WESTERN WATER ISSUES Thomas Broderick, American Water NARUC SUBCOMMITTEE ON ACCOUNTING & FINANCE May...
-
Upload
naomi-freeman -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
0
Transcript of WESTERN WATER ISSUES Thomas Broderick, American Water NARUC SUBCOMMITTEE ON ACCOUNTING & FINANCE May...
WESTERN WATER ISSUES
Thomas Broderick, American Water
NARUC SUBCOMMITTEE ON ACCOUNTING & FINANCE
May 6, 2009
2
Water Issues
• Regulated water rates are increasing much faster than general inflation for a number of reasons.
• Statewide single tariffs are a solution to many issues including avoiding large local rate increases driven by large local investment.
• Even though expensive, it’s time to treat available renewable surface water and stop using scarce groundwater.
• There are significant water shortages developing in specific geographies – case study from New Mexico.
• Water conservation is growing in importance.
• Federal stimulus $$$ arriving shortly for water projects – case study from Arizona.
3
U.S. Water Rate Increases Outstrip Overall InflationCumulative % Increase Since 1996
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Year
Per
cen
tag
e In
crea
se
CPI for AllItems
CPI forWater &Sewer
4
Example of Rate Increase Requested - 73%(in a Small Water District)
$49.38
$85.29
$0
$10
$20
$30
$40
$50
$60
$70
$80
$90
Residential monthly bill based on 11,767gallons water use in Tubac, AZ
Current
Proposed
5
Range of Impact of a Single Residential Water Tariff
Presently, eight separate and unique water tariff districts in Arizona-American’s territory.
Approximate changes in revenue requirement by district if a single water tariff was established for residential water customers in 2010:
# residential customers
• Anthem (48%) rate reduction 8,670
• Tubac (47%) rate reduction 588
• Havasu (43%) rate reduction 1,645
• Agua Fria (18%) rate reduction 35,928
• Sun City West (16%) rate reduction 15,434
• Paradise Valley 3% rate increase 4,889
• Mohave 37% rate increase 16,045
• Sun City 136% rate increase 22,935
10
Groundwater Shortage Developing in Clovis, NM
Exhibit CNew Mexico American Water - Clovis District
Total Well Capacity Compared to Maximum and Average Day Demand
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
1992 1994 1997 2000 2002 2005 2008 2011 2013 2016
Year
Mill
ion
Gal
lon
s p
er D
ay
Average Day Demand
Maximum Day Demand
Total Well Capacity
11
Possible Solutions to Groundwater Shortage (Clovis, NM)
• Drill a test well 2000+ feet deep into new aquifer.
• Build an expensive pipeline from the UTE reservoir.
• Curtailment and conservation.
• Continue to rehabilitate agricultural wells into the same depleting aquifer.
12
Water Conservation & Best Management Practices
• Audits & System leak detection
• Meter repair or replacement
• Efficient toilet replacement and rebates
• Landscape conversion rebates and watering restrictions (e.g., time of day)
• Hot water recirculation devices
• Limitations on water features at new developments & water use plan
• Conservation rates
• Plumbing codes for new developments & requirements for retrofit on home resale
• Car wash water recycling
• High water use notification to a customer
• Public awareness
• Many more BMP’s identified
13
Federal Stimulus $$$ for Arsenic Removal in Tubac
• Federal US EPA mandate to reduce arsenic from 50 to 10 parts per billion of drinking water beginning 2006.
• Unsubsidized cost in Tubac, AZ is $2.3 m for 535 customers – significant rate increase.
• Company sought an exemption on economic hardship – denied – must comply in 2010.
• Recent application for federal grant via Arizona’s state revolving fund.
• Preliminary approval for $1.15 m forgivable principle – cuts rate impact in half.
14
ABOUT AMERICAN WATER
• Founded in 1886.
• Regulated operations in 20 states with more than 7,000 employees serving approximately 15 million people.
• Headquartered in NJ just east of Philadelphia.
• USA’s largest private investor owned water & wastewater utility.
• Publicly traded again since 2008 on NYSE symbol AWK.