wdc.govt.nzwdc.govt.nz/BuildingandProperty/ResourceConsents/... · Name Bryce Allen Address 13...

Attachment 2

Name Bryce Allen

Address 13 Wattle Lane, Acacia Park, Raumanga

Telephone & em ail 0272888227 - [email protected]

Date 7/luly/2017

Whangarei District Council

Resource Consent Manager

Proposal: Disposal of Overburden

’,9 .-

:-’!iVEO 1 3 JUL 2011

Subject: Resource Consent Ref lU1700100

--",

~’. /"

/ /."

.,

<.: i," :’,-,

~.~. As an affected party living at 13 Wattle Lane Acacia Park, J, the under n state that I am opposed

to the granting of the above Resource Consent application for the Disposal of Overburden.

Applicant: GBC Winstone

The reasons for my opposition are as follows:

Increased dust nuisance.

Potential Health h~~ards caused ~y dust. Noise from continual working of machinery.

Lowering of property values.’

Please note that we are not opposed to the current quarry operation but we are opposed to the

extension of any quarry activities onto the farmland which is the buffer zone adjacent to Acacia Park

boundaries.

~"

Deborah & Ian Coates

3 Gastein Road, London

W6 8LT, United Kingdom

12th July 2017



Subject: Resource Consent Ref LU1700100

Proposal: Disposal of Overburden


Whilst we are not currently residing at our property 13 Acacia Drive, Acacia Park, we would like to lodge opposition in consideration of our current and future tenants residing at 13 Acacia Drive, Acacia Park. We, the undersigned state that we are opposed to the granting of the above Resource Consent application for the Disposal of Overburden. The reasons for our opposition are as follows:

Increased dust nuisance;

Potential Health hazards caused by dust; and

Noise from continual working of machinery.

Please note that we are not opposed to the current quarry operation but we are opposed to extension of any quarry activities onto the farmland which is the buffer zone adjacent to Acacia Park boundaries. Yours faithfully

Deborah and Ian Coates

SUBMISSION ON AN APPLICATION FOR RESOURCE CONSENT UNDER SECTION 96 (1) OF

THE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ACT 1991

To: Whangarei District Council

Submitter’s name: Northland District Health Board

1. This is a submission on an application by GBC Winstone for a Resource Consent for land use. Council Refs:

LU1700100.

2. The application is to place overburden from existing Otaika Quarry onto adjoining land zoned countryside

environment and partially within mineral extraction area, as defined in Operative Whangarei District Plan. The

proposal requires consent as a Discretionary Activity.

The specific parts of the application that this submission relates to are those parts which address air

quality, particularly potential adverse health and amenity effects due to the proposal’s close

proximity (adjacent) to residential area(s), and the adequacy of any proposed conditions of consent in

the event that consent is to be granted.

3. The applicant is specifically put on notice about the following matters:

A. Inappropriate source data – the applicant has used meteorology from locations that our air quality

expert does not consider representative despite the presence of (limited) site-specific meteorology

associated with particulate monitoring.

B. Monitoring data shows occasional exceedance of Ministry for the Environment Good Practice Guide

suggested trigger levels for total suspended particulate (TSP) at a residential site now (i.e. before the

activity commences when existing operations are more than 300 metres distant).1 The applicant

states “the Otaika Quarry appears to be the main source of TSP at the monitoring location”. It is

reasonable to assume that additional activities, in closer proximity, will only increase levels of

particulate at adjacent residences.

C. The applicant has not assessed respirable crystalline silica – an established potential public health

issue for residents adjacent to the applicants’ other quarry in Canterbury.2 These two quarries are

mining the same type of rock (greywacke, which contains silica).

D. The applicant has not assessed particulate matter less than 10 microns in diameter (PM10) against the

national environmental standards for air quality. Elevated PM10 levels are also an established

potential public health issue for residents adjacent to the applicants’ other quarry in Canterbury.3

4. This submitter opposes grant of consent for the application.

5. The reasons for this submission are:

The lack of any separation distance between the proposed activity and adjacent residences;

1 Ministry for the Environment, (2016). Good Practice Guide for Assessing and Managing Dust. Wellington. November

2 Environment Canterbury, (2017). Environmental Compliance News: Working Together to Resolve Quarry Dust Issues.

https://www.ecan.govt.nz/get-involved/news-and-events/2017/working-together-to-resolve-quarry-dust-issues/ Accessed 4 August 2017.

3 Ibid.

https://www.ecan.govt.nz/get-involved/news-and-events/2017/working-together-to-resolve-quarry-dust-issues/

To avoid potentially significant adverse effects (i.e. potential exceedance of health-based standards

and guidelines for PM10 and respirable crystalline silica) at adjacent residences; and

To promote the reduction of adverse environmental effects on the health of people and communities

and to improve, promote and protect their health pursuant to the New Zealand Public Health and

Disability Act 2000 and the Health Act 1956.

These statutory obligations are the responsibility of the Ministry of Health and NDHB

The Ministry of Health requires this submitter to reduce potential health risks by means including submissions

on resource consents to ensure the public health significance of potential adverse effects are adequately

considered by consent authorities.

6. The decision sought is to refuse consent.

7. This submitter is not a trade competitor of the Applicant for the purposes of s.308B of the Act.

8. This submitter will wish to be heard in support of this submission but will not be prepared to consider

presenting a joint case on with others. The submitter is willing to consider participation in any pre-hearing

conferences, or mediation.

Dated at Whangarei this 7 August 2017

Gavin de Klerk, Team Leader Health Environments

For and on behalf of NDHB

Address for service

Attention: Gavin de Klerk

Postal address: Northland District Health Board, Private Bag 9742, Whangarei, 0110

Email: [email protected]

Phone: 09 4304100

Fax: 09 430 4493

CC:

GBC Winstone

PO Box 17195, Greenlane

Auckland 1546

Att: Ian Wallace

From: Mere KepaTo: Mail RoomCc: Cr. Shelley Deeming; Solomon Tipene; Juliane Chetham; Deborah Harding; Jared Pitman; Luana Pirihi;

Robyn Patricia Hembry; Sue Tisdall; Marina Fletcher; Selwyn Norris; Patrick Hilton; Mark Strang; John Paki;Bart & Paea de Reuiter

Subject: WASTE MINIMISATION PLAN SUBMISSIONDate: Tuesday, 18 July 2017 6:56:28 PM

Tena koe ratou ma,Once again, I have not been able to use the online submission form onmy computer. My submission is as follows:

WHANGAREI DISTRICT COUNCIL

WASTE MINIMISATION PLAN SUBMISSION & REGISTRATION

18 July 2017

First name(s): Mere

Last name: Kepa

Postal address: 337 Takahiwai Road, RD1 Whangarei 0171

Best daytime phone number: 094330360

Mobile: Nil

Email: [email protected]

I am writing this submission (ü)

Organisation name: NIL

Have you say about rubbish …

The range of items available for purchase have grown exponentially sincecolonisation was commenced in Aotearoa, New Zealand by Queen Victoria’smissionaries, traders, whalers, sealers, military, police, teachers, land agents anddevelopers but councils, businesses and households’ understanding of theirgenesis has diminished almost to the point of obscurity. Modern commercialendeavours, moreover, may not be of the kind that people have been taught toassociate with waste minimization. The endeavours involve battles fought withthe most bathetic instruments, two-for-the-price-of-one specials, sticker basedbribes like red and yellow tag bargains, and free stickers of the All Blacks, butthey are battles nevertheless, comparable in their intensity and demands tohunting and gathering through the forests of pre-European-Aotearoa. Therefore,the big question is How can the Whangarei District councillors managebusinesses and households’ consumerism with attaining waste minimization orreduction? Most of the councillors’ effort will focus on keeping the Vision sharp

mailto:[email protected]
















and distinct at all times. They will be wise to remember that at the heart of wastereduction lies an imperative which is undoubtedly urgent and simple, namelysurvival. They will be preoccupied with the ancient task of trying to stay alive,which simply happens to require, in a consumer economy overwhelmingly basedon the satisfaction of peripheral desires, activities of waste management that areprecise and rule-bound, regular and punctual, and that honour beauty and nature.

