Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals...

45
FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7. Statement of Additional Grounds for Review State of Washington [Rule 10.10(a)] IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON DIVISION I Respondent, v. Appellant. I ^ov\AS»ts^ fl i^vfc^i, have received and reviewed the opening brief prepared by my attorney. Summarized below are the additional grounds for review that are not addressed in that brief. I understand the Court will review this Statement of Additional Grounds for Review when my appeal is considered on the merits. Additional Ground I \ y\ ^ffi <ed Vw -g.. A-.ss \ ^A-x-y-e < oL CIoQvaS -e\ * Additional Ground II If there are additional grounds, a brief summary is attached to this statement. Date: S^.^\ 33*, ^-DiS C^atae Court ofAppeals Cause No. Th-D^l ® ^~ STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL GROUNDS FOR REVIEW

Transcript of Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals...

Page 1: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

FILED

September 30, 2015Court of Appeals

Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for ReviewState of Washington [Rule 10.10(a)]

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF

WASHINGTON

DIVISION I

Respondent,

v.

Appellant.

I ^ov\AS»ts^ fl i^vfc^i, have received and reviewed the opening briefprepared by my

attorney. Summarized below are the additional grounds for review that are not addressed in that brief.

I understand the Court will review this Statement of Additional Grounds for Review when my appeal

is considered on the merits.

Additional Ground I

\ y\ ^ffi <ed Vw -g.. A-.ss \ ^A-x-y-e < o L CIoQvaS -e\ *

Additional Ground II

If there are additional grounds, a brief summary is attached to this statement.

Date: S^.^\ 33*, ^-DiS C^atae

Court ofAppeals Cause No. Th-D^l ® ^~

STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL

GROUNDS FOR REVIEW

Page 2: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

_ _ _ m^nzsss-.&L

___„ .JsA^SAM^^A JQ^a&lXlNL_J^^_

S.L&^~--^^

..JC^LJ^_S?..Cisp_iac£\._•§. *;CX-

JW.

"3o \A isjlsclM. &N0 C>£,3 \

..A.^^je_Vv.C>v^-

...Q.H—&.£££&*—£.aoj^X^^

AH£-„__&§lfcSasBSsfcE-.J^Mc.^x.^i^cfis^.So^l*

J2^Lfiri&.£^^

I^feQM D- ANTE'S I

_.A^jeA\e^L_.__...<^Nc^\\.<9Si<yv_5bioN%-i C<^cf£eft©_->..Cj£.dd[.«L<

...VS.2jC». £«L^.«L Cfjs^[ ^.^ _

Page 3: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

-A—

<b

d

-\

Vft^LLfc.. O-sp Co^\fek}"\S

/

_ A ^>^.vcg.^..r^y^.T ©» &&Qa3>.-

„ J. Pc^AvX^ VooAV-xcy^ - - C

4. _rLr\«^X "S^acX^^- A^vA^WJ-^- ,qLJ)i^r^ovx -. -^. U

_S.. ...i;(^..S.ff.^c..-^v/^, ^SSvsW^c^ oL _C:QvJAS<\r..r. QJ

___& J^.mJ^ ^jL3,J2sLSj^^s^^r_ Q^i^^^...-..^.^—J^*>'J Pr..9..s?..«rJS-i^fe^£i Ma^1^s2s^A^l„.^

A^CgVArAEMT

I _:\..\-\E ^^V^U ^feCbyfc., W^tOfrgjftfoLE. ^^\C -Z.< Z,vAcn^

^u^ To 9^o9fe.?-L-i (WL^t TVfc. ?»vJv.L£. ^L AcAlb)

X^-fe...M\Q^.C) \.yAQJL^\^eMCfe? .^gs^A^fe^.^H \^A.Sr...._

_^fe?E8fe^.%J^X_.liiSs: Coh^^X...^

_.A^^U.^^X.^ fe^A^^.^.L....ibL.l^_-^^

. __ ___. __ _ __ __ __ , __ _ l£

.2 XIV\&, r^SsivBi, co^a:,.„..£ftik^^iD. A.b^^s^.Xi.^^r\^_.ffci&..

\ i4£)vk\^ fts> no A CotQEUcT <£>*P VKlftfc&£.sT 9K3 TV^

_?.6rKC ^Z-JIyi^J^^id^J^lvni'Ji A^^v^il^feS-CQ^J^^k^^

^ce\^eo ftsto VHLEl£> _ — \^

Page 4: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

w

\ft-(^U£. E^ CotOTfc-NTis. Ccoiq-v-q)

-t^oro^q^ <g\w\c?\ crX\V\qc~^,^A. vMg\^^<,x"

*3> iNgL^^C^NJfc. ASfbVS^^iC.^ (<^ CC>aN5fcL- As>*>\GiNfc.P

F^Hg-ft To OfeTsfc.C.-'t To 9^e)S&.cg"\^Ks /-£^Q\>vlCi falrtlfc-

j^s filMTk £G±4£L&_^a_£e±!^^

To t)\sckn^ /Hx. E^oejo.se ^^eiopeo tc> vA^fc-./tertw

. Di^J^iMWtXJ^^

VW^cWuoQ fl-UJLqEJ) vl\C7\r^ C^^A&VM^--^.XlJ

J^.e^vJ^_jTvAi^^

J^a&L._J^;^£i^^

^AADjce Jjjft^^^

Ej3£j&_j£fch>$L_kSS^

AL:sLvD.&i^C£^ - -

jf^^__Cj»ji^^

._ .T^^._.&e»s^ — _Xsa_l

Page 5: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

J>_ Co/\ic4usvo./y. ^>-

J AvSUfc, O? A^\Vo^ti^s

V\i A^>W\ M<h 7 Q M .Cfl Sfcga.

Srt^'A'y vi Ao^^aQV>.,

\5.5L vA^ ^ 3l\

•fbT0*^^-, ^ Qob\-

i :%% ^a_j£^>__s£2>_

^-V°v^-g- S4 _S..sAJ^v.^eferq

i.^%_.^-._^

S>A"cx.A: -c yj y=x y<-.\c . Wycy."-^

A?-k \fcX-v /A^-f__3J7.

"Sa-Vc^-^ \5 ^b -g^y <"-g Xi

%.^ .Jn-Y^. _£5^_30.&.*_55>7„.

g>V«^--e. \j, -^-caps*

S.%S VJl^. _/9=^fLJ^>aS.

SA^X^\J TAca cv* c^v

5"^ \X^ XhooS>t^..

Page 6: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

l£^as£^-jS£i_Jk&3J±s^^

e>v-~x<_ m eg-c^<- O'yfeo)

^6" NiOi^ ^a 4^

S>-\c^:k:<~ ^ A-«^v^c- s.

4V7 v\s ^-7, 4^ L. aa A?l 2>ifL,-

f^-YcC^-d. \J *S> oAvn-€.^-fas,• ir~ - •J"""~*"* ™~.™< "-"n ii. .Tin •,~,l,l • ..li.. ..— .. .,—T1—ll«..—. II II...,.,— -

T-

/4g wirx aa ^.'lo

C"*" \ S.

^3i^^_jvb^L_j&a^_S

^•Wt-<, si g>-o^«.

I£L£L-^6Aj*_j9£$_^^

SAgXg- Vj_ ^Lg\S.. rg

A.3_._-A/>l-,._JL^LXjk.

•s>-V«=^<- \J Ol^Co^

icl<9s sm^ru a^i 1%*+, ^k ?. a^..(P&.l

•=sA-^X •g, vi 00 *t c 0 q.-i.^A.gi_

fo-o. va^ ^|_-^gjL

Page 7: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

A Ai ACnMr^iOTs g»*r <o_gj^u

\ .' .Vys..^_ jC-.^^^y^.A^^.. „ s^^-S" .Sr=?..fNS?.-«?-.?^ .....cS^a.

XA' ..C-j^s... <_:...; _ck o c-^r..' n.^-a e^.

jj _ __ _.2_.s. .XX^ XyA-X^..-.Xv/N^A°\-<L:./.-_ .^X?^°<;i.^\^-- X^^.rA.

4 c=^._S=rL^.S?..-«r-,=A W\.^ e=^.\..2».?i-.c.^e-,^k<?."r>. S=5-a £-s=JCs\-^^ "\^==-.

-Vpx.Q9erAq_„.c^09\nW ^jc cj^<U ^^ ./k>4LX)

..._ SbXv^Av-^n^A Cso.«^?A _.Ap^A>^A-. ..-X<=>*hsA vC-e^ \-=<fe?. \? sp..^^-? V^AXXi ©L .Co^r^AA^t ^J-

l...s..^.X^c..-<^r...s.i cs^At.. ^ -tVsfA. ?5X, ok.<X~-<^:^Xcv-tX X.A *X Xo^lA<^

_X TAX>.^. _.A^XsX C,0>A.<X.. .>si\JQ.\si..<^_.(dcS |̂̂ -^_4.5ir.<A,^^.,..Q.x.s?C.^.S.^ ....'C.\X^dA is2ri_j£^\\!-^l_i«-. dkS.LV5?!?

;! _*5 "X\^- -V-a-X .Cow.d A^\\^X .X=AT "~ """ " NJ.1.CAA.Si.'̂ V-20-S..^=.... Xa.^ .^^y..l_c^ «=i==iC.^=-. Xr^..^rv AXA^^X<X .AB

I I

S^3.«— <=** ^."=-v\t^s\ X-A «r= cA.

J I

j.!..!!

=ES.."'vXn^sA, XrA:..«=. x=^_ ..AX>..X\..'..

Page 8: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

£>

x

Px^srE, w.o.:i.£: .MX^T^msr^^

k£-_.S.e^.^fc»^^

:_kCHft4-^^

^ yfl7&ME-N>T €M^ ADDl^toKflU- CtoUMOs

XArv^ .(T\.cy^..n2..c ©•-£- Afcv-^-. «^V\^v-^.4 .nXAX-^ A^_^._>v:

.V>^_^_^__ X\<gXs__i vcAv^vX -iSrSi'vc^.^.io-C.^s../ ..A^.-«=5r.....<^V.^.<?\oc\3.Ci.!».^. V\c\s/^

-<->_SS V^.?s^X ^___Y^_. M

c?L o.cevAgbc^Jfi^^ Xxb\e-<£_ \^ loo^-aovo.

_=____»____, VslW__r..____cXvX^

.3^\\.Ss >_Jj_5-5:..ri ,_rSAA^-*X-Cii^.

AX jX^S. A_5_L___sX<_-t. A5LSiS-.S_-<3S!iCi.d Q-SFsSL-^r,.S> <iXrc AV\g>3.^

.:_r^\\.oX_^>_!>_. _<e__*._s..cA Lv^._ Xo_^axi_--SlS^=sXi

j^_^j^^\_j3^d^j^^--„iss^>^ <_XX____i„._A jqX_...v~a^_5??K\.VCS

f

„ri Sv_.Ov^.c^. ......Vv-e.. •^Xo^. v^a-^- YAQTyyvcX, Q^£o^S-\

s*„\>^„«_ci atCc..«^§ :A3=> -\vx-g_ VxO'JvS-g-; oAV\<2_sr ~\vNg-N.-i \^q

.cAv<~_s^^ ___ .

X^S^X.. ^At^^Xs^spX „Xs?.. .A^_^...c^^QA^^-^-5C_fe^-.--.Ty^.,

r\o\r\o. .<-?,

S<__.:_=

\~_Ar

Page 9: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

*,

VsA gA_S cca c- _s.c_...-_-L _o ^^^^^JOJ^^-^^^sT^^jC^S^L-.

A___A^-f=_^^

^GyP1 ^g-cr\ W-n X-g-s- O^O-^ O^cA-c-/ "-5.^^-, v\-e.vJ-<--r X-V>\ ca^»-

^OcA^, -^g-sj-g-y/v V>-g--r C_-x^--v WAy.X^>H____C- cTA^-A. Sa^-t-- v^-e-vJ •«

SX-'g-yx-K •^Wc-QnA'X- <=^-^\~\ <-__>-g--^«^v '̂=?A <g^\-S-->'Ov.<-\XA C.g-.0»r\3XA^\g\;

•zb^-g- ^<~-<-_-oQ Q> O ^<^aX\~NCx v_C_\Vx Arw-X ^-^aAtXA-_i;

v\\ov-\^\ c-A-€-<rAf L-o\\^-eLxr gg\^\cA t,^oV\o^=d^ XsArrA:, -Cj5-y-_-N_-^A-_-_.-gr;

vx_VW gv-.-ofVlD^ <gX V\•^c ^-_-gvcA^ oygy<-. Ag-L.A-_L_r\-<-0 '̂~ oAgXsh.

\^\ <s.vj-e_c-i CrNxA^SA&A p ros.<.c.v>Xq--v------1-_i--^

..r.-e.-cf/tA\r-e-5 -\v>-___ 'SfVcXr-x__-. X g co.s_<;._.b-.^i__-_L___----^^

Xq^>A<X ^XcA A^g-U.v\o\Q.'!-i WsyS <"-r^XA^^A__-__rl-___^^

x:-._\-A________I\____>____CX

__!_bA_^AA5_vX^_.X____- ^<)r^ \\ T^^c^As. ^ As

vk_c\<~, C<5,^Ov.c\----__jL o>L ccyp-g- oJL.cx,_ g^\AX._..^X^^

_7v~__g\ -gK. S^e-V-sjAc^ "X-\-c_- ,D^\^> _S \C-\ cs^ -£<-ov~\ -\w-e__ CVv\\c\ S-e_-X.-\<-.

c=\s&^x<=K.}k cvv^c <Sr<«-=.o^<. -Vq-^AaX^^ -B-_^.-_\X^j^o^ 5t.\z_SQ"X\^g-cr-e- vxo eA x-_X *"" A\\>'-<_ v^\-e-cAvci_c--A ^J vcj-t.'A.C.-g-,._\.\^&

s\<_c. -<A 5 W Ava\^ cr-vfa,.>o>\_?-e. /^g__.j_________^_aj&^_^^ s_L

c-\'-___^ai___ -<_ -<£_-r-<--\s_r\-.

