WA SSD TIA FINAL 26.08.2016
Transcript of WA SSD TIA FINAL 26.08.2016
Appendix FTraffic & Transport Assessment
F
Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd
26-Aug-2016
Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project Traffic and Transport Assessment
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project Traffic and Transport Assessment
Client: Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd
ABN: 91 075 245 108
Prepared by
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd 17 Warabrook Boulevard, Warabrook NSW 2304, PO Box 73, Hunter Region MC NSW 2310, Australia T +61 2 4911 4900 F +61 2 4911 4999 www.aecom.com ABN 20 093 846 925
26-Aug-2016
Job No.: 60486360
AECOM in Australia and New Zealand is certified to the latest version of ISO9001, ISO14001, AS/NZS4801 and OHSAS18001.
© AECOM Australia Pty Ltd (AECOM). All rights reserved.
AECOM has prepared this document for the sole use of the Client and for a specific purpose, each as expressly stated in the document. No other party should rely on this document without the prior written consent of AECOM. AECOM undertakes no duty, nor accepts any responsibility, to any third party who may rely upon or use this document. This document has been prepared based on the Client’s description of its requirements and AECOM’s experience, having regard to assumptions that AECOM can reasonably be expected to make in accordance with sound professional principles. AECOM may also have relied upon information provided by the Client and other third parties to prepare this document, some of which may not have been verified. Subject to the above conditions, this document may be transmitted, reproduced or disseminated only in its entirety.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
Quality Information
Document Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Ref 60486360
Date 26-Aug-2016
Prepared by Eric Wu
Reviewed by Nick Bernard
Revision History
Revision Revision Date
Details Authorised
Name/Position Signature
A 10-Jun-2016 Draft for Client Review Simon Murphy Principal Environmental Planner
0 26-Aug-2016 Final Simon Murphy Project Manager
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
Table of Contents Executive Summary i 1.0 Introduction 1
1.0 Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project 1 1.0.1 Overview 1 1.0.2 Proposed Development 1
1.1 Purpose of the Report 5 1.1.1 Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements 5 1.1.2 Traffic Impact Assessment Objectives 5
1.2 Report Structure 6 2.0 Methodology 7
2.0 Legislation, Policy, Criteria and/or Guidelines 7 2.1 Study Area 7 2.2 Background Information Review 7
2.2.1 Database Searches 7 2.2.2 Review of Surrounding Developments (if required and relevant) 7 2.2.3 Review of Previous Studies 7 2.2.4 Assumptions 7
2.3 Method of Impact Assessment 7 3.0 Existing Conditions 9
3.0 Study Area Context 9 3.1 Existing Traffic Conditions 9
3.1.1 Surrounding Road Network 9 3.1.2 Walking and Cycling 9 3.1.3 Public Transport 9 3.1.4 Existing Operational Traffic 10 3.1.5 Existing Crash Data Analysis 10
4.0 Traffic Impact Assessment 13 4.0 Construction Traffic Impact 13 4.1 Future Operational Traffic Impact 13 4.2 Assessment of Parking Layout 13 4.3 Cumulative Traffic Assessment – Battery Recycling Facility 13
5.0 Mitigation, Management and Monitoring 15 6.0 Conclusion 17
Appendix A Crash Data A
List of Figures
Figure 1 Regional Context 2 Figure 2 WA Sit 3 Figure 3 Project Area Context 11
List of Tables
Table 1 Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements – Traffic and Transport 5 Table 2 Crash Summary on Mitchell Avenue (1 January 2010-31 December 2014) 10 Table 3 Battery Recycling Facility Truck Movements 14
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
i
Executive Summary This report presents the traffic and transport assessment relating to the proposed installation of a thermal waste processing plant (the Project) at the existing Weston Aluminium recycling and refining facility at 129 Mitchell Avenue, Kurri Kurri in the Hunter Valley, NSW. An assessment was undertaken of the potential construction and operational traffic impacts associated with the Project.
