Download - ECF 84 Redacted

8/20/2019 ECF 84 Redacted

1/26

!"#$%& ($)$%( ($*#+$ +,!*$-,* $.% ($*#+$ ,- /)*01)"&

"#$%% &'()$#*'+,

-*.'+%'//,

01

23+%4+ 5 6'**'.(7 88-, $% .*1,

9$/$+:.+%71

;;;;;;;;;;;

?@ABC0BDDEFGBHI2

*%210 /%/,*)"&!/ ,- 1)3 #" (!22,*$ ,-/,$#," $, (/#(( 40 &%-%"&)"$( .!"$," 5 3#11#)/( 1126

7,." 3,,&(6 *#+.)*& 30)$$6 )"& *,4%*$ 8!)+9%"4,((

9.%$:? JC%4)$# FK, FD@A I4L+ I1 "3CM*$N, I#1 O".# =41 DPFQK;".##$%% I1 R+:$#74+ O".# =41 @GKDD;6 S88SRTU 5 < J==J88V 88-EFA WX$*/%L U%#$$%, =1616.7L'+Y%4+, 9< FDDDAW$*$ZL4+$? OFDF; QGQBADA@[.C7'('*$? OFDF; QGQBADA>\(.'*? ])3CM*$N^XC1C4(

!"#$%&' )"* +&)&$,-$.% /#$."$ 0 12''2-3% 4456 7"8$ 1"",%6 92:8-*, 1;-..6 -$, 9"&$


2/26

'

$)41% ,- +,"$%"$(

S1 WL$


3/26

''


4/26

'''

$)41% ,- )!$.,*#$#%(

-%&%*)1 +)(%(

? @":A; 12.8"#. - B-3& CD E2*F2$2- ,PAA [1G: GQF OQ%L .-%8&C- CD 9&, @H#-*& @J"*.%6 G$:D,GPP [1 U3ZZ1 F: F>K O91 T:1 FDDA; 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

!&$.*-' I-$> ") +&$C&*6 BD?D CD K2*%. G$.&*%.-.& I-$> ") +&$C&*6 BD?D,A@@ _1U1 @PQ O@KKQ; 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

!E49 5&*)"*3-$:& /"*%&%6 G$:D CD 1;$$&,EKF [1G: QPK OQ%L _1U1 AQK OFDDD; 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

R233&*3-$ CD SD@D I-$>6 BD?D,Q>G [1G: @@DP O@D%L


5/26

'0

S$2.&, @.-.&% CD ?F#2'-* ,A@A _1U1 AKG O@KKA; 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

1-'.&*% CD M:M-8&$,

EKA [1 U3ZZ1 F: GAD O91 T:1 FD@@; 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

T-:8-2*6 4.,D CD +*2FF%,KPA [1 U3ZZ1 EQ@ O91 T:1 @KKE; 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

($)$% +)(%(

?''&:" G$:D CD /-**; 0 7&-$&..& 1&2$


6/26

@

\0$#N C*.'( .**$Y$: )N -*.'+%'// "#$%% &'()$#*'+ .Y.'+7% 9$/$+:.+%7 23+%4+ 5 6'**'.(7

88- Og256h;, I4L+ 644:7, b'CL.#: 6N.%%, .+: b4)$#% i3.CM$+)477 OC4**$C%'0$*N g%L$ 256

9$/$+:.+%7h; '7 %'($B).##$: )N %L$ .ZZ*'C.)*$ 7%.%3%$7 4/ *'('%.%'4+7 .+:, (4#$40$#, '7 73ZZ4#%$:

)N +4%L'+Y (4#$ %L.+ 7Z$C3*.%'0$ .+: C4+C*374#N 7%.%$($+%71 &'()$#*'+`7 4ZZ47'%'4+ C.++4%

40$#C4($ %L$7$ /.%.* :$/$C%7 .+: :4$7 +4% #$)3%j4# $0$+ .::#$77 %L$ (.]4#'%N 4/j%L$

.#Y3($+%7 %L.% %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7 Z#$7$+%$: '+ %L$'# 4Z$+'+Y )#'$/1 T4#$40$#, L'7 #$a3$7% /4#

