Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide...

7
Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing +1 Masayuki Takada 1,+2 , Hideaki Matsubara 2,3 and Yoshihiro Kawagishi 1 1 Nippon Tokushu Goukin Co. Ltd., Gamagori 443-0011, Japan 2 Nagoya Institute Technology, Graduate School of Engineering, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan 3 Japan Fine Ceramics Center, Nagoya 456-8587, Japan Cemented carbide dies with ve categories of composition, namely, WC-Co straight alloys, TaNbC-, Cr 3 C 2 - or VC-containing WC-Co alloys and WC-Ni alloys, were fabricated by sintering and HIP treatment. The wear behavior of these cemented carbide dies for drawing steel cord wire is examined, and material properties such as hardness, transverse-rupture strength and corrosion resistance are evaluated. It is found that the TaNbC-containing alloy shows the longest lifetime as a steel cord drawing die, followed by the Cr 3 C 2 -containing alloy, WC-Co, VC- containing alloy and WC-Ni alloy. The strength and corrosion resistance show no relation with the drawing die life. The hardness has some inuence on the die life; for example, within the same alloy category, there is a tendency that the longer die life is obtained for the material with the higher hardness. However, it is not possible to explain simply from the viewpoint of hardness even why the TaNbC-containing alloy has the longest life though the VC-containing alloy has the nest grain size and highest hardness. The wear mechanism of cemented carbide dies for steel cord wire drawing was discussed, focusing on WC/Co interface adhesion. [doi:10.2320/matertrans.M2013185] (Received May 27, 2013; Accepted July 17, 2013; Published September 25, 2013) Keywords: cemented carbide, tungsten carbide, cobalt, sintering, drawing die, steel cord wire, wear 1. Introduction Steel cord is brass-coated steel wire used to reinforce automotive tires. WC-Co cemented carbide is widely used as a drawing die to reduce the wire diameter of the steel cord from 1.2 mm to about 0.2 mm. The wear of the cemented carbide die is the most important factor affecting the production efciency of steel cord. Improvement of the die life would directly increase productivity of steel cords. Studies on cemented carbide wire drawing dies have been reported that examine die surfaces during copper wire drawing, 1) and the effects of shape 2) and friction and lubrication 3) of the die during steel wire drawing. However, there have been no reports yet on the use of cemented carbide dies for steel cord drawing. Moreover, it is thought that wear of cemented carbide dies is greatly inuenced by the composition and microstructure of the cemented carbide, but as yet there have been no studies on cemented carbide dies from a materials science point of view. In this study, in order to improve the die life for steel cord wire drawing, the abrasion behavior of wire drawing of various cemented carbide dies was evaluated and analyzed in relation to properties such as hardness, strength and corrosion resistance of the cemented carbides. WC-10%Co alloy was used as a reference material and various cemented carbides with additions of TaNbC, Cr 3 C 2 and VC, and also with Ni binder instead of Co, were fabricated. 2. Specimens and Experimental Procedures Commercial WC powders (grain size, 0.5-4 μm), Ta 0.8 Nb 0.2 C (1 μm), VC (1.5 μm), Cr 3 C 2 (1.5 μm), Co (1.2 μm) and Ni (2 μm) powders were mixed in an attritor (time: 14.4-28.8 ks in acetone), dried, pressed and sintered under vacuum at (10 Pa) at temperatures between 1653- 1723 K for 3.6 ks. After sintering, Hot Isostatic Pressing (HIP) treatment of 40 MPa at 1633 K for 3.6 ks, in Ar was performed to remove residual pores. Table 1 shows compo- sitions of 15 kinds of cemented carbide specimens fabricated for this study. The specimens were ve types; additive-free WC-Co alloys, TaNbC-added alloys, Cr 3 C 2 -added alloys, Cr 3 C 2 and VC-added alloys and Ni binder alloys, labeled S, T, C, CVand N alloys, respectively. A WC powder with grain size of 1μm was usually used in preparing S, T, C and N alloys, while coarse powders with 2 and 4 μm grains were used for T and C alloys and ne WC powder with 0.5 μm grains was used for CV alloys. Microstructure observation by SEM and Rockwell-A hardness (HRA) testing were performed on the fabricated specimens. Transverse rupture strengths were obtained using rectangular specimens with dimensions 4 mm © 8 mm © 25 mm and a span of 20 mm. Conditions for corrosion experiments were 333 K for 7.2 © 10 6 s (2000 h) with a wet lubricant of emulsion type liquid. Specimen surfaces were observed and mass changes measured after each corrosion test. Figure 1 shows the shape of the dies and schematic views of the steel cord wire drawing machine. All the dies were immersed in the lubricating liquid. The composition of the steel cord was steel with 0.82%C, the surface was coated with brass and the starting diameter was º1.17 mm. The number of wire drawing stages (number of dies) was 21, the nishing wire size was set at º0.217-0.221 mm by polishing treatment, and the drawing velocity at the last stage was 800 m/min. The dies fabricated in this study were used as the last three dies in the drawing process (Fig. 1). The other dies were cemented carbide dies normally used in manufacturing of steel wires. When the above-mentioned three dies for this study reached the end of their lives, all other dies were changed to new ones. When the wire diameter reached º0.225 mm, the die was judged to have reached its useable lifetime. The number of wire drawing experiments was 3 to 5 +1 This Paper was Originally Published in Japanese in J. Japan Inst. Metals 76 (2012) 385-390. +2 Corresponding author, E-mail: takada.masayuki@tokyorope.co.jp Materials Transactions, Vol. 54, No. 10 (2013) pp. 2011 to 2017 © 2013 The Japan Institute of Metals and Materials

