1
Dealing with Difficult HR Issues
2
Employee Harassment IssuesPresenter: Joe Hunder
PartnerLabour and Employment
3
Introduction
• Workplace and sexual harassment is unwanted and offensive behaviour. Both are unlawful.
• Employers are under a duty to prevent workplace and sexual harassment and to respond appropriately.
• Practical and legal consequences.
4
Recognizing Harassment
A. What is “Workplace Harassment”?• Unwelcome conduct that is offensive in nature.• Elements of unwelcome conduct• Characteristics of “offensive in nature”
• Could the behaviour reasonably offend, humiliate or intimidate the person to whom it is directed?
• Examples
5
Recognizing Harassment
B. Sexual Harassment• What is it?• Key Characteristics• Examples
6
Avoiding Harassment – Guidelines for Prevention• “R.A.P.” Test
• “Loved One” Test
• “Essential to Getting the Job Done” Test
7
Preventing and Responding to Workplace Harassment – Employer Duties
A. Employer duties:• What they are?• A policy is the cornerstone of prevention and control of workplace harassment.
8
Preventing and Responding to Workplace Harassment – Employer Duties
B. Harassment Policies:• Contents• Implementation and Enforcement
• Provide copies
• Ensure consistent application and adherence
9
Absenteeism and the Duty to AccommodatePresenter: Adrian Elmslie
Partner
Labour and Employment
10
Step IIdentifying the problem and its cause
11
Making sure the correct information is collected• Be clear about whose responsibility it is to keep track of or report employee absences.
• Maintain written records.
• Institute a call in policy for all unscheduled absences.
• Make sure you find out why the employee is absent from work.
• Use the Information
12
Step II
Identifying Types of Absenteeism
13
Types of Absenteeism
Generally there are two categories of absenteeism:
a) culpable absenteeism; and
b) innocent absenteeism
i) caused by transient ailments
ii) caused by a disability
14
Culpable Absenteeism
Absences within the employee’s control and for which there is no justifiable or reasonable excuse.
Examples:
• sleeping in
• failure to arrange transportation
• lateness or inability to work due to physical or mental conditions within the employee’s control
• absences that are not supported by medical verification where requested or required
15
Innocent Absenteeism – Disability or Transient Ailment?Absences that are beyond the employee’s control.
• Is the condition permanent or ongoing? (A temporary condition is not a disability unless it recurs as part of a medical condition).
• Is the condition so serious that it restricts life’s important functions?
• Is the condition common to the broader public? (e.g. the common cold, no matter how severe, is not a disability).
16
Step III
Managing Absenteeism
17
Culpable Absenteeism• Dealt with the same way as other types of misconduct.
• Best way to ensure consistency and to avoid problems is to have a written attendance policy.
• Attendance policy should include the following elements:
– Statement of Attendance Expectations
– Reporting Procedure
– Medical Notes
– Disciplinary Measures
18
Managing Innocent Absenteeism
Transient Ailments
• Focus on verifying that the reason for the absence is legitimateand assisting or encouraging the employee to correct the cause through counselling or other means.
19
Managing Innocent Absenteeism
Disabilities
• Duty not to discriminate under s.7 of the Human Rights Act
• Duty to accommodate disabilities
• Must accommodate to the point of “undue hardship”
• Employees must cooperate in the accommodation process
20
The Accommodation Process
1) Gather Information
2) Maintain Written Records Regarding the Accommodation Process
3) Investigate All Options and Consult with Relevant Parties
4) Implement
21
Obligations of the Departing EmployeePresenter: Cristina Wendel
Associate
Labour and Employment
22
Obligations of Departing Employees
• Employee obligations at law
• Contractual obligations
• Remedies
23
What obligations does a departing employee owe to the employer?• Obligations arise from 3 basic sources
1) Common law duties2) Fiduciary duties3) Contractual duties
24
Common Law Obligations
• Owed by all employees
• Part of every employment contract
25
What are the common law obligations?
