Web viewThe most considered active initiator for the L-lactide ring-opening polymerization is...
Transcript of Web viewThe most considered active initiator for the L-lactide ring-opening polymerization is...
A class seminar on
USE OF POLY (LACTIC ACID) AS PACKAGING MATERIAL FOR
DAIRY INDUSTRY
By
Sushil Koirala
B Tech 4th year
Department of Food Technology
Pokhara Bigyan Tatha Prabidhi Campus
Institute of Science and Technology
Tribhuvan University, Nepal
2015
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
Use of poly (lactic acid) as packaging material for dairy industry
A class seminar submitted to Department of food Technology,Pokhara Bigyan
Tatha Prabidhi Campus,Tribhuvan University.
Sushil Koirala
Department of Food Technology
Pokhara Bigyan Tatha Prabidhi Campus,Pokhara
Institute of Science and Technology
Tribhuvan University, Nepal
April, 2015
ii
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
Tribhuvan University
Institute of Science and technology
Department of Food Technology
Pokhara Bigyan Tatha Prabidhi Campus
Approval LetterThis class seminar entitled Use of Poly (Lactic Acid) as Packaging material for Dairy
Industry presented by Sushil Koirala has been accepted as the partial fulfillment of the
requirement for the B.Tech. Degree in Food Technology.
Seminar Committee
1. Campus Chief…………………………………………………….
Mr.Hari Prasad Khanal, Campus Chief
2. Convenor………………………………………………………….
Mr Ramesh Baral , Lecturer PBPC
3. Commentator……………………………………………………………….
Mr.Prakash Timalsina, Senior Technical Officer at Sujal Dairy and Lecturer, PBPC
Mr.Abhishek Khadka, Lecturer (PBPC) and UNYSAN member.
Date of Submission: 24th Chaitra, 2071
iii
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
Table of Contents
Approval Letter..............................................................................................................iii
Table of Contents...........................................................................................................iv
List of figures.................................................................................................................v
List of plates..................................................................................................................vi
List of Abbreviations.....................................................................................................vii
1. Introduction...............................................................................................................1
1.1 General Introduction.......................................................................................................1
1.2. Commercial viability of PLA..........................................................................................2
1.3 Use of Polylactic acid as a packaging material in dairy industry.....................................3
1.4 Statement of the problem.................................................................................................3
1.5 Objectives of the seminar.................................................................................................4
1.5.1 General objectives.........................................................................................................................4
1.5.2 Specific Objectives.........................................................................................................................4
1.6 Significance of the seminar..............................................................................................5
1.7 Limitations of the work...................................................................................................5
2. Literature review........................................................................................................6
2.1 Poly (Lactic Acid)............................................................................................................6
2.2 Synthesis and Production of Poly (lactic Acid)................................................................7
2.2.2 Lactic acid from Dairy Industry..................................................................................................9
2.2.3 Lactide and PLA production......................................................................................................10
2.2.4 Ring Opening Polymerization....................................................................................................10
2.2.5 Environmental Aspects...............................................................................................................11
2.2.6 Energy requirement in relation to production of PLA.............................................................12
2.3 PLA processing technologies for food applications........................................................12
2.3.1 Extrusion......................................................................................................................................13
iv
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
2.3.2 Injection molding........................................................................................................................13
2.3.3 Thermoforming...........................................................................................................................13
2.4 General Properties of PLA............................................................................................13
2.4.1 Thermal stability of PLA............................................................................................................13
2.4.2 PLA properties............................................................................................................................14
2.4.3 Barrier properties of PLA..........................................................................................................14
