Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

download Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

of 14

Transcript of Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    1/14

    ri

    te

    r

    e

    a

    ch

    e

    s

    r

    i

    ti

    n

    Se

    co

    n

    d Ed

    it

    ion

    om

    p

    let

    e

    R

    e

    vi

    sio

    n

    D

    O

    N

    LD

    M

    U

    R

    R

    Y

    Uni

    versi

    ty of

    New

    H

    am

    pshir

    e

    HO

    UG

    HTO

    N MIF

    FLI

    N

    O

    MP

    NY

    ost

    o

    Da

    llas Gen

    eva

    Illi

    nois

    H

    ope

    well

    Ne

    w

    J

    erse

    y

    Palo

    lto

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    2/14

    Copyright

    98

    by

    Houghton

    Mifflin

    Company. All

    Rights Reserved.

    No

    part

    ot

    this book

    may

    be

    reproduced

    or

    transmitted in

    any form

    or

    by

    any means

    electronic or

    mechanical

    including

    photocopying

    and recording

    or by

    any

    intormation

    storage

    or retrieval

    system except

    as may

    be

    expressly

    permitted

    by

    the

    97 6

    Copyright

    Act

    or

    in

    writing

    by

    the

    Publisher. lermission

    must he

    obtained trom

    the

    individual

    copyright owners

    as

    identified herein. Requests

    for

    Houghton

    Mittlin

    material

    should

    be addressed

    to

    Permissions

    Houghton

    Mifflin

    Company

    One Beacon

    Street Boston

    MA

    02108.

    Printed in

    the

    U.S.A.

    Library of

    Congress

    Catalog Card

    Number:

    84 81981

    ISBN 0 395 35441 2

    Ec HuH j

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    3/14

    7

    he

    h

    e

    PLA

    N

    t

    he

    mo

    st

    im

    port

    ant

    writi

    ng u

    sual

    ly

    tak

    es p

    lace

    b

    efore

    t

    here i

    s

    w

    riti

    ng

    at

    t

    ist

    vh

    at

    vr

    u

    uial

    lv

    thmk

    of is rit

    ing:

    the prod

    ucti

    on

    o

    t

    h

    t

    runn

    ing dr

    aft Wr

    iters

    write

    b

    efore

    th

    ey

    writ

    e.

    id had

    the

    strange experience

    of

    being

    laboratory

    rat

    in

    writing

    i

    s

    tudy

    b

    y

    Dr

    .

    C

    aro

    l

    B

    erke

    nkot

    ter

    of \lic

    higa

    n T

    echn

    olog

    ical

    Un

    iver

    sity.

    De

    cisio

    ns and

    Re

    visio

    ns:

    he

    Pla

    nnin

    g

    Str

    ateg

    ies

    of

    P

    ublis

    hing W

    rit

    W

    e

    r

    Car

    ol

    Ber

    kenk

    otte

    r

    an

    d

    Re

    spon

    se o

    f a

    La

    bora

    tory Rat

    o

    r Bein

    g

    lot

    P

    rotoc

    oled

    Do

    nald

    M

    .

    M

    urra

    y Col

    hy,i Ce

    imip

    ncif i

    on

    mud

    C

    oni

    mum

    nca

    toun

    ,

    vol

    .

    n

    o.

    2

    , May

    lo

    pp.

    5

    l72

    .

    No

    te:

    the w

    ord

    not

    s

    houl

    d

    b

    e

    V

    s

    trick

    en

    fr

    om

    b

    on

    p

    age 17

    1. S

    he

    s

    tudi

    ed

    my

    w

    ritin

    g

    ove

    r

    a two

    -and

    -a

    ha

    lfm

    ont

    h per

    iod

    f

    ocus

    ing

    o

    n

    two

    aca

    dem

    ic

    art

    icles

    an

    d

    a

    ne

    wsp

    aper

    h

    e

    edit

    oria

    l

    wro

    te

    lurin

    g th

    a t time

    alth

    oug

    h di

    d w

    ork

    on

    o

    ther pro

    jects

    mm

    lu

    dinh

    tut

    on

    md

    p

    ot

    tr\

    Sh

    t

    hid mt

    mp

    rrro

    rd

    i

    it

    i

    s

    um

    mt

    w

    hile

    wro

    te

    a

    s

    wel

    l as

    kee

    p

    ev

    ery

    not

    e

    a

    nd

    eve

    ry

    dra

    ft.

    h

    en

    sh

    e

    stu

    died

    the 1

    22

    nin

    ety

    min

    ute ta

    pes

    and

    the dra

    fts.

    She

    also int

    ervie

    wed

    SO

    m

    e

    and

    o

    bser

    ved m

    e w

    ritin

    g.

    e

    r

    Th

    e

    o

    st im

    porta

    nt dis

    cove

    rs

    fur m

    e was

    th

    at sp

    ent thre

    e-fif

    ths

    i

    th

    o

    f

    my

    tim

    e

    or

    mo

    re

    col

    lecti

    ng

    i

    nfor

    mati

    on

    and

    p

    lann

    ing

    my w

    riti

    ng.

    ise

    Mo

    st

    o

    f my rew

    ritin

    g t

    urne

    d out

    to b

    e in fact

    pla

    nnin

    g. O

    n

    o

    ccas

    ion

    a\

    sp

    nt 90

    perc

    ent

    of

    my

    writ

    ing

    tim

    e

    pla

    nnin

    g.

    r

    l

    3erk

    enko

    tter

    s re

    te

    s

    sea

    rch and

    my

    ow

    n

    obs

    erva

    tions of m

    y

    m

    ost

    elfe

    ctiv

    e

    w

    ritin

    g stude

    nts

    ful

    a

    nd

    co

    llea

    gues

    le

    d me

    to

    the mo

    del o

    f t

    he

    wr

    iting

    proc

    ess

    pr

    esen

    ted in

    thi

    s

    hook

    .

    it S

    Inex

    perie

    nce

    d writ

    ers o

    ften wr

    ite to o soo

    n.

    c

    an

    hear

    the

    r

    eade

    r

    S

    sa

    ying

    But yo

    u

    sug

    gest

    ed

    we st

    art

    th

    e w

    ritin

    g c

    ours

    e by havi

    ng

    our

    d.

    stu

    den

    ts

    pl

    unge in and

    w

    rite. This

    is on

    of

    the c

    ontr

    adic

    tions

    can

    never

    fully

    resolve

    in

    my

    own teaching.

    Mv

    beginning students need

    t

    o wr

    ite im

    med

    iately

    so

    that

    th

    ey

    exp

    erien

    ce th

    e

    t

    errit

    ory

    o

    f w

    ritin

    g

    f

    or

    su

    rpri

    se.

    W

    he

    n

    the

    y

    kn

    ow w

    hat it

    i

    s

    to

    wr

    ite

    t

    hen

    t

    hey ca

    n

    sta

    rt t

    o

    i

    tel -

    lea

    rn

    to wr

    ite

    mor

    e eff

    ectiv

    ely.

    W

    ritin

    g

    is

    a

    skill

    and

    stud

    ents

    need

    to

    irv

    m

    ess a

    roun

    d w

    ith

    pain

    ts be

    fore

    they

    learn

    to p

    aint

    pl

    unk

    at a

    p

    iano

    lOW

    befo

    re

    th

    ey

    are

    taug

    ht

    s

    cale

    s

    fo

    ol

    arou

    nd

    wi

    th a

    b

    aske

    tbal

    l

    gett

    ing

    the

    we

    fee l o

    f it be

    fore

    the

    y

    are

    pu

    t

    thr

    oug

    h

    a

    form

    al

    p

    ract

    ice. W

    ritin

    g

    un

    like

    in a

    rt

    m

    usi

    c and spo

    rts

    has

    n

    ot

    bee

    n a

    m

    atter

    of

    pl

    ay

    fo

    r

    ou

    r stu

    dent

    s

    for-

    at

    l

    east n

    ot s

    ince

    th

    e

    ear

    liest

    g

    rad

    es of sch

    ool.

    Th

    ey ha

    ve to

    w

    rite

    to

    ea

    ls

    reex

    perie

    nce tha

    t

    es

    senti

    al

    play

    .

    Wh

    en

    they

    a

    re

    in

    the g

    ame

    w

    e ca

    n

    b

    egin to he

    lp th

    em

    pla

    n

    s

    o they

    w

    ill

    w

    rite befo

    re

    the

    y

    wr

    ite.

    lost Mu

    ch

    o

    f

    the

    h

    ad

    wr

    iting

    w

    e

    rea

    d from in

    expe

    rien

    ced w

    riter

    s is

    the

    fec-

    direct result

    of

    writing before

    they

    are

    ready

    to

    write.

    Effective

    plannin

    g

    ter

    s

    doe

    snt

    di

    scou

    rage d

    iscov

    ery

    as lo

    ng

    as it

    is

    o

    pen-

    ende

    d

    and ex

    peri

    rnen

    tal

    an

    d

    the write

    r

    un

    ders

    tand

    s

    w

    hat

    J

    ohn

    Fm

    vles

    say

    s

    F

    ollo

    w

    the

    t

    I

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    4/14

    U

    L

    HV

    M

    N

    U

    RP

    R

    IS

    I IH

    E

    I

    R

    V

    L

    SS

    m

    LO

    R

    Y

    VI

    W

    R

    IT

    IN

    G

    a

    cc

    id

    en

    t

    tea

    r

    th

    e

    fi

    xe

    d

    pla

    n

    tha

    t

    is

    th

    e

    ru

    le

    .