During the peak construction period, it is anticipated that:
- Up to ten light vehicles per day accessing the Project Area (assuming an occupancy rate of one person per car); and
- Approximately two heavy vehicles (trucks) accessing the Project Area per day. Truck movements are likely to be spread throughout the day as equipment and materials are required onsite.
Construction traffic is expected to have minimal impact on the surrounding road network.
The future operational traffic would experience an increase of six shift workers and two maintenance staff. In addition, approximately three extra truck deliveries would be generated on a typical weekday. These increases are expected to have a minimal impact on the surrounding road network.
There are sufficient existing parking space on site to accommodate existing, construction and future operational staff numbers.
A Construction Traffic Management Plan (CTMP) should be prepared and implemented before construction commences to manage construction traffic. Operational traffic would be managed in accordance with Weston Aluminium’s existing site traffic management requirements.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
ii
This page has been left blank intentionally.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
1
1.0 Introduction
1.0 Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
This section provides an introduction to the Weston Aluminium (WA) site (the WA Site), the proposal to install and operate medical and other waste processing equipment at the WA Site (the Project), and the purpose and content of this report.
1.0.1 Overview
WA proposes to install and operate thermal processing equipment at their existing aluminium recycling and refining facility at 129 Mitchell Avenue, Kurri Kurri in the Hunter Valley, NSW (refer Figure 1).
In response to the ongoing decline in traditional focus areas within the aluminium and steel sectors, and identified growth opportunities in other and emerging markets, WA proposes to further adapt and diversify its plant, equipment and processes to enable the thermal processing of other wastes. This Project promotes development of the Kurri Kurri region, providing employment opportunities and contributes to the growth of industrial development in an environmentally sustainable manner.
The WA Site is ideally positioned in the Lower Hunter to cater for the ever-increasing generation of wastes and the resulting increase in demand for regional specialist waste management. As part of the Project, WA proposes to construct and operate purpose-built infrastructure for the safe receipt, storage and processing of medical and other wastes. Currently, such wastes must be transported significant distances, often interstate, for disposal. WA has a strong demonstrated history of planning approval and environmental license compliance with stringent environmental requirements currently enforced through a comprehensive environmental management system.
1.0.2 Proposed Development
Proposed thermal processing equipment is to be incorporated into the existing WA Site footprint, using existing access, storage areas and emission control systems. Proposed plant and equipment would be located within the northern end of the WA Site (i.e. the Project Area) and still remaining within WA property boundaries. The location of the Project Area is shown in Figure 2.
The kiln is proposed to be established in an east-west orientation, with enclosed input storage facilities and a dedicated feeding system. The existing Baghouse 5 is to be utilised for emission capture and treatment of process emissions from the proposed plant before discharge to atmosphere.
The Project would use WA’s existing site entrances, parking and laydowns areas.
PA
CIF
ICH
IGH
WAY
PA
CIF
ICH
IGH
WAY
SY
DN
