26 respondents show agree ness that skill and education can
increase the employment and decrease the unemployment.
In the fifth hypotheses we will accept the Null Hypotheses and reject the Alternative
Hypotheses. It is because of the responses from the students and employees which saythat 18 have disagreed with the statement that Immobility of workers has led to
unemployment. Now we can say that immobility is not related to the unemployment.
From the informal interviews we also come to now that our culture of getting white coaler
job, increase in population, poor infrastructure which results in attracting low investment
that leads to generation of less employment, all these contribute to unemployment.
Recommendations and Suggestions :
Comprehensive economic planning is necessary for the best direction and
utilization of economic resources of the country, plus new avenues of employment
must be created.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
41
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
42/45
Research on Unemployment
Comprehensive population control policies should be developed and implemented.
The best remedy for seasonal unemployment is the development of small scale
and cottage industries.
For fighting technological unemployment, attempts should be made to pass ontechnical training in them who are thrown out of employment due to technological
advancement.
Opportunities for investment may be created, since full employment depends on
effective demands which are made up of two items-investment and consumption
expenditure, private investment may be stimulated by the pursuit of a low interestrate policy or of a modified income tax policy.
Conclusion
The research paper which we have undertaken has focused on the issue of unemploymentand factors responsible for it. Our study was limited to the literature survey and
interviews. However an attempt was made to dig out the roots of the problem. It was
found that unemployment was much higher than the general impression provided by thegovernment. Unemployment has been the result of no consistent policies of the Govt. The
Research Methodology and Report Writing
42
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
43/45
Research on Unemployment
frequent charging of govt. and adaptation of new policies by every new Govt. has led to
higher level of unemployment in the country. Political Instability is one of the major parts
of it that unemployment has increased due to it. Privatization in the short run may reduceemployment by downsizing the organization but in the long run it will benefit the country.
It will bring efficiency in the organization and organization will get prosperity.
Investment is the main factor which should be considered. The people should be givenincentives to invest their money. Now-a-days the native Pakistanis are investing in
different countries but not investing in Pakistan. They should be called for it. Foreign
investment should be given chance and liberal policies should make for foreign investors.Education level has to be improved and skilled development programmes has to be
launched. Govt. should make educational and skilled development programmes. For
temporary solution of unemployment unemployed individuals should be givenunemployment allowances which will reduce the tense and stress of individuals.
BIBLOGRAPHY
Azmat WazirPositive Approaches to Economics OCEAN Publisher D. I. Khan
Pakistan 2002, pp 63-69.
Kelvin Lancaster Introduction to Modern Microeconomics 6TH Ed. Rand
McNally and Co. Chicago U. S. A. 1999, pp 230-233.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
43
8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
44/45
Research on Unemployment
Munawar Shah (Sept. 2002) Unemployment in Pakistan Pakistan Management
Review pp 15-19.
Karamat Ali The Political Economy of Pakistan Publisher Vanguard, Pakistan
2002 pp 108-130.
Shachle An Economy Querist Brook Crutchley USA 1998 pp 77-82.
Khan, Ahfaque H. (2002) Factor demand in Pakistanis manufacturing,
International Economic journal. vol.2, no 3, autumn 2002.
National Manpower Commission (2001) report of the national manpower
commission, ISLAMABAD.
Hussain, Akmal (2000) sub committee on employment and poverty alleviation.
Committee on social and economic wellbeing for the 8th
five year plane.PIDE,Islamabad.
Naqvi, S, N H. (2004) social problems and economic scenario, committee on
social and economic wellbeing for the 8th five year plane.PIDE, Islamabad.
Papalier, Wendkrs Human Development 5th Ed. McGraw Hill Inc. U. S. A. 2002
pp 442-445.
Reynods Economics 3rd Ed. IRWIN-Dorsey U. S. A. 2003 pp 168-170
Richard Economics Houghton Mifflin Co. U. S. A. 1998 pp 125-128.
Compbill Economics 3rd Ed. MeGnnell Co. U.S.A. 1997 pp 27-30.
www.idapp.org/faqs/glossary.htm
www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htm
www.noacsc.org/auglaize/wk/cos/socialst/glossary.htm
www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTM
Interviewees Name and Contact No.
Mr. Waqar Ahmad
Section Officer, Overseas Pakistan Foundation for Manpower.
Ph. No # 9224267.
Research Methodology and Report Writing
44
http://www.idapp.org/faqs/glossary.htmhttp://www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htmhttp://www.noacsc.org/auglaize/wk/cos/socialst/glossary.htmhttp://www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTMhttp://www.idapp.org/faqs/glossary.htmhttp://www.wa.gov/ftp/esd/lmea/usergude/glossary.htmhttp://www.noacsc.org/auglaize/wk/cos/socialst/glossary.htmhttp://www.ces.bc.ca/cg2001/GATEWAYS/PUBL/MCS_SITE/APPEND/APPENDB.HTM8/4/2019 Final Project of Rmrw Unemployment
45/45
Research on Unemployment
Mr. M. Shamim
Section Officer, Overseas Pakistan Foundation for Manpower
Ph. No. # 9204581
Mr. M. Azam
Assistant Director Institute of Manpower
Ph. No. # 9209676
M. Ali Khan
Research Officer Ministry of Labour and Manpower B. Block
Ph. No. # 03005193363
Mr. Syed Hasnat
Staff Economist AERC
Ph. No. # 03009153580
Mrs. Ferzana Naheed Khan
Lecturer Department of Economics QAU
Ph. No. # 2206692
45
Top Related