Transcript of Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide...

Page 1: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1

Masayuki Takada1,+2, Hideaki Matsubara2,3 and Yoshihiro Kawagishi1

1Nippon Tokushu Goukin Co. Ltd., Gamagori 443-0011, Japan2Nagoya Institute Technology, Graduate School of Engineering, Nagoya 466-8555, Japan3Japan Fine Ceramics Center, Nagoya 456-8587, Japan

Cemented carbide dies with five categories of composition, namely, WC­Co straight alloys, TaNbC-, Cr3C2- or VC-containing WC­Coalloys and WC­Ni alloys, were fabricated by sintering and HIP treatment. The wear behavior of these cemented carbide dies for drawing steelcord wire is examined, and material properties such as hardness, transverse-rupture strength and corrosion resistance are evaluated. It is foundthat the TaNbC-containing alloy shows the longest lifetime as a steel cord drawing die, followed by the Cr3C2-containing alloy, WC­Co, VC-containing alloy and WC­Ni alloy. The strength and corrosion resistance show no relation with the drawing die life. The hardness has someinfluence on the die life; for example, within the same alloy category, there is a tendency that the longer die life is obtained for the material withthe higher hardness. However, it is not possible to explain simply from the viewpoint of hardness even why the TaNbC-containing alloy has thelongest life though the VC-containing alloy has the finest grain size and highest hardness. The wear mechanism of cemented carbide dies forsteel cord wire drawing was discussed, focusing on WC/Co interface adhesion. [doi:10.2320/matertrans.M2013185]

(Received May 27, 2013; Accepted July 17, 2013; Published September 25, 2013)

Keywords: cemented carbide, tungsten carbide, cobalt, sintering, drawing die, steel cord wire, wear

1. Introduction

Steel cord is brass-coated steel wire used to reinforceautomotive tires. WC­Co cemented carbide is widely used asa drawing die to reduce the wire diameter of the steel cordfrom 1.2mm to about 0.2mm. The wear of the cementedcarbide die is the most important factor affecting theproduction efficiency of steel cord. Improvement of the dielife would directly increase productivity of steel cords.