REFERENCE

De Bottom, Alain. (2009). The pleasures and sorrows of work. Australia:Penguin Group. ISBN:9780241143537

Solid waste management bylaw-2013

Te Karearea Strategic Partnership Forum

Noho ora mai na Mere

Language is shared humanity

Ray Tonkin

P/O Box 5762 Wellesley St. Auckland 1141

Ph 0274976026 Email [email protected]

10/07/2017



~._’--"’~"’~

-.1 \ \ 18 ",/ \ \ 1.~:,._......_,_J , /_ ’\ ::..../ .....~ /9

:~,;;’/ RfctvEO /

1 3 JUL 2011

Proposal: Disposai of Overburden

\ :-.. \;/::’;>/ \.... -";’C/L.

." , ’,~ .

/ ~’r \

, ~’..

!.-

Subject: Resource Consent Ref LU1700100


As an affected party being the owner of 17-19 Acacia Drive, Acacia Park, I, the undersigned state

that we are opposed to the granting of the above Resource Consent application for the Disposal of

Overburden.

The reasons for my opposition are as follows:

Increased dust nuisance.

Potential Health hazards caused by dust.

Noise from continual working of machinery.

Please note that I am not opposed to the current quarry operation but am opposed to extension of

any quarry activities onto the farmland which is the buffer zone adjacent to Acacia Park boundaries.

Yours faithfully

,,~- ’IPrivate Bag 90231 Whangarel 0148 I New Zealand

T: 09 430 4200 I 0800 WOC INFO I 0800 932 463 I F: 09438 7632 W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:[email protected]

(~~) ~,~t~~~ l~~

Submission on resource consent OffIce use

This submission on an application for resource consent is made under Section 96 ofthe Resource Management Act 1991. ~

Please complete all sections of this submission fonn includi g~"~EPlease print clear1y. It is important that you complete this fo In" I.

questions about making a submission please contact the dL ~ p’an~;-ritX(n~District Council, on 09430 4200.

If faxing, please mail or drop off the original fonn to Whang~ lei DistrW~1soon as possible. .

r 11\1("’11

To Resource Consents ManagerWhangarei District CouncilPrivate Bag 9023

Whangarei 0148

Details of person(s) or organisatlon~s) making submission

Full name ’o---nA of- ~{Jlh.. VS V, I J Postal address L, 1 ,q Co: C IU &v

I

Phone ((fq) /.., ’J 0 ’> 7/2. Fax

Details for correspondence (if different from above)

Full name

Postal address

Phone () Fax ( )

I am/we are making a submission on the application for resource consent described below $~’ ( /7

Name of applicant W I~ to ..~ Council ref LU 00100

Proposal P ~ ~/I/\ I (J c,/C

It

In generall/we (please y/’ appropriate box)

o Support the application urDppose the application 0 Neutral

The particular parts of the application l/we support/oppose or wish amendments to be made to are (please y/’ appropriate box)

I2whole application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)

A copy of your submission must be served on the applicant as soon as reasonably practicable after service of your submission on Whangarei District Council

061337785 August 2010

,r-,

The reasons for making my/our submission are {AtItI

f +~. ( /I.. Q,h r~~

./2A /fJ- ~ y 0 cJ ~

RECEIVD ~iRi8iji

2017

WHANGAREI

DISTRll.!:::01JNr~.1I . __

Ilwe wish Whangarei District Council to make the following decision

(please fI’ appropriate box and if appropriate give details of the natUf8 of a’!!fOnditons sought) o Approved the application [!J Decline the application

r~

(Attach any additional sheets used)

Appearance at Council hearing In support of submission (please,;’ appropriate box)

0/

....

l/we wish to be heard in support of my/our subm ission (This means that you CM speak at the hearing)

l/we do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you cannot speak at the hearing)

My/our slgnature(s) and date signed

5] IJW 2/7 (J Datemaking submission or person authorised

behalf of person making submission

I! l/we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)

Notes on Council hearings

A hearing may not be held on this application for resource consent in accordance with Section 100 of the Resource

Management Act 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard,

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Management Act 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the application for resource consent, persons who have made a submission will be notified 10 working days before the date of the hearing of the date, time and place of the hearing.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, mediating or facilitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who have made submissions on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.

A copy of your submission must be served on the applicant as sooo as reasonably practicable after service of your submission on Whangarel District Council

061337785 August 2010 2

Private Bag 90231 Whangarei 0148 I New Zealand T: 09 430 4200 I 0800 woe INFO I 0800 932 4831 F: 09 438 7632

W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:mail/.oornOwdC.govt.nz

Submission on resource consent

This submission on an application for resource consent is made under Section 96 of the Resource Management Ad. 1991.

Please complete all sections of this submission form including those on the reverse. Please print clearly. It is important that you complete this form in full. If you have any questions about making a submission please contact the duty planner at Whangarei District Council on 09 430 4200.

To Resource Consents Manager Whangarei District Council Private Bag 9023

VVhangarei 0148

Details of person(s) or organisation(s) making submission

~:~~(~~ ~~~~~cifP~

Phone ( :ll- \ :5 q c:;> Kq l Fax ( )


Full name

Postal address

($\~ ~VHf\NGA~f,1

Office use

RECEIVEDS

CUSTOMER SERVICE

- 9 AUG 2017

WHANGAREIDISTRICT COUNCI

Qcl, 0:’--’ ..rCUp

Full name

Postal address

Phone) Fax ( )

!JI1itlwe are making a submission on the application for resource consent described below

Name of applicant G- g C. \...0 ~~V)es Council ref l-u l CO , oa

Proposal ’\2e.$~..rc.e ~~~\~’0~)

In generalllwe (please ., appropriate box)

[J Support the application ~pose the application [J Neutral

The particular parts of the application Ilwe support/oppose or wish amendments to be made to are (please ., appropriate box)

~Ie application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)

(~~ A,\A~ .


061337785 July 2016

. WHANGAREI

~IV DISTRICT COUNCIL

The reasons for making my/our submission are (Attach any additional sheetll wed)

~~’E.. ~&.


(please ~ appfDPrlate box and if appropriate give details of the nature of any condilions sought)

[J Approve the application ~ine the application


Appearance at Council hearing in support of submission (please ./ appropriate box)

~e wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you ~n speak at the hearing) CI l/we do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you ~nnot speak at the

hearing)

My/our slgnatu

Signature I’NIkIng subminion or person autho Date

J sign on behalf of pereon making submission

p’ I!!’..e have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)

Not.. on Council hearings


Management Ad. 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it I18C8I88ry andIorthe applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard.

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Managem<<tt Ad 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the appIic8tion for resource consent, persons who have made a submission will be notified 10 wortdng days before the date of the hearing of the date, time and place of the he8ring.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Ad 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, mediating or facilitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who have made submissions on the application may be invited to such 8 meeting if held.

Privacy Information

Once your submission illodged with the Council it becomes pubic infonnation. The information will be stored on a

public register and held by the Whangarei District Council. The details of your submission may also be available to the

public on the council’s website.

A copy of your submisaion must be served on the eppIant u soon u reasonably practicable after service of your submlulon on Whengarei District Council

081337785 July 2018 2

SWAGSouthern Whangarei Action Group

9 August 2017



PO Box 11-057

Whangarel Mall Centre 0148

CUE~TO;\iH::F{ SE:h\

Subject: Resource Consent Ref LU1700100- 9 AUG 2017 t WHANGf\I’"\t:\ I

DISTRICT COUNCIL_JProposal: Disposal of Overburden


Swag are opposed to the granting of the above Resource Consent application for the Disposal of

Overburden.

