7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 1/24
Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-first
Century: Revisiting The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
Lyle A. Scruggs
James P. Allan
World Politics, Volume 60, Number 4, July 2008, pp. 642-664 (Article)
Published by Cambridge University Press
DOI: 10.1353/wp.0.0020
For additional information about this article
Access Provided by Bristol University at 02/18/13 11:18PM GMT
http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/wp/summary/v060/60.4.scruggs.html
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 2/24
Research Note
Social Stratiication
and Welare regimeS or the tWenty-irSt century
rvs The Three Worlds o
Welare Capitalism
B lyle a. ScruggS JameS P. allan*
IntroductIon
in s s pb, gøs esp-a-s’s Three Worlds o Welare Capitalism s v
pv ss w ss Ws ep v ps s.1 is s ss s v b x w s b s pv wss, s q s ss pvp s p. a j s s pp s s p spp s -s w ss Ws s. ts p,k v ps, s vs: s pss;s s ws ss x
s; s vp s w pss b ss sqs sp. W Three Worlds vv,wv, ws — s ss— p ss p ps p sps s
* S s s pp w w spp n S. W w k k l Kw, s World Politics , svws s s .
1 gøs esp-as, The Three Worlds o Welare Capitalism (P: P uvs Pss, 1990).
World Politics 60 (J 2008), 642–64
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 3/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 643
2 t sv s vws “ws w” , W as Jgss, “t Ws W m? a S a rp,” Journal o European Social Policy 12, . 2 (2002); esp-as, Social Foundations o Post-Industrial Economie s (nw yk: ox uvs Pss, 1999), sp p. 5. t b “ws” s b xp s. aps, s, xp, k css db m, “i- W S rs: t lks bw Ps, iss os,” Governance 5, . 1(1992). S ep, s, xp, mz , “t ‘S m’ W S ep,” Journal o European Social Policy 7, . 1 (1996); g B, “cs-s W Ss: a tw ds app,” Journal o Social Policy 26, . 3 (1997). os s ss s sps w sp ss Three Worlds . t s xsv s bw s
s z , xp, a o, “g S rs czsp,” Ameri-can Sociological Review 58, . 3 (1993); d Ssb, ., Gendering Welare States (l: S,1996); a S, “Wk W g eq: a nw tp,” s Ssb.o s s j s s/sss ps ( , -p, sk p, pb pss) s w ss. S, xp, gr, “c d: a dvp cq,” Policy and Politics 28, . 3 (2000); J. g, “d B: a cpv ass Wk-ij Ps,” Journal o European Social Policy 14, . 1 (2004); m Pw aBs, “W rs W mx,” European Journal o Political Research 43, . 1(2004). , sv v z pp v ps. Sm Sv, “ls avs mp rss cpv rs,” Compara-tive Social Research (gw, c.: jaI Pss, 2007); ax hks l Kw,
“Vs W cps,” Socio-economic Review 1, . 1 (2003).3 s s s ks Three Worlds p s s s p, s . J ms iii, “t Ws Pb op? Vs, V, e SP,” International Journal o Public Opinion Research 16, . 2 (2004); c J m, “rv- W rs: eps ip av S P,” World Politics 57(ob 2004); S Svs, “Ws W as rsb: a cps e Ws ns,” European Sociological Review 13, . 3 (1997); P Ps, “t nw Ps W S,” World Politics 48 ( J 1996); ev hb J d. Sps,Development and Crisis o the Welare State: Parties and Policies in Global Markets (c: uvs c Pss, 2001); d Swk , Global Capital, Political Institutions, and Policy Change in Developed Welare States (cb: cb uvs Pss, 2002); rb e. g, B h, rms, hk-J dv, The Real Worlds o Welare Capitalism (cb: cb uvs
Pss, 1999); e B m h, “W Ss S mb: hw e- S P m a css- ds ass bw opos dss,” Research in Social Stratifcation and Mobility 24, . 4 (2006).
4 i w ss s sss s s, esp-as ( .1 . 2, 74) s s s as gss (. 2) v s psz w w w s decommodiy b s ss z w ss.
w s. i ws, v s ws (p-p) w s .
