Ws Optimizing Wp03b Overview FRA Miyoshi
description
Transcript of Ws Optimizing Wp03b Overview FRA Miyoshi
-
Energy Saving Technology by Proper Remodeling of Hull
Jun MIYOSHI
Regional Training Workshop on Optimizing Energy and Safety at Sea for Small-Scale Fishing Vessels, SEAFDEC
Feb. 47, 2013, Bangkok
National Research Institute of Fisheries Engineering, FRA
PresenterPresentation NotesI am Jun Miyoshi from the National Research Institute of Fisheries Engineering, or FRA.I will be talking about Energy Saving Technology by Proper Remodeling of Hull.
-
Introduction
2
National Research Institute of Fisheries Engineering, FRA
Shipbuilding Company
Hokkaido Univ.
Fishing vessel performanceFleet planning for proper fishing management
Basic design, sea trials, etc.
Maneuvering performance and mathematical model construction of hydrodynamic forces acting on a ship hull
Born in 1972
PresenterPresentation NotesFirst, let me introduce myself.I was born in 1972; I graduated from Hokkaido University, where I studied the maneuvering performance of a ship and the construction of a mathematical model of hydrodynamic forces acting on a ship hull.I then worked at a shipbuilding company and was engaged in basic design and sea trials, especially those of commercial ships and battleships.Currently, I am studying and researching fishing vessel performance and fleet planning for proper fishing management by using the system engineering method.
-
Table of Contents
3
1. About Resistance
2. Proper Remodeling of a Hull
3. Summary
2.1 Installation of the bulbous bow2.2 Fins fitted forward of the propeller2.3 Shape refinement of the appendages of a hull
Types of resistance, Scale effect
4. Future topics
PresenterPresentation NotesHere is the table of contents for this presentation.First, I will talk about resistance by reviewing the types of resistance and scale effect which are important to think of technology for energy saving. I will then describe the proper remodeling of a ship hull. This topic mainly involves hardware improvements to a fishing vessel. I will focus on three topics in particular: installation of a bulbous bow, fins fitted forward of a propeller, and shape refinement of the appendages of a hull.I will then provide a summary of the presentation.Finally, I will talk about future topics.
-
1. About Resistance
4
-
Types of Resistance Acting on a Ship Hull
5
Two types of resistances act on a ship hull.
Pressure Resistance Viscous Pressure ResistanceWave-making Resistance
Frictional Resistance
Total ship resistance = Frictional Resistance + Viscous Pressure Resistance + Wave-making Resistance
PresenterPresentation NotesTwo types of resistances act on a ship hull: frictional resistance and pressure resistance. The pressure resistance can be divided into viscous pressure resistance and wave-making resistance. The total ship resistance consists of frictional resistance, viscous pressure resistance and wave-making resistance.
-
Relations of Forces
6
Direction of forces
Magnitude of forces
Pressure
Friction
Thrust Inertia force for ship motion
Frictional R. Pressure R.
PresenterPresentation NotesI now talk about the relations of forces, such as their direction and magnitude.When a ship is moving forward by the thrust force from a propeller, the tangential stress, or friction, and normal stress, or pressure, work on a ship hull.The friction and pressure generate frictional resistance and pressure resistance. The directions of these resistances are opposite to that of the thrust.The ship moves forward by the inertia force.The relations of the magnitude are shown here.The thrust minus the frictional resistance and pressure resistance is the inertia force.Thus, to save energy, we must reduce the frictional resistance and pressure resistance as much as possible.
-
Frictional Resistance
7
Boundary layer
Flow velocity Flow velocity
Rf
SmoothSurface of a ship hull
CoarseNo slip Rf
Gradient of velocity Viscous stressFrictional resistance
OutsideInviscid
Viscous
PresenterPresentation NotesI describe the frictional resistance here.The surface condition of a dirty ship hull is very coarse with no slip condition.When the flow is running at this velocity magnitude, the velocity is very low owing to friction near the surface. Gradually, the magnitude of the velocity becomes higher and finally becomes the same as that of the velocity in the far fluid area.The gradient of the velocity is the viscous stress and generates the frictional resistance.For a clean surface condition, as the surface is smooth, the velocity magnitude is larger than that of the coarse condition. Thus, the gradient of the velocity is lower, and the frictional resistance also becomes lower.The field with the gradient for the velocity is said to be the boundary layer.In the boundary layer, the fluid condition is viscous. Outside, the fluid condition is inviscid.