EY
-NE
WC
AS
A
T
LE
FRE
EW
Y
SY
DN
EY
-NE
WC
AS
A
T
LE
FRE
EW
Y
Tea Gardens
North Arm CoveEast SeahamEast Seaham
DalwoodDalwood Twelve Mile CreekTwelve Mile Creek
Pindimar
ButterwickButterwickGosforthGosforth
LuskintyreLuskintyre
WindermereWindermere Maitland ValeMaitland ValeGretaGreta
MelvilleMelville
FerodaleFerodale
Winda Woppa
Brandy HillBrandy HillBolwarra HeightsBolwarra Heights EagletonEagleton
LochinvarLochinvar
RothburyRothbury
RutherfordRutherford Soldiers PointHintonHintonAllandaleAllandaleNelson BayOsterleyOsterley
RaworthRaworth Taylors Beach
FarleyFarley LornLorn
Berry ParkBerry Park
DuckenfieldDuckenfieldOyster CoveOyster Cove
Millers ForestMillers Forest
BishopsBridgeBishopsBridge
KeinbahKeinbah
Fingal Bay
Gillieston HeightsGillieston Heights
Anna Bay
Bobs Farm
Salt AshSalt Ash
Louth ParkLouth Park
ThorntonThornton
Raymond Terrace EastRaymond Terrace East
HeatherbraeHeatherbraeCliftleighCliftleighBoat Harbour
LOXFORDLOXFORD WoodberryWoodberry
WilliamtownWilliamtown
BuchananBuchanan
AbermainAbermain
TomagoTomago
TarroTarro
Black HillBlack HillNeathNeath
HexhamHexham
Fullerton CoveFullerton Cove
KearsleyKearsley
KooragangKooragang
LenaghanLenaghan
Richmond ValeRichmond Vale
StockringtonStockrington
FletcherFletcherShortlandShortland
ElringtonElrington
West WallsendWest WallsendMulbringMulbring
SeahamptonSeahampton
StocktonStockton
Cameron ParkCameron Park
WallsendWallsend
MayfieldMayfield
KillingworthKillingworth
HolmesvilleHolmesvilleMount VincentMount Vincent Elermore ValeElermore Vale
TeralbaTeralba
MerewetherMerewether
BrunkervilleBrunkerville Macquarie HillsMacquarie Hills
CHARLESTOWNCHARLESTOWN
WhitebridgeWhitebridgeFreemans WaterholeFreemans WaterholeBooragulBooragul
CongewaiCongewaiFennell BayFennell Bay WindaleWindale
RedheadRedheadAwabaAwaba
TorontoTorontoValentineValentine
CooranbongCooranbong
MartinsvilleMartinsville
BELMONTBELMONT
Kilaben BayKilaben Bay
RathminesRathmines
Myuna BayMyuna Bay
BlacksmithsBlacksmiths
SWANSEASWANSEA
MORISSETMORISSET
BalcolynBalcolyn
MandalongMandalong
Caves BeachCaves BeachBrightwatersBrightwaters
Cams WharfCams Wharf
Cedar Brush CreekCedar Brush Creek
GwandalanGwandalanWyee PointWyee Point
WyeeWyee Crangan BayCrangan Bay
Catherine Hill BayCatherine Hill Bay
Durren DurrenDurren Durren
Frazer ParkFrazer Park
DoyalsonDoyalson
JillibyJilliby
Bushells RidgeBushells Ridge
KiarKiarFreemansFreemans
HalekulaniHalekulani
WallarahWallarah
GorokanGorokan
NoravilleNoraville
WyongWyong
WatanobbiWatanobbiWyongahWyongah
Norah HeadNorah Head
MagentaMagentaTuggerahTuggerah
Palm GrovePalm Grove Chittaway PointChittaway Point
Berkeley ValeBerkeley Vale
TocalTocal
NEWCASTLE
RaymondTerrace
RaymondTerrace
MaitlandMaitland
CessnockCessnockKURRIKURRIKURRIKURRI
WESTONWESTON
LakeMacquarie
LakeMacquarie
WA SITE
P a c i f i c O c e a n
GrahamstownDam
GrahamstownDam
LakeMunmorah
LakeMunmorah
LakeBudgewoi
LakeBudgewoi
TuggerahLake
TuggerahLake
S t o c k t o nB i g h t
Blacksmiths Point
Stinky Point
Flat Rocks Point
Norah Head
Pelican Point
Bird Island
Nine Mile Beach
Stockton Beach
0 10km5
NPWS Estate
State forest
Existing native vegetation
SEPP14 Coastal wetlands protected area
Urban area
Major road
Regional road
Railway
KEY
G:\!E
NV
\GIS
\Pro
jects
\604 P
roje
cts
\60486360 W
esto
nA
lum
iniu
m\F
IGU
RE
S\T
raffic
\60486360 F
1 R
egio
nal C
onte
xt 04 0
7 2
016
TO
REGIONAL CONTEXT
FIGURE 1
Environmental Impact Statement
Weston Aluminium Recycling Facility
Swamp CreekSwamp Creek
Black Waterholes Creek
Black Waterholes Creek
Dee
pC
reek
Dee
pC
reek
Wall
isC
reek
Wall
isC
reek
Wal
lis
Cre
ek
Wal
lis
Cre
ek
Buttai Creek
Buttai Creek
Main
Road
Main
Road
Cessn
ock
Ro
ad
Cessn
ock
Ro
ad
JohnRenshaw
Drive
JohnRenshaw
Drive
Lang Street
Lang Street
Fra
me D
rive
Fra
me D
rive
Saw
yers
Gully
Road
Saw
yers
Gully
Road
