Webley, Qualitative Approaches to Empirical Legal Research

8/3/2019 Webley, Qualitative Approaches to Empirical Legal Research

1/21

"&%%'!!#$%!#

#$#

8,0-0

3974/:.943,3/,.74:3/

":,9,9;07080,7.2094/8,7041903/03910/99084.,8.03.08,3/

:2,390824700307,9,3990/8.53041,35,79.:,7%,98349948,9,9,078/43492,0:80416:,9,9;07080,7.2094/8390743

57,.9.0,3.42243,57,.9943078,70:3,,709,990:3/079,06:,9,9;00257.,0,7080,7.43,70:,7-,8890.,80-,80/2094/41089,-8390

,974:,3,8841570.0/039831,.9,1472416:,9,9;07080,7.:83

/4.:20398,884:7.02,907,:96:,9,9;00257.,0,7080,7.4081,7

-043/983/417080,7.%8,590734914.:843.42243,0,

,3,8841.,808-:93890,/574;/0,3389394/11070396:,9,9;02094/82,341.,;0-003:80/389:/080,233504508507.0594341,,3/

:89.08001470,2500338!,9894:89.089:/,07.039

3907,.94388001470,250$,7,9,3/089307889:/41/;47.0,078,3/907

.0398,9073,9;0/85:907084:94320.,3828,3/90770,943859

900,889028001470,250,;809,889:/41901,220/,9430,,/

54933,3/,3/,08,3/3,,3/70,9-,9.84-807;,94341

1,220/,943808843803/07900,574108843,3/574108843,

/03991470,250:11,3/0-0889:/41420384.9478,3/.,7007-70,8

,3/0,,/,3/,..08894:89.08001470,2504470,/09,889:/410,,/24/08,3/6:,9410,807;.0/0;07

92,-0051:94-039,-,8./013943416:,9,9;07080,7.7,3/078:0899,96:,9,9;07080,7.

1:3/,2039, /0503/8 43 ,9.3 50450 3 907 43 9077947 ,3/

3907,.939902390743,3:,04390743907288/03910/

9 84.44 .:9:7, ,3974544 ,3/ 549., 8.03.0 ,243 4907

/8.5308 6:,9,9;0 7080,7. ,8 -003 8003 94 -0 3,9:7,89.

09347,5.,3/5,79.5,947

3,9:7,89.7,3/0720,39,9907080,7.8.43/:.90/3983,9:7,

.43909419039010/7,9079,33,303;7432039.43897:.90/-907080,7.0709347,5.9020,3489.3,3,3974544.,80380,3/-5,79.5,947

9020,39,9907080,7.8:-0.95,8,3,.9;05,79390574.088%0,9907840;07,.4390890/5439,808,0,230,907390,5907030

.438/07,3,884197,.08/4.:20398.43897:.90/-948049079,3907080,7.07147,3437080,7.5:754808:.,8,20/,70547947,54./4.:2039

":,9,9;0,5574,.08,70/893.917426:,399,9;0430839,9

%0.3.,,6:,9,9;04-807;,943/03910890570803.047,-803.041

8420933.4397,89946:,399,9;04-807;,943.3;4;0820,8:7390

/070094.842010,9:70857080397,3/07


2/21

43806:0396:,9,9;07080,7./408349/0503/4389,989.,6:,391.,943-:9,990259894.,59:70,3/.,9047084.,5034203,,3/90720,338,:0709,

05,39,9

30 300/8 94 ,;0 , 34943 41 6:,9,9;0 /893.9438 -09003 84.,

.,904708 -01470 430 .,3 20,8:70 4 2,3 50450 -043 94 430 47 90

4907 .,9047 1 430 ,398 94 34 90 .44:7 /897-:943 3 , 10/ 41140784301789300/894089,-89080941.44:789,9,7039010/903

430.,389,79.4:393901407841,5,79.:,7.44:7%08,20897:0147

84.,1,.98

983495488-09420,8:70901706:03.41,84.,1,.9:399,8-003/03910/

,3//0130/

36:,9,9;07080,7.90/,9,,70:8:,.40.90/974:97002,3

2094/8:80/83473.42-3,943/70.94-807;,9433/0593907;08,3/,3,8841/4.:20398147,/8.:8843800,!:3.

47!,9943%0/,9,2,9,0,3:2-07411472892,3.:/034908

2,/0-907080,7.079,9574;/0,/09,0//08.7594341,9070,3/4

50450//,990//9073907,.9438574.0880809.47,/08.759434190

7080,7.0784-807;,9438,3/70,.943894909-,80/84:7.0884:3/8;/0447

2,08,9,2,,84-0390147241,97,38.75947;07-,926:490841,9,8

8,/-907080,7.5,79.5,398,3/907080,7.0747,9,879903390909

84:7.089,98080,23343806:039/,9,2,-0/07;0/1742907080,7.

5,79.5,398479098,3/2,08/70.93901472416:490847;,907080,7.07

3901472418470770,.9439447:3/0789,3/341,9,88,/4779903

%070,7028.43.059438,-4:9036:,9,9;0,3/6:,399,9;07080,7.

,3//110703924/0841/,9,.40.943939480,5574,.0884:/-0:80/$420

,;0,7:0/9,96:,9,9;02094/884:/-0:80/1470547,9477080,7.

7080,7.9,98/0830/940,2300907,388:089:,94347574-020898,3/

18494/01309,3/6:,399,9;07080,7.2094/814705,3,9477080,7.7080,7./0830/94/0907230474,388:089:,94347574-028,898-:99,9

-4995082,-0:80/147/08.759;089:/087080,7./0830/94/08.7-0,388:0

89:,943574-024780941,999:/08%0807:08.439,3,30020394197:939,9

/110703914728417080,7./083,3//1107039/,9,.40.9432094/803/

90280;08247070,/94/11070399508417080,7.6:08943:9907:08,70-

3420,38/090723,9;0985488-094:806:,9,9;07080,7.1470547,947

05,3,947,3//08.759;07080,7.,3/94/7,.,:8,310703.08174290/,9,

,88:2341.4:7809,9907080,7.07/0;0458,3,557457,907080,7./083,3/

,/4598,3,557457,90/,9,.40.9432094/,3/24/0841/,9,,3,88347/0794,3807907080,7.6:0894385480/08,.438/070,.419080,907390

,5907

%0/8.:88439,9144888:-/;/0/394880.9438%0178980.943

.438/07890904709.,.43909,3//0;0452039416:,9,9;07080,7.9,8349

-0035488-09444,9,3419088:083/09,4794;03/059,3807894,

90904709.,.79.828416:,9,9;02094/8%080.43/80.943574;/08,-701

4;07;041,850.98416:,9,9;07080,7./0833.:/38,253;,/9,3/

/0503/,-9%097/80.9430,2308,7,3041/,9,.40.9432094/8

02540/36:,9,9;00257.,0,7080,7.,3/9014:7980.9434:93089700

024/0841/,9,,3,88.,88.,.439039,3,88/8.4:780,3,88,3/


3/21

74:3/0/90472094/%011980.943574;/08,.,8089:/94:897,902,3419090208/8.:880/390570;4:880.943817427080,7./083947080,7.2094/

,3//,9,,3,88%013,80.9434110788420.43.:8438,-4:96:,9,9;07080,7.390.43909410257.,0,89:/08

":,9,9;0#080,7.88:259438,3/%04709.,&3/075333

98/11.:994574;/0,570.8047/0,..0590//013943416:,9,9;07080,7.

,3/909047:3/0753339-0.,:80842:.41909077,38.4390890/4897080,7.0784.43/:.96:,9,9;07080,7.4:/,7009,99884.,.43.0730/

0,23085034203,390784.,809938110/478-03:3/079,03,3/.438/07894805034203,3.43909$420,7:09,905890244.,,3/

43944.,/110703.08,70,9900,794190/;/0-090036:,9,9;0,3/6:,399,9;07080,7.,3/,84,9900,794190/013943,/11.:9089390

6:,9,9;07080,7.907,9:7058902444308:3/0789,3/341903,9:7041

340/0,3/439444308:3/0789,3/341903,9:7041-034770,98

907043070,94780;07,47/4080,.507843.43897:.99074370,9,110.990,3.430.43/:.987080,7.390757098/,9,,3/705479813/38%094

2094/44.,97,/9438708943/110703905890244086:,399,9;02094/8,70

41903,884.,90/9/0/:.9;070,843306:,9,9;02094/841903700,;

433/:.9;070,84330/:.9;070,84338-,80/43,0307,54908085480/

-01470/,9,.40.943-038070,83/:.9;070,8433800894/07;00307,

90208475,990738174290/,9,.40.90/,8907080,7.574708808:90;039480

0307,,9438,7034994:9907574-028

%014.:8416:,399,9;07080,7.078437474:8/,9,.40.943,3/24/0841

/,9,,3,8885747088;0-035.0/:5-6:,9,9;07080,7.0783903943

3.70,8390,..059,-9416:,9,9;07080,7.13/38:9/0859090

82,7908-090036:,399,9;07080,7.,3/,90,8984206:,9,9;07080,7.90

-,88:543.:/20398,702,/03909497,/943870850.9;0841903;00/,8-03;07/1107039,35:706:,399,9;07080,7.078,7:09,9