-
8In order to reduce the frictional resistance, the surface should be smooth.
Energy Saving through Frictional Resistance
From the hardware viewpoint, smooth paintingand a small surface area are required.
-
Viscous Pressure Resistance
9
Boundary layerVortex
The vortexes absorb large amounts of energy from a ship.A ship consumes large amounts of energy in order to generate vortexes.
The boundary layer is detached as the pressure becomes higher around the aft of a ship.
PresenterPresentation NotesI now talk about the viscous pressure resistance, which is one of the pressure resistances. When a ship is running, a boundary layer is formed on the surface. Around the aft of a ship hull, many vortexes are generated.Around the aft, the flow velocity changes suddenly, and the pressure distribution also changes. Thus, the boundary layer detaches, and vortexes are generated. The vortexes absorb large amounts of energy from the ship. Thus, the ship consumes large amounts of energy in order to generate vortexes.These actions become the viscous pressure resistance.
-
Energy Saving through Viscous Pressure Resistance
10
Boundary layerVortex
The boundary layer does not detach as the pressure gradually changes around the aft of a ship.
PresenterPresentation NotesTo save energy with regard to the viscous pressure resistance, it is important to avoid the generation of vortexes. If an object like this is made or attached, the boundary layer does not detach, because the pressure changes gradually around the aft of a ship body.
-
Wave-making Resistance
11
The waves absorb large amounts of energy from a ship.A ship consumes large amounts of energy in order to make waves.
PresenterPresentation NotesI now describe the wave-making resistance, which is one of the pressure resistances.When a ship is running, waves such as those shown in these pictures are formed.The waves absorb large amounts of energy from a ship.Thus, the ship consumes large amounts of energy in order to make waves. These actions become the wave-making resistance.
-
12
Ship motion
Pressure
Pressure R.
A smaller entrance angle for the ship hull generates lower wave-making resistance; the total form is also important.
Entrance angle of a hull
Energy Saving through Wave-making Resistance
This pressure resistance and gravity are associated with the formation of waves.
PresenterPresentation NotesThis slide is on saving energy by reducing the wave-making resistance.When a ship is running, a pressure force acts on a ship hull in the normal direction.The pressure resistance is generated in the direction opposite to the ships motion.This pressure resistance and gravity are associated with the wave formation.As the waves are generated mainly at the bow of a ship, the entrance angle of the ship hull is a key factor to reducing the wave making. A smaller entrance angle of a ship hull generates lower wave-making resistance. The overall form of the ship hull is also important.
-
Summary of Kinds of Resistance and Improvements Possible
13
Pressure Resistance Viscous Pressure Resistance
Wave-making Resistance
Frictional ResistanceEnsure a smooth paint of the surface of a shipDesign a ship with a small surface area.
Design the curvature of the aft of a ship hull or object to be gradual so as to not detach the boundary layer and prevent the generation of vortexes.
Design the entrance angle of the bow of a ship hull to be small so as to not change the curvature dynamically.
-
Type of Force and Order of Magnitude
14
Inertial
Viscous
Type of Force Order of Magnitude of Force
U 2 2
Gravitational g 3 U
[N]
[N]
[N]
When considering the fluid characteristics and resistance scaling, the force type and order of magnitude are important.
Where velocity = U (m/s), length = (m), density = (kg/m3), viscosity = (kg/(m s)), gravitational acceleration = g (m/s2)
PresenterPresentation NotesI now describe the types of force and orders of magnitude.There are three type of forces: inertial force, viscous force, and gravitational force.The order of each magnitude is as follows. The forces are expressed by using the density, ship velocity, ship length, viscosity of water, and gravity.The inertial force is associated with the ship mass and acceleration by a propeller.The viscous force is especially associated with the viscosity of water.The gravitational force is especially associated with gravitational acceleration.
-
Scale Effect of Viscous Resistance
15
Inertial
Viscous
(Frictional resistance and viscous pressure resistance)
U 2 2
U
U
Re
Reynolds number
The characteristics of the boundary layer on the surface of an object are governed by viscosity.Scaling is associated with inertial and viscous forces.
The frictional resistance and viscous pressure resistance depend on the Reynolds number.
-
Scale Effect of Wave-making Resistance
16
Inertial U 2 2 U2
g
The wave-making resistance depends on the Froude number.