SWAG is an action group formed to preserve and and maintain the safety and general

quality of life in our community and to promote a long term vision for Southern

Whangarei and as such find GBC Winstones proposal to dispose of overburden on the

Pegram Block is not in the interest of the nearby residents, the Blue Goose future tourist

developments nor in the interest of the many users of the sport grounds and the proposal is

in conflict with the vision we have for entrance to Whangarei; we would like to see WDC

to showcase the entrance. GBC Winstones Otaika Quarry is close to entrance to

Whangarei, with the quarry access way on a junction with SHl. The Pegram Block is

about 1.4kms from Whangarei Harbour and about 3.6kms from the CBD and because of

this location the conflicts are complex and numerous.

Overburden is an unavoidable product of quarrying. By its very nature quarrying results in

permanent damage to the landscape. It is large scale and intrusive. By seeking to use the

Pegram Block for the disposal of overburden, Winstone’s operations would intrude further

into the neighbouring communities bringing more adverse effects of dust, dirt, noise, and

vibration in close proximity.

Otaika Quarry and the residents both need certainty by managing incompatible land uses.

A 300 metre interface was established legally during the Acacia Park subdivision consents.

(see Russell Mcveagh’s 1995 letter attachment #1). The MEA buffer around the Quarry,

with the 500m setbacks, precisely and absolutely separate conflicting land uses and thus

should remain.

From GBC Winstones website: ’Non-residential ’buffer zones’ protect neighbours from

noise and dust around our quarries’ - see attachment # 2

’Shelter belts of native trees endemic to the area are planted wherever possible’ -

Contrary to this, we note they plan to plant willows, acacias (blackwood) and

poplars on the Pegram Block.

Other reasons:

1. GBC Winstones is socialising their business problems onto the community: visual

amenity, dust, noise, vibration are a major components of the overall negative impact

and locals and residents already put up with dust and noise nuisance, unsocial hours,

vibrations, blasts, and a higher maximum noise limits.

2. The proposed disposal of overburden on the Pegram Block is excessive- 2.4 million

cubic metres on land that is marked as unstable on WDC maps. This proposed weight

and mass could affect surrounding water courses according to Professor Jarg Pettinga. 3. The timeframe is too long. 35+ years is permanent, not temporary and the adverse

effects could be passed to the next generation of owners.

4. Residents should be able to live in peaceful surroundings. 5. We are also concerned because this could potentially have a huge impact on other

bodies such as the environment and the harbour, visitors and tourists, recreational

areas, and the noise and dust nuisance could be a health hazard and it is highly likely

to devalue surrounding property and making them difficult to sell for over 35+ years. 6. Winstone’s Quarry has been operating for over 50 years. Suddenly overburden has

become an urgent problem with only one solution and that solution has a significant

unpropitious impact on their immediate neighbours. 7. A change to MEA would allow a ~ industrial activity adjacent to well-established

Living 1 and 3 environments, which would not be compliant to RMA amenity and

reverse-sensitivity rulings, on land that is designated L1, L3 and countryside. 8. A Mineral Extraction Management Plan, regarding overburden, should exist viz.

64.3.1, v. The Plan should include the proposed location and dimensions of

overburden storage and deposition areas and stockpiles of mineral material.

Landowners and ratepayers should not be the bandaid to poor business management

nor operational problems. 9. Quarry and residents should be separated by a buffer. Environment Court Winstone

Aggregates v Auckland Regional Council A49/2002 - where it was held that effects

such as noise and vibration could not reasonably and economically be contained

within the site and a reverse-sensitivity buffer was imposed. This means that the

area, the entrance to Whangarei, within 4 kIns of the CBD, about 1.2 kilometres from

Whangarei Harbour.

Therefore it is up to Regional Council, WDC and the Environmental Court, with use of

objectives, structure plans, rules and the RMA(1991) to constrain industrial activities and

manage environmental effects for the health, wellbeing and safety for current and future

generations and because of our concerns above, SWAG would request the local authorities

to support the ratepayers and residents to retain a buffer.

In this case it should be people first. Residents, landowners, rate-payers should be entitled

to certainty and should be entitled to a healthy peaceful existence.

We would like WDC to show case the entrance of Whangarei, with tourism and the

Hundertwasser building, becoming ever more important to the district’s economy. This is

an unique diverse area, there are numerous aspects to weigh up against each other. The

Otaika, Raumanga, Toe Toe Structure Plan 2009 recognises this and identifies a number of

opportunities.

SWAG supports all opposing submissions to the above.

Sources:

Prof. Jarg Pettinga, Head of Department of Geological Sciences,

University of Canterbury.

WDC Otaika-Raumanga-Toe-Toe Structure Plan; 2009

WDC Planners Report on Winstone’s Proposed Plan Change 59 - 2006

Please find attached a few supporting documents

A. ~r~~~\ RUSSELL McVEAGH McKENZIE BARTLEET & COJOHN COlLINGWOOD KING

JOHN OLUVL!\ lU$K

FOSS MICi-IArL SHANAHAN

GEOFFREY THOMAS RlCKlIT5

GERARD PAUL C\JRRY

ANDREW tlAWKSWORTH BROW’

RICHARD ARKLf GREEN

GUY ROliGHAM CHAPMAN

,OH~ rAUl HASUTT OLDFIElD CAMEKo."\IllEMfNC

GREGORY JOHN 5HANAHA....

PATRJCkCAlLAGHAN BOWLER

DEREK ARn1l;R NOLAN

JEF....REy I{UatRI MORRJSO:-.J

CEOFfR,fY DENIS Cl EWS

ROBERT lfO~ARDT()WNFR

ANtHONY FREDERICK (,RAr..;l

fR,ANCI-;XAVIERQLIN DEREK SAMUf.lJOHMTO;\; I’HIlIPCHAKU5CREAGH

LAWRf~C.E STEPHEN MAYNe.

",...DREW WILLI"...... HARMOS

JOHN KOfIERT fORTESCl FARUEll

JOHN MAXWISLt COLLINGS

fREOERICt;. 10H1’\ THORP

,OHN~It;rHEN KGREGORY WIU lAM THOMPSO.....

ALAN STANlEY JAMi:’5A’COURT I’RUDENC’: MARY FLACK..

(’HRISTOJ’HUl I’A T1{ICK BROWNE

SIMON IOH"J BERRY

CEOFFRfY,OK’" HA’U.,EY CHRISTOPHER [’AT RICK F.ISOCI.L "-’CX)R[

MA TTH’EW .-":ICHOlAS OUI’II\INt.;

LANCE HAMltTO"," HEEI\AN

’>AU. GERARl) FOLEY

RICHARD BR1JCf GOLDlNC. MEHRTE"iS

DAVID GEORGE WETHERELL

PHIUrCEORGE SkELTON

STEI’HfN BRl’CE lOWE

PAUL f-RANCIS MAjVREY SHELLEY ANNE HODGE

BE15Y-ANN HOWE

JuS11N BAIN MACRAE SMITH

PAUL Wll.5O:\ DAVID

I’RAVIR ATINDRA TESIRAM

LLOYD M’:THO:\;Y JAMES KAVANAGH

MARK)OHNGAVIN SIMON MICHAEL HOR....JER

CRAEME DAVIDQUIGUY MICHAEL REX CRONI~

KERRYWAVNE FULTO....

ALAN MlRRAY "MERSON

BARRISTERS, SOLICITORS & NOTARIES PUBLIC $0 qZ) 215’THE SHORTLAND CENTRE, 51-53 SHORTLAND STREET,

PO BOX 8, AUCKLAND 1, NEW ZEALAND.