6:,399,9;07080,7.036:7083944-807;,-020,8:7,-03/0503/0391,.98070,8

2,35:706:,9,9;07080,7.078,7:09,990036:7039484.,.43897:.90/

1,.989,9/4349,;03/0503/03.0-043/9020,33,8.7-0/94902-50450

%8,8-00305,30/,8,34-0.9;08:-0.9;0/;/04739072841,/893.943

-090035489;89,3/3905709;8947.43897:.9;8905890244.,,5574,.08

40;079070,704907,894.,90470,3//030,90/11070391472841

6:,9,9;07080,7.!,9943.574;/08,3097020.785,3/:801:8:22,7419080,3/,.4:9308902,35439841/05,79:7014790

;,74:824/08416:,9,9;0036:7!489;82.438/07850450,890574/:.984190703;7432039,3/907080,7.07,990259894-0,34-0.9;04-807;07%0

7080,7.070,23089003;7432039,3/50450870,.943894984,894:3/0789,3/9003;74320391,7-0990739075709;82,84.438/07850450,890574/:.9841

90703;7432039-:9,//943,,894804.43897:.99003;7432039974:907:3/0789,3/38419#080,7.0781742903905709;8997,/943,702470

3.30/9414.:843,33/;/:,8330747/907:3/0789,3/3419047/,3/

,88:.,70088.43.0730/,-4:97080,7.074-0.9;9,890-00;09,90,

.43897:.94:74370,9


4/21

74,/7080,7.078,;0903/0/94/;/039443041947080,7.97,/94385489;82,3/39075709;82!489;82,8903/0/94-030/946:,399,9;0

7080,7.,3/3905709;82946:,9,9;07080,7.,94:907083430.088,73-0900339075709;82,3/6:,9,9;07080,7.,3/3/00/9070,706:,9,9;0

7080,7.078,8/8.:880/,-4;04:3/079,07080,7.1742,5489;8989,3/5439

304,30,3/'07-,1470,250,550,794-02470.480

,884.,90/9905489;89.43.05943416:,9,9;07080,7.9,39039075709;89304190/11.:90841335489;82946:,399,9;07080,7.,3/39075709;82

946:,9,9;07080,7.89,992,8:0899,96:,399,9;0/,9,850,147

90280;08-0.,:8090,704-0.9;0,3/9,96:,9,9;0/,9,706:7039075709,943

,3/,.414-0.9;9,3/9:8;,/9":,399,9;0/,9,89,989.,/,9,706:70

:2,339075709,94394;090220,3380079076:,9,9;0/,9,

84209208300/94-06:,3910/94574;/08420:3/0789,3/34141706:039

5,79.:,790208020709390/,9,

,9:7,8.03.0874:3/0/35489;82,3/7080,7.074-0.9;9,3/84.,

8.03.07080,7.,82:.3.422439903,9:7,8.03.0839870,7/

:7025708.7-0817899,9,88:25943884:/349-02,/03,/;,3.04190

7080,7.574.088,3/,570.43.05943884:/-0/8.,7/0/$0.43/0895:,9089,9905034203,94-03;089,90/,3/90,9084:/-00,230/2:89-0

/0907230/-01470907080,7.8:3/079,03-:9,1907570;4:87080,7.13/38,;0

-003.438/070/0.,289,9907080,7.574.08884:/-04-0.9;039080380

41-03;,:030:97,,3/.,5,-04170;0,39097:9,-4:9,;03574548943

%8830053990549088908936:,399,9;097,/943384.,8.03.0

7080,7..870/4039413,9:7,8.03.0$4206:,9,9;07080,7.078,/07094

9080903098,3/9:8.438/079,91/4300-496:,9,9;0,3/6:,399,9;0

14728417080,7..,3-088902,9.,3/574/:.0;,//0503/,-013/383

04,30,3/'07-,,7:09,96:,9,9;07080,7.8:89,8.,5,-0,86:,399,9;07080,7.41574/:.3;,//08.759;0,3/.,:8,310703.08-49-03

:3/075330/-908,204.41310703.00;0394:90948908,3/90.36:08

417080,7.2,-0/1107039

40;077080,7.078,0/9439075709;82,7:09,95489;89,5574,.08

947080,7.2,1,8479039.420894:3/0789,3/3,3/70;0,390,07841

84.,20,33,3/.439099,9:3/075384.,-0,;47,3/57,.9.08.39:73

574/:.0,3/70574/:.0897:.9:7,70,94384;07920%02094/41:3/0789,3/3

50450820,330907989020,339,990,99,.9490743,.943847

9020,3390,99,.944907504508,.9438,0-07.,0/;07890030

.438/070/9894-0902094/9,9,84.,8.03.0884:/144,36:,9,9;02094/8/7,:54398:3/0789,3/34184.,7080,7.:9150450

.43897:.99074320,33070/4089,90,;0907080,7.074800894:3/0789,3/4907820,33841,3/,7:089,99074041,6:,9,9;0

7080,7.0783499439070.9430843;0-:93890,/94/08.7-0,..:7,90,349078050703.084,8940.9,9907080,7.5,79.5,39-00;0847

:3/0789,3/8,3/94574;/06:4908,80;/03.07,9079,394:/0974:430843038,99,95078432:899347100%8706:708025,97,9079,3

/89,3.00;0319,9025,984:/-0/07;0/1742,5,.04130:97,9!,9943

.430/9057,80025,9.30:97,9$420,7:09,9897553,,90

.439093,3,99025994,.0;04-0.9;92,31,.9:3/07230907080,7.90

,3,88,3/9013/388001470,2504:7/0:,3/4112,3

,9/4089,920,3357,.9.0920,389,9347/079470,0,73174249078


5/21

4302,300/943907,.999027,9079,394702,303970/89,3.0/%07080,7.07.40.98/,9,-,41/08.7-3,980,80,7/47930880/3,

30:97,,,3/94:9507843,:/203933905709;897080,7.074:/,7:09,907,3,88,,87010.9074317,20417010703.0-0.,:80344308

.,5,-041-034-0.9;0,20,33-0384.,.43897:.90/$04:/,7:0

9,994/0398894/0390455479:39147907080,7.0794:3.4;07,3/94

.796:00743:3/0789,3/3.8,325479,395,794139075709;897080,7.

39070893,9908,20920,86:,9,9;07080,7.,8-0.4202470

.4250,3//;/0/398904709.,:3/0753338,3/:3/0789,3/38,088

.0,7904709.,/0130/2094/416:,9,9;07080,7.,8-0.4203.70,83

545:,7,3/,550,7894,550,947080,7.0781742/110703997,/9438%88343,874:3/0/9047%074:3/0/90477080,7.2094/800894.40.9,3/

,3,0/,9,38:.,,84,8940307,9090471742/,9,84:7.08:83,.4389,39.425,7,9;02094/9706:708907080,7.079470;8907/08.75943841

5034203,940,230090790,;0.4393:0/;,/947300/,203/2039%0

2094/,550,7894-0-74,/5489;89398:3/075333840;0790,3

.907080,7.07097,.98/,9,174290/,9,84:7.08,550,7894,;024703

.42243939075709;82,90,8939057,.9.04184207080,7.078,8/8.:880/-0474:3/0/90479:8,550,7894879,74:3/2,34190904709.,/0-,908

4305890244,94:90,70//03:3/07908:71,.0

#080,7.083

#080,7./0838,1:3/,2039,25479,391,.9473,37080,7.5740.93.:/3

6:,9,9;089:/0840;077080,7./0832,300/94-0247010-0,3/

,/,59;094.,33.7.:289,3.08,3/:3/0789,3/38037080,7.8.43/:.90/3

89:1470,250034-807;3,20/,9432009347,.039200939,3

5,.03,84.9478411.03/083907286:,9,9;07080,7.:314/89/0;0458

,8907080,7.070,73824703490747/890050720398349:8:,809:5,3/

903,40/947:3,43,570/0907230/.4:7803890,/907080,7.2,-070/0830/942009.,33.43/9438507.059438,3/13/38%820,389,990

7080,7./0832,-070,9;01:/905,7,209078419089:/,3/90,5574,.

,3/2094/8,/4590/2,,;094-0,203/0/94,..4224/,90,9070/

:3/0789,3/38,3/.,33/3,2.811070397080,7.07802-7,.08:..,30

2470470883$420.438/07,1:/2094/94-0,5489;0-030193/.,93907085438;0308841907080,7.,3/907080,7.070490782,

050703.07835,3.9,990,7048390775439089:/

%070,701;0-,8.,850.9841/0833,6:,9,9;00257.,7080,7.89:/

43.0907080,7.07,817,20/906:0894394-05480/3907080,7.78990

7080,7.07300/894/0907230902094/449,98902489,557457,9094,3807

906:0894393,3.43897,3988:.,8290/,..08894/,9,09.,

.438/07,943809.7080,7.07.438/070907,.,8089:/2094/8:7;08

,3/3907;085,79.5,394-807;,943,3/09347,5/4.:2039,7,3,8847,

.42-3,943418:.2094/88094,3807906:0894324890110.9;0,9,

2,-00307,90/-0,233/4.:203989,9,70,70,/308903.0974:3907;097,38.7598974:,:/447;8:,70.47/38475.9:708974:

4-807;,9433490847974:8:7;03897:2039847,3:2-074184:7.083.42-3,943$0.43/907080,7.07300/94.438/07494800.9077080,7.