Gravitational g 3
FnFroude number
Ug
The characteristics of the waves are governed by gravity.Scaling is associated with inertial and gravitational forces.
-
Summary of Principal Force and Scale Effect of Resistance
17
Pressure Resistance Viscous Pressure Resistance
Wave-making Resistance
Frictional ResistanceThe principal force is the viscous force.Scaling depends on the Reynolds number.
The principal force is the viscous force.Scaling depends on the Reynolds number.
The principal force is the gravitational force.Scaling depends on the Froude number.
-
2. Proper Remodeling of Hull
18
-
2.1 Installation of Bulbous Bow
19
Bulbous bow A bulb-type object attached to the fore part of a ship hull.
PurposeReduce wave-making resistance
Bulbous bow of Japanese fishing vessels that have lengths of less than 15 m
-
Role of Bulbous Bow
20
Attach a bulbous bow
Bulbous bow itself makes a wave
The purpose of a bulbous bow is to reduce wave-making resistance.
Wave becomes small from wave interference
Wave-making resistance is generated
PresenterPresentation NotesWhen a ship moves forward, a wave is made like this, and wave-making resistance is generated. This resistance is proportional to the square of the wave height.When a bulbous bow is attached, the bulbous bow itself makes a wave.Owing to wave interference, the wave around the ship hull becomes smaller.The purpose of a bulbous bow is to reduce wave-making resistance by inducing wave interference.
-
Improvement Method using a Ship Model
21
-
Summary of the Installation of Bulbous Bow
22
The wave-making resistance is reduced by wave interference.
The main resistance to be reduced by using a bulbous bow is wave-making resistance.
-
2.2 Fin-fitted Forward Propeller
23
FinsPlates fitted on the aft of a ship hull. Many types of fins are produced by shipbuilding companies.
PurposeImprove the wake pattern (i.e., flow pattern past a hull) in order to achieve high propeller efficiency.
-
Role of Fins
24
Rearrangement of the flow (wake) pattern
PresenterPresentation NotesThe flow pattern at the aft of a ship hull is like this. Because of the vortexes, the flow becomes turbulent.The purpose of the fins is to rearrange the flow pattern and achieve high propeller efficiency.
-
25
Improvement around the Aft of a Hull
Smooth the shape of the aft of a hull in order to improve propeller efficiency
PresenterPresentation NotesThis is one improvement to the aft of a ship hull.This is a Thai fishing vessel.When a propeller is running, thrust force is produced.If the form becomes smooth or fins are attached, the propeller efficiency is improved, and a larger thrust force is produced.
-
Summary of Fin-fitted forward Propeller
26
The fins rearrange the flow pattern and achieve high propeller efficiency.
The main resistance to be reduced by using fins is viscous pressure resistance.
-
2.3 Shape Refinement of Appendages of a Hull
27
AppendageObject attached to a ship hull: 1) skeg, 2) bilge keel, 3) sonar cover, 4) structures around a rudder, and 5) anodes
PurposeReduce mainly viscous pressure resistance
Appendages of a Thai fishing vessel (SEAFDEC excursion 2010)
-
1) Skeg
28
Flat plate of the aft of the keel plate
PresenterPresentation NotesI now talk about the skeg.
-
Role of Skeg
29
Wind, WaveMaintain course
Same effect as feathers on an arrow
The skeg is used to maintain course.
Viscous pressure resistance
PresenterPresentation NotesThe skeg is used to maintain course.When wind or waves are hitting a ship in this direction, the course of the ship changes. When the course changes, viscous pressure resistance acts on the skeg, and the course is then maintained.This effect is the same as that of feathers on an arrow.
-
Skeg of a Thai Fishing Vessel
30
Vortexes are generated by the skeg.The viscous pressure resistance is large.
Skeg of a Thai fishing vessel
PresenterPresentation NotesThis is the skeg of a Thai fishing vessel.Vortexes are generated by the skeg, and the viscous pressure resistance is large.
-
Improvement of the skeg
31
Vortexes are generated.
Viscous pressure resistanceis reduced.
PresenterPresentation NotesThis is an improvement of the skeg in order to reduce the viscous pressure resistance.As the vortexes are generated from this part, small fins are attached here.This reduces the viscous pressure resistance.
-
2) Bilge Keel
32
Plates attached to both sides of the bilge of a hull.
Bilge keel of a Thai fishing vessel
PresenterPresentation NotesI next discuss the bilge keel.