W ss w s s b qs v ss, s vss b bb s ss pv s p -pv p .2 Bs s ss v sss bss s p, w bs s p- ps s w s w s.3
i s w v esp-as’s s ss b p, bk ss s b, pb vb .4 W s pv ss w ps, 1980 2000,
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 4/24
644 world polItIcs
w s v w s v . W spp sv s w s. ts s, b w ss p s w s , qs s Three Worlds p.5
t ps s ws. W b w sss ss s p w s . W x s s w s-, sk s s s pssb ps. W w w sss s v p ss ws ps Three Worlds . , w sss s ps ss pv ss s p v
s s.
themeanIng of socIal s tratIfIcatIon
m ssp w s s s s xps v ps s, s s s xps. ts s pszs w w s p ss s s. P ss
s ss v, s, z pps sp s s, b ws s 1990 bk esp- as b s s pv ws s: “[W] ss b q psv,b w s s s. o v ss, ss, vss. es w p s w q b s s.”6
i s w s s, , bs svpvs s s xpss -s w w ss w ss b “” “s.” i s w bf p-ps ss w esp-as’s “ws w.”
S p conservative w s s s p psv ss s s. w p sb b ps, s p “” s . ts,
5 S l Ss Js P. a, “W S d e oecd cs: a rp rvs,” Journal o European Social Policy 16, . 1 (2006); cBb, “d Ws W rvs,” Journal o European Social Policy 16, . 1 (2006).
6 esp-as (. 1), 58.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 5/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 645
w svv w s v s b ss w s vs s xp, v s b ss- w ps s, -s ps , s s. i s w s vps— Bsk’s g, xp— s cs w ps psz s s.
Liberal w s sk pps. css bs s s ps s v s k vs b z p- b pxs s s b s. i s s, ss bs q, P’s s,
w b b s ss b -p w k.7 as P p , wv, b s ws pssv w “ks.” i s p, s pp s s p-s xsv w k ppss s s sks psb ss sp . lb w s v k v pv s s sks, v w -
s sb “-bs” qs s. t w s social democracy . lk s svv b ps, “ss s ws ws ps w s- s s . b vs, ws s s .”8 t s s s- p w s spp ss ps ps psz vss bss—ss ss s—k s ps s zsp.Pps pps ss s w s pp p Sws “pp’s ” s vk b sap P ab hss 1920s: “i pvsq, ss, p, pss. . . . [t] zs’ . . . ps bk w s bs w w v zs bw pv , s p, p.”9 ts, s w p s b q k ss w s ps .
7 K P, The Great Transormation (1944; Bs: B Pss, 2001).8 esp-as (. 1), 65.9 Q h h hk ms, Policy and Politics in Sweden: Principled Pragmatism
(Pp: tp uvs Pss 1987), 157.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 6/24
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 7/24
t
a b l e 1
d I m e n s I o n s o f w e l
f a r e s t a t e s t r a t I f I c a t I o n
W e l a r e R e g i m e I n d i c a t o r
O r i g i n a l S o u r c e
( 1 9 8 0 / 8 1 )
C u r r e n t
S o u r c e
( 1 9 8 0 / 8 1 )
L a t e s t D a t a S o u r c e
D e f n i t i o n
c s v v
p s
s s a , 1 9 8 1
s s a 2 0 0 2
b p y s
p b
p s s s ( j
p s y )
– 1
0 . 3
s
I l o , 1 9 8 1
I l o , 1 9 8 1
P s &
W s , 2 0 0 6
( . 1 7 ) , I l o , 1 9 9 6
x p p s s
v
p y s s
p g d p
– 0 . 7
0 . 5
l b
s - s p
I l o , 1 9 8 1
I l o , 1 9 8 1
I l o 1 9 9 6
s
s p
p b
s x p
– 0 . 6
0 . 4
p v p s s
e s p - a s , 1 9 9 0
n / a
s
s p
p
s s
– 0 . 3
0 . 2
p v s p
o e c d , 1 9 8 5
h r s 2 0 0 4
h r s 2 0 0 4
s
s p
s p
– 0 . 9
– 0 . 1
S s
v v s s
s s I b
c w e d
v s k s s ,
p y , k - p
- s p s
– 0 . 6
0 . 7
v b f q y
s s I b
c w e d
v
b w b s
x b f s ( p s x )
s k s s , p y ,
- s p s
– 0 . 5
0 . 7
S o u r c e s : s s a : u . S . S S y a s
, S o c i a l S e c u r i t y P r o g r a m s t h r o u g h o u t t h e W o r l d ( W s : g p o , 1
9 8 1 , 2 0 0 2 ) ) ; I l o : i l b o z ,
T h e C o s t o S o c i a l S e c u r i t y ( g v : i
l b o z , 1 9 8 1 , 1 9 9 6 ) ) ; s s I b : S c z s p i s s e s p - a s (
. 1 ) ; o e c d : o e c d ,
M e a s u r i n g H e a l t h c a r e , 1 9 6 0 – 1 9 8 3 ( P s : o e c d , 1 9 8 5 ) ; c w e d : l y S s , C o m p a r a t i v e W e l a r e E n t i t l e m e n t s D a t a s e t , u v s y c , 2 0 0 4 ) ; h r s : e v y h b ,
c s r , J d . S p s , d v B y , J s B k f , C o m p a r a t i v e W
e l a r e S t a t e s D a t a S e t ( n w s u v s y , u v s y n c , d k
u v s y
i u v s y , 2 0 0 4 ) .