Cessnock Road
Cessnock Road
John Renshaw Drive
John Renshaw Drive
Leg
getts
Driv
e
Leg
getts
Driv
e
HU
NTER
EXPR
ESSW
AY
HU
NTER
EXPR
ESSW
AY
WA SITE
Werakata National Park
Kurri Kurri
TAFE
CESSNOCKLGA
HYDRO ALUMINIUM
KURRI KURRI
Gillieston HeightsGillieston Heights
Sawyers GullySawyers Gully
Rathluba Ridge
CliftleighCliftleigh
LoxfordLoxford
BuchananBuchanan
Heddon GretaHeddon Greta
AbermainAbermain
WestonWeston
Kurri KurriKurri Kurri
NeathNeath
ButtaiButtai
Stanford MerthyrStanford Merthyr
Pelaw MainPelaw Main
0 2km1
Weston Aluminium Site
National Park and Wildlife Estate
Parks and reserves
Existing vegetation
Highway
Road
Railway
Watercourse
KEY
LOCAL CONTEXT
FIGURE 2
Environmental Impact Statement
Weston Aluminium Recycling Facility
G:\!E
NV
\GIS
\Pro
jects
\604 P
roje
cts
\60486360 W
esto
nA
lum
iniu
m\F
IGU
RE
S\T
raffic
\60486360 F
2 L
ocal C
onte
xt 26 0
5 2
016
TO
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
4
This page has been left blank intentionally.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
5
1.1 Purpose of the Report
1.1.1 Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements
The Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements (SEARs) require that the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the development must meet the form and content requirements in clauses 6 and 7 of Schedule 2 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000.
The WA thermal waste processing facility Project EIS has been prepared in accordance with Division 4.1, Part 4 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (EP&A Act), which ensures that the potential environmental effects of a proposal are properly assessed and considered in the decision-making process.
In preparing this Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA), the SEARs issued for the Project (SSD_7349) on 16 December 2015 have been addressed as required by Clause 75F of the EP&A Act. The key matters raised by the Secretary for consideration in the Traffic Impact Assessment are outlined in Table 1 along with a reference to where the requirements are addressed within this report.
Table 1 Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirements – Traffic and Transport
Secretary’s Environmental Assessment Requirement Section Addressed
Traffic and Transport
Traffic and Transport – including: - Details of all traffic types and volumes likely to be
generated during construction and operation, including a description of haul routes;
- Assessment of the predicted impacts of this traffic on road safety and the capacity of the road network, including consideration of cumulative traffic impacts at key intersections using SIDRA or similar traffic model;
- Detailed plans of the proposed layout of the internal road network and parking on site in accordance with the relevant Australian Standards; and
- Plans of any proposed road upgrades, infrastructure works or new roads required for the development.
Section 4.0 Section 4.0 Section 5.0 Section 4.0
1.1.2 Traffic Impact Assessment Objectives
The purpose of this report is to describe the Project and provide an overview of its potential effects on traffic and transport. The TIA includes:
- A review of the existing traffic and transport conditions;
- An assessment of forecast construction and operational traffic and possible transport impacts; and
- Consideration of measures to mitigate these impacts, if required.
The TIA has assessed impacts on the road network in the AM and PM peak hour of a typical weekday, as these generally represent the worst case conditions for traffic impacts.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
6
1.2 Report Structure
This report is structured as follows:
Section 1.0 Introduction – outlines the Project and presents the purpose of the report.
