Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

21
www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

Transcript of Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

Page 1: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Pilot Project Report

PENNSYLVANIAASPHALTIMPROVEMENTNETWORK(PASIN)

Page 2: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Intent

Pennsylvania ASphalt Improvement Network (PASIN)

an initiative to develop, pilot and implement an ISO 9000-2000 based Quality Management System (QMS) from pavement design through qualification, procurement, manufacture, delivery of materials, installation, acceptance testing and maintenance of asphalt pavement

Page 3: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Intent

• The objective of the Phase 1 PASIN Pilot effort was to test the construction portion of the overall Asphalt Pavement Delivery Process during the 2007 construction season.

• This effort continued with Phase 2 PASIN Pilots, applying lessons learned from 2007 to projects in the 2008 construction season.

Page 4: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Who was involved Phase 1 2007

• ECMS No. 75816, Schuylkill County I 81-07M in District 5-0.

Eastern Industries, Inc.

• ECMS No. 57791, Jefferson Co. SR 28 Section 510 Game School Road 3R in District 10-0.

HRI, Inc.

PAPA

Page 5: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Who was involved Phase 2 2008

• ECMS No.79105, Lycoming County, SR 15 Section A20/A30 NB, in District 3-0.

Glenn O. Hawbaker, Inc.

• ECMS No. 80092, Fayette County, SR 21 Betterment in District 12-0.

A. Folino / Hansen

PAPA

Page 6: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

PASIN Implementation Process

1. Say what you

do

2. Do what you

say

3. Prove it

4. Improve it

Page 7: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Quality Management System Components

• 1 Control of Documents• 2 Control of Quality Records• 3 Control of Nonconforming Product• 4 Customer Complaints• 5 Corrective and Preventative Actions• 6 Internal Audit• 7 Management Review

Page 8: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Quality Manager

PASIN Steering

Team

Company Mgt. Team

Best Practices Support

Internal Audit Team

PASIN Impl. Team

External Audit Team

PASIN Implementation Teams

Page 9: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Process Overview

• Review the Requirements of the Contract

– Special Provision requirements– Links to 408 requirements

• Assign Quality Manager Responsibilities

– Authority over plant and field processes– Develop quality management processes– Assign documentation responsibilities

Page 10: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Process Overview

• Develop HMA Production & Paving Plan– Incorporate the Production Best Practices (74) – Incorporate the Paving Best Practices (42) – Establish methods to monitor the key controls– Incorporate capturing metrics data – Address the Quality Management System

Components

Page 11: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Process Overview

• Establish a Management Review Team

• Implement HMA Production and Paving Plan

– provided training to the plant and field personnel on the Best Practices and Key Control Points.

– provided training on new checklists, log reports, maintenance of records, etc.

Page 12: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Process Overview

• Conduct Internal Audits– made up of contractor employees – trained by PASIN Implementation Team

• Report Outcomes– Metrics data– Records of system implementation results

• Internal audits• Corrective and Preventative Action Reports (CPAR)

– Participate in an After Action Review

Page 13: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Results

• Process successfully implemented– Implementation Plan Template was an

improvement• Management closely involved

– But could play a larger role• Communication links improved• Documentation improved

– Non-conformances– Customer Complaints

Page 14: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Hawbaker Plant

Page 15: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Hawbaker Field Operations

Page 16: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Better Materials Plant

Page 17: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

A. Folino Paving

Page 18: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Conclusions

The production processes were not altered much Best Practices and Key Controls guide to

success

The documentation effort was greatly increased over normal procedures Uniform processes Reminders to stay on track Learning tools

Electronic documentation is easily accessible company wide

Page 19: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Barriers

• Industry partners must – Understand the requirements– Recognize the need to improve– be willing to adopt the system

• Department staff needs to– Understand the process the contractor is undergoing– Audit the QC plan implementation– Build a comfort level that QC is improved

Page 20: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Next Steps

• Finalizing the report

• Recommending additional pilots in 2009

• Expanding to all Districts in 20??

• Companies applying system throughout their organization

• Becoming the standard procedure

Page 21: Www.dot.state.pa.us Pilot Project Report PENNSYLVANIA ASPHALT IMPROVEMENT NETWORK (PASIN)

www.dot.state.pa.us

Thank You for your attention

2008 PASIN Quality Managers

Rick Hetzel Bill Scott Bob Bunting