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 8/24
648 world polItIcs
v x ps (4), ss w s v vs v s (2), ss s v bw v ss (0). ts s s , s ss b s w s v p.
Bs p, s Three Worlds pps v considerably p . t s ws tb 1 sw, sz vs, ps - s bk: v w s sb. (Psp w v ps +1 –1 s v.)i ps w esp-as’s p -
ss, w s ps, b s w p s x vs b s.
conservatIve s tratIfIcatIon
corporatIsm
W s ps s p w w s s s b pv v-
s w p ps, w pspv s ( s sp) s -ss pss. ts s s b b s -p pb ps s. t ps v xp s b pp b bs s Social Security Pro-
grams throughout the World .12 t s s tb 2 pvs . t s s b s s s Three Worlds 1980; s s ps 1980; ps p w xs 2004.
t k s s ss w - v pss ep s, s s, i, as, s v v s pbps ss. o w s—i Jp— v bw w ps. i s w p b ss i sps sbsvs: s 1990s s ps ss’s
s s. o w, ss ss s vs w p s.
12 S S as, Social Security Programs throughout the World (Ws, d.c.:gv P o, 1981, 2004).
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 9/24
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 10/24
650 world polItIcs
i ss s x ss , w wesp-as’s .13 t ss sw pss b-s w s. a ss, s v x ss 2004 1980. a p- s v ps ps sss. n sps, s i Jp ss 4 2.g’s x s s b w , bs ss s bs p ps s.
etatIsm
t s tb 2 pss sw s pb ps ps (s p gdp) v
pb s wks.14 us p 1980, w sss s esp-as’s ss -v s.15
i p svv s x, w p Three Worlds .16 ts ss sw p-ss bs w vs tb 2. 1980s, as, ,B, g v pv s gdp pb s pss. Sv s—c, as,
nw Z—v s s. ov, s s s ss. t xps Sw Jp, wv pb pss s s ss Three Worlds . cp 2000 w 1980 , vsp ss b s, ss sv s.17 Sss as, nw, u K, w s g, i, i, Sw.
13 a s 0 s v w w s ss; s 2 s v b ss s w ss q v; , s 4 s v s
w v sv ps ss.14 1980s, w s ss oecd, Social Expenditure Database (SOCX 2004)
(Ps: oecd, 2004) s, i lb oz; w s Cost o Social Security (gv: Ilo, 1983). Vs s s v s ss w ss. W s oecd s u Ss 1980 bs Ilo ss pps s- s v p ps sp. W s Ilo’s s i 1980, bs oecd x pb s pss b ts. W s oecd’s s ns, bs x sb pss, s pp b s pss sw.
15 t s s Sw. t Ilo sw , ss jp pbsv ps xps bw 1970s 1980s Sw, b 1.2p 2.4 p gdp. W w bv , bs,
ss, Sw s v pb s wk.16 W s xps s 1 p ss gdp, s s z. Bw 1 2.1
p (sv), s s 2, x s 4 s ss xps 2.1 p.
