Workshop Report -...

Workshop Report

4-Day Project Planning Workshop with

National and State Partners from Tamil Nadu

“Land Use Planning and Management”

Date: 25-28 October, 2016

Venue: Auroville, Pondicherry, India

Project Planning Workshop for Pilot State Tamil Nadu – Land Use Planning and Management

2 | P a g e

Prepared by:

Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH Registered offices at Bonn and Eschborn, Germany

B-5/2 Safdarjung Enclave New Delhi 110029 T: +91 11 49495353 F: +91 11 49495391 W: www.giz.de/india Responsible:

Mr. Georg Jahnsen, Director Land Use Planning and Management Project Sustainable Urban and Industrial Development Authors:

Ms. Tanaya Saha, Mr. Shriman Narayan from Land Use Planning and Management, Sustainable Urban and Industrial Development Photo credits:

Cover Photo: Getty Images bought by GIZ Workshop photos: GIZ/ Land Use Planning and Management Team and Auroville Consulting New Delhi, November 2016

http://www.giz.de/india


3 | P a g e

Table of Contents

Background ......................................................................................................................... 7

Introduction to the Planning Workshop ............................................................................ 7

Programme of the Workshop ............................................................................................. 8

Participation in the Workshop ........................................................................................... 8

Day - 1: Setting the Context ............................................................................................... 8

Day - 2: Project Management ........................................................................................... 10

Day - 3: Human Capacity Development Strategy ............................................................ 15

Day - 4: Briefing Session .................................................................................................. 16


4 | P a g e


5 | P a g e

List of Abbreviations

1. AAI 2. CAG 3. CII 4. DoLR 5. DCZMA 6. FICCI 7. GIZ 8. HRCE 9. MoRD 10. NGO 11. PWD 12. RD 13. SHG 14. SIPCOT 15. TANGEDCO 16. TICC 17. TNSCB 18. TNSCZMA 19. TNSEIAA 20. TNSDA 21. TWAD

Airports Authority of India Comptroller and Auditor General Confederation of Indian Industries Deparment of Land Resources District Coastal Zone Management Authority Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry Deutsche Gesselschaft fur Internationale Zussameinarbeit Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Ministry of Rural Development Non Governmental Organisation Public Works Department Rual Development Self Help Group State Industrial Promotion Corporation of Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation The International Cargo Carriers Tamil Nadu SLUM Clearance Board Tamil Nadu State Environmental Impact Asessment Authority Tamil Nadu State Department of Archaeology Tamil Nadu State Coastal Zone Management Authority Tamil Nadu Water Supply and Drainage


6 | P a g e


7 | P a g e

Background

The Department of Land Resources in the Ministry of Rural Development (DoLR, MoRD) and The Deutsche Gesellschaft fur Internationale Zussameinarbeit are jointly implementing the “Land Use Planning and Management” project in the framework of the Indo-German Technical Cooperation with an objective to apply instruments of integrated spatial and land use planning in Indian states. ‘Land’ is a “State subject”, as stated in The Constitution of India. Thus the project mainly focuses on outputs that caters to state, and envisions to provide platform for facilitation of the state works at national level for matters that are important to link to national level. GIZ jointly with national partner DoLR, MoRD have selected two pilot states Odisha and Tamil Nadu through a selection procedure. For planning of project in each pilot state GIZ had organised a kick off project planning workshop with the State of Tamil Nadu and national partner DoLR, MoRD in Auroville, Pondicherry during 25th October to 28th October, 2016.

Introduction to the Planning Workshop


8 | P a g e

The objective of this workshop was to assess the existing Land Use Planning and Management System in the State of Tamil Nadu and also understand the national interventions in the current land use planning practices and evolve and finalize project plan, processes, expected results and the Human Capacity

Development (HCD) requirements for applying instruments of integrated spatial and land use planning.

Programme of the Workshop

Day 1: Setting the Context; land use planning practices at state, national and international level. Day 2: Identification of tentative demonstration areas, key processes and results of project Day 3: Identification of key work packages and broad Plan of Operations/Work Plan Day 4: Presentation of Workshop outcomes before Secretary, Housing and Urban Development, Tamil Nadu The Detail Agenda is given at Annexure I.