-
Role of the Bilge Keel
33
Direction of viscous pressure resistance
The rolling of a ship is reduced by using the viscous pressure resistance.
Viscous pressure resistances work in the direction opposite to ship motion.
The bilge keel is used to reduce rolling.
PresenterPresentation NotesThe bilge keel is used to reduce the rolling of the hull.When a ship rolls, vortexes are generated around the bilge keel, and the viscous pressure resistance works in the direction opposite to the ship motion. The rolling of the ship is reduced by using the pressure resistance.
-
Improvement of the Bilge Keel
34
Picture quoted by NRIFE, FRA
The flow pattern underwater is similar to the wave pattern on the surface
PresenterPresentation NotesThis is one improvement to the bilge keel.The flow pattern underwater is similar to the wave pattern on the surface.If possible, the bilge keel should be along the stream line.
-
Improvement of the Bilge Keel
35
Shave the corner smooth in order to reduce the viscous pressure resistance
Bilge keel of a Thai fishing vessel
PresenterPresentation NotesThis is another improvement to the bilge keel.An airfoil cap is attached to the tip of the bilge keel and smoothed by shaving of the corners of the wooden keel in order to reduce the viscous pressure resistance.
-
3) Sonar Cover
36
The sonar cover or echo-sounder cover is used to protect against bubbles and obstacles.
Sonar cover of a Japanese fishing vessel (trawler)
PresenterPresentation NotesNext, I discuss the sonar cover.
-
Observation of Flow around a Sonar Cover
37
Stream linesRe = 1.0 105
PresenterPresentation NotesThe stream lines past a sonar cover are very complex.As the vortexes are generated, the viscous pressure resistance becomes large.
-
Improvement of a Sonar Cover
38
Photo by Kawashima
-
Observation of Flow around Different Types of Sonar Covers
39
Original shape of cover
Improved shape of cover
Flow
Re = 1.0 105(sonar cover level)
Flow pattern of the bottom of a ship
PresenterPresentation NotesThis slide shows the observed flow around different types of sonar covers. This picture is the flow pattern of the bottom of a ship. The flow is running from left to right. This is the original shape of the cover. The other is the improved shape of the cover. The original sonar cover has a square shaped in the aft, while the improved sonar cover has a smooth shape. When the flow goes past the original sonar cover, the strings are swinging. In contrast, when the flow goes past the improved sonar cover, the stream line is smooth.The vortexes, or viscous pressure resistance, are the main reason for the resistance.This picture clearly indicates that the improved design can reduce resistance.
-
4) Structure around Rudder and an Improvement
40Airfoil cover
Rudder structure of a Thai fishing vessel
-
Shoe Piece and an Improvement
41
-
42
5) Anode Protections
A steel ship has many anode protections on the hull, rudder, bilge keel, and sonar cover in order to avoid steel corrosion.
The resistance of each anode protection is small for a ship, but many anode protections cannot be ignored as resistance objects.
-
43
Anode Protections on a Rudder
Anode protections on a rudder experience high-speed flow velocity from the propeller.
The resistance is proportional to the square of velocity; rudder anode protections, in particular, should not be ignored as resistance objects.
-
44
Comparison of ResistancesR
esis
tanc
e
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
Results of Model Testing at FRA
Re = 1.5 105(aft propeller)
-
45
Improvement of Arrangement of Anodes on a Rudder
-
Improvement of Arrangement
46Improved arrangement
Original arrangement
Observation of flow pattern
PresenterPresentation NotesThis slide shows examples of rearranged anodes.The black objects are anodes. This is the stream line. In order to reduce the viscous pressure resistance, anodes are attached along the stream line.
-
47
Improvement of Anode Shape
Original
Improved
-
48
Rudder Shape
Airfoil type
Plate type
Plate type
PresenterPresentation NotesRefinement of the rudder shape is useful for energy saving.There are many types of rudder shapes.
-
Relations among Forces Acting on the Airfoil-type Rudder
49
Flow
Flow
Drag
Lift
Propeller
ThrustResistance
Rudder
The airfoil of a rudder generates thrust force. The total resistance of a rudder is reduced by the thrust force.
PresenterPresentation NotesI now discuss the relations among forces acting on the airfoil-type rudder.When the propeller is running, the circulating flow acts in this direction on a rudder. The drag force and lift force are generated in these directions. Then, the resistance and thrust forces are produced in these directions. Finally, the total resistance works at this magnitude and in this direction.
