7/27/2019 Cambios Color
1/7
Color changes during storage of honeys in relation to theircomposition and initial color
Adriana Pereyra Gonzales a, Leila Burin b, Mara del Pilar Buera b,*,1
aDepartamento de Quimica Organica, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Ciudad Universitaria,
1428 Buenos Aires, ArgentinabDepartamento de Industrias, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Ciudad Universitaria,
1428 Buenos Aires, Argentina
Received 11 March 1999; accepted 22 April 1999
Abstract
The causes of darkening in honey have been attributed to Maillard reaction, fructose caramelization and reactions of poly-
phenols, however, no systematic studies exist on this subject. The inuence of composition and initial color on the rate of darkening
of several Argentine honeys submitted to storage at 37C during 90 days was evaluated through spectrocolorimetric measurements.
The most suitable color functions to evaluate darkening of honeys [lightness (Lab*), browning index (BI), metric chroma (Cab*),
metric hue (Hab*) and 1/Z] increased linearly as storage time increased, after an initial induction period of very low browning
development. The slope of the linear browning development zone with time was an index of browning rate, and it was analyzed in
relation to the initial color and the composition of honeys (moisture content, total nitrogen, total lipids and polyunsaturated fatty
acids, fructose and glucose content). Of the analyzed variables, the initial color was the parameter which better dened the rate of
darkening of honeys. # 1999 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd on behalf of the Canadian Institute of Food Science and Tech-
nology. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Honey; Color; Darkening
1. Introduction
The color of honey is one of the factors determining
its price on the world market, and also its acceptability
by the consumers. Light honeys are usually mild in a-
vor and of a higher commercial value than dark colored
honeys (Wootton, Edwards, Faraji-Haremi & Johnson,
1976; Wootton, Edwards & Faraji-Haremi, 1976;
White, 1978). Argentina is the third world producer of
honey, which represents 62,000 ton per year (Nimo,
1998). During shipping to far countries and/or during
storage, darkening of honey may occur, and parallel
changes in its organoleptic properties have detrimental
eects on its quality, masking its original aroma, which
promotes loss of competitiveness in the world market
(Milum, 1939; Aubert & Gonnet, 1983).
The rate of darkening has been related to the composi-
tion of honey and of the storage temperature (White, 1978;
Gupta, Kaushik & Joshi, 1992). Of the compositional
factors, the ratio of glucose to fructose, nitrogen content,
free aminoacids, moisture content have been cited as pos-
sible factors determining the rate of darkening (Lynn,
Englis & Milum, 1936; Schade, Marsh & Eckert, 1958).
Lynn et al., (1936) indicated that the main causes of
darkening in honey could be: (a) reaction aminoacid-
aldol (Maillard reaction); (b) combination of tannates
and other oxydated polyphenols with ferrum salts; (c)
instability of fructose (caramelization reaction).
However, there is still controversy over the relative
inuence of these factors on the darkening of honey.
While Ramsay and Milum (1933) stated that the Mail-
lard reaction was the main cause of darkening, Lynn et
al. (1936) indicated that it was only a secondary factor.
Milum (1948) observed that darkening during storage
depended on the initial color of the honey.
Despite the known incidence of the commercial value of
the color of honeys, and of the occurrence of darkening
0963-9969/99/$20.00 # 1999 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd on behalf of the Canadian Institute of Food Science and Technology. All rightsreserved.
P I I : S 0 9 6 3 - 9 9 6 9 ( 9 9 ) 0 0 0 7 5 - 7
Food Research International 32 (1999) 185191
www.elsevier.com/locate/foodres
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +54-11-4576-3397; fax: +56-11-
4576-3366.
E-mail address: [email protected] (M.P. Buera)1 Member of Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientcas y
Te cnicas de la Repu blica, Argentina.
