Vote-by-Mail Envelope Design for Californiaelections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/vote-by-mail/pdf/guidance.pdfDec...
Transcript of Vote-by-Mail Envelope Design for Californiaelections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/vote-by-mail/pdf/guidance.pdfDec...
Design Documentation
Vote-by-MailEnvelopeDesignforCaliforniaDecember15,2017
In2018,thefirstcountiesinCaliforniawillstartthetransitiontoanewelectionsmodelundertheVoter’sChoiceAct,inwhichallvoterswillreceivetheirballotsbymail,withoptionstoreturnthembymailordropbox,ortheycanchoosetovoteinperson.
Tohelpprepareforthistransition,theCenterforCivicDesignhasworkedwiththeCaliforniaSecretaryofState’soffice,countyelectionoffices,andnationalexpertstodesigntemplatesforthevote-by-mailpackages,includingtheenvelopessentoutbythelocalelectionoffices,theballotreturnpackages,andtheinstructionsforvoters.
Thegoalsforthedesign
Thegoalofthisprojectistocreatematerialsthatcanbeusedinanycounty,whetheritisimplementingthefullVoter’sChoiceActornot.Aconsistentdesignforvote-by-mailwillhelpelectionofficesandadvocacygroupshelpvotersidentifyandusevote-by-mailmoreeffectively.Itisalsoafreshdesigntogoalongwithanewvotingmodel.
Thisdesignisintendedtobeaflexibletemplate,providingconsistencyandalogicallayout,whileallowingforvariationsbasedonthesizeandlayoutofdifferentenvelopestylesandelectionmanagementsystems.
Anotherimportantgoalisavote-by-mailpackagethatevennewvoters,voterswithlowliteracy,orvoterswithlowcivicliteracycanuseaccurately,toreducethenumberofballotsthatcannotbecountedorrequirecorrections.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page2CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Asuccessfuldesignwillmakeiteasierforvoterstovotebymail,withinaffordableandrobustelectionadministration.Thedesignmustworkforallstakeholders:
• Makeiteasierforvoterstorecognizeandreturntheirballotaccurately,withclear,effectiveinstructions.
• SupportbilingualballotstomeetVotingRightsActlanguageaccessrequirements,whilestillmakingtheenvelopeseasytoreadanduse.
• Improveelectionadministrationbycreatingmaterialsthatreduceerrorsandmakeiteasiertoprocessvote-by-mailballots.
• Supportastatewidevotereducationcampaignabouthowtovotebymail,bycreatingrecognizableconsistencyacrossthestate.
• Supportlocalelectionofficeswithflexibilitytocustomizethetemplatestolocalinformationandtheirproceduresandsystemsforhandlingvote-by-mailmaterials.
• SupportaccuratehandlinganddeliveryofballotssentthroughtheUSPostalService(USPS).
What’sinthedesign?
Thedesignincludes:
• Alogicalarrangementofthecontentelementsthatcanbeadaptedtodifferentenvelopesystems.
• Alayoutthatcanadapttodifferentsizeenvelopes,withinareasonablerangeofsizesincommonuse.
• Sampletextfortheenvelopesandinstructionalinsertsthatcanbecustomizedtotheneedsofeachcounty.
• Guidelinesforhowcolorcanbeusedconsistentlyandmeaningfullytosupporteasyidentificationoftheenvelopesandspecifications.
• Sampleinstructioninserts.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page3CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
TableofContents
Envelopelayouts..............................................................................................4Outgoingenvelopefront 4Outgoingenvelopeback 5Returnenvelopefront 6Returnenvelopebackwithoverprinting 7
Usingcolorstoidentifyballottypesandcounties.............................................8Vote-by-mailcolorpalette 9
Descriptionoftheelementsontheenvelopes...............................................10PostalandElectionMailrequirements 10Identificationasanofficialvote-by-mailenvelope 13Signaturesandotherforms 14Voter’sdeclarationandwarnings 17Finalchecklistandreminders 18Instructionsontheenvelope 19Envelopestructuralelements 20
Instructionsinsertorsecrecysleeve...............................................................21
Ballotsecrecyandsignaturesecurity..............................................................23
Listofelementsontheenvelopes..................................................................24
Howweranthisproject.................................................................................25
Sourcesforrequirements...............................................................................26
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page4CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
EnvelopelayoutsThelayoutsaredesignedforapproximately6”x9”envelopes.PleaseseetheseparatePDFfileforfull-size,higherresolutionimages.Theselayoutsareintendedasaguidetouseincreatingaccuratelayoutsforyourenvelopestyle.