17 t Ilo sv 1990s sp pbp pss. pb 2000, w p
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 11/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 651
conservatIve stratIfIcatIon Index
1980 b sv p sp-s bw ss s ps Three Worlds . B ps bw “s” “” ps, w ns u Ss sw ps bw “” “w” ps. t B p sp b b p s s: Bs v s 2 cps 4 es, 6( 8). S, p u Ss ss b s bk ss s ps.18 vs
“” “s” p, s s ss ps s: w v p s ps ps p Three Worlds . t s ns s w svpb p s, , s n s, v b s.
Our results or the late 1990s suggest a decline in conservative stratifca-tion among the key conservative welare states . tw s svv
s 1980s, i g, b ss s v . i-s pb s ps sp s xps w sv -s pp “svv” s 1980s.19 W wbks v v v sv sp, w ssp w s v ss ( xp, - pb/pv s wks s pbpss), w w s s s p “pv- ss” s wks v .
lIberal s tratIfIcatIon
prIvate health spendIng
d pv sp ss 1980, p tb 3, s w p Three Worlds (
rb Ps ew Ws, “cv Sv Ps Ss W,” WBk S P dsss Pp . 602 (2006). W s s Ilo ( 1989) s v pp.
18 W ps bs S S as’s s bw
sp ps ps sp ss v s v ps. (ts s s sb b sbs s ps, s s ss v s pb ps -ps, w s w s s.)
19 a p s pb s sp v svs’ pvss s ss s v pb s wk.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 12/24
t
a b l e 3
l I b e r a l w e l f a r e
s t a t e s t r a t I f I c a t I o n
P r i v a t e H e a l t h S p e n d i n g
( % o H e a l t h S p e n d i n g )
M e a n s - T e s t e d P o o r
R e l i e
( % o T o t a l S o c i a l S p e n d i n g )
L i b e r a l S t r a t i f c a t i o n I n d e x b
E A
1 9 8 0
L a t e s t
E A
1 9 8 0
L a t e s t
E A
1 9 8 0
L a t e s t
a s
3 6 ( 4 )
3 7 ( 4 )
3 1 ( 4 )
3 . 3 ( 2 )
4 3 . 0 ( 4 )
4 9 . 0 ( 4 )
H i g h 1 2 c
1 2 a s
1 2 a s
a s
3 6 ( 4 )
3 1 ( 4 )
3 1 ( 4 )
2 . 8 ( 0 )
3 . 1 ( 0 )
3 . 4 ( 0 )
1 2 S w z .
1 2 c
1 2 c
B
1 3 ( 2 )
1 7 ( 2 )
2 8 ( 4 )
4 . 5 ( 2 )
2 . 9 ( 0 )
5 . 3 ( 0 )
1 2 u S a
1 2 u S a
1 2 u S a
c
2 6 ( 4 )
2 4 ( 4 )
2 9 ( 4 )
1 5 . 6 ( 4 )
2 0 . 2 ( 4 )
1 6 . 5 ( 4 )
1 0 a s
1 0
D e n m a r k
1 0
D e n m a r k
d k
1 5 ( 2 )
1 2 ( 2 )
1 7 ( 2 )
1 . 0 ( 0 )
1 2 . 7 ( 4 )
1 3 . 6 ( 4 )
1 0 J p
1 0 J p
1 0 J p
2 1 ( 4 )
2 1 ( 4 )
2 5 ( 4 )
1 . 9 ( 0 )
1 3 . 0 ( 4 )
1 2 . 7 ( 4 )
1 0 S w z .
1 0 S w z .
2 8 ( 4 )
2 1 ( 4 )
2 4 ( 4 )
1 1 . 2 ( 4 )
1 5 . 8 ( 4 )
1 0 . 5 ( 2 )
g y
2 0 ( 2 )
2 1 ( 4 )
2 5 ( 4 )
4 . 9 ( 2 )
4 . 1 ( 0 )
6 . 2 ( 0 )
M e d i u m 8
8
F i n l a n d
8
F i n l a n d
i
6 ( 0 )
1 9 ( 2 )
2 7 ( 4 )
5 . 9 ( 2 )
2 . 5 ( 0 )
3 . 3 ( 0 )
8 n .