Studies on cemented carbide wire drawing dies have beenreported that examine die surfaces during copper wiredrawing,1) and the effects of shape2) and friction andlubrication3) of the die during steel wire drawing. However,there have been no reports yet on the use of cemented carbidedies for steel cord drawing. Moreover, it is thought thatwear of cemented carbide dies is greatly influenced by thecomposition and microstructure of the cemented carbide, butas yet there have been no studies on cemented carbide diesfrom a materials science point of view.

In this study, in order to improve the die life for steel cordwire drawing, the abrasion behavior of wire drawing ofvarious cemented carbide dies was evaluated and analyzed inrelation to properties such as hardness, strength and corrosionresistance of the cemented carbides. WC­10%Co alloy wasused as a reference material and various cemented carbideswith additions of TaNbC, Cr3C2 and VC, and also with Nibinder instead of Co, were fabricated.

2. Specimens and Experimental Procedures

Commercial WC powders (grain size, 0.5­4µm),Ta0.8Nb0.2C (1 µm), VC (1.5 µm), Cr3C2 (1.5 µm), Co(1.2 µm) and Ni (2 µm) powders were mixed in an attritor(time: 14.4­28.8 ks in acetone), dried, pressed and sintered

under vacuum at (10 Pa) at temperatures between 1653­1723K for 3.6 ks. After sintering, Hot Isostatic Pressing(HIP) treatment of 40MPa at 1633K for 3.6 ks, in Ar wasperformed to remove residual pores. Table 1 shows compo-sitions of 15 kinds of cemented carbide specimens fabricatedfor this study. The specimens were five types; additive-freeWC­Co alloys, TaNbC-added alloys, Cr3C2-added alloys,Cr3C2 and VC-added alloys and Ni binder alloys, labeled S,T, C, CVand N alloys, respectively. AWC powder with grainsize of 1 µm was usually used in preparing S, T, C and Nalloys, while coarse powders with 2 and 4 µm grains wereused for T and C alloys and fine WC powder with 0.5 µmgrains was used for CV alloys.

Microstructure observation by SEM and Rockwell-Ahardness (HRA) testing were performed on the fabricatedspecimens. Transverse rupture strengths were obtained usingrectangular specimens with dimensions 4mm © 8mm ©25mm and a span of 20mm. Conditions for corrosionexperiments were 333K for 7.2 © 106 s (2000 h) with a wetlubricant of emulsion type liquid. Specimen surfaces wereobserved and mass changes measured after each corrosiontest.

Figure 1 shows the shape of the dies and schematic viewsof the steel cord wire drawing machine. All the dies wereimmersed in the lubricating liquid. The composition of thesteel cord was steel with 0.82%C, the surface was coatedwith brass and the starting diameter was º1.17mm. Thenumber of wire drawing stages (number of dies) was 21, thefinishing wire size was set at º0.217­0.221mm by polishingtreatment, and the drawing velocity at the last stage was800m/min. The dies fabricated in this study were used as thelast three dies in the drawing process (Fig. 1). The other dieswere cemented carbide dies normally used in manufacturingof steel wires. When the above-mentioned three dies for thisstudy reached the end of their lives, all other dies werechanged to new ones. When the wire diameter reachedº0.225mm, the die was judged to have reached its useablelifetime. The number of wire drawing experiments was 3 to 5

+1This Paper was Originally Published in Japanese in J. Japan Inst. Metals76 (2012) 385­390.

+2Corresponding author, E-mail: [email protected]

Materials Transactions, Vol. 54, No. 10 (2013) pp. 2011 to 2017©2013 The Japan Institute of Metals and Materials

Page 2: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

and the average value of the amount of wire drawn (kg) wasobtained, and finally the relative value (ratio) of the drawnamount of wire was used to evaluate die life. The relativevalue of drawn wire was defined as the ratio between theaverage wire drawn for each alloy divided by the averagewire drawn for the reference alloy, S1. We refer to this as therelative value of wire production. Dies after the drawing testswere cut into halves and the wear condition of the dies wasobserved by SEM.

