Early dioxin exposure and later health effects
Gavin W. ten Tusscher, M.D., Ph.D., paediatrician
Department of Paediatrics and Neonatology
Westfriesgasthuis, Hoorn, Netherlands
Proof of evidence: Ringaskiddy-Indaver Pleanala Hearing
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 2
Overview
– Introduction
– Background exposures
– Accidents
– Final thoughts
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 3
Why dioxins?
– Numerous chemicals potentially harmful, however …
– Dioxins are well studied
– Much data available on health effects
– Personal area of experience
– Dioxins are almost exclusively waste-products
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 4
What are Dioxins and PCBs?
1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9 O
O
PCDD
1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9 O
PCDF
6 5
4
3 2 2’ 3’
4’
5’ 6’
PCB
o m
p
m o o m
p
m o
PCB
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 5
Dioxins
– Are of the most toxic substances known
– Colourless crystals or solids in pure form
– Not intentionally produced except for small quantities for research
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 6
Why a healthhazard?
– Extremely difficult to break down (metabolise), thus accumulating, long half-life
– Stored in fat (adipose) tissue
– Exposure via placenta and breast milk
– Europe has high background exposure levels
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 7
What is background exposure?
– Concentrations we are exposed to in our daily lives
– WHO recommendations as a result of extreme toxicity and potential for enormous health effects
– EU intake limit currently: 14 ng/kg BW/week
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 8
Accidents
– Yusho, Japan, 1968
– Yucheng, Taiwan, 1978
– Seveso, Italy, 1976
– Agent Orange, Vietnam War
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 9
Vietnam
– Agent Orange was dioxin contaminated defoliant used on large scale in South East Asia during Vietnam War
– Data is beginning to emerge of large scale • birth defects• illnesses• Cancers
– These effects are also seen in second and even third generations!
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 10
Birth Defects
– Increase in hypospadias, phimosis, cryptorchidism, SGA, spontaneous abortions in polluted part of Russia
Revich et al. Gig Sanit 2002; (1): 8-13
– Increased miscarriages and premature birth; 60% congenital malformations after Agent Orange
Le et al. Reprod Health Matters 2001; 9(18): 156-64
– Increase in orofacial clefts
ten Tusscher et al. Chemosphere 2000; 40: 1263-70
– Other birth defects?
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 11
Zeeburg
– 1960s large scale incinerations of various chemicals in largely unknown quantities in open air
– Seven-fold increase in cleft lips/palates
N on-syndrom al orofacial clefts: trend of incidence for 1960 -1969
0
2
4
6
8
1 9 6 0 1 9 6 1 1 9 6 2 1 9 6 3 1 9 6 4 1 9 6 5 1 9 6 6 1 9 6 7 1 9 6 8 1 9 6 9
Zeebu rg
W ilhe lm ina
per 1000 births (live + stillborn)
year
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 12
Miscarriages,prematurity
Increased miscarriages and premature birth; 60% congenital malformations after Agent Orange
Le et al. Reprod Health Matters 2001; 9(18): 156-64
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 13
Infant deaths
Increase in infant deaths and infant deaths with congenital disorders near solid waste incinerator
Tango et al. J Epidemiol. 2004 May; 14(3): 83-93
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 14
Infancy and later childhood
Disruption immune systemPluim et al. Acta Paediatr 1994; 83(6): 583-7
Weisglas-Kuperus et al. Pediatric Res 1995; 38(3): 404-10Nagayama et al. Chemosphere 1998; 37(9-12): 1781-7
ten Tusscher et al. 2003; 111(12): 1519-23
Reduced platelet counts (necessary for coagulation), persistent effect
Pluim et al. Acta Paediatr 1994; 83(6): 583-7ten Tusscher et al. 2003; 111(12): 1519-23
Chickenpox at a younger ageMore middle-ear infectionsLess asthma
Weisglas-Kuperus et al. Environ Health Perspect 2000; 108(12): 1203-7
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 15
Thyroid, liver
Disregulation of thyroid function
Pluim et al. Lancet 1992; 339: 1303, Environ Health Perspect 1993; 101(6): 504-8Koopman-Esseboom et al. Pediatr Res 1994; 36(4): 468-73
Liver damage
Pluim et al. Acta Paediatr 1994; 83(6): 583-7
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 16
Pulmonary problems
– Decreasing lung function with increasing prenatal exposure (p=0.045)
– Decreasing lung function with increasing postnatal exposure (p=0.0002)
– Increase in asthmatic complaints with increasing exposure (n=4)
– ten Tusscher et al. Acta Paediatr 2001; 90(11): 1292-8
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 17
Italy
– Lichen very sensitive to SO2 concentrations
– SO2 good indicator of air pollution
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 18
Lichen biodiversity determined in 662 places in Northern Italy (2 425 samples)
Lung cancer mortality 1981-1988
Cislaghi C & Nimis PL. Nature 1997; 387:463-4
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 19
Biodiversity and lung cancer r = 0.95, P < 0.001
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 20
Psychology, neurology
Precocious neuromotor developmentIlsen et al. Chemosphere 1996; 33(7): 1317-26