8
8
N . Z e a l a n d
i y
1 2 ( 2 )
2 0 ( 2 )
2 7 ( 4 )
9 . 3 ( 4 )
3 . 4 ( 0 )
6 . 2 ( 0 )
6 d k
8 u K
8 u K
J p
2 8 ( 4 )
2 9 ( 4 )
2 2 ( 4 )
7 . 0 ( 2 )
1 1 . 9 ( 2 )
7 . 2 ( 2 )
6 g y
6 g y
6
n s
2 2 ( 4 )
3 1 ( 4 )
3 7 ( 4 )
6 . 9 ( 2 )
6 . 2 ( 0 )
2 . 8 ( 0 )
6 i y
6 n .
6 g y
n w Z
1 8 ( 2 )
1 2 ( 2 )
2 2 ( 4 )
2 . 3 ( 0 )
3 3 . 0 ( 4 )
2 7 . 9 ( 4 )
6 u K
6
N . Z e a l a n d
6
I r e l a n d
n w y
1 ( 0 )
1 5 ( 2 )
1 5 ( 2 )
2 . 1 ( 0 )
8 . 8 ( 2 )
1 8 . 1 ( 4 )
6 n .
S w
7 ( 0 )
7 ( 0 )
1 5 ( 2 )
1 . 1 ( 0 )
1 1 . 2 ( 2 )
1 2 . 0 ( 2 )
6
N o r w a y
S w z
3 5 ( 4 )
3 9 ( 4 )
4 4 ( 4 )
8 . 8 ( 4 )
8 . 4 ( 2 )
9 . 5 ( 2 )
u K
1 0 ( 2 )
1 1 ( 2 )
1 9 ( 2 )
1 . 0 ( 0 )
1 5 . 7 ( 4 )
1 5 . 9 ( 4 )
L o w 4
a s
4 a s
4 a s
u S a
( 4 )
5 4 ( 4 )
5 6 ( 4 )
1 8 . 2 ( 4 )
2 0 . 2 ( 4 )
1 9 . 7 ( 4 )
4 B
4 n w y
4 B
4
2 B
4
I t a l y
M e a n
1 9 . 6
2 3 . 3
2 7 . 4
6 . 0
1 3 . 1
1 3 . 3
2 n . Z
2 i
4 S w
S t a n d a r d
D e v i a t i o n
1 0 . 8
1 1 . 7
1 0 . 2
5 . 0
1 0 . 8
1 1 . 1
2 i
2
I t a l y
0 n w y
2 S w
0 S w
s o u r c e s : S
s t b 1 e s p - a s ( . 1 ) .
t b s s v s p
w s s ; s x s s . 2 0 2 1 .
b t
v b p v p s s p s s p
s s p ; w s e s p - a
s ’ s s s b p s . c s b
z b w e
s p - a s y s s .
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 13/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 653
xp, =0.91 s). hwv, v ss—, i, i, ns, nw— ss sb p. t s x sps nw i, w w 14 13 p p, spv. i ss, w w vs pv sp, b 5–7 p ps. ts, sp v , k s s s s v ss w “b” s. cs s s c nw Z— s p b w s—v w pv ss sp s v b w ss s b w ss. ts s, s, bs s s, p, v z
s.cp 1980 2000 sss sb “b-
z” vp sss v w-p. t v pv-- sp s 23.3 p 27.4 p. t s xp ss 5 ps bw 1980 2000, w, B nw Z, p b- ss. o as J-p, b pv “x pb-pv” sss 1980,
p decline 5 p ps 2000. i s, health care is clearly a sector with convergence around a still mostly public, but increasingly private, spending trajectory . , s s v sw b w ss sw pps pv v s svv ps.20 W w s s, s, s w w sv s b p v k p.
means- tested poor relIef
t s tb 3 p s-s ss s sp Three Worlds p. t s,Ilo’s Cost o Social Security , spp pbs s bs 1990s, s w w b x ss b 1989. t bw ss esp-as’s s v w.S n s, aps, u Kv sb s s bs s
20 i ss s x ss, w s s Three Worlds. P- v sp ss p 10 p s 0; ss bw 10 20 p s 2; pv sp ss 20 p s 4. (nb: p b s Three Worlds s below , w w u Ss !)