• Duty of good faith and fidelity
• Duty to give reasonable notice of termination of employment
26
Duty of good faith and fidelity – what does it include? • Continuing obligations after employment has ended
– Duty not to misappropriate confidential information
27
Duty of good faith and fidelity – what does it not include?• Generally does not prohibit solicitation of clients or employeesafter employment has ended
• Generally does not prohibit competition– Exceptions:
• While employed, cannot take preparatory steps to set up the competing business during working hours or on the employer’s premises
• Cannot use confidential or proprietary information belonging to the former employer when competing
28
Duty to give reasonable notice of termination of employment• An employee is required to give its employer reasonable notice of his or her intention to resign
• The employee is prohibited from competing with the employer during this period
• Confirmed in the 2007 ABQB decision in Torcana Valve Services Inc. v Anderson
29
How much notice is required?• The period of notice required should correlate to the amount of time required by the employer to replace and train a new employee
• Factors
30
Fiduciary Duties
• Who is a fiduciary?
• What additional obligations are owed by fiduciaries?
• How long are those duties owed to the former employer?
31
Fiduciary Duties – who is bound?
• Variety of tests set out in the case law
• The determination is fact specific
• Must look at the employee’s actual powers and responsibilities – job titles are not determinative
• Usually there are 3 general characteristics to a fiduciary relationship:
– The employee has the scope for the exercise of discretion or power– The employee can unilaterally exercise that discretion or power to
affect the employer– The employer is vulnerable
• “Key” or higher level employees
32
Fiduciary duties – what are the additional obligations?• Cannot take a maturing business opportunity from the employer either during or after the term of employment
• Competition with the former employer after the term of employment in and of itself is not automatically a breach
– BUT the right to compete is qualified ‐ the employee cannot actively solicit the former employer’s clients for a reasonable period of time.
33
How long are the fiduciary duties owed?
• Fact specific
• Similar factors as for reasonable notice of termination
34
Contractual Duties
• Confidentiality agreements
• Restrictive Covenants– Non‐solicitation– Non‐competition
35
Confidentiality Agreements
• Useful to define and clarify what is considered confidential or proprietary information and clearly impose the restrictions on the use of that information
36
Restrictive Covenants
• Key Case – Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., 2009 SCC
– Recognized the tension between the freedom to contract and the public policy on restraint of trade• Presumption that restrictive covenants will generally be unenforceable as being in restraint of trade
• Exception – where the restrictive covenant is reasonable, it will be upheld
– Confirmed the need for increased scrutiny for covenants arising in employment contracts as opposed to the sale of a business
37
What constitutes a reasonable restrictive covenant• Depends on the particular facts and circumstances
• Basic factors for reasonableness:– Must protect a legitimate proprietary interest– Must be reasonable in terms of:
• Time
• Geographic area
• Nature of activities prohibited
– Terms must be clear, certain and not ambiguous– Must be reasonable with respect to the public interest
38
Drafting Restrictive Covenants
• Notional severance
• Courts will not rewrite ambiguous clauses to make them enforceable
– Ambiguous clauses are considered unreasonable– Clauses with descending restrictions will not be enforced
• “Blue line” or “blue pencil” severance– an offending part of a clause may be removed where that part is trivial
and not part of the main substance
39
Remedies
• Two main remedies available– Damages– Injunction
40
Damages
• Intended to put the former employer back in the position it would have been in had the breach not occurred
• Where the employee has competed in breach of his or her duties, the former employer has a choice for the measure of damages:
– its lost profits; or – the profits gained by the former employee and the competing business
41
Injunction
• Interlocutory – i.e. prior to trial
• To restrain the former employee from continuing the breach
• 3 part test:– Prima facie case – Irreparable harm – Balance of convenience favours the employer
42
Conclusion
• Range of duties owed by departing employees
• Remedies are damages and/or an injunction
• Cases are generally very fact specific
43
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
Presenter: Colleen Verville
Partner
Labour and Employment
44
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
‐ Who does the Canada Labour Codeapply to?
