x!.*.m.. - LUKMAAN IAS...2. 9 (a) since there are law, rules., regulations, ethlcs and conscience to...

1 QUESTION ANSWER BOOKLET I CSE-GS (MAIN) 2016 PAPER IV

TEST XV (MOCK TEST IV)

1 ETHICS, INTEGRITY & APTITUDE I 1 / ~ i m e Albwed : Three ours] I Maximum Marks : 2501

QUESTION PAPER SPECIFIC INSTRUCTIONS

I w c rcad cach of ihc tollo\v~np 1n5trt1ctions c ; ~ ~ - c ~ ~ I I I v O~forc n t l e n i n t ~ n ~ i o n s l There are F0URTEI:N cluestlons dlvltlrd 111 nvo sccttons dncl printed in ENGLISH. 1 I All questions arc compulsory. I I

I The number of marks carried by a question/part i s intlicatcd against i t I I 1 Answer must be written in the medium authol-iscd in the Admission Certificate which must be 1 I 1 ststed ctarly on thecover ofthis Question-cum-Ansrvcr (QCA) Bookkt in the spaceprovided. No 1 I 1 marks will be grveri Tor ansrucr written i n medium other th<irn the atrthorized one. I I I l2'ord limit in questions, if spcciCicti, shoukl be adhered to. 1 I 1 Any page or portion of the pagc left blank in the Question-cum-Answer Booklet must be clearly f I I struck off. I Marks Detail ~ a m c ...rz?.!!k!* .... x!.*.m..

.................................... I

Roll No.:

I Mob. h o .................................... qm4c(?3-7c(~

Starting Time:- 1' '

Invipilator" Signature

Scanned by Camscanner A

Salamuddeen

Rectangle

LUKMAAN IAS .... Lawlwith E@ ...

Do not wrilc in this space.

SPACE FOR TEACHER'S REMARKS

1. Understanding of cluestions:

2. Structure of answer:

3. Content of answer:

4. Presentation:

5. Any other remarks:

Scanned by Camscanner

LUKMAAN IAS

Section A

(a) What are hurnan nature and ~ ts role in guiding human c o r ~ d ~ c t ? MOW human nature of Indian people can be described:'

(i) I t is due to human nature that India has peace and harmony in our society.

(ii) Human nature of people is rcsporlslble for no or slow progress of our country in many aspects. (150 words) 10

Scanned bycamscanner

LUKMAAN IAS I

in this space.


LUKMAAN IAS ...= L& with E@ ...

ce4.o e-*

@ WITH - l ; ~ 4 s m 1-5

P_ i d w && - i Y c ( L l a

Y


LUKMAAN IAS a.a. L tad with E@...

7 1 . (bi inf? laea of 'minimum government and maximum governance' has

become a popular model of governance todav in thn hpht of t h , ~ A .

- 1 . ... -,--

I "<

Slarement. ~nalvse the following questions with suitable ii~......_..~ and in the end explain how ethics can help in reconciling both views?

1. It propagates the philosophy of Mahattt~a Gandhi-that peep should govern themselves, that is, self governance^

I -

I ii. This idea runs afoul to the fart that people cannot govern t hemsnlves, they must be governed. (1 50 words) 10


LUKMAAN BAS .... ~ d w i t h E @ s = s

DO nu- e' ?+ w &krn intbisy bs _.___

in

' -4

R M & s b L Y C - 9 6/


LUKMAAN (AS


LUKMAAN IAS


mm.. &&with E*..m Q la thj!

2.

9

(a) since there are law, rules., regulations, ethlcs and conscience to gulde public servants conducts, most of the tlme they rnay face moral

dilemma In this context consider the following questions:

i. In such situation one should give preference to law and rule over conscience as the latter is difficult to establish objectively.

ii. Explain with any specific example which has conflict between them that how you will overcome such moral dilemma?

(150 words) 10

.... 3. Gwen are two quotations ,,lumI thinkerlphiloro~h ?,. For each of these,

bring out what it means to you in the present context:

(a) "It is easy to hate and a is difficult to love. This i5 how thewhole scheme

15

- Do not writ, in this space.


LUKMAAN IAS .m*m Lasdwith E* *.*

D o not write

&OeAteS rYuicc in this space.

dc w;;l-

7 , b - W2s' U C -

_,r..c

: 7 - J M , A nari - P 'P I

d - &3 ' ~3-2

& .)