*$.0$ %4 $+Y.Y$ '+ :'7C40$#N .Y.'+7% %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7 '7 ).7$: 4+ +4%L'+Y (4#$ %L.+ . 7$#'$7

4/ LNZ$#)4*'C .CC37.%'4+7j#.+Y'+Y /#4( ($#$*N '(Z*.37')*$ %4 /.+%.7%'C.*j%L.% .#$ +4%

73ZZ4#%$: )N .+N X$**BZ*$.:$: /.C%3.* .**$Y.%'4+7 '+ L'7 ?@ABCD #E !CDB>HE )KKIG


7/26


8/26

G

%L.+ @Q (4+%L7 ./%$# R+4+N(437`7 L.CM .+: Z3)*'C.%'4+ 4/ %L$ 2"H.#N $(.'*7 .+: /'*$7jXL$+

g9$/$+:.+% 24Y$ .+: L'7 .774C'.%$7 '(Z*$($+%$: %L$ W$.( WL$('7 )*3$Z#'+%h OXL'CL '7

.ZZ.#$+%*N . #$/$#$+C$ %4 %L$ L.CM$: 2"H.#N $(.'*7 .+: /'*$7;1 -*1`7 "#1 Po>1 S+ L'7 9$C*.#.%'4+,

&'()$#*'+ 7%.%$7? gS )$Y.+ 73//$#'+Y L.#( /#4( %L$ W$.( WL$('7 )*3$Z#'+% :3#'+Y T.N FD@F,

XL$+ 9$/$+:.+%7 24Y$ .+: L'7 .774C'.%$7 *.3+CL$: %L$'# 4+*'+$ )3**N'+Y C.(Z.'Y+, q\0$#N)4:N

"*4Y R)43% "#$%% &'()$#*'+1`h G,D, \c1 @, &'()$#*'+ 9$C*1 m Q1 &'()$#*'+`7 7$*/B7$#0'+Y

.77$#%'4+ 4+*N /3#%L$# :44(7 L'7


9/26

Q

7Z$C'/'C.**N $cC*3:$: 9$/$+:.+%7 24Y$ .+: ='CM*$77 /#4( %L.% C*.'( '+ L'7 +1Q O91 T:1 @KKE;1

S+ .+N C.7$, &'()$#*'+`7


10/26

A

F1 RY.'+ Y4'+Y 43%7':$ %L$


11/26

P

)$/4#$ %L$ L4#7$n . oEK OFDDK;1

&'()$#*'+ C*$.#*N M+$X 4/ L'7 Z3#Z4#%$: '+]3#N /#4( %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7` .**$Y$:

C4+:3C% '+ [$)#3.#N FD@@, .7 L$ /4#%L#'YL%*N C4+C$:$71 -*1`7 "#1 >1 WL$


12/26

E

Og\a3'%.)*$ %4**'+Y L.7 *4+Y )$$+ C4+7':$#$: .+ $c%#.4#:'+.#N #$($:N '+ %L'7 C'#C3'%, .+: *'%'Y.+%7

/.C$ . C4+7':$#.)*$ )3#:$+ %4 :$(4+7%#.%$ %L.% '% .ZZ*'$71h;1

R7 %4 %L$ %.*$ 4/ %L$ .+4+N(437 XL'7%*$)*4X$#, %L$ /.C% %L.% %L$7$ .**$Y.%'4+7 X$#$ +4%

Z*$.:$: '+ L'7


13/26

>

k7%.%3%$ 4/ *'('%.%'4+7l1h G,D .% @D1 J+ '%7 /.C$, %L$ 7%.%$($+% .%%#')3%$: %4 T#1 b4*/$ OXL'CL %L

256 9$/$+:.+%7 :$+N X.7 7.':; (.M$7 +4 7$+7$1 G

=4%.)*N, &'()$#*'+ :4$7 +4% $cZ*.'+ XLN %L$ Z477')'*'%N 4/ $+%$#'+Y '+%4 . %4**'+Y

.Y#$$($+% g'/ %L$ C.7$ X.7 #$74*0$:h X43*: C4+7%'%3%$ g$c%#.4#:'+.#N C'#C3(7%.+C$7h %L.% (.:$