8:-0.9847/4.:20398,3/42,394800.930053990/,9,.40.943


6/21

2094/89,980,8.480394,/459%097/,850.9.43.0738490/,9,,7094-0,3,0/907080,7.07:80,74:3/0/90472094/.439039,3,88

/8.4:780,3,88902,9..4/38947.,473:89.,3,884789,989.,,3,8898-0/430:83503,3/5,50747990,/41,.425:9074:79

09.,.438/07,94382:89-0,99014701743941907080,7.07823/,8901789

7:08949794/434,72945,79.5,398,3/15488-094/4842044/3,

907080,7.072,300/949,0394,..4:39090790,70473,430473,90,2,8982,,;0,325,.943;,74:8,850.9841907080,7./083347/0794

,3807907080,7.6:08943,81:,3/70,-,85488-09825479,399,9,

1;0,850.98/4;09,,3/,7039:3090,.4907

%070,70,3:2-07417080,7.897,90083.:/305072039830257.,0,7080,7.9080419039,09014724182:,90/89:,94388947.,

,3,8083907;08,3/8:7;08:80/94/0907230;08,3/507.059438.,8089:/08/4.:2039,7,3,88..4:/3.:/08947.,,3,88,3/,3,88

417080,7.070307,90/4709,3989,989.88:.,8.489-03019,3,8089430920

9,894:99,95,79.:,7950841/,9,0702470,557457,90147/11070399508

417080,7.6:089436:,9,9;0/,9,,894:92470:801:9024700547,947

907080,7.06:,399,9;0/,9,,894:92470:801:902470/08.759;04705,3,947907080,7.!,79.:,77080,7.2094/8-0.,20,0/95,79.:,7

950841036:73907;08,3/.,8089:/08-0.,2030/90547,947

7080,7.,3/050720398,3/8:7;089/08.759;0,3/05,3,9477080,7.3

,7:089,94;079209080,88:259438,;0-003705,.0/-,2470

3:,3.0/,5570.,943419070,9;0207984190/11070397080,7.897,9008,3/

7080,7.2094/80,7:089,9247025479,399,390950417080,7.-03

:3/079,0389019-0900390897,90.,8089:/,7.;,,3,888:7;009.

90147241907080,7.6:089434,907003409.0907

907080,7.14.:80843.43902547,7478947.,0;0398,3/0907907080,7.07300/894,;0.439744;075,79.5,39-0,;47470;039847-.4397,8984507,93

3,3,9:7,89.809933.,.41.4397454808101,3574-028

0333/.,9089,984207080,7.0782,.438/07,6:,398,3/.2470,557457,90.42-336:,9,9;00547,947471440/-,6:,399,9;08:7;0.89031440/:593/0593907;087907

.438/0789,992,-0:801:94:3/079,06:,9,9;07080,7.,19076:,399,9;07080,7.849,9903:,3.0841,3/20.,3828:3/07390902089,9,;0

02070//:73906:,399,9;05,802,-00,230/32470/09,

$,253

7080,7.078300/94.438/0742943907;047,9944-807;047,3,0

,3/42,35,79.5,39847/,9,84:7.08,7030.088,7940.913/383.

4302,,;0.431/03.03490747/8,8907080,7.073907;00/,8:11.039

3:2-074150450474-807;0/8:11.039389,3.08347/0794.,59:70,850.97:241;054398,3/050703.08,3/94-0,-09470547913/389,9705479903:,3.0841050703.07,9079,3,3,774507850.9;08,7:0419:2-6:,399,9;02094/8

700,;4390.40.94341,706:,3990841/,9,1742,303970545:,94347,7,3/4247705708039,9;08,2503,88902,9.1,843$:./,9,,70,3,0/

89,989.,849,9.43.:84382,-0/7,394574;047/8574;0430472470/0130/5490808190/,9,/4349.4;07,303970545:,9439825479,399,9

90,701742,8:11.039,70,3/705708039,9;0477,3/428,250419,9545:,9431907080,7.0780894,7:09,9.43.:8438.,3-0/7,3174290


7/21

/,9,,-4:99003970545:,943%88,9549.,45343548,703903/0/94/4!4890784509,9-800.93,705708039,9;0477,3/428,2504190

545:,943413907089,83708543/0398.,701:47/0/:3,2-:4:86:0894383,.43889039,,3/,3,839,9/,9,:83,557457,9089,989.,90.36:08

90-0,-0940307,0949003970545:,943413907089":,399,9;089:/08

9,9,;0-0030/0830/,3/000.:90/84:/574/:.013/389,9,70

0307,,-09490545:,9431,3,557457,908,250,8-003/7,317429,9545:,943800,.

3.4397,896:,9,9;07080,7.903/89414.:843,82,073:2-07414-807;,943847/,9,84:7.08090750450470;039847/4.:20398.,70

.438/070/94-0/,9,7.,3/9:84794189:/,3/940,2309023/059%070,70;,74:88,25390.36:089,92,-002540/$4206:,9,9;0

7080,7.0782,,/459;07843841705708039,9;0477,3/428,253:80/-6:,399,9;07080,7.07890782,,/459,33903943,897,910/8,2532094/

3.90038:709,9907080,7.8,2503.:/08147389,3.05045047

/4.:2039830.,904708470,2501907080,7..43.073890;08410,

574108843,8908,2502,3.:/0,.079,33:2-0741:/08,.079,33:2-0741

,/;4.,908,3/,.079,33:2-074197,38,.943,,078347/0794.,59:70,1:7,3041;08,2430,574108843,8%07080,7.072,459147,834-,

8,25390.36:020,339,980-039,74:5417080,7.5,79.5,398

343940747490780/03910/3,/;,3.038420,,3/903,80,.94

574;/0/09,84184204300804290.438/0794-0,44/7080,7.8:-0.9147

905:754808419089:/,3/39,9,7,/:,-:/:5,,7078,25041

5,79.5,3989073,9;0907080,7.072,8004:9050450470;03989,9,70

094574;/07.84:7.084131472,94347/,9,!,9943/08.7-0898,8

5:754801:8,253

":,9,9;07080,7.078,70349:8:,.43.0730/9,990805045047

89:,943884:/-089,989.,705708039,9;0-0.,:8090/43498009470,.

13/389,9,700307,,-094,303970545:,9433890,/14.:80/3/059

89:/08,70/0830/944-043//08.759439413/20,330;0319,920,338

70,90/94,33/;/:,8050703.084190:89.088902147389,3.04790

507.05943841,82,3:2-07415045043,..08894:89.0147389,3.03/059

7080,7.,1147/8907080,7.0790455479:39940,7347080,7.5,79.5,398

:3/0789,3/9047/,3/3907,.990,.49070/0830/89:/:8:,

,84574;/013/389,9.,59:70,-74,/7,3041050703.087,9079,394801742

43,10504504789:,9438%013/38-0705708039,9;03908038041

.,59:73907,3047;,7,9433,503420343-:93493908038041,43147900892,9434190/897-:9434190503420343390545:,943,8,40%0

0903994.907080,7.0797:0989475898,.0398050703.0841906:,9419047:3/079,03-90784.94788004470,/09,

/0503/94,70,90903943907080,7.2094/02540/907479.9800.:90/,3/,84430805890244.,507850.9;03.0,,319089:/,8

-0030/0830/,3/000.:90/9039013/3884:/-0;,/,3//0503/,-0-:99,9/40834920,39,990-00307,,-0%013/38

84:/574;/0389394,503420343,3/900903994.98570803947

,-8039-:9:306:,399,9;07080,7.6:,9,9;013/387,70574;/0,20,8:70

411706:03.414..:7703.0


8/21

',/970,-9,3//0503/,-9416:,9,9;07080,7.

8/8.:880/,-4;06:,399,9;07080,7.2094/8,;0-003.48030/94903,9:7,8.03.08,3/:/20398,-4:9906:,9417080,7.,;0903/0/94,/45998

507850.9;0',/9,3/70,-9,70-4990728:80/09038;0370850.94189:/089,92,0:80416:,399,9;0/,9,',/98,20,8:7041900903994.