DX CXl0085. FAX 0-9-377 1849. TELEPHONE 0-9-309 8839.

.... ".: . ’-’

;)-~4-793

;G: S. ~ @

IOURREr

I.:: .

4-

RfCF/VfR 2 1 SEP 1995

, / ",

..c..... ~~..>

~- ....

....

DtIJ1<-’U"W1’

YOLR REi

\..~ \. RECORDS I

\:’:~ W.D.C. .~~I "

,< w~......... "/’ "<<,,,# i ~’. . J’

.... "!1,#’ .... _!; l j I,": " /

."-J;.....__..~~ ..,.

CO’5l1lTANTS

ROBIN LANCE CO:..:(.RfVE

ClLIA ~IARY (:AUC\i[Y - (V’~II"’m)

20 September 1995

The District Planner

Whangarei District Council Private Bag 9023 WHANGAREI

PROPOSED SUBDIVISION - D TAYLOR - TAUROA STREET, SOUTBDALE

1. We act for Wtnstone Aggregates Limited (’Wmstone"). Our client has referred to

us your letter of 11 September 1995 regarding the above subdivision on land

adjacent to Wtnstone’s Otaika quarry.

2. Winstone wishes to place on record its concern regarding residential activity in close proximity to the Otaika quarry. Tbe coropa..l1y’S vieVl! is that r~sidentlal a...’1d

rural residential development and quarries are incompatible in close proximity to one another. New residential developments should be directed away from

mineral resource areas, and particularly from operating quarries (as from other forms of industry).

3. The Otaika quarry contains reserves of very good quality aggregate and is a resource of major district and regional significance. The location of residential

development in close proximity to the quarry will have an adverse effect on

quarry operations in that it will constrain the way Winstone normally operates its quarry.

4. As you are aware, the Resource Management Act 1991 ("RMA") imposes a duty on all landowners and occupiers to avoid adverse effects on the environment

aristng from activities carried on by them. The areas adjacent to quarries are

commonly subject to the effe ts of noise and vibration from blasting. With

WELLINGTON OFFICE: THE TODD BUILDING, CNR BRANDON STREET & LAMBTON QUAY,

PO BOX 10-214, WELLINGTON, NEW ZEALAND. OX SX11I89. FAX 0-4-499 9556. TELEPHONE 0.4-499 9555

RUSSELL McVEAGH McKENZIE BARTLEET &t CO 2

residential activity in close proximity to the quarry, Winstone would be restrained

from operating and continuing its long term development of the Otatka quarry in the way it might otherwise do so, particularly in carrying out blasting activities. As the Council is aware, if Winstone’s quarrying activities have an adverse effect

on adjoining residential land, then any owner of that land could bring an action in nuisance or apply for an enforcement order to stop those activities. Permitting residential activities to locate in close proximity to the quarry could therefore

compromise the long term productive use of the mineral resource. This effect on Winstone’s operation of the quarry is a potential effect on the environment which the Council must take into account when considering the application.

5. For a llUmbe.l" of years, Winstone has taken action to ensure that residential

activity does not come too close to the quarry. For example, in the mid-1980’s Winstone requested the Council to include a notation on its planning maps indicating that ground vibration could occur within 1,000 metres of quarry workings. At that time, the need for a buffer area around the quarry was also considered by the Council and it was proposed that this be a matter included in the next review of the district plan. Winstone has also made submissions on the draft strategy documents which have preceded the formulation of a new district

plan. Those submissions stressed the importance of buffering the quarry from

encroaching residential activity.

6. In our view, the potential adverse effects of the subdivision proposal could be

remedied or mitigated by the imposition of a 500 metre buffer area in which no

dwelling units are allowed between the quarry boundary and the subdivision. In its present form, the subdivision plan fails to provide fully for such a buffer area as part of proposed lot 3 and almost half of proposed lot 18 are within 500 metres of the quarry boundary. If the subdivision were permitted as currently

proposed, a dwelling could be erected or a multi-unit development take place anywhere on those lots, bringing residences within 500 metres of the quarry.

7. Winstone therefore seeks an amendment to the subdivision scheme plan so that

no lots for residential purposes are located within 500 metres of the Otatka

quarry boundary. In our view, unless such amendments are ma e to the

subdivision scheme plan, the proposed activity would have adverse effects upon Winstone as the neighbouring occupier of the quarry which are more than minor. In our view, unless the suggested amendments are made, the application w11l have to be publicly notified because it would fail the tests contatned in section

94(2) of the RMA.

8. We also note that there is support for such an amendment to the scheme plan in the subdivision policies contained in the Transitional District Plan. In particular, a subdivision must have regard for the characteristics of adjoining land and the

present and likely future pattern of development of that land.

’..

RUSSELL McVEAGH McKENZIE BARTLEET & CO 3

9. We therefore look forward to your confirmation that the Council has required the

applicant to redesign the subdivision scheme plan to ensure that no lots for residential purposes are within 500 metres of the quarry boundary. or that other

means are found to exclude dwelling units from this buffer area.

Yours faithfully RUSSEU McVEAGB McKENZIE BARTLEET a co

~, t, (;; L0l\~--- Anne BuchanaD

Senior Solicitor

ALA560M

ATTACH~ #2

From GBC- Wnstones website - COMMUNITY AND ENVIRONMENTS

WEARE COMMITTED TO MAINTAINING GOOD COMMUNITY RELATIONS, HAVING A

POSITIVE IMPACT ON THE COMMUNITIES AND ENVIRONMENTS IN WHICH WE

OPERATE, AND LEAVING A NET ENVIRONMENTAL GAIN.

We have been around for a long time, nearly 150 years, and our business is built on long-term

growth and resilience which can only be achieved by integrity and responsible behaviour. It’s

key to our business. We know that our industry has the potential to significantly impact the communities and environments in which we operate, and for people to have both negative and positive perceptions of who we are and what we do. There can be conflicting values between our

industry and the community. A balance has to be struck between the potential disturbance of

operations to our near neighbours, and the requirement for sources of aggregates upon which

society depends. The need to maintain and improve our physical surroundings drives the requirement for

aggregates. The same need also demands, rightly, that these aggregates are extracted and

transported with as little disturbance to the environment as possible. Great care is taken to minimise the effects of our activities on our surroundings, and afterwards to restore our sites to conditions at least as good as, and if at all possible better than they were before operations began. There are many ways we work to be a good neighbour in the community and to achieve positive environmental outcomes:

All management staff at our 26 sites are encouraged to engage in open and active communications with all their neighbours, building strong and positive links with the local

community. In this way, concerns around such issues as environmental management and

operational capability can be discussed and acted upon. At our larger quarries this

process has been formalised through the establishment of Site Liaison Groups. We have public open days and school trips, field trips and excursions on site for students Non-residential ’buffer zones’ protect neighbours from noise and dust around our

quarries Shelter belts of native trees endemic to the area are planted wherever possible We regularly go over and above our council consent requirements to ensure positive environmental and community relations

Sponsorship of community-based events, groups and initiatives.

~--- ! ’.

. -.

"

Private Bag 9023 I Whangarei 0148 I New Zealand

T: 09 430 4200 I 0800 WDC INFO I 0800 932 463 I F: 09 438 7632

W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:[email protected]

(~~> ~~~I~~~)~ (~~

Submission on resource consent Office use

This submission on an application for resource consent is made under Section 96 of

the Resource Management Act 1991.

Please complete all sections of this submission form including those on the reverse.

Please print clearly. It is important that you complete this form in full. If you have any

questions about making a submission please contact the duty plann hangarei District Council, on 094304200.