Section 2.0 Methodology – describes the methodology employed for the Traffic impact assessment.
Section 3.0 Existing traffic conditions – describe the road network and characteristics.
Section 4.0 Assessment of potential impacts – describes the potential impacts of construction and operational traffic resulting from the proposed Project.
Section 5.0 Safeguards and management - provides a summary of environmental mitigation, management and monitoring responsibilities in relation to Traffic management for the Project.
Section 6.0 Conclusion.
Appendix A Detailed crash data.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
7
2.0 Methodology
2.0 Legislation, Policy, Criteria and/or Guidelines
Where applicable to the Project this report has referenced the following criteria and guidelines:
- RMS Guide to Traffic Generating Developments 2002; and
- Australian /New Zealand Parking Facilities Standard 2009.
2.1 Study Area
The traffic and transport study area of the Project consists of Mitchell Avenue, Government Road, Hart Road and the Hunter Expressway. The site is accessed from Mitchell Avenue, while Government Road and Hart Road connect to site to the Hunter Expressway. Refer Figure 3.
2.2 Background Information Review
2.2.1 Database Searches
Background database searches were conducted by exploring RMS Average Daily Traffic Volumes and Historical Traffic crash data around the Project site:
- No relevant traffic survey locations were available from the RMS Average Daily Traffic Volume database; and
- Traffic crash data was collected on Mitchell Avenue and the surrounding road network from 2010-2014. The crash data includes total crash number, crash location, crash time, crash type and crash movement.
2.2.2 Review of Surrounding Developments (if required and relevant)
A review of RMS planned projects in the Kurri Kurri area indicates that there are no planned road or infrastructure upgrades in the vicinity of the Project site.
2.2.3 Review of Previous Studies
A number of environmental assessments have been undertaken for the site as part of past approvals and modifications. Traffic assessments, included in these environmental assessments, have informed the existing conditions for this study. No other available traffic impact assessments for operations on adjacent sites were found. These previous studies described the traffic generation and potential impact of the existing operation as detailed in Section 3.0.
2.2.4 Assumptions
The following assumptions were used in the traffic and transport impact assessment:
- Up to three trucks and ten light vehicles per day would be generated during the construction phase;
- Three heavy vehicles in and out of Project site in both AM and PM peak hour during the future operational phase; and
- All the light and heavy vehicles would access the site using the Hunter Expressway, Government Road, Hart Road and Mitchell Avenue.
2.3 Method of Impact Assessment
As the predicted traffic volumes for both construction and future operations are relatively low, SIDRA modelling is not considered an appropriate tool to reflect the construction and operation traffic impact because the impact is minimal. SIDRA modelling is unlikely to be able to add any value to the impact assessment due to the low existing and proposed traffic numbers. Therefore, a qualitative analysis was undertaken to assess the construction and operational traffic impact on Mitchell Avenue and its surrounding road network.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
8
This page has been left blank intentionally.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
9
3.0 Existing Conditions
3.0 Study Area Context
The WA Site is located at Kurri Kurri, within the Cessnock local government area in the Hunter Region of New South Wales. It is approximately 40 km northwest of the Newcastle CBD, as shown in Figure 1. The WA Site is located within an established industrial area. Residential areas in Kurri Kurri and Weston are located to the southeast and west of the WA Site, respectively.
3.1 Existing Traffic Conditions
3.1.1 Surrounding Road Network
The key components of the road network surrounding the Project site are described below.
Hunter Expressway
The Hunter Expressway at Kurri Kurri is generally a two-lane divided road. It links the New England Highway to the north and the Pacific Motorway to the south. It has a posted 110 km/h speed limit and is an approved B-double route.
Hart Road
Hart Road is a two lane, two way local road that intersects with the Hunter Expressway, and connects to Government Road to the west. It has a posted 70 km/hr speed limit. The Hunter Expressway interchange with Hart Road (Loxford interchange) has east-facing on- and off-ramps only.
