VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION...

27
VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose, Ashok K. Ghosh, N.P.Roy, Ajay Nupur Bose, Ashok K. Ghosh, N.P.Roy, Ajay Upadhyay, Amardeep Singh & Sushant K. Singh Upadhyay, Amardeep Singh & Sushant K. Singh Department of Environment and Water Management, A..N. College [ Magadh University] Patna, India

Transcript of VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION...

Page 1: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

VULNERABILITYOF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN

THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA

Nupur Bose, Ashok K. Ghosh, N.P.Roy, Ajay Nupur Bose, Ashok K. Ghosh, N.P.Roy, Ajay Upadhyay, Amardeep Singh & Sushant K. SinghUpadhyay, Amardeep Singh & Sushant K. Singh

Department of Environment and Water Management,A..N. College [ Magadh University]

Patna, India

Page 2: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

BACKGROUND OF THE PROBLEMBACKGROUND OF THE PROBLEM

Our studies indicate that newer alluvial deposits of the Bihar Plains are the areas of widespread and intense arsenic contaminated ground water sources.

Detection of arseniferous aquifers in Bihar, India, in the last 4 years exemplify how ground water quality has been compromised on account of its unplanned and excessive utilization in domestic and agricultural sectors.

It is leading to one of the most daunting health challenges to the Indian society, as it is affecting some of the densely populated impoverished rural areas.

Page 3: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

Bihar – Districts studied for Arsenic Bihar – Districts studied for Arsenic contaminationscontaminations

WEST

BENGAL

BALLIA, U.P.

Page 4: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

AIM OF THIS STUDYAIM OF THIS STUDYTo facilitate the recently introduced mitigation To facilitate the recently introduced mitigation

strategies by-strategies by-b.b. Determining the quantum of population at Determining the quantum of population at

risk in villages with arsenic contaminated risk in villages with arsenic contaminated aquifers.aquifers.

c.c. Classifying the villages on the basis of an Classifying the villages on the basis of an index index of vulnerability to arsenic poisoning.of vulnerability to arsenic poisoning.

d.d. Obtaining feedbacks regarding the Obtaining feedbacks regarding the sustainability of recently initiated mitigation sustainability of recently initiated mitigation strategies.strategies.

Page 5: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

Methodology Methodology Water samples from about 27,061 hand pumps were Water samples from about 27,061 hand pumps were

tested, first by Field Test Kits and then subject to tested, first by Field Test Kits and then subject to confirmatory UV/AAS tests.confirmatory UV/AAS tests.

Index of Vulnerability from 1-10 was derived on the Index of Vulnerability from 1-10 was derived on the basis of total population [Census data] and percentage basis of total population [Census data] and percentage of contaminated pumps in study area.of contaminated pumps in study area.

Questionnaires distributed in areas of arsenic hotspots Questionnaires distributed in areas of arsenic hotspots for information on the duration of consumption of for information on the duration of consumption of contaminated water, depth of hand pumps, nutrition contaminated water, depth of hand pumps, nutrition and health problemsand health problems

Page 6: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

POPULATION AT RISK IN THE STUDY POPULATION AT RISK IN THE STUDY AREAAREA

43.57728,7877218TOTALTOTAL

45.35294,3382510BHAGALPURBHAGALPUR

28.7565,0621612VAISHALIVAISHALI

33.84117,6092496BHOJPURBHOJPUR

32.27251,788600PATNAPATNA

% OF % OF POPULATION IN POPULATION IN THE STUDY BELTTHE STUDY BELT

POPULATION POPULATION VULNERABLE TO VULNERABLE TO

ARSENIC TOXICITYARSENIC TOXICITY

NO. OF NO. OF CONTAMNATED CONTAMNATED

SOURCES IN SOURCES IN AFFECTED AFFECTED VILLAGESVILLAGES

DISTRICTSDISTRICTS

Page 7: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

VULNERABILITY INDEX - PATNAVULNERABILITY INDEX - PATNA

Up to 4 [low risk ] – 53 villagesUp to 4 [low risk ] – 53 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 17 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 17 villages6 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 086 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 08

villagesvillages8 – 10 [high risk] – 19 villages8 – 10 [high risk] – 19 villages

Page 8: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

VULNERABILITY INDEX - BHOJPURVULNERABILITY INDEX - BHOJPUR

Up to 4 [low risk ] – 71 villagesUp to 4 [low risk ] – 71 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 22 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 22 villages6 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 206 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 20 villagesvillages8 – 10 [high risk] – 30 villages8 – 10 [high risk] – 30 villages

