7/29/2019 Decision-Making in project management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/decision-making-in-project-management 1/5
Paper and Poster presented at:EnginSoft International Conference, Verona, Italy, 20-21 Oct. 2011.
ENGINSOFT Newsletter Year 8, No 4, Winter 2011.
1
Reconsidering the Multiple Criteria
Decision Making Problems of Construction
Workers; Using Grapheur
A.Mosavi1, M.Azodinia2, Kasun N. Hewage1, Abbas S. Milani1, M.Yeheyis1,
1University of British Columbia – Okanagan, School of Engineering, 3333 University Way, Kelowna, BCV1V1V7, Canada.
2University of Debrecen, Faculty of IT, 4033 Debrecen, Hungary.
Summary
We are dealing with a series multiple criteria decision making problems and analysis related to Canadian
construction projects including waste management, productivity improvement, human and IT factors, emergy
based lifecycle, and process optimization.
The urgent increasing of using IT in construction projects has been one way to improve the process of solving
our problems [2]. The construction project managers have to make tough decisions. They are considering
different tools of IT and would like to invest on getting better data analysis tools for enhancing their decisions.
However making critical decisions for the complicated and multiple criteria problems of construction projects inwhich huge amount of data are involved is not a simple task to do. As the data-sets of our problems are often
huge they can not easily be handled with the traditional means of data analysis. In order to better manage thedata collected and make the most of our data-sets we utilized the advanced interactive visualization tools
provided by Grapheur and reconsidered our problems. Here the idea for solving the multiple criteria decision
making problems is to visually model and clarify the whole dimension of problems. The effectiveness and
performance of the interactive visualizations, made by Grapheur, are evaluated along with a number of our
study cases related to construction workers. As the main result, the 7D plots and the option of sweeping throughdata have been found very useful for our applications. The achieved hidden information through Grapheur’s
visualization tools would enhance our further decisions.
Keywords
Building construction workers, IT usage in construction projects, reactive business intelligence, reactive search,
Grapheur, multi-objective optimization, multiple criteria decision making, interactive visualization, multi-
dimensional plots, 7D graphs, sweeping through data
Introduction to Grapheur
Grapheur is a data mining, modeling and interactive visualization package implementing the Reactive Business
Intelligence approach [3] which connects the user to the software through automated and intelligent self-tuning
methods on the basis of visualization. The principles of Grapheur were originated from researches on Reactive
Search Optimization [4]. The user friendly and innovative interface of provided visualization, via an interactive
multi-objective optimization, facilitates the process of making tough decisions. Grapheur is a handy and simple
tool in which frees the mind from software complications and concentrates on mining the useful information indata. It puts the user in an interactive loop, rapidly reacting to first results and visualizations to direct the
subsequent efforts, in order to suit the needs and preferences of the decision maker.
7/29/2019 Decision-Making in project management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/decision-making-in-project-management 2/5
Paper and Poster presented at:EnginSoft International Conference, Verona, Italy, 20-21 Oct. 2011.
ENGINSOFT Newsletter Year 8, No 4, Winter 2011.
2
The Reactive Search is utilized within Grapheur to integrate some machine learning techniques into search
heuristics for the visualization complex optimization problems and interactive decision making accordingly. InReactive Search for self-adaptation in an autonomic manner, we benefit from the past history of the search and
the knowledge accumulated while moving in the configuration space [4].
Grapheur sample visualizations
In one of the building construction projects a number of workers were surveyed with questionnaires and
observations [1]. Each row of our data-set is a construction worker with the corresponding columns,characterized by a series of parameters which are the ID and photo of each person, work time, looking for materials, looking for tools, specialization, moving , instruction, idleness and the other characteristics of the
construction workers. The primary result of our survey clearly notes the urgent need for training programs to
improve workers’ skill levels. However the decision-making on how and with what rate the training programs
should be arranged is not a simple task and it has to be considered from different perspectives and criteria. In
order to learn how the training programs would affect team efficiencies, team spirit , and team perceptions of supervision, Grapheur [5], the flexible and powerful Business Intelligence and Interactive Visualization [3] is
utilized. With the aid of provided data mining and visualization some useful and hidden information are
achieved which would enhance the process of solving the multiple criteria decision making problems of our case. After clarifying the dimension of the problem and finding out the relation between involved parameters
and objectives, the effective decisions are easier made.
