What Do VARs Mean Measuring the Output Effect of Monetory Policy

8/2/2019 What Do VARs Mean Measuring the Output Effect of Monetory Policy

1/37

`@| _L |i V+t 4i@?q i@th?} |i |T|

,giU|t Lu L?i|@h) L*U)

aL? O LUh@?i

a*) c bb.

Devwudfw

YDUv ghvfuleh wkh klvwru| ri rxwsxw dqg rwkhu yduldeohv iroorzlqj prqhwdu|vkrfnv1 Wr phdvxuh ri wkh hhfwv ri prqhwdu| vkrfnv/ rqh pxvw dgg hfrqrplf lghq0wli|lqj dvvxpswlrqv1 L vshfli| wkh uhodwlyh hhfwv ri dqwlflsdwhg dqg xqdqwlflsdwhgprqh|/ dqg L fdofxodwh krz YDU0edvhg phdvxuhv ri wkh hhfw ri prqh| rq rxwsxwfkdqjh dv rqh ydulhv wklv dvvxpswlrq1

Wkh dqwlflsdwhg2xqdqwlflsdwhg dvvxpswlrq lqxhqfhv phdvxuhg rxwsxw hhfwv dvpxfk ru pruh wkdq wkh yduldeoh vhohfwlrq dqg vkrfn ruwkrjrqdol}dwlrq dvvxpswlrqvrq zklfk wkh YDU olwhudwxuh irfxvhv1 Dvvxplqj wkdw dqwlflsdwhg prqhwdu| srolf|fdq kdyh vrph hhfw rq rxwsxw uhvxowv lq pxfk vkruwhu/ vpdoohu/ dqg shukdsv pruheholhydeoh hvwlpdwhv ri wkh rxwsxw uhvsrqvh wr prqhwdu| vkrfnv1

MHO Frghv= H85/F65/F85Nh|zrugv= Prqhwdu| srolf|/ yhfwru dxwruhjuhvvlrq/ lghqwlfdwlrq1

Xqlyhuvlw| ri Fklfdjr/ Ihghudo Uhvhuyh Edqn ri Fklfdjr dqg QEHU1 Dgguhvv= JudgxdwhVfkrro ri Exvlqhvv/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Fklfdjr/ 4434 H1 8;wk Vw1/ Fklfdjr LO 9396:/ ::6 :35 638


2/37

W?|hL_U|L?

`@| @hi |i hi@* igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U)q }i hiUi?| *|ih@|hi @t hi|h?i_ |L

|t U*@ttU ^it|L?c @?_ @t 4i@thi_ |i t|Lh) Lu hi@* @?_ ?L4?@* @h@M*it uL**L?}

4L?i|@h) tLU!t ) |?!?} U@hiu**) @ML| L |L _i?|u) 4L?i|@h) TL*U) tLU!t ELhc

@ Uh|U 4}| U@h}ic M) i|i?ti t?}c |t *|ih@|hi @t @| *@t| ThL_Ui_ 4T*ti

hitTL?ti u?U|L?t |@| U@T|hi UL44L? it @ML| 4L?i|@h) TL*U)

dW?tih| 6}hi ihio

6}hi Thiti?|t |L i@4T*itc |@!i? uhL4 LUh@?i Ebbe@ U thi)t |t

*|ih@|hi EAi tTiUU@|L? @?_ it|4@|L? Lu |iti V+t t _itUhMi_ ? |i TTi?_

Ai |LT hL Thiti?|t hitTL?tit |L @ L?i t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? 2 tLU! ? ?iTiU|i_ hti

? 2 t uL**Li_ M) @ ThL|h@U|i_ hti ? 2 Ai ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i hitTL?_t | @? ?|@*

_iU*?i @?_ |i? @ ThL|h@U|i_ hti At hitTL?ti U@? Mi ?|ihThi|i_ @t @ R*^_|) igiU|

uL**Li_ M) @? R?@|L? igiU| L?t4T|L? @?_ L|T| hti |i4TLh@h*)c @?_ ThUit

hti Ai *L?}h? UL?t4T|L? @?_ L|T| igiU|t @hi 4U *itt |@? L?i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh

uhL4 3ihL W? |i ML||L4 hLc ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i ??L@|L?t @hi ti_ |L _i?|u) 4L?i)

tTT*) tLU!t W? hitTL?ti |L @ thThti ?Uhi@ti ? |i ui_ih@* u?_t h@|ic UL?t4T|L?

@?_ L|T| _iU*?i |i4TLh@h*)c ThUit _iU*?ic @?_ _iU*?it Ai ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i

@*tL t|@)t } uLh ^|i tL4i |4i @u|ih |i ?|@* tLU!

Ai }i?ih@* T@||ih?t ? 6}hi @hi t| @| 6hi_4@? EbSH |@}| t |L iTiU|OLiihc |i 4@}?|_it @hi @ M| thTht?} Ai L|T| hitTL?tit @hi ThL|h@U|i_c

4Tt@Ti_ @?_ *@h}i |T| Ti@!t |L )i@ht @u|ih |i tLU!c @?_ |@!it i )i@ht

4Vhh dprqj pdq| rwkhuv Ehuqdqnh dqg Eolqghu +4


3/37

|L _i L| |T| htit M) @ML| fDI uL**L?} @ L?it|@?_@h_ _i@|L? tLU!c U

t @*tL @ML| fDI( t?Ui 2 t 4U t4@**ih |@? L|T|c @?_ |i M@ti t @}@? 4U

t4@**ih |@? 2c |t hitTL?ti 4T*it @ *@h}i @4T*U@|L? ? _L**@h |ih4t ?_ W ti*iU|i_

|iti tTiUU@|L?t ? T@h| |L 4?43i |i t3i @?_ *i?}| Lu L|T| hitTL?tit 54T*ih

tTiUU@|L?t E2c L|T| @?_ ThUi *ii* uLh i@4T*i ThL_Ui ii? *@h}ih @?_ 4Lhi

ThL|h@U|i_ hitTL?tit

Aiti 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L?t U@T|hi t|Lh)c |i @ih@}i @*it Lu 4L?i)c L|T|c

?|ihit| h@|it @?_ L|ih @h@M*it uL**L?} @ 4L?i) tTT*) tLU! `@| _Lit |t t|Lh)

|i** t @ML| |i igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U)q `@| _Lit | |i** tc uLh i@4T*ic @ML|

|i ULhti Lu ii?|t i tL*_ iTiU| u |ihi t @ 4L?i|@h) tLU! ?L| uL**Li_ M) |i

Ut|L4@h) uh|ih iT@?tL? Lu 4L?i)q | @?L|ih @)c L 4TLh|@?| t |i ThLtLc

_i*) ?i}*iU|i_ ? |i V+ *|ih@|hic |@| |i V+ 4i@thit |i igiU|t Lu TL*U)

tLU!tc L?*) u |i) @hi uL**Li_ M) |i Ut|L4@h) uh|ih TL*U) @U|L?tq `@| _Lit

|t t|Lh) |i** t @ML| 4L?i|@h) |iLh)c @ML| U !?_t Lu 4L?i|@h) 4L_i*t L?i

?ii_t |L UL?t|hU| ? Lh_ih |L ?_iht|@?_ @?_ }_i 4L?i|@h) TL*U)q W? T@h|U*@hc _L

|i hitTL?tit 4i@? |@| i 4t| UL?t|hU| 4L?i|@h) |iLhit | 4TLh|@?| _i*@) @?_

ThLT@}@|L? 4iU@?t4tq

W| t |i4T|?} |L |?! |@|c L?Ui 4L?i|@h) TL*U) tLU!t @hi ULhhiU|*) _i?|i_c

|i 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L?t ThL_i _hiU| @?tiht |L |iti ^it|L?tc _hiU| 4i@thit

Lu |i igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U) Ai i|i?ti iUL?L4U ?|ihThi|@|L?t Lu 4T*ti

hitTL?ti u?U|L?t ? |i V+ *|ih@|hi U@? i@t*) *i@i hi@_iht | |t 4ThittL?

| 5@h}i?|


4/37

dW?tih| }hi 2 ihio

AL Mi tTiUUc uLUt L? |i 4L?i)$4L?i) @?_ 4L?i)$L|T| hitTL?tit T*L||i_

|L}i|ih ? 6}hi 2 Wu L?*) ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i|@h) tLU!t U@? @giU| L|T|c |i L|T|

hitTL?ti _Lit 4i@thi |i _)?@4U igiU| Lu |i ?|@* 4L?i|@h) tLU! hiUti*)c ? |t

U@ti |i L|T| hitTL?ti t RTL*U) ?@h@?|G 4L?i) tLU! ** @i |t igiU| L?

L|T| ? @?) hi}4ic Lh ?L 4@||ih @| |i T@| Lu 4L?i) uL**L?} |i tLU!

| tTTLti ?t|i@_ |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i|@h) tLU!t U@? @*tL @giU| L|T| Lc

|i UL?|?i_ iT@?tL? Lu 4L?i) |@| t iTiU|i_ |L uL**L @ tLU! U@?c i? | @TTi?tc

U@ti |i ThL*L?}i_ iT@?tL? Lu L|T| uL**L?} |i tLU! Ai igiU|t Lu @ 4L?i|@h)

TL*U) tLU! L? L|T|c i |i TL*U)?@h@?| ^@?||)c Lh |i T@| Lu L|T| uL**L?}

@ tLU! |@| t ?L| uL**Li_ M) |i @M|@* uh|ih iT@?tL? Lu 4L?i)c 4@) Mi ? u@U|

t4@**c tLh| @?_ _iU@)?} Eh@|ih |@? 4Tt@Ti_ Wu @ 4L_i* ThL_Uit @?|UT@|i_

4L?i) igiU|tc | 4@) ?L| hi^hi @4T*U@|L? @?_ _i*@) 4iU@?t4t |L Mi UL?tt|i?|

| |i _@|@

u ULhtic L?i @?|t ?4Miht Lh }h@Tt( it|4@|it ?L| t|Lhit ,@U|*) @| 4i@thi

Lu |i igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U) _Lit L?i }i| uhL4 @tt4?} |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) U@?