3. Experimental Results

Figure 2 shows SEM microstructures of each alloy. TheWC grain size of T alloys is smaller than that of S alloys, andgrains of T alloys tend to become slightly smaller with anincrease of the amount of TaNbC, and WC grain size of Talloys is larger when the grain size of the starting WC powderis larger. The WC grain size of C alloys is smaller than that ofS alloys, and the WC particle diameters of C alloys becomelarger with increasing grain size of the starting WC powder.

CV alloys have extremely fine microstructures by utilizingthe particle effect by VC addition and ultrafine WC particlepowder. The effects of TaC, Cr3C2 and VC addition onmicrostructures (WC grain size) of these alloys are similar tothose reported in the literature.4­6) N alloys without othercarbides have coarser WC particles than S alloys, and Nalloys with Cr3C2 addition have smaller microstructures thanS alloys. These results are also similar to those reportedpreviously.4)

Hardness and transverse rupture strengths of these alloyswere compared. Their average values are presented inTable 1. Hardness of T alloys was greater than those of Salloys, and the hardness rises with an increase in TaNbCcontent, and falls with an increase in WC grain size.Transverse rupture strengths of T alloys tend to be slightlylower than those of S alloys, and do not vary when TaNbC isadded, but decrease with an increase in WC grain size.

Hardness of C alloys is higher than those of S alloys, andrise with a decrease in the amount of Co, and fall with anincrease in the WC grain size. Transverse rupture strengthsof C alloys are 3.3­3.4GPa for 6%Co, which is almost equalto those of S alloys. Hardness of CV alloys is higher thanthose of S alloys and rise with a decrease of Co content.Transverse rupture strengths of CV alloys with 10%Co arehigher than those with 6%Co and reach 3.8GPa. N alloyswithout other carbides have lower hardness than S alloys,and the N alloy with Cr3C2 has a higher hardness. Thetransverse rupture strengths of N alloys tend to be lower thanthose of S alloys.

Figure 3 shows wire drawing curves for the four kinds ofcemented carbide dies. The wire drawing curves exhibit astaircase pattern because the wire diameters were measuredwith a micrometer with a precision of 0.001mm. The finalwire diameters obtained º0.217­0.220mm and the lifetimeof the die, was judged when the diameter reached a thicknessof º0.225mm, although there were some cases of the wire

Brass plating

Steel 0.82%C

Measuring

No.1 No.2 No.3 No.4

In liquid lubricant

RewindNo.19 No.20 No.21

1.17mm

Evaluation in this study.

Final diameterof wire

0.225mm: φ

10°

1.17~0.22mm8.

9mm

7.6mm

Steel cordwire

Cemented carbide die

φ

φ

φ

Fig. 1 Schematic illustration of steel cord drawing machine. In this study,the three dies of No. 19­21 were evaluated.

Table 1 Alloy content and grain size of WC powder of the cemented carbide specimens for steel cord (wire) drawing dies.