    Bu

    t th

    a

    t d

    oe

    s n

    o

    t

    m

    ea

    n

    th

    e

    w

    ri

    te

    r

    sh

    ou

    ld

    no

    t

    pl

    an

    P

    la

    nn

    in

    g

    i

    n

    w

    ri

    tin

    g

    e

    nc

    ou

    ra

    ge

    s

    the

    ki

    nd

    o

    t

    i

    d

    nt

    s

    F

    o

    wl

    es

    a

    nd e

    ve

    ry

    o

    th

    er

    w

    ri

    ter

    n

    ee

    ds

    .

    P

    la

    nn

    in

    g

    tak

    e

    s

    th

    e

    pl

    ac

    e

    of

    th

    e

    m

    an

    y

    dr

    af

    ts

    th

    at

    a

    re

    u

    su

    al

    ly n

    ec

    es

    sa

    ry

    w

    ith

    o

    ut

    a

    d

    eq

    u

    a

    te

    p

    Ia

    on

    in

    g

    1

    0

    Ct

    IS

    A

    n

    e

    ff

    ec

    tiv

    e p

    ie

    ce

    of w

    ri

    tin

    g s

    ay

    s

    o

    ne

    d

    om

    in

    a

    n

    t

    t

    hin

    g

    .

    A

    s

    Ku

    rt V

    o

    nn

    eg

    ut

    J

    r

    s

    ay

    s

    l

    on

    t

    p

    u

    t

    a

    n

    yt

    h

    in

    g

    in

    a

    s

    to

    ry

    th

    at d

    o

    es

    n

    ot

    ad

    va

    n

    ce

    t

    he

    ac

    tio

    n.

    T

    he sa

    m

    e

    t

    hin

    g

    ca

    n b

    e

    s

    ai

    d fo

    r

    a

    rg

    u

    m

    e

    n

    t m

    e

    m

    o

    te

    ch

    n

    ica

    l

    w

    ri

    tin

    g

    o

    r

    po

    et

    ry

    .

    E

    ve

    ry

    el

    em

    e

    nt

    i

    n

    t

    he

    t

    ex

    t

    s

    u

    p

    po

    r

    ts

    a

    nd

    a

    dv

    an

    c

    es

    th

    e

    ma

    in

    po

    in

    t.

    P

    la

    nn

    in

    g

    st

    ar

    ts

    w

    it

    h

    th

    e

    se

    ar

    ch

    fo

    r

    th

    at

    d

    o

    m

    in

    a

    nt

    m

    ea

    n

    ing

    .

    Th

    e

    re

    ar

    e

    a

    nu

    m

    b

    er

    of

    te

    ch

    ni

    qu

    es

    t

    ha

    t

    h

    el

    p

    th

    e

    w

    ri

    ter

    di

    sc

    ov

    er

    the

    f

    oc

    us

    of

    a

    p

    ie

    ce

    of

    w

    ri

    tin

    g

    b

    ef

    ore

    it

    is w

    ri

    tte

    n.

    B

    u

    t

    th

    e

    wr

    ite

    r

    s

    h

    o

    ul

    d

    n

    ev

    er

    fo

    rg

    et

    t

    h

    at

    th

    e

    ac

    t

    o

    f w

    rit

    ing

    i

    ts

    elf

    is a

    n

    ac

    t

    of

    d

    is

    co

    ve

    ry

    .

    Th

    e

    fo

    cu

    s

    i

    s n

    ot

    f

    ou

    nd

    th

    en

    k

    ep

    t

    unchanged

    The

    writing

    will

    refine the focus

    q

    ua

    lif

    y

    it

    a

    d

    ap

    t

    it a

    nd

    m

    an

    y

    tim

    e

    s

    c

    au

    se

    it t

    o

    ch

    an

    g

    e

    c

    om

    p

    le

    tel

    y.

    Th

    e wr

    ite

    r

    d

    o

    es

    no

    t

    ar

    riv

    e

    at

    th

    e

    f

    ina

    l

    d

    e

    st

    in

    a

    ti

    o

    n

    b

    ef

    or

    e

    t

    ak

    in

    g

    t

    he

    tr

    ip

    b

    u

    t t

    he

    wr

    ite

    r

    st

    ill

    ha

    s

    to

    ha

    ve

    a

    n

    i

    de

    a of

    th

    e d

    e

    s

    ti

    na

    t

    io

    n b

    efo

    re

    sta

    rt

    in

    g

    o

    ut

    .

    P

    oi

    ntl

    es

    s

    w

    a

    n

    d

    er

    in

    g

    is

    n

    o

    t

    v

    er

    y p

    ro

    du

    ct

    iv

    e.

    Si

    gn

    ifi

    ca

    nt

    di

    sc

    ov

    er

    ie

    s

    i

    n ch

    em

    i

    str

    y

    ar

    e

    n

    ot

    m

    ad

    e

    in

    th

    e

    l

    ite

    ra

    tur

    e c

    las

    s

    T

    he

    w

    rit

    er

    n

    ee

    ds

    to

    h

    av

    e so

    m

    e

    i

    de

    a

    of

    w

    h

    at

    m

    a

    y

    h

    a

    p

    p

    en

    d

    u

    ri

    n

    g

    t

    he

    ex

    pe

    di

    tio

    n

    to

    wa

    rd

    s

    m

    e

    an

    in

    g.

    He

    re

    ar

    e

    so

    m

    e w

    a

    ys

    t

    he

    w

    rit

    er

    fi

    nd

    s

    t

    he p

    ot

    en

    tia

    l

    foc

    u

    s

    i

    n a

    pie

    ce

    o

    f

    wr

    iti

    ng

    .

    The

    Focal

    Point

    P

    ai

    nt

    ers

    an

    d p

    h

    o

    to

    g

    ra

    p

    h

    er

    s

    d

    ire

    ct

    th

    e

    v

    ie

    we

    r

    s

    e

    ye

    to

    a

    si

    ng

    le

    sp

    ot

    from

    w

    hi

    ch

    th

    e

    pi

    ctu

    re

    c

    an

    b

    e

    un

    d

    e

    rs

    t

    oo

    d

    I

    t m

    ay

    b

    e

    h

    elp

    fu

    l

    to

    s

    t

    ud

    y

    p

    ai

    n

    ti

    n

    gs

    or p

    ho

    t

    o

    gr

    a

    p

    h

    s to l

    ea

    rn

    v

    is

    ua

    lly w

    h

    at

    w

    e

    n

    ee

    d

    to

    d

    o

    w

    ith

    w

    o

    rd

    s.

    Th

    e w

    rit

    er

    sh

    o

    uld

    l

    ea

    rn

    the po

    w

    er

    of

    a

    s

    in

    gl

    e

    p

    oi

    nt

    to e

    n

    erg

    iz

    e

    a

    n

    e

    nti

    re

    dra

    ft

    .

    lik

    e

    to

    l

    oo

    k

    fo

    r

    a

    n

    or

    ga

    niz

    in

    g

    sp

    ec

    ifi

    c

    a

    q

    u

    o

    ta

    t

    io

    n

    s

    ta

    tis

    tic

    co

    nc

    ep

    t s

    ce

    ne

    th

    a

    t

    w

    i

    ll dra

    w

    a

    ll

    th

    e m

    ate

    ri

    al

    t

    og

    eth

    e

    r.

    fi

    nd

    it he

    lp

    fu

    l

    to

    s

    ee

    k

    a

    rev

    e

    ali

    ng

    d

    eta

    il

    a s

    ig

    ni

    fic

    an

    t

    f

    ra

    gm

    e

    nt

    th

    a

    t

    wi

    ll e

    xp

    os

    e

    an

    au

    th

    or

    s

    s

    tyl

    e

    a

    fa

    ilu

    re

    in

    a

    la

    w

    a

    c

    ha

    ra

    ct

    er

    s

    w

    ea

    kn

    es

    s.

    M

    an

    y

    ti

    m

    es

    a

    s

    in

    gl

    e

    i

    m

    ag

    e

    wi

    ll s

    pa

    rk

    or o

    rg

    an

    iz

    e

    a

    pi

    ec

    e

    o

    f w

    r

    iti

    ng

    .

    W

    ill

    iam

    Fa

    ul

    kn

    er

    ex

    pl

    ain

    ed

    T

    h

    e S

    o

    un

    d

    a

    nd

    t

    he

    Fu

    ry

    b

    e

    ga

    n

    w

    ith a

    m

    en

    ta

    l pic

    tu

    re

    .

    T

    he

    p

    ic

    tur

    e

    w

    a

    s

    o

    f

    t

    he

    m

    u

    d

    d

    y se

    at

    o

    f a

    l

    ittl

    e

    gi

    rl

    s

    drawers

    in

    a

    pear tree

    where

    she could

    see

    through a window where

    h

    er

    gr

    a

    n

    dm

    o

    th

    e

    r

    s

    fu

    n

    era

    l

    w

    as

    ta

    kin

    g

    pla

    ce

    an

    d

    r

    ep

    or

    t

    w

    h

    at w

    a

    s

    h

    p

    p

    n

    in

    g t

    o

    h

    er

    b

    r

    o

    th

    e

    rs on

    th

    e

    g

    ro

    u

    n

    d b

    elo

    w

    .