Page 9: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

VULNERABILITY INDEX - VAISHALIVULNERABILITY INDEX - VAISHALI

Up to 4 [low risk ] – 59 villagesUp to 4 [low risk ] – 59 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 09 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 09 villages6 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 086 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 08 villagesvillages8 – 10 [high risk] – 02 villages8 – 10 [high risk] – 02 villages

Page 10: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

VULNERABILITY INDEX - BHAGALPURVULNERABILITY INDEX - BHAGALPUR

Up to 4 [low risk ] – 71 villagesUp to 4 [low risk ] – 71 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 22 villages4 – 6 [moderate risk] – 22 villages6 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 206 – 8 [moderately high risk] – 20 villagesvillages8 – 10 [high risk] – 30 villages8 – 10 [high risk] – 30 villages

Page 11: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

DISTRICT-WISE INDEX OF VULNERABILITYDISTRICT-WISE INDEX OF VULNERABILITY

818163636767252252TOTAL NO. TOTAL NO. OF OF VILLAGESVILLAGES

2828272717176969BHAGALPURBHAGALPUR

0202080809095959VAISHALIVAISHALI

3030202022227575BHOJPURBHOJPUR

1919080817175353PATNAPATNA

8 – 108 – 10[HIGH RISK][HIGH RISK]

6 – 86 – 8[[MODERATELY MODERATELY

HIGHHIGH]]

4 – 64 – 6[MODERATE][MODERATE]

UPTO 4UPTO 4[LOW RISK][LOW RISK]

INDEXINDEX

Page 12: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

Symptoms of ARSENICOSIS?Symptoms of ARSENICOSIS?

Page 13: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

NODULES OVER SKINNODULES OVER SKIN

Gayanti Devi Laxman Munda

Page 14: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

THICKENING AND DISCOLORATION OF THE THICKENING AND DISCOLORATION OF THE SKINSKIN

AlopeciaAlopecia

Tetary Kumari

Page 15: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

SKIN LESIONS SKIN LESIONS

Sirka Munda Junardi Rai

Page 16: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

NODULES, THICKENING AND DISCOLORATION NODULES, THICKENING AND DISCOLORATION OF THE SKINOF THE SKIN

Anita Devi

Page 17: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

THICKENING AND DISCOLORATION OFTHICKENING AND DISCOLORATION OF THE SKIN THE SKIN

Anita Devi

Page 18: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

Discoloration of skin and Discoloration of skin and Nodules Nodules

Ritesh Kumar

Page 19: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

Melanosis and Keratosis

Kalawati KumariSiajanki Devi

Page 20: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

DISCOLORATION of the SKIN

Master Ranjeet Agin Singh

Page 21: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

White Spot on Skin White Spot on Skin

Kusum Kumari

Page 22: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

Agin Singh

Nodules and Cracks over Thickened Soles

Diffuse varicose lesions of the soles with cracks and fissures and keratotic horns over palms/soles.

Page 23: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

VISIBLE SYMPTOMSVISIBLE SYMPTOMSThe symptoms we detected in our field study resembles symptoms reported in West Bengal and Bangladesh

Suresh Roy Kalawati Kumari

Page 24: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

CURRENT MITIGATION CURRENT MITIGATION ADOPTEDADOPTED

RAIN WATER RAIN WATER HARVESTINGHARVESTING

REVIVAL OF OLD REVIVAL OF OLD DUGWELLSDUGWELLS

TAPPING WATER FROM TAPPING WATER FROM DEEPER AQUIFERSDEEPER AQUIFERS

Page 25: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS ADOPTION OF AWARENESS PROGRAMSADOPTION OF AWARENESS PROGRAMS COMMUNITY PARTICIPATIONCOMMUNITY PARTICIPATION REGULAR MONITORING OF HOTSPOTSREGULAR MONITORING OF HOTSPOTS PROPER MAINTAINENCE OF OPEN DUG PROPER MAINTAINENCE OF OPEN DUG

WELLSWELLS USE OF GRAVITY DRIVEN LOW-COST USE OF GRAVITY DRIVEN LOW-COST

FILTERSFILTERS HEALTH CENTRES FOR VERIFICATION & HEALTH CENTRES FOR VERIFICATION &

TREATMENT OF ARSENIC POISONING TREATMENT OF ARSENIC POISONING SYMPTOMSSYMPTOMS

Page 26: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTACKNOWLEDGEMENT

WE THANK UNICEF, BIHAR WE THANK UNICEF, BIHAR CENTER FOR THEIR SUPPORT FOR CENTER FOR THEIR SUPPORT FOR

THISTHISPROJECTPROJECT

Page 27: VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC … · 2007. 9. 11. · VULNERABILITY OF POPULATION EXPOSED TO ARSENIC CONTAMINATION IN THE MID GANGA PLAIN OF BIHAR, INDIA Nupur Bose,

THANK YOUTHANK YOU