'% g'(Z477')*$h %4 /'*$ L'7


14/26

K

S+ .+N C.7$, &'()$#*'+ :': +4% .C% :'*'Y$+%*N '+ Z3#73'+Y L'7 C*.'(7 XL$+, .7 L$ C4+C$:$7,

L$ X.7 .X.#$ 4/ %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7` .**$Y$: '**$Y.* .C%'0'%'$7 4+ [$)#3.#N E, FD@@, N$% :':

+4%L'+Y /4# 40$# /43# N$.#71@&& G*L2$, QK> _1U1 .% KP Og6$ L.0$ Y$+$#.**N )$$+ (3CL *$77

/4#Y'0'+Y '+ #$C$'0'+Y *.%$ /'*'+Y7 XL$#$ %L$ C*.'(.+% /.'*$: %4 $c$#C'7$ :3$ :'*'Y$+C$ '+

Z#$7$#0'+Y L'7 *$Y.* #'YL%71h;n!E49 5&*)"*3-$:& /"*%&% , EKF [1G: .% QEE O/'+:'+Y Z*.'+%'//7 :':

+4% :'*'Y$+%*N Z3#73$ %L$'# #'YL%7 XL$+ %L$N X.'%$: N$.#7 ./%$# %L$'# C*.'( .CC#3$: %4 /'*$ C'0'*

bS, @@o@F1 WL$


15/26

@D

C*.'(71 ") +&$C&*6 BD?D, A@@ _1U1 @PQ, @>G O@KKQ;1 R7 $cZ*.'+$: )N %L$ %L.% +$'%L$# C'0'* bS


16/26

@@

Z3)*'7L$:, 4# :'7%#')3%$: %L$ W$.( WL$('7 Z'%CL (.%$#'.*7n #.%L$#, .7 &'()$#*'+ .:('%7, %L47$

(.%$#'.*7 X$#$ C#$.%$: )N W$.( WL$('7 .+: %L$+ L.CM$: .+: #$*$.7$: )N R+4+N(4371 =4# L.0$

%L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7 7%'Z3*.%$:j.7 :': %L$ Z3)*'7L$# '+ 92:& j%L.% %L$N '+%$+:$: 4# L.:

M+4X*$:Y$ %L.% %L$ W$.( WL$('7 Z'%CL (.%$#'.*7 X43*: )$ 37$: %4 %.#Y$% &'()$#*'+, 4# %L.% %L$

Z'%CL (.%$#'.*7 .C%3.**N :': .77'7% 9$/$+:.+%7 24Y$, ='CM*$77, .+: %L$'# .774C'.%$7 '+ %L$'# .**$Y$:

C4+:3C% .+: %L.% %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7 '+%$+:$: %L.% #$73*%1 92:& '7 %L37 XL4**N '##$*$0.+%1