‐ Who may file a Canada Labour Code complaint?
‐ What is the nature of a wrongful dismissal claim?
‐ Who can file a wrongful dismissal Statement of Claim in Alberta?
45
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
‐ What is the cost to file an unjust dismissal complaint?
‐ What is the cost for filing a Statement of Claim?
46
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
‐ What is the time limitation for filing an unjust dismissal complaint?
‐ What is the time limitation for filing a wrongful dismissal Statement of Claim?
47
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
‐ What is the process to file an unjust dismissal complaint?
‐ What is the process in the Courts?
48
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
‐ What are the powers of an adjudicator?
‐ What are the powers of the Courts?
49
Canada Labour Code Part III: Unjust Dismissal Complaints v. A Statement of Claim filed in the Courts
‐ Can the adjudicator’s decision be appealed?
‐ Can the Court’s decision be appealed?
50
How Unions Acquire the Legal Right to Represent Alberta Employees and Adopting a Union Free PhilosophyPresenter: Fausto Franceschi
Partner
Labour and Employment
51
Certification Application
• Alberta’s Labour Relations Code applies• To be certified, a union must convince the Board that
– The applicant is a trade union– There is no legal impediment to the certification application– Groups of workers (bargaining unit) the union wishes to represent is
appropriate for collective bargaining– 40% of the employees in the bargaining unit applied for support the
union’s application
• Majority of the employees (more than 50%) who vote in a secret ballot representation vote have selected union representation
• Process happens quickly (usually 7 – 10 days from the date of application to vote)
52
A Typical Union Organizing Campaign• Employees may invite the union to organize their workplace or the union may proceed without an invitation
• A union gauges depth of employee support• A union attempts to develop a cast of “inside organizers”• Obtaining employee support – union card or petition• What unions sell. What workers buy.
– Higher wages– Better benefits, including pensions– Job security– Seniority rights– Protection from an employer’s arbitrary actions (grievances)– A bigger say in the workplace– A safer workplace– “Insurance”
53
A Typical Union Organizing Campaign
• Some campaigns are covert operations and some are publicly announced
• Signs of a covert operation– Odd employee behaviour
• Talkative employees are suddenly silent
• Employees huddling when not required to do so by their jobs
• Avoidance of supervisors
– Appearance of union literature • Pamphlets, stickers
• Union success rate– Alberta: Unions win 81% of certification applications that go to a vote
(131/162 between April 1, 2009 and October 28, 2010)
54
Employer Responses: Strategy
• Unfair Labour Practices– What are they? – Legal and Practical Consequences
• Role of supervisors (inside and outside of the campaign)
• Intensity of Response – depends on each situation
• Communication plan (lawful) is essential
55
Union Free Philosophy
• Have a union free philosophy (be a “pro‐employee” organization)
• Employees are unlikely to want third party union representation if they are working for you and feel valued
– Fair wages and benefits– Invite employee feedback– Opinion polls– Open door policy (as opposed to a false open door policy)– Listen to employee concerns– Have an issue free workplace philosophy– Strive for high morale (get rid of jerks)– Leadership needs to have a presence with employees– Being union free is a process, therefore devote time to it – it will make you a
better company, as well as keeping you union free
Questions?
Thank you for Joining Us
Joe Hunder 780.423.7354 e: joe.hunder@fmc‐law.comAdrian Elmslie 780.423.7364 e: adrian.elmslie@fmc‐law.comCristina Wendel 780.423.7353 e: cristina.wendel@fmc‐law.comFausto Franceschi 780.423.7348 e: fausto.franceschi@fmc‐law.comColleen Verville 780.423.7103 e: colleen.verville@fmc‐law.com
The preceding presentation contains examples of the kinds of issues companies dealing with difficult HR issues could face. If you are faced with one of these issues, please retain professional assistance as each situation is unique.
Top Related