Way Forward For Juniors R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
-
Upload
richardschodde -
Category
Documents
-
view
302 -
download
5
description
Transcript of Way Forward For Juniors R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
The way forward for the Junior Sector in difficult times
A Case of When the Going Gets Tough?
Richard Schodde: MinEx Consulting
AusIMM Technical MeetingMelbourne, 7th July 2009
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Overview
• Review how the Australian junior explorers responded to the bust in the late 1990s– Who disappeared and how did it happen?
– Who were the winners and losers?
• Using data from the published reports identify the spending and cash raising patterns of the Juniors over the business cycle. From this make projections on:– Likely future level of spending and where its going
– How many companies are under stress and who might disappear
• Comments on how the industry can rise to the challenge
2
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
December 1998 versus December 2008
• In December 1998 there were 215 junior mineral explorers listed on the ASX . By December 2008 this had grown to 554 companies
…. But 425 of these are new entrants, with only 154 of the original 215 companies lasting the distance
3
Question - What happened to these companies, and what lessons can we learn from them?
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
In recent years a large number of Junior Explorers have entered the market
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
Dec-92 Dec-94 Dec-96 Dec-98 Dec-00 Dec-02 Dec-04 Dec-06 Dec-08
Deletions
New IPOs
4
Number of Additions/Deletions in Quarter
Source: MinEx Consulting based on ASX dataNote: Data excludes IPOs for Producers
Caution No data on Deletions prior to June 1998
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
The industry has gone through a major boom-bustLevel of exploration in Australia: 1992-2008
5
Total Expenditures (2008 A$M) Total metres drilled (Million)
Source: ABS 8412.0, December 2008Note: Data reported on an annualised basis
1997
2007
Expenditures down 50% from
peak in 1997
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
But the situation wasn’t as bleak as it first appears
• Of the 215 Junior Explorers that were around in Dec 1998, only 28% of them disappeared
• Of the 61 Junior explorers that disappeared, the main factors were:
46% were taken-over
25% were promoted to Producer status
2% relocated overseas10% went bankrupt
19% turned into Dot-Com companies
6
These are what investors want !
Ie 16 out 215 Junior Explorers ultimately became Producers. This gives a conversion rate of 7%
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
And much of this didn’t happen overnight
• In December 1998 the average age of the junior explorers was 5.6 years. Those that ultimately disappeared, lived on for another 6 years
…. Giving a total average life expectancy of 12 years
7
This is comparable the average life expectancy of a dog (8 to 15 years)
Source: ABS 3307.0.55.001, 2008
In 2007 the median period between marriage and divorce in Australia is currently only 12.5 years
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Winners and losers in the last downturn
Winners• Those companies who used new approaches to exploration to find the
elephants:
– Minotaur (Prominent Hill), BeMaX (Mineral Sands), Moto (gold in the DRC)
• Those companies who had the vision to take strong positions on big company discards:
– Oxiana (Cu/Au at Sepon) and Indophil (Cu/Au at Tampakan)
• Companies that had the vision to be first into a neglected commodity
– Fortesque (Iron Ore), Paladin (U3O8)
Losers• Dot-Com companies
• Those companies that went to sleep and missed the subsequent boom
8
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
The key challenge facing junior explorers
• Because most junior companies are still at the exploration stage they need to continually raise money to fund their programs
– Lower commodity prices makes it harder to get a project into production or sell the project
– The Global Financial Crisis has made it harder for exploration companies to replenish their funds
9
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
ANALYSISHow did companies survive the last downturn?
• Using data published by the Juniors in their quarterly reports to the ASX it is possible to determine long term trends in the:
– Level of cash available
– Typical rates of expenditure (and where it goes)
– Average life expectancy of a company if no further funding becomes available
10
The analysis was used to make observations on how the industry survived the last down turn and develop strategies for companies going-forward
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Snapshot of cash position of Australian Junior exploration companies: end-March 2009
12
Note: Survey based on random sample of 256 junior explorers listed on the ASXof which 168 were active end-March 2009 out of a total of ~550 companies
A$ Million
Median cash position is $2.10m
(ie half of the companies are above/below this figure)
Source: Derived from Company quarterlyreports lodged with the ASX
Average cash position is $9.1m
Quartile 1Quartile 3
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Change in cash position: 1998-2008Sample of Australian Junior Exploration Companies
13
A$ Million per company
Note: Survey based on random sample of 256 junior explorers listed on the ASX between December 1998 and March 2009
$2.10m
Even in tough times it is possible
to raise money
$0.62m
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Change in expenditures: 1998-2008Sample of Australian Junior Exploration Companies
14
A$ Million per company
$1.34m $1.49m
$3.38m
Note: Expenditures are reported on an annualised basis
Company expenditures have been halved in the
last six months
Source: MinEx Consulting
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Cash burn rate for Australian Juniors(Years)Annualised cashflow divided by cash reserves
15
Years
0.60
1.14
Median life expectancy remains at 1 year
Source: MinEx Consulting
Without additional funding, a quarter of the industry will go out business within 6 months … but that’s nothing new !!