2.4.4 Studies on migration from PLA.................................................................................................14
2.4.5 PLA modifications.......................................................................................................................15
2.4.6 Biodegradability nature of PLA.................................................................................................15
2.5 Application of PLA........................................................................................................15
2.5.1 Reference to Dairy Industry.......................................................................................................17
2.6 Quality control of PLA..................................................................................................17
2.7 Pros and Cons of using PLA as Packaging material in Dairy industry.........................17
2.7.1 Pros...............................................................................................................................................17
2.7.2 Cons..............................................................................................................................................18
3. Conclusions..............................................................................................................20
REFERENCES............................................................................................................21
APPENDICES...........................................................................................................................................25
v
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
List of Tables
Table 1: Physical properties of Lactic Acid.........................................................................................8
vi
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
List of figures
Fig 2.1. Polymerization routes to Poly (lactic Acid) showing the formation of lactide and
PLA........................................................................................................................................7
Fig 2.2 General routes of PLA production showing direct polycondensation and ring
opening polymerization..........................................................................................................8
Fig 2.3: Stereo isomers of Lactic acid....................................................................................9
Fig 2.4 Greenhouse gas emissions (kg/ton) for production of various polymers. ..............11
Fig 2.5 Showing the energy requirement comparison of various packaging materials.......12
Fig 2.6: Some commercial PLA products............................................................................16
v
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
List of plates
Plate 1 Showing general process of PLA yoghurt cup manufacture from corn................................17
Plate 2 showing PLA cup..................................................................................................................19
vi
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
List of Abbreviations
Abbreviation Full form
PLA Poly (Lactic Acid)
PET Poly Ethylene Terapthalate
PE Poly Ethylene
PP Poly Propylene
GRAS Generally Recognized As Safe
BOD Biological Oxygen Demand
LDPE Low Density Poly Ethylene
DP Direct Polycondensation
ROP Ring Opening Polymerization
OPS Oxially Poly Styrene
LLDPE Linear Low Density Polyethylene
WVTR Water Vapour Transimission Rate
GC Gas Chromatography
FI Flame Ionization
PBPC Pokhara Bigyan Tatha Prabidhi Campus
UNYSAN United Nations Youth And Students Association
vii
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
1. Introduction
1.1 General Introduction
Poly (lactic Acid) (PLA) is the first commodity polymer produced from annually
renewable resources like corn starch and beet roots. Some of the environmental benefits of
PLA, such as low energy to produce and reduced green house gas production, are
presented and opportunities for the future . PLA was discovered in 1932 by Carothers (at
DuPont) . PLA is a rigid thermoplastic polymer that can be semi crystalline or totally
amorphous, depending on the stereo purity of the polymer backbone. L-lactic acid (2-
hydroxy prop ionic acid) is the natural and most common form of the acid, but D-lactic
acid can also be produced by microorganisms or through racemization and this “impurity”
acts much like co monomers in other polymers such as polyethylene terephthalate (PET) or
polyethylene (PE) .
PLA is a unique polymer that in many ways behaves like PET, but also performs a lot like
polypropylene (PP), a polyolefin. Ultimately it may be the polymer with the broadest range
of applications because of its ability to be stress crystallized, thermally crystallized, impact
modified, filled, copolymerized, and processed in most polymer processing equipment. It
can be formed into transparent films, fibers, or injection molded into blow moldable
preforms for bottles, like PET. PLA also has excellent organoleptic characteristics and is
excellent for food contact and related packaging applications. In spite of this unique
combination of characteristics, the commercial viability has historically been limited by
high production costs (greater than $2/lb). It is one of the few polymers that can be easily
modified by using a controlled mixture of L-or D-isomers to yield high molecular weight
crystalline or amorphous that can be used for food contact and are generally recognized as
safe (GRAS) .
The biggest advantage that puts Polylactic acid way in front of other biodegradable and
non-biodegradable materials is its biodegradability and biocompatibility. In 2008,
worldwide plastics production was around 245 million metric tons which can’t be degraded
.