-
Relations among Forces Acting on the Plate-type Rudder
50
Flow
FlowDrag
Propeller
Resistance
Rudder
The plate-type rudder does not generate thrust force.The resistance of this rudder is larger than that of the airfoil-type rudder.
-
Improvement of Rudder Shape
51
Attach an airfoil or round-shaped cover.
-
3. Summary
52
-
53
Main Resistances
Bilge keelViscous pressure
resistance
Sonar coverViscous pressure
resistance
Anode protections Viscous pressure
resistance
Bulbous BowWave-making
resistance
Rudder structures Viscous pressure
resistance
SurfaceFrictional resistance
PresenterPresentation NotesThe main resistance to be reduced using the bulbous bow is the wave-making resistance. The main resistance to be reduced by the surface is the frictional resistance. Finally, the main resistance to be reduced using the bilge keel, sonar cover, anode protections, and rudder structures is the viscous pressure resistance.
-
54
Scaling
Bilge keelRe, Fn
Sonar coverRe
Anode protections Re
Bulbous BowFn
Rudder structures Re
SurfaceRe
-
55
Improvements
Bilge keelAlong stream line
Sonar coverAirfoil shape
Anode protections Airfoil shape,
Along steam line
Bulbous BowWave interference
Rudder structures Airfoil shape
SurfaceSmall area,
smooth painting
-
56
Estimation of Energy Saving
Bilge keel2%3%
Sonar cover2%3%
Anode protections 1%
Bulbous Bow2%5%
Rudder structures 1%
Totalabout 10%
Clean surface2%3%
PresenterPresentation NotesThis slide is on the estimated saved energy.The effect of each measure is small, but the total effect reduces fuel consumption by a useful amount.
-
4. Future Topics
57
-
58
2. Modeling on computer
3. Calculate the resistance by the computational fluiddynamics (CFD) method
1. Capture the form of a fishing vessel
Analysis of fluid for Energy Saving
3D modeling tool, Rhinoceros
3D Camera of FRA
ANSYS FLUENT, OpenFOAM
We are considering fluid simulation of fishing vessels from member countries
4. Conduct experiments of the resistance by the model testing
FRA Basin
-
59
Optimization of form and size of an individual fishing vessel and the fleet
Optimize the ship form considering the result of the analysis and the operation of a fishing vessel.
Optimize the fleet size and total gross tons,considering the fish resources and economicmanagement.
-
Thank you for your attention
60
Energy Saving Technology by Proper Remodeling of HullIntroductionTable of Contents1. About ResistanceTypes of Resistance Acting on a Ship HullRelations of ForcesFrictional ResistanceEnergy Saving through Frictional ResistanceViscous Pressure ResistanceEnergy Saving through Viscous Pressure ResistanceWave-making ResistanceSlide Number 12Summary of Kinds of Resistance and Improvements PossibleType of Force and Order of MagnitudeScale Effect of Viscous ResistanceScale Effect of Wave-making Resistance Summary of Principal Force and Scale Effect of Resistance2. Proper Remodeling of Hull2.1 Installation of Bulbous BowRole of Bulbous BowImprovement Method using a Ship ModelSummary of the Installation of Bulbous Bow2.2 Fin-fitted Forward PropellerRole of FinsImprovement around the Aft of a HullSummary of Fin-fitted forward Propeller2.3 Shape Refinement of Appendages of a Hull1) Skeg Role of SkegSkeg of a Thai Fishing VesselImprovement of the skeg2) Bilge KeelRole of the Bilge KeelImprovement of the Bilge KeelImprovement of the Bilge Keel3) Sonar CoverObservation of Flow around a Sonar CoverImprovement of a Sonar CoverObservation of Flow around Different Types of Sonar Covers4) Structure around Rudder and an ImprovementShoe Piece and an Improvement 5) Anode ProtectionsAnode Protections on a RudderComparison of ResistancesImprovement of Arrangement of Anodes on a RudderImprovement of ArrangementImprovement of Anode Shape Rudder ShapeRelations among Forces Acting on the Airfoil-type RudderRelations among Forces Acting on the Plate-type RudderImprovement of Rudder Shape3. SummaryMain ResistancesScalingImprovementsEstimation of Energy Saving4. Future TopicsAnalysis of fluid for Energy SavingOptimization of form and size of an individual fishing vessel and the fleetThank you for your attention