5 w 5 m wJ@+

C H & tM+fa*( j r i z 7f 1

-tlrLYi m f d / (J@rc-nu


Scanned by Camscanner - --

LUKMAAN IAS .... Ldwi th E@===

n G b in this spa,,.

/

.

WtQ

LUKMAAN IAS .... Lmwith EW... /

00 no>,t b m - e ~ ~ ~ ) & bb in this space%

in a~a~m k e l ' h ' e 5


LUKMAAN IAS

(a) Should society adhere to &r tradition and culture Or it should accept change? In this context consider the following questions: in this spa,,

(200 words) 10

i. Tradition and culturegive identity to society and hence, it should not be changed.

i i . Change is inevitable, it is only unchanging reality.

In the end, discuss how ethics can help in bringing clarity on the above issue.

Scanned by Camscanner - *-.

LUKMAAN IAS -

4. (b) Discu-jr)

I

I '-f1, ethical public administrator. in this

t k

i. He/she must pay attention to both, immoral means to attain moral ends; and moral means to attain r-noral ends.

I it- Helshe must prefer policy impartiality over ethical neutrality. (150 words) 10 I

LUKMAAN IAS

i. They have strengthened democracy at the cost of governance. ii. They have strengthened both governance and democracy but at the

cost of economic growth. (150 words) 10

.... L W with E*...


There is a view that in the last three decades governments have given too many rights 10 citizens wch as in terms of local bodicr, Citizen's chaner, RTI, RTE, whistle-blowing law, rights getting expansion due t o innovative interpretation by judiciary, etc. In the light of this statement, answer the following questions.

"Of write in this

LUKMAAN IAS 111.

Do OO>~+

in this bpar e.

. \ U

@-.

29


LUKMAAN IAS

(150 words) 10

Qdlic. EC*an.h SUAU Z K >

efkw *cA& a u e y t c I m.mm


6. Discuss the reasons why public servants are expected for ,more ducipline in their conduct than others and hence there are code of c o n i d code of

DO- 4 i n spa,

ethics for them? Is a public servant only a public servant during office hnllrq nr

ethical norms should be practiced outside office hours also? Explain.

LUKMAAN IAS -

Scanned by Camscanner -

LUKMAAN (AS t... Lstld with E m ...

What meant bureaucratic work culture and how it is different from ~'o~es~io..l work culture? Discuss the facton rrsponriblc for their djsfjnetive characteristics. DO you think that a fully prof~srinnaliscd br~resvcricy will not S I J ~ ~ $0 Indian conditions? Give ju~lification lo W U view (150 wordr) 10

DO not write in this space, I--


LUKMAAN IAS


Scanned by Camscanner % -- -

LUKMAAN IAS

All nations give first priority to their citizens for example they are given some constitutional rights which are not enjoyed by people of other countries. Doesn't it show giving preference to citizen over human? Is it ethically justifiable to di~lde D P O P ~ ~ on the basis of citizenship, that is, territorial sovereignty7 I l I ~ ~ r t r a t ~ und erplcr~r~. (150 words) 1U

G ' N - C ~ ;Q ;r r +W

-,k

n this spree.

ned by Camscanner -7%-

L U K ~ ~ ~ ~ IAS D m m m L*with E*...

Rj.e - F~F .sPA- Chnned Do not II n'tc

pms f-t) gcS- e in this space,

l%vcSu3 - virCrce $ 'k+ P l).?ydb - avC*-' __ -

e

wtcX- s==

g ~ . o - k - @ - ' & A 7 .

&&,JjJ& ju~graQ :, t - I - - "9 lY &a

.i?s===

& * Lr. LP' '-

38

Scanned by Camscanner -----\IX-_~

LUKMAAN IAS

Scanned by Ca,mScanner

LUKMAAN IAS

ping and rape in-moving ch city. There have been

informed and formal complaints were filed but s t i l l the menace was not addressed. Interestingly, in one such case when complained was filed by the woman, the m e h ims~l f became stalker. These Incidents have found wide coverage in the media which has further abetted fedslness and lack of safety to women. It is also a setback to the city police which has in past special drives for creating awareness on women safety and has taken many measures including community policing.

a) Suppose you are the Deputy Police Commissioner in the city then what more specific measures will be taken to tackle the menace of stalking and other issues?

b) Discuss the behavioural problems of the police in thiscase and whether disciplinary action as transfer is sufficient orthere in need for upholding police accountability if i t is, so how?.