U Ctg.\ 5WJC yj 3<^is^v. L^Sl^S^^j^]-^-^AW"!^ «k\ XX ft^y. 43S,.. g.lX.g:_..XgL7^ JL^^c^V-AS^-hc\ -g-£J__js^\_________C^ ~${ _C__-_-__Aj--A^^

_X_A-_-_-V_-_A---a-_-^^ -B--_--a-^-\-----i-_----^^

X_Y.:_=L___-^^

X-!__-S_-t-_-y_^_-2-____^___S.\L-£i_L_-_-_-_. _.JaX-&_*_~.j Vv^^n^^ As» v>^V--y Xa-__.^__\js^sLt___ _____=___v__k^_

A-_v_=. __c_&_^X4iT-*- ——

Page 10: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

4

JD____-

\rj AXQA.!2>

X.o_5::\..._(iAi_5„c)ic.!^.)-._ <s_v__>...s_X^^^£»ja___ _^_AA_Ai_?kh>- __-_=^__s_d_j_jck _€^_.JaP_X^i--i--D-- -XX___^__.

_<5Arr_-A 5.L~X2_._

..C-__\C_1.^..X9..^il ___-J_J_5J=_ Xx^-^JQ^p -e.o\ C\^ O^._ X-^_C XQ\

__t>_^___5^^^

A-_,^--V_-v -V-<i__fs>v\-^-\ •<. oV ___\X£-_s>_£_<Aa-^^

r_X^-_K--s_>_S_-3= <s__.s_-__-_:—JS2_V_x__^S__\C_ a___r___ aXv \\ \cA

:v-\ \ _as___a>_*va_)-iU---G^^

A, 5^Sb_--S-_i--_5LJ_v__ Y}^.^^\£.^.^^A^^J^^.~-^}c_»\ _»_.£?

-A__v« A «^V_2l_A-S_ A.__v.C

Xo.». Go-sS-S -^^vaX:

._V__\«d. ^yVXA^p._^A _*OU^.C_ SisJift rr^ssXX __ - - - -_ 9^? ^. H4 _ _ _

^^___\kaX-^_o_^

___?__KL1-__-_-d___0-__n_t___ —M-

to*?-- I-OW...

X^^-AV^^... „Xa<_-... X Xs. _S-

jQ-I AM

Hs

-S_3.V_v:0

^_> *-—a.

A..

W\~-\

1.

____sr__ __.A<X__N..-^>-^-'?-^__v'-__^

jy_jg^_,„_r__k.^_r_^^-CX___X^__>_ ____5__^_.___=__J^ SSS-SL

^ S_2=

^Xr_,___Y---^A_.,_x^_.;-

-e\..__._.vSA^.._X_vsi:_-_.o^

c\__?_r_\-?u.C-_^ CLo_^_AdX_<3A_XX__)-^A.v_<.^^_L_Qii.-t?A!l _ - - -

w\ -«__pv_-v\ r\ ^Jr_Xt ^c^^s^^s£j^^^s^-.<-..-sJS^r^A. _W-^__Ak_si_...2.C^l

_Xa..:<- ..._=_^.-5^\.«_*-_- ._.-S-A.<^..^.i-^--..Xi^^.-A_^^_«..^_-j. SAJ.CV^. _V__\.v5_\_."3

.C-.a.<:.\r:s^k__'..a..c:..X^_«_<A ..._,..X?__t_\. X_c_x_r_: X\ CL_=--A? _.c- _ .v1____--c.c3A._-_. ' x cA -t^\Q.

Page 11: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

X

___„__...__-_Xjq_^^X

Xjq.-^x^-* f-A.recAl-i -X-o—v. wv-i cAXAVvAc-g-^, qX_jA_XsL—A

VXAoAcv^cy -svV\-<_- c*>\<-\3 X o^s^_-<__. r*^r- V \aq^csAX V^-po?y_-\3 i^owv\^._.-^-r. \ y\ov.csn-i

X^oX X^-7 voO-e-c-c.- _c._-_>_-3yX--Q_---l^\Vn^-\<- OAcrV^-g-c" W^ ^A^-<X V-A-_^_-^^^A^-^

rc-\^_. %^ <Xv\ A^\^~n\.<__ V___.-€.-g->^. S^^A.^^ Qn-vcA v^/.c.r-\_^^Ooc-X '̂v-^VX> V^ v-v^>V\c^_X X^\-g--n cXcX VAo\ S..^^.,'

__V_iX_3--^__^^

:S:__A..__W._._^^ _S-_-*--_X-^^^

_0___-__rJlt_?____r-___--_<^ v-S-^.V. /-

A^__X_riv_i3-S___i___--_.^\W\S ....._?> ^XxeaVA __fsX^^~A_-A5rX Q_a3.

.-___rA_:-S--_...-^ _.^j-_-_._A_.__-^^

X_-A=__\-i2--__^ (S-s^^^-^—-

iJr_____5___r___^_____3-fc__-^

__=l-----ir._t-_?.^.v*':-- A1^ V<-C_vi-c_ __,\\, -V.-g- ^W-yTst-<___? \ >_-> XvvA_.C^.

Jc_!C_____j__j£-___^^^NJv C \\ ^AS> -Vv--> A-C.S.\iX _S_._-^_^--_-.-_vS_-5^^

O-kNov---. <^_S\X\y*\g-< QvxXv v%a<^^^_.A_-_X.r______^

-_-___^______A__-^^^ *X X-^^"-^^w\ k^A^^c. A^ v^v3A-^^a .^_£___^g=M_z3-^^

.Vv_<--c_ C_-o_S-«_- vxb^vS «=XV 5__v__^__^

\X_-5__, OG____i__;_i___W^

L<?-:_3.<Xs,__C^^ <£^&-^^^^~~^^^~^^-^^^

..cA___\_civ__A3 A^.^__X_-_-__-C^ —.__A_^-__X-.X-3_1

._<i_-Sj2..^^ ^-j__iS__S__c___d__)___a£:—_^Xs>.—_t_5s_—«____a^!?___!_-__-tL V^ __X_A-^__---A~-S--_2_-?X^f-_iS._._XA_^^ X

Page 12: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

Co

-.-<=E\X.-J___a_-_<s -•3.___.X^Al\-C. X^-A_=-A_^

V <r <_>W. q \ AXoXA -acr.q,

^-eJPoct.- Xc-Ac-A^ A^-y-r, 'SV-^-g- vKx-a-S sj-e-r-i r^-\s-\«=-

A:-__---_c-XX5C_^ ssJL _Xv___r___JsiAiA^=.a_

.__^_s4\ck_S-i-_^

-^_cA,_i.s_fe fVA oAvv, -e-g- c. t -V\ -__- =?\\-g_^<_.c_l \JvcX

_S*_^_S3lX_^S^

S^V\Ae, Xv> «___. V^^.D.-A..9,5ii^^- "v^SnS. _-__>X\\ \ ..._-> .9fo.5ir.-:

3^? %^T AS-Prk>.\j..-c-i._^„<__^__s.._3...<^.-.. ^.s^^^<s^..-^\....<^\.^..^..-^^^r..T^j=^. vX^XLas-

<==?v__v_X..._:^^ V e-OCc5 <__y-dV" A^j-i^. S^._sA-_L__L___._

,.ic.1^.^.:.<__^-^\__^-ri. _'==__---=> __v5.j__lk!cX_-_^.s.v;r_\.. X_3--_. .X\...<_-. ..@XAX\-a c__v___,.._iX.P>__^_- _X-v-c^_. __g_A\>_^c»-c^_j^_^J^J^_a _£_-___-•-_. .c__.-_i_^__>._^.'̂

^ X V jX\~-3>vX >^v_.-«-t-~A-Vvjs.c=0\w- V^X^r- -tp cX\C,----._=A W\ __> y r Q

^S2<2.^^^^k^ O^N ^--c- X0^ X VN? X< '̂" ^^ '___X_Z5^_-_s_-__s^^

-XaX^-^. .._^.:_y.A.o\.____^^ cA-<J_-b\<~-^-5^-»V<-r. ^Q -g-^'^^A-S.-e- V

SAfN^^uX j£_s__a„1s^^ X^A A>a g_ g\S___A \\A

AzS>. vvAvX.-<s-g^X Xe Wv.<-—i ._______ri_---_dL-_-=-^^ A_v\.___^=__-__

.__^_.C_v.5-.A~^?---_ _ •— - - —- - -VxVv~Naa-ovjJ_: A^a<_ •=\Aw\\^c5a^^ _XX_A.--i ^___?___^

i:l=-X_X.^ __5N__v__^_.-____3-fc___^_s^

X^_;c-__. JS__3^-r__^.__S-_. _.X.c_vc)v__..V-\-C_..__^.-V

_S.s_>_9_J^Ta_j__3_ \^yz^__£SLs&*^^5^iStes gJXaA^^ c£Szl2=£ZX^_^^.__.A>=.. <^_^_t-X>saVi-X..^=_. _Jt. X=^_X_<- <Aj^'^l^d^^^Ss^trz.,Q.y.s^^cXX\v..^.v.iM...^

Page 13: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

7

V.c^<-v^^to^A^^A\^/ X AXl^ Q.rv^c.^>_-_?\U_|/ \ A.\<>}VAqAT .Ws_v_.._£, .vXc^..:<^_^^ _X_A__X X__s..A.... yv>-i ...X-__.._=.wA-*-^__*_-X\. «*_£ v^<.<^oAv \-v A^cXV\.r_. _C5..y> <X Asy\ __»Q r«L.^ -S.W..«sX_a.S A?vA .-«?-._. SA-^-cA?£-.A>, .cAvSA^r=A vk^VaX \ XT <=?

X.oyO .<A_r-^A^<- ^X^ M^.-^ -S-^-^.X. ^/X \r___>. .:_>A.v_..-5X OA .-tilAv. ___, vv^vA^^vA^c^vo^ Avv=Xr cvowv^^v .V\«*r.. N_=?.... ^> -^-o*s

. A__5o..v: __3._-«_^>.r. ^A^- 's^^_s_>_r^___X._*. _ - - -

S^ -<=XC<_^S.<- _Co.o^3^ ^.r "A^s-eX Aw=^\ X..__,...__.._-_„,A.^,A..<-^sQ.vJ'<- X.^A'A ^.:S..«A~ _^Xr ....<=\ X^.Ac_._<___. \AA.Xn-1

" " S£_M_:.^L__ _ _ _ - - - -

:_a<_v\\XX<l_ 5XL\- VAx^Coo^AvAcX \_h A^.._.P.r.Q^.^<v>A_iyys.\^<^^^^<^A<^x .£_*_*__ _=** _.^s_^_^--&jc _W CC) evA^A^^r.X|j.vC.-^^XvVX-t" \X.X^..-^. C-S\-._k\AO^.v%.s\__r./. _X^yvA/.CA.e:.C.eA

<C^c: .____AV_sX.^^ __ _

Oa_^__Xs_tv _\X AA_^^._^v_AlA .c^WA-----^\\<Q=i •<_--e-.A<S. -...AX^A,..- C^S-X^^A. X.^aC..__W-..^_^^ _XaX

..jitX. 2_?_ _\A^A.^_AJ?-^.- C-tc-.^-.^XnJ:.?^ ._^_&\_i_:«_. *__aXA yA^_^sS.rv3,A_-_.AVs.>r_.0__rA^_A. XXAXa.- «3_J^e_,„C .ikS..-^_ XaXJ! X^X X.-^<=_-._?* _

isi-A^^ e.lS.SS5_-_feX____^

XiXX-^. AVv^_.-^vA_?. .^X._b5_v£.fe X_s.v^.^__ _Av-A.X_._r_:ijyYVoSa.^..^ s.VA_o^A-^-^r_-.^

iJ.7A^_A_-____.>-_V- -_J_C5.;S,v. :_=___ -S___a..Xli--- oA_A_£?.v_A_^!J^„c<XA, _^>__-.d. __>Xa. ..-?=^s _._aXX^Aa XXA,^-X-..._3Va e_-_ A-XX-^ —iX.OA5_-._^^

^o -c_- _<S-\ -e_ _.SaX\ X,__Lj7l_ri. _.___AOj^v v;Aa^.X^-._-^.-^..v__X_

,Y%3>__ _C-2^.. S^r_i_ - - -- - - - - - -

v.v^ c xa ^sxxr^- vi louso, isa va^ 6bpp...5..^fr>V_ c_-.vo.c-Ar •^^A-==-X«r^^^-_-.'3.',c; <_-^A^-x~\^vv^.r__.oV......-\_r_3...

Page 14: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

.d__^X__=___-_A^

\~v X<r\-_-A. A~*,°<"~ S-cCowd _A -e-gyr __-•___- C_W\\cV vaa qV-eaXX^-

£_k-4oax_ _

Vv^x wam C-c\_==.-_=.,, Aa-AA ct_a <r.v->X o-L C.<o-_-\Xr gSsY*X<-:

.vv^-^vXv: <o<" C-o-^N- -^c-g_-=_AA o-\ \-gj-4 rAXv-g-^X^^- ^XAm \X

Kfb>-^----^-A?^ A^-3 S-»-g-<_>=» X^ 3-g-s=-.<-cv-A v-^-'^T'toaX^, AX-^-AX-T;

f_bX-<- -g-O -a~_r _3-^^<-v__;^-r___gJl ya/\--i Vy oV -<^<3r\>-\f ^^-aIPE". X~?__--_g?X<~-<__cvA,—i .,-g.A^ -o-a. ..V-v-g-<r Sqv^\<_ *!!-> \> C-gv-v-X A_A_\__-Al

(_-lv--3^A^-^\^-c^_=,\ AS-A,<_U- «==^\\<.c\-^i-A V\\-\t--- <g_U \<A -EUaC---- v>AA^v-

.-S>S?\.tc. ._-!_a_^A_^_v..-<-_A ^V^<_-____ft^vi_^-cAL \.r......y_^..r\ iXsr <a$$J4Dl

J^VlXX"^ __ .„ -

\ . XcX. .!_A_.Q.. \_^._rA.-v-3-_-^-A.5e_._-ii-_..^ XL X_>\ _==•./ . yAA?.r _.cAl.d

OT C-^C-^^y-vr Vo v^ e. ~yv\c-X vaa—1 y^o^-c W<aX _r-> -e. -e_^\ vXS

_rt5_. __?__.:£___A. _^-.7_-r_....s-t..'2.l_ .V__A.-. A_r_i <- ..__V4_0_«3fc A-AX^C-tT =X_ ....3.._^_*5_«_-„

._ _ __X_. c g. - 37 ^ |g-, s>, _G\abX.,_g% \X_^._..tep -S55__tb

Plr-X_-.tC--^Vc_aV-<_, CIcnvaS.-^-- -£*-»_•«- __vS^^5vA_---_i--_&^

<~ _-??/\a vv^-g_ •=?•> \ ^-\A~C3ir' ^^ g^^A^ ^ —v CL <-<---«=-3r----g-\ X15^ c^ -C._-§_=___-T___*__

yg-A-g-. *_=>-gA^-gJ^ A>\<--A v\c^^3 V^ ve-?^- 5<A^-a_t vk-,\\V

._r___-_->_(____S._ri _^_____...___--:.___X^^i^vA_.X -X=_ .^-_1_^____3^s__-<<ci_A___?_=C <c>--^X0^^-A^--^A » ^—Kc\-e--\e<_. V__>_i?>_S„._A.^

aSVa c^.-^—i Y yo^Q'^^A<- C-_.-v5<_ -X=»<^ N-b-^y-^A

c^v\ A-QtC-vf < ^A-a-A . .

