World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/...16 Alaa HAmed Abd Expert operation and...

E2286 VOL. 7

Consultant Office

Appendix (5) Events of 1st public meeting on 08/09/2009

Friday 419/2009 On AI Ahram news paper

j'.. A ~ ~

a."..-... t.>J~1 Jj~t~~,,,tALtf~ ($r

" .. ~1Sj1t~ __WIIiI!,..!

r ~ .. ,,/'\ ; ..U':J!1I., ",. • «\ / '11A~t,,.tt .J.;~"!t\ ~-'"

i.:>~ ~~ ~JL-.j.1 .1..cL....JI

Draft Final report (3) (or updating and modernizing TB2

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Consultant Office

Scanned lists of the attendance written hy themselves

\ t

" -4

3

Draft Final report (3) {or updating and modernizing TE2 2

Consultant Office

Draft Final report (3) (or updating and modernizing TB2 3

Consultant Office

~~~.~------....................------------------------------------------

Drafi Final report (3) tor updating and modernizing TB2 4

Consultant Office

•

Draft Final report (3) for updating and modernizing TB2 5

Consultant Office

~~~------------------------------------------------------------~

Draft Final report (3) (or updating and modernizing TE2 6

Consultant Office

no Name Job tiUe Company Tel. No e-mail Address

1. Bahaa EI Deen Askar General Manager Egypt Air 0123622601 b.askar(wyahoo. com

2. Ali Abd Allah EIAid General Manager and Vice-Chairman of the Committee on Environment

Egypt Air 0101221585 Elabd48(c'i;hotma il.com

3. Abd EL Waheed Shafee Administrative officer

Cairo Airport Company

0104824487

4. Mokhtar Ibrahim Administrative officer


0167384916

5. Said Fadeel Administrative officer


0107586913

6. Said Abd Alaah Bayomi

Administrative officer


3232

7. Abdel Aziz Ahmed Senior Specialist at TBI


4331

8. Farrouk AbdEI Hal Expert of transport and traffic in the study

MB Consultant 0121652231 FCQm 4rcv.hotma il.com

9. Mohamed Abd EI Fatah

HV AC engineer Cairo Airport Company

2178

10 Mohamed Salah Assistant professor Mechanical Engineering

Faculty of Engineering Ain Shams University

0109752816 Salah mamdoun @engineering.co m

II Mohsen AbdAllah Air Quality Technician

Center for Environmental Risk Reduction Cairo University

0122658915

12 Ragheb Said Abou EI Magd

Power Engineer air quality sector, Ministry of Environment

•

0129844769 Ragheb sied@v ahoo.com

13. Mohamed Hassan Computer Me 00 Stoyhere 86(mh I


Consultant Office

no Name Job title Company Tel. No e-mail Address , ,

Salah Engineering of Ramadan otmai1.com Business Men Association

14 Emad Mohamed Assistant professor Faculty of 0102916793 Emad aklc{ivyah Ahmed at electric Engineering AI- oO.com

department Azhar :

I

University

I 15 Hassan Said Assistant professor AI-Azhar 0101237772 Thefuctor dram

of Preventive University (W)::ahoo.com Medicine Faculty of

: Medicine

16 Alaa HAmed Abd Expert operation and Ministry of 0103050191 Alaa hamed85 EIMpatte maintenance of Air Environment, falhotmail.com

quality monitoring Egypt stations

17 Badawia Mohamed Senior supervisor Administrative 4412 Services Development at

I


18 Fatma Ibrahim Director of TB2 Cairo 2816 Information center Airport

Company

19 Hoda Fadel Farag Information center TB2 Cairo 2544 i Airport

Company 20 Nayera Ramadan Information center TB2 Cairo 2816

Airport Company

21 Asmaa Mohamed Premium Service Cairo Airport 2255 passenger Officer Company

22 Somaia Ahmed Protocol department TB2 Cairo 2503 I Airport

Company 23 Nariman Mohamed Protocol department TBI Cairo 3055 Narnarl980@xa

Airport hoo.com Company

241 Amani Mohamed Environmental Egyptian 0110757472 Amanyaboel so Specialist Company for [email protected]

Airports 25 Sanaa Osman Director General of Egyptian 0101421107 Sanaa os@yaho

Quality control & Company for


Consultant Office

no Name .Job title Company Tel. NQ e-mail Address "

o.comenvironment Airports

26 Walaa Hamed Environmental Specialist

Egyptian Company for Airports

0101978941 Wmyo 16 7@,y ahoo.com

27 Iman Ahmed Environmental Specialist


0103568131 Emy 618Cwyaho o.com

28 Waleed Mohamed Environmental Specialist


0103724127 Waleed.elsaghee [email protected]

29 Hassan EIHami Aviation Observer Technical Office for operation at Cairo airport company

0107882732 Elhami hassan @vahoo.com

30 Hebah Saeed Supervisor for Safety measure

Cairo airport company

0103938140 Heba said45(t1)y ahoo.com

31 Mageed Hamed • Senior Specialist of the environment

World Bank Mhamed I @worl dbank.org;