LUKMAAN IAS m s m m Lasdwith [email protected]

i r imktJ-.

#, V Y ) ! w u d 6 5 [ :

& Hok bl_ fi*u. & 4 &cks 7 I' -QYr

C

\ire - i* ir*j. T e ~ m e P--

LUKMAAN IAS -


LUKMAAN IAS ...I Ladwith E*...

Do no;;', in this space.

m*

rrck b - 4

c- ( not coo+ be- re -

Ci) k d o 4 - * +-&!!!+ e e h u ~

' ~ Y Z ~ . * mule J ";P

eam4.t-

L 3 V t e h . o ~

- 43

- - - - --"-- --Scanned by Camscanner

LUKMAAN IAS

) bordering her state. I

....

I Although she has not filed a formal complaint but the incident has gone viral on social media. There have been reactions also from all quarters including government of India. It is very shameful for thefountry that people belonging tfl a particular region are still doubted on thelr natlonallty. 1

( Suppose you are the head of the immigration department of the airport then 1

DO-& in thissparc

10.

I a) Give your reaction to the above incident. 1

There is a report of racism at one such international airport of the C s w . Miss A has alleged that the immigration officerjhumiliated. her by repeatedly ~ ~ k i n g u e r t ~ o n r about her-aiity. he officer looked at her P ~ ~ S P O ~ and told you didn't look like an Indian. The officer alsoasked her other inappropriate quPstions like nc~rnh~r of 5t;ltcs in the country and thc number of state5

I b) Evaluate the following options and choose the most appropriate one, giving reasons - -I

I i. NO any courses of action will be taken as i t is one-off incident. 1 I ii. Only warning should be issued to the officer that he should not

repeat in future. I I iii. First allegation should be established and Miss A should be

persuaded to file a formal complaint t o proceed for disciplinary action against the officer. I

iv. Warning should be issued to the officer and a sensitisation Programme should be initiated in the department about for appropriate conduct. (250 words) 20

nc- i w d d I

--A Scanned sv.w-A. by Camscanner

LUKMAAN IAS


LUKMAAN IAS /

canmur\i -

47


Scanned by Camscanner - - + -

LUKMAAN IAS

LUKMAAN IAS

The emergency like situation has restllted into respiratory related prohl~ms such heart and asthma and children are being considered as the most vulnerable. One death has also been reported.

Suppose you are the -he pollution_6tePaLUnent of the city then

a) Is it failure of environmental governance or a humafiure? Analyse the factors responsible for failure of regylition of human activities in the city. /

b) What should be the immediate steps taken to tackle the emergency?

c] Discuss the medium and long term steps so that the city air pollution is contained at acceptable. (250 words) 20

\rs- W k 4-b- 94

Lstd with E~JE... emem

I Recently, a metro~olitan city which is also the NCTof the cuuntlyis ~xperiencir~g r n o l witc -


- eXtremC a i r n u t i o n due to which i t has been unofficially declared as

I L ~ ! The City appears to be like a gas chamber. C

The immediate causes are burning o f m s t u b b l e s in vicinity states a n d k e c s e r s on the festive occasion. The other factors are related with city lifestyle wherein most of the human polluting activities remain largely u s u l a t e d . Other cities in the country which are close to the vicinity states have also started facing air pollution problems.

in thisspacc.

LUKMAAN IAS ..ID Lasd with E@...

I mod - ; canhro po-trt*cl f i s~yc DO*,, in (hi5 xP*t

/ MC la;r*iC,+ b e -1

LUKMAAN IAS .... L&with E a r n . .

w c f t u l ~ c : Do not write \ in this space.

--CC

w - mm* Q. wyd $ br_l

3 -7f fih'3e.M ,A-

a W a

iMb-. _____L

4

&n&u&rn s > 6(d;*b &- -7

I


LUKMAAN [AS .... Ladwith Ek@=== /

h 2 k - k p!4d! & * in DO*,, this

&

Cki\bren , o\ b u

, . ,4

I

- 53

Scanned by Camscanner I '

11.1 Ladwith E*... h7vd+e k \SSU advirw Do not write

2 in this space.

- -

0 kdw\oa*-Q

.--c..----c- iekMeQ


LUKMAAN IAS ~ejrdwith Etgpmmm w w m m

/ A wrestler who ha5 participatpd at international and n a t l o , n ? ? m t t birth to reoresent India in the upcorning Olyrnpic through a court battle in ihisspact replacing the sportsperson who won a medal in the last O l ~ r n ~ i c .

