Promotional StrategyMKT4230
Source, Message, and Channel Factors
Patricia Knowles, Ph.D.
Associate ProfessorClemson University
1
2Promotional StrategyMKT4230 2
The Persuasion MatrixThis chart presents the persuasion matrix, which helps marketers see how each controllable element of the communication process interacts with the consumer’s response process:
TextbookPages 179 - 180 / Figure 6 - 1
3Promotional StrategyMKT4230 3
Promotional Planning ElementsThis chart presents specific decisions that correspond to the numbers in the cells of the persuasion matrix in the previous slide:
TextbookPages 179 - 180 / Figure 6 - 1
Who will be effective in getting consumers’
attention?
SourceAttention
4
ReceiverComprehension
Can the receiver comprehend the ad?
1
Which media will increase
presentation?
ChannelPresentation
2
What type of message will create favorable attitudes?
MessageYielding
3
Promotional Planning
4Promotional StrategyMKT4230 4
A Direct SourceThe term source means the person involved in communicating a marketing message, either directly or indirectly.
• A direct source is a spokesperson who delivers a message and/or endorses a product or service, like actress Hayden Panettiere, who appears in this ad sponsored by The Milk Processor Education Program.
• An indirect source, say a model, doesn’t actually deliver a message, but draws attention to and/or enhances the appearance of the ad.
• Some ads use neither a direct nor an indirect source; the source is the organization with the message to communicate.
TextbookPages 180 / Exhibit 6 - 1
5Promotional StrategyMKT4230 5
Source Attributes & Receiver Processing ModesThis visual shows the three categories of source attributes and the receiver processing mode associated with each.
TextbookPages 181 / Figure 6 - 2
• Credibility – the extent to which the recipient sees the source as having relevant knowledge, skill, or experience and trusts the source to give unbiased, objective information.
Internalization – the process by which a receiver adopts the position advocated by the source because it is perceived as accurate and makes it part of his or her belief system
• Attractiveness – refers to the similarity, familiarity, and/or likeability of the source.Identification – the process by which an individual is motivated to seek some type of relationship with the source and thus adopts similar beliefs, attitudes, or behaviors.
• Power – refers to the ability (real or perceived) of the source to administer rewards or punishment to the receiver
Compliance – the process by which the receiver accepts the position advocated by the source
6Promotional StrategyMKT4230 6
Source CredibilityThis visual shows the basic dimensions of source credibility, expertise, and trustworthiness:
TextbookPages 181
Source
Ethical
Honest
UnbiasedBelievable
Knowledgeable Trustworthy
Skillful Experienced
7Promotional StrategyMKT4230 7
Experts Lend Authority to an AppealThis visual shows an ad for Dove soap, which promotes the fact that it recommended by dermatologists who are experts in skin care.
TextbookPages 181 - 182 / Exhibit 6 - 2
It demonstrates how advertisers apply the concept of source expertise in their advertising messages.
Endorsements from doctors and dentists are also common in advertising.
8Promotional StrategyMKT4230 8
Corporate Leaders as SpokespeopleThis visual shows an advertisement from Jerome’s Furniture, which often uses their president or chairman as an advertising spokesman. It introduces the use of corporate leaders as advertising spokespeople. A number of companies use their founders, presidents, or CEOs as the spokesperson in their ads.
TextbookPages 184 - 185 / Exhibit 6 - 3
Note: This is a good time to show the Jerome’s Furniture spots on the instructor video DVDs. You may also wish to show a Wendy’s ad. Dave Thomas, the founder of Wendy’s fast-food restaurants, appeared in more than 800 ads for the company between 1989 and early 2002, when he passed away. He is one of the most popular and effective corporate executive spokespeople ever to appear in commercials for a company.
9Promotional StrategyMKT4230 9
Limitations of Credible SourcesStudies have shown that a high-credibility source is not always an asset, nor is a low-credibility source always a liability. High- and low-credibility sources are equally effective when they are arguing for a position opposing their own best interest.
A low-credibility source may also be as effective as a high-credibility sources due to the sleeper effect, whereby the persuasiveness of the message increases with the passage of time.
Over time, the association of the message with the source diminishes and the receiver’s attention focuses more on the favorable information in the message.
Many advertisers hesitate to count on the sleeper effect, however, since exposure to a credible source is a more reliable strategy.