Outgoingenvelopefront
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page5CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Outgoingenvelopeback
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page6CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Returnenvelopefront
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page7CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
ReturnenvelopebackwithoverprintingTextundertheflapnotshowninthisview
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page8CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
UsingcolorstoidentifyballottypesandcountiesThecolorsoftheenvelopeshelpvotersandelectionadministratorsidentifydifferenttypesofballotenvelopeseasily.ThecolorsarealsohelpfulfortheUSPS,becausetheyhelpdistinguishenvelopesontheirwaytovotersfromthosereturningtotheelectionsoffice.Thecolorwrapsaroundtheedgeoftheenvelopesoitisvisibleinastackofmailersmakingthemeasytoidentifyatthepostalfacility.[4]
• Alloutgoingenvelopesusethesamecolor,amediumblue.
• Thestandardcolorforreturnenvelopesisadarkgreen.Therearealso7alternativecolors(3additionalcolorsand4lightervariations)thatcanbeusedforoverlappingspecialelectionsreturnenvelopes,todifferentiateneighboringcounties,or(fornon-VCAcounties)toidentifyallVBMdistrictsvs.voterswhohavechosenvote-by-mail.
• UOCAVAreturnenvelopesusebrownoranalternativelightertan.
• Provisionalballotsusepink.CVRprovisionalballotsuseyellow.
Exampleofhowcolorsmightbeusedintwoneighboringcounties
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page9CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Vote-by-mailcolorpalette
Theenvelopecolorsmeetaccessibilityrequirementsforlargewhitetext.ThedarkcolorsmeetWCAG2.0LevelAAAat7:1contrast.ThelightercolorsmeetLevelAAat4.5:1contrast.Theprovisionalenvelopecolorshavegreaterthan10:1contrastwithblacktext.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page10CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Descriptionoftheelementsontheenvelopes
PostalandElectionMailrequirements
Outgoingenvelope
Returnenvelope(top)
(A)Electionmaillogo
(B)FacingIdentificationMark(FIM)
(C)PostagePaidorPostageinstructions
(D)Countyreturnaddress
(E)Returnservicerequestednotice
(*/F)Voter’smailingaddress(andwindowontheoutgoingenvelope)
(G)Electionofficemailingaddress(onreturnenvelopefront)
(H)IntelligentMailBarcode(IMB)
InthisdesigntheUSPS“addressingarea”isthespacetotherightofthecoloredarea.
ThissectionincludesalloftheelementsneededtoaccuratelysendtheenvelopesthroughtheUSPostalService.Whendesigninganenvelope,pleaseconsultthepostalmanualstobesureyouunderstandtheentirerequirement.[3]
ElectionMaillogoSeeUSPSPub631forinformationabouttheelectionmaillogo.
• Followrequirementsforclearspacerequiredaroundthelogo.
• Besuretousethecorrectsizeofthelogo-mostvote-by-mailenvelopeswillusethemediumsize.
FacingIdentificationMarks(FIM)FollowUSPSspecificationsforspacingandplacementofthesemarks,whichareusedtohelptheautomationequipmentfindthefrontoftheenvelope.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page11CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
PostagePaidorPostageinstructionsFollowUSPSregulationsforthepostageblockintheupperrightcorner.
• Textmustbeaminimumof8points.
Researchwithlow-literacy,lowcivicengagementvotersininnercityBaltimoresuggeststhattheinstruction“PostageRequired.PostOfficewillnotdeliverwithoutproperpostage”ismoreeffectiveifplacedbelowanemptyrectanglebecauseparticipantsinterpretedanythingexceptanemptyboxtobepostage-paidmail.[7]
ElectionofficereturnaddressSeeUSPSDMM-603foraddressinginstructions.