Government Road
Government Road is a two lane two way regional road. It links Hart Road to the north and Mitchell Avenue to the south. It has a posted 60 km/hr speed limit.
Mitchell Avenue
Mitchell Avenue is a two lane, two way regional road that provides access to local industrial areas. It connects Government Road to the west and Northcote Street to the east. The Project site has a direct driveway connection to Mitchell Avenue. Mitchell Avenue does not have a posted speed limit. The default speed limit for a road in an urban areas, defined as having buildings next to the road, is 50km/hr, unless an alternative speed is signposted.
3.1.2 Walking and Cycling
There are no existing footpaths or cycleways provided along Hart Road or Government Road. There are a few sections of footpath provided along Mitchell Avenue outside particular factories, but these are sporadic and not continuous.
The shoulder lanes in both directions on the Hunter Expressway and on the off-ramp at the Loxford interchange are marked for cyclists.
3.1.3 Public Transport
Train
The South Maitland Railway crosses Mitchell Avenue at a level crossing approximately 200m to the southeast of the Project site. There are no regular users of this privately-owned railway. It is occasionally used by the remaining coal operations in the South Maitland Coalfields on an irregular basis. There are no regular commercial or passenger train services on this line. Regardless, trucks accessing the WA Site as part of the Project would not traverse this level crossing to access the WA Site.
Bus
There are three bus services (route 160, 163 and 164) on Northcote Street providing services from Cessnock to Kurri Kurri and Cessnock to Newcastle. All the buses provide regular services from Monday to Friday. Route 160 does not operate on Sundays or public holidays. However, there are no bus stops in the vicinity of Northcote Street.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
10
3.1.4 Existing Operational Traffic
There are currently 28 full time staff and up to two contractors working at the WA Site per day. On average, 10 heavy vehicles move in and out the WA Site every day (WA, 2016), The operating hours for existing truck movements are from 7am to 10pm, as per the existing site consent conditions. All light and heavy vehicles access the WA Site from the Hunter Expressway, Hart Road, Government Road and Mitchell Avenue. There are no heavy vehicle movements through the Kurri Kurri town centre.
There is a range of vehicle parking options currently available on the WA Site. Staff and visitor light vehicles typically park in the designated parking area at the front of the WA Site. Heavy vehicle typically move through the weighbridge or to the relevant park of the operation depending on their transport task.
3.1.5 Existing Crash Data Analysis
There were 16 crashes in total between January 2010 and December 2014 on Mitchell Avenue and the immediately surrounding road network. Of the 16 crashes, six occurred on Mitchell Avenue as shown in Appendix A. Of the six crashes, there were no fatal crashes, four injury crashes, and two non-casualty crashes (as shown in Table 2).
Table 2 Crash Summary on Mitchell Avenue (1 January 2010-31 December 2014)
Road Section from
Section to
Section Length
Total Fatal Injury Non-casualty
Mitchell Avenue
Government Rd
Northcote St
1.47km 6 0 4 (2 in 2011, 2012,2014)
2 (2011, 2014)
Of the six crashes on Mitchell Avenue:
- Three took place in 2011, one in 2012 and two in 2014; and
- Three involved truck movements, of which two were due to truck movements in and out of industrial sites.
This indicates that while there does not appear to be a worsening crash situation on Mitchell Avenue, the increase in truck movements requires assessment.
