11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open...

30
Unsolicited Bulk Email UBE Unsolicited Commercial Email UCE spam spamming spammer Postfix 11.1 ... ... ... 139

Transcript of 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open...

Page 1: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Unsolicited Bulk Email UBE

Unsolicited Commercial Email UCE spam

spamming

spammer

Postfix

11.1

...

...

...

139

Page 2: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Internet

relay server

scatter-shot

DNS MX

11.2Internet

Denial-of-Service attack

reject

open relay

open relay

140

Page 3: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

11.3 Open RelayInternet

Open Relay Open Relay

SMTP Sendmail 8

Open Relay

Open Relay

SMTP Postfix

Open Relay

Open

Relay

Postfix

11.4Open Relay

f a l s e - p o s i t i v e

identification

141

Page 4: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

whitelist

11.4.1SMTP SMTP

IP

Open Relay

Internet

Open Relay Open Relay

IP

IP

DNS-based

Internet

DNS-based DNS-based B lack l i s t s

DNSBL Realtime Blacklists RBL

Open Relay DNS

MTA server MTA

server

Open Relay

DoS

DNSBL

142

Page 5: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

RBL DNS

IP RBL PTR MTA

RBL IP

RBL nospam.example . com

192.168.254.31 NoSpam

DNS PTR 31.254.168.192.nospam.example.com

192.168.254.31 Post f ix Pos t f ix IP

nospam.example.com PTR IP

Postfix

DNSBL

Open Relay

DNSBL

11.4.2

Our Rates Have Never Been Lower!!

lowest mortgage rate

11.4.3

143

Page 6: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

viagra HTML

viagra vi<!--oxo-->agra

HTML

v1agra vi@gra

...

11.5

1. SMTP

2.

IMAP POP

3.

MUA MDA

Postfix Postfix

Spamassassin

144

Page 7: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

MTA

MDA MUA

MTA MDA MUA

Pos t f i x

Postfix

Postfix

11.6 Postfix Postfix UBE

UBE Postfix

Postfix

restriction OK

REJECT

IP

DUNNO

Postfix SMTP

Postf ix

regular express ion

Postfix

Postfix

Postfix

145

Page 8: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

11.7

smtpd_client_restrictions

smtpd_helo_restrictions

smtpd_sender_restrictions

smtpd_recipient_restrictions

smtpd_data_restrictions

SMTP

Postfix

11-1 SMTP header_checks

body_checks 11.9

SMTP

11.7.1 SMTP 11-1 SMTP 11-1

SMTP client socket Postfix

socket Postfix IP 11-1

IP Postfix smtpd_client_restrictions

IP

146

Page 9: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

11-1 SMTP

1. post x/smtpd[866062]: connect from mail.ora.com[10.143.23.45]2. post x/smtpd[866062]: D694B20DD5B: client=[10.143.23.45]3. post x/cleanup[864868]: D694B20DD5B: \

message-id=<[email protected]>4. post x/qmgr[861396]: D694B20DD5B: from=<[email protected]>, \

size=486, nrcpt=1 (queue active)5. post x/local[864857]: D694B20DD5B: to=<[email protected]>, \

relay=local, delay=98, status=sent (mailbox)6. post x/smtpd[866062]: disconnect from mail.ora.com[10.143.23.45]

HELO Postfix

smtpd_helo_restrictions

MAIL FROM RCPT

TO

smtpd_sender_restrictions smtpd_recipient_restrictions

DATA

header header_check

body check_body 11.9

Postfix MDA

Postfix SMTP

4xx 5xx

11.7.2Postfix UBE

main.cf UBE

Postfix

smtpd_client_restrictions =smtpd_helo_restrictions =smtpd_sender_restrictions =smtpd_recipient_restrictions = permit_mynetworks,