907080,7.07,8.,59:70/,3,..:7,907010.94341,503420343#0,-970107894900903994.9020,8:702039574.0/:70473897:20398:.,8,8:7;0

4:/574/:.0908,20/,9,070994-0,/2389070/,9,/110703992047-84204300807,3/07%,0394090770,-9,3/;,/9

/0907230900903994.907080,7.1/430-842043008047389

/1107039.43/94384:/0,/9482,7/,9,70,-9,3/09079013/38

9,91417429,9/,9,4:/574;/0,3,..:7,907010.9434190503420343

-037080,7.0/;,/9%0907234441;,/9,3/70,-9,70/07;0/

17425489;897,9079,339075709;89.43.05943841/,9,,3//,9,,3,88

39075709;897080,7.078,7:09,99070,708420/11.:9089,5535489;89

39075709,94384170,-9946:,9,9;07080,7..8088.43.0730/9

6:,399,3//897-:943,3/24709504508:3/0789,3/38419020,3341

84.,1,.98

3,//94332:.6:,9,9;07080,7.907080,7.07890/,9,.40.943

944,80,8904304,3,0890/,9,349077080,7.907080,7.072,

.43897:.9,/,9,.40.9439448:.,8,8:7;0..,59:70890/,9,,94308905

7024;0/1742907080,7.07%00903994.907080,7.078,89,-0,3/

70,-0/,9,.40.943944/0503/8438470797,33,3/050703.084

25479,39,70900903994.808394549072094/942,0

,/:89203983909419054994-07010;0,3/9470547943908970398,3/

0,30880841077080,7.94-0850.1.7,9079,39448005330713/38

,3/94574;/00;/03.038:55479415439894,44907894.0.900903994

.80,8/7,3,..059,-0.43.:84381742900;/03.0#,9079,3:8390

.43.0598;,/9,3/70,-984207080,7.07857010794,8808890/0503/,-9,3/3907984204:/8,97:89479308847900903994.907080,7.,3/9813/38,7017001742-,8416:,9,9;089:/083907284190

6:0894385480/902094/8:80//,9,0307,90/97,3:,94390.42-3,943412094/8,3//,9,950824/0841,3,88,3/0907900;/03.08:55479890

13/38$420,7:09,96:,9,9;07080,7.,82:.940,7317426:,399,9;0.43.059438,3/490788:.,87907,7:09,96:,399,9;07080,7.,8

2:.940,7317426:,9,9;07080,7.40;07-4997,/9438908981476:,9

03.425,88,3,88088203941907080,7./08390/,9,.40.9432094/,3/90

/,9,,3,88347/0794:/0;,/9,3//0503/,-970,-9419013/38

,3/9:8,70088039,82,7%030980.943.438/07/,9,0307,943,3/

.40.9432094/8

'":,9,9;0,9,0307,943,3/40.943094/8

0/4306:,9,9;07080,7.84:/,//944:7:3/0789,3/3413/;/:,8

050703.08,3/-0,;474741897:.9:708,3/47,3,94384741490784.,

5034203,',74:87080,7.2094/88:55479/110703995084113/38

-0.,:80/11070392094/8574;/0/11070393898%880.943.438/0784200/,9,.40.943,3/47/,9,0307,9432094/8.43.0397,934394809,9,70

2470/0:80/36:,9,9;00257.,0,7080,7.$00.94341/,9,.40.943


9/21

2094/88,70/0503/03943907080,7.6:089430,/394907080,7.897,90/0839,9-089198907080,7.4-0.9;0890,;,,-941,..088945,79.:,7

/,9,84:7.08,3/907084:7.08,;,,-094.43/:.99089:/9.,88:08,845,,325479,397403.4.0417080,7.8:-0.9,3/7080,7.2094/%01443

8:-80.943814.:8433/;/:,,3/74:53907;084-807;,943,3/

5,79.5,394-807;,943/4.:2039,3,88,3/.,8089:/7080,7.

3/;/:,,3/74:53907;08

3/;/:,,3/74:53907;08574;/07080,7.0789,..0889449078202470841050703.08,3/507.0594383907;082,-0.43/:.90/1,.0941,.047

702490;,900543047;/0433/;/:,3907;08,70:80/09038;0-

6:,9,9;07080,7.0780,2330,5034203,,3/507.05943841,,3/90

0,5741088438001470,250$42207,/%4739434.:874:5874:5

3907;08,7043041,7,30416:,9,9;0/,9,.40.9432094/89,92,0,/94

-49:801:/,9,,3/97:5,79.5,9473907;0073907;0003907,.94374:58

,70349:89,.43;03039,94,..:2:,90903/;/:,340/041907

202-078%0;0780830789.,943898,3/84:94389,94:/349.420

,-4:994:990274309,%0,70:80/0881706:03930257.,0,7080,7.9,3,703/;/:,3907;08574-,-35,79-0.,:804190

30,9;0.43349,9438,884.,90/9907:803905,79549.,,703,,3/35,79

-0.,:8090,70489.,2470/11.:99447,30,3/706:70,80/1,.9,947147,30,250800:11,3/0-0

$4200307,7:08,55946:,9,9;03907;0847389,3.09084:/

-00907;074480897:.9:70/907080,7.072,2,0:80415742598948900790

/8.:8843974:,807084188:08/0020/25479,39-907080,7.074743

802897:.9:70/907080,7.07,;084208096:08943894,8-:9902,47941

6:089438-0450303/0/7,9079,3.480/190708543/039.4380398

3907;08,700307,9,50/0705488-094,4907080,7.0794,3,090

1:97,38.7593907;08,700970200110.9;0,9,73073/,9,433/;/:,8507.05943847;08,3/439070,8433:3/07390708543808%0,84

574;/0,33893943/;/:,8050703.0840;0790/4349574;/044//,9,43903907;0008-0,;4749079,3-0,;473,33907;080993

-0.,:8041574-0284120247,3/800.9;070.,,;3903907;04-807;0/-,97/5,792,,8889907080,7.0719089:/8940,230-0,;4747

3907,.9438-090037080,7.5,79.5,3983,,3/70,9-,9.

%7/5,79,3/5,79.5,394-807;,943

-807;,9437080,7.817,:992094/44.,,3/09.,/11.:9081

50450349,990,70-034-807;0/903902,.438.4:847

8:-.438.4:8,907907-0,;47343,890,947300110.9:9.4;079

7080,7.54808831.,3909.,574-028$4207080,7.078573.5,

09347,50782,22078090280;083,89:,943147,30903/0/5074/41

008470;0324398470,78,3/005,4:73,9434909074-807;,9438%0

7080,7.072,0;035,79.5,9039003;74320397,9079,34-807;0,8,-89,3/07

%81472417080,7.,890-030199,97080,7.5,79.5,3984;07920-0.420088

,110.90/-7080,7.07570803.0,3/70;079942470:8:,5,99073841-0,;4740;0798,84,7:0/-490789,97080,7./07;0/974:5,79.5,39

4-807;,9432,-09,390/-90,.41.79.,7010.943,309347,5078


10/21

4:/,7:09,9433,9;08,5489;07,9079,3,30,9;04198950417080,7.,890/81,7-09907/,9,,843,8907080,7.07702,387010;080

0,2308.79.,07,88:259438,3/249;080.07,3/00789,90

%02489 .425090 1472 41 9084.44., /,9:2 ,1907 , 8 90 1472 3

.905,79.5,394-807;07,90789,34-807;,94341842084.,0;039

90 0;0398. 570.0/0 ,3/ 144 9 ,3/ 05,3,9438 41 98 20,33-5,79.5,398 ,3/ 850.9,9478 -01470 /:73 ,3/ ,1907 98 4..:7703.0 $:. ,

/,9:2 ;08 :8 2470 31472,943 ,-4:9 90 0;039 :3/07 89:/ 9,3 /,9,

,9070/-,3490784.44.,2094/

3,,7:089,94-807;,943574;/08/,9,9,9.,3349-0.40.90/;,3907;08

3,3089:/9,9/70:5435,79.5,394-807;,9433900257.,

0,,703,844/87080,7.43-,7789078.07844/

9078570107944-807;01742,24703/0503/03989,3/5439,8,34:98/077,9079,3,8,5,79.5,39%81472414-807;,94382470094-00584/.

7,9079,3.4393:4:839,9907080,7.074-807;08,850.1.0;039470;0398147,

70,9;084795074//;4.,90841987080,7.2094/.438/079,99.42-308

8420/89,3.09,0,941455479:390894.40.9.43909:,0/7.

/08.75943419080993,3/6:490817429480-034-807;0/00,,709,8

89:/41/;47.084.947802540/981472414-807;,943,4394907/,9,

.40.9432094/8/8.:880/3/09,-04-807;,9433490880094.,59:7090

/09,41908.03084-807;0/,4397080,7.07507.0594384194808.0308%0

84:/-08:11.039/09,0/94147290-,884170547989,99,09070,/0739490

8.0304-807;0/,3/,424707948,7090050703.0,3/0,7317429,8

2:.,885488-0974:907990347/:9,..088.,3-0/11.:9,3/908

4179310/34908706:708.438/07,-057,.9.080044/$420

7080,7.078.44803890,/949,5070.47/903907,.943,2437080,7.8:-0.98

9.438039,80,8942,04-807;,94334908800$,7,9,3/089307

":,9,9;0/4.:2039,3,88

4.:2039,7,3,88.,3574;/0,0,941/,9,7,33174290411.,9490

507843,90909-,80/,3/902,0-,80/4.:2039,784:7.0849079,3572,70,84:7.088:.,8.,808,3/89,9:908,7070,9;0:3/07:90/3

0257.,0,7080,7.0;0394:90574;/0,7.84:7.041/,9,147,30,2508000-0,349089,9

4.:20398 ,8 90 80/2039,9438 41 84., 57,.9.08 ,;0 90 549039, 9431472,3/897:.9:7090/0.8438.504502,043,/,,3/4307

9072-,8890,84.43899:905,79.:,770,/384184.,0;0398%090

:8 ,-4:9 90,857,9438,3/ 3903943841905074/94.90 70107 ,3/

/08.7-05,.08,3/84.,70,943858,9,9200302,349,;0-003

-473470708253495708039

%0,55,703970:.9,3.0410257.,0,7080,7.07894:803430,/4.:20398,8

84:7.0841/,9,2,35,79-005,30/-902,3/11073.43.05943841,9.43899:908,557457,902094/,3/,-4:99070,3.09,9.,3-05,.0/43

/4.:20398,884:7.0841/,9,92,,843/.,909,97080,7.078,;034914:3//4.:203989,990.438/07:801:/,9,84:7.08147907080,7.