\v-v wy-. C_„^^S.__-!§___-_. AA ;y_«_i_=_^_dl_-L--J_-S^

___-_X.:<^

,A_C2-_ Av^jg- _c^v^Xa-c- *-\ X <• S > \a_\V -g^A. AVv -<^ V*_^<-0_Z_3.__!L

A-K-^S. _._C.o.^_X.Vk^ .V»K-_3..S. d_JQj__._«, _r^..9__S^.._-5_cl___>>^-X

Am^ (^Avi^r.. _^..Jrk_iiiJ_-._^^.__^-^_ C-_c?.cn_£_^^. _

Page 15: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

_E_X_-

-&VAS.V-

__C_J)v-SJ

iw

__ibflS.

iQ*k

Aaj

3

\^A_yAyC,3 (C->pvvA\c_-^A 'T^-sVwvaova-j A^ X^^-^^^1^^^'^''X

\^V-AvAC^A A^^^, ^A-<=^-a"^_. ^-?--V\v.WvA vV^rV^^A 1. ^ ^-\

gjr A>a-^_ pros^-ov^Aror- gas_^~<_-<A Xo&a, A^\ -^ VV\.Aa-_S__r____

AVv\3 <_^V-^ck-e-c-A. vN\cV\~a Xa <-- .ApXAs.vX\^ ^ W-^P ^ g-AA c^A

_^3__A-e.'S-VA'vs^S*

4A^JigX--lSA

_<oC_aX^-^AXi 9-.o^X '̂ V vv-.0*^ X ^s^_._-^_Qvds_--e-i------^--g-j-•-_^__A.<----s\xv>^S ftwd V^-v 'So'rr^ .V_^___g3-_^--L-_-r^-=j--_A___\ <L 3 r-g- -^fAA<--5»\Ao-A$/ k_\jA \ X-g-"g-A \ vA^-g-ol :_£&__ A_____A_

___-_^_^_^qi_-A__=». gNv\c_v_n —1~^^\ v-OsW^X Vy=\_s. S=_d _e_e_^x_j!AA^\X-5_.--_-X.

fSX=X-<^- -CJ^-Hf, g\^vg\ ^.sV^ "7°^ V*-\~ ^-^XSXv^_-3t sXXvo_,r-_v-.__C-s-_-_.^ 3-rg-g---^A

AO,__=V_0_\____X-x_; ^.Ae_-_^\-^Ap--i -?•-_=_ ^cXa'^S'^^' <=a,-S- A\^_^._c_k-L-jp---^-^

7X\<=i_V > XL y^.X^\S, t0v->''5 x^^\__-__X-

_^._^_____53_5X_5-^^^Us.

_X__^_}Ax^^____^

>jX\^-a" -tvqT *--. ~Iv.h -XAXn.._l--_-->_-3-5^J--v

-.___aX_X-_---^_^ •e^rS

.c\. A^<a— VvovaS-j^-Z-sa-s-jiA'

XX__k____V_ .C___-=*_ ^X*or\^f]

Tvx __S__t_v__*_^-3-^^

XaV.

V__A-A..'a^ V->^:

Xt_S__i;____-_l_V-^ ____i__^_AXS^^

__A_...g^,. £f- o-^JT AV\«=-A Ia •<___. vj^<^r3 3CAV-AS, __^-v<--- ^J£_JL_sJX <. 5, X<3>

Page 16: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

vACL

5.

lo

j_\.vA__rX_.X..^^

X\ X va <_ v-Kp vaA.—\ X^A %^=; <?>,r-A.,cj..;..,,. ,f-S'—* -5=--a A,A X.' voO-ecvrX

©

__-Ajs>.AXA-va-^s....

x_,<_-v c-<£-, c.-_5._c_-i-S-.sA_Il

v=.^c\!____d,_l'_r.

J_pQj>_.

.._A_-A.5...._..

_A-J,

•<___---_

X _-__U

^-e.S

\X saa ,—!<_. K-\ Sc\\g\ __X____l___^.__lX_l_^

Xr§!.J--r_ _..S^___-_S-_X. S*sMX —( D̂ ^ °^-A, r__L-S__^.„AA.^_-A^\ XrA.-Q.y^ AVa^A As-. "__j_oA^__,oyv. \ ._^_l__5.-_b^A_^L...

^..^^SL.s>.^^^y^^^^^^^^<=iA .___Ar_..ri A-A.._____ <-_-^.-A- <___.<_

_S_^._f>--ii-_- /-A_o____L A cA? «acs\ ^a^^-^^ X :^_A3As.___Lr„"X

VAA.O..t;_^^

—TOM, tOv-X. vooVx^X Xs-e_ c_"\vc3<av.X -\\-e~ S> v<^- A^^^^„_XasX"_

w\jz\\<„<-3. ,..,~nccpv-a, ,.,f_=>'=s>-i A^_A\ s „7 5_ -^-^Ar Vs"vSb°N__-.9,\; ___

^-\S<_- Wv -S_ -y)/\-v_=X-C- v^-AvAX>, AS^C-g;.-.^

^-•_r-^V_v-X___:^->A-^ .p..:r____<_.!-_.^ .^___?r_r__A_!:

_\_^..^___^__^.fc__\. X\qS--- p.cX<"<.s _?__-.!^.-XA.T\.,„

___ A^u^-.v^r-A c__<--^X^^~' .„..\^_.___X_v:...Aa.-§?_. .v_XvA.X"---^X_^_....-v_-^!A.A

C\v_=_\ xz- \^~> _c^vyv ^A_t_J-L_-i!b._-~.... X_5^;_<-__...X_A™\A^...S^^

__^\^_s_--_,_^!?.r>.>. __^-A-S^^^__X_i^------.^^^^^-S--^-^^---:- - - — —-

Vva, t <X fVr<=<A: -g, y\ A<\r\<y^cv^/ \2.k \X^>

./-A^-X^XL Lxs>-os.i f^X^xX^ ^^^^^^^^^A^^.\^3^

-S_5_yv>.A..?_.rv X.!?lsX_=va^-^.^ A_____>_L,^.'_ih^ ,.__yi-^.._^...A.___^.V-.^ri'-!--i

Page 17: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

It

\v.

\oo\c Xr QcsrWcX^r iAA.g>yvA^. •grvS'—\ cXc\y-\A3 X.v^\S--A

A"-<--SV\v«-a O-a-1 •

\ ^AOro^-C-C (S^\a\q^ A"-^-'=>VS>^a'0-n-| oL- \-\^V\-m3 .W\oAW -<_c* X €-N? '̂v -y/ <A <-A ^--Xe-^cA'̂ ^-A' eg L Wv s eX<=AA7~ Ao A^y

V-ajC -l c_A ^.-\->--_c-na^\\^ -.___ xj) V<^. AA^a-g Q< <_oAaW_>\\\Xl A'A Or-Q3<C-aj

X>-=><-' C-AaAAcV ccyO-e. g-v-^-cX C_sa.\'\o\ 'MoVcsX^-'' "X AX*8*-^

_________^____!_^^

xjjvcVA-^a '\a •\V>!;N_5» C_^y3-«-_ . SA-A^_- \^» c\ X__^__--_Xv_^^

t_7V*-*-C_A Vv/\ <-5~ \^v->-A^A" V-> •<? -g-iT- (^Q\a\!_^ A-g-^> V\vvA.<--vA.-i A^oXr e

y-y\^_U-<--J. AA-a.-c_ ^vXjS, _<_;_Sj^,^-5^A^\n _XXXX /OsX -g-*-A 5^M-d

-__.r_A_E-_-_v-.---_---.) AVa-^- C"\eX^-vAS

_C__-d-^-^-S-X-N____-A_^

_v_X^-^X__-_.._ ___^^

«OsL_S___-A_Q_^^^__D.j___wX_il.c.Xa.s_._^

_2*_>__£a__J-^^

X_.j___.M_g_r:.rr[ s..^<A-*g_g-n>_>-e-_^tc ^XoAyv ^\.-^^_o^^^_jgg_C-J-t_-_s-_k-S_-_^L__________2L_=__V_<_=-___3^

^\vv^s?<lJi *3 X\X 4^-M-S, _

X>-_\-_?----._-__^

Wqv-^> Aa^ _<__, \avJ<S^c5><X^^ Q______X_£__^\XA__^_5^^

:\KcL_?-__--Xs^^

Page 18: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

\?~

^.VAArr_v ._V\_k _^L\-rA.5 G_ncLXX^-MX-.-?_C... .S_r_\.„_!_-A-._A___1_:

A...._.:Xoi3

AA^X-X^^A^a.,^ _o_cdfcs_^_eQ__^^ _r_A_ _.^_7_^._A^L.C..Qv^vl_«^^^

.L_^_^ —

AV\<__ <r.Wv_^-<_- <=N~\cA SO Q^vx-e:\/ vjC_^\ L^ TSM <- C-VX^a^.A

.SX.^__.-_\~___^^ AX^X "X^^ 7A=AcA \jX-y ^-,-eA_X.-_=_, (p«^v.-5-s» \_k\-^--c-A Arc_» v.xXv-c\!-; Av\QSxg. ^?X^ <—.S) A?-.? i:.45--..^4...: _ _ __

\XX\ <_. A'-^_v•JD^Xs~f_A_AX *fS-A.-^^-A....«£-___C\

\ <_JJA £>VS^~ A___x cA^X^^_X>/-/C- \_i..«,r>. S--<--o,«^A? \-\_/cX

^^wvX x--€_p c-.vX OvA^-s Aj^<_ J^XcA~ _;_^_gdx^^£=^-^^^=^j*Z*^r.C^r*^=&..„ vAA.-l._ ._^„<A-^.rv^VA£< ^ -?cA-_ _Xv..<__ .B_C_A^^7.. _.JLX-51.^-CA£.._C. _.-C_.__^_A.XS--r/__--SX\._a^__ cXaoA. ..y\.<s!\ ^...aX AXXL..-QOTC.^ VO <^\A-X ~\V-\^_, VVl^^ k=>><_AA.\-A-C.l AM<- CZ-CAV^A-^-^o

vQ^v, Qv. _S v-O -g-^g- \ ~v-^/ A-A--?--_" XsA ^VkXv AaX, XX AyA ^A~1_C^ri

_ _ _ gxx \fy\ov-i v^^ovy. ^-fi^c- Aw<- ^x^-^x _.A.^S^a.X-'̂ _c___v.: A XXX^X -x^X^_.._._-V_i_s_i:X_ :___^aAX.X3-^..-G^I'GX£ Vo X ^-c- As__\_^-:_A-^ <Xi .-A-AJ-rr

-_^_..aXs>____X-a^XX- ^^^ -^iAX-<7 a\ CAX/ \ vj^ -g_AX A_-?__. Va-^-.t' Ac_vA3^-j X -e-AXr •<-

.^--Xc.__Xa_1--_^.'̂ ^/.--.^X--__-._...X-^.X.__X>v^2__-r-__;Xrq _o_r\..^

.^AaA^... s_^v_-_X „.^ AX..-5rr^_->_A. _^ X..e^.__^-_aKr_-vXX c_.-^a,A_______§_C:_^/.-.X_-^ :_A_A-_l__.._0_--§^

CxX ^_-.._...-__^va.-_^_> ^-Aa-?^ r^A'<-3^:^.ci )..X^^ys- A~= l^..-<?_-_--/Vvvv=v. AX^-_S,^^A/<-r X-^-.-aAv:^c" A_^ ^^^^.S-.sA..AA<__,AX^S^__AI A5.c\_.-5?sAc..,-<L-^ _2-_^Q_-.--_5_<_S_ >a^^ _."S;.^

Page 19: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

\la

vvcA -e__.c1.ca.X AA-A*""! AXXvA ?^X_S_S. ___-^

vA^A -<__. ^-a \<___ -g_.:<SL-P _yyVM X.rrXsH.VV._=V_-._A _*_==•. A'-A, CD^A-e_. cl Av_ ____

JSP-<2-*aA_-aX° o <r 5C^ ,A^..~ ..•- _

AAa^s_ -A_r.w>A.ri .. ^.^^'^^^..^....S^^<^.^!a~^r/ _A Xa-vT A _>x, ovVa.....

Aaa-^Ctc-. , /A eAX-^-r vsi^S X^ vn-a--i v> X <-_ -«- c_>^-

_.^..>_A!->A^.-e=mS _i.&$> XX, -M.r.. _ _ _

\A_A.~ci- :a.q^.s-._a Av\s_X_ A Aa_.=-\_??..X.^^^XaaA^

X ^.^^^cAc.. .^S.S.X._ _S: f^i?..VAA.•^.X.', SE>.C XXXt~ \o_«o.^».^..^=-.^?s..-_?:.X. -..S>.._-s..v_A_A...-_SrT_ r.AuA_^_^AA.^ _?x_^_v____._?s;

tg^C <=\ \?._C^._^.AX/ -cl. O-L .Cl^-_^_5._-_-).A._^..'!\ tA_A__^--_AA_^AA._q X^Af-S.