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
PLA excels from others on this aspect as when pure PLA is exposed toexcessive heat or
moisture or as a natural process over time, the polymer chains that make up the substance
begin to break down. This creates ever smaller polymer chains. The result of this process is
lactic acid, which is a naturally occurring nutrient that is also found in milk. Lactic acid is
completely biodegradable, and it poses no threat to local wildlife or water supplies. As
lactic acid breaks down in the environment, it produces carbon dioxide, water, and stable
organic matter used to form humus and topsoil . Almost all the conventional plastics such
as PE, PP, PS, and PVC are resistant to microbial attack; on the contrary aliphatic
polyesters like PLA are readily degraded by microorganisms present in the environment
1.2. Commercial viability of PLA
PLA requires 20-50% less fossil resources than comparable petroleum based plastics. With
PLA, carbon dioxide is removed from the atmosphere when growing the feedstock crop
and is returned to the earth when PLA is degraded. Since the process recycles the earth’s
carbon, PLA has the potential to reduce atmospheric CO2 levels. Disposal of PLA fits with
existing systems including the additional option of composting. Long-term, with the proper
infrastructure, PLA products could be recycled back to a monomer and into polymers. The
landmass necessary for feedstock production is minimal. Producing one billion pounds of
PLA requires less than 0.5% of the annual US corn crop. Compared to the escalating and
volatile cost of petroleum-based feed stocks, long-term PLA will eventually reap the
benefits of a more stable and lower priced feedstock. In spite of PLA’s excellent balance of
properties and environmental benefits, traditionally the commercial viability of PLA has
been limited by high production costs, more than 2$ for 0.453 kg. Until the last decade,
PLA has enjoyed little success in replacing petroleum-based plastics outside of biomedical
applications like sutures. Though development of PLA is at the early stages of
commercialization versus more traditional, petroleum-based plastic, expansion of
commercial adoption for applications like PLA bottles has been rapidly increasing as of
late .
To address the challenges of high production cost for the production of PLA, newer
methods like Melt Condensation are being studied .
2
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
Also by using other sources of dextrose, optimizing lactic acid, production processes and
its costs, substituting electricity energy by wind and solar energy for PLA production,
optimizing PLA production processes, and increasing PLA demands, reduction of its price
can be attained.
The present PLA price is much lower than in previous years, but it is not fixed and it even
will be considerably lower in the future because, according to expert forecasts, beyond
2010 the global demand for biodegradable plastics will continue to increase by 30% each
year and PLA will take a large part of this market because of its valuable properties .
1.3 Use of Polylactic acid as a packaging material in dairy industry.
Dairy industry produces huge volumes of wastes, both solid and liquids. This waste poses
escalating disposal and pollution (high BOD) problems and represents a loss of valuable
biomass and nutrients. However despite their pollution and hazard aspects, in many cases,
dairy processing wastes have a good potential of converting into useful products of higher
value as by-product, or even as raw material for other industries. Organic acids are
examples of such valuable by-product of the fermentation of high carbohydrate containing
industrial substrates. They therefore could be utilized cheaply as substrate for
microorganisms producing intermediate volume high value organic acids like lactic acid.
Lactic acid is under increasing demand in food and for production of polylactic acid
polymers, which possess outstanding packaging applications. Wastes generated from dairy
plants may be regarded as a viable option for meeting this growing demand for lactic acid
and lactic acid has received attention for use if a wide range of applications mostly as it
acts as a monomer for the production of biodegradable PLA .
PLA with incorporated bioactive material has been effectively used for milk packaging .
1.4 Statement of the problem
According to environmental, economic, and safety challenges have provoked packaging
scientists and producers to partially substitute petrochemical-based polymers with
biodegradable ones. The figures shows the global production of plastic to stack up to 245
million metric ton ,that’s a lot of non-biodegradable petroleum based plastics. Plastics
manufacture makes up 4.6% of the annual petroleum consumption in the U.S., using
3
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
roughly 331 million barrels per year. None of this energy is recovered when plastics are
disposed of in landfills, and very little is recovered when plastic waste is incinerated . So
the need of the hour and focus is to shift to biodegradable biopolymers to save the world
and reduce the use of petroleum based packaging materials. Dairy industry possess
problem in LDPE and pouch packaging its low mechanical and wet strength . Also it has
problems on low temperature fragility and when stored at lower temperature LDPE
packaging material doesn’t contain to the stored temperature.