Details of person(s) or organisation(s) making sub

Andrew Wyon Barclay Postal address

45 Acacia Drive, Whangarei 0110

) 430 8683

CUSTOMER S D

ERVI - 9 AUG 2017 WHANGAREI ICT COUNCIL


Whangarei 0148

ES

Full name

Phone Fax


Full name

Postal address

Phone Fax (

I am/we are making a submission on the application for resource consent described below

Name of applicant G BC Wins tone Council ref L U 1 700100

P ILand Use Consent to place overburden trom eXIstmg Otaika Quarry onto adJommg roposa

1 d d ’d’ t d .

H .

I . .

1 .

i:Ul :l.Ulll:: cuullL.lYl:jl I:: I::llVl1Ullllll::ll iUl piuLu1 Y wIL 1l1l1l1l1ll::U1 I::ALU1CLIUll i1.lI::i1,

ae defiued iu operathTe Whaugarei Diitrict PIau

In generall/we (please ,/ appropriate box)

CJ Support the application rz{ Oppose the application CJ Neutral

The particular parts of the application I/we support/oppose or wish amendments to be made

to are (please ,/ appropriate box)

~ Whole application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)

A copy of your submission must be served on the applicant as soon as reasonably practicable

after service of your submission on Whangarei District Council

061337785 July 2016

’J

.

.. ’tI

The reasons for making my/our submission are (Attach any additional sheets

Increased nuisance from dust

ed)’ _ 9 AUG 2017

" ,-...-..-~

DISTRICT~ o.VI’’’rll

-Long term nature o~osal-=-too-long

--In]mctcrt’ increased noise on local amenity values

I/we wish Whangarei District Council to make the following decision

(please ,/ appropriate box and if appropriate give details of the nature of any conditions sought)

1:1 Approve the application Decline the application


Appearance at Council hearing in support of submission (please ,/ appropriate box)

~ l!we wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing)

I" do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you cannot speak at the

hearing)

My/our signature(s) and date signed

Signature of rson making su ssion or person authorised Date

to sign on behalf of person making submission

. l!we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of

the Resource Management Act 1991)



Management Act 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do

not wish to be heard.

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Management Act 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the application for

resource consent, persons who have made a submission will be notified 10 working days before the date of the hearing

of the date, time and place of the hearing.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for the purpose of clarifying,

mediating or facilitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who

have made submissions on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.

Privacy Information

Once your submission is lodged with the Council it becomes public information. The information will be stored on a



9/08/1 7


061337785 July 2016 2

.,.Private Bag 90231 Whangarei 01481 New Zealand

T: 09430 4200 I 0800 WOC INFO I 0800 932 463 I F: 09 438 7632 W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:[email protected]

~$~) ~’~:C~~~ L~~


To Resource Consents Manager Whangarei Distrid Council Private Bag 9023 Whangarei 0148


:::-. ~CA~~~~~ ,s7t::~~ - ’-’’’’~~ J

Phone (O~7) LfO :::rz 0 I . Fax ( )

Details for correspondence (if dlHerent from above)

This submission on an application for resource consent is made under Section 96 of the Resource Management Ad 1991.

Please complete all sadlons of this submission form including those on the reverse. Please print clearly. It is important that you complete this form in full. If you have ny

questions about making a submission please contad the duty planner at Whangarei Distrid Council, on 09 430 4200.

RECEIVED If faxing, please mail or drop off the original form to Whi h~iiI!)~~ES soon as possible.

- 9 AUG 2017

WHANGAREI DISTPIC-T COU~-ICH..

Full name

Postal address

Phone () Fax ( )

I amlwe are making a-submission on the application for resource consent described below

Name ofapplicant r;. c.. w\ ~<:) o ~6 Council ref l- ) 700 ’00

Proposal D\cs.~o~fTt-- ~ h)t:eB ~tJ D~"-HfS Pec,~ J-DCK.

In generalllwe (please y/ appropriate box)

D Support the application . ~pose the application 0 Neutral

The particular parts of the application l/we support/oppose or wish amendments to be made to are (please y/ appropriate box)

~hole application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)


061337785 August 2010

..., -ri/I!’" ," .

--’:’__"-’.-w’=""’.,-"’~

r;:’::GEJVED

CUSTOMER SERVICES

- 9 AUG 2017

WH ~\.;;!AREI The reasons for making my/our submission are (Attach any addltJo s"et~ COUNCIL

..-- _14 {a 111: ~ W% d 3 L(2U ’U?’ ~ dcwr - ,;,~ ":i’ -’’a r - 4l/\ VO 111 (c.. ac,1t! VV\~ .

, NO ’L ~ ~

of tVlr~ .- [Jl sfv vban an. /fw.--aj N-: .

.

f) fl t 1Stot’\UV CtDf/1 cav~~

aft.p rtUex ~q


(please rI’ appropriate box and if appropriate give details of the nature of a~ oo)Jitions sought)

o Approved the application [B’Decline the application


Appearance at Council hearing in support of submission (please .-’ appropriate box)

o l/we wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing)

a lIwe do not wish to be heard in support of my/our’submission (This means that you cannot speak at the hearing)


q. ~. 19- Date

lIwe have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)



Management Act 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard.


Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, mediating or fa litating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who have made submissions on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.


061337785 August 2010 2

NZ Chamber of Commerce Northland’s submission in support of LU1700100

The Orchard Level One, Cnr Cameron & Walton St PO Box 1703 Whangarei 0140 p - 09 438 4771 e - [email protected]

w - www.northchamber.co.nz

Submission to


Submission regarding:


Council ref: LU1700100

Proposal: Land use consent to place overburden from existing Otaika Quarry onto

adjoining land zoned countryside environment and partially within a mineral extraction

area.

Submission by:

The Chamber of Commerce and Industry Northland Inc.

INTRODUCTION

Since 1903, the NZ Chambers of Commerce Northland has served the needs of the

region’s business community through its public policy and advocacy initiatives and its

business development programs and services. The Chamber currently has

approximately 470 financial members that employ the equivalent of 3600 full time

employees. Our membership includes many business that expect their views to be

represented in this Feedback

We strongly support policies that strengthen the development of Northland businesses

through:

Freedom of enterprise to generate and contribute economic, social and cultural wealth

to Northland;

The development of a market economy in which there is minimal interference

from central and local government;

The strengthening of Northland’s performance as a pre-eminent commercial,

industrial and communications centre.

The Chamber also works to ensure that Northland has a business-friendly environment

where all businesses can grow and prosper because we believe businesses are central to

Northland’s economic development and are the engine of growth.

NZ Chamber of Commerce Northland’s submission in support of LU1700100

THE PROPOSAL

In general we support this proposal.

Aggregate is a significant resource for the Northland region. A sustainable supply of

aggregate is essential for continued development to enable people and communities

to provide for their social, economic and cultural well-being. This is not only required

to provide for building, construction and roading projects associated with growth,

but also to maintain and redevelop existing infrastructure.

The Otaika quarry is Northland’s largest supplier of aggregate and is an extremely

important aggregate resource for the region.

The Northland Chamber of Commerce is concerned that if the proposed overburden

disposal area for Otaika Quarry was declined or even restricted, it may result in a

reduced availability of this regionally important aggregate resource for Northland.

The ongoing supply of aggregate is crucial to many current and future projects in the

Northland region. Further without a secure and efficient supply of aggregate, it may

be difficult for many businesses in Northland to commit to further capital investment

in Northland, or continue to operate at all.

We would welcome the opportunity to be heard on this submission.

Tony Collins

Chief Executive Officer

Private Bag 90231 Whang.rei 01481 New zealand T: 09 430 4200 1 0800 wee INFO I 0800 932 4631 F: 09 438 7832

W: www.wdc.govlnzIE:maiJroornOwdc.govt.nz



Please complete all sections of this submission form including those on the reverse. Please print clearly. It is important that you complete this form in fun. If you have any questions about making a submission please contact the duty planner at Whangarei District Council. on 09 430 4200.

