WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs....

29
WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital Mutilation United Nations Human Rights Council June 27, 2012 Geneva, Switzerland WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORK WUNRN®

Transcript of WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs....

Page 1: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN 

Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality

FGM - Female Genital Mutilation

United Nations Human Rights CouncilJune 27, 2012

Geneva, Switzerland

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

Page 2: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.
Page 3: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

SUDAN VICTIM CALLS FOR A FUTURE WITHOUT FGM

By Halima Mohamed Abdel Rahman As a young girl, Sudanese Voices of Our Future correspondent Halima Mohamed Abdel Rahman was circumcised at the hands of the elder women of her community. Now an advocate for the practice's abolition, she shares her own story and calls out for reform.

Page 4: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

UN CEDAW COMMITTEE GENERAL RECOMMENDATION NO. 14 FEMALE CIRCUMCISION - FGM - FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION

UN CEDAW COMMITTEEGeneral Recommendation No. 14 (ninth session, 1990)

Female Circumcision

The Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women,

Concerned about the continuation of the practice of female circumcision and other traditional practices harmful to the health of women,

Noting with satisfaction that Governments, where such practices exist, national women's organizations, non-governmental organizations, and bodies of the United Nations system, such as the World Health Organization and the United Nations Children's Fund, as well as the Commission on Human Rights and its Sub- Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities, remain seized of the issue having particularly recognized that such traditional practices as female circumcision have serious health and other consequences for women and children,

Taking note with interest the study of the Special Rapporteur on Traditional Practices Affecting the Health of Women and Children,4 and of the study of the Special Working Group on Traditional Practices, 5

Page 5: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FGM - UGANDA - OVER 200 GIRLS TO BE CIRCUMCISED

A circumciser shows the razorblades, the instruments of the FGM ritual

By Frederick Womakuyu - 11-15-2010

Elders in Bukwo and Kapchorwa districts of Uganda are preparing to circumcise over 200 girls next month despite a new law banning the practice. The Uganda law calls for life imprisonment punishment for a person who commits aggravated FGM. But elders swear that the whole tribe would rather go to prison than abolish a custom they inherited from their ancestors. 

Page 6: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.
Page 7: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

INDONESIA - FGM A CUTTING TRADITION

Female circumcisers and their attendants waiting in an elementary-school classroom, where they do their work. When a girl is taken — usually by her mother — to a free circumcision event held each spring in Bandung, Indonesia, she is handed over to a small group of women who, swiftly and yet with apparent affection, cut off a small piece of her genitals.

Photo - Stephanie Sinclair, Story - Sara Corbett

Page 8: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

European Parliament Resolution of 24 March 2009 on Combating Female Genital Mutilation in the EU (2008/2071(INI))

The European Parliament,–   having regard to Articles 2, 3, and 5 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted in 1948,–   having regard to Articles 2, 3, and 26 of the 1966 UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights,–   having regard in particular to Article 5(a) of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), adopted in 1979,–   having regard to Article 2(1), Article19(1), Article 24(3), and Articles 34 and 39 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted on 20 November 1989 by the UN General Assembly,–   having regard to the 1989 UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment,–   having regard to the 1990 African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child,–   having regard to Article 1, Article 2(f), Article 5, Article 10(c), and Articles 12 and 16 of General Recommendation No 19 of the UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women, adopted in 1992,–   having regard to the Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action, adopted by the June 1993 World Conference on Human Rights,–   having regard to the December 1993 UN General Assembly Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women, the first international human rights instrument relating solely to violence against women,–   having regard to the Declaration and the Programme of Action of the UN International Conference on Population and Development, adopted in Cairo on 13 September 1994,–   having regard to the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action, adopted by the World Conference on Women on 15 September 1995,

Page 9: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

Page 10: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FORCED FGM - GIRL IN AGONY OF PAIN - SUSTAINED SUFFERING

Page 11: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE 8 YEARS OLD AND TOLD YOU WERE

GOING TO A BIRTHDAY PARTY. BUT, WHEN YOU GET THERE,

THE DOOR CLOSES, AND THERE IS NO PARTY. THE

NIGHTMARE OF FGM BEGINS, SO MUCH PAIN,

SO MANY TEARS.

