Stock template
INV theme
Business modelProduct
Segment breakup
Key Parameters
Reasons to buy
Reasons not to BUY
Prior probability
Industry history
Company history
What all went WRONG IN INUDSTRY
What can kill the idea
Ecosystem
Sh patternPromoters XX
FIIs & DIs
Valuation
AVG [2006]
Current [TTM]
PB
EV/EBITA
Owner Earnings ~ = EBITA
EBITA excluding
Profitability
BS analysis
Working capitalSee CF Analysis
DebtD/E =
leverage = Business model
Why Re-ratingSee key parameters
Why Not something else
% allocation
When to sell
Portfolio aggregation risk
Mental models
Guidance
Peers
Industry
History
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Segment breakup
Revenue mixProduct wise [FY14]
Other
EBITA mix
Capital employed
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Business model
Quality
Pricing power
Competitive advantageScale, capacity
Access to skilled labour
Capital intensive ?
Bullet proof capital structure?
Debt/EBITA
Debt/4yr avg OCF
Debt/4yr avg FCF
Debt repayment schedule
(EBITA+ interest )/Interest
Porter 5 forces
Entry Barriers
Brand power
Economies of scale
Easy/difficult for competitor to replicate
Does it make life difficult for competitors?
Environmental issues
Intensity of competition among existing players.
Threat of substitutes
Bargaining power of customers
Bargaining power of suppliers
Product level economics
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Product [Business]
Growth
Consistency
LT
Durablility
Predictability
No material growth Equities = Bonds
Very HIGH growth NOT required
Certainty matters MORE over HIGHER GROWTH
ROCE
Capex + Working capital
Lower the better
Avoid businesses with Both HIGHCapex
Working capital
Strong entry barriers
High RoCE
Re-investment potential
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Key Parameters
Growth Scale of opportunity
Valuation
EV/EBITA [TTM]
Core EBITA FY14
PB
Ready to hold for 5-10 YRSYes
50% decline in price after 3 yrs
EBITA
Implied EV
Current EV
Key Risks
Price Risk
Business Risk
Mgt Risk
What will drive share price
Margin expansion
PE expansion/Contraction
Revenue growth
Market perception
ContrarianValueEdge.com
ContrarianValueEdge.com
People
How to judge mgt
Objective
Capital Allocation Incl FA + Working capital
Capital distribution [Div]High Payout ratio, ROCE & Growth
High quality business
Good ROE over a PERIOD OF TIME
Subjective INTERVIEW
Vision
Size of opportunity
Threat
Mgt
Integrity
Probably OO 2 type operator
Basant rule: Innocent till proven guilty
Red flags
Competency Operating skills
Vision
Execution
Compensation
Good business High probability of good mgt
Remuneration
Bad quality business High probability of bad mgt.
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Strong competitive advantage
Gross profit
Capacity utilisation
CCC
1999-2002
2003-09
2010-14
2014
Receivable days
2002-08
2009-14
2014
CCC = Cash conversion cycle
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Reasons to buy
Other positives
Strong competitive adv
LT Trends
4Ps
People
Product
Potential
Predictability
Pain/Problems business solve
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Reasons not to BUY
Other negatives
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Other negatives
What went wrong in past
Possibility of equity dilution
No history of earnings power
ContrarianValueEdge.com
What can kill the idea
Do Pre-mortem
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Profitability
8 Y AVG Div Payout ratio
ROIC [4yrs avg]
EBITA
Asset turnover
ROIC
SpreadROIC - Interest rate
Derived ROEROIC + Spread * Debt-equity ratio
Capacity
1997-2004xx
2005xx
2007xx
2008-11xx
FY 14xx
Capacity Utilisation
1997-2001xx
FY03-10xx
FY11xx
FY 14xx
Cash flow analysis
Du Pont analysis [4yrs AVG]
PBT breakup
EBITDA marginxx
Depreciation % salesxx
Interest % salesxx
PBT Marginxx
Asset turnover
xx
FY14
15 yr AVG
Pre-tax RoAxx
PBT/Total assets
Leverage [Assets/Equity]xx
FY14 =1.8x
Pre-tax ROE AVG42%
Tax rateBook tax rate34%
Cash tax rate30%
Net marginx%
Margin analysis
Sales CAGR
FY04-14xx
FY09-14
FY11-14xx
USD terms
FY04-14xx
2009..14 = xx%
FY11-14xx
ASP
FY05-11x
FY99-2002
FY97-98
INR USD
1993-97INR 30-36
1998-2011INR 40-48
FY1253
FY1358
FY1460
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Margin analysis
EBITDA margin
Gross margin
FY 99-2001xx
FY03-10xx
FY12-14xx
Accounting adjustments
Emp cost
FY02-11 avg
FY12-14
Emp cost CAGR
FY04 to 08
Capacity
Core sales
xxx
FY09 to 147% CAGR
Capacity
PowerFY99-2010xx
FY11-14xx
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Gross margin
FY 99-2001
FY03-10
FY12-14
Reason Gross margin
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Ecosystem
State of labour
Regulations
SuppliersSubtopic 1
Customers
Changes in technology
Environmental issues
Exposure to inflation
Is it a win-win situation for ecosystem
Society trends
Distribution channels
ContrarianValueEdge.com
ContrarianValueEdge.com
ContrarianValueEdge.com
ContrarianValueEdge.com
History
1995
1997
1998
1999
2000
2002
2004
2008
2014
2012
2011
2010
2009
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Cash flow analysis
NWC
Receivable days
FY01-08
FY10-14
FY 14 xx
Inventory
FG
RM days
FY 01-07 xx
FY08-13 xx
FY14 XX
% of sales
FY01-08 XX
FY11-14 XX
FY09 & 10 XX
ContrarianValueEdge.com
ContrarianValueEdge.com
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Mental models
Working for business
Working against business
ContrarianValueEdge.com
Other positives
Detailed Annual report Since 1999
ContrarianValueEdge.com