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 14/24
654 world polItIcs
b z. n s, ss pbb under-estimate s-s sp bs w “bs ps”sp s –s s v sb s sp -s spps bv vs ps s s.21
o s ss v s- bw “s-s” “” -s ps. tbs Three Worlds ss -s bs ks ( psb spp pss s) w x- s-s . hwv, s b-w s s s s p s, s ss b ss p-
p.22 i b s-s s s b, w s s s s-s b s b ss ss. o s sss p s bw w - ss pp ss xs ( s, s s) w ( s,w s).23
o s s ss k s
s sb w ws p Three Worlds . nw Z-, dk, , u K sb w ss. W xp ( pps J-p), s v s svv ws s sp pv s-s ps.
prIvate pensIons
d s pv pss ps s v .24 d k pb s s, wsp k vs pv Three Worlds s 1980
21 ix vs s-s ps w p p Three Worlds. s, w pp x vs nw Z as bp s v. nx, w s sz v ps s Three Worlds, –.6 +.4, w pp bs 6.7 15.6, spv.
22 t ss Three Worlds s p -s- pb psspps w s s-s sp n s u K- b w s u Ss c. i s pps -sbs ( xp, s sss ps) w x .
23 S, xp, css m (. 2).24 esp-as pvs xsv s ss s p pv ps p-
s , b s s vb; esp-as “t cps P rs: a i,” m r, gøs esp-as, l rw, s., Stag-nation and Renewal in Social Policy (ak, n.y.: m. e. Sp, 1987)). Ps s
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 15/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 655
s. W v s k v ks v sbs, w ssp pv s ss v, , s s s p.
lIberal stratIfIcatIon Index
t - s tb 3 pss b s -x 1980 s vb. Ss bw 0 12. (B s, svv sss s bw 0 8.) cp ss w ss Three Worlds 1980 sss sv s. s, ss v ss ss Three Worlds . S-, s ss v s s pvs
ss. t, s s b pv-s p. dk s sps k-bss s. i, s b w s p- ns. W s - u Ss c, s v s. mw, sv s— p, nw Z — s b 1980 pvs b ss.
Pps sk s p v .
t bw w ps sss welare states in the early twenty-frst century are more liberal than they had been just two de-cades earlier . o s w ws ss 1980, sxv ss s p. (o , ,sws b s v p.) ts s, s, ss w w ss v b “k pb” v s. i ss- s pv pss ps sp s ss s, s k v s w b . ov, s s -s s, vs sp ps, oecd w ss v bz s s.25
lxb i S, , w s p pv s s. hwv, ss lIs v ss b v s s,p ss b b ss.
25 S, xp, P Ps, Dismantling the Welare State? Reagan, Thatcher, and the Politics o Retrenchment (nw yk: cb uvs Pss, 1994); g g, Partisan Politics inthe Global Economy (cb: cb uvs Pss, 1998); d Swk, Global Capital,Political Institutions, and Policy Change in Developed Welare States (cb: cb uvs Pss, 2002); s css, The Future o the Welare State: Crisis Myths and Crisis Realities (nw yk: ox uvs Pss, 2004); P l, Growing Public: Social Spending and Economic Growth since the Eighteenth Century (nw yk: cb uvs Pss, 2004).
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 16/24
656 world polItIcs
socIalIsm
t ss s x Three Worlds ss w -ss. t s, “vss,” s p s v p
b v b p s, skss s-, pb pss. t s, “b q,” s (v-) s x p p, skss, pb ps ps. t - b s s w S czspis Pj.26 t cpv W es ds(cwed) s v p s-s s x. tb 4 pvs ; s cwed 2002. As was the case with welare state liberalism, our results dier considerably rom conventional wisdom regarding which countries score high
or their “socialist” welare program principles .
unIversalIsm
cwed ss s s s ps 1980 w vs ss Three Worlds . i ss -’s v v s v w 10 p w ws -p. cv s svv w ss
(sp as, B, , g, i, i, ns) u.K. ds v svv vss s ss pp w s b pvs p. cv s ( 20 p ) s: u.K., i, , B.27 o ss ss vss s ppb w p Three Worlds as c.28
i w p w s vss 2002 w 1980,
v s s s, ss- v- s p s w ps. uvss s
26 ts s s pb vb.27 i pps ss s s Three Worlds P , State, Economy ,
and Society in Western Europe, 1815–1975: A Data Handbook (k/c: cps V/S. Js Pss, 1983). rss u K Three Worlds v bs n is bs, s v. cv s i, , B p s , s ws p. cwed ss ss B. , cwed ss ss p b salarie non-salarie v b assurance maladie s s sss. ts s ps vss s ’s s. cwed ss s b ps s v pss ’s , s s svvs s p ps spps.