    N

    on

    -f

    ict

    io

    n

    as

    w

    e

    ll

    a

    s

    f

    ict

    io

    n

    or p

    o

    etr

    y

    o

    fte

    n

    be

    gi

    ns

    w

    it

    h

    a

    n i

    m

    ag

    e

    th

    at

    co

    nt

    ai

    ns

    i

    n

    a

    se

    ns

    e

    the

    w

    h

    ole

    st

    or

    y

    t

    he

    ac

    or

    n

    th

    a

    t

    c

    on

    ta

    ins

    an

    oa

    k

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    5/14

    \jV

    hat w

    ord

    s

    or

    p

    hrase

    s

    hav

    e sp

    ecial

    me

    anin

    g

    to

    me as

    w

    ork

    on

    pie

    ce of

    writ

    ing? O

    ften

    a r

    athe

    r or

    dina

    ry wo

    rd

    W

    e

    a

    ll

    have

    s

    uch code

    wo

    rds

    i

    n our

    life: th

    e nam

    es

    of our

    fa

    mily

    the

    nam

    e

    our

    h

    ome

    tow

    n

    th

    e tit

    le

    spe

    cial

    son

    g

    Som

    etim

    es such wo

    rds

    or

    ph

    rase

    s

    p

    rovi

    de

    lo

    cus

    To

    f

    ind

    t

    he loca

    l

    poin

    t

    the writer often starts

    by

    simply

    standing

    back

    from

    al

    l

    t

    he res

    earc

    h

    cl

    osin

    g

    the no

    tebo

    ok

    push

    ing

    the

    file

    draw

    er

    s

    hut

    an

    d

    si

    tting

    back

    with

    a pad

    pape

    r a

    nd

    tryi

    ng

    to put

    dow

    n

    t

    he

    mo

    st i

    mpo

    rtant

    thi

    ng

    the

    wri

    ter

    ha

    s lear

    ned

    from

    all

    th

    e m

    ater

    ial

    t

    he

    w

    rite

    r

    has

    col

    lecte

    d

    W

    riter

    s

    s

    ome

    time

    s

    fin

    d it he

    lpfu

    l

    to st

    and

    ba

    ck and

    a

    nsw

    er

    som

    e

    time

    s in

    a

    par

    agrap

    h

    us

    ually

    in

    a

    sente

    nce

    o

    ften

    in

    a

    p

    hras

    e o

    r

    a

    word

    su

    ch

    qu

    estio

    ns

    as

    :

    W

    ha

    t sur

    prise

    d

    me th

    e mos

    t?

    Wh

    at

    orga

    nizin

    g spe

    cific

    w

    ill

    he

    lp

    me

    cont

    rol m

    ater

    ial?

    W

    hat

    is the

    m

    ost rev

    ealin

    g

    de

    tail

    have

    disc

    over

    ed

    or

    can

    r

    emem

    ber

    ?

    What

    im

    age

    s

    ticks i

    n my

    m

    inds

    e

    ye a

    nd see

    ms

    to

    sy

    mbo

    lize

    t

    he

    ent

    ire

    subje

    ct?

    Wh

    at pe

    rson

    r tac

    e do rem

    em

    ber

    f

    rom do

    ing

    th

    e re

    sear

    ch?

    W

    ha

    t id

    ea

    k

    ept

    co

    min

    g h

    ack to

    me

    d

    urin

    g th

    e

    tim

    e was

    colle

    ctin

    g

    ma

    teria

    l?

    [

    Wha

    t

    co

    de w

    ords

    h

    ave

    spec

    ial mea

    ning

    to

    me no

    w?

    W

    hat is

    the

    mos

    t

    imp

    ortan

    t sin

    gle

    fa

    ct h

    ave lea

    rned

    ?

    W

    hat

    is

    th

    e most

    sig

    nific

    ant quo

    tatio

    n

    he

    ard

    or rea

    d?

    W

    hat

    i

    s the

    one t

    hing

    my

    re

    ade

    r n

    eed

    s to

    kno

    w m

    ost

    a

    ll?

    W

    hat

    d

    o

    rem

    embe

    r

    in gr

    eates

    t de

    tail?

    i

    What

    event

    is

    central

    to

    what

    happened?

    l

    W

    hat

    sta

    tistic sti

    cks

    in

    my he

    ad?

    l

    W

    hat

    did

    I

    thin

    k w

    hen

    was

    do

    ing

    the resea

    rch?

    Wha

    t di

    d

    fee

    l wh

    en

    w

    as

    do

    ing

    t

    he re

    searc

    h?

    o

    W

    hat

    per

    son

    i

    mpre

    ssed

    me

    t

    he m

    ost?

    W

    hat s

    tory

    or

    a

    necd

    ote

    d

    o

    rem

    em

    ber?

    o

    Wha

    t p

    atte

    rn

    or ord

    er

    d

    id

    b

    egin

    t

    o

    see?

    Fram

    ing

    A

    noth

    er wa

    y

    to

    de

    velo

    p

    foc

    us i

    s to

    fra

    me t

    he

    s

    ubjec

    t

    T

    his i

    s cour

    se

    another

    word

    for

    the

    tra ditiona l

    counsel

    achieving unity

    But

    unity

    fo

    r mos

    t b

    egin

    ning

    w

    riter

    s

    impl

    ies

    a f

    inish

    ed k

    ind

    inter

    wov

    en

    c

    om

    p

    leten

    ess

    the

    y

    c

    anno

    t co

    ncei

    ve

    It is

    m

    ore h

    elpf

    ul

    t

    o

    thi

    nk

    of f

    ram

    ing

    the su

    bjec

    t

    or

    b

    uildi

    ng

    a fen

    ce

    a

    roun

    d it

    P

    LA

    N

    s

    re

    i

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    6/14

    2

    I

    IIIV

    Jf

    \J

    5tl

    RP1

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    7/14

    p

    ro

    ble

    m

    so

    lv

    in

    g

    anim

    als

    a

    nd

    we

    need

    pr

    ob

    le

    ms

    to

    solv

    e. Som

    e

    stu

    d

    ies

    of

    cr

    eativ

    e pe

    rs

    on

    s

    ha

    ve

    h

    ow

    n

    tha

    t

    they see

    pro

    blem

    s

    to

    be

    olve

    d

    wh

    er

    e

    oth

    er

    s

    do

    no

    t. We

    see

    a

    pil

    e of b

    eer

    b

    ottle

    s

    an

    d th

    e

    arti

    st

    sees

    the

    p

    roble

    m o

    f

    ca

    tch

    in

    c

    th

    e

    w

    ay

    t

    he

    l

    ight re

    flect

    s

    o

    ff

    the

    b

    ro

    w

    n a

    nd

    gree

    n gla

    ss.

    w wr

    iter se

    es,

    in the

    same be

    er bo

    ttles

    ,

    a

    s

    tory in

    t

    he

    way

    Joe

    ke

    pt com

    ing

    o

    n t

    oo

    st

    ro

    to th

    e girls

    at

    t

    he party and the kindly

    way t

    ha

    t

    Judy p

    ut

    him do

    w

    n Th

    e socia

    l

    w

    o

    rk

    er l

    ooks at th

    e

    bot

    tles a

    nd

    se

    es

    th

    e

    pr

    oble

    m

    of

    alco

    holis

    m

    o

    n

    ca

    mp

    u

    s

    tha

    t

    nee

    ds

    solv

    ing.

    I

    the

    Wh

    at

    Is

    the Rea

    ders

    Q

    ues

    tion?

    ,vor

    k

    An

    ef

    fecti

    ve

    piec

    e

    of

    writ

    ing

    a

    ns

    w

    ers

    a

    re

    ader

    s

    q

    u

    est

    io

    n and

    to do that

    w

    ith

    the

    w

    riter

    m

    u

    st

    lear

    n to a

    n

    tic

    ip

    ate

    the

    r

    eade

    rs

    co

    ncer

    ns. S

    ome

    time

    s

    er

    wil l

    s

    it

    do

    w

    n an

    d

    torm

    ally

    wr

    ite

    out

    s

    uch qu

    estio

    nS

    a

    s:

    c

    tive

    W

    hat

    do

    es t

    he

    r

    eade

    r n

    ee

    d

    to

    kno

    w?

    bjec

    t

    W

    hat

    wi

    ll

    i

    nt

    ere

    st the read

    er?

    riter

    n

    Wh

    at

    can t

    he

    r

    ea

    de

    r

    use?

    bject

    What

    will

    help the reader?

    tO

    Wh

    at

    will

    s

    ur

    pr

    ise

    t

    he

    read

    er?

    tt

    ec-

    Wha

    t w

    ill m

    ake the re

    ad

    e

    r a

    n

    a

    ut

    ho

    ri

    ty?

    er S

    Wha

    t

    w

    ill

    th

    e r

    ea

    de

    r

    r

    us

    h

    to

    t ll som

    eon

    e

    else?

    r

    iter

    a

    n

    ce

    lyi

    ng

    V

    OIC

    E

    e

    r

    to

    Voic

    e allo

    ws

    the re

    ad

    er

    to he

    ar an i

    nd

    iv

    idu

    a

    l

    hu

    m

    an

    h

    ei

    np

    ta

    k

    f

    rom

    the pag

    e.