7/27/2019 Cambios Color
2/7
during storage, literature related to investigate the main
causes of darkening is scarce. Wootton, Edwards, Faraji-
Haremi and Johnson (1976) and Wootton, Edwards and
Faraji-Haremi (1976) analyzed the changes in chemical
composition of six Australian honeys and reported that
the amount of sugars and free aminoacids in them were
not related to the extent of darkening after storage of thehoneys at 50C. Schade et al. (1958) indicated that the rate
of honey darkening may increase as increasing the moist-
ure content increases. The content and type of natural
polyphenols (such as avonoids) inuence the color of
fresh honeys (Chandler, Fenwick, Orlova & Reynolds,
1974), and their degradation reactions may also cause
color changes during storage.
The objective of this present work was to analyze the
rate of darkening of several Argentine honeys of multi-
oral origin as a function of their main components
(glucose, fructose, total nitrogen, moisture content and
lipids), and of their initial color, during storage at 37C.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Samples
Sixteen oral honeys from dierent geographic plain
regions of temperate climate from Argentina, two from
woody temperate areas and one from a tropical region,
were analyzed. The samples were provided by ocial
institutions or private producers with guarantee of gen-
uiness and known history.
Composition of honeys had been determined in a pre-vious work, as described by Bertoni, Pereyra Gonzales and
Catta neo, (1994). Moisture content was determined by
AOAC (1980) method 31.111. Glucose and fructose were
evaluated as described by Ugarte and Karman (1945). Total
nitrogen by AOAC 2.24 (1950) method in semimicro scale.
Total lipids were analyzed using the Folch, Lee and Sloane
Stanley, (1957) method. Fatty acid composition as described
in Pereyra, Gonzales, Bertoni, Gros & Catta neo, (1994).
2.2. Color measurements
Measurements were done in a Hunterlab 5100 (Hunter
Associates Laboratory Fairfax, VA) spectrocolorimeter,
with white background in Plexiglass 5.3 cm diameterer
sample holders, with a sample thickness of 4 mm. The
illumination mode illuminated the aperture area (4.7
cm). The color functions, which in previous experiences
have been proved to be adequated to follow the dev-
elopment of browning pigments (Buera, Petriella &
Lozano, 1985; Buera & Resnik, 1989) were calculated for
illuminant C, and the 2 angle observer, through the tris-
timulus values X, Y, Z, taking as standard values those of
the white background (X=79.01; Y=83.96; Z=86.76).
The following equations were employed (Lozano, 1977):
Luminosity: L*abL*ab =116 (Y/Yn)
1/316
a* =500 [(X/Xn)1/3(Y/Yn)1/3]
b* =200[(Y/Yn)1/3(Z/Zn)1/3]
Metric chroma: C*ab
C*ab =(a*2+b*2)1/2
Color dierence CIE 1976: E*abE*ab =[(L*ab)
2+(a*)2+(b*)2]1/2
Metric hue dierence: H*abH*ab=[(E*ab)2(L*ab)2(C*ab)2]
1/2
Metric saturation: suv
suv
=13[(uHuHn)2+(vHvH
n)2]1/2
uH =4X/(X+15 Y+3 Z)
vH
=9Y/(X+15 Y+3 Z)
where: uHn 0X2009; vH
n 0X461; Xn 98X041; Yn
100X00 y Zn 118X103, are the values calculated for
illuminant C and at the 2 angle observer. : dierence
between the values corresponding to the sample at time
t and t=0.
Browning index (BR) (Buera et al., 1985) was also
calculated as:
f 100 x 0X31 a0X172Y whee x
omtioodinte Xa X Y Z
Before placing the samples in the cuvette for color
measurement, they were placed at 50C for 30 min in a
water bath to decrease their viscosity and to allow the
measurement of the volume with a syringe, carefully
avoiding air bubbles. It was demonstrated, in a pre-
liminary study, that this initial treatment of the samples
did not alter their color.
Illumination was done from the bottom side of the
samples. The standard white plate was placed over the
cuvette which contained the sample. The standard
deviation of the color measurements, estimated from 20
determinations of the same sample was 2.5% and 5
measurements of each sample were necessary to obtain
an error lower than 3% at a condence level of 95%.