11/21

%070,702,3,5574,.0894/4.:2039,3,88,3/9070838:11.03985,.094/8.:88902070%024/041,3,8890,3./,9,,70097,.90/

174290/4.:2039835,79/0503/43903,9:704190/4.:203981470,250090790,701472,.422:3.,9438.,80705479808,9433085,507,79.08

4754./4.:203984731472,.422:3.,943884.947103490857;,90099078

09.$4207080,7.0782,.438/0790.4390993.90/4.:20398070

79903,3/9073903/0/,:/03.090782,0,230908:-89,3.04190/4.:2039-:934998.43909$4207080,7.078,;0/0;0450/,.0.8941

6:0894389,990-00;0907080,7.0784:/,8-01470/4.:20398472,08,70

800.90/70;00/,3/,3,0/8001470,250330,388941096:089438

4.:2039,7,3,88,8-003.79.0/43,3:2-074174:3/8$420

,7:09,9/4.:20398,703498:8.059-0948.0391.88902,9.,3,883005395489;8997,/9438%4,909039.,3430/7,.43.:843817429080

/4.:20398478420/4.:203987010.94770547970,9/08.7-3,30;039,

507.0594347,3:3/0789,3/3,3,9073,9;0;089,9

/4.:203987057080399057,.9.,706:7020398147.90070.70,90/473

490747/8905:754804190/4.:203997/.43.0594389,9/4.:20398/434970547984.,70,9,88:.-:9,70,84:7.04120,338034:904:743

.:9:7,:3/0789,3/3347/079403,0920,338.,7002-0//0/

390/4.:20399801,%8.43.05943706:708907080,7.0794

0.99020,33419047/8,8:80/390/4.:20397,9079,394:8090

7080,7.07843:3/0789,3/3419047/8,3/90720,33840;0798

,5574,..,30,/9490.43.:8439,990/4.:203970570803983493-:990

47/8,3/20,338939472,37080,7.078/4.:20398574;/00;/03.041

54./70.943808,9;039039:3/0789,3/3841507.0;0/8479.423847-089

57,.9.03900,88902,3/,03/,147.,308004.147,/8.:8843

,8089:/08

%0.,8089:/2,-00907,3:2-70,897,909,9.42-308,7,3041/,9,147

0,2508:7;0/,9,3907;08/4.:2039,7478947.,,3,8847,/893.92094/41:3/079,37080,7.3/08.7-08,.,8089:/,8,30257.,89:/

9,93;089,908,.43902547,7503420343939870,10.439090850.,0390-4:3/,708-0900390503420343,3/.43909,70349.0,70;/039

.,8089:/2,:8009076:,9,9;0476:,399,9;02094/847-493,7:089,9.,8089:/08.42039700950805,3,9470547,947,3/

/08.759;00.438/0789,990,70-089:80/94,38074,3/6:089438

974:3/059,3,884143089:,9430;039474.,943%0,70:801:0390

7080,7.07,8990.439744;079089:,9439,98080894390774,904703

907080,7.07808949089,5490889,9,8-003-,80/43,-74,/,..0590/

904700390904709.,:3/075333419054908883499801908:-0.94190036:7:9.,8089:/08,701,71742,30,84594394:434300;03947.,804747,3,9434789:,9432,-0.438/070/92:89-0

0,230/370,9/09,70343,82,3/,9,84:7.08,85488-0%0:8041/1107039/,9,84:7.08.40.90/:83,7,30417080,7.2094/8,88898370/:.3

905488-99,9907080,7.0,/94280,/313/38-,80/43,33.4250905.9:70%0574.08841:832:950/,9,84:7.089470,.074:3/0/

.43.:84388343,897,3:,943%8,//80994,313/38#080,7.0782,.4480940,23024709,34300;03989:,943.,804747,3,943:83,


12/21

.,8089:/1472,9,94:-0.,:80907080,7.2:8914.:83/059430,.43092,-0574-9;0920.438:2394:3/079,0.,8089:/08147,,703:2-0741

89:,9438470;03988003%0830.,8089:/,898744983,3974544070,82:950.,8089:/08,;0-0032470:8:,384.44.,

7080,7.800,2009,.,8089:/7080,7.8/0830/9414.:83

/09,43,;0389:,9437,9079,394574;/013/389,9,700307,,-094

490789:,943840;0792,-05488-09470,.,0307,.43.:843-908939013/3841430.,8089:/-:3/079,3,3490747190850.1..,80

7057080398,93,87010770/94,8,.79.,.,80

%030980.943.438/07970041902,32094/8:80/94,3,090

/,9,0907907080,7.0784310/349084-807;,9434:73,83907;097,38.7598,3/844347/4.:20398/0;0450/-49078

'":,9,9;0#080,7.3,8390,9,,3/

3/30,33

,9,,3,88,3/90/7,341.43.:8438,3/13/38174290/,9,,70,243

902470.4390394:8,850.98416:,9,9;07080,7.4.,3430/07;0;,/,3//0503/,-013/38174270,28414-807;,943349083907;097,38.759847

/4.:2039880805,38

%02489 8074:8,3/ .0397, /11.:9 390 :8041 6:,9,9;0 /,9, 8 9,9

2094/841,3,88 ,7034901472:,90/47 6:,399,9;0/,9, 9070,70.0,7.43;039438907080,7.07.,3:80:990,3,891,.0/9,-,341

6:,9,9;0/,9,,8;0710:/030814757490.943,,389801/0:84309,430 90 5708039,943 41 :370,-0 47 3;,/ .43.:8438 94 8.0391. 47

54.2,3,:/03.084.,30-08:709,9,30,79:3/03,-0

80703/594:813/3834931,.9743

08,.438/07970070,9;0/0:80/24/0841,3,8839880.943.,88.,.439039,3,88/8.4:780,3,88,3/9074:3/0/90472094/

7043.4/3.,8--889,908

3;4;08 /03913 ,3/70.47/3430472470 5,88,0841909474907

/,9,90288:.,8905,798415.9:7089,9384208038000251908,20

904709.,47/08.759;0/0,&8:,80;07,5,88,08,70/03910/,3/90

,7090330/9,3,201479,9/0,90.4/0

:90,.2094/800894/0;045.4/08,3/94:80.4/08389/1107039,8

%080-0/8.:880/-04

,88.,.439039,3,88,88.,.439039,3,888:80/940,230909472,080907/4.:203989,9,;0-003/0;0450/14749075:7548083085,507,79.08.,80705479809.47

7080,7.0307,90/90988:.,83907;097,38.75989898,990.:854190

6:,399,9;0,3/6:,9,9;0/;/039,99419033;4;08902,9..,9047,94347

.4/3,80,8.4:393901706:03.9.94809020847.4/08,550,7

439039,3,88,8/0,55.,9439.,3-0:80/940,230903,9:70,3/

1706:03.415,79.:,79508410,5034203,93570887054798470,.,808


13/21

4794.438/0790.439039413907;084754./4.:20398970/:.0890994.4/08-.,904739028390909,3/903.4:3934..:7703.08419480902894

,4310703.0894-0/7,3174290/4.:203991,.9,908,3,8841439:/3,.,304;079201470,2504:804190907290774789,8.,30/4;07920

3.,80,439039,3,88.,3-0/08.759;0/030,9390.4/08,3/90

70,943858-09003902-:992,,84-0:80/9405,34794/0;045,9047

47904708#080,7.078:83.,88.,.439039,3,887,9079,324706:,9,9;01472841.439039,3,882,-0.,701:94038:709,990,;0/7,3,7,3/4247

705708039,9;08,25041/4.:20398477080,7.5,79.5,398943907;0398

70850.9/7,343906:,399,9;08,25397,/9437,9079,3436:,9,9;0

2094/8%0,84-0.43.0730/9;,/9,3/70,-9390803809,9

948090728,70:80/-6:,399,9;07080,7.078-0.,:80907.4/08:39841

20,8:702039,3/90310703.089,990/7,1742902,70-74,/6:,399,9;03

3,9:70#080,7.078005,.4/0-449,9574;/08,30,.9/09,0//08.75943

410,..4/0347/079403,-0490789470;0907,3,88,3/9470,.:/20398

,-4:990;,/9,3/70,-94190/,9,,3,88,3/13/38

40;078420.439039,3,898,7024703.30/94,7/8,6:,9,9;0

39075709,943,3/2,:805:7548;08,2530886:,391.,943,3/247039075709,9433907/0;045203941.4/08,3/907970,92039419480.4/084/0