    G

    ood

    wr

    iting

    alwa

    ys

    has a

    s

    tro

    n

    g

    a

    n

    d

    ap

    p

    ro

    p j

    vo

    ice. V

    oic

    e

    i

    s

    the

    qu

    ality

    m

    ore

    t

    ha

    n an

    y

    o

    th

    er

    tha

    t allo

    ws

    u

    s

    r

    ec

    og

    ni

    ze

    ex

    ce

    p

    ctic

    u

    tio

    nal

    po

    h

    ntia

    l

    i

    l

    bc

    in

    ni

    ng

    r

    iter vo

    ice

    is

    qu

    ih

    tv

    mor

    c th

    r has any

    other

    that allows us

    to

    recognize

    excelIenvriting

    We

    respond

    to

    ucd

    o

    ie

    wh

    e

    n

    we

    he

    ir it Voi

    ce

    gi

    ves

    th

    e tcxt

    in

    id

    u

    ili t

    y

    en

    ergy

    c

    once

    rn

    Voic

    e

    is

    of

    cou

    rse

    cl

    osely

    a

    llie

    ty

    le or

    tone, h

    ut

    pr

    efer

    th

    e

    ving

    term

    voi

    ce fo

    r

    it s

    eem

    s m

    ore

    ac

    cii f

    Ie

    a

    nd

    mo

    re

    he

    lpfu

    l

    for

    the

    be

    g

    in

    P

    oint

    nc

    r H

    ov

    ev

    er

    w

    e disc

    uss

    st

    y

    see

    ms

    t

    o

    g

    ct

    r

    eh

    te

    d

    t

    fash

    ion

    S

    tyle

    the

    s

    ou

    n

    ds

    like

    s

    om

    e

    th

    in

    g

    y

    o

    y off

    the shel

    f.

    It

    is m

    ade

    by

    so

    meon

    e

    els

    e

    y of

    an

    d

    it

    ch

    an

    ge

    s

    w

    ith

    t

    h

    as

    on

    The t

    erm

    st

    yle

    e

    n

    co

    ur

    ag

    es

    th

    e m

    isc

    o

    n

    t

    by

    ccpt

    lon

    th

    it

    w

    r

    it1

    ng

    i

    nh

    er

    cn

    tly dis

    ho

    n

    es

    t

    tha

    t

    t

    hc

    s

    rit

    er ha

    s to

    say

    d

    wh

    at so

    m

    eo

    n

    eie

    w

    a

    nt

    s th

    e

    write

    r

    to sa

    y

    in

    m

    an

    ne

    r

    a

    p

    pro

    p

    ria

    te

    to

    h

    the

    so

    meo

    ne

    s

    3

    ut

    goo

    d w

    r

    itin

    g is

    ho

    n

    es

    t

    h

    on

    es

    t in

    w

    h

    at s

    s

    aid

    a

    nd

    h

    on

    es

    t

    i

    n4

    ow

    i

    t

    is

    s

    aid

    r

    D

    ona

    ld

    H

    G

    rav

    es

    o

    f t

    he

    U

    nive

    rsity

    of

    Ne

    w Ha

    m

    pshire

    t

    h

    is

    m

    o

    nu

    m

    en

    ta

    l

    stu

    di

    es

    of

    child

    ren w

    riti

    ng

    one

    o

    f

    the

    f

    irst

    th

    in

    gs

    the

    no

    tice

    d

    wa

    s

    tha

    t the

    m

    ost

    effe

    ctiv

    e y

    ou

    ng

    wr

    iters

    wer

    e

    alw

    ays p

    ra

    c

    e a

    re tic

    ing

    w

    ha

    t the

    y

    w

    oul

    d write

    in

    the

    ir

    he

    ad

    s

    b

    efore

    the

    y wrot

    e.

    He calle

    d

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    8/14

    trite

    por

    art a

    tntly

    iters

    iting

    ;

    its

    the

    i

    the

    use

    with

    23

    DFS

    The

    writing process

    is organic.

    It

    grows

    and

    changes

    during

    the

    act

    writing.

    What

    is

    being

    said

    changes

    what

    was

    intended

    to

    he

    said, The

    structure

    the

    piece

    writing

    must be

    adapted to

    the

    evolving

    message

    that is

    being

    delivered

    to

    the

    writer by the

    draft

    and

    will be

    delivered

    to

    the

    reader

    in the

    finished

    version.

    There

    is

    no

    one way

    to

    design a

    piece

    of writing.

    As

    we

    study

    effective

    writers

    we

    find some

    pieces

    writing

    that were

    written

    without

    the

    slightest

    hint

    the

    order

    that

    would

    be

    imposed by

    the

    raw

    material

    on

    itself and

    other pieces

    of

    writing

    that

    were

    constructed

    from

    precise

    blueprints.

    The

    type

    of plan

    depends,

    to a

    large

    degree,

    on

    the

    persom

    ality

    the

    writer.

    But

    think

    it

    is

    dangerous for any

    writer to

    feel

    that

    he

    or she

    can

    never

    work

    from a

    careful

    plan

    or,

    on the

    other

    hand,

    must

    always

    have

    a

    careful

    plan.

    The

    academic

    article

    wrote

    before

    starting

    this

    draft

    was

    written

    without any

    formal

    plan at

    all It

    evolved

    from the

    first

    paragraph

    as

    naturally

    as

    a

    river

    flows

    to

    the

    ocean.

    It

    seemed to

    flow

    naturally

    from

    a

    plan

    that was

    unconscious,

    if it

    existed

    at all

    Each

    part

    the

    writing

    came

    to

    me as

    if

    were

    following

    invisible

    instructions.

    accepted

    that;

    who

    wouldnt?

    Then

    turned to

    write

    the

    final draft

    of this

    book,

    and

    found

    myself

    making

    the

    most

    detailed

    plan

    have

    ever made.

    It

    was

    necessary,

    and

    it

    was

    helpful,

    so

    made

    the

    plan.

    But, of

    course,

    havent

    followed

    the

    plan,

    not

    exactly.

    And

    when revised

    and

    edited

    the

    book,

    had

    more

    plans:

    three

    that

    mailed

    to the

    editor in

    separate

    envelopes

    in

    one

    day.

    Each

    plan

    thought

    was

    the

    final one.

    None was.

    The

    outline

    is

    only

    a plan;

    the

    writing

    demands

    its

    own

    direction

    and

    develop

    ment.

    have

    had

    to

    leave

    things

    out

    and make

    room

    for

    new pieces

    information.

    have had

    to

    change the order and the

    pace, the

    proportions

    and the

    dimensions.

    have

    had

    the

    excitement

    writing

    a

    book

    that

    is

    more

    than the

    plan,

    but that

    does

    not

    mean

    that

    didnt

    have to

    have

    a

    design

    from

    which

    to

    work.

    In

    fact,

    had

    a

    number

    designs,

    each

    one

    more

    complicated

    than

    the

    last,

    until

    saw

    a new

    simplicity.

    And

    then

    that,

    in

    turn,

    became

    more

    complex,

    until

    it led to

    a

    simplification.

    The

    writer needs

    a

    plan as

    an

    explorer

    needs

    a map.

    Its

    the

    guess

    how

    things

    may go

    from

    past

    experience.

    But

    it

    is

    only

    a

    guess.

    Ye t

    nothing

    will happen

    most

    of the

    time

    if

    there is

    no design.

    The

    writer

    will

    simply

    wander

    and

    have

    to try

    to

    impose.a

    design

    later

    on,

    when

    it is

    much

    more

    difficult

    to do.

    Each

    sketch

    what may

    be

    the

    design

    the

    writing is

    a

    predraft,

    in which

    problems

    are

    identified

    and

    solved.

    And

    the

    more

    experienced

    the

    writer

    is

    and

    the

    more

    difficult the

    writing

    task the

    more

    likely

    the

    writer

    will begin to

    work

    with

    sketches

    what

    may

    need

    to be

    written

    before

    the

    first

    draft is

    begun.

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    9/14

    U

    L

    I

    A

    I

    L

    \

    tR

    I

    R

    N

    I

    li

    ii

    u

    li

    ii

    v

    t

    th

    e r

    ea

    d

    e

    r

    a

    se

    i

    N

    e

    of tu

    l

    li

    ll

    m

    e

    n

    t o

    r

    c

    l

    os

    u

    re

    t

    d

    r

    aw

    s th

    e pi

    ec

    e

    to

    h

    er

    a

    n

    d r

    ei

    n

    fo

    r

    c

    es

    w

    h

    a

    t th

    e

    w

    ri

    te

    r h

    as sa

    i

    d

    W

    ri

    te

    r

    s ra

    r

    e

    ly

    u

    s

    e

    th

    e

    l

    o

    n

    na

    l

    c

    o

    n

    cl

    u

    si

    o

    n

    th

    e

    s

    u

    m

    i

    g

    u

    p

    t

    ha

    t

    i

    s

    w

    ri

    tt

    en

    d

    ir

    e

    ct

    ly to

    th

    e

    r

    e

    a

    de

    r

    .