Signal CategoryGrain size ofWC powder

d/µm

Alloy content (mass%)HardnessHRA

Transverserupturestrength·/GPa

Corrosionresistance

Relative valueof wire

productionTaNbC Cr3C2 VC Co Ni WC

S1Straight

1.0 10 bal. 90.3 3.3 bad 1.0

S2 1.0 6 bal. 90.8 3.2 bad 1.4

T1

+Ta0.8Nb0.2C

1.0 0.9 6 bal. 92.5 2.8 normal 1.7

T2 1.0 1.1 6 bal. 92.6 3.0 normal 1.9

T3 1.0 1.3 6 bal. 92.8 2.9 normal 1.6

T4 2.0 0.9 6 bal. 92.0 3.0 normal 1.5

T5 4.0 0.9 6 bal. 91.5 2.7 normal 0.8

C1

+Cr3C2

1.0 1.0 10 bal. 91.7 2.5 good 0.9

C2 1.0 0.6 6 bal. 92.9 3.4 good 1.4

C3 2.0 0.6 6 bal. 92.2 3.3 good 1.3

CV1+Cr3C2, +VC

0.5 0.9 0.5 10 bal. 93.0 3.8 bad 0.7

CV2 0.5 0.9 0.3 6 bal. 93.8 3.1 bad 1.2

N1

Ni binder

1.0 10 bal. 89.8 3.1 bad 0.7

N2 1.0 1.0 10 bal. 91.4 3.2 good 0.9

N3 1.0 0.6 6 bal. 92.2 2.9 good 0.8

M. Takada, H. Matsubara and Y. Kawagishi2012

Page 3: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

diameters exceeding º0.225mm at the time of measurement.It is seen that wire drawing curves show some scatter ineach alloys category. The cause of this scatter is complex anddepends on many factors such as the type of wire rod,lubricant, material of the die and surface finishing. Studiesto reduce such scatter are also required. In this study,we seek firstly to clarify underlying factors determiningcemented carbide die lifetimes, and will not consider thecauses of the scatter in more detail. It takes, depending onthe materials and conditions, one to four weeks to conduct awire drawing experiment. Wire drawing experiments wereperformed three to five times for each alloy, their average

values calculated, and comparison between each kind ofmaterial performed.

Table 1 shows average values of the relative value of wireproduction for each kind of alloy. Relative values of wireproduction for S1 and S2 were in the ranges of 0.91­1.09and 0.70­2.11, respectively, giving average values of 1.0 and1.4, respectively. Therefore, the lifetime of S2 was slightlylonger than that of S1. The relative value of T2 was in therange 0.92­2.54 with an average of 1.9, which was thehighest value in this study. Moreover, the average values ofT1, T3 and T4 were more than 1.5, which is significantlylonger than that of S1. However, the average value of T5

S1 S2 T1

T4

T2

T5

T3

C2C1

CV1 CV2

C3

N1 N3N2

2μm

Fig. 2 SEM microstructures of the fifteen kinds of cemented carbide specimens.

S2 T2

CV2

Fin

al d

iam

eter

of w

ire,

D/m

m

0.217

0.218

0.219

0.220

0.221

0.222

0.223

0.224

0.225

0.226

0.227

C2

first drawing test second drawing test third drawing test fourth drawing test fifth drawing testRelative value of wire production

0.217

0.218

0.219

0.220

0.221

0.222

0.223

0.224

0.225

0.226

0.227

1.00.50.03.02.52.01.51.00.50.0 3.02.52.01.5

Fig. 3 Final diameter of wire vs relative value of production for the drawing dies of S2, T2, C2 and CV2.

Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing 2013

Page 4: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

was as low as 0.8. The value of C2 was in the range 0.79­1.76 and its average value was 1.4. The average values ofC1 and C3 were 0.9 and 1.3, respectively. Relative valuesfor CV2 were in the range 0.28­2.54, and its average valuewas 1.2. The average value of CV1 was 0.7, which waslower than that of S1. This was the lowest value for materialswith Co binder. The average values of N1, N2 and N3 werebelow 1, indicating that their lifetimes were shorter thanthat of S1.

The comparison between average relative values of wireproduction of each alloy reveals the following trends.Comparison among the groups of alloys shows that Talloys with TaNbC exhibit the best drawing performance,followed by C alloys with Cr3C2, S alloys with no addition,and CV alloys with Cr3C2 and VC. Further, the drawingperformance of N alloys with Ni instead of Co is lowest.Moreover, comparison among the same kinds of alloysshows that drawing amounts are greater for 6%Co alloysthan for 10%Co alloys, and the finer the WC grain size thegreater the lifetime. In the following section, the relationshipbetween materials properties and drawing performance areexamined.