• Theelectionofficereturnaddressontheoutgoingenvelopemustmatchthepostalpermitnumberusedforpostage.BesuretoincludethefullZIP+4.
• Forreturnenvelopesthatare“CourtesyReturn”(thatis,notpostage-paidreturn),USPSrequiresthattherebeaplaceforareturnaddress.
• Thelayoutleavesablankspaceonthereturnenvelopecorrespondingtothelocationoftheelectionofficereturnaddressontheoutgoingenvelope.Somemailingspecialistssuggestincluding3blanklinesforthevotertowriteareturnaddress.(USPS703.82.5)
AncillaryServiceEndorsementsSeeUSPSPub507dforreturnserviceoraddressservicerequests.
• Thereare4possiblelocationsforthistext,withthespaceunderthereturnaddresstheleastconfusingonthecrowdedoutgoingballot.
• Anendorsementmustbeatleast8-pointtypeinallcapitalletters.Itmuststandoutclearlyagainstthebackgroundandhave¼”clearspaceonallsides.
IntelligentMailBarcode(IMB)SeeIMBdetailsandguidelinesathttps://ribbs.usps.gov.
• TheIntelligentMailBarcodes(IMB)supporttheUSPSIntelligentMailServices,includingtrackingmailpieces.
Mailingaddresses• Theelectionofficemailingaddressisprintedonthefrontofthereturn
envelope,withtheassociatedIMBcode.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page12CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
• Thevoter’soutgoingmailingaddressiseitherprintedonthebackofthereturnenvelopeandshowsthroughawindowintheoutgoingenvelope,orcanbeprintedontheoutgoingenvelope.
Anopenissue:thevoter’soutgoingmailingaddressThelocationandtreatmentofthevoter’soutgoingmailingaddressisstillanopenissue.Electiondepartmentswanttoprintitonthebackofthereturnenvelopesoitshowsthroughawindowintheoutgoingenvelope.Thisallowsalloftheinformationforeachvotertobeprintedononeenvelope,eliminatingthechallengeofsynchronizingtwoenvelopesandtheballottypes.
However,duringthe2016election,somereturnedenvelopesweredeliveredbacktothevoter,whenpostalautomationequipmentreadthevoter’saddressandIMBasthedestination.TheUSPSisstilltestingpossiblesolutionstothisissue.
Suggestedsolutionsbeingtestedinclude:
• PlacingtwoduplicateIMBaboveandbelowtheelectionsofficemailingaddressonthefrontofthereturnenvelope.Thismayincreasethealgorithmic“weight”ofthatsideoftheenvelopefortheautomationequipment.[3]
• PlaceanIMBfortheelectionsofficeinthelowerrightcornerofthebackofthereturnenvelope,whereitishiddenbelowthewindowontheoutgoingenvelope,butvisiblefortheautomationequipmentduringthereturntrip.[13]
Pleaseconsultyourelectionmailspecialistbeforefinalizingyourenvelopelayout.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page13CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Identificationasanofficialvote-by-mailenvelope
OutgoingenvelopeReturnenvelope
Identificationasanofficialballot
(I)Countyseal[8]
(J)Officialballotnotice[1-a.5]
(K)Envelopetype(returnenvelope)
(L)Canvassingboardnotice(returnenvelope)[1-a.5]
(W)Deadlines
(ø)Coloredarea
Backofthereturnenvelope
Identificationofthecountyandelection
(M)Thenameofthecounty[13]
(N)Thenameanddateoftheelection[13]
OfficialballotidentificationandcanvassingboardnoticeInthecoloredarea,thecountysealandtextidentifytheenvelopeandwhatitholds.
• Thecountysealorotherofficiallogoappearsonallenvelopes.Althoughvotersmightnotidentifyaspecificcountyseal,theydoseeseals,ingeneral,asasignofofficialinformation.Itwillalsohelpelectionworkersdifferentiatebetweenenvelopesfromtheircountyoranotherone.
