8/14/2019 Young v Valhi and Harold Simmons Et Al 382 A2d 1372

1/7

^j`c # Em xbc Oeaaek _xeog pbfic)jx xbc sjac xfac) xe ~|e}fhc mjf|) |cjsekjlic jkh czf!xjlic x|cjxackx xe ]jibf's oeaaek sxeogbeihc|s exbc|xbjk Oekx|jk xb|e`b xbc crobjk`c em (

8/14/2019 Young v Valhi and Harold Simmons Et Al 382 A2d 1372

5/7

^j`c =

?2< J+>>)>>>|csixfk` m|ea ifzfhjxfek em fxs j`|foix|ji ~j|xkc|!sbf~ pfxb ^|hckxfji Fks|jkoc Oea~jkv em Jac|fojscx emm j`jfksx Oekx|jk's xjr iess oj||v!me|pj|h j}jfi!jlic me| o||ckx sc fk xbc jaekx em (3>>)>>>) peihbj}c cmmcoxch xexji xjr sj}fk`s em (:3>)>>>) e| j~!

~|erfajxciv (+?8 ~c| sbj|c+ Bepc}c|) F ja sjxfsmfchxbjx sob xv~c em xjr sj}fk`s oeih lc jobfc}ch lvacjks exbc| xbjk xbc ac|`c| bc|c ~|e~esch) kjacivlv jozfsfxfek em jk 2># Fkxc|csx fk xbc oeaaek

sxeog em]jibf lv Oekx|jk) lv xbc ac|`c| em xbc sajiiOekx|jk WMK=Q fkxe ]jibf) e| xb|e`b exbc| oe|~e|jxcjozfsfxfeks+

MK=+ Hcmckhjkxs j|`c xbjx sob j ac|`c|peih lc kmcjsflic fk if`bx em ifxf`jxfek~ckhfk` j`jfksx Oekx|jk+

Js xe xbc ~essflfifxv em mx|c oekmifoxs em fkxc|csxlcxpcck Oekx|jk jkh ]jibf fksemj| js lsfkcss e~!~e|xkfxfcs j|c oekoc|kch) fx asx lc le|kc fk afkhxbjx Oekx|jk fs j beihfk` oea~jkv) e}c| 6># Em xbcjsscxs em pbfob oeksfsx em]jibf's oeaaek sxeog) jkh

xbjx ~jsx oekmifoxs em fkxc|csx) sob js xbc jiieojxfek emijkh hc}cie~ackx e~~e|xkfxfcs lcxpcck sob sl!sfhfj|v jkh fxs ~j|ckx) xbc ca~ievccs em pbfob j|cjoxjiiv ]jibf's pfxb ekc croc~xfek) jkh fxs aobij|`c| slsfhfj|v) bj}c lcck afkfaji+ Lx jssafk`xbc|c xe bj}c lcck afke| oekmifoxs em fkxc|csx fk xbc~jsx js xe pbfob em xbc xpe oe|~e|jxc ckxfxfcs bc|cfk}ei}ch sbeih bj}c bjh xbc e~~e|xkfxv xe `e fkxexbc liclc||v lsfkcss e| xe hc}cie~ iexs fk J|gjksjs)jkh jssafk` sfafij| ~|elicas js xe pbfob em xbc xpeoe|~e|jxfeks sbeih lc emmc|ch sob j mx|c e~~e|x!kfxv) |cifjkoc ek sob ~|fkof~ic kjaciv xbjx ~exckxfjioekmifoxs em fkxc|csx sbeih lc j}efhch) fs) F lcifc}c)

seacpbjx oekx|f}ch fk if`bx em xbc |cs~coxf}c sftcs emxbc xpe oe|~e|jxfeks bc|c fk}ei}ch jkh xbcf| ~jsxfkxc|!oe|~e|jxc hcjifk`s fk xbc ~c|feh pbfob bjscij~sch sfkoc Oekx|jk's jozfsfxfek em oekx|ei+

Pbc|c xbc ~j|xfcs ljsfojiiv hfmmc| js xe xbc ckxf|c mjf|!kcss em xbc ac|`c| fk fssc fs js xe xbc ojsb ~|e~eschxe lc ~jfh xe xbc afke|fxv sxeogbeihc|s em ]jibf)kjaciv xbc sa em (# ^|cafa e}c| jkh jle}cxbc |cockx aj|gcx ~|foc em ]jibf sxeog) j ~|foc j||f}chjx jmxc| ~jfksxjgfk` |cscj|ob lv Jijk J+ Aescs em

Heafkfog jkh Heafkfog) jk fkhc~ckhckx fk}csxackxljkgfk` besc) pbfob bjh cj|ifc| mekh j ~|foc em(:3 xe (:= j sbj|c) j mf`|c (< xe (? jle}c xbc J!`sx ?>) :60= aj|gcx ~|foc) xe lc mjf| xe ]jibf's hfs!sckxfk` afke|fxv sxeogbeihc|s khc| xbc ~|e}fsfeks emxbc ~|e~esch :60= ac|`c| pbfob mjfich xe |cocf}c xbc|czfsfxc }exc) jixbe`b) em oe|sc) sob ac|`c| oek!xca~ijxch xbc fssjkoc xe ]jibf sxeogbeihc|s em sc|fcs

:> Xbeasek \cxc|s+ Ke Oijfa xe E|f`+ S_ @e}+ Pe|gs+

8/14/2019 Young v Valhi and Harold Simmons Et Al 382 A2d 1372

6/7

^j`c 0

?2< J+ jkh xbjxxbc se!ojiich lckob aj|g sjic xe ]jibf lv xbcAoOj|xbvs em xbcf| 3?)?=8 sbj|cs em ]jibf jx (:= ~c|sbj|c pjs kex jk j|as' ick`xb x|jksjoxfek) fx lcfk`oicj| jx xbc xfac xbjx A|+ Bj|eih _faaeks bjh scx~ek j oe|sc em oekhox hcsf`kch xe |choc fk fa!~e|xjkoc jkh ixfajxciv xe cifafkjxc jii afke|fxv fk!xc|csxs fk ]jibf) j oe|~e|jxc ~eifov kex jooc~xjlic xexbc AoOj|xbvs+ Fk sbe|x) F ja sjxfsmfch xbjx xbcAoOj|xbvs) joxfk` cj|ifc| xb|e`b Mj|kbja Oe|~e|j!xfek) jkh bj}fk` ajkj`ch ]jibf's j`|foix|ji joxf}f!xfcs ksoocssmiiv h|fk` j h|e`bx ~c|feh) jkh bj}!fk` mjfich xe beih oekx|ei em ]jibf fk :603) pc|c oek!

xckx) ~j|xfoij|iv fk if`bx em xbc xbck oekxfkfk` pcsxoejsx h|e`bx) xe pfxbh|jp m|ea ]jibf pfxb xbc lcsx`|joc jkh ~|foc ~essflic+

MK0+ _cc _pjkxek }+ _xjxc @j|jkxv Oe|~e!|jxfek) Hci+Ob+)

8/14/2019 Young v Valhi and Harold Simmons Et Al 382 A2d 1372

7/7

^j`c 2

?2< J+