1.5 Objectives of the seminar
1.5.1 General objectives
To study the use of PLA as packaging material.
To study the prospective use of PLA in dairy Industry.
1.5.2 Specific Objectives
To study the emergence and actual bottlenecks of PLA
To study the production, application, merits and demerits of PLA as packaging
material
To study the compatibility of PLA as packaging material for Dairy industry.
4
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
1.6 Significance of the seminar
To cognizant food technologist on the perspective supersede of it to conventional
packaging material that impose the environmental threats.
To study the potentiality of PLA on the basis of its cost and energy keeping in mind
the adoption in industry is focused on this matter.
To present Poly (Lactic Acid) as a potential alternative packaging material to dairy
industries from the waste generated by dairy industries.
To give impetus to food technologist on Packaging material in broad sense as well
with knowledge of application of PLA in dairy industry.
This entire attempt is to make a world greener and better.
1.7 Limitations of the work
No work is an easy walking like ice on the cake. There were few uphill challenges and task
that led to constraints of this study. Few of them are mentioned below
This study fails to relate the use of PLA for developing country like ours where
primary basic packaging material has still not found its place.
5
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
2. Literature review
2.1 Poly (Lactic Acid)
Research and development of packaging materials and packaging technology have shown a
clear and irreversible trend toward “green” and active packaging. New studies on
packaging materials have emphasized the use of biobased materials. The examples include
agricultural fibers; products and byproducts from agricultural processing such as cellulose,
starch, and pectin, polymers were synthesized using renewable biobased monomers, such
as (PLA), polyhydroxybutyrate, and Ecoflex®, as well as proteins from animal tissues,
soybean flour, and corn. Those materials are biodegradable, and their final degradation
products are nontoxic and environmentally friendly .
Among these biobased monomers, PLA have caught the worlds’ attention.PLA is aliphatic
polyester, a thermoplastic, high strength, high modulus polymer that can be made from
100% renewable resources. PLA is degraded by simple hydrolysis of the ester bond and
does not require the presence enzymes to catalyze this hydrolysis .
In today’s world of green chemistry and concern for the environment, PLA has additional
drivers that make it unique in the marketplace. The starting material for the final polymer,
lactic acid, is made by a fermentation process using 100% annually renewable resources.
The polymer will also rapidly degrade in the environment and the by-products are of very
low toxicity, eventually being converted to carbon dioxide and water.
PLA can be prepared by both direct condensation of lactic acid and by the ring-opening
polymerization of the cyclic lactide dimer, as shown in Figure 2.1.
Because the condensation route is an equilibrium reaction, difficulties of removing trace
amounts of water in the late stages of polymerization generally limit the ultimate molecular
weight achievable by this approach. Most work has focused on the ring-opening
polymerization of lactide, although other approaches, such as azeotropic distillation to
drive the removal of water in the direct esterification process, have been evaluated. Cargill
Dow LLC has developed a patented, low-cost continuous process for the production of
lacticacid-basedpolymers.
6
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
The process combines the substantial environmental and economic benefits of synthesizing
both lactide and PLA in the melt rather than in solution and, for the first time, provides a
commercially viable biodegradable commodity polymer made from renewable resources
Fig 2.1. Polymerization routes to Poly (lactic Acid) showing the formation of lactide and PLA
2.2 Synthesis and Production of Poly (lactic Acid)
Poly (lactic acid) (PLA) is produced from the monomer of lactic acid (LA). PLA can be
produced by two well-known processes .
direct polycondensation (DP) route
And the ring-opening polymerization (ROP) route.