    M

    o

    re

    e

    f

    fe

    c

    ti

    v

    e

    e

    n

    d

    i c

    o

    m

    e w

    h

    e

    n

    th

    e

    w

    r

    it

    er t

    in

    d

    s a

    w

    a

    y to

    c

    onclude

    y

    implication giving the

    reader

    s

    o

    m

    e

    th

    in

    g s

    p

    ec

    i

    fi

    c

    t

    ha

    t

    w

    ill m

    a

    k

    e

    t

    h

    e

    r

    e

    ad

    e

    r

    e

    t

    o t

    he

    c

    o

    n

    cl

    u

    si

    o

    n

    t

    h

    a

    t

    t

    h

    e

    w

    ri

    te

    r

    w

    a

    n

    ts

    To

    d

    o

    t

    h

    is

    w

    r

    it

    e

    rs

    u

    s

    y

    u

    se th

    e

    sa

    m

    e

    te

    c

    h

    n

    iq

    u

    e

    s

    th

    a

    t

    a

    r

    e

    u

    se

    d

    t

    o p

    r

    od

    u

    c

    e an

    ef

    f

    ec

    ti

    v

    e

    T

    h

    e

    T

    r

    ai

    l

    W

    h

    e

    n

    y

    o

    u

    n

    g

    w

    r

    it

    e

    rs h

    a

    y

    b

    e

    g

    in

    n

    in

    g a

    nd

    a

    n

    e

    n

    di

    n

    g

    t

    h

    en

    t

    h

    e

    y

    c

    a

    n

    b

    e

    gi

    n

    t

    o

    s

    e

    e

    th

    e

    tra

    il

    w

    il

    l

    l

    e

    ad

    th

    e

    m

    th

    r

    o

    u

    gh t

    he

    i

    r

    m

    a

    t

    er

    i

    al

    .

    W

    r

    it

    er

    s

    k

    n

    o

    w

    t

    he

    y m

    u

    s

    t e

    fr

    om

    bu

    n

    d

    n

    ce

    n

    th

    ey

    e

    x

    p

    ec

    t

    p

    ro

    b

    l

    em

    s i

    n

    s

    e

    le

    c

    ti

    o

    n.

    S

    or

    e

    s

    of c

    o

    ur

    s

    e

    t

    h

    e

    t

    ra

    il

    w

    ill b

    e

    in

    s

    tin

    c

    t

    iv

    e

    or

    m

    m

    ed

    i

    at

    e

    ly

    r

    hu

    t m

    a

    n

    y t

    im

    es w

    r

    it

    er

    s

    w

    ill

    n

    e

    ed a

    m

    a

    p

    u

    t

    un

    l

    ik

    e

    g

    e

    og

    r

    a

    maps

    the one they

    draw themselves

    is

    usually

    more

    helpful

    th

    a

    e

    on

    e d

    r

    aw

    n

    y

    s

    o

    m

    e

    o

    ne e

    lse

    W

    r

    ite

    r

    s

    h

    a

    v

    e

    to

    f

    in

    d

    th

    e

    ir

    o

    w

    n

    in

    a

    t

    io

    n

    s

    a

    n

    d

    th

    e

    ir o

    w

    n

    w

    a

    y to

    g

    e

    t

    th

    e

    re

    .

    T

    he

    S

    k

    e

    tc

    h

    A

    t

    t

    h

    e e

    nd

    o

    f

    t

    h

    e p

    l

    a

    nn

    i

    n

    g

    p

    r

    oc

    e

    s

    s

    th

    e

    w

    r

    it

    er

    m

    a

    y

    b

    e

    a

    bl

    e

    to

    d

    r

    aw a

    s

    k

    et

    c

    h

    o

    f

    th

    e w

    ri

    ti

    ng

    to

    b

    e

    d

    r

    af

    te

    d

    .

    S

    o

    m

    e

    w

    r

    it

    er

    s

    y

    th

    e

    ir n

    a

    tu

    r

    e

    n

    e

    ed

    a

    n

    ex

    t

    re

    m

    e

    l

    y

    d

    et

    a

    il

    ed

    s

    k

    et

    c

    h;

    o

    t

    h

    er

    s

    n

    e

    e

    d

    o

    n

    ly s

    c

    ra

    w

    l

    e

    d

    re

    m

    i

    n

    de

    r

    s

    o

    f

    k

    ey

    p

    o

    in

    ts

    ;

    a

    n

    d

    sti

    ll

    o

    t

    he

    r

    s

    e

    s

    pe

    c

    ia

    l

    ly fi

    ct

    ion w

    ri

    te

    r

    s sa

    y

    th

    e

    y

    n

    e

    e

    d

    no

    s

    u

    ch

    sk

    e

    t

    ch

    a

    t all

    a

    n

    d

    a

    re

    in fa

    ct

    f

    r

    ig

    h

    te

    n

    e

    d t

    h

    a

    t

    a s

    k

    e

    tc

    h

    w

    ill k

    e

    e

    p

    th

    e

    m f

    ro

    m

    th

    e a

    c

    c

    id

    e

    nt

    a

    l d

    is

    co

    v

    e

    ri

    e

    s

    es

    s

    en

    t

    ia

    l

    t

    o

    a

    g

    o

    o

    d

    p

    i

    ec

    e of w

    ri

    ti

    n

    g.

    Of

    course writers

    who create

    fine

    pieces

    of

    finished writing without

    a

    s

    k

    e

    tc

    h

    s

    h

    o

    ul

    d

    n

    e

    v

    e

    r

    u

    se

    on

    e

    .

    E

    v

    e

    n

    th

    o

    s

    e

    w

    r

    it

    er

    s w

    h

    o

    a

    r

    e

    m

    o

    s

    t o

    pp

    o

    s

    e

    d

    to

    s

    k

    et

    c

    he

    s

    w

    ill r

    un

    i

    n

    to

    w

    r

    iti

    n

    g ta

    s

    ks th

    a

    t

    d

    em

    an

    d t

    he s

    uc

    c

    e

    ss

    f

    ul

    om

    p

    l

    et

    io

    n

    o

    f

    a

    s

    k

    et

    c

    h

    A

    n

    d

    i

    f

    y

    o

    u

    ta

    lk t

    o

    e

    f

    fe

    c

    ti

    ve

    w

    r

    it

    e

    rs w

    h

    o d

    o

    no

    t

    m

    a

    ke

    s

    k

    e

    tc

    h

    es

    on

    p

    a

    p

    e

    r w

    hi

    le

    th

    e

    y

    a

    r

    e

    in

    th

    e p

    re

    w

    r

    it

    in

    g

    st

    a

    ge

    y

    ou

    w

    i

    ll

    f

    in

    d

    t

    h

    at

    th

    e

    y

    ha

    v

    e

    a

    v

    e

    ry g

    oo

    d

    id

    e

    a o

    f w

    h

    e

    re th

    e

    y

    ar

    e h

    e

    ad

    e

    d

    .

    T

    h

    e

    ir sk

    e

    t

    ch

    is

    in

    th

    e

    ir

    h

    e

    ad

    no

    t

    on

    p

    a

    p

    e

    r.

    m

    t

    a

    lk

    in

    g

    a

    b

    o

    u

    t

    o

    u

    t

    lin

    i

    n

    g

    of

    c

    o

    ur

    s

    e

    b

    u

    t

    th

    e

    t

    er

    m

    o

    u

    tl

    in

    e

    h

    as a

    c

    o

    n

    n

    o

    ta

    ti

    o

    n

    of f

    o

    rm

    a

    l

    r

    ig

    i

    d

    p

    l

    an

    n

    in

    g w

    h

    i

    c

    h i

    s

    co

    n

    tr

    a

    d

    ic

    to

    r

    y to w

    ha

    t th

    e

    w

    r

    it

    e

    r d

    o

    e

    s

    .

    T

    h

    e sk

    e

    tc

    h

    is

    n

    o

    t

    a b

    lu

    e

    p

    ri

    n

    t

    th

    a

    t

    h

    as

    to b

    e f

    o

    ll

    ow

    ed

    ; it

    is

    a

    w

    a

    y of

    g

    u

    e

    ss

    in

    g w

    h

    a

    t

    th

    e

    p

    ie

    c

    e o

    f w

    r

    it

    in

    g

    wi

    ll

    lo

    o

    k

    li

    ke s

    o

    th

    a

    t

    t

    he

    w

    r

    i

    te

    r

    c

    a

    n ta

    k

    e

    a

    l

    oo

    k

    a

    t t

    h

    e

    p

    ie

    c

    e of

    w

    o

    rk t

    h

    a

    t

    m

    ay b

    e

    c

    o

    n

    s

    tr

    uc

    t

    ed

    a

    nd

    m

    ak

    e

    c

    h

    a

    ng

    e

    s

    b

    e

    fo

    r

    e t

    h

    e

    ti

    m

    e

    c

    o

    n

    s

    uming process

    of

    completing a

    draft.

    T

    h

    e

    r

    e ar

    e al

    so

    s

    o

    m

    e

    p

    i

    ec

    e

    s

    o

    f

    w

    ri

    ti

    n

    g

    t

    h

    a

    t

    a

    re

    al

    m

    o

    s

    t

    i

    m

    p

    o

    ss

    ib

    l

    e

    to

    o

    u

    t

    li

    ne

    or

    s

    k

    e

    tc

    h

    : h

    u

    m

    o

    r

    a

    m

    oo

    d p

    i

    ec

    e

    m

    o

    s

    t

    p

    o

    em

    s m

    u

    c

    h

    fi

    c

    ti

    o

    n

    es

    p

    e

    ci

    a

    ll

    y th

    a

    t w

    h

    ic

    h

    d

    ep

    e

    n

    d

    s

    o

    n

    c

    ha

    r

    a

    ct

    er m

    o

    re

    t

    ha

    n p

    lo

    t f

    or it

    s s

    uc

    c

    e

    ss

    .

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    10/14

    There

    are

    a

    number

    ol dilterent vavs

    to

    sketch i

    piece

    of

    writing in

    Fr nnc.

    Fhe

    sketch

    most

    frequently

    use builds

    naturally

    trom

    the

    planning

    te hniques

    used

    in

    this

    section of

    the

    book.

    have

    a

    title

    a

    lead

    the

    three

    to

    five main points

    and an ending.

    have

    built a

    frame

    around what want

    to

    say.

    know where

    will

    start and how.

    know

    where

    expect to

    end and how.