TextbookPage 185
10Promotional StrategyMKT4230 10
Sources of AttractivenessThis chart explains the three basic characteristics of source attractiveness:
TextbookPages 185 - 187
Resemblance between the source and recipient of the
message
Similarity
Knowledge of the source through
repeated or prolonged exposure
Familiarity
Affection for the source resulting from physical appearance, behavior, or personal
traits
Likeability
11Promotional StrategyMKT4230 11
Top Celebrity EndorsersThis visual shows an ad featuring Maria Sharapova, who has endorsement contracts with a number of companies, including Nike, Land Rover, Tiffany, and Cole Haan.
TextbookPage 186 - 187
• Top Male Endorsers– Tiger Woods– Phil Mickelson– LeBron James– Michael Jordan
• Top Female Endorsers– Maria Sharapova– Jennifer Lopez– Jessica Simpson– Venus/Serena Williams– Michele Wie
12Promotional StrategyMKT4230 12
Advertising Risks of Using CelebritiesThis chart outlines the risks to the advertiser when utilizing a celebrity spokesperson:
TextbookPage 187 - 190
The celebrity’s behavior may pose a risk to the company
The celebrity may overshadow the product being endorsed
The celebrity may be overexposed, reducing his or her credibility
The target audience may not be receptive to celebrity endorsers
13Promotional StrategyMKT4230 13
Meaning Movements and EndorsementsThis meaning movement and endorsement model illustrates why celebrity endorsements are effective:
TextbookPages 190 - 193 / Figure 6 - 3
14Promotional StrategyMKT4230 14
Kelly Ripa: The “Do-It-All” WomanThis ad featuring is an example of how a celebrity’s culturally acquired meanings carry over to the endorsement process.
TextbookPages 190 - 191 / Exhibit 6 - 7
McCracken suggests that celebrity endorsers bring their meanings and image into the ad, then transfer them to the product they are endorsing.
Then, in the final stage of the process, the meanings the celebrity has given to the product are transferred to the consumer.
This visual presents a list of factors that marketers should consider before spending the company’s money to sign a celebrity endorser:
15Promotional StrategyMKT4230 15
Choosing a Celebrity Endorser
TextbookPages 194
Trust
Risk
Familiarity
Likability
Factors
Match w/Audience
Match w/Product
Image
Cost
16Promotional StrategyMKT4230 16
Q-Score = Star PowerQ-scores to determine the popularity of sport personalities, actors, actresses, and entertainers. Marketing Evaluations, Inc. surveys a representative national panel of consumers several times a year.
Lance Armstrong
Respondents are asked to indicate whether they have ever seen or heard of a performer or sports personality and, if they have, to rate him or her on a scale that includes:
• One of my favorites• Very good• Good• Fair• Poor
Q-scores are also broken down on the basis of demographic criteria, such as a respondent’s age, income, occupation, education, and race so that marketers have some idea of how a celebrity’s popularity varies among different groups of consumers.
TextbookPages 194
17Promotional StrategyMKT4230 17
Applying Likability: Decorative ModelsThis visual shows an example of how some companies are taking a non-traditional approach to advertising by using everyday women rather than supermodels in ads.
TextbookPages 194 - 196 / Exhibit 6 - 9
Research shows that physically attractive communicators generally generate more favorable evaluations of both ads and products than less attractive models. Recent studies, however, show that some women experience negative feelings when comparing themselves with the beautiful models used in ads and the images of physical perfection they represent. In response, some companies developed advertising campaigns that tell women, as well as young girls, that they’re beautiful just the way they are.
As this ad reflects, Dove has taken a social advocacy approach in its campaigns, which uses everyday women to “change the status quo and offer in its place a broader, healthier, more democratic view of beauty.”
18Promotional StrategyMKT4230 18
Source PowerThis visual presents the final characteristics in Kelman’s classification scheme:
TextbookPages 196
Perceived Control Perceived Concern Perceived Scrutiny
Compliance
19Promotional StrategyMKT4230 19
Clint Eastwood: Source PowerThis ad is an example of source power. It reinforces the message that an indirect way of using power is by using an individual with an authoritative personality. Clint Eastwood’s authoritative image as a rugged, tough guy makes him an effective source in this public service ad, which commands people to not pollute or damage public lands.