4@||ihq OL tLh| @?_ t4@** @hi |i |hi hitTL?ti u?U|L?t ? |t U@tiq W? |i ML_)

Lu |t T@Tihc W @_LT| @*|ih?@|i iT*U| _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L?t ? U @?|UT@|i_

4L?i) U@? @i tL4i igiU| L? L|T| 6hL4 |i it|4@|i_ 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L?tc

W U@*U*@|i it|4@|it Lu |i igiU| Lu 4L?i) L? L|T| ?_ih |i @*|ih?@|i _i?|u)?}

@tt4T|L?t W ?_ |@| |i it|4@|i_ L|T| hitTL?tit @h) @ *L| @t L?i U@?}it _i?|u)

?} @tt4T|L? Ai @?|UT@|i_?@?|UT@|i_ _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L? t @t 4TLh|@?| |L

|i L|T| igiU| 4i@thit @t |i @h@M*i ti*iU|L? @?_ Lh|L}L?@*3@|L? @tt4T|L?t L?

U |i V+ *|ih@|hi uLUtit W @*tL ?_ |@| |i @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i*t _L hit*|

e


5/37

? L|T| igiU| it|4@|it |@| @hi 4U tLh|ih @?_ t4@**ih |@? |i 4T*tihitTL?ti

u?U|L?

Ai TL?| @?_ UL?|hM|L? Lu |t T@Tih t @| |L _L | 4T*ti hitTL?ti u?U|L?t

@u|ih |i) @i Mii? it|4@|i_ AihiuLhic W ti @ u@h*) t|@?_@h_ tTiUU@|L? @?_ _L ?L|

uLUt L? |i @h@M*i ti*iU|L?c tTiUU@|L?c @?_ Lh|L}L?@*3@|L? ttit L? U |i

V+ *|ih@|hi h}|*) uLUtit Ai Ui?|h@* }i?ih@* T@||ih? Lu RULhhiU| t}?tc Tihtt|i?|

TL*U)c @?_ Tihtt|i?| hitTL?tit |L tLU!t t ?L| @| @** ti?t|i |L |i _i|@*t Lu tTiU

U@|L?c @?_ t UL44L? |L @*4Lt| @** |i 4L?i|@h) V+t ? |i *|ih@|hi AihiuLhic |i

^@*|@|i hit*|t @TT*) |L 4Lt| Lu |@| *|ih@|hi

,TiU|i_ 4L?i)q

5L*_ @? i4ThUt| ii? UL?t_ih |i TLttM*|) |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i|@h) U@? @i

hi@* igiU|tq wU@t Eb.2c b.c @?_ ? @ uLhUiu* t44@h)c bbS t@)t ?L W? wU@t< 4L_i*c

L?*) ?iTiU|i_ 4L?i|@h) TL*U) tLU!t U@? @i hi@* igiU|t wU@t< i t @||h@U|ic

t?Ui | U@? iT*@? |i u@U| |@| 4L?i|@h) TL*U) tL4i|4it tii4t |L @i *@h}i L|T|

igiU|t M| @| L|ih |4it tii4t |L @i t4@** Lh ?L igiU|t Ai iTihi?Ui Lu bHfH2

t Lu|i? tii? @t @ U*@ttU i@4T*i Lu @ *@h}i igiU| Ai _iM@|i Lih |i }hi@| _iThittL?

tii4t ?L |L Mi Lih L 4L?i|@h) TL*U) U@ti_ |i _iThittL? h@|ih |@? i|ih

| __ tL | ? |i i?_t Lu )Tih?@|L?t E5@h}i?| bHS @?_ Uhhi?U) hi@*@|L?tc

4L?i) }hL| Lh |t t|LU! U@? U@?}i M) u@U|Lht Lu |Lt@?_tc *|ih@**) Lih?}|c |

?L hi@* igiU| @| @**

wU@t< hiUL?U*@|L? Lu |iti _gihi?| hi}4it @t @ _h@4@|U 4T*U@|L?G t)t|i4@|U

4L?i|@h) TL*UitQTL*Uit |@!i? Thi_U|@M*) M) Ui?|h@* M@?!t |L Lgti| hiUittL?tQ@i

?L hi@* igiU|tc @ TL?| 4@_i uLhUiu**) M) 5@h}i?| @?_ @**@Ui Eb.D At 4T*U@|L?

4@) i*T |L iT*@? |i _U*|it |@| Ui?|h@* M@?!t @i u@Ui_ ? ?i |??} L|T| Lh

D


6/37

iU@?}i h@|it M) |h)?} |L t)t|i4@|U@**) Lgti| hi@* tLU!t

OLiihc wU@t< i @t ?L| Mii? ?iht@**) @UUiT|i_ @?) @|Lht t|@|i Lh hii@*

it |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) @t hi@* igiU|t Lh Ei^@*i?|*) |@| t)t|i4@|U TL*U)

4@||iht 6Lh i@4T*ic +L4ih @?_ +L4ih Ebbe U*@4 |@| t)t|i4@|U 4L?i|@h) TL*U)

i?_i_ TLt|@h hiUittL?t Ai @h}4i?| @}@?t| Uhhi?U) ?L?t @?_ i_ iU@?}i h@|it

t |@| |i) Thii?| ?@|L?@* }Lih?4i?|t uhL4 Tht?} t)t|i4@|U 4L?i|@h) TL*U) |L

Lgti| UL?|h)tTiUU hi@* tLU!t Ai *|ih@|hi |@| i@*@|it ?L4?@* B |@h}i|?}

E6i*_t|i? @?_ 5|LU! bbec O@** @?_ @?! bbe @hi hiUi?| i@4T*it t Thi_U@|i_ L?

|i _i@ |@| Mi||ih t)t|i4@|U TL*Uit U@? hi_Ui |i @h@?Ui Lu L|T|

L?i|@h) |iLht|t @i @*tL UL?t|hU|i_ 4L_i*t ? U @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i|@h) tLU!t

U@? @i hi@* igiU|t ih*@TT?} UL?|h@U| 4L_i*t EA@)*Lh b.bc t|U!) ThUi 4L_i*t EuLh

i@4T*ic +L|i4Mih} bH2c bbe tii @*tL *@?U@h_ bbf uLh @ hii | hiuihi?Uitc

*4|i_ T@h|UT@|L? 4L_i*t EBhLtt4@? @?_ `itt bHc +L|i4Mih} bHec 4Lhi hiUi?|*)

*@hi3 @?_ |!itL? bbS @hi Th4i i@4T*it ,i? wU@t< Eb.2 4L_i* U@? }i?ih@|i

igiU|t Lu @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) u 4L?i) t ?L| ?iU|i_ M) ThLTLh|L?@* |h@?tuih W? wU@t@?_ 5|L!i)


7/37

2 L_i*t Lu |i @?|UT@|i_%?@?|UT@|i_ tT*|

2 ihi

W tTiUu) |L t4T*i 4L_i*t uLh |i hi*@|L? Mi|ii? 4L?i) @?_ L|T| |@| U@T|hi

@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) igiU|t Ai ht| 4L_i* @**Lt iTiU|i_ @?_ ?iTiU|i_ 4L?i) |L

@giU| L|T| W| t

+| ' @W Eu db6| n E b E6| .|36|o n K

W Eu B|

t|iht!t L? @W Eu @?_ KWEu _i?L|i t|hU|h@* *@} TL*)?L4@*t b t @ ThitTiUi_ T@h@

4i|ih |@| @hit Mi|ii? f @?_ KW

Eu B| U@T|hit ?L?4L?i|@h) L|T| _t|hM@?Uit

t b $ f |t 4L_i* tTiUit |@| L?*) ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4@||iht t b $ |ihi t

?L _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? @?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i)

Ai tiUL?_ 4L_i* t @ t*}| 4L_U@|L? Lu @ t|@?_@h_ t|U!)ThUi 4L_i* E+L|i4Mih}

bH2c bbec

+| ' @W Eu %6|

k

ku

.|3# kq

kqu3

6|$& n KW Eu B|q t @ _tUL?| u@U|Lhc t*}|*) *itt |@? c @?_ k Mi|ii? f @?_ 4i@thit |i ULt|t

Lu ThUi @_t|4i?| Ai t|U!) ThUi4L_i* U@T|hit |i _i@ |@| ThUit @?_ i?Ui

L|T| hitTL?_ |L iTiU|i_ u|hi 4L?i) Ai _t|hM|i_ *i@_ Lu u|hi 4L?i) uL**L?}

|i iTiU|@|L? U@T|hit |t igiU|c @Mti?| uhL4 |i ht| 4L_i* t |i ThUit|U!?itt

T@h@4i|ih k $ fc |t 4L_i* @*tL hi_Uit |L |i ?iTiU|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i* Eb ' fc @?_

@t k $ | hi_Uit |L |i 4iU@?t|U 4L_i* Eb ' W| }it @ 4L_i* ? Mi|ii? |iti

|L i|hi4it |@| t 4Lhi UL4T*U@|i_ M| tL4i@| 4Lhi }hL?_i_ ? iUL?L4U |iLh)

|@? |i ht| 4L_i*

W @tt4i |@| |iti hi*@|L?t Mi|ii? 4L?i) @?_ L|T| @hi ?@h@?| |L |i TL*U)

hi}4i( L?Ui i @i it|4@|i_ |i T@h@4i|iht @W Euc i U@? U@*U*@|i |i hitTL?ti Lu

.