reject_unauth_destination

147

smtpd_helo_restrictions

Page 10: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Postfix

Postfix

Postfix access map

11-1 Postfix UBE

check_helo_access

smtpd_helo_restrictions smptd_sender_restrictions

Postfix

11-1

type:mapname

type:mapname

type:mapname

type:mapname

148

Page 11: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

11-1

permit_ reject_

check_*_access type:mapname mapname

access table Postfix

key-value

11.7.3

11-1 reject_ permit_

Pos t f i x OK

REJECT DUNNO Postfix

REJECT

Postfix OK

REJECT

OK

REJECT

DUNNO Postfix

REJECT Postfix

RCPT TO Postfix HELO

OK RCPT TO REJECT

Postfix SMTP client

REJECT

REJECT RCPT TO Postfix

149

Page 12: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

REJECT

REJECT main.cf smtpd_delay_reject

no

smtpd_delay_reject = no

Postfix server SMTP client

Postfix

Postfix

soft_bounce = yes

soft_bounce 5xx 4xx SMTP

client 5xx

5xx

4xx SMTP

client soft_bounce

SMTP client

soft_bounce

soft_bounce

warn_if_reject

REJECT WARN SMTP client

Postfix

soft_bounce

warn_if_reject

warn_if_reject

smtpd_recipient_restrictions =permit_mynetworksreject_unauth_destinationwarn_if_reject reject_invalid_hostnamereject_unknown_recipient_domainreject_non_fqdn_recipient

150

Page 13: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

HELO Postfix

smtpd_recipient_restrictions =permit_mynetworksreject_unauth_destinationreject_invalid_hostnamereject_unknown_sender_domain

reject_unauth_destination

reject_invalid_hostname mynetworks

mynetworks_style permit_mynetworks OK

smtpd_recipient_restrictions

permit_mynetworks OK REJECT

DUNNO Postfix reject_unauth_destination

Pos t f i x mydestination

reject_unauth_destination REJECT DUNNO

DUNNO Postfix reject_invalid_hostname HELO

REJECT

DUNNO Postfix reject_unknown_sender_domain

MAIL FROM DNS

REJECT REJECT Postfix

MDA

11.7.3

check_*_access IP

Postfix

permit_mynetworks mynetworks

mynetworks_style

151

Page 14: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Postfix SMTP

SMTP

DNS

DNS

DNS

DNS

DNS

RBL DNS MTA

Postfix RBL client

reject permit

warn_if_reject

access map

Post f ix

key-value IP

... OK REJECT

check_client_access maptype:mapname

check_client_access IP

Postfix DNS IP

PTR

check_helo_access maptype:mapname

check_helo_access

HELO Postfix

152

Page 15: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

check_recipient_access maptype:mapname

check_recipient_access

RCPT TO

Postfix

check_sender_access maptype:mapname

check_sender_access

MAIL FROM

Postfix

check_sender_access check_recipient_access

[email protected] example.com

user@

user1@example .com

[email protected] example.com

[email protected] [email protected]

user@

check_client_access check_helo_access IP

IP 192.168.143.23

10 10.12 10.12.154

Postfix

OK

Postfix

REJECTREJECT message-text

Pos t f i x

access_map_reject_code check_*_access

maps_rbl_reject_code reject_maps_rbl

554

DUNNO

Postfix

153

Page 16: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

FILTER transport:nexthop

transport table

transport nexthop

HOLDHOLD message-text

hold queue Postfix

MDA

DISCARDDISCARD message-text

Postfix

Postfix

DISCARD

Internet

email

4xx message-text

400 ~ 499

5xx message-text

500 ~ 599

regular express

Postfix IP

11.9

smtpd_client_restrictions = check_client_access hash:/etc/post x/client_access

smtpd_sender_restrictions =check_sender_access hash:/etc/post x/sender_access

smtpd_recipient_restrictions =permit_mynetworksreject_unauth_destinationreject_invalid_hostnamereject_unknown_sender