TextbookPages 196 / Exhibit 6 - 10
20Promotional StrategyMKT4230 20
Recall and Order of PresentationA basic consideration in the design of a persuasive message is the order in which message arguments will be presented. Research on learning and memory indicate that items presented first and last are remembered better than those presented in the middle. The strongest arguments should be placed at the beginning or end of the message, never in the middle. Presenting the strongest arguments at the beginning of the message assumes a primacy effect is operating, whereby information presented first is most effective. Putting the strong points at the end assumes a recency effect, whereby the last arguments are most persuasive.
TextbookPages 197 / Figure 6 - 4
Reca
ll
Beginning Middle End
Order of Presentation
21Promotional StrategyMKT4230 21
Silk Uses an Open Ended MessageThis ad for Silk Soymilk is a good example of an open-ended message, which encourages consumers to be open to the idea of drinking soymilk.
TextbookPages 198 / Figure 6 - 11
Marketing communicators must decide whether their messages should draw a firm conclusion or allow receivers to draw their own conclusions.
In general, messages with explicit conclusions are more easily understood and effective in influencing attitudes. However, this effectiveness can depend on the target audience, the type of issue or topic, and the nature of the situation. For example, more highly educated people may resent attempts by the communicator to draw a conclusion.
22Promotional StrategyMKT4230 22
Buckley’s Uses a Two-Sided MessageThis visual shows a Buckley’s ad, which uses a two-sided message structure to promote the product’s effectiveness.
TextbookPages 198 - 199 / Exhibit 6 - 12
• A one-sided message mentions only positive attributes or benefits.
• A two-sided message presents both good and bad points.
This ad for Buckley’s cough syrup is a good example of a two-sided message. Ads for the brand typically poke fun at the cough syrup’s terrible taste, but also suggest that the taste is one reason why it is so effective. The persuasive impact of message sidedness depends on a number of factors, including:
• The amount and importance of the negative information• Attribute quality• Placement of the negative information• The correlation between negative and positive attributes• Whether the advertiser discloses negative information voluntarily
23Promotional StrategyMKT4230 23
An Ad Using a Refutation AppealIn a special type of two-sided message known as a refutational appeal, the communicator presents both sides of an issue and then refutes the opposing viewpoint. Refutational messages are useful when marketers wish to build attitudes that resist change and must defend against attacks or criticism of their products or their company.
TextbookPages 199 / Exhibit 6 - 13
This ad used by the Almond Board of California refutes nutritional concerns about the fat content of almonds.
Acknowledging competitors’ claims and then refuting them helps build resistant attitudes and customer loyalty.
24Promotional StrategyMKT4230 24
Verbal vs. Visual MessagesAds use pictures to affect the way consumers process the accompanying copy. In this ad, Arrowhead Mountain Spring Water uses a beautiful visual image of the mountains to communicate a key product attribute… purity.
TextbookPages 199 - 200
Other advertisers design ads in which the visual portion is incongruent with, or contradicts, the verbal information presented. The logic behind this strategy is that the use of an unexpected picture or visual will grab the consumer’s attention and get him/her to engage in a more effortful or elaborative processing.
Studies show that using a visual that in inconsistent with the verbal content leads to more recall and greater processing of the information presented.
25Promotional StrategyMKT4230 25
Test Your KnowledgeThe campaign centered around the theme “Pork, the Other White Meat” is designed to show consumers that pork is as lean as chicken. Ads in this campaign use:
A. Conclusion drawing
B. A fear appeal
C. A refutational appeal
D. A humorous appeal
E. An affective conclusion
26Promotional StrategyMKT4230 26
Message Appeal ChoicesThere are two broad categories of message appeals:
TextbookPages 201 - 202
Many believe that the most effective advertising combines practical reasons for purchasing a product with emotional values.
Subsequent slides will discuss the message appeal options of comparative advertising, fear, and humor.
Appeal to both
Appeal to the feelings and emotions of consumers
Appeal to the logical, rational minds of consumers
27Promotional StrategyMKT4230 27
Message Appeal OptionsThis chart presents advertising message appeal options:
TextbookPages 202 - 206
Fear Appeals
• May stress physical danger or threats to health
• May identify social threats
• Can backfire if level of threat is too high
Comparative Ads
• Especially useful for new brands
• Often used for brands with small market share
• Used often in political advertising
Humor Appeals
• Can attract and hold attention
• Often the best remembered
• Puts consumers in a positive mood
28Promotional StrategyMKT4230 28
Miller Lite’s Comparative AdvertisingThis ad is an example of how the Miller Brewing Company effectively used comparative advertising to take on Anheuser-Busch. Comparative ads hammered home the message that Miller’s beers are better tasting than Anheuser-Busch brands, such as Budweiser and Bud Light.