Figure 4 shows relationships between relative values ofwire production and hardness, and those between the relativevalue of wire production and transverse rupture strength.Firstly, plots of the relative value of wire production andhardness show that most of the alloys with relative valuesof wire production above 1 have hardness around HRA92,while for alloys of higher hardness the relative value of wireproduction tended to be lower. In other words, relative valuesof wire production reached a maximum for hardness ofHRA92.5 to 93. In the range of HRA92.5 to 93, the relativevalue of wire production of T alloys was highest, followedby that of C alloys. Moreover, the relative value of wireproduction of CV1 was low even with HRA93, and that ofN3 was considerably inferior even with HRA92.2. On theother hand, plots of relative value of wire production versustransverse rupture strength reveal that the relative value ofwire production is greater than 1 for strength of 2.8­3.4GPa,although the relative value of wire production of some alloyswith high transverse rupture strengths was low, indicatingthat there is no simple correlation between relative value ofwire production and transverse rupture strength.

Figure 5 shows the surface structures and mass changes ofdies after corrosion experiments. The results show that masschange increase in the order C2 < N2 < T1 < CV2 < S2,and SEM images show that parts of the Co phases arecorroded by the lubrication liquid for all alloys. Further,excellent corrosion resistance was seen for binder phases ofCo and Ni with Cr3C2, indicating that corrosion resistancedoes not correspond directly to the results of the wiredrawing amounts.

Figure 6 shows SEM images of dies cut parallel to the wiredrawing direction. The left side of each micrograph is theentrance side of the wire and the right side is the exit point. Inthese micrographs, multiple removal events are observed inthe bearing part of S2, and comparatively clear stripe-shapedscratches (perhaps deposits) are observed in T2. Further,scratches can be seen in the passage direction of the wire inC2 while no particularly large areas of particle removal orscratches can be observed in the micrograph of CV2.However, observation of the wear surfaces of dies did notreveal any conditions that correspond to differences in wiredrawing amounts of different materials.

4. Discussion

In total, fifteen different alloys categorized into five classesthat can be used as cemented carbides for wear resistant toolsand dies for steel cord wire drawing were fabricated and their

Rel

ativ

e va

lue

of w

ire p

rodu

ctio

n (b)(a)

Fig. 4 Relative value of wire production for each die (specimen) as a function of (a) hardness and (b) transverse rupture strength.

S20.018

N20.010 %

T10.035

C20.001

CV20.088

10μm

Fig. 5 Corrosion resistance experiments of cemented carbides of S2, T1,C2, CV2 and N2 showing SEM microstructures of specimen surfaces andweight loss (%) after dipping in drawing lubricant for 2,000 h at 60°C.

M. Takada, H. Matsubara and Y. Kawagishi2014

Page 5: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

wire drawing (wear) behaviors examined systematically.The results reveal that the lifetime of cemented carbidescontaining so-called refinement additives such as TaNbC,Cr3C2 or VC tended to be longer than that of additive-freeWC­Co alloys. In particular, the longest wire drawing lifewas observed for an alloy with TaNbC; this material shouldbe the best for steel wire drawing dies. The relationshipbetween mechanical properties such as hardness and trans-verse rupture strength of each alloy and corrosion behaviorsin a lubricant and wire drawing lifetime were examined. Thetransverse rupture strength and corrosion resistance appearto have almost no relationship with wire drawing lifetime,but there are some correlations between hardness and wiredrawing amount.

First, we discuss the effects of refinement additives bycomparison with additive-free alloys. In order to consider therelation between wire drawing amount and hardness plottedin Fig. 4 in detail, we compared alloys of the same materialsclass (additives) and found that the wire drawing amountincreases with an increase in hardness. However, such atendency is not seen across different alloy classes. Thereduction in grain size for three kinds of additives proceededin the order TaNbC < Cr3C2 < VC, and hardness increasedin the same order while wire drawing amount, in the contrast,decreased in the order TaNbC > Cr3C2 > VC. In alloys withVC, it is easy to obtain alloys with high hardness havingultrafine microstructures while the results show clearly thatthey are not suited for dies for wire drawing of steel cords. Incontrast, alloys containing TaNbC do not always show finemicrostructures, but excellent wire drawing amounts (longlifetimes). Alloys containing Cr3C2 lie somewhere betweenthe two. Considering that ultrafine particle cemented carbides

with VC are widely used in tools for ultra-precisionmachining such as micron drills, this result is very importantwhen it comes to their practical use in wire drawing dies.