Participation in the Workshop The workshop was participated by officials from national Partner institution DoLR, MoRD, GoI; and from Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority, State Planning Commission within State Planning Department, and Department of Town and Country Planning in Tamil Nadu, national spatial planning expert, GIZ experts. Participants list is given at Annexure II

Day - 1: Setting the Context The participants were welcome by Mr. Georg Jahnsen, Director, Land Use Planning and Management Project, Sustainable Urban and Industrial Development, GIZ. He briefed the agenda for the 4 day workshop. This was followed by a round of self-introduction by the participants. The moderator, Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi, Sr. Advisor, Quality Assurance Cell, GIZ, further set the context for sharing of current practices in land use planning which was covered in the following technical presentations. Technical presentations are attached in Annexure IV

“Land and Land Use” , by Mr. Sugato Dutt, State Planning Commission, Tamil Nadu

“Land Use Planning Process”, by Mr. M. Sekaran, Additional Director, Directorate of Town and Country Planning, Tamil Nadu.

“Land Use Planning Interventions at National Level” , by Dr. S.K. Kulshreshtha, Independent Spatial Planning Expert, India.

“Integrated Spatial and Land Use Planning and Management – Concepts and International Examples”, By Ms Elke Matthaei, Advisor, Rural Development, GIZ, Germany.

Pic: Mr. Sugato Dutt making presentation

Pic: Mr. M. Sekaran making presentation


9 | P a g e

Mr. Sugato Dutt from State Planning Commission, presented broadly the geo-physical and human landscape of Tamil Nadu and the State Development Vision. He highlighted issues of drastic change in land use from agriculture to non-agricultural use, reducing water resource in the state. He also demonstrated the spatial planning challenges vis-s-vis the accelerated, innovative and inclusive growth targeted in the Development vision of the State. His presentation aptly captured the essence of current trends in planning, development targets, baseline statistics and realities and shifts in land use. He also presented the 2 diverse cases of Kanchipuram and Tirunelveli, where the former has a market driven rapid transition of land use from agriculture to non-agriculture and the latter has stagnated land markets with large land owners. Mr. M. Sekaran from the Directorate of Town and Country Planning presented the process involved in plan preparation. He demonstrated the Plan hierarchy and defined the various types of Plans in the hierarchy. He also elaborated the process of Master Plan preparation including matters of constitution of Authority for Master Plan, the contents of a Master Plan, the process of consent on Master Plan, process after consent, and approval process. He also touched upon the currently used modern techniques of preparation of Master Plan and Regional Plan. Dr. S.K. Kulshreshtha, presented the intervention of national government in land use planning process. He highlighted the provisions in the Constitution of India stating the powers of State and Union in the 7th schedule

and the provisions of the 74th Constitutional Amendment validating the role of central government in making policies, programmes, guidelines and model acts. He also featured the current programmes, laws, policies, notifications and guidelines of different Union Ministries that impact the land use planning. Ms Elke Matthaei, Advisor, Rural Development and Infrastructure, GIZ, Germany, presented international cases on land conflicts as a result of incompatible uses, current trend in the land sector, environmental impacts due to improper land use planning and requirement of good land governance. She emphasised the need for new understanding of the complexity of land matters. She focussed on the underlying urban prosperity brought about in different continents in the world by efficient urban planning and management. She also referred to The New Urban Agenda and Land Use Planning of Habitat III and highlighted that readdressing the way cities and human settlements are planned can make a contribution to sustainable development, improve human health and well-being, as well as foster resilience and protect the environment. The principles of spatial planning involving various institutional coordination and stakeholders was explained and examples from Germany was cited where several land use planning conflicts in various processes were solved by the land use planning instruments and tools. The session closed with group discussion on specific issues in the state that should be focussed in the project. The day concluded with Auroville site excursion.

Pic: Dr Kulshreshtha

Pic: Ms Elke Matthaei making presentation


10 | P a g e

Day - 2: Project Management The participants were welcome by Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi and he summarised points from presentations and discussions in Day 1. The session further moved to explanation of the project offer on “Land Use Planning and Management” by Mr. Georg Jahnsen.

The four project outputs discussed are as stated below:

Output A: Land use policies (guidelines and principles). The states developed guidelines and principles of integrated spatial and land use planning that include aspects of sustainable development, the protection of ecosystem services and resource-efficient land use.

Output B: Planning Instruments: Technical and methodological as well as administrative and procedural planning instruments that are in line with the implementation of the guidelines and principles of integrated spatial and land use planning, are tested.