8/37

L|T| |L @hM|h@h) 4L?i|@h) iTih4i?|t wU@t Eb.S @h}i_ |@| @ }LL_ tLhUiQ

M| ?L| |i L?*) tLhUiQLu TL*U)?@h@?| hi*@|L?t @hi hi*@|L?t U@hiu**) }hL?_i_ ?

iUL?L4U |iLh) L| Lu |i @MLi 4L_i*t @i tL4i }hL?_?} ? iUL?L4U |iLh)c M|

|i _)?@4Ut @W Eu @hi @_LU Ai 4L_i*t @hi ?|i?_i_ @t @ iM*i )i| ThiUti @)

Lu U@T|h?} i@t*)?|ihThi|@M*i @?|UT@|i_?@?|UT@|i_ _t|?U|L?tc @t uL?_ ? 4@?)

4Lhi uLh4@* 4L_i*t @?_ _tUttL?t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U)

W? |i hi4@?_ih Lu |t tiU|L?c W _ii*LT @?_ 4L|@|i |iti 4L_i*tc @?_ W tL L

|L _i?|u) |i T@h@4i|iht @W Eu uhL4 |i 4T*ti hitTL?ti u?U|L?

22 ?|UT@|i_?@?|UT@|i_ 4L_i*

L_i*

6ht|c tTTLti |@| L?*) ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) @giU|t L|T| Ai t|@?_@h_ 4L_i* E@tc

uLh i@4T*ic ? 5@h}i?|


9/37

5iUL?_c tTTLti |ihi t ?L _t|?U|L? Mi|ii? @?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i)c

tL Lh t|hU|h@* i t

+| ' @W Eu 6| n K

W Eu B|

A)TU@**) L?i LTit Lh 4TLtit |@| @W E ' fc tL |@| |i *ii* Lu 4L?i) @t ?L *L?}h?

igiU| L? L|T|

?i 4@) @}@? UL4T*@? @ML| 4UhLuL?_@|L?t OLiihc |t t @ 4L_i* | @

}hi@| t|LhU@* |h@_|L? ? i4ThU@* Lh!c uhL4 |i 5| wLt 6i_ hi}hittL?t E?_ihtL?

@?_ aLh_@? bSH @?_ |t 4@?) @?|iUi_i?|t |L |i _)?@4U 4*|T*iht U@*U*@|i_ M)

+L4ih @?_ +L4ih Ebbe Lt| 4TLh|@?|*)c |t 4L_i* t 4T*U| ? @?) _tUttL? |@|_Lit ?L| iT*U|*) _t|?}t igiU|t Lu @?|UT@|i_ t ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i|@h) TL*U)

5?Ui @*4Lt| ?L TL*U) _tUttL?t 4@!i |t _t|?U|L?c ii? @4L?} @U@_i4Utc | tii4t

Lh| ?|ihThi|?} |i _@|@ | |t i

6?@**)c i @?| @ 4L_i* |@| @tt4it |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) U@? @i tL4i igiU|c

|L} ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4}| @i t|hL?}ih igiU|t t @ @) |L U@T|hi |t _i@2c

5

Pdq| rwkhu vfkhphv duh srvvleoh1 Rqh pljkw wu| wr doorz vhsdudwh g|qdplf hhfwv ri dqwlflsdwhg dqgxqdqwlflsdwhg prqh|/|w @ d

d +O, pw . d

x +O, +pw Hw4pw, . e +O, w=

Dodv/ dd dqg d

x duh qrw vhsdudwho| lghqwlhg1 +Vhh Frfkudqh 4n4On4

4f|p +O, =

Dv n $ 4> zh uhfryhu wkh dqwlflsdwhg prqh| fdvh/ dv n @ 4> zh uhfryhu wkh xqdqwlflsdwhg prqh| fdvh1Wklv prgho ohg wr n shulrg rvfloodwlrqv lq d +O,/ vr L gr qrw suhvhqw wkh uhvxowv1 Prghov dorqj wklv olqhpxvw doorz glhuhqw djhqwv wr kdyh glhuhqw lqirupdwlrq odjv/ lq rughu wr dyrlg n0shulrg g|qdplfv1

b


10/37

W @tt4i @*it uLh b ?

+| ' @W Eu db6| n E b E6| .|36|o n K

W Eu B| E

W_i?|U@|L?

#i?L|i |i L?| 4L?} @ih@}i hiThiti?|@|L? Lu L|T| @?_ 4L?i) ELh ui_ih@* u?_t

h@|ic @t L?i 4}| hiULih uhL4 @ V+ @u|ih @** |i Lh|L}L?@*3@|L? @tt4T|L?t @i

Mii? 4TLti_c @t uL**Lt

%6|+| & ' %

S66 Eu S6+ EuS+6 Eu S++ Eu & %

"6|"+| & ( .#%

"6|"+| & k "6| "+| l$ ' U Ee

,ih) _i?|U@|L? uLh4*@ Mi*L }Lit |hL} ?U@?}i_ ? *@h}ih V+t W _hLT UL?

t|@?|t @?_ TLttM*i |4i |hi?_tc tL |@| + @?_ 6 |)TU@**) hiThiti?| |i _i|hi?_i_ *L} Lu

L|T| @?_ @ 4L?i|@h) @}}hi}@|i W uLUt L? |i L|T| hitTL?ti |L 4L?i|@h) TL*U)c tL W

_L ?L| ^it|L? @h@M*i ti*iU|L?c tTiUU@|L?c tLU! @h@M*i ULUic Lh|L}L?@*3@|L?c

@?_ t@4T*?} ihhLh ^it|L?t |@| Eh}|*) Tih@_i |i V+ *|ih@|hi

W? Lh_ih |L _i?|u) @W Eu c tMt|||i |i 4L?} @ih@}i hiThiti?|@|L?t uLh +| @?_

6| uhL4 i^@|L? Ee ?|L i^@|L? E ,^@|?} ULiUi?|t L? 06|c i LM|@?

S+6 Eu ' @W Eu dbS66 Eu n E b S66 Efo ED

Ai KW Eu @hi hhi*i@?|( @W Eu t _i?|i_ uhL4 |i L|T| @?_ 4L?i) hitTL?tit S+6Euc

S66Eu @*L?i W 4@|U TLiht Lu u ? i^@|L? ED |L ?_ |i i@Wj uhL4 iS+6cj @?_

iS66cj ,T@?_?} @?_ 4@|U?} TLiht Lu uc i LM|@?

@Wf 'S+6cfS66cf

( @W 'S+6cc b

S3&'f @

W&S66cc3&

S66cf : f

W? |i tTiU@* U@ti |@| L?*) ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4@||ihtc b ' fc i _L ? u@U| hiULih

|i t|hU|h@* ULiUi?|t @W Eu uhL4 |i 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L? E?i U@? @*tL tii

f


11/37

|t u@U| uhL4 i^@|L? 2 _hiU|*) ,^@|L? ED t4T*it |L

@W Eu ' S+6 Eu *S66 Ef ES

Wu |ihi t ?L _t|?U|L? Mi|ii? @?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i)c b ' c i ti

|i _)?@4U hitTL?ti Lu L|T| |L @ ?| 4T*ti |L 4L?i)c 6| h@|ih |@? |L |i 4L?i)

??L@|L?c "6| ,^@|L? ED t4T*it |L

@W Eu ' S+6 Eu *S66 Eu E.

W? |t U@tic |i hi}hittL? ULiUi?|t Lu + L? 6 @hi ?@h@?| |L TL*U)c ?L| |i 4T*ti

hitTL?ti u?U|L? 6Lh i@4T*ic +L4ih @?_ +L4ih Ebbe @?@*)3i t)t|i4@|U TL*U) |

@ i |@| |ihi t ?L iTiU|i_?iTiU|i_ _t|?U|L? LhhiU|*)c }i? |t ic |i)

Thiti?| @ _)?@4U t4*@|L? Lu |i hi}hittL? Lu + L? *@}}i_ + @?_ *@}}i_ 6 |L 4i@thi

|i igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U) h@|ih |@? @? 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L?

Ai wU@t 4L_i* @*tL 4@!it Thi_U|L?t @ML| ThUit W? |t |i|MLL! uLh4c | t

_ihi_ uhL4 @ hi*@|L? Mi|ii? L|T| @?_ ThUi thThtit

+| 'w

wdR| .|3R|o

|L}i|ih |

6| ' +| n R|

W _L ?L| ti 4i@thi_ ThUi hitTL?tit ? |i U@*U*@|L?t |@| uL**L ) uLUt t L? |i

igiU| Lu |i iTiU|i_?iTiU|i_ _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L? L? |i 4L?i) |L L|T| hi*@|L?

6Lh |t uLUtc W _L?