VtEs <-?A ... _C^_QV__AX ^A.._S_A____>..sr,..A^^__A_.:

\ .vj_^__s___s» e\ .S&i^A^* lX\.._^ ^~v^ P_X.Xj..JA_*^<C?<~' vrvy—i_ X^AAa^3 *~ A«a. \ AvS5 W^AX21-^"_^s .a^-c., S>.._??.__jj\ X^-A XX_X._^._.C_!EAA_.'̂ _sL_ vvam..ASbA2S: _Q.^^XXX

.CXXi_S_A.' _.__ _ - __ _ _

XXX.-^rrA V- .'__>-5>-0V—• \_-__s -XXXAp_.cX\ _r_-.. _N_X..'B.._^_k.jAX.A_-r _^-__-^_-T.:A.,_a__A_ _\ .SX-^-O-^'^ A^-^-"^-- ^XX.!...-.\ .c_v-\k-*s^_A_A-_==• X. Xa-a.An.-^.^.^aXt-i. XL. .,.aA..9..___.-A.a'_../ cea_->5_

A>AAXn\.-S-_. X . .S^-'rV?? _X_-_A0.^_-_-.AiA^.flr__vA_.^_.-_ A Vs_S__X-_ AArA-TL.cX«=\.S.S.. cs--^ Cc?n-^©'v^, \ v>sX-«lXjm_i "3Q Qg^cl

ijAx^A: >_vr_A^V Xa'A-S.S; Px,oV_^.5:A- c5__.__\X Q(_j^.^.^^\r^J^^^j^Q?>$..jjvXX..^_A_ X_ C.^.v_^.-^..X!!S^\S.--.X_.--^_!j\ ..XcAaA. Ar^ Av_-=_-As____.:^ _^_-_XA__-._____._v_.A

.|j__A ,.J«__y...._e___Cl A_XS-_____X VA-/V^\ _ ."_SO_ _Cj5-.__-.S_L.__A^_ _vC'___5_-__A-A_0sA X.XXI i

ILNAXv; j_!_^si._§-_s_L. _.. ._ - - -— -• i fi.j _ XA;~\ ^^r^^Si&^rS: <SAr_,X %s.j^k^:^^kS>..^'?^pSjS» v_o__?=£.f j

IAc^A-V^-^-a. <a.A,A :^:_?s<:=^.,--vX -a-cl.Xi «?=_.A:A va.qXA'a.A WAh-! ii/^y-» «/v—. __=• -*—*-_ v-^—i -<—~ -__»—v— oA^__, ___, \ >_ \ _*=• \_ v \ f?. .__ •A—-.-.vs>__. cA c^s>--v

\-_.

Page 20: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

•n

A^-€_.-^A v...A...'̂ .,-?...^_..S*.v „X_.-^^^^^^a _a__»_a5.5-j P..^.c.^.._?.Hr.._-sPX

ij-cxP ^..._._g_\_A.cA. vy^.^\^__X^X,s.vA S=?./__-?_Aja. .:?-.. ^it.a.^a-: <__.

AA v__> X cr-s c -<=__. va.o7 \-\ yyA.'ri X AAX..> A X^slL^_. \o.5__.___.__~_s

.^=-_L^^-«a^_rr__ _AS?A^^t^ AAXs\.~].^Xs?^A^ _<iX *

^Xo.,A>AX:=X c_2v.'--_a. \ stc.\A.«\ A^? frv^Xv.^rsf^- X"-|^AAoV-e-J-SiXv^^A or y~caXX"xC\ A^A^l cS^a-A... A=> -X^s. «-X

.j^S__A.\\cA-i^.-^-_-tA. :.C\aA~ A-.Xl.__. At^-V^Xa^^ __AX_..~ ,J\^i.._?_L>A_nA.v\;-_X^^ ^__XAXX\.._i) ...A X__=^.^A^vAr_C ..'!_____-s.„S..X

^^_^AA^^__^_...\_!5...?--....__f__\X. ^.v^sA^-^aA-AA5jrA ..

_^_r£r_r__._c..-?S-T \__rA._r\ AXa_fX_....___-_.*=..v__>..__r^.r^_-r>.._rrr__r.X. A _X ^o\

—-. ._X!.,^.Vv^v^-A..S=.A7A.<__."-A.!.... _

\XX\ -?r_r> <_i?_^rv _?-•_.XA-— \_r_A_TJ__i_ _>_-\._-..^.>-5r_^.^_^.A__^.__.

..-_£__ _q_<o. .\___;__c^__jS-_s-__-t _?-_3A5_X.X_L_f__Xi <___t.-__s. _____?„XX:_-^_Aa-™

,_\^C._n....-..^^.__?^- X?. A^_A<___ nXvAv"t__ cpC 7>A <- Q.x-v=yvr ^t-g-^ fA>\X-^..^_-A_l _^____!___k..§_. ^.5^-.SrS.^^^l^^sA^,..-^^^^-^^ a^__\.\?.E_av^XAX_...'

¥! Xi _^L9..____.^..__A....A:. ___-!>.__^.s_:-^_eA.._S7c_ yAAA___._ AaaXc _X_A._s_rl\v_\X-^-t"".__?. _A_X.-^._C5Xa.^_X..^ .r_t___^>___?_...!__.. S__A ^_.._.^

I A_N_>_V>_.^r-rr>_^^ X= ^..._^_^.._~rA.X_A _r^A^..^-S_fe.!_>_i _A_-___sj«__^^.'sS^A.^.^E^l :_2-_f___!_:.._-_-..^

LJ\p._r;-_^-^_5__t_>__-?-_^^ .:Af__..-...-S^..-__^ AX---—

.j.i.._^rXAX4-t ._ _ ___ _._, — _ _ — — —

........_^.:_____^^ _.

hicAfi;.^..- 5=XV:i—^XXsa_sA-A..^_.__L.5_._^.^.'^XvX _AX 0*^.^.3...

c==_x caX... vte. Xa^^^I A^-^^A^aX *A.>. .'^A^\AX^itAW\ _s -<__L>X\rv-c <___ c___<=v. 5 -c \ •=_=_ -=v <Cvo^a.V_-\ vjj c-v-v. C<2. _

Page 21: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

\<z

ISiT

.X....XXtt^.,X.^^

Eftii_>feD_j_is_J_^^ ^>^^^^^%,„.A^S^^

.A^^i^^

__s_i_ISe_J2___^_d_c^^

iJl .AX<XAW.£_kAA CoMT^M\K\Cn £_>J \\)"P/OCE. \ K.

..__\j^_._C_£_S£-_

AX .-=s_ X^_aX^-<-^_..??_ _3M<sf\toS. <=a_a-?pI ,__X==X.<S-v-v\^rvfe-V-a_<_A . Ca__A'-e- .^\__^;P^5_"A'r-i XacxA. V>.<___....^oi>_cA_3?. Coia^.D)....-

.£- Avy^^ r c-i^A^ A^a*?aA: Aa-a.^.. AX\nAv-v\. c^ep. AvvXt fe^

^^^^ oA^iS. -A. qA" <==*. C<=7>_aA f~ •€___>* SJ..\_-___

-^^.C-S-A-A... S^-<-A_£.5_Il^r_A_.,.A_.... _,._.. -

>QvOvcA'x -*g__ Z-vACc^^ _AA.A_5-C_:_?__^:r_^

jypA^g^A \s\-e- <_a.s>\<-^g-cA ,3> o XX ^v^v^-i A_.'-A.A'̂ jrs»A'̂ ^wsAXa1^—X—- Cov-r^.c-A w\ •<— AI- \^\ VA_roAQi. __ ^_ S^oX Ac.q.'m,...

l-]_,_X.^____.^^Jl^^^^^^^..^ X^^^X OAS v~\-n MvA^<_r'__X,av-^gAAA^1AW-X X^A_^___.:^^

]A_Xe<_A_2. ._=__X..-A_X\-^^^ AX^A. V.OS__^-5-__I s___>___?__r_-_-=:..XkSr.^_-A.,lv^-<=:_^_ AJ«-a 5«_^rv_^\ y^-Av: <T^X a_MX__-__-_j \Xa_Xa _5=5^l__-_«-K___\.-S_^J-C_^_-3_?.-^-S^/.__.._A~_AC.3X..-_A_Ad

H <X^_^A.X--^^-^^AS_ _^.-__.A_-A___^._...-j{^

X^-S» ^vij__U...<^__i___r-_vAi_-^___-^ -_-XX. .t52=S~._£_=.__X. iA5_. gp>^A -e_ V)s. ^

10.

<*=l^c\ _._^_____^.0!.^v-^S:aA ..Q. XX.A-a.VA vAyv-^ Vov-^gX-Xj A_-a„...A2-X__^.^A. ^_=^__C_c_}_S^^^

-vc_i ......sJf .<gAA/ Ax^.;«___...S_Ar^_^^^CoX^\.A-«_pl AAA <__ \J\X <L 5. . <=_X LS5 AA..<-. >_s_.^.3 v_-v«-£\7.._

c_-sc_.cf/Ay/v \ r -<_X A. _A ASaj-cA C-C-aXaS-. >__--. A„c\ 3.^j__s^.e c ja_ .-__>^__aC £-5..-

Page 22: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

-J-J-—•

i i

. fa

!j3i.S>svAv.-_:i.'__^. .....^.^C-^Si c^A_^aA___^v^a^^C cA>o-<s-_s_ v\ vX

-S_0.9.0 .^AaA X\jSa cA,_Cr:CL\XV ^.^__A^?_ 3AxA_ A^A-^u

A^-v^v^Xv^A^Xc ^aX.^..^ ,-^.>_...s_^.i____A.^_^..._• a^\ <slxXn^^x c<=ns.5AA_3<a•£__ <^^cfMSX <~X cvaA ..C-CXXr^^^ "^-X XXOv^a jXy\..-c__.

_Yyx._crX\._^_r e_>A- Aaa-<__ XX^-a,..__?-X .\i.s.s.._X.v^A. -*XAa-£_ -\. •==*..-\v.\t2_ Vs^x ^Av\css AX^~ Ava<-

.^X_=X^_^., caX AVv,,-e. _..r^^_Qjr_A_.Cs_cJs-_-?.ri_ .qJ^_•^.vj vX.^-*-a c.-C/ -=3*a •«_^^jt__ASa «l, 3V<V\>AA X._XjA_

_.X_^X^<^a3a_._c--. AAca.vn X^-^^-AS.../ ."aXs_:;A\_<A !^.«_-._-.^-<Ar^-5_.:

AJ05-..._--. _...SAA\AA. A^a.a^XX^^ _=_^^__s.?_i_.s__d___^_c<S*?a_c\ _ Ks__X-a_..^V_5--sl__^X AA-A-rsA. .SA'C-. .A-s_.-A^X Xa-c-,.3\jAX

Cf\^XvA .^rn X.^.*: 2.AXAA OXL, _AS...-.._ _ _ _—IA 0^^^ AXtei.. ^Ag-c Av\«_x JXr<s^ ,*a^^.X.Aa

.!vpX.o^3..-'5rr- ...V^._^.^^9\.p.^vc.-_0, vro\A.e.SS ^^Aor- Ar-=>

.^.__S__a_^^ ___^.T:_^AAr^__^^ __ _

^jt^_s_-_--^L_ Aaa^v^^XAa..-^ _^aaX^\._?_- i____Q_^.9:__>_5:.5_:.__s_^_ .^XAAaAS.... __=__V__=___c_o_^A pX.^.^r§>._s- Aaa \^..-%X._^^A_^.B —---

t.^_=A<A.A^^Aj3___=A_0.^ .?XL TVo.^,,.^^.^^^^^^^,-..-. _._: i f—> . 10 \ vje_ <zs?^ _-_§,>-_. A_^_e^^_C_.7e_ ......„.^.:^.a_)_^_>_:..Xa"_a...[<_A-X.VVa.A^^A._^.VA ._.<-2.£ .._._^^ .S_5^__?r_>-. X_A AtAXA^r.^v\...5v_ CD jr. C?A..S_-A..^-........A-'__A .'VA_.__L_v. ,.X_.S_!s.A_._:^_'2.5_.X.. .Ajs?.-...v3__y?X..vi_js- .,..^X_s_cX=_r. Acs ..aaXa^X^AX .._^_^.A.X,>t^..C-.rs_. vA.s^X^'^^-^r

..Az_?.._......^^..^X-^X_.X_^Aa._ __^s.__a ._.__^..^_^.r^.rA-.AA,^_A _...<A<*t_N_^!_^l_j_2_rpLvXa-% XcA...-§..:^_.l.:.-._..X^ _X^-^-^_."?^-A^.....-_-5X_AaXir_o^\. ^.laa ^^3_XX^A AXjXc <=\ <A -g-A~<^-^X^XaT a....—-

AAXrt _X-'-> "1_-<:__-'r_A,-A.S! "^ ..X.jfk ..________Z____X._^-..A..ir_:_. _-^.-X.X_aa.\^V

IjX-iX^ A^.-^^-AV^O'rA _^_Xa.a_. J^_^_.^AX__.X _A_A____1jCcb-Av^AA:. X-a ^. a^-cA -a, ^ Cvao,l^ gj^ _4p_4 Cl-0I 1

Page 23: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

'7

^Xaxx cicx^-A-gA wj^oje. vx^wc^Ar vxac^s -sdW^

A~e> Aarpq^: \\jsX-g-X.t^v=\ \^=> A^-a,<______-<_ c_i_sq._a.cX OtVH<-

AAAtf-- JkaC\-3 \-»_-=> A^n^- V-^<~-|

Vi-A-gJ^.vJSlvAA.'̂ A?X- N^^A!__.A <___-_--C_^ t_-\vA_c^\ cX^f-iAptza r~ X-A ^

A^^i. oroS-ocXror ct\^^va<s=X V <zyj\ g-Ar<-Ler A^% cg><rcA-<--x- Xar aA~ A--o Sr_.<_-, .gACC^AXL-^ X-A<_^ \>-a.^ j cr^^V-cA.__„_k_te__^=a.^^_- -—- _Xsl_X_a^_^_<^-\_jS^__^____sAAL-.__---^^

<_A__?_____^;_____^^

w Aw-c Xv^-^a^A- ^ Atx?i%-^x^X ^ ,AA_-. y- -^ .^cX-aA AXva-^ "EX^, .4aaX0oA__g_j_4vid_gfAg

_2___A^-_eA^_X_^ov^

-XvAr- o_s_^_____S_-_A_________>^^

Av^\ A>\\ s> c:.«=-^3 <__, Axa -__l zeX^A^A-i- X-^A^^ J

cAW\d._ Ar,.^ X^.3-g- Cq^<tXAA-^->Xa.^"acX rvAo^ "X\Arvr-\c-_Jv CLe. v-Ky-A V-.S Vo\<^ ^_-_-_A' n^\ "1 Co^A "S-XA-Ov-XvA-AC-A cA°A

Ar-o «=*• ^yJ\X\C S~-~£5^\r~ Arc-AeaA, A e\^A -^sXaI AX-.*-C<o amvcAr\csv-\ Vo vc=>-'̂ -- . ..^_.<^^.__g___-__S-.v/\A

Xr

A c_^~v__ju__^_^^j_^-X&__V_<2AX^,__„_^OJL A^A g_ <_J_SA,c^.<-e. .gjc

Asb.____k^<_-_^^

_A__S--___-.--->-X_^ —A-r-A:

_<=>;

,A-^_A-a- Aa<^A vav- ,_<___:•-_. yeV eMC<_ . ca-vcA k?<-CA^ -e_ .-\AA_gj

=» ^^ ^-____.-^_ Nc\ •g-A-A.C_--~«---.». . . . .