• Bothoutgoingandreturnenvelopesincludenoticethattheenvelopecontainsanofficialballot.
• TheReturnEnvelopeisnamedintheidentificationsoitcanbematchedtoinstructions,makingiteasierforvoterstounderstandwhichenvelopetouse.
• Thereturnenvelopeincludesanoticethatthereturnedballotistobeopenedonlybythecanvassingboard.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page14CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Deadlinesforreturningtheballotbymailorbydroppingitoff• Thedeadlinesforreturningtheballotareincludedsothatthiscritical
informationisavailabletothevoterontheenvelopeitself.
Duringusabilitytestingoftheprototypes,voterswantedthistextaslargeaswouldfitontheenvelopeeasily.[14]
Identificationofthecountyandtheelection• Printingthenameofthecountyonthebackofthereturnenvelopeishelpful
forelectionadministration,sothataworkerlookingonlyatthebackoftheenvelopecaneasilyidentifyballotsfromanothercounty
SignaturesandotherformsCaliforniaElectionsCode3011and354[1]requireseveraldifferentsignaturesontheballotreturnenvelope.Thissectionincludesalloftheadditionalformsthevotermayneedtocompletesigningandsealingtheenvelope.Thelayoutalsoincludesrelateddesignelementsthathelpmaketheenvelopeseasiertouse.
Alloftheseelementsareonthebackofthereturnenvelopesothatsomeoneexaminingtheenvelopecanseethemallatthesametime.
Themostimportantoftheseformsistheareaforthevoter’ssignatureandrelatedinformation.
Totheextentpossiblewithdifferentenvelopestyles,thelocationofthesignatureonthereturnenvelopeshouldbeasconsistentaspossible,sothatstatewidevotereducationcanaccuratelyportraythelocation.[5]
Evenifthesignatureareamovessothatitcanbeplacedappropriatelyaroundtheenvelopeflaporbelowapeel-awaytabthathidesthevotersignature,thesignatureareashouldbeconsistentlyplacedbelowthevoter’sdeclaration.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page15CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Votersignatureareawithwitnesssignature
Blanksignatureform
Formwithvoterinformationprinted
(O)Voter’ssignature[1-a.2]
(P)Thedateofsigning[1-a.4]
(Q)Voter’snameandregistrationaddress[1-a.3]
(R)Voterscancodefortheelectionmanagementsystem[13]
(S)Awitnesstoamarkinplaceofasignature[354.5]
(+)Holestoidentifythesignaturearea[12]
Voter’ssignatureandaddressThevoter’ssignatureblockincludesseveralelements,arrangedinaconsistentlayout.
• Theareaforthevoter’ssignatureisenclosedinarectangle,withalargeXinside.Thismakesitvisuallydistinct,andencouragesvoterstosignwithinthespaceprovided.Thisalsohelpswithsignatureverificationforbothmanualandautomatedsystems.Noothersignatureontheenvelopeshouldhavethismarkorbeenclosedinabox.[4,9,10]
• Thetitleforthisareaisaninstruction,“Voter:signhereinink,”placedjustabovethesignaturebox,with“Powerofattorneynotacceptable”insmalltypeonthesamelineorjustbelowit.[4,9,10]
Duringusabilitytestingoftheprototypes,votersaskedwhethertheyhadtosigninink.Theywantedconfirmationthattheyhadallthedetailsright.[14]
• Punchedholesaroundthesignatureareacanserveasguidestohelpblindorlowliteracyvoterssignaccurately
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page16CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Thetwoholeshelpblindvoterstotactilelyidentifythelocationofthesignaturespaceandthecorrectorientationoftheenvelope.Onegoesallthewaythroughtheenvelope,oneonlythroughthefrontorback.[12]
Blankorpre-printedformTheformforthevoter’sname,andaddresscanbeleftblank,tobefilledinbythevoter,orcanbeprintedontheenvelopeaspartoftheaddressingprocess.