12/37

ttit |L ?|ihuihi | |i ?|ihThi|@|L? Lu |i 4L?i)L|T| hi*@|L? 6?@**)c |ihi @hi

_gihi?| 4L_i*t |@| }i |i t@4i ^@?||) Thi_U|L?t M| _gih L? ThUi Thi_U|L?t

E6Lh i@4T*ic |i wU@t @?_ `LL_uLh_ bbe 4L_i* ? U h4t ti| |ih tTT*) Uhi

? @_@?Ui @*tL }i?ih@|it L|T| igiU|t M@ti_ L?*) L? ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) tLU!tc M|

| _gihi?| ThUi Thi_U|L?t |@? |i wU@t b.2 4L_i* OLiihc uLh |i ThTLti Lu

i@*@|?} @ }i? 4L_i* @?_ |t _itUhT|L?t Lu @*|ih?@|i TL*Uitc L?i L*_ @?| |L

*LL! @| @** 4TLh|@?| @h@M*it ?U*_?} ThUitc @?_ 4TLti @?_ |it| @?) hit|hU|L?t

2 5|U!) ThUi 4L_i*

L_i*

4iU@?t|U hi*@|L? Mi|ii? 4L?i) @?_ L|T|c +| ' @ Eu 6| t ?L| UL?t_ihi_

@ tihLt @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i* M) |iLht|tc _itT|i |t UL?|?i_ TLT*@h|) ? TL*

U) _tUttL?t E|i @Mti?Ui Lu @?) _t|?U|L? Mi|ii? iTiU|i_ @?_ ?iTiU|i_ TL*U)

@U|L?t @?_ i4ThU@* Lh! W?t|i@_c 4L_i*t ? U ThUit @hi i_ ? @_@?Ui M) ?L4

?@* UL?|h@U|t Lh L|ih uhU|L?t @hi @ UL44L? @?_ |h@U|@M*i uh@4iLh! |@| U@? }i?ih@|i

@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) igiU|t

?i 4t| Lu ULhti tTiUu) @| ThUit @hi ti| |L ? @_@?Ui W ti @ t*}| 4L_U@

|L? Lu @? iT*U| t|U!) ThUi 4L_i* _i |L +L|i4Mih} EbH2c bbe W|t tTiUU@|L? @?_

Ui?|h@* Thi_U|L?t @hi |)TU@* Lu 4@?) t|U!) ThUi @?_ ?L4?@* UL?|h@U| 4L_i*t +L|i4

Mih} TLt|t @ _i|@*i_ @?_ h}LhLt 4UhLiUL?L4U t|hU|hi OLiihc t *L}*?i@h3i_

ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L?t @hi |i t@4i @t |Lti Lu @ hiThiti?|@|i ThUiti||ih L 4@43it

@? LMiU|i u?U|L? | @ ThUi @_t|4i?| ULt| |ih4c

4@tR|

2.[|

q|kE k E kq ER| 6|

2 n k ER| R|32l

EH

k t @ T@h@4i|ih Mi|ii? f @?_ |@| 4i@thit |i ULt|t Lu ThUi @_t|4i?| 5U@*?}

2


13/37

|i ht| |ih4 M) kq @t ?L igiU| L? |i ThLM*i4c M| t4T*it |i uL**L?} i

ThittL?t Ai h@|L Lu *ii* ULt|t |L ThUi U@?}i ULt|t t @** |@| 4@||iht A@| ULt|

h@|Lc k* dE kE kqo c }Lit 4L?L|L?U@**) uhL4 f |L 4 @t k }Lit uhL4 f |L W

4L_u) +L|i4Mih}


14/37

|L @__ @_LU _)?@4Ut |L |i t|U!) ThUi 4L_i*c }?}

+| ' @W Eu

%6|

k

ku.|3

# kq

kqu36|

$&n KW Eu B| Ef

i U@? |?! Lu |t 4L_i* @t @**L?} i*LU|) |L hitTL?_ |L 4L?i|@h) tLU!tc i

+| ' @W Eu E6| R|

W_i?|U@|L?

W ThitTiUu) k @?_ q q t @ _tUL?| u@U|Lhc U W tTiUu) @t q ' fbH Ai hit*|t

@hi ?ti?t|i |L q tL *L?} @t | t ?i@hih |L |@? |L f W @h) |i T@h@4i|ih k uhL4 f |L

@?_ |h@U! |i hit*|tc @t i i@4?i_ |i ti?t||) |L |i T@h@4i|ih b ? |i @?|UT@|i_

?@?|UT@|i_ 4L_i* E `i U@? |i? _i?|u) @W Eu uhL4 |i 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L?

*}}?} |i V+ hitTL?tit S66Euc S+6Eu |L 4L?i) tLU!t ?|L Efc i LM|@?e

E kuE kqu3S+6Eu '

6L lqyhvwljdwhg dq dowhuqdwlyh zd| wr hqulfk wkh g|qdplfv/ e| dgglqj kljkhu ghulydwlyhv wr wkh remhfwlyhixqfwlrq/

4

5H[

w

w %+sw pw,5 .4

[n@4

n +sw swn,5&

Wkh h{lelolw| lq +O, doorzv wkh prgho wr surgxfh pruh frpsoh{ prqh| dqg rxwsxw lpsxovh0uhvsrqvhixqfwlrqv1 Krzhyhu/ doo lpsxovh0uhvsrqvh ixqfwlrqv duh qrw srvvleoh/ vr wklv prgho vwloo lpsrvhv uhvwulfwlrqvrq f|p +O, dqg fpp +O, wkdw duh qrw vdwlvhg e| wkh srlqw hvwlpdwhv ri wkh YDUv lqyhvwljdwhg ehorz1 Rqhfrxog hvwlpdwh wklv prgho e| pd{lpxp olnholkrrg/ lpsrvlqj lwv uhvwulfwlrqv rq wkh gdwd1 Krzhyhu/ wkhfrvwv ri kljkhu ghulydwlyhv ri sulfh fkdqjh gr qrw vhhp pxfk pruh frpshoolqj wkdq wkh d +O, sro|qrpldodv d srolf|0lqyduldqw ghvfulswlrq ri whfkqrorj|1

Lw lv whpswlqj wr jhqhudol}h wkh prgho +43, e| vlpso| doorzlqj jhqhudo odjjhg hhfwv ri d glvwulexwhgohdg ri ixwxuh prqh|/

d +O,sw @ Hwg

O4

pw=

Wklv irup fdswxuhv wkh pdmrulw| ri vwlfn| sulfh ru qrplqdo frqwudfw prghov1 Krzhyhu/ rqh fdqqrw vhs0dudwho| lghqwli| d dqg e1 Ixuwkhupruh/ wkh srlqw ri wkh vwlfn| sulfh prgho lv wkdw wkh iruzdug dqg

edfnzdug odj sro|qrpldov duh olqnhg e| frpprq _whfkqrorjlfdo% sdudphwhuv17Zh rewdlq gluhfwo|

f|p +O, pw @ d +O,

4

4

4 OHw4

4

4 O4

fpp +O, pw=

Qrz/

Hw44

4 O4fpp +O, pw @

fpp +O, fpp +,

4 O4pw=

+\rx fdq fkhfn gluhfwo| wkdw wkh fpp +, whupv uhpryhv wkh fxuuhqw dqg ixwxuh pw 1 Vhh Vdujhqw 4


15/37

@WEukkE uE qu3S66Eu n E kE kqS66Ekq

lE

t k $ fc i^@|L? E hiULiht |i 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L? @t ? |i b ' f U@tic

i^@|L? ES t k $ c i hiULih |i t@4i _)?@4U 4*|T*ih Lu |i b ' U@tic

i^@|L? E. W? |i *@||ih U@tic |i h4 ti|t ThUi R |L @ UL?t|@?| 6Lh k 5 Efc c W

tL*i i^@|L? E hiUhti*) uLh |iq

@Wr

uhL4 @*it uLh iS66c c S+6cj M) 4@|U?} |i

ULiUi?|t L? i@U TLih Luu AL U@*U*@|i |i L|T| hitTL?ti |L 4L?i|@h) iTih4i?|tc

W ht| ?_ |i ThUi T@| W tL*i i^@|L? Eb uLh ThUit }i? @ T@| Lu 4L?i)D @?_ W

|i? ?_ L|T| uhL4

+| ' @W Eu E6| R|

At 4L_i* @*tL 4@!it Thi_U|L?t uLh ThUit t @MLic W uLUt L? |i hi*@|L?tT

Mi|ii? 4L?i) @?_ L|T|c }?Lh?} i|h@ hit|hU|L?t |@| UL4i uhL4 ThUi _@|@

V+ hit*|t

2 V+c @?|UT@|i_?@?|UT@|i_ 4L_i*

6}hi T*L|t |i hitTL?tit |L |i 4L?i) tLU! uLh |i 2 V+c }hi 2 UL**iU|t |i

4L?i) @?_ L|T| hitTL?tit |L @ 4L?i) tLU! Ai @TTi?_ _itUhMit |i 2 V+ ?