When few days are left in the event. there are reports of doping against He alleges for foul practices by some people in his foods. initial investlgarlo~ also happen3 frorrl ~ h ~ s : angle. tie Is being portray5 as cledll.

The Indian anti-doping agency also clears his name which is challenged in the "--. .".%..mC

world anti-doping agncy. This agency rule against the wrestler and consequently, he loses chance to participate in the Olympic. At this stage, India loses chance to replace him in the category he could have participated. Most importantly, image of the country has suffered. - Suppose you were the concerned authority to take a final decision on his participation and replacement at early stage when the controversy first surfaced then I_L

a) Discuss the courses of action that you could have followed and give reasons in justification.

b) What steps should be taken by the sports authorities in the country to avoid such embarrassment at national and international level.

c) To what extent adoption of a code of sports ethics at national level will help in this regard? (250 words) 20

Scanned by Camscanner .*". 9 . " " -L-.rU.-..

. . -"- ,. . , . . .,..,.& . ., . .. . - l..l--."--.-l-l_.l. ._ ..- . ..-, --.- * ~. A

- ,

LUKMAAN IAS mm m m Led with E*...

$

Scanned by Camscanner ,;

LUKMAAN IAS

-" Id- in this space.


LUKMAAN IAS ..ll Ledwith E@ ...

1dedQJ-Q +kF F3 Do not write in this space.

5 && ~ " 4 U - a LCC-


LUKMAAN IAS


LUKMAAN IAS

law and order problems. This has also been corroborated by a report on the issue by the NHRC, which has also become controversial. I

I...

Interestingly, the city has always had communal harmony. It has seen no trace of communal tension even at a time when parts of UP witnessed a lot of violence and communal hatred during 2013. I

There is a historical city in one of the districts of up, Recently, it has been in

news due to controversy on a report by a person of the city that there has been exodus of people only belonging to majority community although they are in minority in the city. /'w-

The controversy is on the claim that the migration is only due to fear of the dominant community in the city and not due to other reasons such as search

+= 6 better life, employment, safety and security due to gagsters menace and

a) Suppose you are the District Magistrate of that district then what should be your immediate priorities and why? I

Do not "rite

in this

b) Discuss the role and significance of various stakeholders you will seek help and why? I

I c) Discuss your courses of actions which will be able to not only provide short term solution but also be long lasting in establishing rule of law and peace and harmony in the city. (250 words) 25 I


LUKMAAN IAS mm.. sadw with Ec@=.. -

Do not writc in this space.

&- AmM -m r-

6 4

Scanned by Camscanner ,

LUKMAAN IAS


LUKMAAN IAS lm.. Lad with Ect~.. .

Since the location is in remote area which is sp;trs~iy populated, there are over

m i a t i o n which are going to be affected in relocation. The locality has children, youths, adult men and women, aged,'farmers, local traders and b~rsir i r~sr~ren. 1 hey have been llvlna happily i r l that r ~ ~ ~ , o t ~ , ~ ~ and with their C O ~ C efforts; Iare~ly the village has been self rel iqt .

They are not against the plant or any developmental project but they also don't - want disru~Qon in their lifestyle, social harmony, belongingness and emot~onal attachment, recreation, business, and farming, which they have narrated to you on your visit to the area. Some of them have even threatened that if this h a s n , they will commit suicide.

Suppose you are a government officer and has been given with adequate Power the task t o successfully r e a t e them, then

wha t will be your order of priority to the above stakeholders while exploring various options and why?

b) What are the various options available to you?

) Evaluate them and choose the most appropriate One. giving ~easons.

14. Do not write n this spacc.

Government has officially decided to con'struct a nuclear power plant in one district of a staLe. All the clearances have been done such as design, disaster ~r=ng.,o,[~Jkarea, population which will be relocated, etc., and the locat.ion has been found v w , e a l for the plant.


LUKMAAN IAS


LUKMAAN IAS m.. I

-, -tLj be Do not write in this space.


LUKMAAN IAS


x!.*.m.. - LUKMAAN IAS...2. 9 (a) since there are law, rules., regulations, ethlcs and conscience to...

Documents

Transcript of x!.*.m.. - LUKMAAN IAS...2. 9 (a) since there are law, rules., regulations, ethlcs and conscience to...