($~~ \\’H;\NG/\~EI

Office use


Whangarei 0148

Details of peraon(s) or organisation(s) making submission

Full name 11,(.( A. itA Y ;s 01’-1 ~ f~ J...;..{ ~ 5 Postal address :?> J ~ c, -"9 c,,1 -4 PIt’cJ/~ Jt/l-ItAN Cc". wfl~~ "" /lE 1011 D

Phone (0’> I/. ’3 8DH~fo Fax ( )


Full name

Postal address

Phone ( Fax (

I am/MUll’" making a submission -em the applicationfor.resouree consent described below

Name of applicant ~ c. WI A..I S r () AI e Council ref L ~ ,.., 00 PO 1+ 1’- (If ’3

Proposal /.. RN LJ U. ~ C"oN ’5 NT

In generalllwe (please ,/’ appropriate box)

[J Support the application ~ppose the application [J Neutral

The particular parts of the application l/we support/oppose or wish amendments to be made to are (please ,/’ appropriate box)

~ Whole application. or (Attach any additiona’sheets used)

A copy of your submission must be served on the applicant aa soon as rusonably practicable after service of your submission on Whang.rei District Council

061337785 July 2016

I..~\ WHANGAREI t~.. DISTRICT COUNCil

The reasons for making my/our submission are (Attach any addItIonII,Meets used)

! <:6:.1’ ,:jJ()flo{ Pc,{$/ 4-/l/()fS/C r~ 1itt!- Q"",JlUf/ A~ ,r 1$ . ,

Itlrt OtVllC{C( ,., CH"N4;’;; ()~ ~~.t?t,,(~1C 4/1L.-&- lP;V~ /I#~ -1P -rN/~ Lc)H/ W/NSrON^-~ S"A..r-P’;~ P IU.~u~ N /~orlfcr

s -rJIIS IS ~ M t:’J 4aQt; Yt!J~ ~$’""~~~ M.,/t1V I ~rW s

"tl() -r ev,l1 ~ ’L ~ OlAf, dtt-’- -r ,/If!!-.

t4C 70 ;C.,-’.. H_-’Z---’i:1’u..-v~IC.’ . ’;I?~e:c;’---.;;c"

H~J ~ 11J ~&.L- C r:. ~T 7’’’’~.(’ 4/"~ ~/&4- ~up -mtC" \ P(lL’,r ~<::’;: evtt;~

l/we wish Whangarel District Council to make the following decision $

(please ""appropriate box and If appropriate give detaila rK"" natufB of any conditions sought)

(J Approve the application ~ Decline the application

(Attach any additiona/8heets used)

Appearance at Council hearing In support of submission (p/eaH fI" 8PPfOPI’I.. box)

[J l/we wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing) ~ lIwe do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This meafUI that you cannot speak at the

hearing)

My/our slgnature{s) and date signed

~(t~.. . Jrf( ~ft-flOI7 or person authorl8ed . Date

on behalf of person making subm..ion .

r;i" l/we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)

Not.. on Council h.arings


Management Ad. 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard.

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Management Act 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the application for resource consent, persons who have made a submission will be notified 10 working days before the date of the heering of the date, time and place of the hearing.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, . mediating or facilitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who have made submissions on the application may be invited to sucl1 a meeting if held.

Privacy Information

Once your submission is lodged with the Council it becomes public infonnation. The information will be stored on a


public on the council’s website. .

A copy of your submission must be seMKI on the applicant IS soon .. reuonabIy practicable after service of your submission on Whangarei DiItrid Council

081337785 July 2016 2

Private Bag 90231 Whangarei 01481 New Zealand T: 09430 4200 1 0800 WDC INFO 1 0800 932 463 I F: 09438 7632

W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:[email protected]


This submission on an application for resource consent is made under Section 96 of

the Resource Management Act 1991.

Please complete all sections of this submission form incloding those on the tev~~e. Please prin~clearly. It is important that you complete this form in full. If you have any questions abtJt:making a submission please contact the duty planner at Whangarei District Council, on 09 430 4200.

,To Resource Consents Manager

Whangarei District Council Private Bag 9023

Whangarei 0148


Full name? e::;k CAr M a.;-..... + (.. "’"’ D b eA

Postal address -rOcL- -rOe." l<.cra..d. R b to

Phone (or) ,~~ ~ 7 ~ z...,S Fax ( )


Full name

Postal address

Phone

i~~\ WHANGAREI "/~~ DISTRICT COUNCIL

Office use

Wh~e..-\’ 0\70

Fax (

I amiwe’ are making a submission on the application for resource consent described below

Name of applicant leA, Be i vJ \ ’v’\.~ ’\-0" ~ Council ref L.tk \..:.+.001 DO

Proposal ~~ LLAJc.,.. ~)e.A.v"\- -+v flA.-ce,.... b\.4N’~ ........ ~~ 0J’\’7~h’",,~ ~~~ ~r o’\+O aJj ;"",’’’’’’f’ ~~ 7~’^’cJ ~~u,,,,,~~ s, e.

.’

In generalllwe (please" appropriate box)

o Support the application ~oppose the application 0 Neutral

The particular parts of the application I/we support/oppose or wish amendments to be made

to are (please "appropriate box) ’’y

~ Whole application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)


06/337785 July 2016

tt~~ WHANGARfl "’,,," DISTRICT COUNCIL

The reasons for making my/_ submission are (Attach any additional sheets used)

I’-’wish Whangarei District Council to make the following decision

(please tI’ appropriate box and if appropriate give details of the nature of any conditions sought)

(J Approve the application u( Decline the application


Appearance at Council hearing in support of submission (please.,;’ appropriate box)

[J l!we wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing)

~ 1/1.1~-~~ wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you cannot speak at the hearing)

’’’’.

My/.... signature(s) and date signed

~"..{, Signature of person making submission or person authorised


uI’ l!we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)

3-’1)- 2..0\7 Date



Management Act 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do

not wish to be heard.

.’

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Management Act 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the application for

resource consent, persons who have made a submission will be notified 10 working days before the date of the hearing of the date, time and place of the hearing.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for the purpose of clarifying.

mediating or facilitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who

have made submissions on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.

Privacy Information

Once your submission is lodged with the Council it becomes public information. The information will be stored on a




06/337785 July 2016 2

I...............’........................................;.~................... ..’ , .~ . ,..’,-,

. ,

. ,--.-:’".: -- ,-:’~

.PrivttI,’. T: Of 430.-01....