-._TAA_A..jt^._^ Ca,^1

_C_S=_-_CjC-X--<-----5_3^

____jj5_^_j___!i_c____^^^^S^Acy

CKvA.cA d <__->gy CV\ -e_X- r

Page 24: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

a.

1$

THv^. Xx^VrlL CoOvX\ \pjAvL^-0A7o \tO\]Es7, V<c,ftTfc.

Kn\S> XN\Qaa\\-Ac. ftS 7,0 ft Coeo91AC7 &£- IM7W£_S7;JQrL TAA<L Ma <XX X.XAX ..XX^X^XA^KJA^ fAs5\ c-^X)

;C_vDO^eL \<k\\A<^fU T:v\-^ VAQTvqkJ X?o£ XxX^CfcAA^Kn

Cooki^L vJiAs xiee^A^eo PAk>D ^\l~JtS>-

I X-x__ X<~\<=X <C_vOVaXv. Cova9\XA^ :t^X\-__-X-..._____®L__.X_s_vA:X.V-v-_5rA:„, "^>*~\ <:^A c \ <lXc a^.^aAvc-^ A^-° Ava<_- ^^^XCA<5?\^ C_X ^^A"! W\oAA.^v-a r-^-<gp\-Ar_^S^AA^g_. C__^_____A

r -g__jp a~a^-.^.^va -^-y"X; v^a^ ^oXj__.r>._A^-A.^.....^

.^.•S.??..^ O &vXT -«^a '^x -

1 iv\ vAfX ^SV \AQvjCi «XXA oi- <=a *S-v-aXc7\ e^A cA-XX'j\^ _.-^P-^c^ \\s. -__ gj_£2_-5-A-_^_--S-_>J__--S-. sM- <^>.o. -vS^, ^j^_.X-CiS^jtXSX .oX__--AaX_Z-^

A^A------ X •g-'A~ ^^ ^ ^ CpV-ASe-l

15X X_Q>.A_

•^£ eX. A^ <-___-^\'sAr^-icA <-_=> g-V*^-^^-

XX. X__L___X__!---k_.

xA _A X°^-_ <- *•=__. •e-.-'e^^- vr_3^-_.\^<r.X'-^ A "^,^v.-^.._-.^A--X^_: _=^ft 9 * n^X ^X CoQvaS -X. g^A-A^ <- A^ ^ a. v^r -

(____> •<__<pO_^-v v^vcA

A.-C.X-___......X__---_r\ X _._<AAj<^.......vvX.1^A...'..-... _ ._ _ ._VAX-e---A X •<£-- A^-X_i:._^..?X^^T^«A.._ Xsavaa.._XXv^../...._.X__?r.._S5X

_AQ:_4..J-A^

^^e ..P..A.o_._a_.__^^ __3_A-_ri.. X_r..A._S-__--X-_-.^-,.^.^

X S^-^-S? <=^ _:x_?.^X._7..-._Af^._^

<P_-_?_-_<r _^^.^X__?_=_.XA A ____^___^_.:_!~_^

a^X^Xs-AAs_5^^ D_X.^ „A_AA_9__^.___ _.

cr

C__S-_-_-b^____^_5_^^

sX; V\-^^eA

_ ITv^-s,

LZ_pC_A____J_t__J_=__^^AA v. _- <s_^c vva -e_ -e___ArA -\ "-X Aa

O^M" _. V^.'A-2, Or<-.c\g_A~g-(^v^AA-A--g-gA 9r\i.r V

Xr_A___\__--__^^ AwXt. V-Xf ~a <~ V-;^^^ A^*1^

Page 25: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

\°l

AAa-«-'s_~..__s_-- \._=?..«=_sro =?-AA.-«-_!.\.-«r«A jOApX-___<_. \p.^\^AeX\X ^ °? Aas

WN^ri C.?_\-S» "!— . AA_aX\7X..____-. >r_A.^-__._=A._?H^i _Xz__! •=? 55 ___A._.X .A_>aXX-A.__

/AA^AA'SX jTjAac;j<-^_-. _AaC->_5-^\^_> XXt-*5^.,XA r D~X.<•_=:

C..-jN.v-^-r.. ..?_-.... .X>. ^..CAf~ _X=> Xv\__^.___:V_A2=_> Mr_-_V\sX _A/A <=-. Xa,=\. A S>_e_.?

V-a,AAa<1_ AyvA.f-.P/. A-_t___>A.€r^A .^^_A_A 3_«_A_ .do.S^.^.i AX_?-_ AAtf

9.CpC<€.^q OA.c_rcA V»^<=\S-; 7Ae:vl....VsSX^<.'0 \.^..^._5V.

•~t._o.PjA ^_<=.y- -H A>>A....C-__fkS_jX JAVA __?-_r^- X «~ .XX:^SX;_.O-a As

VA ^ t:.^vX^^^sX ^eA .V_>1_=5 ..s?_>£_.^.Xc-a.s».j-a/.p <-s£„v--_vAvj=b.v--Av Xv.^_.._._^-r:& X^..rA..^__^.X<^A- _^_^_^__s±_^ _.c\-^.S^.,<j_?3__.«3.vaA- vXA^_ Q.>>i__L AXa.^ Sje>^jA^<r^..5^A-_t-_-__?l_..

i ,ic..,~_srA.,_\.^_. _X^?>-X^3-v.<?__,./ a^-a,>--^j€^^ ^.A_^XV?~X XXXac

Lv_>_v_«-. __^Xve=?^x A _^._s._____sd_ k___4_?-^--4- -Mp-•--— .-_7P55.^.._aX.-| X^^' - - - -

^.^___D2-_^_.-^r':=A VvfSJ-k V^_-_A__-A^.X___^^^

3JU ws.ri .C_.^_2>_.<«/_._^_L_-k_^.__s^ .3_-t^_-:-?-:XL-_

S*__^__?A.S_. 5C-? ST -_=__-"^.v^A__-A.>Ac5. X__^.__LV_r>_. .____^ .XrA .r>.___5._._^.SL^.5A.?__r_v£.i

.X^^^—X___v_. _._ ____ - — - -~ - - - -

j! X\A^ Xs_A\^.^-\ -^.X.r^>A^_A AAa^-C-Xa: A_.._XiVcAjjWvv^A A^SA^^A^O .AVvXy". A ^^^«-£2.XA_^.__?1j

ij^^^AXAVAX ^^"""^ ^^ 5^."*^-^^^ ^AA^AA. -^VS.^-l.--?_-?_^-^-V_l_-IiT-SvA_A ^_«^s^s_.y_-->..-^. Aa-a^ vaa^^. ks> XXa><_Xv _^_«_____^_^-S-j_.

"\\

jJAXNCA •___, XXAe^O£_. _X.__=.^-^.vAX__.yAA__^EA_-A; X.__5__...i_AA.^_a A ^__^._>_____>\ ijjj^xjeu. <o v_AAq_ XAf\.. cA5:._....^A^j=vrA. Va_JXj_4S SAX_aAAX-__. _XX<:.jjTjA,.v_k sAi ._^__a__Sr.5_^-_t_h-^^._«=: \___?>_ js_*_2_.«_?_->-SlA_^-^__ <ea ^,.s__-__Aj?__c. .._^!____X__1v_Xq;^,1=?.^j^^ _.-=_\rj-_-_ 5_\_SX.._-

yAA..?S.cA..«r-__ Xa5>.C._ _V__A_?r- __Xl_?5.>A._^_.>_ AXs.rj^_, _\Vv_A.O^^

__. <-_c^vA.s.<_, ..j^n PXpva_^_ a^a-.^ .X_3.<=X X.^.•^r.s.^^XX .-A.r-X vAr. A Va«=.v( -_. ss\ e^_s e__r- "=s-s-^_^ \Aa_-__A \.A<A

W\ <2_<T \ A^> G3_

I

i1

i ;-» A ._- -—- _^\

Page 26: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

io

\_)^g-____,p\X<^- gX\\ Av\.-__. Xcr^eAs XA^.s^..^_^

X,,,... yy O^-.cq, Va^u e^-OvX Vc^cAA^ c"f VJ&o(s£Jl__.\_XLfekL£_X^ V.....Xs.vX A^-,.sAfc...^s_L_l^^c\fi.^V. ^OCve^g- vMe., V>ANa^ X^ X°^ -X^-AC <___ va-a-i

_C___SE__iS_J_S^^

Y*A-<- O^vA^-^-A CL<qv--Ovc:A vavX VXvA^. ..y^\A^-. S.X_A?. XgrA.^gA_A

C_A.v--\ cV -€-vAA O A~\Q^\-_s_\X^t , £_ii_r_b_=_X_M^.^^

A____1VA,=A..X--S__S_.A.X^-.^~X_..___AZ5 X-e-X^-'Xv /....___^_VA.-__:'V-A>.^-^„<-tST_ _VXje___,

Cvaos-c Ar^3 ^.^.v_rA.-T^.._.;.<^^A^gV,_ j>^j?X.9_X:<^. .y>_A..<___.

j______k__=/.J!--^lsi^ _. X_3AX-..A_>A_-AA_-. .._?_£_.„.^.XaX ^_i__!_X-_-

A~y-_> o Xc-~ A^\ qAcA i Xl.^. gAv^°^A^ \_tA______A__ __$_-=» _v£___,.-7.. ^SSz^^Sl^

._-_b„vc_A^._,X

r--g-«XA^ XiSX^_s^_r_--5_____-r

X^\<_-^ A c-K-g-C-AcA.-c-cA :_____s._.J_s_...^

._Xo_XXAx-.XbAAA.._^^

•e^^_^^__r_^^..XXX_^^^^

v._!-»X-c-=-_v^_-?u-„___-^ SXX-_L___=_?_>•_. AvA^^r -f2--^ ^£.._^_-a_i

o-^AX_AX^.:r^ a_^s.s...-^_^^^._^ Xr\_ AXaa..£:X.___x.^A..&.^ -

(Q^ fA.,^A....r. ^D..._-_..Xov:^.......^-* -X-_-.XX..S-....A^A..^^X. V_^_c, -&.^As5AAs _X_«aA.Xv vaa ^.-.^....S^-X^X.^.^ S-9X__-«..-it _A^Xr^_^.._....A_^..--_§r__.

.-%_^S_£__«ra_ -_?_^E__?_^-«^ _A^-S_._AAl _.!_Q_^_. AX.^- X^._A^.^_-x__\XAc_..._jCXv_nj-5^^ X.._^___i_k^-AX_

A....._._E{A-Xi5-t__&- A...V._-V-_\.^S^-g^g____A_._!7ijsXv^ °a -gyo; A\ ~v Qk Aro ^X\SAJ___r_X\"--A _S>lA.r.... Co__!____?

_oAe.._^AiS^^

Page 27: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

XX.^ XsAcAcy..C..^XX._^X ^^^- -^^^XS.X; .._._SU^S=^..^_^^.--s_._^!.v _\q_y.Vs_aoAa.a?_-^.Frs\.cA A^^_^XAXvj-| \ X c_ vaX ..^.sA...<£><>X^s/.<

-^ w\o X_o_^_.!° \._?>x 2- <=-a-a-X AX -_==-. X^aX^^- 5?^>.p.. ..vy\?sA..-<^. sX .Sr\<- ?5-jc._Aaa.<A. .... rf MvaA^-??^. \ .... VN.r^sy <r-.....=_.

va_a.o A~\o-a A-^ Xr *-v__K: ©C. v^_.^-_2_/ -\a-a,^~^ aAt v>0>cj-S>AX

±5?_^<f^jo.z?^-e^ X-A.j-2-- 0;j-5^5-.A^A._>. ._.X^.:_X_^.^ ^..^ A"_a=- :Aa_a-i_ _X

^.5__t vX:..........o.xX:X \ £X> i_ -AX. .C-AAa ._<-__ OOj->.j=b. rej. cs.r*;.. Vcs_5__ O..^C_.-?Jr s> cx£.