_i|@*

s1 6371 , Khqfh/

f|p +O, @ d +O,

fpp +O,

4

4 O

4

4 O4

^fpp +O, fpp +,`

Htxdwlrq +44, iroorzv e| pxowlso|lqj erwk vlghv e| +4 O, 4 O4 dqg vlpsoli|lqj wkh frhflhqwrq fpp +O,1

8L qg s4 iurp wkh uhtxluhphqw wkdw sulfhv qrw h{sorgh dv w $ 4/ dqg wkhq qg rwkhu sulfhvuhfxuvlyho|1 Wkh vroxwlrqv duh

4, Dqwlflsdwhg vwhs= w 4 = sw @4

45 +,4w > w 4 = sw @ 4

445

w=

5, Xqdqwlflsdwhg vwhs= w 3 = sw @ 3> w 4 = sw @ 4 w4=

6, Xqdqwlflsdwhg eols= sw @ 3=

7, Dqwlflsdwhg eols= w 4 = sw @+4,+4,

45 +,4w > w A 4 = sw @

+4,+4,45

w

D


16/37

dW?tih| }hi ihio

Ai *iu| @?_ T@?i* Lu 6}hi Thiti?|t |i *@} TL*)?L4@*t @W Eu |@| i it|4@|i

@tt4?} |@| @hLt uh@U|L?t Lu @?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) @giU| L|T|

At t @*tL |i igiU| L? L|T| Lu @ T@h|U*@h 4L?i|@h) ?|ihi?|L?c @ ?| ??L@|L?

? 4L?i) |@| *@t|t L?i TihL_c Lh @? R?@?|UT@|i_ M*T

Ai igiU|t Lu |t iTih4i?| @hi |i t@4i @UhLtt _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L?t uLh |i ht|

^@h|ih | |i? |i L|T| igiU| U@*U*@|i_ | |i ?@?|UT@|i_4L?i) @tt4T|L?

?Uhi@tit _h@4@|U@**)c @?_ _iU@)t M@U! |L 3ihL ih) t*L*) At igiU| tc Lu ULhtic

i@U|*) |i 4L?i) |L L|T| 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L? T*L||i_ ? 6}hi @?_ 6}hi 2

Ai L|T| igiU| U@*U*@|i_ | ?L @?|UT@|i_%?@?|UT@|i_ _t|?U|L? t ih)

t4@**c @?_ hiih|t |L 3ihL @u|ih |hii ^@h|iht Wu |t ihi |i |hi 4L_i*c |i 4T*ti

hitTL?ti u?U|L? L*_ }i @ ih) 4t*i@_?} }_i |L |i igiU|t Lu |t 4L?i|@h)

?|ihi?|L?- 6h|ih4Lhic L?i L?*) ?ii_t |L @tt4i |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4@||iht

t*}|*) ? Lh_ih |L _i?|u) tLh|*i_ igiU|t Lu |t 4L?i|@h) ?|ihi?|L? Ai b ' f2

@tt4T|L? ThL_Uit @ hitTL?ti T@||ih? 4U U*Ltih |L |i UL4T*i|i*) @?|UT@|i_ Eb '

@tt4T|L? |@? |L |i UL4T*i|i*) ?@?|UT@|i_ Eb ' f @tt4T|L?

u ULhtic @** |i 4L_i*t E@*it Lu b }i _i?|U@* L|T| hitTL?tit |L @ 4L?i)

??L@|L? |@| t uL**Li_ M) uh|ih ?Uhi@tit ? 4L?i) ThitUhMi_ M) |i 4L?i) $

4L?i) hitTL?ti u?U|L? Ai) _gih L? |i ^it|L?c R`@| u |i 6i_ tLU!t 4L?i)c

@?_ |i? uL**Lt @ T@| Lu u|hi 4L?i) _gihi?| uhL4 |i t|LhU@* T@||ih?q

? @??L?Ui_ M*T ? 4L?i) t @?L|ih ?|ihit|?} 4L?i|@h) iTih4i?|c t?Ui @?)

TL*U) U@? Mi _iUL4TLti_ ?|L @ t4 Lu iTiU|i_ @?_ ?iTiU|i_ M*Tt Ai h}| @?_

T@?i* Lu 6}hi Thiti?|t U@*U*@|L?t Lu |i hitTL?ti |L @? @??L?Ui_ M*T Lc |i

@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i* hitTL?ti t |i *@h}it| E*i@t| t4@**c @?_ |i t@4i @t ? |i *iu|

S


17/37

@?_ T@?i* t ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4@||iht 4Lhic |i hitTL?ti }i|t t4@**ih Wu L?*)

?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4@||ihtc |ihi t Lu ULhti ?L hitTL?ti |L |t @?|UT@|i_ M*T

W? iih) U@tic |i L|T| hitTL?tit L?i tiit @hi 4U tLh|ih @?_ t4@**ih |@? |i

4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L? u L?i @**Lt @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) |L ii? @i tL4i @giU| L|T|

Ai |iLhi|U@* _i?|U@|L? t ^@?||@|i*) @?_ iUL?L4U@**) 4TLh|@?|( |t t ?L| @

4?Lh tti Lu uLh}L||i? b.f


18/37

ThUi ?Uhi@ti @t |i t@4i ULt|t @t ThUit .I @@) uhL4 |ih ThLTih *ii* +L|i4Mih}

EbH2c bbe @h}it |@| |iti hi*@|i ULt|t @hi ?L| tL ?hi@tL?@M*ic ? |@| |i ULt|t Lu

ThUi*ii* _i@|L?t 4@) Mi *L Oi TLt|t @ 4L_i* Lu _t@}}hi}@|i_ 4L?LTL*t|U@**)

UL4Ti||i h4tc ? U |i ULt|t Lu @?} @ ThUi *ii* _gihi?| uhL4 |i ?_t|h)

@ih@}i @hi }c M| |i ?_t|h) @ih@}i U@? _i@|i uhL4 6| M) @ }hi@| _i@* | *||*i

ULt|

6}hi D Thiti?|t |i U@*U*@|i_ hitTL?tit |L @?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ t|iTt @?_

M*Tt ? 4L?i) uLh ThUi t|U!?itt k ' fH Ai k ' f @?_ k ' *4|t @hi |i t@4i @t

|i @?|UT@|i_ b ' f @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ b ' 4L_i*t ?it|}@|i_ @MLi k ' fH 4@!it

@? ?|ihit|?} ?|ih4i_@|i U@ti W ?U*_i |i ThUi T@|tc t?Ui |i) 4@!i U*i@h L |i

L|T| hitTL?tit @hi }i?ih@|i_

dW?tih| }hi D ihio

5|@h| | |i |LT *iu| ULh?ihc @? ?@?|UT@|i_ M*T ? 4L?i) hUit _L ?L| 4Li

@| @** ? |t U@ti Ai) U@??L| 4Li ?|* L?i TihL_ @u|ih |i M*T t !?L? |L @i

@TTi?i_ | M) |t |4ic 4L?i) @t hi|h?i_ |L |t Lh}?@* *ii* @?_ t iTiU|i_ |L

hi4@? |ihi 5?Ui +| ' @W Eu E6| R| c L|T| uL**Lt |t L?iTihL_ 4T*ti 6| R|

| |i *@} T@||ih? @W Eu 5?Ui |i *@}t @W Eu @hi t4@** @?_ tLh|c |i 4L_i* Thi_U|t

@ t4@** @?_ tLh| L|T| hitTL?ti

L|Ui |i UL?|ih?||i hit*|G tt4?} t|U!ihThUit 4T*it tLh|ih @?_ t4@**ih

igiU|t Lu |iti 4L?i|@h) ?|ihi?|L?t |@? t }i? M) |i 4T*tihitTL?ti u?U|L?t

Ai @tt4T|L? Lu t|U!ih ThUit uLhUit t |L it|4@|i @ 4U t4@**ih @?_ tLh|ih _)?@4U

hi*@|L? @W Eu |L hi4@? UL?tt|i?| |L |i V+ hiThiti?|@|L? Lu |i _@|@

i| *LL! @| |i igiU|t Lu @? @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) M*T ? |i |LT h}| ULh?ih L

ThUit hti tL4i@| ? @_@?Ui Lu |i M*Tc M| ?L| 4U t?Ui |i M*T t iTiU|i_ |L

H


19/37

*@t| L?*) L?i TihL_ @?_ | t ULt|*) |L h@ti ThUit AihiuLhic |i L|T| hitTL?ti t

t4*@h |Lc M| t*}|*) t4@**ih |@? |i T@||ih? uL?_ uLh |i ?@?|UT@|i_ M*T

Ai ML||L4 hLc *iu|c Thiti?|t @? ?@?|UT@|i_ t|iT ? 4L?i) u|ih |i 4L?i)

??L@|L?c ThUit t*L*) ?Uhi@ti Ai L|T| hitTL?ti *LL!t @*4Lt| *!i |i 4T*ti

hitTL?ti u?U|L? W| tL*_c t?Ui |i ?@?|UT@|i_ t|iT t t4*@h |L |i @U|@* TL*U)

hi}4i Ai 4iU@?t4 M) U |t 4L_i* hiThL_Uit @ _h@?L| hitTL?ti t ^|i

_gihi?| uhL4 |i ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i* Liih Ai _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? 6 @?_ R

t ?L t|h?} L| Lih 4@?) ^@h|iht +| ' @W Eu E6| R| |t }it @ _h@? L| igiU|

Lu |t 4@?)TihL_ 4T*ti |hL} |i hi*@|i*) tLh| t|hU|h@* *@} @W Eu

`i? |i 4L?i) t|iT t @?|UT@|i_ EML||L4 hLc h}|c ThUit hti ? @?|UT@|L?