Output C: Human Capacity Development (HCD) Education and training programmes (different forms of learnings) for integrated spatial and land use planning that focus on sustainability management, regional planning, environmental planning, resource management and procedures for participation are acknowledged. Output D: Organisational and institutional development Concepts of integrated spatial planning and land use planning institutes pertaining to strengthening professionalism, enhancing advisory and enforcement capacities as well as to political/social awareness generation are discussed in the public (expert meets). The project planning measures were further discussed with the participants from the State. This was followed by a group work (2 groups) on the following topics: Feasible and non-feasible reasons affecting the success of the projects. The list of reasons for which Integrated Land Use Planning and Management will be successful are as mentioned below:

Political will exist for replicating unified agencies

State Vision document 2023 summarises overall state development vision

Willingness to avoid conflict among users

Willingness to protect environment and eco sensitive zones

Inevitable allocation of resources

Importance given to issues of water scarcity

Chief Minister’s dream about improvement of villages. It is reflected integration of cities with rural areas in master plans

Pic: Discussion on Project Outputs

The Presentation focussed on the deliberation of the Project outputs and indicators/ success factors to measure the achievement of each output. The core, steering and support processes to arrive at four outputs of the project were also discussed, followed by discussion on expected Results/ Results model.


11 | P a g e

Availability of villages and urban centres

Long protected coastal line

Availability of financing and sharing of revenue

Availability of composite local planning areas (LPAs)

Availability of legislation

Availability of experienced institutions like CMDA, MUDO, TNUDP, FAP, SCP.

Advent of IT solutions, GIS based plans

SMP Monitoring committee

The list of reasons for which Integrated Land Use Planning and Management will not be feasible are as mentioned below:

Multiple agencies and lack of cooperation

Conflicting priorities

Political interests

Lack of trained man power

Lack of comprehensive database

The next group exercise was conducted to work on “Criteria for Pilot Area Selection” and “Potential Demonstration Areas for Integrated Spatial and Land Use Planning”. The participants from the different state departments of Tamil Nadu was divided into two different groups for working on the above mentioned topics. The outcomes of the two group works are as shown below:

Pic: Demonstration on criteria for pilot selection and potential pilot area

The criteria for selection of the pilot areas has been listed as mentioned below:

1. Area of national strategic importance 2. Political acceptance/ less sensitive areas 3. Priority of State to promote certain local potential 4. Demographic trends, urbanisation levels, literacy levels

Pic: Group work on ‘Project Non feasibility’ reasons

Pic: Group work on ‘Project Feasibility’reasons


12 | P a g e

5. Proportion of urban and rural mix 6. Environmentally sensitive areas 7. Areas of economic importance 8. Dovetailing with state schemes 9. Availability of natural resources (water etc.) 10. Spatial expanse/ size of pilot case 11. Areas where underprivileged groups will be considered 12. Involvement of multiple sectors 13. Moderately well connected 14. Topographical importance

Areas selected for tentative demonstration of integrated spatial and land use planning is

1. Madurai-Thoothukudi Industrial Corridor (MTIC) 2. Erode-Salem-Namakkal region 3. Chennai Metropolitan region 4. Coimbatore Thirupur Nilgiris region

Reasons for tentative selection of the above mentioned demonstration areas are as mentioned below: MTIC/ MTIC Region: MTIC is a priority with respect to the Tamil Nadu State vision 2023 as well as for the Central Government. It is an upcoming industrial corridor proposal which will have spill over effects and will have lot of potential to integrate ecological, and economic activities, ancillary activities and land uses and support infrastructure. It has the potential of planning a region with integrative spatial planning approach Chennai Metropolitan region: The urban development of Chennai Metropolitan area has a spill over effect on the surrounding districts and hence this region with a cluster of districts was also suggested as one of the demonstration areas. Statutory plan viz., Master plan (Land use plan) is available for the Chennai metropolitan area (CMA) comprising of entire Chennai district, part of Kanchipuram and part of Tiruvallur. No statutory plan available for the remaining part of Kanchipuram and Tiruvallur. There was a preference to develop a Regional plan for the entire area of 3 districts like NCR of Delhi in the first priority, since rapid development witnessed in the peri-urban area just outside CMA boundary is not regulated properly and even within the CMA boundary, inadequacy of provisions in the present Master Plan of CMA is also felt need to be addressed in the proposed Regional Plan. If this regional area is chosen, then Master Plan (Statutory Plan) may also be prepared for the local planning area inset of the Regional area which may be either the entire taluk of Chengalpattu or entire taluk of Tiruvallur. Coimbatore-Tirupur-Nilgiris region: A lot if industries in Tirupur, Coimbatore has growing urbanisation, and Nilgiris includes the Ghat regions. However, it was pointed out that the Ghat section also included the Eco sensitive zone. Erode-Salem-Namakkal region: This is a region which has future growth potential and this is a region for which Master Plan proposal is sanctioned. Since, this corridor development is the prime focus of the State involving plans prepared by other related departments as well.