Page 12: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

UNFPA - REPORT ON GLOBAL CONSULTATION ON FGM

This UNFPA FGM Report addresses the needs for closing gaps in law enforcement, building capacity, mobilizing resources, and building global partnerships.

Page 13: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

TOOLS FOR FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION

Typical tools for carrying out female genital mutilation

Non-sterile mutilation- Not performed in a hospital - No anesthetics

Page 14: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

EGYPT BANS FEMALE CIRCUMCISION AFTER GIRL'S FGM DEATH

BBC 6/28/07 - Egypt has announced that it is imposing a complete ban on female circumcision, also known as genital mutilation.  The announcement follows a public outcry after a young girl died during the operation.

A ban was introduced nearly 10 years ago but the practice continued to be allowed in exceptional circumstances.

A health ministry spokesman said no member of the medical profession would be allowed to perform the operation in public or private establishments.

Page 15: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE A RADIANT BRIDE? BUT, YOU

WERE CIRCUMCISED AS A LITTLE GIRL..

YOU MUST BE CUT OPEN FOR THE WEDDING NIGHT.

WILL THE FGM PAIN NEVER END?

THE WEDDING NIGHT AND SO MANY NIGHTS

AFTER, CAN BE FULL OF PAIN, EVEN CREATING INFECTIONS.

Page 16: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

TEARS OF A 9-MONTH OLD GIRL FOLLOWING HER CIRCUMCISION IN ASIA

Page 17: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FEMALE CIRCUMCISION COULD CAUSE INFERTILITY - SWEDISH STUDY IN SUDAN

Female circumcision, which is practiced in more than 30 countries and affects 2 million girls each year, could cause infertility.

Swedish researchers, who examined nearly 300 women in Sudan where the practice is widespread, said on Friday women who had undergone circumcision, or female genital mutilation (FGM), were five to six times more likely to be infertile.

"All sorts of female circumcision, not only the severe forms, probably cause an increased risk of infertility. This is a very important argument to be used in areas where this is practiced," Dr Lars Almroth, a pediatrician and researcher at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, said in an interview. An estimated 135 million women and girls have been circumcised, according to the human rights group Amnesty International.

The research, which is published in The Lancet medical journal, is the first clinical study to show it has the opposite effect. "We found that the more extensive form of genital mutilation, the higher the risk of primary infertility. The risk is very high -- 5 to 6 times higher -- than in the other group," Dr. Almroth said referring to women who had not been not circumcised. By Author - Patricia Reaney

Page 18: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE READY TO DELIVER YOUR FIRST

BABY. THE FGM HAS LEFT YOU TOO CLOSED.

YOU LIVE FAR FROM A HOSPITAL. THE BABY TRIES TO COME.

FINALLY, YOUR BABY GIRL DIES. YOUR INSIDES ARE TORN.

YOU NOW HAVE OBSTETRIC FISTULA. YOUR HUSBAND

DOESN’T WANT TO BE NEAR YOU ANY MORE.

YOU MOURN FOR YOUR LOST BABY.

Page 19: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

AFRICAN YOUNG GIRL IS HELD DOWN IN FORCED FGM

Practiced in Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Oman, Yemen, Sudan, Somalia, Djibouti, Mauritania, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Iran, and other countries, FGM is carried out with knives, scissors, scalpels, pieces of glass or razor blades. There is rarely anesthesia, or instrument sterilization.

Page 20: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FILMS CAN SHOW THE GRAPHIC DOCUMENTARY OF THETORTURE, PAIN, AGONY OF GIRLS DURING & AFTER FGM

http://irinnews.org/film/?id=4129

Razor's Edge - FGM Video

Page 21: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

ETHIOPIA - INITIATION DANCE OF GIRLS BEFORE FGM

These girls dance in the initiation ceremony that leads to their circumcision. If they refuse FGM, they will be discriminated against or ostracized from their community.

Credit: IRIN

Page 22: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

International Day of Zero Tolerance forFemale Genital Mutilation - February 6

Page 23: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

MANY BRITISH IMMIGRANT GIRLS UNDERGO GENITAL MUTILATIONARRANGED BY FAMILIES DURING SCHOOL HOLIDAYS - DESPITE LAWS

The Guardian - 25 July 2010

Female circumcision will be inflicted on up to 2,000 British

schoolgirls during the summer holidays – leaving brutal physical and

emotional scars. Yet there have been no prosecutions against the

practice.