w: ,

~~~i ~:ldAN(~J\~FI

OffiCeUM

:1’1*.....on on en~ for .....’.............,...H.,Gf . ;.......~Ad1881.

". .,-.,.

... ~’8 compIett ..lICII ...~/IIIo;_~....._.._....~. . PleM&prlnh:ldy, It.,. :IrnpOrtInt 11,.; .’f’.Hf -.,*’Y’. q&liitIout.tMfdn8..IUbrniIIioI\..... .___..~

.on4342O.

" ’ .

.

’uII fI8tn8

POltlt...... ~G\ \ ’K

.,.. ~) ’t3cg,\~ ~... fOr c~pondenc. (".",.,.,ffom. ...)

Fulneme

PoIW.......

Phone () Fu ( )

lamlW.... makln..aubin_lon on "’;~’for resource,eonaent dMcrtbed below

.......otappttcant :J:~ \- Ck.\::i:>(q,. O~\Wf’ CouncK ref L\N~ , 0’0 ’00

p,.., Ds~o$q\ o O’\IcLX~(ci~~ .

RECEIVED

QMEH SERVICES

kt".....,tlwe (,.... -" appropIItItft-J . /’

C SuI’f,Dlt the application ’

GJ Oppoae....appIicatton a Neutral

The ....... ... of~the ......on u.~..,wteham8ndmenta to be made to... (P..........,.,.",.. box)

. .

, Wttote ~, or (Attach y atJdIIIonSI.".. u

f

A copy of your IUIlllOn rpultbe__on ""~.IOOA-.ntIIOnIly practicable after tervicof your ....IIIOOrtWMnpnti Dietrict Council

0SI337785 July 2018

,r,. ..

9.......1 ..

--.

~.......... for, maldng my/our aubml.........(It......tIfIfIltIouI’....

~\q,,~ J.~~-\ ~""’\.sQ\t~.

~Q.\~\"’ ~C(2..Q, ,CClU.S~"’~\.l($ .t .

~O’S~ ~O~ Cl’\C"o...~"~\Wqx:~~’~).. o rnQc...""NL-t’1

. .""’’’W’fIangarel DIatrlctCOU’.....:...’....tI...tteo..., -

- -

- ’. .

"’1’’’’’’ ’",;’-,,- .

bOx end ..11---...4... . BIi....:.’deIIIIIa’.."of.1fIiIU

.":,::,,. ’._..,..,.

,,.... ......-...... ...,.,....-- ..’ ., ’ .’ .. ’.

"’’’’ --.,-.., . ,- ". , "’", . .

.

IJ Approv4t.. appJclfon .

’Decffne .. """

(AttichanyadclJ#onal.thNts wed)

A........ 8tCouncU........;."’.uppol’tot...........!...... ,;’ .",."".tebox)

i =:":;~:==:~m;:====:;~~ hellrlng)

MyIour..............nd date .tlned

~1IIIImIIi.._.......... \ ’ OJ -’;;}..

to. onOthill of....-n ft’IIIIdnetullni. ’

"1(’ 1Iwe... .....copy of mytour..... applicant(Th18 i8 requlredlJy Section 96(4) of the R..,aMansgement Act’1001}

.

..... on Councll....rlngs

AhearinO may not be hiIId on Chi. appIIQIjIian for reeource CDniM~ with Section 100 of the Resource MInagement ’1981 if the contMt 8UthoI’tty "’not CDntIdeI’ it .....ltyendlthe eppIlc8nt .ndthe submitters do not.wIah to’be hurd.

In ~ WIth Section 101 of the ReIOUR:e MIInafIment’A 1.’, if .,....,. iato be held on the appllclltion for ~00MeIIt; persona Who have made. IUbmIatfon will.. n10 WOrtdng days befont the date of the hearing oflhe date. time end ptac& of the hearing.

~.meeIInp are provided for by SectIon 89 of the ~Management A1981 for the purpoae of cl8rifying, mecor facI’8IDIuIIon of.ny .... ....... to" eppIicIrIon forretOUl’Ce.conaant. Persons who hIVe made aubmfaione on the appIicatIonmeybe InVIt8d to 1UCIh. meeting ifhefd.

Prlvacy’lnformatIon

Once your tubmIeIIon II fodged with the Council it ’**"" publlcwor,nauon; The Intonn8tion witt be stored on a ~bIc regI8ter and held by the WhangareI DistrictCo. The detaIII of your aubmileion may alia beavailabte to the public on the council’. webIIte.

A copyofy~muIt.__on..~’tli)(_...,~pl’llCtfCabll after ...ofyour~or.~.DIItrIct Council

08J33’1’781 July201e 2

CEIVED

CUSTOMER SERVICES

- ’AUG 2017

Private Bag 9023 I Whangarei 0148 I New Zealand T: 09 430 4200 I 0800 wee INFO I 0800 932 463 I F: 09 438 7832

W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:mailroornQwdc.govt.nz

ource consent


Please complete all sections of this submission form including those on the reverse. Please print clear1y. It is important that you complete this form in fuH. If you have any questions about making a submission please contact the duty planner at Whangarei District Council on 09 430 4200.

To . Resource Consents Manager Whangarei District Council Private Bag 9023

Whangarei 0148


Full name -=L..J ~ C- C. fL~/1.:\’" \.A

Postal address J .D . ~t"),{ boq , o’\A \\~

.

Phone (~ 4<:;Ct’1 l l~ ~

Details for correspondence (If different from above)

t:::)W4~ ~

Fax ( )

($~) Wf iAN,l;A~E,1

Dt ~"7_

Full name ~ t-:) f- CL.. ll.o, .Ar....JI:)

Postal address ;26 QeAC-.\A D\..& G, Q.~~CAI b~’ I

Phone) Fax ( )

I amlwe are making a submission on the application for resource consent described below

Name ofappticant ~ \J-..)’~~"ToNt:: Council ref LUl 001 at)

Proposal ’lo ~(.\~. /61j2;>\..4i1.06-J rVl.M 01"A’\LA uJ::VlR..’1

C>J’To A "S Ol~ 1,..,\ t{ "’~

In generall/we (pleas8 ,/ appropriate box)

~pport the application Q Oppose the application I:J Neutral

The particular parts of the application l/we support/oppose or wish amendments to be made to are (please ,/ appropriate box)

[J Whote application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)


061337785 July 2016

~.... WHANGAREI ’W DISTRICT COUNCil

. ~

. .

;- ,

r

,

The reasons for making my/our submission are (Attach any additional shee:. .

~\.\c::&)~~ "-1~"To ~p~ ~ ft QLA~fl.,wf

d)EI1A..,..~~ T ~SuM --rP.Q-r ~ ’^")~ ~\~(Ltc..-r

~PP’-’1 of \~\c.,u "r1’-1 A~ettEe..A""’\ ):q". ~’ ~l\.,J60

~ ~~c.. ~ ~.:?\AA.5 ~~. QJ,~,~ p:v~{J",~ \.IC ~ C,So-r/l.,c-..., ~ ~\-\L~ ~"T"’ ~

Qc..(ouItC$ To f~~n~.

l/we wish Whangarel District Council to make the following decision

(please ~ appropriate box and If appropriate give detaiIa of the natul8 of any condIIions sought)

~ Approve the application a Decline the application

(Attach any additioneI aheets uaed)

Appearance at Council hearing In support of submlsalon (pi.... ~ 8PPfOPI1ate box)

~ IIwe wIIIh to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing) L::r IIwe do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you cannot speaIc at the

hearing)

My/our slgnature(s) and date signed

~-~-- to sign on behalf of person I’n8king submission

a l/we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)



Management Ad. 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it nece8l8ry and/or the applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard.

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Management Act 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the application for resource consent, persons who have made a submission will be notified 10 wor1dng days before the date of the hearing of the date, time and place of the hearing.

.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Ad. 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, . . mediating or falitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the applic8tion for resource consent. Persons who have made submis8iona on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.

Privacy Information

Once your submission is lodged with the Council it becomes public inforrn8tion. The information will be Itored on a public register and held by the WhangaAti District Council. The details of your submission may also be available to the public on the oouncIrs website.

cv/~/I/ Dale

A copy of your submission must be served on the applicant as soon .. rwaonebIy practicable after service of your submIasion on WhMgarei DiItrid CouncIl

061337785 July 2018 2

Private Bag 90231 Whangarei 01481 New Zealand T: 09 430 4200 I 0800 wee INFO 1 0932 4631 F: 09 438 7632

W: www.wdc.govt.nzIE:rnailroornQwdc.govt.nz

~$~~ VVHAt~GA~f I

Submission on resource con.ent Office use


Please complete all sections of this submission form including those on the reverse. Please print clear1y. It is important that you compl ny