Pic: Stakeholder map and relationship for Regional Plan pilot case Pic: Stakeholder map and relationship for Master Plan pilot case


13 | P a g e

The next session focussed on presenting the Results model (network of results leading to project objective) prepared by the GIZ project team and discussing it further with the participants followed by group discussion on creating stakeholders map for preparation of 2 pilot studies, one on regional plan and the other on master plan. Mr. Shailendra explained to the participants, the GIZ tool of stakeholders map and stakeholder relationship, and instructed to list all the possible stakeholders in 3 categories namely; government/ public, private, civil society. He also mentioned, the stakeholders which are most important should be placed closest to the bottom corner of the segment drawn on board. The outcome of the two group works have been captured in the photographs presented below. The stakeholder map has been documented in the figure in Annexure III. The group work on mapping the stakeholders was followed by presentation from German expert on Human Capacity Development principles.

The demonstration on Capacity Development Strategy for individuals, organisation and society, was followed by a group work on the following 2 topics. Participants in the Group 1 on Policy (guidelines and principles)

Mr. M. Sekaran

Dr. Sugato Dutt

Participants in Group 2 on Planning Instruments

Mr. Shivashanmugam

Mr. Abhishek Agarwal

Mr. Shriman Narayan

Pic: GIZ Tool explaining relationship between Stakeholders

Pic: GIZ Tool explaining the format of Stakeholder Map

Pic: Presentation on Concepts of Human Capacity Development


14 | P a g e

Ms. Tanaya Saha

Mr. Georg Jahnsen

Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi

Ms. Elke Matthaei

Ms. Saroj Jaisia

Dr. S.K. Kulshresstha

Mr. Adwitya Patro

Details of the discussion is briefed in the table below.

Pic: Capacity development requirements for achieving outputs on policy and planning instruments

Which Capacities

For Whom

For what Individual Organisation Society Policies (guidelines and principles) : Output A

Assistant Directors, DTCP on content drafting

Capacity for collection, linking, analysis, monitoring in TNGIS

Capacity of facilitation, moderation and coordination (DTCP, SPD)

Orientation to Secretary H& UD, Head of division (Land Use, Assistant Director DTCP

Baseline assessment and data collection learning to supervisor, Planning assistant

Technical, methodological as well as administrative and procedural instruments in line

Deputy Director and assistant directors on technical methods training

- Classification, standards, zoning, new concepts

Training on computer related softwares, analysis and presentation to LPA, DTCP


15 | P a g e

Day - 3: Human Capacity Development The participants were welcome by Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi and he briefed the summary from presentations and group works in Day 2. The day started with discussion on capacity development requirements on Output C and Output D.

Key Participants of Group on Output C

Mr. Sugato Dutt

Dr. S.K.Kulshreshtha

Mr. Abhishek Agarwal

Key Participants of Group on Output D

Mr. M. Sekaran

Mr. V. Kuman

Mr. Shriman Narayan

Ms. Tanaya Saha

with implementation of policies(guidelines : Output B

Training to draftsman (AutoCAD, GIS)

Communication specialist on procedures

Improved procedure for involving private sector participation, training on public communication

Learnings for improved expertise in special areas (environmental, hydrogeologics, disaster management

Anna University IIT (M) Private education institutes

Technology application in mapping and consultation process

Watershed Management, Environmental NGOs, Social NGOs

Expertise of development indicators

Working with professional bodies

Conflict management techno-legal expertise

.

Pic: Human Capacity Development Requirements for output D

Pic: Human Capacity Development for output C


16 | P a g e

He participated in HCD on day 3 and gave important inputs on setting up an IT cell to ensure the capacities are stored in-house and can be used to train any future employees. The Human capacity requirement for output C and output D was discussed with inputs from Director DTCP. The details of discussion are briefed in the table below.