1. Supporting the decisions on workers’ skills
Here the idea for solving the multiple criteria decision making problems is to visually and effectively model the
problems and clarify the whole dimension of them. For instance we are trying to find out with which rate and
how, the workers’ level of skills should grow in order to maintain their performance with regard to team perceptions of supervision. In order to study a part of this problem, we are considering the similarity map and
the parallel filters for optimizing the idleness characteristic of the workers. The related multidimensional plot
of the networks is created based on the collected data from the workers. The color code represents the
specialization of the workers and the size of the bubbles is proportional to the idleness of workers. In our similarity map of the graphical visualization, the gray level of the edges and the generated clusters provide
valuable information for the decision maker. In the following figure and with the provided video the capability
of the similarity map for an effective clustering of the workers into meaningful clusters is illustrated (figure 1
right side).
The parallel filters (Figure 1 left side) are other useful tools for optimization. The usefulness of parallel filters in
reducing the complexity from the process of decision making is evaluated. We start from the matrix of work time in a multidimensional space while aiming at filtering particular workers and examining their performance
within a particular group e.g. those who have had maximum idleness characteristic.
Figure 1: Parallel filter (left side) and similarity map (right side)
7/29/2019 Decision-Making in project management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/decision-making-in-project-management 3/5
Paper and Poster presented at:EnginSoft International Conference, Verona, Italy, 20-21 Oct. 2011.
ENGINSOFT Newsletter Year 8, No 4, Winter 2011.
3
2. Displaying the precise condition of each construction worker
For the complete visualization of the condition of each construction worker over all parameters, the colored
bubble chart is selected. In the following figure (left side), the colored bubble chart shows work time versus specialization for each worker. The color code and the size of the bubbles represent looking for material characteristic and the idleness status of the workers respectively. Additionally the shape of the bubbles displays
the looking for tools characteristic of the workers.
In this graph we have found clustering tool very useful for a deep understanding of the different groups of workers. In this case workers could be grouped according to the given characteristics. After grouping, one
prototype case for each cluster is visualized which is indeed a very effective way of compressing the
information and concentrating on a relevant subset of possibilities.
Figure 2: Bubble chart (left side) and sweeping through data in the bubble chart (right side)
3. Sweeping though different characteristics of workers; tracking and
examining the problem with the aid of animated graphs
In the previous graph (Figure 2 left side) the relations between work time, specialization, idleness status, looking for materials, and looking for tools characteristics of the construction workers were visualized. Moreover
sweeping though data and studying the generated animations on sweeping is an effective tool for further
visualization along with advancing a particular objective. For instance in our next visualization experience the
previous graph is reconsidered by sweeping though looking material , Idleness and skill level as the time
advances (illustrated in Figure 2 right side).
4. Analyzing a particular cluster of workers and their characteristics;
sweeping through skill level and team perception of supervision
In a new created bubble graph, figure 3 right side, the idleness and specialization characteristic of a cluster of
four workers is associated with the size and the color of the bubbles relatively. Here by sweeping through team perception of supervision and the level of specialization of field workers in our building construction project, theachieved information from a limited cluster of workers can clarify the problem with more details in different
scenarios. For instance when the skill level of the workers and the team perception of supervision are monthly
increased relatively by the rate of 10% and 5% within a year, the idleness characteristic is smoothly monitored.
We can also play the resulted animation in smooth mode and track the past values (they appear in a lighter tone
in the background of the plot), in order to focus on the changes which occur according to morning and afternoonworking shifts.
7/29/2019 Decision-Making in project management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/decision-making-in-project-management 4/5
Paper and Poster presented at:EnginSoft International Conference, Verona, Italy, 20-21 Oct. 2011.