2.3. Storage
The samples were distributed in aliquots in hermeti-
cally closed containers of high density polyethylene.
They were stored in forced circulation ovens maintained
at a constant temperature 37(1)C during adequate
periods of time, after which colorimetric determinations
were done, over a total period of 90 days.
186 A.P. Gonzales et al. / Food Research International 32 (1999) 185191
7/27/2019 Cambios Color
3/7
3. Results and discussion
Fig. 1(a) shows the initial color of honeys in the CIE
chromaticity diagram, in which the tristimulus values
are limited to a plane, determined by the x and y chro-
matic coordinates. Most of the samples are located on a
line to which corresponds a dominant wavelength of 575nm, as observed for samples of yellow to light-brown
colors obtained through non-enzymic browning reac-
tions (Buera et al., 1985), and also observed by Aubert
and Gonnet (1983) from spectrophotometric measure-
ments of honeys. The darker honeys were located in the
descending part of the curve, and showed a displace-
ment of the dominant wavelengh to the red zone of the
chromaticity diagram. Fig. 1(b) shows the CIE chro-
maticity coordinates of the honeys, after 90 days of
storage at 37C. It can be seen that a displacement of
the dominant wavelengh occurred for all the honeys, to
the red zone of the diagram. The CIE tristimulus values
allowed an objective approach to color grading, den-
ing a picture of the chromaticity (yellow-red) of the
samples, which is not possible by the visual classica-
tion of honey by the ocial Pfund method from light to
dark (Aubert & Gonnet, 1983).During storage at 37C the darkening of the samples
could be followed by any of the color functions which
were previously related to browning development: suv
,
Hab*, IB and 1/Z (Buera et al., 1985; Buera & Resnik,
1989). As shown in Fig. 2 for the color function Hab*
after an initial induction period, in which no browning
occurred, it followed a period of linear increase of color
with time. This behavior was observed in many pro-
ducts subjected to non-enzymatic browning (Song &
Chichester, 1966; Labuza & Saltmarch, 1980). The
samples included in Fig. 1 were chosen in such a way to
obtain a representative picture of all the analyzed sam-
ples, covering the whole range of color changes andbrowning rates observed. The slope of the linear part of
the curves was calculated, and considered as an index of
the rate of browning, as a pseudo zero-order rate coe-
cient. Table 1 shows the correlation coecients resulting
from the linear correlation between the color functions
and storage time data, obtained by least squares. The
rate of darkening could be followed by any of the selec-
ted color functions (the rate coecients for the metric
hue development is reported in Table 1). The induction
period for browning development at 37C, calculated as
the value of the abscise for which the ordinate was zero,
was between 10 and 30 days, and the values were alsoincluded in Table 1.
Fig. 1. Scheme of the CIE chromaticity diagrams showing the initial
(a) and the nal (b) color of honeys.
Fig. 2. Evolution of the color functionHab*, with storage time at 37C
for some honeys, representative of the whole range of color changes.
A.P. Gonzales et al. / Food Research International 32 (1999) 185191 187
7/27/2019 Cambios Color
4/7
To investigate the variable which most inuenced the
rate of darkening, the slopes of the linear part of the
curves were analyzed in relation to the main components
of the honeys, and also to their initial color. Fig. 3 shows
the dependence of the calculated browning rates (k) with
some of the analyzed variables. Of the analyzed vari-
ables, the rate of darkening of honeys had no dependence
with the compositional variables, and the initial color
(IC) seemed to be the best parameter to dene browningrate. Metric saturation (s
uv), a color function dened
above (see Materials and Methods section) is related to
the purity of color and was selected as an index of the
initial color value of honeys. suv
has been found to be an
adequate function to follow color changes in transparent
products yellow to brown colorations (Petriella, Resnik,
Lozano & Chirife, 1985; Buera et al., 1985). Fig. 3(a)
shows that the rate of browning did not have any corre-
lation with the concentration of the main sugar compo-
nents of honey (glucose and fructose). At the acidic pH
value of the honey (3.84.5), fructose is more reactive
than glucose towards browning development (Buera,
Resnik & Petriella, 1992), but as both sugars are in a
large extent and the variability between samples was
small, the concentration of fructose was not a limiting
factor for browning development. Amino compounds
play an important role in interactions involving reducing
sugars. Wootton, Edwards, Faraji-Haremi and Johnson
(1976) and Wootton, Edwards and Faraji-Haremi, (1976)
indicated that although total nitrogen content was rela-
tively unaected by storage at 50C, the total free ami-
noacid content decreased, but the changes in free
aminoacids were not related to the extent of darkening.