Swamp CreekSwamp Creek
Black Waterholes CreekD
eep
Cre
ek
Wall
isC
reek
Wall
isC
reek
Wal
lis
Cre
ekk
Buttai Creek
Main
Str
eet
Main
Str
eet
Cessn
ock
Ro
ad
JohnRenshaw
Drive
Lang Street
Lang Street
Fra
me D
rive
Fra
me D
rive
Saw
yers
Gully
Road
Saw
yers
Gully
Road
Cessnock Road
Cessnock Road
John Renshaw Drive
John Renshaw Drive
Leg
getts
Driv
e
L
Mitchell Avenue
Mitchell Avenue
Go
vern
men
t R
oad
Go
vern
men
t R
oad
Hart R
oad
Hart R
oad
Northcote
Street
Northcote
Street
Railw
ayPara
de
Railw
ayPara
de
Westo
n S
treet
Westo
n S
treet
Gingers Lane
Gingers Lane
Bis
ho
ps
Brid
ge
Ro
ad
Bis
ho
ps
Brid
ge
Ro
ad
Ho
sp
ital R
oad
Ho
sp
ital R
oad
Mulbring Street
Mulbring Street
WA SITE
Kurri Kurri
TAFE
HYDRO ALUMINIUM
KURRI KURRI
Loxford Interchange
To Newcastle/Sydney
Gillieston Heights
Sawyers Gully
Rathluba Ridge
CliftleighCliftl
LoxfordLoxford
BuchananB
Heddon GretaHeddon Greta
Abermainain
WestonWeston
Kurri KurriKurri Kurri
Neath
Buttai
Stanford MerthyrStanford Merthyr
Pelaw MainPelaw Main
0 1km0.5
Weston Aluminium Site
National Park and Wildlife Estate
Parks and reserves
Existing vegetation
Highway
Route to Hunter Expressway
Road
Railway
Watercourse
Educational facility
Medical facility
KEY
TRANSPORT CONTEXT
FIGURE 3
Environmental Impact Statement
Weston Aluminium Recycling Facility
G:\!E
NV
\GIS
\Pro
jects
\604 P
roje
cts
\60486360 W
esto
nA
lum
iniu
m\F
IGU
RE
S\T
raffic
\60486360 F
3 S
urr
oundin
gT
raffic
Netw
ork
04 0
7 2
016
TO
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
12
This page has been left blank intentionally.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
13
4.0 Traffic Impact Assessment
4.0 Construction Traffic Impact
Construction traffic as part of the installation of the new process equipment includes light vehicle and heavy vehicle movements. There would be approximately 6-10 contractors accessing the Project site during the construction phase. Based on an occupancy rate of one worker per light vehicle, at the peak of construction traffic is expected there would be:
- Up to ten light vehicles per day accessing the Project Area (assuming an occupancy rate of one person per car); and
- Approximately two heavy vehicles (trucks) accessing the Project Area per day. Truck movements are likely to be spread throughout the day as equipment and materials are required onsite.
In the context of construction heavy vehicles could include vehicles in between Classes 3 – 12 in accordance with the AUSTROADS vehicle classification system.
All construction vehicles would access the WA Site from the Hunter Expressway, Hart Road, Government Road and then Mitchell Avenue. Based on the low construction traffic volume, the Project is likely to have a minimal impact on Mitchell Avenue and the surrounding road network. No infrastructure upgrades would be required as a result of traffic generation during the construction phase.
4.1 Future Operational Traffic Impact
The future, operational traffic would experience an increase of six shift workers and two maintenance staff. In addition, approximately three extra truck deliveries would be generated on a typical weekday.
The anticipated operating hours would be 24 hours per day, 7days per week. Despite this, truck movements are expected to be made between 7am and 3pm, Monday to Friday. Regardless, the WA Site would still operate under the existing site licence conditions, requiring all truck movements to be between 7am and 10pm. In the context of the operation of the Project, trucks would generally be in Classes 3 – 5 in accordance with the AUSTROADS vehicle classification system.
All vehicles would access the WA Site from the Hunter Expressway, Hart Road, Government Road and then Mitchell Avenue. No heavy movements would travel through the Kurri Kurri town centre. Once on site, vehicles would travel on the existing internal road system, which has adequate capacity to accommodate increased operational traffic and which has been designed to service heavy vehicles.
Based on the small increase in operational traffic, the future operational traffic impact on the surrounding road network is expected to be minimal. No infrastructure upgrades would be required for the operation of the Project.