    And

    have

    a

    strong

    sense

    of how

    will

    get

    from

    beginning to end.

    have

    the

    same feeling.

    am sure

    that

    a builder

    has when

    a

    house is

    framed

    in;

    theres a lot

    of work

    to

    do

    but

    the entire

    job

    can he

    visualized.

    Fhis

    sketch

    allows

    me

    to

    examine

    the

    voice

    as well as

    the

    structure

    of

    the

    piece of

    writing. In

    an

    article

    or

    a

    chapter

    usually

    write a

    draft

    very

    fast

    it one sitting

    or

    two and Im

    able to

    do this

    because

    the sketch

    is

    so complete.

    As

    build this frame

    may look back

    and

    use

    titles

    leads endings

    trails

    have

    sketched earlier. may look back

    and

    use

    some and

    use

    new

    ones

    that

    come to

    mind

    or

    may choose

    not

    to look

    back

    but

    just

    to

    sit

    down

    and make a

    new

    frame knowing

    that all the

    work

    have done is

    in

    my head

    where it belongs. can

    check

    back later if feel

    it

    will

    help.

    Qucri.

    Nonfiction,

    both magazine

    articles

    and

    books is

    often

    p

    r

    posed

    and sold

    by

    a query.

    Many

    writers

    use

    a letter to

    query

    an

    editor

    but find

    that letters

    tend to

    become

    discursive and

    do not

    allow

    the

    writer to

    show how

    he or

    she

    intends

    to

    write

    the piece and

    do

    not

    help

    the

    editor

    visualize

    the

    piece.

    write my address

    and phone

    number

    single spaced

    in

    the

    tipper

    left hand

    corner of a

    piece

    of

    plain

    paper.

    Two

    lines

    down

    in

    caps

    and

    underlined

    put the title and under

    it in upper and

    lower

    case

    en

    tered

    the

    name

    intend

    to

    use in

    writing

    the piece. Two

    more

    lines

    down

    single spaced

    write

    the

    lead

    as

    think it

    will he written

    in

    the

    final

    copy.

    do not

    tell

    the

    editor about the

    piece

    but reveal

    it

    through

    this

    lead which is

    ordinarily

    not

    more

    than ten

    lines.

    Then

    indented

    single spaced

    and

    hulleted

    make in

    five lines

    or less

    the

    three

    to

    five

    main

    points. Then

    back

    out to

    the normal margin

    and single spaced

    write

    a

    paragraph

    or

    two telling

    the editor

    about

    any

    special

    qualifica

    tions

    have permissions

    to

    get the

    story research

    materials

    market

    possibilities anything

    the

    editor

    needs to know. This

    takes

    no more

    than

    one page

    unless

    am proposing

    a

    book in

    which case

    the bulleted

    items

    become

    chapters each

    one

    with a title

    and five lines

    telling what

    would

    he in

    the chapter.

    In that

    case

    the

    proposal

    is

    two to

    three

    pages

    long.

    The

    query

    of

    course

    is not appropriate

    for

    the mood

    or humor

    piece.

    Such pieces

    have to

    he written

    and

    then

    submitted

    because

    the

    editor

    has to

    see and hear

    the

    voice

    to

    decide if it

    should

    he published.

    hat

    the

    de

    r

    hat

    ii

    e

    S

    can

    te rs

    s in

    like

    pful

    w

    n

    w

    a

    wed

    .5

    of

    no

    eep

    ig.

    iou

    sed

    O

    m

    iake

    lind

    etch

    ias

    a

    t

    the

    it

    is

    the

    and

    ift.

    le

    to

    tion

    :esS.

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    11/14

    th

    the

    ore

    SI ii

    xes

    ii

    ts

    the

    yard

    and

    S

    hers

    any

    best

    cate

    fore

    he

    ted

    a

    ns

    urses

    N

    were

    ore

    en

    rmal

    aty

    nt

    to

    age

    VIAs

    37

    or belo

    wav

    erag

    e

    stud

    ents

    . Ihe

    re

    w

    ere

    no

    pro

    gram

    s

    For

    stu

    den

    ts

    who

    ha

    d

    lea

    rnin

    g

    p

    robl

    ems

    . came

    From

    a

    p

    oor

    educ

    atiu

    nal

    b

    ackg

    roun

    d

    or

    sp

    oke

    ano

    ther lang

    uage tha

    n En

    glish at h

    orn

    E

    The

    on

    eroo

    m

    sch

    ool

    hous

    e

    or small

    local

    high

    school

    otf

    d

    very

    Few

    co

    urses

    and

    they

    wer

    e

    o

    ften taug

    ht

    out

    of an

    cien

    x

    thoo

    ks

    that were out

    of

    date. There were few

    si n

    Iaciht

    or

    courses

    th

    at

    req

    uired

    spe

    cial

    equ

    ipm

    ent

    or

    special

    te

    ache

    r

    tr

    ing .

    Fea

    cher

    s

    t

    augh

    t ma

    ny

    s

    ubje

    cts for

    w

    hich

    th

    ey

    we

    re unp

    pared

    s

    tayi

    ng a

    day

    ah

    ead

    of the s

    tude

    nts if

    t

    hey

    w

    ere

    luck

    nd ha

    d

    n

    ot

    m

    oonl

    ighte

    d

    a

    t ano

    ther job the nigh

    t

    befo to

    m

    ake

    end

    s

    m

    eet

    Teac

    hing m

    ethod

    s

    we

    re

    p

    rim

    itive

    dull

    d repe

    titive

    .

    Sp

    ellin

    g

    for

    ex

    amp

    le

    was

    u

    sua

    lly

    taug

    ht

    thro

    ug e

    s

    pelli

    ng bee

    Poor spel

    lers

    wa

    s

    one

    w

    ere el

    imin

    ated

    n

    augh

    t. llthe at

    tenti

    on

    wen

    t

    to

    the good spel

    lers wh

    o

    surv

    ive

    an

    d

    co

    mpet

    ed

    a

    gain

    st e

    ach

    o

    ther

    .

    Th

    e

    a

    rticl

    e will obv

    iousl

    y

    ye a

    str

    ong pe

    rson

    al

    poi

    nt

    of

    view

    am

    still

    angry

    at

    the educati

    I

    did not receive

    in

    a school system which

    w

    as

    c

    onsi

    dere

    d

    one of

    th es

    t in the natio

    n. I d

    o

    h

    owe

    ver hav

    e access

    to

    re

    cord

    s

    ev

    en

    so

    stu

    den t

    pape

    rs fro

    m the goo

    d ol

    d

    da

    ys

    be

    twe

    en

    W

    orld

    War

    nd W

    orld

    W

    ar

    11

    and

    I

    will

    d

    ocum

    ent

    my

    case

    wit

    h ob

    ject

    ive

    e

    vid

    cc

    will l

    ight

    en up

    the sta

    tistic

    s

    with q

    uote

    s from

    s

    tude

    nts

    a

    nd tea

    ers ab

    out th

    e goo

    d old days

    and a

    few a

    necd

    otes of

    my

    ow

    n su

    ch th

    e day

    the

    te

    ache

    r

    was r

    emo

    ved from class

    beca

    use

    he

    r enga

    gern t

    h

    ad

    b

    een

    an

    noun

    ced

    .

    The

    re

    w

    as

    no

    ev

    iden

    ce tha

    t

    sh

    ed

    d

    one

    it

    y

    bu

    t

    th

    e en

    gage

    men

    t

    a

    nnou

    nce

    men

    t

    s

    how

    ed she int

    ende

    d

    to

    d

    o

    it ar

    ried

    wom

    en

    t

    each

    ers wer

    e

    ag

    ains

    t

    th

    e

    law in

    m

    ost s

    cho

    ol

    dis

    trict

    and man

    y

    te

    ach

    ers h

    ad to sup

    port

    th

    eir

    par

    ents and

    c

    ould

    not

    a

    ffor to ge

    t

    ma

    rried dur in

    g the D

    epre

    ssion

    b

    ecau

    se t

    hey

    wou

    ld

    lose

    th

    jobs They were

    ca

    ugh

    t

    in a tra

    p.

    No

    wo

    nder

    Miss Ca

    rey bro

    ke a

    r

    e

    r

    s

    lam

    ming th

    e

    de

    sk ev

    ery few

    wee

    ks

    an

    d jamm

    ed

    had stud

    ents

    ys

    eif in

    clud

    ed

    ru

    mp

    dow

    n

    into a

    was

    teba

    sket

    .

    olumn

    W

    rite

    rs

    n

    eed a ske

    tch to co

    ntro

    l

    th

    e

    a

    bun

    danc

    e

    of ma

    teria

    l

    the

    y

    ac

    cum

    ulat

    e

    befo

    re be

    ginn

    ing

    a

    dra

    ft. Don

    ald

    G

    rav

    es

    w

    ho

    stud

    ies

    t

    he

    w

    ritin

    g of

    c

    hild

    ren

    an

    d a

    lso

    w

    rite

    s him

    self

    d

    raws

    a

    colu

    mn do

    wn

    th

    e left

    s

    ide of

    a page

    He p

    uts

    ev

    eryt

    hing tha

    t

    mi

    ght poss

    ibly b

    e in

    the

    a

    rticl

    e

    or c

    hapt

    er

    in

    that

    co

    lumn

    .