800.943,3//0;0452039,70,2,9907417080,7.0739075709,943,3/7080,7.07

:/2039%07080,7.07/0;045,33/041/08.7594789,-089,9

8:22,709008803.04190/08.75943,.4/094,490/,9,94-0.,90470/

%0803/.08,70343,8.4/317,208,3/2,,;024703.42243914728

4174:3/0/90479,36:,86:,399,9;0.,88.,.439039,3,88#080,7.078

70,/90909945:4:90207390208,9902593942,0902,8850.1.,8

5488-0-,3,3490,70:80/9029841907:8090.4390993

.90,550,7,3/84433.090809020884/190-0.420.4/08.2,903-0.4:390/,3/.438/070/370,9438594907.4/08

$4207080,7.0782,.4/0:83503,3/5,5070490782,:80

.425:9078419,708:.,8';4,3/9,894,8889902390747425:907

,88890/,3,882,059488902,90.4/3-:9988970,394390

7080,7.078800.94341.4/08,3/0739075709,943419070,943858-09003

90288:..439039,3,88.,3-0,70,9;088902,90/24/041

6:,9,9;0/,9,,3,88970,9;00/0;0450/7:08418,253800.943

41.4/08,3,88419480.4/08,3/70547934113/3840;079702,38

39075709;0,3/907080,7.072:89-0,-094:891908,2532094/,3/90

;,/94107.4/317,2094,70,907/07009,332,3490714728416:,9,9;0,3,883,//943,8,:07,7:08908:-0.941.439039,3,888

.43903957080393902,907,-03,3,0/7,9079,3,9902,907,/408349

.439,3%07080,7.07.,32,010.,28,-4:92,907,9,9834914:3/390

909-.425,784392,907,9,985708039:308880,8,57475490889,9809089897010703.09490570803.047,-803.0415,79.:,7.439039390

/4.:20398439039,3,88870,3943,70,9;0,70/,9,809.,48907080,7.0794390774,9090.43903941,7,3041/4.:2039894/7,.43.:8438

70,9394,9020479020847,74:54774:588:.,884.947847:/0847

9054.099:814.:80843.40.9;087,9079,33/;/:,88490.4390941

.422:3.,94382,-05,79489030,2339090947902,03

6:08943


14/21

8.4:780,3,88

8.4:780,3,888,03707,9079,3,83024/041/,9,,3,889070,70,3:2-0741,5574,.08:3/0730,990:2-70,90728.4:780,3,8814.:80843

9098,3/0,230890:8041,3:,0839,7,22,75,:808089,9438705099438,3/8443390/8.4:780-0389:/0/98,3097020/09,0/

2094/9,9,3,089090947/-47/5,:80-5,:80.4:53/08.7594390;,:,943390.,80413907;08/8.4:780,3,88700843097,47/3,7

/09,0/97,38.7598.438/0789,99070,7014:72,3902083/8.4:780,3,88,.43.073990/8.4:7809801,;041,3:,0,8

.43897:.9;0,3/.43897:.90/,3025,88:543/8.4:780,8,147241,.943,3/,

.43;.94339070947.,47,3,94341/8.4:78014728419092,-0

,3,0/,3/9890897:.9:704190/8.4:7807,9079,39020,33-03/90

9099,989004-0.94189:/%047,3,9434190909,3/98.439039,7090

8:-0.94190036:7%8147241,3,88/408349,99025994:3.4;074-0.9;0

1,.983/00//8.4:780,3,898;0/8.4:780,884.,.43897:.90/,3/,8,,3

.90850,07477907.,3089,-8,5,79.:,7;07843419047/%82,

800270,9;0897,9147,7/-:99005,3,943414/8.4:780,3,8984

,-4:99074781,72470,24754:8

$420070 -09003 97,38.75943 ,3/ 793 :5 90 08803.0 41 /43

/8.4:780,3,88800289485,,0;070:8;0 9830;076:90.,59:70/- /08.759438 41 .4/3 8.0208 5490808 ,3/ ,3,9., 8.02,9,

40;07:89-0.,:80908841/8.4:780,3,88/434903/90280;0894 574.0/:7, /08.75943 9070 8 34 300/ 147 902 94 -0 /0-07,90

28910/ ,3/ 5,.0/ -043/9070,. 41,-:990 .4348.0398.4:780,3,88882,7942,349079,884:73,8981470,250,70349;03

1472,97,333/03913,92,08,30;039308,3/09,1907,8479920 3 90 574108843 907 80380 41 308 ;,:08 8 ,7/ 94 8,0 %070

70,8348:-899:901470,733-/43

89490714728416:,9,9;0/,9,,3,88/,9,2:89-0.4/0/47.,90470/84

,89470;0,20,338.439,30/9390/,9,%07080,7.0780094/0;045

,-089,9.,59:70/11070395034203,570803939097,38.7593/8.4:780,3,88

907080,7.0780094:3.4;075034203,,8:3/078944/-907080,7.8:-0.9

7,9079,35034203,9,990.,370,/3949097,38.759174290743

050703.08:08989,9.4/384:/-0,84503,3/3.:8;0,85488-03

900,789,08-:94;07920,8/110703.0802070907080,7.0713/5,9907389,9706:7090.4/0894-070130/7094:947700.90/&30.,88.,.439039

,3,898/8.4:780,3,898.438/07,983495708039,80,8,985708039:94/408,7080,7.07349,980,8/0;0450/84:3/.4/08

5,79.:,70380-00;089,9,/8.4:7803.:/307438.43897:.90/

!49907,7:089,9.4/0884:/-08:-0.90/94/0;,39.,80,3,8820,339,9/,9,9,9,550,7894.4397,/.9.4/0884:/-08:-0.994850.,8.7:9384,894

,8889970133.4/0894,70,9070;041850.1.93,//943,94:349

:36:094/8.4:780,3,8892,-0:801:94.0.4907080,7.5,79.5,398

;090,3,88900903994.,90789:/08,;0,700/947,;0/0;,90/

17429013/38,3/900903994.70,/078,;00;,:,90/9089:/,3

/8.4:780,3,8983.:/0909099,990,;0,3,0/,85,794190

5:-.,943574.088849,9490789442,8:-0.9994,3,88#080,7.0782:89

.4389,3970;0907.4/08940,230090790.4/08,..:7,90/08.7-0


15/21

5034203,,8;00/974:900084190850,074779077,9079,3,8;00/1742907080,7.07889,3/5439

74:3/0/90472094/

3005392:.6:,9,9;07080,7.74:3/0/90473;4;08/0;0453

9047,8907080,7.574.00/87,9079,390893,54908854890/3,/;,3.074:3/0/9047,8,3,550,942,36:,9,9;07080,7.078-0.,:8091448903,9:7,5,9907341:2,3036:79,48907080,7.0794800,3:3/0789,3/341

,3,70,-/0;0453,3/70133,9047,8247080,739,-4:990,70,9857,2,9.,3/09904709.,,807,3/$97,:883490747/874:3/0/

9047574;/08,17,204714790407080,7.574.088,3/349825,20,38

41097,.93/,9,98,9047417080,7.,/,9,.40.9432094/,24/041

,3,88,3/,,410307,939047

94:/507,58-0:801:9405,390,.9:,7080,7.574.088-,41

:897,9430089,-80/9047814720/,1907970089,0841,3,88,94:9089,08,7034930.088,7.4380.:9;0,3/907080,7.07.4:/-0

:3/079,3/110703989,0882:9,304:8,880,//82470909847/4.:2039894908,250808,3,3$9,0430894,3,0/4.:203983907;097,38.7598

474-807;,9433490894/8.4;07.43.059:,.,904708174290/,9,-,8..4/08%88/430-70,/3,/4.:203930-30,3/20243,88902,9.147241

34909,35034203,9,9,7025479,3930,.803903.0475,7,7,594.420:5

9.43.0598%07080,7.0784:/3490,3939,98970807,880870,/3

0,.3041909%8408-043//08.7-3,980,870,/,3/3.:/08,3

70,.94389,980,8949090947,3,884.,94389,985739423/%889,08

343,84503.4/3-0.,:804198-70,/9;07920907080,7.0784:/

7013007.43.05989480.43.05989,9.4393:0944/84/,88070,/8974:90

/4.:2039884:/-0059,3/9389,9,703498:89,30/3,907/4.:2039884:/

-0700.90/%07080,7.07.4389,39.425,708,980,814:3/30-30

/4.:2039-/4.:203994038:709,9074-807;,9438,70574/:.3705.,-0.43.05987,9079,34304114-807;,9438

39080.43/.4/35,809070,943858-09003900;072470850.1.