154

Page 17: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

4xx

5xx

5xx

4xx

4xx

MX

MX

SMTP

client_access

10.157 REJECT192.168.76.23 REJECTcurrentmail.com REJECT

sender_access

[email protected] REJECTmarketing@ REJECTspecials.digital-letter.com REJECT

postmap Postfix

# postmap /etc/postfix/client_access# postmap /etc/postfix/sender_access

11-1 Postfix

155

Page 18: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

permit_auth_destination

Postf ix Posfix

mydestination inet_interfaces virtual_alias_maps

virtual_mailbox_maps relay_domain

[email protected]@example.net

permit_auth_destination DUNNO

REJECT Postfix

permit_mynetworks

IP mynetworks

UBE

Postfix server

reject_unauth_destination

Pos t f i x Pos f ix

mydestination inet_interfaces virtual_alias_maps

virtual_mailbox_maps relay_domain

[email protected]@example.net

relay_domains_reject_code 554

11-1 SMTP

OK

reject_invalid_hostname

HELO

invalid_hostname_reject_code 501

reject_non_fqdn_hostname

HELO RFC FQDN

non_fqdn_reject_code 504

FQDN Windows

156

Page 19: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

reject_non_fqdn_recipient

RCPT TO RFC

FQDN non_fqdn_reject_code

504 FQDN

reject_non_fqdn_sender

MAIL FROM RFC

FQDN non_fqdn_reject_code

504

reject_unauth_pipelining

Pipelining

SMTP pipelining

MUA MTA

pipelining Postfix

reject_unauth_pipelining SMTP client

DNS

DNS DNS

DNS Internet email

DNS

DNS

DNS

DNS

reject_unknown_client

SMTP client socket Postfix server socket

IP reject_unknown_client Postfix

DNS IP PTR IP DNS

DNS Postifx

DNS IP IP socket

IP Pos t f i x

unknown_client_reject_code 450

reject_unknown_client

DNS Internet IP

PTR

157

Page 20: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

reject_unknown_hostname

HELO A MX

unknown_hostname_reject_code 450

HELO FQDN

reject_unknown_recipient_domain

RCPT TO DNS A MX

unknown_address_reject_code

450

reject_unknown_sender_domain

MAIL FROM DNS A

MX unknown_address_reject_code

450

MAIL FROM

MAIL FROM

unknown_*_reject_code

450 Postfix

Postfix DNS DNS server

DNS server Postfix 450

Real-Time Blacklist RBL

SMTP server DNS

DNS DNSBL DNSBL

Postfix

DNSBL DNSBL

reject_rbl_client rblprovider.domain

IP 1.2.3.4 4.3.2.1 RBL

dnsbl.example.com 4.3.2.1.dnsbl.example.com

DNS A IP

Postfix

158

Page 21: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

reject_rhsbl_client rblprovider.domain

rblprovider.domain A

reject_rhsbl_sender rblprovider.domain

rblprovider.domain

A

DNSBL DNSBL

DNS

RBL

Postfix

permit

Postfix

reject

Postfix

defer

11.7.4HELO

smtpd_helo_restrictions

smtpd_helo_restrictions = check_helo_access hash:/etc/post x/helo_accessreject_invalid_hostname

helo_access

greatdeals.example.com REJECToreillynet.com OK

Postfix HELO

Postfix

159

Page 22: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

HELO example

check_helo_access Pos t f i x

helo_access example

reject_invalid_hostname example

Postfix

HELO greatdeals.example.com

Postfix check_helo_access helo_access

greatdeals.example.com REJECT Postfix

HELO oreillynet.com

Postfix check_helo_access helo_access

oreillynet.com OK Postfix smtpd_helo_restrictions

smtpd_sender_restrictions

HELO mail.ora.com

Postfix check_helo_access helo_access

mail.ora.com reject_invalid_hostname

mail.ora.com Pos t f i x

smtpd_sender_restrictions

11.8 SMTP SMTP SMTP client/server

Postfix SMTP

smtpd_helo_required

SMTP cl ient HELO EHLO SMTP RFC SMTP

clients server HELO EHLO

Postfix SMTP

smtpd_helo_required = yes Postfix

SMTP RFC Postfix

strict_rfc821_envelopes = yes

Postfix

HELO/EHLO

SMTP

160

Page 23: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

11.9Postfix Postfix

header_checks

mime_header_checks MIME

nested_header_checks

body_checks

Spamassassin http://spamassassin.org Postfix

pa t t e r n

action

Postfix

Postfix

11.9.1mime_header_checks nested_header_checks

header_checks

regexp

Posix pcre Perl

header_checks = regexp:/etc/post x/header_checksbody_checks = regexp:/etc/post x/body_checks

/

/match pattern/ REJECT

161

Page 24: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

header_checks

/free mortgage quote/ REJECT/repair your credit/ REJECT My credit is very good./take advantage now/ REJECT

Subject: Postfix

My credit is very good.