    Th

    en he

    dra

    ws thr

    ee

    a

    ddit

    iona

    l

    colu

    mns

    a

    nd

    h

    eads

    the

    first

    o

    ne

    beg

    inn

    ing the

    s

    econ

    d

    o

    ne

    midd

    le

    and the

    third

    one

    end.

    F fe

    places items

    in

    each column. Obviously some things

    are left o

    ut an

    d

    ne

    w it

    ems

    oc

    cur to hi

    m tha

    t

    h

    ave n

    ot

    b

    een in

    the

    lef

    t han

    d

    c

    olum

    n.

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    12/14

    S

    H

    IJ

    V

    [

    II

    N

    l

    IR

    1

    u

    b

    I

    : [

    IL

    k

    l

    [

    V

    L

    I

    i

    \;

    B

    u

    y.

    l

    l

    i

    e

    se

    s

    ke

    t

    ch

    e

    s

    a

    re

    vv

    ay

    o

    f

    v

    is

    u

    a

    liz

    i

    n

    g

    th

    e

    fi

    n

    is

    h

    ed

    r

    o

    d

    uc

    t

    v

    va

    v

    ot

    dr

    a

    w

    in

    g

    a

    m

    a

    p

    o

    t

    w

    h

    a

    t

    m

    a

    y

    be

    e

    xp

    l

    o

    re

    d

    n

    e te

    r

    es

    t

    in

    g

    w

    a

    y

    t

    o

    d

    o

    th

    i

    s i

    s

    to

    d

    r

    a

    w

    s

    k

    e

    tc

    h

    th

    a

    t is

    b

    a

    se

    d

    o

    n [

    lie i

    m

    p

    a

    ct

    [l

    ie

    p

    a

    rt

    s

    o

    f

    a

    n

    a

    r

    ti

    cl

    e w

    il

    l

    h

    a

    v

    e o

    n t

    he

    r

    e

    ad

    e

    r

    . I

    he

    lea

    d

    m

    ig

    h

    t

    be

    r

    e

    p

    re

    s

    en

    t

    ed

    by

    bo

    x

    th

    a

    t t

    a

    k

    es

    quarter of

    the page

    Ihe end

    might

    be

    as large

    and

    one

    o

    r

    t

    w

    o

    tu

    r

    n

    in

    g

    p

    o

    nt

    s

    lm

    os

    t a

    s

    l

    ar

    ge

    F

    li

    e s

    k

    et

    c

    h w

    o

    u

    ld

    s

    h

    o

    w

    th

    a

    t t

    h

    e

    fi

    rst

    pa

    ra

    g

    ri

    p

    h

    h

    a

    s

    n

    o

    rm

    o

    us m

    p

    ac

    t

    l

    re

    a

    d

    er

    ,

    an

    d

    th

    a

    i

    i

    x t

    s

    ix p

    a

    g

    e

    s

    [

    or

    e

    x

    a

    m

    p

    le

    , b

    e

    fo

    r

    e a m

    a

    j

    o

    r t

    ur

    n

    in

    g p

    o

    in

    t h

    a

    v

    e

    li

    ttl

    e

    n

    p

    t

    th

    e

    p

    o

    in

    t

    o

    t

    t

    he

    s

    ke

    t

    ch

    is

    t

    o

    m

    a

    k

    e

    s

    u

    re

    t

    he w

    ri

    te

    r

    k

    n

    o

    w

    s

    th

    o

    se p

    o

    in

    t

    s

    of

    i

    m

    p

    a

    c

    t

    an

    d

    t

    h

    en

    d

    is

    c

    o

    ve

    r

    s h

    ow

    to g

    e

    t

    t

    he

    r

    ea

    d

    e

    r

    to t

    he

    m

    .

    Re

    x

    plu

    s

    ce

    lu

    u

    n

    t

    he

    w

    o

    rk

    i

    ng

    w

    r

    it

    e

    r

    c

    o

    n

    st

    a

    nt

    ly

    e

    x

    p

    er

    im

    e

    nt

    s

    ,

    d

    pt

    i

    ng

    te

    c

    hn

    i

    q

    ue

    s

    h

    e

    o

    r

    sh

    e l

    e

    ar

    n

    s

    t

    ro

    m

    co

    l

    le

    a

    g

    ue

    s

    .

    In

    o

    u

    tl

    in

    in

    g

    th

    e c

    h

    a

    p

    te

    rs

    f

    or

    o

    n

    e b

    o

    o

    k

    m

    a

    d

    e

    ;

    r W

    es

    lef

    t

    h

    an

    d

    c

    ot

    u

    in

    h

    at

    ft

    h

    e

    p

    a

    g

    e

    th

    e

    n

    ,

    w

    i

    th

    t

    he

    o

    th

    e

    r

    h

    alf

    m

    a

    d

    e

    a

    si

    z

    ab

    l

    e

    b

    ox

    b

    r t

    he

    t

    itl

    e

    t

    h

    e

    l

    e

    ad

    a

    n

    d

    th

    e en

    d

    .

    T

    he

    s

    p

    a

    ce

    in

    be

    t

    w

    e

    en

    w

    a

    s [

    or

    t

    h

    e

    s

    e

    q

    u

    en

    c

    e

    o

    n

    t

    h

    e

    le

    ft

    ha

    nd

    s

    id

    e an

    d

    th

    e

    d

    o

    c

    u

    m

    e

    n

    ta

    ti

    o

    n

    o

    n

    t

    h

    e r

    ig

    ht-hand

    side Working

    through

    this sketch

    h

    e

    l

    pe

    d

    m

    e

    m

    a

    k

    e

    a

    m

    u

    c

    h b

    e

    tt

    e

    r

    b

    o

    ok

    an

    d

    a

    m

    or

    e

    i

    n

    te

    re

    s

    ti

    n

    g

    on

    e

    t

    ha

    n

    c

    o

    u

    ld

    ha

    v

    e

    i

    m

    a

    g

    in

    e

    d

    .

    R

    c

    nd

    ur

    s f

    uc

    st

    u

    us

    \

    nt

    ic

    i

    pa

    t

    in

    g

    th

    e

    q

    u

    es

    t

    io

    n

    s

    th

    e

    r

    ea

    d

    e

    r m

    us

    t

    h

    a

    ve

    a

    n

    s

    w

    e

    re

    d i

    f

    th

    e

    w

    r

    it

    er

    i

    s

    to

    p

    ro

    d

    u

    c

    e

    a

    n

    e

    ff

    e

    ct

    iv

    e

    an

    d

    s

    a

    ti

    sf

    y

    in

    g

    pie

    ce

    ot

    w

    ri

    ti

    n

    g

    i

    s a

    t

    ec

    h

    n

    iq

    u

    e

    h

    a

    v

    e m

    en

    t

    io

    n

    e

    d ea

    r

    li

    er

    in

    th

    is

    s

    e

    ct

    io

    n

    o

    n

    p

    la

    n

    n

    in

    g

    a

    n

    d

    w

    il

    l

    m

    e

    nt

    io

    n

    in

    C

    h

    a

    p

    te

    r

    3

    in

    t

    h

    e

    s

    ec

    t

    io

    n o

    n

    r

    e

    vi

    s

    in

    g

    It

    i

    s

    a

    ls

    o a

    g

    o

    o

    d

    w

    a

    y

    to

    m

    a

    k

    e

    a

    s

    ke

    t

    ch

    of

    a

    b

    o

    ok

    t

    he e

    as

    ie

    s

    t w

    ay

    t

    o

    d

    o

    t

    h

    is

    i

    s

    to

    d

    ra

    w a

    lin

    e

    d

    o

    w

    n

    th

    e c

    e

    nt

    e

    r

    o

    f th

    e

    p

    a

    ge

    s

    p

    ac

    e

    th

    e r

    e

    ad

    e

    r

    s f

    ive

    qu

    e

    s

    ti

    on

    s

    o

    r

    so

    in

    th

    e

    l

    eft

    c

    o

    lu

    m

    n

    ,

    a

    n

    d

    sk

    e

    t

    ch

    i

    n

    th

    e

    a

    n

    s

    w

    e

    rs in

    th

    e

    r

    ig

    h

    t

    Y

    ou

    may

    have

    to

    number a

    nd

    m

    o

    v

    e

    t

    h

    e q

    u

    e

    st

    io

    n

    s

    ar

    o

    u

    nd

    u

    n

    ti

    l

    y

    o

    u a

    re

    a

    b

    le

    t

    o

    a

    n

    ti

    ci

    p

    at

    e

    th

    e

    o

    rd

    e

    r

    in

    w

    hi

    c

    h

    t

    he

    r

    e

    ad

    e

    r

    w

    ill a

    s

    k

    t

    h

    em.

    B

    rnc

    k

    tt

    .