• Whenanamemustbeprinted,includethatinformationintheprompt,makingitaclearerdirection.[4,10,14]
• Printingthenamehelpsavoidspousalswaps(whenfamilymembersreturntheirballotintheother’senvelope).Thiscausesproblemswhenthewrongvoteris“checkedin”ashavingreturnedaballot.[4]
• Preprintingthevoter’sregistrationaddress(ratherthantheaddressfortheirvote-by-mailballot)ontheenvelopehelpslowliteracyandlowcivicliteracyvoterscomplywiththisrequirementforacceptingavote-by-mailballot.
• Somecountiesalsoprintasmallcodethatcanbescannedtobringupthevoter’srecordintheEMS.
WitnesssignatureareaAwitnesstothesignatureisrequiredforvoterswhoonlymakeamark.
• Thissignatureshouldbeplacedonaline(notinabox)sothatitdoesnotcompetewiththecriticalvotersignature.
Duringusabilitytestingoftheprototypes,voterswereconfusedaboutwhosenametowriteandwhoshouldsignwhenthepromptjustsaid“Name”[14]
Bearernameandsignature
Backofthereturnenvelope
(T)Bearer’snameandsignature[1-a.9,10,11]
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page17CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Californialawrequiresthatifsomeoneotherthanthevoterreturnsavote-by-mailballot,theymustbeidentified.Thissectionofthecodewasamendedin2017toallowanyperson,notjustthosewithalistofspecificrelationships.
• Thename,relationship,andsignatureofapersonauthorizedtoreturnaballotforavoterisinasmallformontheoutsideflapoftheenvelope.
Inusabilitytestingtheprototype,voterswereconfusedaboutwhosenameandsignaturewasneeded,sothepromptwaschangedtosay“Theirname”and“Theirsignature”toclearlyidentifywhoshouldsign.[14]
• Thenameanddateoftheelectionishelpfultoensurethatonlyenvelopeswithvoterinformationforthecurrentelectionareused.Itisalsousefulinthecaseofoverlappingspecialelections.Itisalsoonthebackofthereturnenvelopewithotheractiveelements.
Voter’sdeclarationandwarnings
(V)Voter’sDeclaration(1-a.1,8)
(X)Signaturewarning(1-a.6)
(Y)Votingtwicewarning(1-a.7)
Thevoter’sdeclarationincludesseveralsections:
• Adeclaration,underpenaltyofperjury,statingthatthevoterresideswithintheprecinctinwhichheorsheisvotingandisthepersonwhosenameappearsontheenvelope.(a.1)
• Astatementthatthevoterhasneitherapplied,norintendstoapply,foravotebymailvoter’sballotfromanyotherjurisdictionforthesameelection(a.8)
• Awarningthatthevotermustsigntheenvelopeinhisorherownhandwritingandthatitmustmatchthevoterregistrationsignaturefortheballottobecounted.(a.7)
• Awarningthatvotingtwiceisacrime.(a.6)
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page18CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Finalchecklistandreminders
(Z)“Beforeyouseal”checklist
(U)Howtogetareplacementballot
Afinalchecklist,placedsothatitisvisibleastheenvelopeissealedremindsvotersto:
• Signthevoter’sdeclaration
• Puttheirballotintheenvelope
InShastaCounty,somevoterscheckedoffitemsintheinstructionsandthefinalchecklist,showingthattheyhadseenandusedthisinformation.[11]
Otherhelpfulremindersincludehowtocorrectamistakeontheballot.Thisinformationcanbeintheinstructionsinsertinmoredetail,butshouldalsobeontheballot.
• Howtogetareplacementballot[13]
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page19CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
Instructionsontheenvelope
(AA)Messagearea
(BB) Contactinformation
(CC) Howtoreturntheballot
Theoutgoingenvelopehasroomonthebackforinstructionsorotherhelpfulinformation
Messagearea• Thebackflapoftheoutgoingenvelopecanbeusedforamessage.Thisarea
cancallattentiontoanythingnewintheelection–suchastheVoter’sChoiceAct
Contactinformation• Thecontactinformationshouldincludeallofthewaystocommunicatewith
theelectionsoffice,includinginformationinanylanguagestheofficesupports.