In order to study these results further, it would benecessary to consider the wearing mechanism of cementedcarbides as a function of their microstructures. Figure 7shows a model we propose for describing the wear mechan-ism of a cemented carbide die during steel cord wire drawingbased on the findings of this study. First, wear modes can beroughly classified into two types, micro-wear and macro-wear. Here, macro-wear means a wear mode in which someportion of the die is removed by work-piece materials (steelcord). For example, the scratches seen in the bearing of thedie shown in Fig. 6 are one such macro-wear. A possiblecause is that hard materials other than the die piece, such aspowder dust, chips from dies or impurities in work-pieces,are drawn in along with the wire. Further, such wear can be acause of the scatter in wire drawing amount. However, forsimplicity we assume that the differences in wire drawingamount obtained in this study for different classes ofcemented carbides are not directly related to macroscopicwear. This assumption is supported by the observation thatthere is almost no correlation between transverse rupturestrength and wire drawing amount of the cemented carbides.This is most likely because all of the cemented carbidematerials used for this study are high strength materials forwhich residual pores are removed by HIP treatment, macro-wear hardly occurs. If low strength materials without HIPtreatment had been used, the scatter would have been evengreater and the results presented here (in terms of differencesbetween types of material) may not have been obtainedreadily interpretable.

C2

S2

CV2

T2

Approach Bearing

0.1mm

Fig. 6 SEM images of bearing surfaces in drawing dies at the end of the useful lifetimes of S2, T2, C2 and CV2.

Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing 2015

Page 6: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

Plots of hardness versus relative wire drawing amounts,several a tendency for the wire drawing amount to fall whenthe hardness exceeds a certain value, in other words, thetendency that the relative values of wire production peak at acertain hardness. This is thought to indicate that the harder amaterial, the more likely macroscopic wear (partial chippingof a material) is to occur, owing to the brittleness ofextremely hard alloys. However, frequent removal of largeparticles and scratches were not observed in bearing parts ofdies of the hardest alloy (CV2) and therefore it is unlikelythat macroscopic wear is the determining factor. In the caseof dies with alloys that are harder (more brittle) than thoseused for this study, such macroscopic wear may be the mainfactor.

Based on the consideration that the wear mechanism ofmost importance here is micro-wear, Fig. 7 shows schematicdiagrams of how wear proceeds in WC­Co with a compositemicrostructure; In the early stage of wear (Fig. 7(b)), thesoft Co phase is worn to some depth (around 0.1­0.2 µm) fora microstructure containing the two phases WC and Co. Inthe following step (Fig. 7(c)), the surface of WC is worngradually (probably micro-chipping) occurs. In the last step(Fig. 7(d)), WC grains fall off one at a time, and wearprogresses more rapidly. The wear lifetime of the dies in thisstudy is defined as the point where the wire diameter (diediameter in other words) becomes thicker by 5 µm andtherefore as the point where a cemented carbide is worn by2.5 µm compared to the original surface of the die. If theWC grain size is 1 µm, two or three WC grains will havebeen removed from the surface by the end of the dielifetime. Here, it is thought that process (b) is influenced bythe hardness of the Co phase and its wear is suppressedmore effectively for smaller WC grain sizes. Moreover,process (c) is influenced by the WC grain size, and wearof the WC phase is suppressed better for finer grain alloys.The fact that wear lifetimes are longer in finer grain alloysfor alloys with the same additives indicates that processes(b) and (c) are suppressed in such alloys. Incidentally, it ispossible that the differences between alloy types areinfluenced by process (d). It is known that in the cementedcarbides containing VC and Cr3C2, these elements dissolvein Co liquid phase during sintering and are precipitated onthe WC/Co interface during cooling after sintering.7) Sucha precipitation phase (layer) may decrease the adhesion