.X.'2-. C_Q.._aX .Aaa.-5->j\. ACj^-^^O AAAfX _V-A.-?_.-_.^.>A!_A.^._?__ A>A___X<

._=A <Ac\r_•€...-s^..... <=?s.-^.*-\.. A..5. %AA.-<_-_ A>AAAaj>j-5vAA;\MqX<->.^A A.-A

PA.CS, .X?..V.X_.AA'a_^A:\ X^.e\X-e-X_ X=?. \^A=A^ ^3<-_tAA-.3_

.___2V^^.,_ri,...!s_0._rN_r-\.." ....._ .— — - - • -•• - -

/^-AA;-"S~CA Aaa=X _C?Co ..^___-jf '̂XAyA^,/ A Avs o..vN^V\A._AaX

.^A_XA<A^S^^^-^^X.^./- A-S-AA-A _A_.._._-A_i___'c=s.._^ _._v^-___i5:?--^^.:_-^Ax.....n-_'̂ .j

._^_kr.-<=_^d-_=L \^js-^l<^. f_^. ^j>^pX_-d:_-A<2 .i_.vL.?. vaa<_, X

rX_ _..__A-A__k___....__^\X _ -_ — - - - -

•"XXaj^--^-.. X X..__L-_:_-A..X<_:X.._ Arf5 _-___...^_r<=A....-VA-Ari _A1-_X__

.tc_0 -^>s>s^...J^^r\^.sZ C^J^sS^^-.^OL^r^kss'^^i^T. AI^SlAl .T^toiJAAa-X.-A-X_.-..A....-X.QArx.-A eXo.-._X& AAa^-... X_^c_X__rv^-^.._X^_^_____-l

A>aX . .!TV»A:..r. - - — - - - - -- --

..C^.-S.VvV'ri- Vj/.^O.l.i, <=A X<A~AV ^A-A^r Xa?.A_e.AXA. ._A..._=. ..rrA_-_r^rA... .<_r__L^_-Si _.A_o_.__5.X_a. X^°>^a3-Xv c\ <=y=A-a

X_>:f. ,Pk.^53X^_.yv^.j€_, ^.-X5^--?.-^

AAa-,^ ;3,.^_A_A55L__=_,- X^.o^__?_-X- A-A.^.r VXa.^^

iA_A_Arr_^ A.^.^X.!_^_^^. _AAa_=_X..a<^.^_._-A>_^i^2?._ ^^....^-C^A-A.\w^. X-c-5 r-vA-A-<;..X va, (£3 r- <r ^_.cj_-X'ri _ Ai-v? _7V.A.Ar.^._-iS__r-A......-Ar|.

y^-AcpX.A-)v-'v/ ..^X?.-J.\.S-.__v..s\.^v A AX_.^jS yj\oA . 0-v yy\ "==-

Oc=X <s->-^X ^_c_.^aaX. 7AX.A=-. Xr^^.Q->^A.rAA-.----,s '̂=^s7 ^VA^/AtA

Page 28: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

2,2-

Ax^cyS, A^. ... S^.T—r-X^VA.. -__-.-QV.C-X °y <--• \aA\Vs.o^a .. J-AXnX ' V cAo\r

X<gAA/ %e~. ..?A .-AAsAAo^ _S_-__^._-..vrAiA_r) X._?_=.'__kX...- \A_\Si \A\f_je_

x~XX:jrb X^v^^^ A^A^g-V'^ A-a XX- AX v ,

IZ^^x-su^ .k_S....,vX_^_._ _--Jk-s_s_^^5=__X^.AXS_...iS>ArA. ,£SXP-!--i -__5A_^_<eW-.:_^^ iS±-u.*r^i^_illiJ!a

VA <V-1

X__X.C._-a.r_^-X X XA S-. Co^AJv^r- Xo v-x-^s-^. X, X5.^.5_--.._-Aj__^ !_L_S=~_---!-^--^

X O^A

JIAXa._-S= ....^X-^___-^_-X-...:^^^.jX.__eS!^ .^^X^r-A-....._>^xA_3..^r__;..,.-..._^= .S_jX\AS-_VA____±a_ VjVA... o X _AJ~A ....... VV^— .____---^__S-._\A^^ ^jQ-aC^c-;

__7\~acA v_jsO.Ax\^ X_:_!A_-_J!X^

X \ *=_- -^a.\ £»3 v/vxv -a va>\ 0 AX.£> "X / X> >->X__XX^Xaa.AA A_l^A-.____..s:

_<_X.s_-.XXA.rA A-ajs-X-..

.!-S-__A.-C..^^ 'X-Xe OvArP o-S-^X^-

_C__:_!~A^S^AAA.t£- C _.Q_-_KS_X_.^X_^^ _X_o Cva w-a e.X A"^a. -yq.

.._^^_--_t Xzo -^^j€^._f£^.PJf_J^^.^_ X^._tAX^_ -lXVj^..j^..AX__!=?...__...r_A..-__L_t_r>_. x_:_-A.A7aaA^..--3.A a^:_A\ _QV.i^^

..._X^.-^^^-^^'^'XA^A_x.- ,_. -._. .-..-.. — .- - — --..,-..__—

Qka XxX^_...2^ AX-<= vA^xaXAzi-...-..^CL vA^yw, AC^A\...?rXv./......A._.._..-0^^^ ..Co.r_rA.^.^AA.<^l_ ;,.As?. .^-__X.A-A

_A-^.-.._..:f---_X

js_^.__k_s=a .X_^_r.^Vs..^-_^^_^^.r\ -X^.AXx.._.Cso.;0.r\_s-^Aj \e=vj\ s. C5. vyx'A <A<- «-\ v>v-a g_.AA.v_.-A AX^*"" ^^ v7^ "̂sXaAAAr.

oVq. ^_ \-^. _\XA.c C)X<-sA. S^^y^n^'^.\s:j^^^.^f^^^~^^^^Ae, _X^=^Ar^~^ -VA_A"q_ Ax_-p-_r^3.'^.

11.0 fA9 X. -AXvA

Page 29: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

23

:____-_>. V :aV.Ac\_^__._A-XA^

jS_xA_s_-_-.-s.-J_;.' x^\;__, \^<_.ffieicX^- <=?xss\ s.A-rs.rA...^.....^- A.a_a

Aaa,-^. vva. vcAcxl^- _^X___^-s____i _X_XA.r}_A.jL.-„A_. XL-AX X-—-"AXA-X:v!_D.^X <0 3T^CL \ 3X\—I VK^Xa-^A X^L S)y>V.$. _^__v__S__Lj2iSL^!

Afq A^Av> vvx^i C <^.S> -<£- r vXX <-^~^ X ^ oroS <-.<=.aaX

.VOjjV^ X^<Avvc<lc.X^X' . .

VAc O v~A-<-_<aA O VxlA AXv. ^b !_AA_QjXAX_..-.,Xr2_...._

_-_^_^A.-e..._._..«__Z_>XA_^_-

_^_^_^_.5.._^___ia^_ :XX.:^_.._...W^A-^-_--jgg>X-. f\Xv^v._;gAs._.^ ct\aA _-_:Aji^:A:.-S-,-C..r:_ „

Page 30: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

i*>.

2-T

XMcAri-A A__s)Xavv__a...AAAa_=__ AAA-Tq _s_-^^_^.____^^L\S^si .A^__._A^_^_?_..- 5A._.„Xr_.cAXC^-. XX CN-c^Jft s.^pec^xSor CX

Azd_. A->=vA\^ Ato XoA~>. V AA ^4 <j_^.A5

_A A/w Af)vXX

,^--»-k___. x^

LQL__L__ OA. <=><- vj^.^3, caXXX*o -e X ~^<_A p. s •

ly_.^\^^^ /A^^A&Ti-^OOCX Q_£_ ^Q\J^.^L-..A^S>\^^.

.Xosi.tvAS.fei^XAlL

AlvcTx^v ^vAA^^^D.vv5=> AiAC.©/sje>\-^7^^7 ^.7Xvfe>A&NA./_..--

?Pt)L£S> T.D. XA^^L AaAAAAA "A^t^ SAAfesTakATXAJAA .\SsvAfe, £«=...

..JsAD ^Xk^CXL,. XAA\IXa>-A0. _DXS^-C7 Ao X?g.\.3t.X^_7&§2A

.XEj9_&\lO-3__-_^^ Qsx^X^MX...^

AXftLtAA To AAAAvJAA^ T o 3AA\2j?AAfess, XvXXA. .^AALS.E...... MYSfeS. _

i_X\AA^.Cfe,__ _ _ .- —.- — - -—

A_.v_A.__..^v_-_c_xvX.\_A.^

o-^.v:_?s-^i^ -__s\A_XiX.Xosy__g Aaa..-^-. ____._SS_v^.A-_^_^

X- AA\ S ..X..XX_^3<^._:_ _ - - - —

X^CAAv. ^^^^^YS^^r^S^iCS^. X-SXX:. _V_-_---CD-v).^.-_-.X,...„.C.OV^.vaaC3Jv

qX\ .A_sXX_...;Xa^ lizajs^Lj&s^L-^-

ci L_z_i^_^_^__L__t^je^_^

As^^^X^X wv^ ^ YXAX A70 «?V. _AXA\.r <?_X QXXvC, AXX.=,<-,<=*->_>: A^rD^r.V^A .wvr.T-^ \X-c-, oro._Xj

,-A-c5--A_'~<a__A __s> •c__, - ,.._.

...f^.C, -_«- JL rv..«>-_.._

Page 31: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

23

.iX^^...^ X_3A\*J-l .X_.-..^A_.ON..^._.A_^.

avAPoreS.v_; ____-__i_X-lSX .y__\..X_l_---^

Xj.._X.A__U.x_d \^j_-..^W

AAa.3Jl__C.q_v^^ _?__-J.X._X^-_vA-.'?^-._^A___--_S-

._-__XX<-_)^A-C:^ g\c^<^t ___^__..t_X-?^-^-0__i_Aj£__..,OA^^ _C-S_-^S_«-dL -_^__-M-^L__=

A-O. ;Ss^Xr:<c^^

,0_A.A.r_>X--3.-.«X. --__5-_-_-_--A A_A\ s _C.Q.r_^__A-A.^Xr. ..As?- __^._-__=....._-._^^_X.?-V.S__._-_^.3A^ A___k_5= __4___S_A__^_!_>/___J_te_^ A- _^C5i^_j____-_X-

UA*^Xv.-=c-A A.. d'vj.'rA.t AgJ-.^S>SS> <aa.^X\^. «=aA_.c_Xv AWsXa/:a5o.,. X-- _...^avA l.\ X^oaxa SaXX^Xa,^- XC3M Vx-..^^Ak <Xr X.jj,. s~.s_. <?=? XAr^->r.ri \ c\>a^.sU* ^ Aan XV. sA3A .•«...:. -«*. a.-a Akv <__Lo_l£_v____t--^ \_^A^£:^3X.__^ X.Xj3_>^.--VX-A.\^<^<=^___..^._r_X^_S._^v^^,^oV .V.vr^.^_o..C«-t^.'A./._._.A._ Xi<A_~' Dl _,l_?^.r_l<cl _•^VAAAAtt-i £_O..C_ ..C-_Oi_0^_-^^0.\!&./-siC..&_.^...-... - -

fSv^AWA-^ 7.a <3X=3r^ s.'IkrXc^ Cx5_^l-.._ciiefa^_..Ce>v3kvv.S:^

-OC^A^aXX ykA_vA.X.c>r_:....-Av<?- ^^Qs.^^^^\.&^*£=^=: 3jsA__-_-*2_-.." X<__jV>a..-_..X .lA^S-X^ _0__*!_S_S. _f^^_^__&_-.

ii>__.Arto._.XX^

_^.A-i _«-_r___..XX'A^

c=^.^_._.W^^ A_X_xs__ AX^,^^iA^^vA_d_...C.., ..SA)__:AX^_.._^..y._.-S.&2>., ..^V^A^ vi C^c^r, __35_.vX^> %A-J&l lk% >_r5_VL_fejj2 M_2^_.™^_A_s_i_ss_iL_.^yJvVv^-^jA., -AX-^.._.AXvA..--^a c^JvA..-..-^vSO^S_-=.A AX^A^L^.--.A5_--_

WVv^jv-*-. Xt^* 3-e£--sJ s-jt.

Page 32: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

zc

tXr (XX ^cX Xc-vA^-iot W CcoSS ~€_?CLc\wv\^A'ggt WvX

<_

Axv^ ^-.ov v.¥ Av\gAr A'y^^. gAe-X^^3-^--- eov_vAS>-J a^o\ xXv_s^xy^^-e-dL ^\cX^Ae \ACow9vsXJr CovAAvvd; oXscX

\vA>)g ^AA dai-^A-cS^S \Xc^c-^\*=^C.-<-X At^a,^ "HA*^3 ^"^X^

C .y_wv.X gA-^-V^ c ^ •Vc'̂ c-V^-a^ AX o-^ ._<giALxX\___^jp___^A-^A\Ava-^ v^Wviio^ _5gg.g-\«=v\:\sA ^^A ooAx^^

t_) -<^-X -^->a g, •«___ ca^-.v-awas. -gj. A-.e^-,\A-^.^X \^s_-_-S-^-5_ygjs^-lJJS-a-W\c\am A^vqAaA-i -r->X=.\-€__r__V\o'-Ac^W\-g-/ \ <-_«=*. c\A*a«=°\. •^/•A '̂sVx CM

s__> ^ AaA^-Y"0^^^--^^^ ^ K? 1n'L' ]1 ^- -̂ - • X^ ^Jr^--AAja^ <c ^ v-^-y XA-^.oV A^=- «=^g\cAr<s-=. AK-g- ci<_aov.c-T A-a Aw

^a_--vAL-_^^

»w^ ^x? o£-i--l-_\Xv^AaX^ \Xv7^- p-r^-S-d-^^^

c--<-_o\A-g ^ vac, ^g-c <-, fr \ cA^vXA A<-A^v^ gwc\ A cXqXA

n alp H2--XXX

O wAaA Xa -g- Or-o-S •<-. ^ vX- r ^=»<^\.a •cy_x XA-e~~v.c\ V\g.o gA,-A_cA, va^\-i A<A-g^v5-c <-_-. qQ'a5 -*X VsAr\S >_A

_ic-g-C-^_x=--!-at_^^

Page 33: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

.X

J~ I

._.^}Xxi,„_^^^

JD.&XA<Xvi^^^^

Xo XXXaA!^

ArN.fr XXAX "9 £.O5bvb-CLoq^XV VAvAlASXA-XA V&g* ^_\SJ^^1nVJ^0

-^•.^...M\XA„....^ X^^^xX\X^ A) vaX AXaa^s^ AXx^iNA

CH\toC. flLLE-£.e_.Q MVCL-yy^ tep\^\U\7N..

A.__x....X-_!A:^^

-_L_eA_>.S._XX.AvrvX^ ...:X_ 3...-^r.-?A. .=^r>X ..fei!;?^-:^

S_L^_--\^^----^=_=-X^ .f_5...^.Xx._-_A_.AX,^___XX^^.....A^^f^_A-^

._-A_-_Xa1c-A^XA^

X.XA^....4^ X -V

-AA:̂ .s"- £=V ....!_I-AX-!AA_.^^

*___.. -<£__ t-__\Ajs?j

-.X ,.Ax...^ r\/\A -e. wA:

ASA

AA-v

<=v

,<r;.^_.^_r- ___---A_-_=-3A<

aVa. v\<r Q.^_>asX_._.X.^-..

AA^^.-5V'aVcaca C-cA _A_-__.

cAc-4~AX-

as

v^XxX:X_rX ^S1--^...^^'^SL^S:^^J^S^^^~:

a^=>-cXxaCc> __.