SummaryofhowtoreturntheballotTheotherareaforinstructionsisanoverviewofhowtoreturntheballot.
• Theinformationistailoredtoeachcountyandtheoptionsavailable.
• Includealinktofindalistofdropboxes,pollingplaces,andvotecenters.
• Bilingualenvelopeshaveashorterversiontoallowbothlanguagestofit.
• Bothversionsuseiconstoillustrateeachoption.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page20CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
EnvelopestructuralelementsSomefeaturesarebuiltintotheenvelope,ratherthanprintedonit.Whenthesefeaturesareused,thelayoutoftheotherelementsmayneedtoshifttofittheenvelopedimensions.
• Thebottomofanaddresswindowshouldbeatleast¾ofaninchfromthebottomoftheenvelopetoensurethestabilityoftheenvelope.
• Apunchedholeinthereturnenvelopeshowselectionworkersifaballotisintheenvelopewithoutopeningit.Thisholemightbepartofthepairofholessurroundingthevoter’ssignatureareaasaguide.
• Someoutgoingenvelopeshaveasmallwindowpositionedtomakeiteasytocheckthatthecorrectballottypehasbeeninsertedintoeachenvelope.
• Usingasignatureprivacytabmeansthatthesignatureareamustbepositionedundertheflapofthereturnenvelope
• AnycoloredareathatwrapstothebackoftheenvelopemustbenarrowenoughthatitdoesnotinterferewiththeUSPSclearspacearoundtheaddressorautomationfeatures.Amaximumof½”isagoodstartingruleofthumb.
• Thesizeofthereturnenvelopeshouldallowvoterstoeasilyfitallofthematerials(includingballotandsecrecysleeve,ifused).
IntheVSAPstudy,whenthefitwastootight,participantsworriedthattheenvelopewould“notstaysafelysealedinthemail.”[6]
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page21CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
InstructionsinsertorsecrecysleeveTosupportvoters,thedesignincludesavoterguideinsertwithdetailedinstructions,appropriatetowhetherthecountyhasimplementedtheVoter’sChoiceAct.Theseinsertsgivevoterscomplete,clear,plainlanguageinstructionsincludedwithintheballotpackagethatwalksthroughtheentireprocessfrommarkingtheballottoreturningit.
Theinstructionsinclude:
• Theprocessforvoting,includingremindingvoterstoreturntheirballot[5,7,8]
• Alistofoptionsforreturningtheballot,includingdropboxes[4,13]
• Awaytofindthelocationanywheretoreturnavote-by-mailballot[4,12]
• InstructionsforRemoteAccessibleVotebyMail,ifavailable[413]
• Thedeadlineforreturningballotsandanyrelatedrequirements[1,4,13]
Somecountiesuseasecrecysleevesotheballotisprotectedwhiletheballotisbeingopened.Instructionsformarkingtheballotcanbeprintedonthesecrecysleeve.Finalinstructionsforsigningthereturnenvelopeandreturningtheenvelope,however,shouldbeonaninsertthatisnotreturnedwiththeballot.
InusabilitytestinginBaltimore,participantshadlesstroubleunderstandinghowtopacktheirballotwhenaninnerenvelopeorsecrecysleevewasdistinctinsizeandappearancefromthemailingenvelope.[7]
Goodpracticeforpackingtheenvelopesistopacktheballotinsideanyinstructioninsertorasecrecysleevesovotersnoticeit.[6,7]
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page22CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
SampleinsertsThesampleinsertsinahalf-pagebrochure
Cover
Howtovote
Electionnameanddate
Optionsforreturningtheballot
Informationaboutpollingplacesorvotecenters
Insideleft
Mark,seal,andsignyourballot
Instructionsforvoting
Howtogetareplacementballot
Howtotrackyourballot
Insideright
50waystoreturnyourballot
Informationaboutoptionsandhours
Maptoshowrangeoflocations
Back
Accessiblevoting
Accessiblevotingmachines
Accessibleremotevoting(ifavailable)
Languagesupport
Contactinformation
ThesampleinsertisavailableonlineasaPowerPointfileinthreeversions:
• EnglishversionfortheVoter’sChoiceActcounties
• SpanishversionfortheVoter’sChoiceActcounties
• Englishversionforothercounties
Thetranslationsfilesarealsoavailable.ThetranslationsweremadebyCTSLanguageLink,buthavenotbeenverified.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page23CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
BallotsecrecyandsignaturesecurityThereisawidevarietyofdesignsforhowballotsecrecyisprotectedandwhethersignaturesarehiddenorexposedonthereturnenvelope.