Lu |i 4L?i|@h) iT@?tL? Ai ThUi hti t t*L @?_ t4LL|c t?Ui |i ThUi t|U!?itt

T@h@4i|ih t *@h}i Ai u@U| |@| q t ?i@h L?i 4@!it |i ThUi T@| ?i@h*) t)44i|hU@*

|T| _iU*?it ? @_@?Ui Lu |i 4L?i) t|iTc @?_ hiULiht i? |i ?Uhi@ti ? 4L?i)

@U|@**) LUUht Ai 4@Lh igiU| Lu @? @?|UT@|i_ t|iT ? 4L?i) t @ _iThitt?} igiU|

L? L|T|-

L4T@h?} @UhLtt UL*4?tc | t U*i@h |@| 4L_i*t | ThUi t|U!?itt U@??L| Mi

ti_ |L t|u) 4iU@?U@* hi*@|L?t Mi|ii? L|T| @?_ 4L?i) |@| _L ?L| _t|?}t

@?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ igiU|t `*i @ 4iU@?U@* hi*@|L? t |hi uLh ??|i

t|U!?itt Ek ' @?_ UL?t|@?| ThUit ii? | t|U!?itt k ' fH Lh ThUi U@?}i

ULt|t . |4it |i ULt| Lu ThUi *ii* ihhLhtc L?i LM|@?t _h@4@|U@**) _gihi?| Thi_U|L?t

uLh @? @?|UT@|i_ t ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) t|iT Ai hi@tL? t t4T*i @?_ }i?ih@*G

?|ih|i4TLh@**) LT|43?} @}i?|t u@Ui_ | tL4i uhU|L? ** @||i4T| |L @_t| MiuLhi

@? iTiU|i_ U@?}i ? TL*U) W? u@U|c |i *@h}ih |i uhU|L?t L?i Thiti?|t |L iUL?L4U

@}i?|tc |i u@h|ih @i@_ |i) ** t|@h| |L @_t| |L |i iTiU|i_ U@?}i ? TL*U)

b


20/37

6i_ih@* 6?_t V+

Ai 4L?i|@h) V+ *|ih@|hi @t hiUi?|*) |hi_ L? @h@M*it L|ih |@? 4L?i|@h) @}}hi

}@|it @t ?_U@|Lht Lu @ U@?}i ? 4L?i|@h) TL*U) ih?@?!i @?_ *?_ih EbHH ht| ti_

|i ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i Aih _i@ t |@| |i 6i_ UL?|hL*t |i u?_t h@|i L? @ _@)|L_@)

M@ttc @UUL44L_@|?} tu|t ? 4L?i) _i4@?_ tu| ? 4L?i) tTT*) t tii? i? |i

6i_ U@?}it |i ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i

Ai ML||L4 hL Lu 6}hi T*L|t hitTL?tit |L ui_ih@* u?_t tLU!t 6L**L?} ht

|@?L ,Ui?M@4 @?_ ,@?t Ebb. W Lh|L}L?@*3i ui_ih@* u?_t *@t| @?_ ?U*_i @

UL44L_|) ThUi ?_i ? |i V+ 6i_ih@* u?_t V+t |L| |t ui@|hi ThL_Ui @

RThUi T33*iQ?Uhi@tit ? |i ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i ThL_Ui ?Uhi@tit ? ThUit ht|@?L

,Ui?M@4 @?_ ,@?t iT*@? |@| |i 6i_ UL?|h@U|t L? ?it Lu u|hi ?@|L?c ?_U

?} @ tThLt ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? UL?|h@U|L?@h) tLU!t @?_ tMti^i?| ThUi htit )

?U*_?} @ UL44L_|) ThUi ?_i @?_ Lh|L}L?@*3?} ui_ih@* u?_t *@t|c |i) UL?|hL* uLh

|i 6i_


21/37

|L @TT*) |@| 4L_i* |L tL4i|?} L|ih |@? @? @U|@* 4L?i) @}}hi}@|i E,i? ? |i

?@?|UT@|i_ 4L_i*c | t ?U*i@h @| @ ui_ih@* u?_t tLU! 4i@?t Wu L?*) ?@?|UT@|i_

4L?i|@h) TL*U) @t ?L??i|h@* igiU|t Q |i _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L? Mi?_ 4T*ti

hitTL?ti u?U|L?t @| _Lit |i 6i_ hi@U|L? u?U|L? i^@|L? Lu |i V+ 4i@?q

e W?|ihThi|@|L?

`U i t h}|q

t i @i tii?c |i @?|UT@|i_%?@?|UT@|i_ _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L? 4@!it @ *@h}i

_gihi?Ui |L |i hit*|t `U _i?|u)?} @tt4T|L? t ULhhiU|q }@?c |i _@|@ EuhL4

L?i hi}4i U@??L| |i** t OLiihc i U@? i@*@|i |i T*@tM*|) Lu |i hit*|t

6ht|c ? |i ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) ic |i t|h!?} t4*@h|) Lu |i L|T| @?_ 4L?i)

hitTL?tit t @ Thi @?_ ?*!i*) UL?U_i?Uic t?Ui |i L|T| hitTL?ti L*_ Mi |i t@4i

uLh @?) 4L?i) hitTL?ti W? |i @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) ic |i L|T| hitTL?ti @t |t *@h}ic

ThL|h@U|i_ @?_ 4T t@Ti ThiUti*) MiU@ti|i 4L?i) hitTL?ti @t |i t@4i t@Ti witt

Tihtt|i?| 4L?i|@h) TL*Uit L*_ }i hti |L *itt Tihtt|i?| L|T| hitTL?tit ?i 4@)

_t*!i |iLhit |@| hi^hi tU UL?U_i?Uit ? |i _@|@ 5iUL?_c |i ?@?|UT@|i_

4L?i) i hi^hit |@| L?i UL?t|hU| @ |iLh) Lu |i *L?} _i*@)i_ @?_ 4Tt@Ti_

hitTL?tic Lh t@**L |iti _)?@4Ut @t @? @_LU T@|U Ai @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) it

hit*| ? it|4@|it Lu @ tLh|c @*4Lt| UL?|i4TLh@?iLt igiU|c Lu |i tLh| }i?ih@|i_ M)

4Lt| Uhhi?| 4L?i|@h) |iLhit L| Lu |iti UL?t_ih@|L?t t}}it| EM| Lu ULhti

U@??L| ThLi |@| |ihi t @| *i@t| tL4i hL*i uLh @?|UT@|i_c t)t|i4@|U 4L?i|@h) TL*U)

W4T*U@|L?t uLh 4L?i|@h) |iLh)

,i?|@**)c i @?| uLh4@* |iLhi|U@* 4L_i*tc tTiUi_ @| |i *ii* Lu TL*U)?@h@?|

|@t|itc |iU?L*L})c 4L?i|@h) @?_ hi@* uhU|L?tc h@|ih |@? @?|UT@|i_%?@?|UT@|i_

2


22/37

_t|?U|L?t Ai 4L_i*t tL*_ iT*@? |i V+ i_i?Uic @?_ |i) tL*_ Mi UL?tt|i?|

| @| *i@t| |i MhL@_ Mht Lu iTihi?Uit | _gihi?| hi}4it

Ai R|iLhit W 4TLti_ L? |i _@|@ @hi @ *L?} @) uhL4 |t _i@* Ai M@tU

?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i* +| ' @W Eu E6| .|36| _Lit Mit| L? UL?tt|i?U) @UhLtt

hi}4it | |i i@h| Lu |i 4L_i* uLh iT*@??} TLt|@h N5 |4i tihit t |i *L?}c

*@h}ic @?_ 4Tt@Ti_ _t|hM|i_ *@} @W Eu A@| *@} t ^it|L?@M*) TL*U)?@h@?|(

_t|ht| Lu |t *@} TL*)?L4@* t i@U|*) 4) 4L|@|L? uLh *LL!?} @| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i)

4L_i*t Ai 4iU@?t|U 4L_i* +| ' @W Eu 6| @t Lu ULhti Mii? tMiU| |L @ }i?ih@|L?

Lu _ihtL? Ai t|U!) ThUi 4L_i* W i@4?ic *!i 4Lt| @?|UT@|i_4L?i) 4L_i*tc t

@*tL ^it|L?@M*) TL*U)?@h@?| W4@}?i t?} |i +L|i4Mih} EbH2c bbe t|U!)

ThUi 4L_i*c A@)*Lh


23/37

@? ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) 4L_i* 6Lh i@4T*ic ht|@?L @?_ ,Ui?M@4 Ebb2 @__

TLh|uL*L @_t|4i?| ULt|t |L @ *^_|) igiU| U@t ? @_@?Ui 4L_i*c ? Lh_ih |L ThL_Ui

@? i|i?_i_ hitTL?ti u?U|L? Ai hit*|t t}}it| @? @*|ih?@|i T@|G u L?i UL?t|hU|t

4L_i*t | @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) igiU|tc |i) ** ?L| hi^hi tU i|i?ti @4T*U@|L?

@?_ Tihtt|i?Ui 4iU@?t4t

L*U) @_Ui

,4ThU@* Lh! t ti_ uLh TL*U) @_Ui @t i** @t ? }_?} |i |iLhi|U@* _ii*

LT4i?| Lu 4L?i|@h) iUL?L4Ut Ai 6i_ E@?_ |t Uh|Ut M@tU@**) @?| |L !?L uhL4

@U@_i4Utc R@| ** @TTi? u i h@ti |i u?_t h@|i |L_@)q At t hi}@h_i_ @t @?

itti?|@**) i4ThU@* ît|L?c @?_ L?i |L U iUL?L4t|t tL*_ Mi @M*i |L }i tL4i

@?tih Mi)L?_ R@| ?|* i ?t UL?t|hU|?} iT*U| _)?@4U }i?ih@* i^*Mh4

4L?i|@h) 4L_i*t | uhU|L?t OLiihc |t t ?L| @ Thi*) i4ThU@* ît|L?c @?_

|i |iLhi|U@* _i?|U@|L? L?i Mh?}t |L |i ttic ii? @| |i t4T*t|U *ii* Lu _t|?