questions about making a submission please con i

District Council on 09 430 4200.

To Resource Consents Manager -7 AUG 2017 Whangarei District Council Private Bag 9023

Whangarei 0148


Full name -.DAMOtJ AND MAt<AMA KE"/TE

Postal address 2. WA’TTLE LANE , ACAc.IPt PA~K., r<PtAMANGA.. WHf\tJ~I.OIfO

Phone --"B) 4~O o08 Fax ( )


Full name

Postal address

Phone ( Fax ( )

..HIniIwe are making a submission on the application for resource con.ent described below

Name of applicant G- c. W\f\lS’fot’lE Council ref ~1I-(2<:r3 Proposal G-OC W\~srOE :)EEK "’f" PftQV\OE F~ ’THE t>LACEMJ9IIT OF Ove~&leoEN

AtoM THe o1’J\nCA CiUAft’i ot-( 11-\6. PEGttAM l.QC.\(

In generalllwe (pleae ,/ appropriate box)

[J Support the application S Oppose the application [J Neutral

The particular parts of the applicationJ/we I -nloppose or wish amendments to be made to are (pleae ,/ appropriate box)

’" Whole application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)

A copy of your submission must be served on tl18 applicant as soon as reasonably practicable after service of your submission on Whangarei District Council

061337785 July 2016

I" WHANGAREI ...~V DISTRICT COUNCIL

The reasons for making ./our submission are (Attach any addltlona’ sheets used)

NO \.1SINfSS St-b.UD BE At5tE 1’t3 Pur CHIlOC’S HEAt.:J1.f. \t4 :JJtPAC2O’i

--n-\tt.OU~ OUST E"MMI5’SIONSr 1"HE PEGrZAM LOO( wPtS IN IT,AlL’" A

FFEe ’l.CNE. W\o-itl\T’s CHA~O?

rwER UWZOEN \S Pt Wf\STE~OUer ~ ,~~ ’F ~E f\.AW IS A-~\IIro

W.\LL E OUMPEO Pfr#fE...~NcENfW 1’l)..oue .CIT’/. DOW!! wANT" "O.\\Sowoutt 0002STeP. w "$fu’-\ES \-.fAVE~~OE NO ATMPT" 1"0 LoK

ELS~E~ "’1’C,) OUMP THIS WASf’C p ooucr NS’TH’S IS 7HE’~ CHEAPESTOpnoN J


(please fI" appropriate box and if appropriate give detaDs of the natul8 of any conditions sought)

[J Approve the application ~ Decline the application

(Attach any additioneI aheets used)

Appearance at Council hearing in support of submission (plea. "’appropriate box) 1t\\S~’1d

j~. l/we wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing)

lIwe do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you cannot speak at the

hearing)

Mylour signature(s) and date signed

Q.(.\f’J.1;- N\~~ . signat~rson making ~~ or person authorised

to sign on behalf of perIOI’IlNIking aubmiaaion

[J l/we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)


A hearing may not be held on this application for reaource consent in accordance with Section 100 of the Resource

Management Ad 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard.

In accordance with Section 101 of the Resource Management Ad 1991, if a hearing is to be held on the application for

resource consent, persons who heve made a submission will be notified 10 wor1dng days before the date of the hearing of the date, time and place of the hearing.

Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Ad 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, . mediating or facilitating reeoIution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who have made submissions on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.

Privacy Information

Once your subm is lodged with the Council it becomea public infonnation. The information will be stored on a


public on the councirs website.

o~ log} 11 Date

--~;

A copy of your submission must be seMld on the applicant as soon as reuon8bly pl8Cticable after service of your submission on Whangarel DIstrIct Council .

061337785 July 2018 2

Private Bag 90231 Whangarei 01481 New Zealand T: 0943042001 0800 WDC INFO I 0800 932 463 I F: 094387632

W: www.wdc.govt.nzlE:[email protected]

I~~\ WHANGAREI ~I~ff DISTRICT COUNCil


This submission on an application for resource consent is made under Section 96 of the Resource Management Act 1991.

Please complete all sections of this submission form including those on the reverse. Please print clearly. It is important that you complete this form in full. If you have any I \ " questions about making a submission please contact the duty planner at Whangarei/

-

District Council, on 094304200. / ’....

’1./;7 If faxing, please mail or drop off the original form to Whangarei District Council as __I soon as ossible. !


Whangarei 0148


..-\ ..’:1’

’1 \.........

...

RECEIVED S .JUl 2017

Full name \-1.~<; r ~Y-I s hn e H- all,’"" .eA1

\..t ()W")a \< aD R 0’, R D 3 J Whan.5 Qr ~ ) O~1 :It. \G\ 125 Fax -

Postal address

Phone


Full name A-<; a.\’o \I-e

Postal address

Phone () Fax ( )

~/we are making a submission on the application for resource consent described belowName of applicant G-Bc. IN I ’’S1011e

Proposal Lof0 USe.. C.OI"l.se.n~ -tv

Qhi.ko QUQ((~ OM-O adjo ni~ In generall/we (please ,/ appropriate box)

o Support the application QI Oppose the application 0 Neutral

The particular parts of the applicatio@e suppo~ppo~r wish amendments to be made to are (please ,/ appropriate box)

Council ref LU I 00 lOO

place. oVMbuvden ..f(oM ev..ISfItj- land 2~ coun-W’j&ide.

E!JWhole application, or (Attach any additional sheets used)


06/337785 August 2010

..

The reasons for making my/our submission are (Attach any additional sheets used)

\ Woulr1 \Ik<. ~ ("~C:~"d,..l V’V’Ij opp ~ ..h’on +-0 & r W\n5h:,n~~ ~Y"")d

ObI’" CoV’>__..e.....+ 4-n ~I~(’ ~ otlf".f’bu...rle.n from ~ OkU\<"C GUQr-nJ ,?nro h->t: _lCtnd C\.dj tV1ln9 A LaC-let {/c.rk s-r~t-l"’ me... r.e51d.~Hk o~ ttCQCla PCt~

pu.n:1--.C(~e -th~<;e. pro~f’:’:.,...h~<.: In ’3D.d. .,::;r.+-h. eCCl.~sf" fh~j e.vu ~e4 -H-1~ "’LUra’ \..l.Kook.} \Ji~c;. CiV\d p~~ ~.d 0/-11 e1- +0 t::Ire&l p,.... u1de,..l.

::1,~:1~’:’*":::’~’: ::~=~ ~~~~:~~~I~,""~:-~1-b~~ DY’\ct --th~s. is no~ .f. lr .to -\-h~..".

I/we wish Whangarei District Council to make the following decision

(please ~ appropriate box and if appropriate give details of the nature of any conditions sought)

o Approved the application B Decline the application


Appearance at Council hearing in support of submission (please ,/ appropriate box)

o

~IIwe wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you can speak at the hearing)

IIwe do not wish to be heard in support of my/our submission (This means that you cannot speak at the hearing)


Signature of p~ 1~~

or person authorised


o I/we have served a copy of my/our submission on the applicant (This is required by Section 96(4) of the Resource Management Act 1991)


A hearing may not be held on this application for resource consent in accordance with Section 100 of the Resource Management Act 1991 if the consent authority does not consider it necessary and/or the applicant and the submitters do not wish to be heard.

’~..J.;. \’ Date


Pre-hearing meetings are provided for by Section 99 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for the purpose of clarifying, mediating or facilitating resolution of any matter or issue relating to the application for resource consent. Persons who have made submissions on the application may be invited to such a meeting if held.


06/337785 August 2010 2

wdc.govt.nzwdc.govt.nz/BuildingandProperty/ResourceConsents/... · Name Bryce Allen Address 13...

Documents

Transcript of wdc.govt.nzwdc.govt.nz/BuildingandProperty/ResourceConsents/... · Name Bryce Allen Address 13...