.43.0598,700,230/94574/:.0904709.,.,90470897010703.0949020248

/0;0450/389,0430%88343,890,,.4/389,014301448

$97,:88,3/47-38;0907080,7.07300/894:3/079,0985,80390941

,5,79.:,790473904907,3/,807.79.089889,3/5439,3/.438/078

9,997:074:3/0/9047706:708907080,7.07949,0847070,/174290/,9,7,9079,39739425480,5,79.:,7904709.,,5574,.4390574.088,807

%097/,3/13,89,041/,9,,3,88894:809089,094904709.,.,90470894/0;045,.470.43.059904747.43.:843,.89,041/,9,,3,88

0,/894,070;041,-897,.943174290473,/,9,0.,:804190...,

/083/,9,.4:/-0.40.90/1479080.43//,9,..0,9908,20920,890/,9,174290570;4:8..0,70-03,3,0/%080.4389,39.425,78438.4393:0

:39907080,7.07.438/0789,9341:79077013020398.,3-02,/0-0,233

2470/,9,:393493308,//0/349324708700.90/,3/90904747

.43.:843,8.789,0/74:3/0/9047,3,88870,3943-49,990

7080,7.074-807;08,88070,/8974:90/4.:20398,3/0770,.943894,980

,84-807;0/


16/21

,3.79.828,;0-0030;00/,99074:3/0/9047,5574,.422039,94788:.,803334909,974:3/0/9047434085,79,94

2009390300/841842039075709;897080,7.078-0.,:8074:3/0/90478,574/:.941,30257.,7080,7.0370.80089488902,90907080,7.

574.08894,4147705.,9434113/38,8706:70/-5489;897080,7.9047

033,3/3.4340;0798,88:2089,9907080,7.07

.438/0789,990.470.43.05980,8,-897,.90/39490478,34-0.9;097:99,9,8-003/8.4;070/32:.908,20,,8.8.0391.573.5082,-0

089,-80/390.4397,79074:3/0/90472094/44.,3-0:3/078944/,8

411073,2094/41:3/079,37080,7.,80,8,88902,9.,5574,.94

6:,9,9;0,3,88,897,901477080,7.7,9079,3,82094/940307,902470

5489;8913/380248924/08416:,9,9;0,3,8898-74,/3/:.9;0,3/

9:8800894/7,4:9.43.0598174290/,9,9447,30902,3/9490470902

-:994/4843,897:.9:70/,3/.438/070/1,843

'":,9,9;0#080,7.3!7,.9.0,80$9:/41,070393907,.94383,;47.043909

347/0794:897,908420419088:087,80/3900307,/8.:8843,-4;098

80.943.438/078,6:,9,9;00257.,0,89:/.43/:.90/-00,,7,.0,3

,3/03,7900,,709,%089:/0,230/90474184.94783

/;47.0.,80833,3/,3/,0849078:.89:/083.:/0,;870930,3/

43889:/370,943943,3/,3/,08,3/$,7,9,3/0893078

89:/370,9439490&$00,,709,889:/831472,9;0-0.,:809

:80/,20/2094/394/893.95,808573.5,4-807;,943,3/3907;08

98420/4.:2039,77080,7.,3/.439039,3,8894,3,0903907;0

97,38.7598

%0-,.74:3/949089:/,8,80941,88:259438,-4:984.947

,/;078,7,823/;47.02,9907880023/00/-9020/,54.2,078

,3/549.,38,74:3/905,88,041,30,2,390&3,570;4:889:/08,/0,230/4;073203954.2,078507.05943841,/;078,7,82

974:,6:,9,9;089:/4154./4.:2039808,3/14:3/9080

,88:25943894-0/08570,/,3/31:039,39054.,3/08,9;0,03/,3

90&,990920%070,899088902,9.0;/03.0:3/0753339080

507.059438,3/0990070570;,039,3/07070:,77010770/943549.,,3/

20/,/8.4:780,8000,,709,889:/84:994.438/0709079080

,88:259438,/,30257.,;,/9-0,23390572,7/,9,84:7.090

,3.84.94783907,.90/9907/;47.0.0398,3/9490784.9478974:4-807;,943413907,.9438,3/974:9097,.08419073907,.9438390

147241099078,3/103490843907.,80108%0,84,80/84.94789405,39073907,.9438,3/907,5574,.94.0398,3/94490784.9478

%8,8,2.7489:/0,233904741,8,250413/;/:,

84.9478%07080,7.078:80/,970014/2094/443901789389,3.090

4-807;0/9035,793070;084.9478,947147,/,/,84-807;,9433949,,8

947080,7.0784-807;0/8420419084.947870.47/3,99084.9478//3

/08.759;090728%005,30/9,9%05:754804198007.80,894,.6:70

0;/03.04190-:83088.439093.90,0784507,90/4905747980/

,3/708543/0/9488:08,890,7480,3/90/09,8419073907,.9439.0398%080.43/24/041/,9,.40.943,894.43/:.93907;08


17/21

984.94784070,80/949,,-4:9570800.90/.,808174290-03334190.,8094905708039548943%08084.9478070174214:77043833,3/

,3/,08,3/070.4803174284.94788931,247,8,3,70,4157,.9.0390,$4.09#043,70.947080.,:8041906:,9,9;03,9:70

419089:/,3/908041908,250907080,7.078.4:/349.,29,990

13/38070705708039,9;041,/;47.084.947833,3/,3/,08-:990

7080,7.2094/8/0540/574;/0/,/05941:3/0789,3/39,9.4:/349,;0-003,30/-6:,399,9;02094/8%07,304184.94789,90703907;00/

574;/0/,;,70941050703.089,9070.438/070/94-0705708039,9;041

/11070399508411,2,84.94780;031349705708039,9;036:,399,9;090728

%0/:,,5574,.94/,9,.40.9434-807;,943,3/3907;0830/94.,80108574;/0/,247074:3/0//,9,809,3/24703/05913/389,34:/

,;0-0035488-0:83,8302094/,430%04-807;,943,40/907080,7.07894,9.84.947.0393907,.943-0,;47,80,894050703.0

907473/,%03907;08574;/0/0;/03.04184.947507.059438907

70,8433,3/907,5574,.94.0398,3/94490784.9478%07080,7.078,80/

9084.947945:4:99010574794903907;0,3/949,974:90.,80%0

/8.:88434190.,80108574;/0/389839484.947.039,3/84.94784.9473907,.9438190790549907080,7.078/70:5,8941574259845036:089438

9,9,.90/,8,20,3894-03/8.:88438435,79.:,788:08.90.4:/:80

33907;0384.947894038:709,9031472,943,83492880/,3/09

/8.:88438070349:3/:.47047,50/-903907;0073.0,90/,9,,/

-003.40.90/903907;097,38.7598070,3,0/:83.439039,3,88,3/

:897,9;06:49080703.:/0/390790:54190713/38,80;/03.041,9

90,/4-807;0/,3/0,7/%06:4908,84,49070,/0794800842041907,

/,9,,439070,/079497,;0949084.9478411.0894899907080,7.078

,3/70,..43.:84384190743

00,,709,813/38,;0/4302:.94.,030507;,8;0507.059438

,243,2,0788420,.,/02.8,3/0;0384201,220/,94789,9/;47.0

84.9478,/459,3,/;078,7,5489:70%014:3/9900;/03.041,/;078,7,82

43.423,.748894.,8083.9070,8,30;/03.04154398.473-

43047-49419084.9478,3/98,550,70/94-0/7;03-90.03987,9079,3

473,9317429084.9478%014:3/,50947,410,25084184.9478

574;/357,.9.,8:55479:/,3.0,8889,3.0997/5,7908,8889,3.04;07

,3/,-4;0,94:/-0050.90/41,84.947,.93,8,/;807,3/.,25433

90,/;078,7,5,7,/2$4.9478970/9403.4:7,0907.0398943049,90

-0900390280;08370,94394./703,3/4:804/88:08,3/902890//34903.4:7,0,.425090-70,3.422:3.,9439,94:/,;0,40/90294

,3/090.,803,70850.98%090,214:3/9,91,39384.9478970/949,020,8:7089470/:.0903843-0900390.4:507,9079,3

3.70,809$4.9478//349800903843,8,30110.9;0944947084;0/85:908-09003905,79083,/;47.0.439093,//943987080,7.574;/088420

0;/03.03/.,939,984.947833,3/,3/,08,90,89/4349,990259942,20904:9.420147907.0398,990050380419049075,79,3/4907

39070890/5,790870,7/08841,55.,-00,34728%08013/38//3498:55479

9054.2,078,3/20/,8507.05943841,/;078,7,82,3/574;/0,3

,9073,9;00;/03.0-,80/5.9:7041/;47.057,.9.033,3/,3/,08


18/21

'43.:8438

845098,5907,8:897,90/9070,70,3:2-0741:3/0789,3/3841

6:,9,9;07080,7.7080,7./083,3/897,90902094/89,92,-0,/4590/94:3/079,08:.89:/0890/,9,9,92,-0.40.90/,3/90,83.902,