Although DP is simpler than ROP for the production of PLA, ROP can produce a low-
molecular-weight brittle form of PLA. Generally, several substances are involved in the
production of PLA, and these relationships have been summarized in figure 2.1. The lactic
acid for the process is obtained from the fermentation of sugar. Lactic acid is converted to
lactide and eventually to PLA. It should be noted that there are two different terms, ‘poly
(lacticacid)’and ‘polylactide’, for the polymer of lactic acid.
7
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
Fig 2.2 General routes of PLA production showing direct polycondensation and ring opening polymerization
2.2.1 Lactic Acid Production.
Lactic acid as we can see from above figure is a building block of PLA production. It is
chemically known as 2-hydroxy-propionic acid with chiral stereoisomer L (-) and D (+)
isomers. Its physical properties are listed in Table 1
Table 1: Physical properties of Lactic Acid
CAS Registry No. 50-21-5(DL-lactic acid)79-33-4(L-lactic acid)
Chemical Formula C3H603
Chemical Name 2-Hydroxy-Propanoic acidMolecular Weight 90.08Physical Appearance Aqueous solutionTaste Mildly sourMelting Point 53°CBoiling Point >200°CSolubility in water(g/100 g H20)
Miscible
Dissociation constant, Ka 1.38*10-4
pKa 3.86pH(0.1% solution,25*C) 2.9
Many dairy products, including yogurt and cheeses, taste mildly sour due to the presence
of lactic acid, which provides additional antimicrobial action in these products . Pure lactic
8
Sushil koirala[PLA in dairy industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
acid has two stereoisomer (also known as enantiomers), which are shown in Figure 2.2.
These two stereoisomers are synthesized by different lactate dehydrogenase enzymes in
living organisms. Currently, 85% of the lactic acid produced is con-sumed by the food-
related industry, while the balance is used for non-food applications, such as the
production of biopolymers, solvents, etc
Fig 2.3: Stereo isomers of Lactic acid
The lactic acid bacteria fermentation process is carried out anaerobically with low energy
production. Red dy et a l. (2008) has divided the Lactobacillus genus into three groups
according to fermentation patterns, namely heterofermentative, homofermentative and rare
heterofermentative. So the microbial fermentation process yield Lactic acid which
according to needs purification technologies like electrodialysis, reverse osmosis, liquid
extraction and ion exchange.
2.2.2 Lactic acid from Dairy Industry
Dairy industry residues comprise a large variety of different biomasses and sludges that
can be roughly categorized to agricultural wastes and food production wastes. Food
9
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
production residues have been tested for bioconversion applications for ages, and the
variety of used materials is large. Whey and other dairy industry residues are the prominent
raw materials with respect to lactic acid production. Whey retains about 55% of total milk
nutrients, from which approximately 70% consists of lactose . Hence these lactose,
according to , Lactococcus lactis can covert lactose to lactic acid , a monomer for PLA.
2.2.3 Lactide and PLA production
Lactide is an intermediate substance in the production of PLA via the ring-opening
polymerization method which is also present in Appendix (A.1)
The purpose of the coupling agents is to increase the molecular weight of the PLA. In fact,
the lactic acid prepolymer is low- molecular-weight PLA. This low-molecular- weight
PLA is unusable- it possesses weak, glassy and brittle properties. According to , the
formation of low-molecular-weight PLA for direct reaction of prepolymer is mainly used
because of the lack of reactivity of the end groups, excess water and high viscosity of the
polymer melt once polymerization completed. Ring-opening polymerization of lactide was
first performed by Carothers in the mid-1900s, and later patents relating to this technology
by Du Pont kick- started the mass production of PLA. The general and basic steps for
lactide production include feeding the concentrated lactic acid into prepolymer reactor and
then polymerizing it. Then it is fed into lactide reactor where after processing crude lactide
is obtained in the form of vapour. Recovery is done by condensation and distillation. This
is again polymerized to form poly lactide .Now Ring opening polymerization proceeds to
produce PLA.