28 i s ss bs w s p s bv (sx-v) p ps. i c cwed ss p s bs sss c ss p s v.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 17/24
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 18/24
658 world polItIcs
b w s, as Swz, -ss sb , i. as’s s w s s s-s ps. i Swz s s bz skss s ss sq p b pp ps pv skss s bs. i i sp s psp s b ss w vs w s.29
benefIt equalIty
B q, w Three Worlds , s p s v s x (psx) bs p-
, skss, ps s. o ss sss s-b q s ss vb pp . o ss w w 10 p sp Three Worlds v ss.
nb, s sps s v ss s b w s, p, c, uK, u Ss. t sp u Ss(63 p vss 22 p) s s . t u Ss
s skss p, s w ss s 0.30
hwv, s x bs s w ps s . o s s bs s bs b vp b S S as s ps b ps s s. p s, v s ps, s , pbs b 50 p v w, k sp b x p b bs . ev s u.S. pss w k x b b w s sb w k s q s w (.54), b s .22.
t q s c Three Worlds s s xpb w.c’s skss p s p s- ss, s q s w ps .
29 W s s x ss vss s standardized ps,s w s-s bs (. 19). t p w vss s s z=–.6, w p s s z=.7.
30 a w ss , , v skss ps. ts ps v s v s p s, b s wk s ss s , w s v p.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 19/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 659
t s x ps s s bs ,bs ps b ws bw apw w s p’s s 1980 ( js bv s 1980 2002).
, q s u K s s s pv Three Worlds . es- bs b skss p s b/bs w bw v p wk’s ( apw ) w. ts, s x b s b p-s. t s- ps ss s 1970s v b bv s w, b p ws s w 1980. a ps w x bs
1979 w v pb ps apw wk w b .
cp s q bw 1980 2002pvs sb v w ss v bss s 1980s. h s xp- b .31 B q -b as, , i, ns s Swz-, u.K., u.S. o- nw s
v s q s.32
socIalIst stratIfIcatIon Index
t - s tb 4 pss b x 1980 2002 x pv Three Worlds. Our results challenge the conventional views that countries conventionally described as socialist score high on the socialist stratifcation index while other countries score low. s, w v v s s, Sw dk, s p ss 1980. -’s s s b s ; nw vs p . mw, c, “qss b” w s v vw, ss s-s s ss. t u K, w f- zsp b , s v x ss s x s 1980.
31 t s s bw 1980 2002 , w ps x b , s p s b vs. t p s s s p v s.
32 ix ss q w bs z-vs s Three Worlds . Ss bw z=–.5 ws 0, w s bv 0.7 w s 4.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 20/24
660 world polItIcs
lk ss 2002, w sbs v -s v ssps b ss ps w s. s, s v -q p. tw , i B, v - s -vs sss. S, ns s p.
dIscussIon
t p ss pv ss pss -s s ps sv ss.i s ss, ss s w w ws p
Three Worlds 1980. B w v s sb v ps s s s b s w ss.
i s p b , k bs w psp q Three Worlds , ss s v v s ss; w v p ss s- s s. t w s
s ss s s bs b p bss Three Worlds p s vs, sp s s s v ss.