ENGINSOFT Newsletter Year 8, No 4, Winter 2011.
4
Figure 3: 7D plot of data (left side) and sweeping through data (right side)
5. Providing a reliable way to find the most productive workers With the aid of a 7D plot the characteristics associated with the productivity come to our consideration within a
single graph. In our case the size, the color and the shape of the bubbles relatively displays the specialization,
the moving , and the following the instructions characteristic of the workers. Moreover the blinking feature
displays the idleness characteristic of the workers who have been idle less than 100 hours (Figure 3 left side).
Discussion and ConclusionsAlong with our study cases the aspects of data mining, modeling, and visualization the data related to
construction workers utilizing Grapheur are considered and briefly presented in this short article. We made the
most of IT applications via newly implemented data mining and visualization tools of Grapheur. Consideringthe ability of Grapheur, the interesting patterns are automatically extracted from our raw data-set via data
mining tools. Additionally the advanced visual analytical interfaces are involved to support the decision maker
interactively. With the further feature of Grapheur such as parallel filters and clustering tasks, the managers cansolve multi-objective optimization problems as it amends previous approaches. Furthermore the animations of
sweeping through data and advanced visualizations including 7D plots accomplish managers and enable them to
screen the data at their consulting room making decision interactively.
In one of our study cases Grapheur provided a widespread view on how the throughput of the whole project
would be affected by the increasing workers’ specialization and supervision. We swept through different
characteristic of workers in order to examine the whole dimensions of the problem. For instance, we assumed
that the problem of having high level of idleness within the workers might be solved by increasing the
supervision and team perception of supervision. For this reason workers are carefully clustered and analyzedwith regard to their level of
idlenessand
supervision. In this particular case, Grapheur has been a facile tool in
modeling the problem with the aid of a 7D plot . Once a 7D plot is created the problem could be visually
analyzed from seven different perspectives simultaneously. In other words a convenient way of concentrating
on our objectives and further decision making is provided by simply observing the size, the color, the shape, andthe blinking of the bubbles. Moreover utilizing further visualization options such as similarity maps, parallel
filters, and clustering would support making a confident decision.
For our future studies aiming at making easier and faster decisions we will reconsider our problems this time
with the aid of a developed issue of Grapheur called LIONsolver [8], Learning, and Intelligent OptimizatioNwhich is capable of learning from human feedback and previous attempts while benefiting from the Grapheur
visualization tools.
7/29/2019 Decision-Making in project management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/decision-making-in-project-management 5/5
Paper and Poster presented at:EnginSoft International Conference, Verona, Italy, 20-21 Oct. 2011.
ENGINSOFT Newsletter Year 8, No 4, Winter 2011.
5
References
[ 1]
Hewage K.N., Gannoruwa A., Ruwanpura J.Y. (2011), Current Status of Factors Leading to TeamPerformance of On-Site Construction Professionals in Alberta Building Construction Projects, Canadian
Journal of Civil Engineering.
[ 2] Hewage K.N., Ruwanpura J.Y., Jergeas G.F. (2009). IT Usage in Alberta’s Building Construction
Projects: Current Status and Challenges, Journal of Automation in Construction.
[ 3] Roberto Battiti and Mauro Brunato, Reactive Business Intelligence. From Data to Models to Insight,
Reactive Search Srl, Italy, February 2011.
[ 4] Battiti, Roberto; Mauro Brunato; Franco Mascia (2008). Reactive Search and Intelligent Optimization.
Springer Verlag.
[ 5] Battiti, Roberto; Mauro Brunato (2010). "Grapheur: A Software Architecture for Reactive and
Interactive Optimization, Proceedings Learning and Intelligent OptimizatioN LION 4, 2010, Venice, Italy.
[ 6] Battiti, Roberto; Andrea Passerini (2010). "Brain-Computer Evolutionary Multi-ObjectiveOptimization (BC-EMO): a genetic algorithm adapting to the decision maker." (PDF). IEEE Transactions on
Evolutionary Computation.
[ 7] http://www.LIONsolver.com/
Top Related