Which capacities? For whom?

For what? Individual Organisation Society

Education and training programme for integrated spatial and land use planning that focus on sustainability management, regional planning, resource management and procedures for participation are acknowledged : Output C

ToT for sustainability management, regional planning, environmental planning

Training cell within state land use board ( for training needs of all department concerned)

Anna University (SAP)

Addl, Joint, Deputy, Assistant Directors

Synchronising planning with development rules

School of Planning Vijaywada

New technology instruments

IRS Anna University

Capacity building policy (DTCP)

State Planninh Commission

Vision, mission, duty chart

Concepts of Integrated land use planning institutes pertaining to strengthening professionalism, enhancing advisory and enforcement of capacities as well as political social awareness generation are discussed in public (expert meets) : Output D

Training on formulation of Plan proposal draft enforcement to Assistant directors

DTCP orientation on mandate, institutional structure, Policy advisory (Commissioner, Additional Director/ Joint Director)

Orientation to Commissioner Additional director DTCP or Joint Director DTCP for stakeholder negotiation and conflict resolution

Process analysis and drafting proposals for Planning Assistant and supervisor

IT Cell DTCP needs training on networking and datacollection and repository making (IT head)

Sensitisation of target groups (public and political

Data collection and processing trainings to draftsman and surveyor

Admin and learning for coordination

The group exercise was followed by a broad Action Plan where the following responsibilities were discussed

Pic: Discussion with Director DTCP Pic: Formulation of work packages


17 | P a g e

Action Responsibility Due date

Documentation of workshop GIZ 15TH November

Draft Work Plan GIZ 15TH November

Common understanding of Land Use Planning process in Tamil Nadu (Flowchart)

DTCP 5TH November

It was discussed that all the documentation will be complete by 30th November.

Day - 4: Briefing Session On the 4th day, the tentative selection of pilot areas in Tamil Nadu along with its selection criteria, the Human Capacity development requirements and the work packages was summarised and presented before Secretary, Housing and Urban Development, Tamil Nadu. Discussion on selection of demonstration area was put up before Secretary, Housing and Urban Development to select 2 areas for demonstration of integrated spatial and land use planning examples at 2 scales regional/ district plans and master plans following group works conducted in the prior days of the workshop. He added his preference for Chennai Metropolitan region as the first order followed by Madurai Thoothukudi Corridor region as the second. He expressed that the selection of region may be guided by factor of medium complicacy keeping in mind the timeline of the project and at the same time should address certain level of complicated issues to demonstrate a good practice and replicable example.

Pic: Briefing of Work Packages to Secretary, Housing and Urban Development

The session was closed with a vote of thanks to the participants by Mr. Georg Jahnsen, Director, Land Use Planning and Management Project, GIZ, India.

^^^


18 | P a g e


19 | P a g e

Annexure I: Programme Schedule


20 | P a g e

Planning Workshop “Integrated Land Use Planning and Management”

25th to 28th October, 2016 . SAIIER, Auroville, Pondicherry.

AGENDA

24th October, 2016: Arrival

16:00 hrs Airport transfers (bus arranged) from Chennai Airport to Auroville

20:00 hrs Check in / Auroville

20:30 onwards Dinner

25th October, 2016: Day 1 Setting the Context

9:30 – 9:45hrs

“Welcome Address” by Mr. Georg Jahnsen, Director, Land Use Planning and

Management, GIZ, Indo German Environment Partnership Programme for Urban and Industrial Development.

Moderation by Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi, Sr. Advisor, QAC, GIZ, IGEP-UID

9:45 – 10.15 hrs Self-Introduction of Participants

Starting 10:15 hrs

Morning with tea break

Talks and/or Presentations on Current Practices of Land Use Planning on State / National Level.

Tamil Nadu, Odisha, National Level Presentation on “An insight into Current Practices of Land Use Planning at National

Level in India”, Dr S.K. Kulshrestha, Senior Planning Expert, Sr. Consultant, GIZ

13:00 – 14:30 hrs: Lunch Break

14:30

Afternoon with tea break

Presentation on “Approaches on Land Use Planning” – by Georg Jahnsen, Director,

LUPM, GIZ, IGEP-UID. Presentation on “Land Use Planning in International Context” – by Mrs. Elke Matthaei,

GIZ Germany Division Climate Change, Rural Development and Infrastructure

16:15 – 17:30 hrs Site excursion

19:30 – onwards Dinner

26th October, 2016: Day 2: Project Management

Start: 9:30 hrs

morning with tea break

Welcome Address & Summary Day 1 by Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi and Georg Jahnsen Introduction to “Project on Integrated Land Use Planning and Management: Boundary

and Focus” - GIZ Land Use Planning Team.