2.2.4 Ring Opening Polymerization
Lactide purification is accomplished by vacuum-distillation of high temperatures. After the
vacuum-distillation of L-lactide, high molecular weight PLA with a controlled optical and
crystal purity is formed by ring-opening polymerization. Ring-opening polymerization of
lactide can be carried out in melt or solution by cationic, anionic, and coordination
mechanisms, depending on the initiator utilized. The most considered active initiator for
the L-lactide ring-opening polymerization is stannous octoate (bis 2-ethyl hexanoate,
10
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
SnOct2), which causes a low degree of racemization at high temperature. It has a low
toxicity and is accepted by FDA.
Appendix A.1 shows ring opening polymerization with stannous octaoate as an initiator
2.2.5 Environmental Aspects
One of the most positive points of PLA production in comparison with the other
hydrocarbon-based polymers is the decrease of CO2 emission. Carbon dioxide is believed
to be the most important contributor to global climate change and its warming. Because,
carbon dioxide is absorbed from air when corn is grown, use of PLA has the potential to
emit fewer greenhouse gases compared to competitive hydrocarbon-based polymers .
Fig 2.4 Greenhouse gas emissions (kg/ton) for production of various polymers. Long-term
emissions for PLA are based on utilization of biomass for the production of lactic acid .
2.2.6 Energy requirement in relation to production of PLA
11
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
PLA as a packaging material has been seen by the world as a major drive force to combat
the challenges of global warming and climate change as it is scientifically approved by all
as 100% biodegradable packaging material. To produce PLA and use it as a packaging
material, however is a different thing altogether from industrial view point where less cost
of production is must. But to everyone’s surprise PLA requires very low energy in terms of
production .
PLA Longterm
PLA year 5PLA year 1PET amorphPPGPPSCellophaneHIPSNylon 66
Various Packaging material
150
120
90
60
30
0
Mean
Energ
y Req
uirem
ent in
KJ/K
g
5
34
57
7677879192
142
Fig 2.5 showing the energy requirement comparison of various packaging materials.
It shows PLA needs low energy input in terms of production which works tremendously in
its favor.
2.3 PLA processing technologies for food applications
2.3.1 Extrusion
12
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
According to Jamshidi an et a l. (2010a)
The first major step in the conversion of plastic resin into films, sheets, containers and so
on, is to change the pellets from solid to liquid or molten phase in an extruder.
Recommended extrusion conditions for PLA pellets include general purpose screws with
L/D ratios from 24:1 to 30:1 and compression ratio of 2.5:1 to 3:1, melt temperature of 200
to 220 ◦C, and also smooth barrels.
2.3.2 Injection molding
Injection molding involves melting a thermoplastic by extrusion, injecting the polymer
melt into a mold, cooling the part, and finally ejecting the part. Injection mold-grade PLA
is injection molded on most conventional equipment, but there could be some torque
limitations if the screw design has a high compression ratio. Compression ratios of 2.5 to 3
should be adequate and the recommended melting temperature is 200 to 205 ◦C. Since
PLA has a lower glass transition temperature (about 58 ◦C) than PS or PET, it might take a
little longer time to set up in the mold.
2.3.3 Thermoforming
PLA sheet can be thermoformed with vacuum, compressed air/vacuum, or only
compressed air assistance. The radiant heater of the thermoforming line for PLA must be
adjusted to very low temperatures. Preheating is not absolutely necessary; however it has
the general advantage that the sheet is homogeneously preheated.
2.4 General Properties of PLA
2.4.1 Thermal stability of PLA
PLA is thermally unstable and exhibits rapid loss of molecular weight as the result of
thermal treatment at processing temperatures. The ester linkages of PLA tend to degrade
during thermal processing or under hydrolytic conditions. PLA undergoes thermal
degradation at temperatures lower than the melting point of the polymer, but the
degradation rate rapidly increases above the melting point. It has been postulated that
thermal degradation mainly occurs by random main-chain scissions. Several reactions such
13
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
as hydrolysis, depolymerization, and oxidative degradation are suggested to be involved in
the degradation process during thermal treatments .