K"#*.8 , $0$+ '/ &'()$#*'+ L.: Z#4Z$#*N Z*$.:$: . *$Y.**NBC4Y+'d.)*$ .':'+YB.+:B.)$%%'+Y

C*.'( 3+:$# T.#N*.+: 7%.%$ *.X, L$ .*74 :4$7 +4% .**$Y$ 73//'C'$+% /.C%7 %4 73ZZ4#% '%1 WL$

, @@E@ OT:1 o@F1 S+7%$.:, L$ .7M7 %L$


17/26

@F

C4+:3C% .**$Y$: '+ %L$ oEK OFDDK;1 WL$


18/26

@G

A: /AB@ ACL 3BI< -IAGL

&'()$#*'+ L.7 +4% .**$Y$: $'%L$# (.'* 4# X'#$ /#.3: X'%L %L$ 7Z$C'/'C'%N #$a3'#$: )N

[$:$#.* b3*$ 4/ K, FKA O91 T:1 FDDA; O'+%$#+.* a34%.%'4+ (.#M7 4('%%$:;1 &'()$#*'+ %L37

L.7 /.'*$: %4 .:$a3.%$*N Z*$.: bS


19/26

@Q

#$*.%'4+ %4 L'7 .**$Y$: '+04*0$($+% X'%L %L$ Y#.+: ]3#N '+0$7%'Y.%'4+ 4/ 94+.*: "*.+M$+7L'Z1

-*1`7 "#1 @Ao@P1 R% %L$ %L#$7L4*:, &'()$#*'+`7 .**$Y.%'4+7 /4# %L$7$ Z#$:'C.%$7 .#$ $+%'#$*N

'+C4+7'7%$+%n L$ 7'(3*%.+$437*N :$C*.#$7 %L.%, 3Z4+ :'7C40$#'+Y L$ X.7 )$'+Y g%.#Y$%$:h )N %L$

256 9$/$+:.+%7, L$ /$*% g'+%'(':.%$: .+: :$%$##$: /#4( C44Z$#.%'+Y X'%L %L$ ["S,h 2,D, \c1 @,

&'()$#*'+ 9$C*1 m Fn %&& -'%"


20/26

@A

L$ Z#40':$: 3+74*'C'%$: '+/4#(.%'4+ %4 %L$ ["S1 G,D WL.% '7 Z*.'+*N '+73//'C'$+% %4 7%.%$ . C*.'(

/4# 4)7%#3C%'4+, '+%'(':.%'4+, 4# #$%.*'.%'4+1 9/71` "#1 @Po@E1

T4#$ /3+:.($+%.**N, %L$ 1['+.**N, &'()$#*'+`7 .**$Y.%'4+7 4/ '+%'(':.%'4+ .+: #$%.*'.%'4+ (37% /.'* )$C.37$ L$

.**$Y$7 +4 .C% C4(('%%$: )N %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%71 2$ .**$Y$7 4+*N %L.% L$ ($% X'%L .+:

Z#40':$: '+/4#(.%'4+ %4 %L$ ["S, -*1`7 "#1, \c1 @, &'()$#*'+ 9$C*1 m @, .+: .0$#7 +4 Z*.37')*$

/.C%7 7L4X'+Y %L.% %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7 M+$X 4/ %L.% ($$%'+Y 4# %44M .+N .C%'4+ %4 Z#$0$+% '% 4

#$%.*'.%$ .Y.'+7% L'( /4# '%, %&& -'%" 9/71` "#1 @Eo@>1

K: -


21/26

@P

@>1 =4# :4$7 &'()$#*'+ (.M$ .+N%L'+Y (4#$ %L.+ . C4+C*374#N .**$Y.%'4+ %L.% %L$ 256

9$/$+:.+%7 M+$X .+N /3+:7 X$#$ :$#'0$: /#4( 3+*.X/3* .C%'0'%N1 \.CL 4/ %L$7$ :$/'C'$+C'$7 '7

'+:$Z$+:$+%*N /.%.* %4 L'7 (4+$N *.3+:$#'+Y Z#$:'C.%$1 9/71` "#1 @KoFD1

&'()$#*'+ .*74 %#'$7 %4 .**$Y$ . +$X (4+$N *.3+:$#'+Y Z#$:'C.%$ .C% 3+:$# @> _1U1

_1U1


22/26


23/26

@>

#W: $;< +=>?@ABCD -AB@E D= )L


24/26

@K

S1" 5 SS, %#J*-1 RCC4#:'+Y*N, +4+$ 4/ 9$/$+:.+% 24Y$`7 .**$Y$: C4+:3C% C.+ )$ '(Z3%$: %4 %L$

256 9$/$+:.+%71 9/71` "#1 GD1

): #CNAEB=C =M 2IBNAKF

WL$


25/26

FD

.**4X :'7C40$#N, .+: %L37 C4+C$:$7 %L.% g.($+:($+% 4/ %L'7 C4(Z*.'+% X43*: )$ /3%'*$1h G,D .%

GPDn %&& -'%" B-.A' I'"FF&*%, FD@A 68 @FQFEPG, .% pFDn 9/71` "#1 G@ +1@E1

W##: +=CK@GEB=C

[4# %L$ #$.74+7 7$% /4#%L .)40$, %L$ 256 9$/$+:.+%7 #$a3$7% %L.% %L$


26/26

+%*$#-#+)$% ,- (%*W#+%

S 2\b\"V