.,.,.,.<=K -e_.ir-

ycAAS-AjSi'r-J

\A-A ^_1 A^aA \\=A VV\.<rrXl-

.__=__^XA<E.._. ^3....._XaS=LS..X__r_

X-...AAa^- fXr-X*; •<=-

g^f\^^\v^Xt.._.__vA.."?_:. _xiy'.,.„.;Ac_:A_j5

v3. \ "A •g-C.-A VQ^AX jjA

A.

^-X— -X

^\v\^a- \.vA.A?_f. X..^..AXX -^^^^±rQ^^<,

r-_A-A^.._;j._Xf.^^^ ^x.

?lxx.L^Z_!!A_^I^

^3_3.-^-X-K_=-v_X-S-i •SA-\ A-V^C-i^

<=X\c--^r>ArX<X xC^'-ko*

•$> T' > vc.

Page 34: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

~/-.~b

_Cj&v>..c.^.cA.^_a £Xo.ce g?s^e?\ <X x^.:x3a...X..rv... x?.vA\xp.Q\Xc XA__§__.-^..^wArxx^Xv^X^ x^v^^x-c. XX_X:^. AxA.w^._^XsAXt<;c\aA ^X*=^^~-\7-,Xc^ XXAAAw'Aam -<x ^X^axa. \...>.,_>XcA.X_«X_-A.^X7 At .CX~a AxxAwX -^XAV-j. X^- vj^=yS rA.c>V.E=v-X .jxAm oX=XA~>^^ vx\.^- \.a AAa, ..<_^AA^XAxaAa

VAx^ cX\X v\?\. •^^•^^X^^^3>X^caX^- AX<-_C=\SAX ©v- X\X A/A <_ <^_^Aa7...X-_c^ C«=v. -S-e_ >\\yA,c\,s=, S?X--^p \X c: X^A X*:X..X.X_a_ X..5rA. XA...X A^AcA _mX_/...cryA_cA _X_^.X_-._^.??.5=:'-.cA _Cx^-^Xa^"^ ." ..._-_ --

\__SL.1^A^^^r^£-^dE^ VfrL X:O.XX.3 XA .'̂ A.WVX...^£_9..X_.:_^_....

AxA wa_s_ ^ Aaa •_—. XxAxA AwxA..._ A _X. x.X xa_?AXv.xA. "xx ?AS>AXAXv Ava_Xa. X^XX^-A-A.XXX... A~A_ ^aa AXsXwa c

"rA S=XA A_.Aj. A.. Xx_ sA.)^J^^J^=^T-—^r^.S^l XXXrXA. AAA _.

£*\e,QA.vA..<^r4. S>XaX cr A cAoXA t^ ^V\<>j <, ^X -«^a V OAXAX_XxxAX .S?.:_XXr AX Xr: XxXx A3 _AA_7SX.IsLs^^iS*,.saA......._Xa.<^-X X_A_4xtXfx3J

U\w, c^^-a^_^c.^-.,. V A^XXX. ArArx .a>Ax^-S .._X5_X^^^-s^-(^^yy^.r^^^£Sr.^i^i\: _x_\7.A.<,.'?_3s..v \Axx _^X:...£Svn(_X:..x.^rx^x_rvX\X-\X «_ x^x*..—.Ar-^rAAAx-fx.. _...yMj5_r-.-...;_^h^.^.!_??. _Xxxx__ _ ~- -

jQ^ _Baa._xw.sA 5>_..._...2=5AX ..aXx.xaa c^ <^^sJ&\xs

^^y X.!XX- .<?=_xx^ Ccv^..^._ Xc> v^xAA aaAAaX AXXX..X^.xa5.s X^x.w_aX^ ...Ax? AXa^xX. >^.^_..y^-^>=^^-...A^--Y

IiA^ia k__A 'px-^?A -^. V. A.xAX-Xxr-.x-X._..-.AXa._^--XxA-xxXxxIJAaasA..A a^&XX^X X^..-.-Xx-_^.-..AAx..X^.^jxxX.X^oj^5_c_aS_-2=x._iiiXA.A^ AA..XX7 _^<_..^.^_sX^—Xa ~c~

AWsA'. Ai.AsA.<,C5 _.^X3 x .XA *AAX p_\X-a \ c^AX , v\v^.\AV AXv^sstJr

i

i

Page 35: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

^L.1

Xjx-n AsAaj«__ ;>^XAxj==> v^o^-S. Xas3x\x.x<_-_ A— Am..-^- A°X"-j. xAA>.1cAwX-a.^X.X.X!X._S__.oxpAX-X^.?,., AvAr QmxXX C_^X_W\.s ©yiA .^\sy<^\ <?aw_X SXAi v"VAa-\ C..X\-c.X XxJNA^si^^L 3..^A-^-A, As-aJX AivA-c.s.,. X-^ XXAa<_ wAw^y X=» XXX<

__-.^X l^V XX- -A^\X Xo^.€_ X^^^^s-A^«XA_xsXx<- OAXA>

X.-^.c^.-_^.X..c>.^A :A=l^-vA^_ic:A XA..X_ fAAA-X .X.^jXx_\__s.'̂ S_.'__i_ XXXX__

-.s-AAx..^ 5A.5s.isX^^^- ut X_5X^x?._Xs «xA XA-AAX^X

.....XsX...-^. ^...x:.j^j^^=£^^Sis:.... .=A_=._\_i--_= _AxAs> _Xs.3^a.^..X?-X.\,\-e_, XXX_A«-A. TAP cX\S.CAQ3.-c-_j^r^..AA AXaXXt. XXAl

.vsiv^-^cSiS^d?^-- X<r yA?x.-n <^-<XXAXXxAw of ...Xx XViA_?'XaxAXaa...... - - - - - - - --• — -

0w ;Xca~v %3..,. Xo\t>,Vx.fi\Wp-cVA fe-vs^

\.s=i-Jt_^_^^ _.X.55A^a-. xx_^swx_c. c_v__>_cA_..^crAvXv.. c^^X Aw_-5_..

X__^A^_=r:A_A<___^.-.__.^...A.^ k_ oXs _...<S__rA AAV<A -g. ca^^. ...c_v..-A.A cAvxXa. <X<_X<-..

,^Xv^ S.3^1Ao3 :<^XxX-A IXA^A.X_.X<-„..p.£c^.sx -Q_-

_^X_sAAaW_. ___iA_Xx._=__ v.v^^_s:.^.A--y*-^/- A>AX._---^.._.-.C.^\X\5> ^W^o^XV,... rX^^.^ s>AX-3 j©-^—J3^.a^.^er^ Xx_s\\

J>&s?..&rJ- «_. nx...... _ _. _ - - - - - -

"AX r^_ 3A_-X^.-_=^ X^Ar^A Xo _X_x_=Xxr.u.fcsAx^

MA.Xx_.a_...-.X^ a_^._....XaX.s^^

.D-c.^js^^^js^__^\j!^^ A== X_Xa.c-.-Xk2A -XA^-._._xxxaA._.XO.X-X.._>__^^ .__S_..X..AX.X^.yX_-rXr:.:- aX_XX_X-. .A.__-_-_—

*=?^A»^a^_S^_-«S^CJg«?s9v .._AvXr._._^

-s*X' 5>

.M €_ .

>2) -<-A- t-A ^> -=- CoovaS -*_v ^^ ^> vS \n_ veV .. \3X<xXxS_. 3

n^AX_a A>x«sA nxcA<xo\^.xX>xX Ax3XAjxX'̂ : '̂ X>x^wxXtAr vX-^-^-^A,s^ XaaX? CcoSS -e^c^^X^\_A_x\A^x_) X

Page 36: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

•*>«

^^V:^.cA XA.^..X_AXXX^^:AAvX^..-_.^:x._x.A .^._.XX.-^X._!^^u^5.^. ^..XA...I\w....-...AX^ S^S>2^^z.2,2z.i—

\^XAAx_-^:...xa^

AAA ==A _ X_=„-^. ~._-:_^

A„.._3_A.ajde_wx2^a^^^_„__ ^>X_0..._Sr--...-..Ax..SAXy- A,SyS<^„jt_2.kX^^ _-3Xx.XC

Xo<

_-s^s.-_a-!A---..A^-sw.x^ -X-^XSixXX.' —^_XaXa^ sxAl !=As..s-__...Av^A?A,. .....XA^ W^xaj._?X _Xo>^...__

AvV_Afk^L.s^^^ .v^._XrX^A^ 5£.Si£riS>^_v___A-_A!_-v_5^^ X^XLXcAaL. _..-..

^X,..^^_jsLw.^_-..-..\xxa

X.^-k_X=a^b-^_~A^^

.^cr_AX.o^^.vp_.rv^3.-^>......x-^^.^.x^e^.'-^_.^L.vcA: ^^..vA.XiA.X _=-..% a__aX

\^ XjX, ^^.^.^

_^cX_2X. 22fil*__^Q3^^

_£&==±^_jslJ^ ^.-.•Xr_x_.__-^A^A^A.-?^. As^<^<±&£&_£AvA.±^...©-C

Page 37: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

•£>.

~~ .X5^_&:jL_^

_.JAXX^^

.Ji^^jLi^iJis^S^.

<r va _=__.!l5-Jl3 .^i^„'^:iA^X_A^_V 5-^^ 53„,.

__V_Y^A.?-=r._...A!^ jC^c^r>^C^-=--X_^i_1.-__LW§. <Xe=J£s_*5-^^

Ar<_^^m^^A_<-^j©~.:-^-,3A_^^—£A£- •^5_.VE-_-

n SA. .a _=, XX^~-—/---Xj

jS^-g _a__-.Sw.c> „jAaA<; o>r~^ -^=A V\\ „s» \^^^<J^C^^^i^^.^.^^*C.l_Xp.r_X_Ai_-^^^

<&\cL^^^&±jc=--=^^1 LO.._\XX£>A „ - -<c

_?..r^5.^.S^fe._A__. C^vaa^cA^X Xv-C^AArq. ^xX_a^..-AvAx-

_u_Wi-~_^^-C^ ,o.xi^w,Aa_X^^

\ a •<">€_ ^-,-WAr^ v< CXoX^. .r>4 vXva ^ 2-.0& (-.

IS ^- GVh-

\___j_Ax\.XvX-^_Xs^A^__o<^ -CI.wvx^Pvc~V=~ AA_ ....^_Af^...«_A_....A.^_cAy.A ^X^^Acvvdt ^v\W A± XAx.._.!XX..,.....£.i> _ _

Page 38: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

X"--

\X.3_-----A^.^^^ xX-fA.vA_jS_......dxAXxlX..

X_r-\.,\^ —

_S2SX..d^XA^XA".,.-..-A -E^As.iX_!£^^

C^^fijs^^^

„^x.®._^^^ oV.._,..Ax,.s;„..3A^.A^.„..x2r^.^_-?_,sXA.oA-«w..X-^s. __^x^owxX._3_^^

LQ...&2-i^-i23-X.Al_.-X.'- &v-_a.X.._..:X_x^^

k\^x^^^-^0-vXvjA^^.A_V^^

.Q^-X_^£_-&--i^-X:--^-^^^Jl\^^--JE%^^\As^^:%S^^-^V-y <o

Aaa^.^-..^ -AAex^ -XAa-

MaAcXa ^s^--^&^^^- ..^-AaA^x^

.^Xx__^:X^^^ ^\^^^^^^^^^^:_£&$>. £3, \A <=xxX j^^^Jil^-S^L: _._ - - - - -

'XvXs :«= _K5X ^.^-X^X._^rA_X5'.X.. .AvX__A_..XrA..frr.. XxC.rj-r_._X=?vA..dL... 'X^..^.^. A.I<s^a^..^-_^-.._.-.-Aa_^,.__ss.A X^^AA^A^^.^-.....

y3^s:;^j^._^.^.„„...c?X _v>_>js:fc^^^ A-A_.--^_AXuA.^^^ —

J&S*_^sv_i3^_C2^^ijv, .. . .

o oAao

^o^_._oX-AAas_ X^.__aXAv_x..s.XA-X-5 ;.x^ .AAiX_.XX„..^

\s

Page 39: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

'brt>

AV\.-^.. .t3A^AyX_ .-X^S^X*

XxXAcyrA^, a.~>. ^E^s^r. NL {^.^^^^1^3.0)^•e^ AxA"A^AxaX.S X^V>XAXAXXW.. A.S b<AS<_,. ?A.S__

SJ. p. ova Ax^AA^o^-l Xt _v".<l_XaA.A^ "XwAx^-^X-.-,-.--

\J2=S>xA^ aa X .34. ^ N.V.... V...U 1

4

e_ ^cXcAq<_A£- Oo.^.A^ X-.^.v.^-V^i .....

Ax-g-..wrii- Ax.3?-vxA A.— .— -..~AX«_... c:cx.x.A X^xxr.

£XA_3_AX___X-A ©I XXXA 3eX-~ry\vA..X A>_>.._£_ _^_AC.X_ SaXxX.- X.XXAt-1-S.gl <X\o V\o»a «^X A_>AaXXX:\^ X AAa«_ r^o^XX?..^ AtxaAs .C<xx~X g^^X. ^a..'..^.^C5J _^.a.A o|_ ^X3^:Xw^.saA..X HAA.<=, AXlAsAxA g?sb>xwk aXAaXx"W\o9 ^-a xv^ ^_.^._..;X\A_2^ .Ava^A_._A.o.x.x_-x1_. ^xXx... S^-a VAjAa/^A^c-.. gAA \i xe <o~... Axv_<?, ^eA-vxx.-. ow-ax - —.—~Xa^x._AXA....^.„...J^3jr^^ XAXX^ .^X>._xx•^V^-.ey-X -^-Cvj\~.S .\r_<s..X^._^...,_^A.....-cE:A. -..._Cx_xs_..X!^^_ ^ Aa AX£A iXXX^ _ _ - a. - _

A £ Av -^3XX^..<_XAX.../.... ...XvA-.^_31^-^-.AA5._V--'5- CXV.-A_.