Due to the low content of free aminoacids in honey, it
could be expected that, if the amino-sugar condensation
was an important cause of honey darkening, nitrogen
concentration must be considered a limiting factor and
the rate of browning should be related to the initial
nitrogen content. However, the correlation between
browning rate and nitrogen content was poor (Fig. 3b).
These results indicated that, contrary to the suggestions
of Ramsay and Milum (1933) and in agreement with
Lynn et al. (1936) the amino-sugar condensation, and thetotal nitrogen content had only a secondary eect on the
darkening of honeys. The instability of fructose may be
one important cause of discoloration, but the high con-
centration of this sugar and the narrow range of varia-
bility between dierent samples of honeys did not allow
correlation of the rate of darkening to fructose con-
centration. Although during extended storage, lipids
may generate carbonilic compounds through oxidation
and promote browning (Taoukis & Labuza, 1996), the
rate of darkening was neither aected by the total lipid
content (Fig. 3c), nor by the individual concentrations of
the unsaturated fatty acids linoleic (18:2) or linolenic
(18:3) [the correlation coecients (r2) were lower than
0.2, not shown]. Schade et al. (1958) indicated that the
rate of honey darkening may increase as the moisture
content increases, but as shown in Fig. 3d, the water
content was not a variable which inuenced clearly the
browning rate. Wootton, Edwards, Faraji-Haremi and
Johnson, (1976) reported that none of the changes
observed during their study on storage of Australian
honeys (color, acidity and total nitrogen content) were
related to the initial moisture content, in spite of the
known importance of moisture levels in browning reac-
tions. When the rate of darkening was plotted as a func-
Table 1
Correlation coecients (r2) for the linear regression between some of the color functions and storage time data at 37C, obtained by least squaresa
Honey suv BR v 1/Z g r
k(r
units/day) I (days)
1 0.9391 0.9434 0.9542 0.8868 0.9321 0.9316 0.104 27.6
2 0.9674 0.9657 0.9391 0.9311 0.9625 0.9419 0.0795 25.6
3 0.9755 0.9354 0.9261 0.8341 0.8461 0.8547 0.121 0
4 0.8623 0.8132 0.8817 0.7918 0.8490 0.8889 0.121 31.95 0.9622 0.9245 0.9303 0.9539 0.9402 0.9193 0.765 30.6
6 0.9105 0.9372 0.9811 0.9523 0.8381 0.9555 0.1397 19.2
7 0.9472 0.9472 0.8931 0.9748 0.9561 0.9654 0.0380 25.9
8 0.9673 0.9267 0.9815 0.9485 0.9554 0.8759 0.0992 30.2
9 0.9113 0.9139 0.9873 0.8460 0.8821 0.8885 0.126 28.0
10 0.9675 0.9325 0.9625 0.9210 0.9623 0.9373 0.0292 11.9
11 0.9766 0.9123 0.9946 0.9056 0.9569 0.9690 0.161 15.7
12 0.9632 0.8954 0.9600 0.9350 0.9614 0.9644 0.090 21.6
13 0.9858 0.9543 0.9428 0.9431 0.9979 0.9769 0.139 20.3
14 0.9589 0.9216 0.9604 0.9963 0.7214 0.9386 0.3722 21.2
15 0.9819 0.9325 0.9979 0.9353 0.9671 0.9881 0.124 0
16 0.9295 0.9325 0.9778 0.9853 0.9427 0.9768 0.149 3.6
17 0.7674 0.9432 0.8060 0.7977 0.8707 0.7214 0.5337 36.9
18 0.9362 0.8997 0.9837 0.8960 0.9189 0.9110 0.173 15.3
19 0.9876 0.9354 0.9546 0.8990 0.9143 0.9089 0.21 12.6
a The slope of the linear part of the curves (k) and the induction period (I) for browning development were calculated for the Hab* color
function. I was calculated as the X-intercept.