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Sources of Cash by Junior ExplorersBreakdown of total cash income
16
Caution: Numbers are based on total cash raised for the entire survey group, and so the overall percentage split by activity is influenced by the actions of the larger companies
Most cash is raised from share issues after the initial IPO
Source: MinEx Consulting
AVERAGE NUMBERS
Breakdown (%)
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Uses of Cash by Junior ExplorersBreakdown of total cash expenditures
17
Most cash is spent on exploration and
development
Caution: Numbers are based on total cash expenditures for the entire survey group, and so the overall percentage split by activity is influenced by the actions of the larger companies
Source: MinEx Consulting
AVERAGE NUMBERS
Breakdown (%)
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
One possible industry response
19
What bears do in hibernation
“What do directors of speculative companies do during bear markets? It’s rather like asking what Collingwood supporters do during the cricket season or what soldiers do when peace breaks out.
In the case of Blue Sky Mines, the Directors have sensibly contracted the company’s activities so that it has been running purely on administrative costs for the past six months. A shareholder at the Annual Meeting last year described us coarsely as management fee-bludgers and was expelled from the proceedings.”
Source: The Official History of Blue Sky Mines by Trevor Sykes 1996
Pierpont
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Where is the money being spent?Expenditures on Exploration + Development versus Administration
20
Note: Refers to Median CompanyExpenditures are reported on an annualised basis
$0.91m$0.79m
$2.48m
$0.42m$0.68m
Money into the ground has been sacrificed
Currently half of the Junior’s funds are spent
on admin/overheads
A$ Million pa for the Median Company
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Five key tips to Survival1. Work hard on developing a loyal shareholder base
- Frequent communication. Send hard copies of your Annual Report
2. Raise money when you can- But need to pin it to a good story
- Keep the project ideas coming forward
3. Keep head office costs to a minimum- Share costs with like-minded Juniors
4. Incentivise your staff- Reward them well and give stock options
5. When spending money on drilling, make sure it’s well spent by camping out with the drilling crews
- Spend time developing good relations with the local community
21
Source: Rob Annells, Executive Chairman of Lakes Oil,as quoted by the Garimpero, Age 13 Oct 2008
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
SUMMARY – The Industry faces tough times
• The industry is midway through the down cycle
– If the last downturn is any guide, expect expenditures to drop by half from the 2008 peak
• Without fresh funding, a quarter of the industry will close down within 6 months and half of the industry within a year
… but the real story is not that bleak
22
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
But history shows that the Industry is made of tougher stuff
• Junior Explorers have always operated with limited cash reserves and short time horizons
• It has faced similar challenges in the past and survived– However some companies will still fail.
– My guess is at most 20% of the juniors could disappear within 12 months
• The down turn also impact the service providers– Drilling activities and analytical activities may drop by half
– State Government drill funding programs will soften this blow
23
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
Looking forward take advantage of the opportunities
• The current climate creates great opportunities for acquisitions and consolidation
• History shows that great companies are born in adversity
• Need to focus on what’s important - success comes to those with a strong vision to find quality assets. – Now’s the time to hire that “gun” geologist, look in the greenfields for
the next giant deposit, buy the next “Sepon”, or take a key land position in a neglected commodity / country
24
MinEx Consulting Strategic advice on mineral economics & exploration
CONCLUSIONS
• The key to survival hinges on the Junior’s ability to raise fresh money from its existing shareholders
• To earn the shareholders’ trust, companies need to continue communicating their vision/strategy . Most importantly, companies need to deliver good exploration results
• The risk is that, in the race to conserve cash companies are cutting back on the expenditures in the field. You can’t make discoveries if you don’t drill holes !
25
The industry will rise to the challenge !!