}t?} @?|UT@|i_ uhL4 ?@?|UT@|i_ igiU|t |@| W Thti ihic @t @ *@h}i 4T@U| L?

|i @?tih L?i }it

Ai ?@?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) @tt4T|L? hit*|t ? L?i ti| Lu @?tihtG Wu |i u?_t h@|i

?Uhi@ti t @?|UT@|i_ Q u |t t |i ?Lh4@* |4i Lh ti| Lu ii?|t uLh @ u?_t h@|i ?Uhi@ti

Q |ihi ** Mi ?L L|T| igiU| Wu |i u?_t h@|i ?Uhi@ti t ?L| @?|UT@|i_c |ihi **

Mi @ *L?}c *@h}ic @?_ 4Tt@Ti_ igiU| L? L|T| @t }i? M) |i 4T*ti hitTL?ti

u?U|L? `@| tMtiî?| @U|L?t |i 6i_ |@!it @hi hhi*i@?| |L |i @?tih

Ai @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) @tt4T|L? hit*|t ? ^|i _gihi?| @?tihtG L*U) R@U|L?t

Q ?L *L?}ih L?*) thThtit Q hit*| ? tLh| @?_ t4@** L|T| hitTL?tit *L?}*@t|?}

@?_ *@h}i L|T| hti U@? L?*) LUUh u |i 6i_ UL?|?it iT@?tL?@h) TL*U) @U|L?t ?

|i u|hic @t | |)TU@**) @t ? |i T@t|

2


24/37

AL LT?L?t h? |hL} 4U _iM@|i Lih |i 6i_


25/37

Ai hit*|t L?i LM|@?t M) 4TLt?} _gihi?| it L? |i igiU|t Lu @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i)

@hi tM|*i 5|U!) ThUi 4L_i*t _L ?L| t|u) @ i |@| L?i U@? }?Lhi |i _t|?U|L?

Mi|ii? @?|UT@|i_ @?_ ?@?|UT@|i_ UL4TL?i?|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U) 6h|ih4Lhic |i

it|4@|i_ t3i @?_ Tihtt|i?Ui Lu L|T| hitTL?tit 4@) Mi t4@**ih i? L?i @tt4it

t|U!ih ThUitc MiU@ti L?i ?ii_t |L @tt4i @ tLh|ih _)?@4U hi*@|L? i? @?|UT@|i_

4L?i) igiU|t @hi @**Li_

6?@**)c |i L|T| hitTL?tit U@*U*@|i_ @tt4?} |@| @?|UT@|i_ 4L?i) U@? @giU|

L|T| @hi 4U t4@**ih @?_ tLh|ih |@? |Lti hiULihi_ uhL4 |i 4T*tihitTL?ti

u?U|L? Wu )Lh ThLht @hi ? u@Lh Lu t4@** tLh| igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U)c Lh 4L_i*t

| *itt hi*@?Ui L? @_LU _)?@4Utc |t u@U| 4@) t}}it| |L )L |@| @?|UT@|i_

4L?i) @?_ t)t|i4@|U 4L?i|@h) TL*U) U@? ? u@U| @giU| L|T|

2D


26/37

S +iuihi?Uit

*@hi3c 6ih?@?_L @?_ ?_hi |!itL?c bbSc Rw^_|)c W?@|L?c W?|ihit| +@|it @?_

,U@?}i +@|itc @?tUhT|c N?iht|) Lu i??t)*@?@

?_ihtL?c w @?_ a w aLh_@?c bSHc RL?i|@h) @?_ 6tU@* U|L?tG Ait| Lu Aih

+i*@|i W4TLh|@?Ui ? ,UL?L4U 5|@M*3@|L?c 6i_ih@* @?! Lu 5| wLt +ii

Dfc 2

@**c w@hi?Ui @?_ 5|iTi? B iUUi||c bHHc RW4TihuiU| ?uLh4@|L? @?_ t|@}}ihi_

ThUi ti||?} 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii .Hc bbbfH

ih?@?!ic i? 5 @?_ *@? 5 *?_ihc bHHc RAi 6i_ih@* 6?_t +@|i @?_ |i @??i*t

Lu L?i|@h) Ah@?t4ttL? 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii H2c bfb2

*@?U@h_c *ih ac bbfc R`) #Lit L?i) giU| |T|G 5hi)c W? i?@4?

6hi_4@? @?_ 6h@?! O O@?c i_tc O@?_MLL! Lu L?i|@h) ,UL?L4Ut V WWc

4t|ih_@4c i vLh!G Lh|OL**@?_ ,*tiih 5Ui?Ui M*tiht V ..bHD

ht|@?Lc w@hi?Ui ac @h|? ,Ui?M@4c bb2c Rw^_|) ,giU|t @?_ |i L?i|@h)

Ah@?t4ttL? iU@?t4c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii H2c eSD

ht|@?Lc w@hi?Ui ac @h|? ,Ui?M@4c bbDc Rw^_|) ,giU|tc L?i|@h) L*U)

@?_ |i t?itt )U*ic aLh?@* Lu L?i)c hi_| @?_ @?!?} 2. ELi4Mih T@h|W S

ht|@?Lc w@hi?Ui ac @h|? ,Ui?M@4c @?_ @h*it ,@?t bb. RAi ,giU|t Lu

L?i|@h) L*U) 5LU!tG 5L4i ,_i?Ui 6hL4 |i 6*L Lu 6?_t 6Lh|UL4?}

+ii Lu ,UL?L4Ut @?_ 5|@|t|Ut

2S


27/37

LUh@?ic aL? Oc bbe@c R5LU!tc @h?i}i+LUit|ih L?uihi?Ui 5ihit L? M*U

L*U) ec 2bDSe

LUh@?ic aL? Oc bbeMc RL44i?| L? +L4ih @?_ +L4ih ? 5|@?*i) 6tUih @?_

a*L a +L|i4Mih}c ,_tc bbe ,+ @UhLiUL?L4Ut ??@*c @4Mh_}iG WA

hittc DH.e

,Ui?M@4c @h|?c bb2 RL44i?|t L? W?|ihThi|?} |i 4@UhLiUL?L4U |4i tihit

u@U|tG Ai igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U)< M) ht|LTih 54tc ,hLTi@? ,UL?L4U

+ii Sc fff

6i*_t|i?c @h|? @?_ a@4it O 5|LU! bbe RAi Nti Lu @ L?i|@h) }}hi}@|i |L A@h}i|

L4?@* B#c ? Bhi}Lh) @?!c ,_c L?i|@h) L*U) U@}LG N?iht|)

Lu U@}L hitt

6hi_4@?c *|L? @?_ ??@ a 5U@h|3c bSc L?i|@h) Ot|Lh) Lu |i N?|i_ 5|@|it

HS.bSfc h?Ui|L?G h?Ui|L? N?iht|) hitt

6hi_4@?c *|L?c bSHc RAi +L*i Lu L?i|@h) L*U)c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii

DHc .

6iht|c A4L|) bb2c Rw^_|)c wL@?@M*i 6?_t @?_ +i@* U||)c aLh?@* Lu L?

i|@h) ,UL?L4Ut 2bc 2e

BLh_L?c #@_ @?_ ,hU wiiTihc bbc RAi #)?@4U W4T@U|t Lu L?i|@h) L*U)G

? ,ihUti ? Ai?|@|i W_i?|U@|L? aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) f2c 22H

2e.

BhLtt4@?c 5@?uLh_ @?_ w@hi?Ui ittc bHc R Ah@?t@U|L?t@ti_ L_i* Lu |i

L?i|@h) Ah@?t4ttL? iU@?t4c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii .c H.2D.

2.


28/37

O@**c +LMih| , @?_ Bhi}Lh) @?!c bbec RL4?@* W?UL4i A@h}i|?}c ?

Bhi}Lh) @?!c ,_c L?i|@h) L*U)c U@}LG N?iht|) Lu U@}L hitt

wU@tc +LMih| , ahc b.2c R,TiU|@|L?t @?_ |i i|h@*|) Lu L?i)c aLh?@* Lu

,UL?L4U AiLh) ec f2e

wU@tc +LMih| , ahc b.c R5L4i W?|ih?@|L?@* ,_i?Ui L? |T|W?@|L? Ah@_i

gtc 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +ii Sc 2Se

wU@tc +LMih| , ahc b.Sc R,UL?L4i|hU L*U) ,@*@|L?G h| i @h?i}i

+LUit|ih L?uihi?Ui 5ihit L? M*U L*U) c beS

wU@tc +LMih| , ah @?_ @?U) w 5|L!i)c bHc RL?i) @?_ W?|ihit| ? @ @t?

_@?Ui ,UL?L4)c ,UL?L4i|hU@ DDc ebD

wU@tc +LMih| , ah @?_ U@i* `LL_uLh_c bbec R+i@* ,giU|t Lu L?i|@h) 5LU!t ?