A.^wv^vi.S .c_vC.X X.CO----M _Ace __=>_-^-_ !S_>-W....^,Ca._X_AA.^^.x.A^^.cij^-,. Ars=>. -X\.xAs..x. _^ -\^^>S^\,\^^s^.i?X.__i^_-^.J3S-jk. xoXq. _a__a.xXapA Axax sA^_a<:. X^a(..^_...aAa.^=._

i-0.c^i

I ^c.L^^^^r^A.X^AX. ANAA..^_-._^Y^-a^ CX&sK XX jVx___-__! vvA.y^s\j.«^.A\^^_ <?s< e. ^AA_. HcAaAx^s, saaXx_x_x__=ti ^ _,

x...._3.._._..XAASiX<x-^..-._- <cx_r_v.A ^x^_-^^-Xxjq^X^c-^...._ -X v

Page 40: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

**>H

*AVa-^- QvToS^^vXir cttast- ^iW-g-X xX^XX-A-e.sX_-

AAaj^X.....oA-X^AXL,.^

A, 1-_JL.X^^A^S^X_ A3__..._XAX_L^AXxA. \ voC.^--. -Ar<r <=\-_>AX\ ^v gy cE\.^_J_XXs--?„J=-^^

.S-_X>X^_:^._^

\\3&.„J1£L„.

^XX.s__.A\._.^_.._^^

.)(X._A._.-__^Xv..rXc 3_xA_„i2AX<^X--i.Xx X=X.^.>X.X^.A:^.._--Cgpv" g>v.<^...^_S_sy^-A.^^y^-fcjv-._..-.-. •-

\ „_X}cS^ASi_--X_^^

<As.;e^.E\.:^^ XlrS^j-Wv- ._y_VAA^\iaA-*swvVx^~> cta,^cA «X^_-XxAaX^-i..-_A__a-_Azjs.^-X-X=\AwX-A^-AX-J

Az_C3. SX.:«^A;±griXX-AX\^^

.Ax__^-X--c?-AAwr^-^ -XXX "Av\^-g-js.-g- 9_:xbi^_,.5x .•>.

XovaX A Co^AcAvaA •^XLX-^.X^^^X

.X_A_-_b AXN----_^^A......5XXJ_.J_... - -

AX...X.3. _\^ve_r*^.3_rsf^sbvJ-J'.<- _..Ax? XXt 'j^..-^._^-^.^.\.:v-^a,.._--.a^v_a..'S-, es5.crXpX.r_. ^-X._...ga.--AXs?^

A^A.^r-. ..._.^XXrA.r^-^A.__=? cpX AsA-A-g,,. Or ^.Xfe-^A. ^ AAX-^a._AXa.A^r25=^.^-X^A^.,...cA\c\ j!0-J5^r„CSL-^ _X*=aP^^^^^^^X-^i^s^./ bo.>r-A__._AX^ tTAA.A.X.'r-.._A.__3.-A_X,.. .xxa...-__-r-XS-.'C..s

A_.___-^vm3A\=v ..<A.r^5_..-x-.A.^s=L Xss vAAovcv^. SX.X_Aw_. .^zx_-x:—_X_--_^-__^.^^

X> <-C.gA^A^. ^x;^_.___vjrA_S£^

OVcvAS. .

\ vxjAa va A-^_ A^^^XX^XAri ^^£^j^^9^^^^^

Page 41: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

•i.s

Ar^.V^-<_ AA°X <r -<s_ S-pOoA,^ \A==AAAXi X-_=r.A. X.V AxxXb

K.vaOQ..-«^.^.c_. X^-«--XvXi-«--^^ X>A-A\^_g^^ A_>XxAc:X\_

V\A_A_s» _y\ pAXA v-a..* >^V\Xfe_o..<^\)..<jr .A\T=. A p...AX.Aw <$-5A_yC

cXXAAr ^^. fX-A=Aex. ^x-xXvaA^ .a<d-XAa3, Ax-. XaqA>O.AAXv .?:X,-A.,r_7 cr?A=>v-.\^. -<r_. cSXX _ VA-a—1 AxX A.Sa.

A cX-Ov^x v/\-<e.-vJ -«^r- ..Qr<,A<rA.vA' C£><~ A.^X.^.r-<_-..,Ax..-<-_-._X ^xA. AyAex^. AXsaAw Xa-taA vxp_r^..^^_>..--..v^jiw^jf?A^jA/vsA^A/ A^> a X ^r^r. g^.\w..X _2^>/v>yjoAtAd.vaAv'.i axa©.x__aAxA. A__>A.^cX.c..^ \ v/vA^Ac \A-e_.sq X^y-A: A^sX^^X e?_j£,._A/a gAo^Aq X^.-..A'^Xv_x_^^ X_rXxX-r_-_=_c. -Xa-A... _X_x^_X____X..

ijy ^r_^-^J_f=A.Aq....- .cX^..XAXaSo^ Ac^.. X^..:g-- aj^_ox.v\.A..s.„ AX_«--c:-_._.-)s(T\T^-^^.^./-^.<S^r^<^. XXxX ^_?=._rA.5X.X-A >J...«.A AxX S.

_x\A.XAA.vvv^..e.rg- X=> ^X-^X ..-Xs_L5=^.X__3. ^xA -.-XVX^.._•..._.

A Xxx-^-pAx c..<-i-^.c.-_A....vx\n X-FAvXr<-.....rXs?.

....XXa^...v^^rri...-_.<^-5AXAA^ Ap«- _A5-Sa-^\ .ka_^_5-A^._AvA_A-r<?^AAA__S____a.-_--___\._._.-A. .A^_..»..._~>c._^

LlxX)X ^aA. QAXA.'-ixAq,, :A^A_xA. A_eA As.....^S-J$Mx^_vXX._-!?rr__:_Ax c____s^-X^ ..X.Q.vxax_,........Xssl.. -X? ...x_-. AX==>.cxAo..X_<.

Ao-i Ax-a, <_ xXj3c^^vx__....c^-a,A. -X^Aa A..X-.._.vAvA Aav._^;. v^X:

.j1aCAXa\X,_. - - -

A ..A^rxx.A^--A X^=>... ApvA^-_\p.E^^.j^.'sr.-.S>..-- >XAa.x-^a A vs^js N._^^.....^A^_^U£A_!-ts. .^wjA

.As^_iXA?w_rA...-._\..--C.x^ Xaa.<^.._ ...XAXaA.^^ A

LLv^^>AvAm_a.X _cA.o At ^.A-r^X ^.-A-AA^^I i ,

liAX__xx_._-X^<o^^vA,^\ _X<?- -0=A5^.<s^._x_._

:!\w.xX^_-_=s-A cr?.X.... ..^.-iX^^^,..XxXXXXAX\.^_^.. aw....CA__\.3.c

Xq XX-a ^XA«-. X .«^c. A^=_ <XXxA.~x <I.....<x^^^_X-. ....•3A^Av_X\Ax .-«=_. _V>_x^, <e>7aa <^r. x-<_AA<^^^vax--_? ..Ax-Xv <CX\—a _-^-jvXiAVA V/a-^— . A ^A*v.<i- X CcNA.5.olA XX.A....cAr On. <

\_-S........S.^r_X.X^N--^--^-^s^v_-,l

Page 42: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

is1-

Aa-rsxx: v-XV-o Am <£__ x.-XvA^A . xX—A<^. fx o\ XX.X\-X

X'g-'^ A~x? A'Q) X-Xa^xX: X^A>\ -C~ y^^.^gA <^A A~-?. «=A.a VA>XXS..

/v\-q_ .SXAXXtfi_sA b^\^^^i^^^£...<^Lj X^.x ccxv\-S -g-_ ^"a-gXXs.'XA.

-S-^AA

V\<=\-

--^.^^^--.--•^A^sXA.JvXj —_.

X. S-.-AAAvyq Ara /A^X -^-^- \Cg\ XvX^g-^ry .VAA_.X(-X,-5A xAwvor-e- X-..S2-WA.^ £=?J^.:_^«_S.._=r_ •Q.A...^feX-S^r-A...S?_._._.

LC\

_-_X.xA^-xA^-tA^ _=_A.,iiH\.sD.w-_x^

......_^^x_r^AV^.._...^)j^ XX-..Aes_A.ovrrl„_ „_ ., _ —

/^.J^_...,_,.Ax?...,_..Aa_a_^-.., A.X5XX_t§A- $bk^A;_ru Am..

_X_-_JE^j__-i^V

Af=A^s__Ax?xXs^^ .^XAxxA-es

AXoj£L„.,.,^

<Axj__b^^X.:3^^

XXjAxAx_.j^^.A._

Acc\J\<a W r -^^ <s_nJ ^^^5^s^^^sS=^^^±LMmo^.\ A<^.:!=y^ A_^__<X s=_h>X_Xr .VA,...^A..„ XA.X-.X.Y. --——••—• '^- A\\XjA^f^j3^^A£^..^s_sfZ!...i._. ...._ -~ - - -— ----- •• - -

V \<^oa^ Qy, Xs-A-A.... .vAXr^.™^SX..AC.hrA3_.-^. ^J^..S.A ..X^vj..;^ y\_g>. !±^^ss=--ssu=_ Xs=_ 'X^j. A AX^...._X...X^^^

.S3^SL£N^Sa.«-._ .tsA- ,XAA...._AsXA.X_-..-.A^^ AAkxt.

_\_ AXaO.XvXaX _^^Sr^_A^^

xAA.-.ASvAXaj^ Xxa..AA::^^-^-X^^

_A ?AA-X:A£rS,rsA^. -XA_xX>-XX_-__X-_.-.^v___As^v=-A-.o_x^

X-.-

v -A -^cA

JA.3X ^X^XL.^..-..^

±^^^=^^1^^jS^Z-J^^^: Axx^xA'A'— - - -••

Page 43: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

D

-i>"?

ClnNVCLvK'g.AQM

\ Ow\X -gLsr crbX=A-AX Aw -<e~ A^ C5..C-.A: Aw xA~,A^^j^^.^ A_^._._..^..oX~.~

\^\ A^-X^i ,^,^.s,-^_X_Xxv;t^_ cV^x^a^y.^g- A.°3> ^ ^XX-i

_O.X._^A._XXS> A^j£.OvA3^a _Q__C-^_=__\_--S._^^^ voA*

z£Ljsisz£SZ£2£z~J^^~^eizg A_rs_:A_sA_..C_iS.-xsA..;^ ___

OV.__A_i!|:_j_jS_^^ ixAX A^€-.X-^_C

V_i C_Or^.A^AX.X_-^A-- _,g!-X.A. X^.C,^C^'g-r ^A-e-X A_XXs ^X-J.

.©A ..AlvjXy 5Ea^t-^xAA©-^...^!C.aX^s5..XA_^^

Vp Ov.'C~ •£?<__• r.A-<Xl. ,b_3._:Sr_..-.XjA^J^^

^ss-,g-—v o^ac.V .^^^j^.c__v_ysAA-^^ — . .-,-,._ -..—

Au»^...,.^AxAX.v3 .C...Sv._§.-j^--XX^

\^v^\Ov,-^v_aAoS>, A_a^j^aj.^S-A_a©jaX...„^^ .-_-As^r:

.-^A^.r__^AX_AA.S.-^_.

V\Uv.vaA<t-A.-i .x=^wx_

i=_?-s..v^__.A. XsA._3.VA:

sz.' s_>x

O^V) V\A-a VAO -g_o.\_?\.-J^\^ g-- A

AoXwAoa_.x_XAXx_^X

..:xAX\ .C-o.A.o..^AiaA£/ ,.Al>.......OXxli-XAa^_sA_...vxaLx\_ S.^_xax xAA._^.x.-c-.. --0.5^3..^. _^.si_AQ-~a X-e-S-c^ A.-r_>...vX^.^_>Xo.xiSaA^^rdd-Z X...x_sX,.xx.__?.xA..^,.x^ „«_\_

-j.vXs^c__..-

-•AX).X..S_o_a ..Ax. .C--C-_X.'-_--jg-r_0_^

VO'O^AcAA^ ___2-.A_S_.A_A.-. ..C.jr.. gg-^vX^--

A-~<=- v^ <w _^_x§*_^_t-5>. ArX °a-A X_j3 <;

_sA_PJ_>„-^_r__V_a

;__ AW G~ <=g.Nj VC-\gL-AV--- •<

__X_<L..C3.3s- .A^_X_~1.._.^X^^^_<3_A _x_^._S-_^.__==-X-\._r_

M: .-XAwAxts-X/ A X^.vsV-AXXv.r\ \vwX"X:?_w.. AXva,

Page 44: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

.3^

.<C<^-xXX \-~=>.C • '̂A^-«=rJ=:..S?.T_r__ .crrA.vs.cA. ..gA,.\5?.WS\2_S w\ V-t

._0-sQ...VA.>_4_\_.C.._\Ai.o..W..--?. <SWA.: 53J-A Co.0.v^._5._..-X.^X.^_^__?r-

x

—ft—

-AcxaXA s_^g_-aApA aXa_XXX^....^^^ As.?:Wv-o_V

,.\A6x.feQ AxA^- ^^ sAcAXAq.. fP_ A 2s>\£_

^.^S.?;CvlA.^^...!i^^^XiX.

^xXaxX^xx-_ Or lAXioGGxAA

l;Q <x^r^ * -_lXr_T=_-

Page 45: Washington State Courts Washington Courts COA SAG.pdf · FILED September 30, 2015 Court of Appeals Division I Form 7.Statement ofAdditional Grounds for Review State of Washington

NIELSEN, BROMAN & KOCH, PLLC

September 30, 2015 - 1:44 PMTransmittal Letter

Document Uploaded: 723596-Johnson Ayodeji - SAG.pdf

Case Name: Ayodeji Johnson

Court of Appeals Case Number: 72359-6

Party Respresented:

Is this a Personal Restraint Petition? Q Yes (S) No

Trial Court County: - Superior Court #

The document being Filed is:

.1—i

i-' Designation of Clerk's Papers Q Supplemental Designation of Clerk's Papers

( ) Statement of Arrangements

Q Motion:

Q Answer/Reply to Motion:

O Brief:

Q Statement of Additional Authorities

O Affidavit of Attorney Fees

O Cost Bi"Q Objection to Cost Bill

Q Affidavit

O Letter("'i Copy of Verbatim Report of Proceedings - No. of Volumes:

*""' Hearing Date(s):Q Personal Restraint Petition (PRP)

(_j Response to Personal Restraint Petition

Q Reply to Response to Personal Restraint Petition

Q Petition for Review (PRV)

(•) Other: Statement of Additional Grounds for Review

Comments:

No Comments were entered.

Sender Name: Patrick P Mayavsky - Email: [email protected]

A copy of this document has been emailed to the following addresses:

Diane.Kremenich(5)co.snohomish.wa.us