strength (holding power of the WC grains) of the WC/Cointerface. In particular, the amount of precipitation is large inVC added alloys and its bad effects may be large. In thisregard, since dissolution to the liquid phase is small inTaNbC added alloys, precipitation during cooling may notbe a concern. Therefore, it can be understood that the abilityto retain the WC grains in TaNbC added alloys is essentiallythe same as that in additive-free cemented carbides. Thereason why the wire drawing amounts, which are the mostimportant results in terms of die lifetimes, increased in termsof the additions in the order of VC < Cr3C2 < TaNbC thusappears to be that they are related to micro-wear events ofthe type in Fig. 7(d) (WC grain removal) depending on thestatuses of the WC/Co interface. In order to confirm thishypothesis, it is important to evaluate the strength (i.e.,adhesive strength) of the WC/Co interface and which we arecurrently carrying out. Moreover, in order to improve furtherthe die lifetimes (wire drawing amounts), materials designprinciples such as the observation that cemented carbideswhich do not decrease WC/Co interface strength, such asfine grained alloys with no VC, are effective will be appliedin the future.

5. Conclusions

Wear behaviors during wire drawing of steel cords wereevaluated for dies made of WC­6%Co, ­10%Co alloyswith TaNbC, Cr3C2 and VC, additives and with Nibinder phase instead of Co, their relationships with materialproperties were analyzed. The following results wereobtained:(1) The best wire drawing performance was obtained for

the alloy with TaNbC, followed by the alloy withCr3C2, additive-free alloy and the alloy withCr3C2+VC. The worst wire drawing properties wereobtained for alloys with the Ni binder phase. Moreover,comparison between materials within the same kind ofalloy group showed that wire drawing amounts weregreater in 6%Co than in 10%Co and for finer WC grainsizes.

(2) The relationships of mechanical properties such ashardness and transverse rupture strength of eachmaterial and corrosion behaviors using a lubricantduring wire drawing were examined and it was found

z z z

Microscopic wear Macroscopic wear

Wear of cemented carbide die during steel cord drawing

Chipping of a part of WC-Co alloy

Co Co Co Co

Co CoCo Co

Wire materialDie surface

(a)Before wearing

(b)Wearing and corrosionof Co phase

(c)Wearing andchipping of WC phase

(d)Dropout ofWC grain

Foreign object

z z

WC WC WC

Fig. 7 Schematic illustration of the wearing mechanism of cemented carbide dies for steel wire drawing.

M. Takada, H. Matsubara and Y. Kawagishi2016

Page 7: Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing · PDF fileWear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing+1 ... 2Nagoya Institute Technology, ... WC grain size

that the transverse rupture strength and corrosionresistance have almost no relationship with wiredrawing lifetime, although hardness does have someeffect on the lifetime.

(3) The wearing mechanism of cemented carbide dies forsteel cord wire drawing, it is considered that the reasonwhy the wire drawing amounts (die lifetime) were largein the order of TaNbC > Cr3C2 > VC by the typesof refinement additives is related to microscopic wearof WC grain removal depending on the status of theWC/Co interface.

REFERENCES

1) H. Nakamura: J. JSTP 19 (1962) 527­532.2) H. Nishimoto and K. Hyodo: Tetsu-to-Hagane 59 (1973) 898­906.3) T. Matsushita: J. JSTP 31 (1990) 958­964.4) H. Suzuki and K. Tokumoto: J. Jpn. Soc. Powder Powder Metall. 31

(1984) 56­59.5) H. Suzuki, Y. Fuke and K. Hayashi: J. Jpn. Soc. Powder Powder Metall.

19 (1972) 106­112.6) H. Suzuki: Cemented Carbide and Sintered Hard Material, (Maruzen

Tokyo, 1986) pp. 249­255.7) M. Kawakami, O. Terada and K. Hayashi: J. Jpn. Soc. Powder Powder

Metall. 51 (2004) 576­585.

Wear of Cemented Carbide Dies for Steel Cord Wire Drawing 2017