2.4.2 PLA properties
PLA has unique properties like good appearance, high mechanical strength, and low
toxicity; and good barrier properties have broadened its applications. It has low melting
point and glass transition temperature which makes PLA better for heat sealing and
thermal processing. It has high tensile modulus and flexural modulus as well
The other important property of polymers is their rate of crystallinity. Crystallinity is the
indication of amount of crystalline region in the polymer with respect to amorphous
content. Crystallinity influences many polymer properties including hardness, modulus,
tensile strength, stiffness, crease point, and melting point.
So, while selecting a polymer for a required application its crystallinity plays the foremost
role. measured the crystallinity of PLA and it was found to be high.
2.4.3 Barrier properties of PLA
One of the most important factors in food packaging polymers is their barrier or
permeability performance against transfer of gases, water vapor, and aroma molecules. The
barrier properties of PLA are remarkable and better than those of OPS. As a consequence,
PLA is suitable for packaging wide range of food. However the oxygen and gas
transmission rate has been found to be on lower side .
2.4.4 Studies on migration from PLA
Lactic acid is the lone monomer in the PLA structure and so, migrated agents are lactic
acid monomers, dimmers, and oligomers. investigated the safety of PLA as a food contact
polymer under different conditions and studied the migration of most probable species
from PLA. They concluded:
Very limited migration can be expected from PLA into foods that it contacts during
the intended conditions of use.
14
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
The small amount of any material that might migrate from PLA into food will be
lactic acid, or its dimers (lactoyl lactic acid and lactide) and oligomers that will be
subsequently hydrolyzed in aqueous systems to lactic acid.
Based on these findings, researchers concluded that PLA is safe and GRAS for its intended
uses in fabricating articles intended for use in contact with food. The projected intake of
lactic acid from PLA is approximately 700 times less than the estimated daily lactic acid
intake of a breast-fed infant. So, for a PLA much of the concerns about migrations of
potential dangerous materials, which exist for petrochemical-based polymers are resolved.
These results are only for pure PLA polymer and more studies are needed for its blends
and copolymers, also for all the compounds that are applied or added for improving
physical, mechanical, and barrier properties of PLA .
2.4.5 PLA modifications
As mentioned earlier because of special properties of PLA makes it a go to packaging
material. However its application has been restricted by high oxygen and moisture
permeability in comparison to other plastics like PE, PP and PET . For extending PLA
applications, the properties like impact strength or flexibility, stiffness, barrier properties,
thermal stability, and production costs must be improved. Generally, modifiers have been
studied to improve stiffness at elevated temperatures, reduce cost, or increase the
degradation rate of PLA. Some efforts of PLA modifications in the field of packaging are
presented in Appendix A.2.
2.4.6 Biodegradability nature of PLA
PLA also will not emit toxic fumes when incinerated. PLA may well break down into its
constituent parts (carbon dioxide and water) within three months in a “controlled
composting environment,” that is, an industrial composting facility heated to 140 °F and
fed a steady diet of digestive microbes .
According to , hydrolysis of ester linkage is the primary mechanism of degradation of
PLA.
2.5 Application of PLA
15
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
PLA has potential for use in a wide range of applications; PLA is a growing alternative as
a “green” food packaging polymer. New applications have been claimed in the field of
fresh products, where thermoformed PLA containers are used in retail markets for fruits,
vegetables, and salads. The market capacity of these products packaged in PLA is
unlimited. The major PLA application today is in packaging (nearly 70%).