    M

    a

    n

    y

    p

    e

    op

    l

    e

    w

    o

    rk

    i

    n

    g

    w

    it

    h

    c

    o

    m

    p

    u

    t

    er

    s

    m

    a

    k

    e

    a

    s

    k

    e

    tc

    h th

    a

    t

    w

    o

    rk

    s

    f

    ro

    m

    ri

    g

    h

    t to

    le

    ft

    a

    n

    d

    u

    s

    e

    s

    b

    ra

    c

    k

    et

    s

    to

    en

    c

    lo

    s

    e th

    e

    ex

    t

    re

    m

    e

    s

    w

    i

    th

    i

    n

    a

    su

    b

    je

    c

    t o

    r

    p

    r

    ob

    l

    e

    m t

    o

    b

    e

    s

    o

    lv

    e

    d

    . F

    or

    e

    x

    a

    m

    p

    le

    ,

    u

    s

    ed

    th

    i

    s

    te

    c

    h

    ni

    q

    u

    e

    f

    or a

    ch

    a

    p

    te

    r

    o

    n

    w

    r

    it

    e

    r

    s b

    lo

    ck

    th

    a

    t

    h

    a

    d

    d

    if

    fi

    c

    ul

    ty

    or

    g

    a

    ni

    z

    in

    g

    .

    p

    ut

    w

    r

    i

    te

    r

    s b

    lo

    ck

    a

    t

    th

    e

    le

    ft of

    t

    h

    e

    pa

    g

    e

    ,

    t

    h

    en

    at

    th

    e

    to

    p

    o

    f th

    e

    p

    a

    g

    e

    p

    u

    t

    g

    o

    od

    a

    n

    d

    a

    t

    th

    e

    b

    o

    tto

    m

    o

    f

    th

    e

    p

    a

    ge h

    a

    d

    .

    T

    h

    e

    n

    w

    o

    r

    k

    e

    d o

    u

    t

    th

    e

    e

    x

    tr

    em

    e

    s

    of g

    oo

    d

    an

    d

    b

    a

    d

    in

    a

    se

    r

    ie

    s

    o

    f b

    r

    a

    ck

    e

    ts

    . In

    th

    e

    en

    d

    w

    r

    o

    te

    a

    p

    ie

    c

    e

    th

    a

    t w

    a

    s

    e

    x

    a

    c

    tl

    y

    th

    e o

    p

    p

    o

    si

    te

    o

    f

    w

    h

    at

    in

    te

    n

    d

    e

    d

    b

    ef

    o

    re

    d

    id

    th

    e

    s

    k

    et

    c

    h.

    w

    r

    ot

    e a

    bo

    u

    t

    th

    e i

    m

    p

    o

    rt

    a

    nc

    e of

    w

    ri

    te

    r

    s

    b

    l

    oc

    k

    an

    d

    t

    h

    e

    b

    e

    n

    ef

    it

    s

    for

    the writer.

    T

    re

    e.

    A

    n

    ot

    h

    er

    w

    ay

    to

    s

    e

    e a

    h

    ea

    d

    t

    o

    w

    h

    a

    t

    m

    a

    y

    h

    e

    w

    ri

    tt

    e

    n i

    s

    to

    d

    ra

    w

    a

    tr

    e

    e th

    a

    t

    sh

    o

    w

    s

    ho

    w

    th

    e

    su

    b

    je

    c

    t

    th

    e

    tr

    un

    k

    m

    ay

    b

    ra

    n

    c

    h o

    u

    t

    a

    n

    d

    g

    r

    ow

    in

    m

    an

    y

    d

    ir

    ec

    t

    io

    n

    s

    .

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    13/14

    39

    duct

    Shapt We

    have all

    seen

    shaped

    poems

    in which the

    typography

    way

    mi

    tafts

    the

    subject a

    poem

    about

    bird

    appears in

    he

    Iiape

    ol

    its

    ot

    bird Shape

    is

    important

    to a

    writer

    and

    its helpful for

    me

    sometimes

    w

    a

    to

    sketch

    the

    shape

    of

    the piece

    of

    writing. It

    may be

    triangle

    a

    fever

    chart

    stairsteps

    - idewavs

    cone

    leading

    to

    one point or its

    reverse

    it

    the

    expanding

    [rom

    one point.

    These

    sketches

    may help me

    see the

    structure

    next

    may

    attempt in

    the writing.

    List

    Lists

    are

    a powerful

    tool

    and

    the

    simple

    list

    may

    he

    the

    best

    way to sketch what is

    written

    The

    writer

    can

    start

    y

    putting

    down

    everything

    that

    has to

    he in the piece

    of

    writing

    and then

    either

    num

    dapt

    bering

    or

    renumbering to

    achieve

    a

    working

    order. The

    writer

    usually

    ipters

    also uses arrows

    and circles and

    lines

    to maneuver

    the parts of

    the

    piece

    with

    into

    coherent

    and logical

    order.

    used a variation

    of

    list

    in sketching

    end.

    this

    book

    y

    writing

    increasingly

    detailed tables

    of contents.

    Fhat helped

    e

    and

    me

    see

    where all

    the small

    parts

    of

    a large

    topic how

    to

    teach

    writing

    ketch

    might

    fit so

    they

    would

    be

    available

    to

    a teacher in

    a

    logical

    order.

    in

    Sten

    beard

    Most

    him

    writers

    make a

    sketch

    by

    using

    three hytive

    inch

    cards. Each

    one will

    have

    a

    word

    or

    a few

    lines about a

    potential

    have

    scene

    in the

    movie. The

    writer

    pins those

    up

    on a

    corkhoard

    and moves

    ccc

    of

    them around

    until

    they are in the

    best

    dramatic

    order.

    have

    found

    this

    nning

    technique

    helpful

    for

    nomfiction

    writing. The

    writer

    puts

    each

    element

    also

    a

    that

    may be in

    the

    final

    piece of

    writing

    down

    on

    a card

    or slip

    of

    paper

    is to

    and then

    plays

    around

    with them

    until

    the

    writer has

    a sketch to

    follow

    stions

    in

    the

    writing

    of the

    piece.

    Often certain

    elements

    are discarded

    and

    t

    You

    new ones added.

    re

    able

    Feldtrs

    If

    the

    writer is

    doing

    a complicated

    research

    subject it is

    often

    helpful to

    set

    tip

    a

    series

    of file folders.

    Then

    notes tear

    sheets

    :h

    that

    and copies

    of

    articles

    even

    books

    can be

    placed

    in

    folders

    and those

    within

    folders can

    be moved

    around

    as

    the

    writer

    works towards

    an

    effective

    hnique

    sketch

    of the book. The

    earliest

    sketches

    of this hook

    took place

    in that

    put

    way

    in

    my

    file drawer.

    e1

    PU t

    Outline.

    The

    formal

    outline

    can

    be a

    helpful

    way fo r

    some

    writers

    te

    to

    sketch the

    subject. The

    advantage of

    a

    system

    of

    Roman

    numerals

    did

    the

    Arabic

    numbers capital

    letters

    and

    small

    letters

    is

    that

    it

    allows

    a

    detailed

    enefits

    form

    of

    planning.

    An

    early

    version

    of

    the

    table

    of

    contents helped

    me

    see

    this

    book

    and

    used

    a whole

    symphony

    of

    typographical

    marks to

    divide topics

    into subtopics

    then

    divide them

    again

    and

    again.

    o

    draw

    The

    danger of

    a

    traditional

    outline

    is

    that the writer

    will

    take

    it too

    iut

    and

    seriously.

    It

    was

    helpful

    for

    me

    to

    make a

    detailed

    outline for this

    book

    but

    it

    was important

    for

    me in

    drafting the

    book

    to

    loosen

    up

    and

  • 8/10/2019 Writer Teaches Writing - Murray

    14/14

    3

    if

    LJ

    II

    11

    SI

    ;

    L

    P

    RO

    E

    * J

    if

    i

    1Y

    O

    F

    ti

    i

    O

    m

    p

    ro

    v

    s

    e

    m

    m

    t

    ha

    t ou

    tl

    ine

    th

    e

    w

    ay

    a

    ja

    zz

    m

    u

    sic

    ia

    n u

    se

    s a

    me

    lo

    dy

    a

    nd

    a

    z

    i

    t

    ra

    di

    tio

    n 1

    m

    m

    wh

    ic

    h

    to

    d

    ep

    ar

    t

    in

    p

    er

    to

    rm

    in

    g

    R

    e

    m

    em

    b

    er

    tha

    t

    t

    he

    a

    m

    ou

    nt

    p

    la

    nn

    in

    g

    fo

    r

    a

    g

    iv

    en

    pi

    ec

    e

    of w

    ri

    tin

    g

    w

    il

    l

    d

    ep

    e

    nd

    o

    n

    t

    he

    co

    gn

    iti

    ve

    st

    yle

    an

    d

    x

    p

    ri

    n

    o

    t t

    he w

    rit

    er

    as

    wc

    ll

    a

    s

    th

    e

    na

    tu

    re

    a

    nd fam

    i

    lia

    rit

    y

    t

    he

    w

    ri

    tin

    g

    t

    as

    k W

    rit

    ing

    is

    n

    o

    t a

    m

    il

    ita

    ry

    ex

    e

    rci

    se

    an

    d students should

    not

    be

    marched

    through

    writing

    by

    the

    nu

    ni

    be

    rs

    a

    ch

    pi

    ec

    e

    w

    ri

    tin

    g

    sh

    o

    uld

    b

    e

    se

    ar

    ch

    in

    g

    fo

    r i

    ts

    o

    w

    n m

    e

    an

    ing

    a

    nd

    i

    ts

    ow

    n

    w

    ay

    ex

    pr

    es

    sin

    g

    m

    e

    an

    in

    g w

    it

    h

    th

    e w

    rit

    er

    fol

    lo

    wi

    ng

    al

    on

    g

    h

    el

    pi

    ng

    b

    ut

    no

    t

    in

    ter

    te

    rin

    g

    w

    it

    h th

    e

    n

    atu

    ra

    l

    pro

    c

    es

    s

    o

    f

    dis

    co

    v

    ery

    th

    a

    t

    ta

    k

    es

    p

    lac

    e

    i

    n

    a

    ll

    g

    oo

    d

    wr

    iti

    ng