188 A.P. Gonzales et al. / Food Research International 32 (1999) 185191
7/27/2019 Cambios Color
5/7
tion of initial color (IC) of honeys, a better correlation
than that obtained for the compositional variables was
found (Fig. 4).The rate coecients, and also the induction periods
were analyzed in relation to the compositional variables
and initial color by stepwise regression analysis of data
(Statistix for windows analytical software was
employed). The best subset regression models that con-
tained all the potential predictor variables were rst
evaluated. To obtain a more complete picture of the
dependence, some transformations in the variables were
applied, such as squares or logarithms, and relationships
between variables, which could account for interactions
between factors, were also analyzed. None of the trans-
formations proved, gave better correlation than the sin-
gle variable ``initial color'' (IC). The results conrmed
that the initial color was the variable which most inu-
enced the browning rate, as observed in Fig. 3. The
equation obtained through linear correlation by stepwise
regression combined the variable IC and IC2 as follows:
k 0X1894 0X3849 sg 0X3177 sg 2
The curve predicted for this equation is shown in Fig.
4 as a dotted line. The square correlation coecient
between observed and predicted values (r2 ) was 0.8018
for a p
7/27/2019 Cambios Color
6/7
however, the induction period did not have any corre-
lation either with the initial color (r2=0.46), or with the
analyzed compositional variables (the best correlation
obtained from a stepwise regression analysis had as r2 of
0.49 for a p
7/27/2019 Cambios Color
7/7
Ramsey, R. J., & Milum, V. G. (1993). The discoloration of honey.
American Bee Journal, 73, 305306.
Schade, J. W., Marsh, G. L., & Eckert, J. E. (1958). Diastase activity
and hydroxymethylfurfural in honey and their inuence in detecting
heat alteration. Food Research, 23, 446463.
Song, P. S., & Chichester, C. O. (1966). Kinetic behavior and
mechanism of inhibition in the Maillard reaction. II. Mechanistics
considerations in the reaction between D-glucose and glycine. Jour-
nal of Food Science, 31, 914919.
Taoukis, P., & Labuza, T. (1996). Summary: integrative concepts. In
R. Owen, & E. D. Fennema, Food Chemistry (pp. 10131042). New
York: Marcel Dekker Inc. (3rd ed.).
Ugarte, L., & Karman, G. (1945). Determination of the ratio glucose/
levulose in Argentine honeys. Anales Asociacion Quimica Argentina,
33, 181.
White, J. W. (1978). Honey. Advances in Food Research, 24, 287371.
White, J. W., Kushnir, I., & Subers, M. H. (1964). Eect of storage
and processing temperatures on honey quality. Food Technology
555-558.
Wootten, M., Edwards, R. A., Faraji-Haremi, R., & Johnson, A. T.
(1976). Eect of accelerated storage conditions on the chemical
composition and properties of Australian honeys. 1. Colour, acidity
and total nitrogen content. Journal of Apicultural Research, 15, 23
28.
Wootten, M., Edwards, R. A., & Faraji-Haremi, R. (1976). Eect of
accelerated storage conditions on the chemical composition and
properties of Australian honeys. 2. Changes in sugar and free amino
acid contents. Journal of Apicultural Research, 15, 2934.
A.P. Gonzales et al. / Food Research International 32 (1999) 185191 191
Top Related