Increase in social problems & aggression in two environments (home and school) with dioxins
ten Tusscher et al. Thesis 2002
In boys less masculine play, in girls more masculine play, with increasing prenatal PCBs
Vreugdenhil et al. Env Health Perspect 2002; 110(10): A593-8
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 21
Brain Development– Ultra modern and
sensitive testing (MEG)
– Retardation in brain development of on average 3½ y
– Possible relation with behavioural problems
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 22
Teeth
More dental defects (caries and enamel)Alaluusua et al. Eur J Oral Sci 1996; 104(5-6): 493-7
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 23
Puberty, fertility
Retardation in initiation breast developmentLeijs et al. Chemosphere 2008; 73(6): 999-1004
Delay in genital and breast development in boys and girls with dioxins
Den Hond et al. Health Perspect 2002; 110: 771-6
Possibly increase in endometriosis with dioxinsDe Felip et al. Toxicol Lett 2004: 150(2): 203-9
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 24
Malignancy
Increased incidence of non-Hodgkin lymphoma (RR 2.3) in vicinity of municipal solid waste incinerator
Floret et al. Epidemiology 2003; 14(4): 392-8
Adolescent colorectal cancer and dioxin?Pratt et al. Lancet 1987; 2(8562): 803
Increased risk of sarcoma (RR 3.3) in vicinity of municipal solid waste incineratorsZambon et al. Environ Health 2007; 6: 19
Childhood cancer/leukaemia births are associated with high atmospheric emissions from combustion processes
Knox EG. Childhood cancers and atmospheric carcinogens. J Epidemiol Community Health 2005; 59: 101-5
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 25
Summarising
• Birth defects
• Hormone disruption
• Decreased lung function
• Reduced production blood platelets
• Immunity interference
• Increased cancer risk
• Influence on the thyroid
• Liver damage
• Dental problems
• Behavioural problems
• Retardation sexual development
• Retardation in brain development
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 26
Accidents
– Often argued that risk of accident in incineration plant is small
– The last years have shown numerous accidents at waste incinerators and by-product storage facilities, resulting in high local exposures
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 27
Quick media search1993 Explosion in vinyl chloride monomer works
1994 Incinerator in Duiven exceeds dioxin emission norm
1995 explosion in incinerator for non-industrial wastes
1996 Fire in waste incinerator in Holland, high dioxin emissions
1997 Incinerator in Rotterdam exceeds dioxin emission norm
1999 Increased incidence of serious diseases, incinerator link
2001 Toxic cloud emission from incinerator
2002 Elbe floods storage depot for dioxins (by-products of incinerations)
2002 Incinerator explosion Japan, 10 injured
2004 Explosion at hazardous waste incinerator, Argentina
2004 Dioxin emissions following faulty filters
2005 Fire at hazardous waste incineration, US, requiring evacuation 1,500 people
2007 Explosion in incinerator, US
2008 Toxic waste catches fire, India
2009 Radiation-tainted waste leaks during truck transport
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 28
Final thoughts
Is the Ringaskiddy area a coastal area at risk for flooding?
According to the World Health Organisation this would be an important reason to exclude the proposed site. Should flooding occur, the risk for human health effects would increase dramatically
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 29
Final thoughts
How much local experience is there in monitoring environmentally related health effects in children?
Probably limited, meaning that the population is extra at risk
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 30
Final thoughts
What biomonitoring needs to be performed in order to have a complete picture of possible environmental exposure?
Sampling of a number of index (key) substances is most probably not sufficient. All possible chemical exposures and their interactions upon each other first need to be assessed in order to have a baseline for comparison during biomonitoring
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 31
Final thoughts
What outcomes of biomonitoring and health monitoring will be considered relevant?
Why not others?
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 32
Final thoughts
What would Indaver and governmental institutions consider “acceptable” mortality and morbidity figures?
How many environmentally-related deaths and illnesses would be considered the threshold for cessation of activities?
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 33
Final thoughts
With whom does the financial responsibility for (possible) environmentally-related disease lie?
Bearing in mind the generally very long period of time between exposure and negative health effects, would Indaver be compelled to set aside monies in a fund for future victims?
Cork, 12-05-2009 Gavin W. ten Tusscher 34
Concluding
– Our children are already being exposed to concentrations that are too high – don’t increase it further!
– Any increase in this exposure, for instance in the case of an accident, only increases the damage done to them
– Dioxins and PCBs (POPs) remain in our bodies for many years
– It is not wise to risk the health and development of our children
Top Related