32 Tomader Sabri General Manager of Quality Control


0102522750 t.sabrey(Wcairoai mort.com

33 Ahmed Mohamed Quality control specialist


0124073976 Ahedemam 14@ hotmail.com

I

34 Amira EISaid Director of Technical Office

Egypt Air 0168821508 Amira egYQtair !

Cwhotmai1.com

35 Noha Mohamed Quality supervisor Cairo airport company

0127805828 nohaQotrv@hot mail.com

36 Mai Mohamed Quality supervisor • Cairo airport company

0103080823 Maimsalem2009 ;a:hotmai I.com

37 Nada Mohamed • Environmental Specialist


0103596893 Nw3m 30@hot maiJ.com

38 Eman Khalaf Environmental Specialist


0121752325 emankhallaf(iih:a hoo.com

391 Rasha Mohamed

i

' Environmental Specialist


0111486390

Draft Final report (3) tor updating and modernizing TB2 9

Consultant Office

no Name .Job title Company Tel. No e-mail Address

40 Amani Melad Planning and Cairo airport 4864 monitoring company Specialist

41 Nour Gelani Clark Cairo airport 4798 company

42 Mahasen Mohamed Head of specialist in Cairo airport 4864 administrative company development

43 Dena Yousef Environmental Cairo airport 2209 specialist company

44 Ghada Abd ElHafeez Environmental Cairo airport 2209 specialist company

45 Farag EI Razaz . Director of Cairo airport 2187 Environmental company Inspection department

46 Ahmed Helmi Director of the Cairo airport 7446 rmhelmy(aJhotm aviation safety company ail.com

47 Nahed Nessem Director of the noise Ministry of 0122407022 nahedns(O)yahoo. Protection section Environment com

48 Samah Sallah Environmental MB consultant 24186182 Eng.mbconsulta Engineer ntl7ilvahoo.com

49: Mona Mohamed Assistant General Egypt Air 26964913 mrashwan(iiJegy Manager Human Airlines ptair.com Resources

I 50 Mohamed Fekry Environmental Ministry of 01011555724 m .f.grana(ill.hotm inspector Civil Aviation ail.com

51 Mohamed Mohamed Head of Central Ministry of 0117404303 Skiko moh(aJya Department for Civil Aviation hoo.com Planning

52! Mazar Emam Ali Director of Ministry of 0105423452 Dr.mazarl7ilhotm Environmental Civil Aviation ~ Affairs

53 Mohamed Mahoud Assistant Researcher National Center 0123664061 Mohamed mah for Research moud 84((llvaho

o.com

Draft Final report (3) {or updating and modernizing TB2 10

Consultant Office

Office Manager MB consultant 24186182 Eng.mbconsulta nttliiyahoo.com

Questions and comments from the attendance during 1 sl the public meeting

Name Job title Comments Reply Eng.Ahmed Director of safety He said that the Air Quality Expert ofthe Helmy and occupational study is project stated that it

health at Cairo "optimistic" for already exists "rather International air and traffic, but than creating from Airport is concerned scratch".

about the truth on All emissions limits are the effect of the within the boundaries of wind speed and the Egyptian law. the direction on the measurements for air quality.

Mrs. Hoda Fadel Information center Pointed to the Idea welcomed and of TB2 at Cairo need for ratified by Consultant International disseminating the and Major GeneraL Airport culture of airports, They agreed that clearly

and media disseminating awareness in a information about the manner to airport is a good idea. maintain behaviors through advertising on television and the Internet.

Mrs. Badria Administrative Indicated that No one can deny this Abo-Zaid Development, some people pay very important point and

Cairo Airport more than once at an opportunity to Company toll gates. This purchase the 3-hours

effect leaves a bad ticket has been made impression on available. public services Public awareness should and passengers at be a top priority. the airport.

Draft Final report (3) [or updating and modernizing TB2 II

Consultant Office

Name Job title O)mments Reply

Mrs. Shakenaz Director of the Research Center for Environmental Studies - Professor, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University

I . Asked if this meeting is the first or second and what is the status of the EIA report.