Althoughelectionofficialsdonotreportmanyissueswithexposedsignatures,inanageofincreasingidentifytheft,hidingthevoter’ssignaturemightbeanissueinthefuture.
Thereissomeevidencethatvoters,especiallyincities,donottruststreet-cornermailboxesassafeorsecure[7,11].Officialsinotherall-vote-by-mailstatesreportthatasignificantmajorityofballotsarereturnedusingdrop-boxesorotherelectionoffice.Thismaybemotivatedbythedesiretoreturntheballotdirectlytoanarmoftheelectionoffice,concernsaboutUSPSreliability,concernsaboutprotectingtheirpersonalinformation,oramixofalloftheseissues.
HidingthesignatureThereareseveralenvelopedesignsthathidethesignatureinuse.Theyinclude:
• Largeenvelopeflapsthatcovertheentireformwiththevoter’ssignatureandaddress.Typicallytheflapcanbeopenedwithoutopeningthepartoftheenvelopeholdingtheballot,sotheballotremainssecretuntilthevoterisauthenticated.
• Rolledenvelopeflaps,whicharefoldedtwicetohidethesignature.Likethelargeflaps,themaincompartmentoftheenvelopeisopenedseparately.
• Signaturewindowsorsmallsectionsoftheenvelopethataretornawaytorevealthesignature.
Thesedesigns,however,haveanimpactonelectionadministrationprocesses,asalmostallofthemrequiretheenvelopetobehandledtwice:oncetorevealthesignaturesothevotercanbeauthenticated,andasecondtimetoopentheenvelopeandextracttheballot.
Otherballotsecurityorprivacysolutions• Inaddition,somecountiespositionthesignatureblocksothevotersignsover
thesealedflap,makingtamperingeasiertodetect.
• Somecountiesincludeasecrecysleeve.Thisisapaperfolderopenontwosides,whichprotectstheballotfromcasualvisualinspectionastheenvelopeisopened.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page24CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
ListofelementsontheenvelopesID Name Used on PostalandmailingelementsA ElectionMaillogo Outgoing,ReturnB FIM Outgoing,ReturnC USPSPostage Outgoing,ReturnD Countyreturnaddress Outgoing
E Returnservicerequested OutgoingF Voter’smailingaddress ReturnG Electionofficemailingaddress ReturnH IntelligentMailBarcode(IMB) Outgoing(voter),Return(office)ElementstoidentifytheenvelopeorelectionI Countyseal AllJ OfficialVBMnotice Outgoing,ReturnK Envelopetype ReturnL Canvassingboardnotice ReturnM Nameofcounty ReturnN Nameanddateofelection Returnø Coloredarea AllVoter’ssignatureandotherformsO Voter’ssignature ReturnP Dateofsigning ReturnQ Voter’snameandregistrationaddress ReturnR Voter’sEMSscancode ReturnS Witnesssignature ReturnT Bearer’snameandsignature ReturnVoter’sdeclarationandothernoticesandremindersV Voter’sdeclaration ReturnW Electiondeadlinenotice ReturnX Signaturemustmatch ReturnY Votingtwiceisacrime ReturnZ Beforeyousealchecklist ReturnInstructionsAA Promotionalarea OutgoingBB Contactinfoforelectionsoffice OutgoingCC Howtoreturninstructions OutgoingStructuralelementsontheenvelope* Windowtoshowvoter’saddress Outgoing+ Holestoidentifythesignaturearea Return
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page25CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
HowweranthisprojectThedesignguidelinesaredrawnfromtheCenter’sexperiencetestingavarietyofelectionmaterials,includingvote-by-mailenvelopesinBaltimoreandShastaCounty,voterregistrationforms,otherelectionforms,andusabilitytestingofdesignprototypes,aswellasfromtheexperienceandwisdomoftheelectionofficialswhohaveworkedonthisprojectwithus.