-0,3,0/,3419080:3/0789,3/38,700/3.42243-6:,9,9;0,3/

6:,399,9;07080,7.0780;0318,253,3/20,8:70841;,/9,3/70,-9/0503/,-92,/1107-09003909497,/943801470.4483,2094/89,3/54394724/041,3,88,7080,7.07300/894.438/07905:7548041

0789:/90,..0889,9802,-0;0394549039,5,79.5,398,3/5,.08900903941077084:7.08907080,7.92017,20903903/0/,:/03.090:8094

.8045089,9907080,7.-05:907;0437080,7.,3/9820,33

,3/0797,33,3/0507980%038084:/.4480,7080,7.897,90,3/,9,9

14817429.88:90/94907080,7.6:08943,3/9089:/8,28

":,9,9;07080,7.85,79.:,744/1470,233090747349,

5,79.:,784.,5034203430898,3/184903,9:70419050342034398088:80147,8808839009039,3//897-:94341,5034203438420939,98-09907

019946:,399,9;07080,7.":,9,9;07080,7.:8:,0/809038;0/,9,2:.419/08.759;039839,89,081742.907080,7.0741903800894/07;0,3

:3/0789,3/34105,990738479020898349:3:8:,94/8.4;079,9430813/38,70,.9:,70,9;024/08938.45013891:":,9,9;089:/082,

349:8:,574;/088902,9.0307,,-013/38-:941903574-0289390

0,88902-08957,.9.03898,3/900110.94154.8198.,343-0

0,230/:833/0596:,9,9;02094/8:89,890.42243,070,73894

:3/0789,3/90,-14.:8343,82,3:2-074125479,39,3/700;,39

570.0/039-0,73.,80884906:,9,9;07080,7.0780984:994:3/0789,3/

3/;/:,8050703.0841,0,20,33,3/90:89.088902,3/907

70,9438599

#010703.08

,:07,5907,88.,4390393,88#0;03

,:07,80,3/:20/8":,9,9;0#080,7.39%092,0

,3/$4:3/!7,.9.,,3/-4443/43%4:8,3/,800$,0

!:-.,9438

0.07,3/007!,79.5,39-807;,943,3/3907;03

425,78433890,/0/":,9,9;0094/44789,3/3;4;02039

990$4.,47/.,4,7,2!:-8355

,.%43":,399,9;0#080,7.390$4.,$.03.0833907,90/

5574,.94#080,7.0830,8:702039,3/$9,989.843/43$,0

!:-.,9438

4.%08947,387,1997,38!!:93,2,3.08907,3.08907

&3;0789!7088

4:7/0:!,3:,0,3/$2-4.!407%4258430/,3/#,243/,3//,284397,38,2-7/0!49!7088

743438,3/::/!$9:,90/43943,3/90:9:7041

0,733/:.,943,#080,7.07


19/21

72,3$4.,#080,7.094/83/0/3147/147/&3;0789!7088

:7088#3900/33974/:.943940/#080,7.90/3

43/43047003,3/&33

,2078,98%8%3,0/$.03.09430308503

&3;0789!7088

,;870930$,3/438$250":,7708049,9438,3/

/:/.,9433;47.0047147/&3;0789!7088$00,5907%0

!,7908'0841:89.05

,;809,439473!:-.:3/0/,20/,9433,#0547994900,$07;.0842288430,$07;.084228843

033,3/3.430/8,3/-4441":,9,9;0#080,7.3/

0/3%4:8,3/,8,$,0!:-83

3,#..4:3983907;08,3/-807;,9438307,3/#

3,0/843909,3/094/3":,9,9;0#080,7.43/43$,0!:-.,9438

3,#,3/70,9-,9.03/480/4478!7023,7#05479

430/,9470393907,.94333,3/,24:79#0;0

:11,3/0-06:,9,3/;07894203$4.9478#080,7.

$9:/'4:20,$4.09#080,7.$9:/$070843/43%0,$4.09

:702%0#:0841$4.44.,094/3/$00.90/%09843

$4.44,3/98094/047700!7088

00,,7,.0,3,3/03,79$,2,078%0;47.047

41$4.9478147/,79!:-83

330,3#&834.:203983#$,58147/,3/':550/8,9,

40.943,3/3,8843/43$,0!:-.,94389/55

44/,7789078078%0,8//0203,3.08907,3.08907

&3;0789!7088

44/,5907$4.40,9347,53#,3,,7,3/%7,;078

0/8%047,3/094/3$4.40,#080,7.,79!:-8355

033!,9894:89.0,94!0450%3-4:943%4,

147/,79!:-83

033,5907,0033,3/!,9894:89.03$,/,,3/!

$.2/90/843/:.93,,3/$4.09#080,7.#010.943843094/8,3/!7,.9.08047,2-7/0&3;0789!708855

--8#3,3":,9,9;0,9,43/43%4:8,3/,8,0

$3,5470$,0!:-.,94389/

//038$4.44,2-7/0!49!7088

#,59078.4:7803,883,:07,80,3/

:20/8":,9,9;0#080,7.39%092,0,3/$4:3/!7,.9.,

,3/-4443/43%4:8,3/,800$,0!:-.,9438


20/21

,807,8.84174:3/0/%0473,8820703.0;847.3

',0,1473,$4.44!7088

,80743897:.9;8974:3/0/%047'44":,9,9;0

$4,1478.:347:2":,9,9;0$4.,#080,7.9956:,9,9;0

7080,7.3091681680392

,807,3/$97,:88%08.4;074174:3/0/%047$97,9008147":,9,9;0#080,7..,4/30

4112,3472841%, !,/05,&3;078941!0338;,3,!7088

:-7:2,3/489033,339075709;0!7,.9.03033

,3/3.430/8,3/-4441":,9,9;0#080,7.3/0/3%4:8,3/,8$,0!:-.,943855

,209:14:7$,3/4793":,9,9;0#080,7.094/8

'4:200-:7!,743/4300$,0!:-.,9438

304,30#,3/'07-,$0833$4.,36:7$.0391.

310703.03":,9,9;0#080,7.!73.0943!73.0943&3;0789!7088

7,3/07#0,-9,3/',/93":,9,9;0#080,7.0;078$,0!:-.,9438

7907%0,9,!:0%0,9:704139075709,9433":,399,9;0

#080,7.207.,34:73,41!49.,$.03.0

790743.:843#080,7.8,088:8308837.04441907,1941$4.40,#080,7.3$,/,,3/!$.2/90/843/:.93

,,3/$4.09#080,7.#010.943843094/8,3/!7,.9.08047,2-7/0&3;0789!708855

08!88:259438,-4:9,0783!4.$9,9020398$:7;041

#00;,39#080,7.443/43%047/,3.047805,792039

41,3/3,3$4.,$0993802439,/8479

,%$4.,#080,7.88:08094/8,3/!7,.9.083/0/3

:.3,2503&3;0789!7088

08":,9,9;0,9,,8,3997,.9;0:8,3.0%0!74-0241

3,88/23897,9;0$.03.0":,7907

08,3/:-072,3":,9,9;0,9,3,883/0/3%4:8,3/

,8,$,0!:-.,9438

4470,/#$0770-0#4078$$077!,907843,3/

42-0707$":,9,3/4893,#0547943904397,.9341;43,2/;.0,3/8889,3.0!4947.%0$9,9430711.0

"!,9943":,9,9;0#080,7.,3/;,:,943094/87/0/3

43/43$,0!:-.,9438

!,99;/03.0,3/!744134.:2039,7#080,7.$420$50.1.!74-028414.:2039,7#080,7.$4.44.,#0;0

!49907#057080393#0,98.4:780#0947.,3/$4.,43897:.943

43/43$,0!:-83


21/21

!:3.3974/:.94394$4.,#080,7.43/43$,0!:-.,94389/

#4-0798$7/07,3/85:9033974/:.943940,3974544

,7243/8479!03:3

$,7,9,3/089307;47.0,078,3/%070398!407

,3/0,333900,!74.088047147/147/&3;0789!7088

$.,3/9%.943,741":,9,9;036:77/0/3%4:8,3/,8,

$,0!:-.,9438

$.499,990741#0.47/4.:2039,7$4:7.083$4.,#080,7.

,2-7/0!49!7088

$42207,/#080,7.3,3/%0478390!74.0880841!74108843,

/0399472,9434:73,41,,3/$4.09

$97,:88,3/47-3,8.841":,9,9;0#080,7.%0.36:08,3/

!74.0/:7081470;045374:3/0/%0473/0/3%4:8,3/,843/43

00$,0!:-.,9438

%4739438843,3.0,3/897:894203,3/900,!74108843

147/147/&3;0789!7088

0-07%0094/444190$4.,$.03.0897,38-$8,3/3.047700!7088

0-0/;078,7,82,3/438038:8%0088,08!74108843,

4/08%7,3829-4:9!74108843,5574,.,3/!74108843,/039994$4.9478

,3/,20/,9478&3/079,3;47.0,99078$43/43

3#,80$9:/#080,7.083,3/094/83/0/3%4:8,3/

,843/4300$,0!:-.,9438

Webley, Qualitative Approaches to Empirical Legal Research

Documents

Transcript of Webley, Qualitative Approaches to Empirical Legal Research