Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer...

19
Chris Bloomingdale, Richard Proost, Mike Ballweg, & Mark Renz University of Wisconsin-Madison Management of Volunteer Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa

Transcript of Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer...

Page 1: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Chris Bloomingdale, Richard Proost, Mike Ballweg, & Mark Renz University of Wisconsin-Madison

Management of Volunteer Winter Wheat in Summer

Seeded Alfalfa

Page 2: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

• Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI • Most common after wheat harvest

• Weed control is typically not recommended with late summer seedings • Volunteer wheat can be problematic in no-till systems

• Winter wheat can reduce alfalfa establishment and yield

• Effective herbicides exist, but limited info on glyphosate (Roundup Ready alfalfa)

Background

Page 3: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

• Compare common products used for winter wheat control to glyphosate and determine the:

1. Efficacy

2. Stand establishment

3. Spring yield

4. Milk yield per ton of forage

Objectives

Page 4: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Materials & Methods

• Established sites in summer 2015

• Seeded alfalfa in fields August

• Replicated across 3 locations

• 4 treatments at 2 different timings

• Data collected: • Fall control rating (28 DAT)

• Spring stand counts

• First cut yield

Page 5: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Methods: Treatments

Timing Alfalfa Stage/Ht. Wheat Height

Early 2-3 TL 10-15cm

Late

10-17cm 15-30cm

Treatment Rate

Control -

Glyphosate 0.86 kg ae ha-1

AMS 0.02 kg/L

Sethoxydim 0.31 kg ae ha-1

AMS 0.02 kg/L

COC 1.7% v/v

Imazamox 0.03 kg ae ha-1

AMS 0.02 kg/L

MSO 1% v/v

Page 6: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

• Randomized complete block design at all locations • 4 blocks at Lancaster & Sheboygan

• 3 blocks at Arlington

• ANOVA via SAS Proc Mixed • Factors were herbicide, timing and herbicide*timing

• Site and block were random variables

• Data transformed if needed • 28 DAT control data arcsine-square root transformed

• Mean separation using Fisher’s LSD (α=0.05)

Materials & Methods: Stats

Page 7: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Results: Fall Control Rating (28 DAT)

P<0.001 P=0.025

Page 8: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Glyphosate

Page 9: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Sethoxydim

Page 10: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Imazamox

Page 11: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Results: Stand Establishment

P<0.001 P<0.001

Page 12: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is
Page 13: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Results: First Cut Yield

P<0.001 P=0.002

Page 14: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Results: First Cut Alfalfa Yield

P<0.001 P=0.001

Page 15: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Results: First Cut Wheat Yield

P<0.001

Page 16: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

• 28 DAT glyphosate provided the best wheat control • Early timing gave minimal improvements in control

• Glyphosate & sethoxydim exceeded 600 stems/m2 threshold • Late applications had 25% reduction in stand densities

• Total yield greatest in non-treated and imazamox • Imazamox 53% wheat

• Non-treated 84% wheat

• Glyphosate and sethoxydim total yield up to 30% lower • 5-16% wheat

Conclusions

Page 17: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

• Volunteer wheat has value as a forage • Dependent on growth stage

• Potential to improve/reduce milk production

• Alfalfa establishment is critical for long term success of stand • Minimize stand loss

• Developing models • Alfalfa stand density vs wheat

• Milk production vs wheat

Developing Decision Support Tools

Page 18: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Results: Stand Density Model St

and

Den

sity

(St

ems/

m2 )

Percent Wheat Biomass

y = -693x + 880 R²adj = 0.5183; P<0.001

Page 19: Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa · Winter Wheat in Summer Seeded Alfalfa •Late summer seeding alfalfa is common in WI •Most common after wheat harvest •Weed control is

Questions?