Preparationfortheprojectincluded:
• Reviewandanalysisofthecontentsandformatcurrentvote-by-mailenvelopesfromallCaliforniacounties,collectedbytheSecretaryofState’soffice.
• ReviewoftheCaliforniaElectionCoderequirementsforinformationandformsonvote-by-mailreturnenvelopes.
• ReviewofUSPostalServicerequirementsforelectionmail.
• Reviewofbestpracticesinvote-by-maildesignsfromotherstates.
• Reviewofrecentresearchonvote-by-maildesignandworkconductedfortheVotingSystemAssessmentProject.
Feedbackduringtheprojectincludedseveralsources:
• ReviewandfeedbackfromCaliforniaelectionofficialsandtheSecretaryofState’soffice.
• ReviewandfeedbackfromtheUSPSElectionMailunitandotherexpertsonelectionmail,includingTammyPatrick.
• UsabilitytestingwithvotersinCalaveras,SantaCruz,Shasta,andTuolumnecounties,includingreviewofthereturnedenvelopesbyelectionofficialsinthosestates.
Wecreatedsampleenvelopes:
• WeusedthemostcommonsizeinthecollectionofenvelopesinuseinCalifornia—9.5”x6.5”outgoingenvelopesand9”x6”returnenvelopes.
• ThefirstsetincludedoutgoingandreturnenvelopesinEnglishandbilingualEnglishandSpanish.Afterusabilitytestingthebilingualreturnenvelopeswerereprintedwithcorrections.
Vote-by-mailenvelopedesignforCalifornia-December15,2017 Page26CenterforCivicDesign|OxideDesignCo.
SourcesforrequirementsElectionofficialssuggestedmanyoftherequirementsduringourinterviews.Othersourcesthateitherconfirmedthatinputoraddedspecificdetailsbasedonpolicyorresearcharelistedhere.
1. CaliforniaElectionsCodeSection3011and354
2. USPSPublications(includingPub631OfficialElectionMail—GraphicGuidelines)
3. USPSpresentationstotheEACStandardsBoard,CACEO,andotherconferences
4. PresentationsorpersonalcommunicationwithTammyPatrick(PresidentialCommissiononElectionAdministrationandpostalelectionmailexpert)
5. CaliforniaSecretaryofState’sOfficepresentationsorpersonalcommunication
6. “Vote-by-MailResearchReport”–LACountyVSAPandIDEO,March2016
7. “MakingVotingbyMailUsable,Accessible,andInclusive”–KathrynSummers,WhitneyQuesenbery,AmyPointer,paperatAHFE2016
8. “BestPracticesforOfficialVoterGuides”–CenterforCivicDesignandLeagueofWomenVotersofCalifornia
9. Showcase:AbsenteeBallotInstructionsinMinnesota–CenterforCivicDesignandMinnesotaSecretaryofState’sOffice
10. Showcase:VoterregistrationformsinPennsylvania(andothers)–CenterforCivicDesignandPennsylvaniaSecretaryofState’sOffice
11. Usabilitytestingvote-by-mailenvelopesinShastaCounty(2015)
12. Oregonvote-by-mailaccessibleenvelopedesign
13. FeedbackfromCaliforniaelectionsofficialsormailingspecialists
14. UsabilitytestingforthisprojectwithvotersinCalaveras,SantaCruz,Shasta,andTuolumneCounties(November2017)
Downloadthisreport
Youcandownloadacopyofthisreportandallsamplefilesforenvelopelayoutsandinsertsfrom:
https://www.civicdesign.org/projects/vote-by-mail
Formoreinformation
Ifyouwouldlikemoreinformationaboutthisproject,orhelpusingthesedesignstoupdateyourvote-by-mailenvelopes,we’dlovetotalktoyou:
CenterforCivicDesign
www.civicdesign.org
410-921-6811