11.9.2

Postfix

REJECT message-text

message-text

WARN message-text

message-text

WARN

IGNORE

SMTP

HOLD message-text

hold queue

DISCARD message

Postfix

5xx

DISCARD

DISCARD 4xx 5xx

DISCARD

162

Page 25: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

FILTER transport:nexthop

Postfix

11.9.3

Postfix

body_checks

Postfix

line_length_limit

2048 header_size_limit 100 K

Pos t f i x

body_checks_size_limit 50 KB Postfix

Postfix

header_checks

/name ?="?.*\.(bat|scr|com|dll|exe|hta|pif|vbs)"?/ REJECT

Postfix Windows

Windows

PC

body_checks

163

Page 26: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

/increase your sales by/ REJECT/in compliance (with|of) strict/ REJECT/lowest rates.*\!/ REJECT/[:alpha:]<!--.*-->[:alpha:]/ REJECT Suspicious embedded HTML comments

lowest rates

.* ! We have our lowest rates in

40 years! HTML VIA<!--ooxx-

>GRA

HTML

postmap msg.txt

postmap

$ postmap -q - regexp:/etc/postfix/body_checks < msg.txtopportunity. increase your sales by 500%. Consider REJECT

postmap

smtpd_*_restrictions

header_checks body_checks

...

MTA MDA procmail maildrop

Postfix Postfix

11.10

Postfix

Postfix restriction class

164

Page 27: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Postfix

1. restriction class

11-1

2.

3. smtp_*_restrictions

check_*_access

check_client_access check_sender_access

check_recipient_access

11.10.1

spamlover spamhater

smtpd_restriction_classes

smtpd_restriction_classes = spamlover, spamhater

smtpd_*_restrictions

spamhater

spamhater =reject_invalid_hostnamereject_non_fqdn_hostnamereject_unknown_sender_domainreject_rbl_client nospam.example.com

spamlover permit

spamlover = permit

165

Page 28: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Postfix

per_user_ube

## per_user_ube#[email protected] [email protected] spamlover

Postfix

smtpd_recipient_restrictions =permit_mynetworksreject_unauth_destinationcheck_recipient_access hash:/etc/post x/per_user_ube

[email protected] Postfix

check_recipient_access

abe la rd@example . com spamha te r

spamhater spamhater REJECT Postfix

MDA [email protected]

Postfix spamlover

11.11Postfix

11-2

11-2 main.cf

smtpd_restriction_classes =spamloverspamhater

spamhater =reject_invalid_hostnamereject_non_fqdn_hostnamereject_unknown_sender_domainreject_rbl_client nospam.example.com

166

Page 29: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

spamlover = permit

smtpd_helo_required = yessmtpd_client_restrictions =

check_client_access hash:/etc/post x/client_access

smtpd_helo_restrictions =reject_invalid_hostnamecheck_helo_access hash:/etc/post x/helo_access

smtpd_sender_restrictions =reject_non_fqdn_senderreject_unknown_sender_domaincheck_sender_access hash:/etc/post x/sender_access

smtpd_recipient_restrictions =permit_mynetworksreject_unauth_destinationreject_non_fqdn_recipientreject_unknown_recipient_domain

smtpd_data_restrictions =reject_unauth_pipelining

header_checks = /etc/post x/header_checksbody_checks = /etc/post x/body_checks

IP

check_helo_access

check_sender_access

hotmail.com aol.com ...

MAIL FROM HELO

167

Page 30: 11epaper.gotop.com.tw/pdf/A141.pdfwhitelist 11.4.1 SMTP SMTP IP Open Relay Internet Open Relay Open Relay IP IP DNS-based Internet DNS-based DNS-based Blacklists DNSBL Realtime BlacklistsRBL

Republic

of Maldives

168