Figure 2.6 Some commercial PLA products
The relatively poor water vapor barrier of PLA has been shown to be a factor limiting the
shelf life of moist foods. For example, semi-hard cheese packaged in PLA lost moisture,
and surface drying was observed after 56 days due to the high WVTR of the PLA; cheese
packaged in conventional materials had a shelf life of 84 days . PLA resins can be tailor-
made for different fabrication processes and made into films, coextruded into laminates,
thermoformed and injection stretch blow molded into bottles. PLA films can be prepared
by the blown double-bubble technology or, preferably, cast tentering, the latter having very
low haze, excellent gloss and gas transmission rates desirable for consumer food
packaging. PLA films also have superior dead fold or twist retention properties, making
them suitable for twist wrap packaging. The major application to date has been as
16
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
food service containers. Other current uses include thermoformed packaging for bakery
products and bags for bread, fresh pasta and salads. Now that production costs are being
reduced, PLA is expected to find packaging applications in areas such as coatings for
paperboard beverage cartons, plastic film wraps for foods, blister packs and plastic
windows in cartons .
2.5.1 Reference to Dairy Industry.
One of the first commercial applications of PLA for foods was packaging of organic
yoghurt in thermoformed PLA cups
Plate 1 Showing general process of PLA yoghurt cup manufacture from corn
2.6 Quality control of PLA
The quality determination of PLA is the determination of lactide composition by gas
chromatography (GC) or flame ionization (FI) technique which measures and detects the
L-lactide, M-lactide and D-Lactide residues. The evaluation of D-lactic acid presence is
very important, especially if the PLA product will be in contact with food or is a biological
implant. The daily allowable intake of D-lactic acid in adult humans is, 100 mg/kg and no
D-lactic acid must be found in infant food
2.7 Pros and Cons of using PLA as Packaging material in Dairy industry
17
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
2.7.1 Pros
According to
Good Ultraviolet light barrier properties.
PLA seals well at temperatures below the melting temperature.
The amount of lactic acid and its derivatives that migrate to food simulant solutions
from PLA is much lower than any of the current average dietary lactic acid intake
values
Environment friendly
Made from 100% renewable resources
Net gas emission is also lower in comparison to other packaging material.
Use of Power is also lower in comparison to other packaging material.
And according to
Due to its intrinsic high value of surface tension of 36 to 38 mN/m, PLA is easily
printable.
Moreover, trays from PLA show an excellent sealability at temperatures much
lower than required to process common polymer material
As PLA has a very good flavor and aroma barrier, it is very qualified for packing
food with a distinctive smell as e.g. cheese or goods, that require a protection of
their specific aroma, like e.g. herbs
The climatic conditions inside a PLA packaging due to the gas exchange from
inside the package to the environment, related to its pronounced permeation ability,
is beneficial for the maturing of cheese without influencing its unique taste.
Another advantage of PLA trays for packing food is its high resistance to grease
and oil.
They are resistant to microbial attack in comparison to PE, PP and PET which aids
in its biodegradability.
2.7.2 Cons
High amount of gypsum is produced as by-product which is environmental hazard
which would also increase the COD level
18
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
Its dynamic application in food is restricted by its high oxygen and water vapor
transmission rate .
It has been observed that largest manufacture of PLA, nature works have used
genetically modified corns which are under huge scruitinity.
Though newer technologies have replaced Ring Opening Polymerization, its high
production cost is still an issue.
Plate 2 showing PLA cup
19
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
3. Conclusions
PLA is derived from starting substance lactic acid which is derived through the
fermentation of carbohydrates. The production of PLA can be conducted by two methods
either by direct polycondensation or ring opening polymerization. Of the two, ring opening
lactide polymerization remains the most widely used method, because the process has
higher yield and low toxicity. The traces of lactide present in PLA are determined to avoid
overdose consumption.
Lactic acid is the monomer for PLA production which is present easily as by-product in
industrial sectors especially dairy from whey and cheese. It can be recovered and used
subsequently to produce PLA for yoghurt and other products so as to minimize the use of
conventional LDPE and LLDPE. It would ultimately be beneficial as it is made from
renewable material corn and is therefore biodegradable making the earth greener and better
place to live in.
20
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
REFERENCES
21
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
APPENDICES
A.1 –Production steps for PLA
25
Sushil koirala[PLA in food industries],sushilbandhu.wordpress.com
A.2 -- PLA modification for the use in different products.
26