TextbookPages 202 - 203 / Exhibit 6 - 15
The ad shown here positions Miller Lite as the better-tasting, low-carb alternative to Bud Light, which helped increase sales to the highest level in a decade. Miller stopped running comparative ads when research showed that consumers were tiring of the combative approach. However, the tactic was resurrected in 2007, when Miller claimed taste superiority over Bud Light.
In politics, comparative ads are used to discredit the character, record, or position of an opponent and create doubt in voters’ minds. However, studies show that “attack advertising” by politicians can result in negative perceptions of both candidates.
29Promotional StrategyMKT4230 29
Fear Appeals and Message AcceptanceThis chart shows that the relationship between the level of fear in a message and acceptance or persuasion is curvilinear. This means that message acceptance increases as the amount of fear used rises, but only to a point. Beyond that point, acceptance decreases as the level of fear rises.
TextbookPages 203 - 204 / Figure 6 - 5
30Promotional StrategyMKT4230 30
Humor AppealsThis chart summarizes the pros and cons of using humor in advertising:
TextbookPages 205 - 206
Does not aid persuasion in general
Cons
May harm recall and comprehension
May harm complex copy registration
Does not aid source credibility
Not effective in bringing about sales
May wear out faster than non-humorous ads
Aids attention and awareness
Pros
May aid retention of the message
Creates a positive mood and enhances persuasion
May aid name and simple copy registration
May serve as a distracter, reducing counterarguing
31Promotional StrategyMKT4230 31
Humor in Print MediaHumorous ads are often the best known and best remembered of all advertising messages, and radio and TV commercials lend themselves to the execution of humorous messages. Use this slide to show the use of humor in lesser-used print advertising.
TextbookPages 205 - 206 / Exhibit 6 - 18
This ad was used by the Australian New Car Assessment Program, which provides consumers in Australia and New Zealand with information on the level of occupant protection provided by vehicles in front and side crashes.
32Promotional StrategyMKT4230 32
Test Your KnowledgeAn ad for Snorestop Extinguisher, a nose spray for eliminating snoring, has the headline, “Wife shoots husband and rests in peace.” This ad uses _____ to attract attention and convey a key selling point.
A. a two-sided message approach
B. a humor appeal
C. a comparative advertising
D. a refutational appeal
E. a primacy appeal
33Promotional StrategyMKT4230 33
Personal vs. Non-Personal ChannelsHere are some of the pros and cons of personal versus non-personal ad channels:
TextbookPages 206 - 207
Personal Selling
• Flexible• Powerful• Real time
• Geared to large audience• Static
Non-Personal Advertising
34Promotional StrategyMKT4230 34
Differences in Information ProcessingThis chart presents examples of self-paced versus externally paced media:
TextbookPage 207
Self-Paced Media
• Newspapers
• Magazines
• Direct Mail
• Internet
• Radio
• Television
Externally Paced Media
vs.
35Promotional StrategyMKT4230 35
Context and EnvironmentInterpretation of an advertising message can be influenced by the context or environment in which the ad appears. For example, an ad for a high-quality men’s clothing line might have more impact in a fashion magazine like GQ than it would in Sports Afield.
TextbookPages 208 - 209 / Exhibit 6 - 19
This cover of Travel & Leisure magazine is an example of an environment in which hotel, restaurant, luggage, and other travel-related ads would do well, partly because the articles, pictures, and other ads help to excite readers about travel.
36Promotional StrategyMKT4230 36
Context and EnvironmentCutter is the amount of advertising in a given medium. For television, clutter includes all the non-program material that appears in the broadcast environment… commercials, promotional messages for shows, public service announcements (PSAs), and the like.
Clutter is of increasing concern to advertisers because there are so many messages competing for the consumer’s attention. On average, one-fourth of a broadcast hour on TV is devoted to commercials; radio stations carry an average of 10-12 minutes of commercials per hour.
And, commercials have dropped in length from 60 seconds, to 30 seconds, to 15 seconds. That means many more commercials are now being shown. A viewer watching three hours of prime-time programming on the major networks could be subjected to as many as 100 commercial messages.
The problem is not likely to go away, so advertisers must continue to look for ways to break through the clutter, such as using humor, celebrity spokespeople, or novel, creative approaches.
TextbookPages 209 - 210
Top Related