All this data was presented on one page that has been passed to all attendees at the beginning of the meeting and during the presentations.

2. Commented that the noise is quantitative and very good traffic is not qualitative regarding air quality there is a needs for air modeling. She also indicated that the current system for solid waste management is very good and there is no need to study it.

This study is still in the preparation phase and not yet over. During the second meeting all required data will be presented. It was clear that the presentation was limited to allow for public questions.

So the target is to provide more time for the public to offer their views, especially given that the meeting had been held during Ramadan. It was explained that this is the first and there will be another meeting on the 29/9/2009 to completely answer all

3. Referred to the need for dealing

with the risks (Risk assessment)

4. Referred to the need for social the points that have been (Social study) addressed in this

meeting. Dr. Foad Khalaf Professor, Faculty

of Engineering, Cairo University

Attention should be paid to different services - toilet water parking lots - the users ofthe airport and the free market System maintenance after

Risk ofHlNl did not end at this stage and we will show what preventative measures were taken. It will be reported in the second meeting.

Draft Final report (3) [Or updating and modernizing TB2 12

Consultant Office

Name Job title Comments Reply ~,

20 years will be fully improved by taking full advantage of the environmental impact study, which is reflected directly on the reputation. In addition to dealing with epidemics and infection.

Eng. Nahed General manager Environmental • has no effect because Saleb of the Department management has these sites used as

of noise ofEEAA not been reference • correction completed. Is that factor can addresses this effect due to the distance. accuracy of the • noise for this location recorded noise is only a reference but levels? our goals related to

residential areas under the influence of aircraft tracks (Nasr City, Sheraton Buildings, K 4.5, Mokattam , ....... )

Dr. Ali EI-3abd Egypt Air Criticized the Air There is no need for the emission work of a new modeling modeling and because it is not a new found it is not building, rather the enough. modernization and At Nasr City, the development of the pollution may be existing bUilding. affected, in 2012, The data obtained indicated based on these very clearly it is below the

deve lopments. limits set by Egyptian law.

Eng. Mohamed Businessmen Data, which was Assumed to be the worst Hasan Association Tenth fed by the noise case scenario if that

of Ramadan model, is occurs. expected any time

Ii

of day?

Draft Final report (3) fOr updating and modernizing TE2 13

Consultant Office

Name Job title Comments Reply Dr. Abd EI-Halem Hashem

Faculty of Engineering Cairo University

What about the incident when terminal TB2 was blackout for two hours and no working equipment due to power failure?

There is a standby generator at the airport, and they should work efficiently in 20 seconds to continue the work without interruption when the power supply shuts off.

Dr. Foad Khalaf Professor, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University

What are alternative solutions in case of power failure or breakdowns in the central air conditioning units?

Attendance rates of different sectors


Consultant Office

Rates and categories of attendance in

the 1st Public meeting

2% 5% 2% 7%

17% 37%

16%

IiJAirlines

• Airport staff

o Universities and research centers

o Ministry of Environment

• Egyptian Company for Airports

I] World Bank

• Environmental management at the airport

o Business associations

• Ministry of Aviation

• ConsuHants


---------

Consultant Office

Rates and categories of attendance in the 1st Public meeting

r-...~~---+ 35

~~~c-+30

25

20 ~

5

'" c ~ '5 '" <:

8

.... c o Q)

~E - <:.!!! e ~ .~

w

o

Percentage of attendance in the 1 5t public meeting according to Gender

IIJiIMale 47%

I. Female! , , 53%


Consultant Office

A small questionnaire for the nleeting 19 response with the following summary

Question yes No 1 What do you think of the level of service in the existing building #2 for

the passenger? And Do I need to improve? 19 0

2 Are you satisfied with the public utilities and infrastructure of Building #2 for passengers?

4 15

3 Is exposure to noise levels acceptable or unacceptable for passengers while you're at the airport, specifically in Building #2?

12 7

4 Are you satisfied with the quality of air infrastructure at the airport? 8 11 5 Do you think that this project will affect the movement of money and

business in the region? 15 4

6 Are you satisfied with the current road network around the new airport?

13 6

7 Do you know about the new road linking the airport Ring Road? 13 6

Draa Final report (3) for updating and modernizing TB2 17

World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/...16 Alaa HAmed Abd Expert operation and...

Documents

Transcript of World Bank Documentdocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/...16 Alaa HAmed Abd Expert operation and...