i s s p ss ps Three Worlds w, , sk sz s ps. i ps, s s , , ss: svv, b,ss. mv, w s, i nw Z,s p, s s -s w w. o , u K-, pp p . is ss w w ss (b ss) w . ts k s b f Three Worlds s sbsq vp w ss.33
33 a ss () w pbs ss s vbs sss w s x, b, ss, svv s (spv), +.55, –.62, .07 –.34, –.23, +.60. t s s, , ss w Three Worlds , bs bb w ss, w x ss ss b-sss p svs svv s s (v) v - w bs ss.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 21/24
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 22/24
t a b l e 5
r e g I m e
c l u s t e r I n g b a s e d o n r e a n a
l y z e d s o c I a l s t r a t I f I c a t I o n
I n d I c e s
E a r l y 1 9 8 0 s
L a t e s t
C o n s e r v a t i v e
L i b e r a l
S o c i a l i s t
C o n s e r v a t i v e
L i b e r a l
S o c i a l i s t
h
8 a s
1 2 a s
8 U K
8 a s
1 2 a s
8 d k
8 F i n l a n d
1 2 c
6 C a n a d a
8 F i n l a n d
1 2 c
8 I r e l a n d
8
1 2 u S a
6 d k
8
1 2 u S a
6 B e
l g i u m
8 g y
1 0 D e n m
a r k
6 n .
1 0
D e n m a r k
6 C a n a d a
8 i y
1 0 J p
6 S w
1 0 J p
6 n w y
1 0 S w z .
1 0 S w z .
6 S w
6 U K
m
6 B
8 F i n l a n d
4 a s
6 B
8
F i n l a n d
4 a s
6 J a p a n
8
4 A u s t r i a
6 N o r w a y
8
N . Z e a l a n d
4 a s
4 n w y
8 u K
4 B
4 I t a l y
8 u K
4 F i
n l a n d
4 S w e d e n
6 g y
4 F r a n c e
4 G e r m a n y
6
4 g y
4 U S A
6 n
.
4 g y
4 J p
6 g y
4 n .
6 N . Z e a l a n d
4 I r e l a n d
4 U K
6
I r e l a n d
4 n . Z
4 n . Z
4 U S A
6 n .
4 N o r w a y
6
N o r w a y
4 S w z .
l w
2 d k
4 a s
2 F i n l a n d
2 a s
4 a s
2
2 i
4 i
2 i y
2 d k
4 B
2 i y
2 N e t h e r .
4 n w y
0 J p
2 i
4
I t a l y
2 J a p a n
2 u K
2 B
0 u s a
2 N e t h e r .
4 S w
2 S w
i t z .
0 a s
2 I t a l y
2 S w
0 u S a
0 c
2 S w
0 c
0 n . Z
0 n . Z
0 S w z .
0 S w z .
c s b p p e s p - a s
’ s s .
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 23/24
socIal stratIfIcatIon and welfare regImes 663
s s s. B s s v .
nw vs b x b ss x. mw, w ss ss 1980s—i B—s sss x 2002. ts, in 2002 most countries scoring highon the socialist dimension are not countries identifed as socialist in Three Worlds (or elsewhere). , 2002 ks k conservative/liberal b ss w s.
conclusIon
i s w v s ssss s -s p- ss k sp w s, p w sbsq s s b bs. as w xs x , w ss s ps sb ss p spp - w ps. s, s sz. P-ps , s v s ss s.
W w k s s, w pp sv “ws w”? o ss v svp ps wk. s, ss s qs pvs p ss p s w s-.37 S, p, ss s qss b p spp “w s,” s pps “w- ps.” t p ssp s ( s) Three Worlds s w s ps p w s b ss . o ss p wss b s , , b sbj sps.
t, ss ss s b s v ws s s 1980s. o , vz sk p s bsv s sw. o , s s sps (p bs, pss, sk p) b vs p b s s ppx f-
bs s s s pp . o f, s37 t p -n ss b bvs— xp, s xp vb
bss ss ss. B s pb pps s-n pss, s s s s b s s bs sss ss.
7/28/2019 2008 Social Stratification and Welfare Regimes for the Twenty-First Century_Revisiting the Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2008-social-stratification-and-welfare-regimes-for-the-twenty-first-centuryrevisiting 24/24
664 world polItIcs
w s ss p; p z x bs s s sp ps s s “sz” ws.
W v s sz s. W v w -ss s w sks s s w v z. B b w s ss k v ws . i v ws s , w w ss w -s .38
38 o v vw ss s fw ss spp v s. hwv, w w ps x. W s b s v x v ss vs z w . o ss b bj ss p p p.
Top Related