Some 500 to 2,000 British schoolgirls will be genitally mutilated over

the summer holidays. Some will be taken abroad, others will be "cut"

or circumcised and sewn closed here in the UK by women already

living here or who are flown in and brought to "cutting parties" for a

few girls at a time in a cost-saving exercise.

Page 24: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FGM PRACTITIONERS SWAY ELECTIONS IN SIERRA LEONE

By Emily Bowers - WeNews correspondent

Fighting female genital mutilation is hard in Sierra Leone, where about 90 percent of women have been cut. The current election season has shown off the political clout of traditional practitioners.

What makes it particularly difficult to combat FGM in Sierra Leone is the political and social power of many of the women who perform it.

Page 25: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

OPERATION GIVES FGM VICTIMS HOPE ON RECONSTRUCTION

CNN - Young girls like this one in Niger are often forced into circumcision by their families. The health dangers involved in this procedure, also known as female genital mutilation (FGM), are increasingly well-known and have lead to international efforts to ban the practice.

But a new treatment pioneered by a French doctor, Pierre Foldes, offers hope for victims of this practice. Dr. Foldes began working with victims of female circumcision almost 30 years ago while volunteering in Burkina Faso.

Page 26: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION/CUTTING - DATA & TRENDS

Page 27: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION-RITE OF TORTURE FOR GIRLS

By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF - NY Times - May 11, 2011

HARGEISA, Somaliland - People usually torture those whom they fear or despise. But one of the most common forms of torture in the modern world, incomparably more widespread than waterboarding or electric shocks, is inflicted by mothers on daughters they love.

It’s female genital mutilation — sometimes called female circumcision — and it is prevalent across a broad swath of Africa and chunks of Asia as well. Mothers take their daughters at about age 10 to cutters like Maryan Hirsi Ibrahim, a middle-aged Somali woman who says she wields her razor blade on up to a dozen girls a day.

“This tradition is for keeping our girls chaste, for lowering the sex drive of our daughters,” Ms. Ibrahim told me. “This is our culture.”

Ms. Ibrahim prefers the most extreme form of genital mutilation, called infibulation or Pharaonic circumcision. And let’s not be dainty or euphemistic. This is a grotesque human rights abuse that doesn’t get much attention because it involves private parts and is awkward to talk about. So pardon the bluntness about what infibulation entails.

The girls’ genitals are carved out, including the clitoris and labia, often with no anesthetic. What’s left of the flesh is sewn together with three to six stitches — wild thorns in rural areas, or needle and thread in the cities. The cutter leaves a tiny opening to permit urination and menstruation. Then the girls’ legs are tied together, and she is kept immobile for 10 days until the flesh fuses together.

Page 28: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

A GIRL CRIES IN TERROR AS SHE IS CIRCUMCISED IN SOUTH ASIA

Page 29: WOMEN'S UN REPORT NETWORK - WUNRN Harmful Traditional Practices Against Women & Girls Panel Laws vs. Practice: Rhetoric vs. Reality FGM - Female Genital.

WOMEN’S UN REPORT NETWORKWUNRN®

Birth of a baby must be a blessing event

But mine was nothing short of a curse

Daddy's face didn't shine. Drums didn't make noise

No shots were fired. No ceremony was held

The new born was me. I am a girl

In my culture, gender counts most.

A girl is not as welcome as a baby boy

Raising camel in the rangeland

is family's highest priority

They believe a girl has no hands for that

Harsh combat against the enemies

is family's highest priority

They believe a girl has no heart for that

Reconciliation in the aftermath of a clash

is family's highest priority

FGM POEM FROM SOMALIA  By Abdi-Noor H. Mohamed

They believe a girl has no head for that

At five I had to face the worst

A knife cut across my genitals

A midwife circumcised me

Stitched me. Infibulated me

Where I used to have a clit

I have a black scar now

Why inflict me with this pain?

This real Pain of primitive cultures

In tears I am, at every stage of my life

Mom and Dad, I'm I not a daughter?

Dear Brother, I'm I not a sister?

Dear mankind, wherever you are

I'm I not a human being?

Tears, Tears, Tears