Developing feasible and not feasible reasoning for an Integrated Land Use Planning exercise in State

Identifying Criteria for Demonstration cases (2 nos.) in State – Group work Identifying Pilot cases/ demonstration cases – Group work Presentation on Process Mapping by Georg Jahnsen and discussion with Partners

13:00 – 14:30hrs: Lunch

Start: 14:30 hrs afternoon with tea

break

Intended Results and Outcomes of the Project – Presentation by Georg Jahnsen and

moderated discussion Stakeholder Mapping – Group Work Introduction to Human Capacity Development principles- Adelheid Uhlmann

19:30 hrs – onwards: Dinner

27th October, 2016: Day 3: Capacity Development

Starting: 9:30


Welcome Address & Summary Day 2 by Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi and Georg Jahnsen

Identifying key work packages and activities

Discussion on Clarity on roles and responsibilities

Presentation for Senior Bureaucrats prepared

13:00 – 14:30 hrs: Lunch

afternoon Excursion and Presentation on Auroville.

19:30 – onwards : Dinner

28th October, 2016: Day 4: Concluding Session with Senior Bureaucrats

Starting: 8:30 hrs


Welcome Address by Georg Jahnsen

Final Presentation for SB Moderated Panel Discussion with SB Concluding session Vote of thanks by Georg Jahnsen, Director, LUPM, GIZ-IGEP-UID.

13:00- 14:00 hrs : Lunch

1400 hrs Departure from Auroville


21 | P a g e

Annex II:

List of Registered Participants


22 | P a g e

S.No Name (Mr./Ms/Mrs) Organisation Designation E-mail

1 Sugato Dutt Land Use Division, State

Planning Commission, Tamil Nadu

Head of the

Department

[email protected]

2 Mr. M. Sekaran Directorate of Town and Country Planning, Tamil Nadu

Additional Director

[email protected]

3 Ms. Saroj Jaisia Department of Land Resources, Ministry of Rural Development, Government of India

Assistant Director

[email protected]

4 Mr. V. Kumar Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority

Assistant Planner

[email protected]

5 Ms. Elke Matthaei GIZ, Germany Advisor [email protected]

6 Mr. Abhishek Agarwal

LUPM, GIZ, India Technical Expert [email protected]

7 Mr. Shriman Narayan

LUPM, GIZ, India Technical Expert [email protected]

8 Dr. S.K. Kulshresstha

Self Employed Spatial Planning Expert

[email protected]

9 Mr. Shivashanmugam

Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority

Chief Planner, Regional Plans

[email protected]

10 Ms. Adelheid Uhlman

GIZ, Germany Sr. Technical Advisor

[email protected]

11 Mr. Adwitya Patro ICPP, GIZ, India Jr. Technical Expert

[email protected]

12 Ms. Tanaya Saha LUPM, GIZ, India Project Advisor [email protected]

13 Mr. Shailendra Dwivedi

QAC, GIZ, India Sr. Advisor [email protected]

14 Mr. Georg Jahnsen LUPM, GIZ, India Director [email protected]

15 Ms. Sudha Keshari Department of Land Resources, Ministry of Rural Development, Government of India

Economic Advisor

[email protected]

16 Mr. P. Selvadurai Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority

Chief Planner, Master Plans

[email protected]

17 Mr. Shambhu Kallolikar

Directorate of Town and Country Planning, Tamil Nadu

Director [email protected]

18 Mr. Dharmandra Pratap Yadav

Housing and Urban Development, Tamil Nadu

Secretary [email protected]

mailto:[email protected]















Annex III:

Presentations


1 | P a g e

Figure: Stakeholder Map for demonstration of Regional/ District Plan


2 | P a g e

Figure: Stakeholder Map for demonstration of Master Plan


3 | P a g e

Annex IV:

Presentations


4 | P a g e

Workshop Report -...

Documents

Transcript of Workshop Report -...