4.2 Assessment of Parking Layout
During the construction phase, there would typically be six contractors working on site, with a maximum of 10 contractors at peak construction periods. During the future operational phase, the workforce could increase by six shift workers and two maintenance staff. There are sufficient existing parking spaces on site to accommodate both existing, construction and future operational staff numbers.
4.3 Cumulative Traffic Assessment – Battery Recycling Facility
The proponents of the proposed battery recycling facility (SSD 16_7520) were consulted to determine that likely traffic loading that may be generated by the battery recycling facility should it proceed. The truck movements detailed in Table 3.
It should be noted that the BRF construction traffic as advised by the BRF proponent is anticipated to be 6 heavy vehicle and 10 light vehicles per day with construction works to be undertaken during standard hours for a period of approximately 18 months. As construction traffic is much lower than operational traffic only operational traffic impact are assessed below construction traffic impacts considered to be negligible.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
14
Table 3 Battery Recycling Facility Truck Movements
VEHICLE MOVEMENTS
B-Double
Semi-Trailer
Standard Truck
Pick-up Trucks
Tipper Truck
Chemical Tanker
Fuel Tanker
Batteries 140 1500 900 125
Anthracite Coal 778 194
Soda Ash 53 123
Iron Grits 30 3
Hydrogen Peroxide 6
Sodium Hydroxide 9
Diesel 55
Pb ingots 126 1000 30
Slags 132
Heavy plastics 150
Anydrous Na2SO4 75 281 19
Polypropylene 123 53 9
Employees/Visitors
Sub-total: 265 3528 1617 153 285 9 55
Total 5,912
As detailed in Table 3 approximately 5,912 trucks movement per year would be accessing the battery recycling facility equated to approximately 17 trucks movements per day. In relation to light vehicle movements from staff and visitors the BRF proponent has indicated they anticipate approximately 60 movements per day.
When combined with the three additional trucks per day accessing the local road network this is considered to have a minimal impact on local road capacity. Furthermore cumulative impacts are considered minor for the following reasons:
- The Battery Recycling Facility would access the wider arterial network via Mitchell Avenue, Government Road and Hart Road then onto the Hunter Expressway. This would avoid truck travelling through the centre of Kurri Kurri;
- The Project and the Battery Recycling Facility would have its own dedicated driveway access to Mitchell Avenue located approximately 50m to the east of the Project site access, preventing potential for trucks be queuing to enter the same access point; and
- Both facilities would have appropriate traffic management plans in place, including driver inductions to make sure site specific and local road network traffic requirements are considered at all time.
Overall the potential for significant cumulative traffic impacts to result from both Projects is considered minor.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
15
5.0 Mitigation, Management and Monitoring A Construction Traffic Management Plan (CTMP) should be prepared and implemented prior to the construction phase of the Project. The CTMP would include the guidelines, general requirements and principles of traffic management to be implemented during the construction phase to minimise the potential for crashes on Mitchell Avenue.
Operational traffic would be managed in accordance with the transport management measures included in WA’s Operational Environmental Management Plan.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
16
This page has been left blank intentionally.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
17
6.0 Conclusion An assessment has been undertaken of the traffic and transport impacts during the construction and future operational phases of the Project. Based on the small volumes of both construction and operational traffic, it is expected that the traffic impact on the surrounding road network would be minimal. The existing parking space provision and existing internal access ways would similarly be sufficient for existing, construction and future operational traffic.
Based on the crash data analysis, it is recommended that a Construction Traffic Management Plan (CTMP) be prepared and implemented before the construction phase.
The WA Site’s existing Operational Environmental Management Plan would be updated to incorporate consideration of the Project’s operational traffic requirements.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
18
This page has been left blank intentionally.
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
Appendix A
Crash Data
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
a-1
Appendix A Crash Data
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
1
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
2
AECOM Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
3
AEC4O Weston Aluminium Thermal Waste Processing Project
Revision 0 – 26-Aug-2016 Prepared for – Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd – ABN: 91 075 245 108
4