@? ,UL?L4) `| 5i^i?|@* hU@titc @?tUhT|c N?iht|) Lu U@}L

wU@tc +LMih| , ahc bbS RL?i|@h) i|h@*|)c LMi* Th3i *iU|hi 4@?tUhT|c N?

iht|) Lu U@}L

@?!c Bhi}Lh)c ,_c bbec L?i|@h) L*U) U@}LG N?iht|) Lu U@}L Thitt

+L4ihc #@_ O @?_ ht|?@ # +L4ihc bbec R`@| ,?_t +iUittL?tq ? 5|@?

*i) 6tUih @?_ a*L a +L|i4Mih}c ,_tc bbe ,+ @UhLiUL?L4Ut ??@*c

@4Mh_}iG WA hittc D.

+L|i4Mih}c a*L a bbe RhUit @?_ |T|G ? ,4ThU@* ?@*)tt @ti_ L? @ 5|U!)

hUi L_i*c `Lh!?} T@Tihc @tt@Uti||t W?t|||i Lu AiU?L*L})

+L|i4Mih} a*L ac bHec R L?i|@h) ,^*Mh4 | Ah@?t@U|L?t Lt|tc aLh?@*

Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) b2c efDH

2H


29/37

+L|i4Mih}c a*L a bH2 R5|U!) hUit ? |i N?|i_ 5|@|itc aLh?@* Lu L*|U@*

,UL?L4) bfc H.2

5@h}i?|c AL4@t ac b.Sc RMtih@|L?@* ,^@*i?Ui Lu @|h@* @?_ N??@|h@* h@|i

AiLhit Lu @UhLiUL?L4Utc aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?L4) He

5@h}i?|c AL4@t ac bHSc +@|L?@* ,TiU|@|L?t @?_ W?@|L?c i vLh!G O@hTih @?_

+L

5@h}i?|c AL4@t ac bH.c @UhLiUL?L4U AiLh)c h*@?_LG U@_i4U hitt

5@h}i?|c AL4@t ac @?_ i* `@**@Uic b.Dc R+@|L?@* ,TiU|@|L?tc |i T|4@* L?

i|@h) W?t|h4i?| @?_ |i T|4@* L?i) 5TT*) +*ic aLh?@* Lu L*|U@* ,UL?

L4) Hc 2eDe

5|hL?}?c 5|ii? bb2 RAi W_i?|U@|L? Lu L?i|@h) L*U) #t|hM@?UitG ,T*@??}

|i w^_|) 33*i 6i_ih@* +itihi @?! Lu U@}L `Lh!?} @Tih `b22.

54tc ht|LTih c bb2c RW?|ihThi|?} |i 4@UhLiUL?L4U |4i tihit u@U|tG Ai

igiU|t Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*U)c ,hLTi@? ,UL?L4U +ii Scb.Dfff

A@)*Lhc aL? c b.bc R,t|4@|L? @?_ L?|hL* Lu @ @UhLiUL?L4U L_i* | +@|L?@*

,TiU|@|L?tc ,UL?L4i|hU@ e.c 2S.2HS

2b


30/37

. TTi?_

At @TTi?_ t44@h3it |i tTiUU@|L? Lu |i 2 @?_ 6i_ih@* 6?_t V+ Thiti?|i_

? 6}hi @?_ |i M@tt Lu @** |i L|ih U@*U*@|L?t 6Lh uh|ih _i|@*tc ?U*_?} |i

*L?} tTiUU@|L? ti@hU |@| *i_ |L |iti RMit| U@ti V+tc t|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc @?_ tL

uLh|c tii LUh@?i Ebbe@ Ai _@|@ @?_ @** ThL}h@4t ti_ ? |t T@Tih @hi @@*@M*i

@ @?L?)4Lt u|T uhL4 u|T?@?Ui}tMUU@}Li_c ? %TM%ULUh@?i%@ht

L| V+t ti ^@h|ih*) _@|@c DbGb2Ge Ai _@|@ ti_ ? |i 2 V+ @hic |

U|M@ti UL_it ? T@hi?|ititc 42 ' *L} 2 E62( g ' ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i E6v66c

^@h|ih*) @ih@}i( U?t ' *L} Lu ?L?_h@M*it n tihUit UL?t4T|L? EB"nB5" n

fSD |4it }Lih?4i?| ThU@tit EBB,"( ) ' *L} B# EB#"( T ' *L} B# _i@|Lh

EB## W h? |i 2 V+ | |L UL?|i}h@|?} iU|Lhtc 42)T @?_ )U W h? |i

V+ ? ihhLh ULhhiU|L? uLh4 | uLh *@}t 6Lh i@4T*i |i ht| *?i t

{62|n ' @f n @E62| +| R| n @2E+| S?r| n

ne

['

K{62|3 ne

['

Ss s|3 ne

['

_{S?r|3 ne

['

e{+|3 ne

['

e{R|3 n 0|n

Ai ihhLht @hi L*it! Lh|L}L?@*3i_ ? |i }i? Lh_ih ,^@*i?|*)c ?L Uhhi?| @h

@M*it LUUh ? |i {62 i^@|L?c Uhhi?| {62 @TTi@t ? |i s si^@|L? @?_ tL uLh|

Ai 4T*ti hitTL?ti u?U|L? }h@Tt |i 4T*i_ hitTL?ti Lu |i *L} *ii*t Lu @** @h@M*it

iUiT| s s

Ai @h@M*it ti_ ? |i ssV+ @hi U ' *L} UL?t4T|L? Lu ?L?_h@M*it n tihUit

EB" n B5"c ) ' *L} Th@|i B#c Lh B# *itt }Lih?4i?| ThU@tit EB#"

BB,"c T ' *L} B# _i@|Lh EB##c UT ' *L} ti?t|i UL44L_|it ThUi ?_i ti_

? ht|@?Lc,Ui?M@4 @?_ ,@?t EbbDc ThL_i_ M) @h*it ,@?tc 4 ' *L} Lu

E6 @?_ g ' ^@h|ih*) @ih@}i Lu ui_ih@* u?_t h@|i E6v66 W h? |i V+ ? *L}

*ii*t | uLh *@}t Ai tLU!t @hi Lh|L}L?@*3i_ ? |i }i? Lh_ih

f


31/37

W?U*_?} }Lih?4i?| ThU@tit @t @MLi i*Tt |L _i?i @ t|@|L?@h) UL?t4T|L?%L|T|

h@|L @?_ i?Ui 4ThLit |i *L?}h? ThLTih|it Lu |i V+t BLih?4i?| ThU@tit

@i ?Uhi@ti_ @t @ t@hi Lu B# Lih |i TLt|@h TihL_ tt}??} fSD Lu }Lih?4i?|

ThU@tit |L UL?t4T|L?c Lh |@!?} |i h@|L Lu UL?t4T|L? |L Th@|i B# hit*|t ?

@ 4Lhi t|@|L?@h) UL?t4T|L?%L|T| h@|L At t @ hi?i4i?|c |i hit*|t @hi ?L|

_h@t|U@**) U@?}i_ u L?i L4|t |i }Lih?4i?| ThU@tit


32/37

6WBN+,5 `WAO AW5

6}hi G Uhvsrqvhv wr prqhwdu| vkrfnv lq wzr YDUv1 Krul}rqwdo d{lv lq |hduv/yduldeohv duh 433-orjv h{fhsw lq shufhqw1 Wrs sdqho= uhvsrqvh wr P5 vkrfnv 1

Erwwrp sdqho= uhvsrqvh wr vkrfnv1 Vhh wkh dsshqgl{ iru ghwdlov rq wkh YDU

vshflfdwlrq dqg hvwlpdwlrq

6}hi 2G P5 dqg rxwsxw uhvsrqvhv iurp P5 YDU ri jxuh 4/ sorwwhg rq vdphvfdoh1

2


33/37

6}hi G Rxwsxw hhfwv ri wzr prqhwdu| h{shulphqwv/ xqghu ydulrxv dvvxpswlrqvderxw wkh hhfwv ri dqwlflsdwhg yv1 xqdqwlflsdwhg prqh|1 Fdofxodwhg iurp P5 YDU1

6}hi eG Odj sro|qrpldo d+O, lqihuuhg iurp p5 lpsxovh0uhvsrqvh ixqfwlrq xvlqjvwlfn| sulfh prgho1 @ sulfh vwlfnlqhvv sdudphwhu1


34/37

6}hi DG Rxwsxw dqg sulfh uhvsrqvhv wr prqhwdu| h{shulphqwv lq vwlfn| sulfhprgho/ xvlqj p5 YDU lpsxovh0uhvsrqvh ixqfwlrq1 Vwlfnlqhvv sdudphwhu @ 3=;1

6}hi SG Rxwsxw hhfwv ri wzr prqhwdu| h{shulphqwv/ xqghu ydulrxv dvvxpswlrqvderxw wkh hhfwv ri dqwlflsdwhg yv1 xqdqwlflsdwhg prqh|1 Fdofxodwhg iurp ihghudo

ixqgv YDU1

e


35/37

6WBN+,5 `WAONA AW5

Aiti @hi i@U|*) |i t@4i }hitc |L| @UUL4T@?)?} U@T|L?t W ?U*_i |i4 ?

U@ti |t uLh4@| t i@tih uLh )L |L Lh! | +iuih |L |i @MLi }hit | U@T|L?t

|L tii U }hi }Lit ihi

D


36/37

S


37/37

What Do VARs Mean Measuring the Output Effect of Monetory Policy

Documents

Transcript of What Do VARs Mean Measuring the Output Effect of Monetory Policy