VITL May 14, 2023

VITLCritical Design

Review (Sec 2.1)

Sunday, May 14, 2023

Team Members: Ryan Hickman, Chris Homolac, Jen Krupp, Kyle Ligon,

Heather Love, Alex Paulson, Kathryn Rash, Veronica Vertucci

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion2

VITL May 14, 2023

Objectives OverviewDesign and build a prototype for the locomotion system of a vehicle exploring a Europa-like surface capable of traversing 1 km of icy terrain in 7 days with characteristic obstacles.

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion3

VITL May 14, 2023

Characteristic Mission ProfileAerial View

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion4

VITL May 14, 2023

Characteristic Mission ProfileSide View

Not to Scale

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion5

VITL May 14, 2023

Theoretical Europa Mission (TEM)• What makes a Europa mission?

– Surface Characteristics• Ice

– Friction (µ~0.55) and Hardness (~6 mohs)• Obstacles

– Inclines, Bumps and Ruts– Environment

• Low Temperature (100K)• Reduced Gravity (1/6 g)• Power Supply challenges-Solar power not viable• Radiation (1MRad)• Low Pressure (10-6 Pa)

– Scientific Objectives• One of the best candidates for liquid water and life beyond Earth• 3 proposed instruments (camera, magnetometer and radiation sensor)

• A Theoretical Europa Mission (TEM) would accommodate all of these.

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion6

VITL May 14, 2023

TEM Simplification• The VITL locomotion will concentrate on:

– Surface Characteristics (previously shown)– Simplified Environment

• Low Temperature– 100K manufacturing and testing is infeasible due to resources and

experience.– Instead vehicle will be designed for 0°C operation

» Entire vehicle can be tested on a “cold” Earth day on frozen lake» Design methods can be extended for TEM using materials for 100K

operation• Reduced Gravity• Accommodate mass of a traditional power supply • NOT worrying about pressure or radiation on Europa (out of scope)

– Simplified Scientific Objectives• Accommodate mass of 10kg payload

– Additional locomotion and sensing requirements• These form the design requirements of the Engineering

Design and Manufactured Unit (EDMU) for Senior Projects

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion7

VITL May 14, 2023

Top Level System Requirements

VITL

Structural 1.0 Electronics 2.0 Performance 3.0

Geometry 1.1

Payload Considerations 1.2

Terrain Crossing 3.1

Inclination 3.2

Direction Change 3.3

Obstacle Detection 2.1

Control 2.2

Mission Life 2.3

Temperature 3.4

Range 3.5

Efficiency/Accuracy 3.6

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion8

VITL May 14, 2023

1.1 Geometry Fit within one cubic meter

Fit within one cubic meter

1.2 Payload Power, heat and facilitate the use of any possible science sent to Europa.

Use a 10 kg dummy payload to simulate the mass

Requirement Flow-down from TEM to EDMU

TEM EDMU

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion9

VITL May 14, 2023

2.1 Obstacle Detection

Sense obstacles specified in PDD, cease movement and wait for further command

Sense obstacles specified in PDD and cease movement

2.2 Controller Some form of odometry coupled with visual data sent to earth to navigate

Use of a COTS controller to manually navigate terrain for testing and verification purposes

2.3 Mission Life

System must operate for 7 days and components must be rad-hard to survive intense radiation environment

All systems must be capable of operation at least 7 days

TEM EDMU

Requirement Flow-down from TEM to EDMU

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion10

VITL May 14, 2023

3.1 Terrain Crossing

Traverse obstacles outlined in PDD on Europa’s surface

Traverse obstacles outlined in PDD on lake ice

3.2 Inclination Stop or go on in any direction on a 20 degree slope

Equating torques yields an Earth slope of 2.62 degrees

3.3 Direction Change

Yaw 180 degrees to allow removal from a dangerous situation

Yaw 180 degrees to allow removal from a dangerous situation

3.4 Temperature Entire vehicle must operate in 90-110K

No 100K testing. Design for 0°C. Some Drive components may be tested

Requirement Flow-down from TEM to EDMU

TEM EDMU

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion11

VITL May 14, 2023

Requirement Flow-down from TEM to EDMU

TEM EDMU3.5 Range The vehicle must

travel a distance of no less than 1 kilometer in 7 days

Must show repeatability to prove that EDMU can travel 1 kilometer

3.6 Efficiency/Accuracy

Destination coordinates accurate to one body length of TEM

Using odometry, a scale of one body length to every 100 meters traveled accuracy must be obtained

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion12

VITL May 14, 2023

EDMU System BreakdownVITL

Drive Electronics Structure Testing

Sensors

C&DH/COMM

Software

Power/Thermal

Sensors

Structures

Facilities

Suspension

Wheels

Motors

Frame

Component boxes

Material Selection

Thermal

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion13

VITL May 14, 2023

EDMU Preliminary LayoutScience Payload

TEM Power (dummy mass)

BatteriesSonar and ProximitySensorLaser Range

Thermal Strip

Suspensionand Drive trainAttachments

Motor Controller

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion14

VITL May 14, 2023

Structures EDMU LayoutAccelerometer andRate Gyro

Receiver, C&DH Board, and Motor Controller

ThermalStrip

For Analysis, assume Aluminum alloy

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion15

VITL May 14, 2023

Structures EDMU LayoutScience Payload

TEM Power (dummy mass)

BatteriesSonar and ProximitySensor

Laser Range

Thermal Stripand Motor Controller

Suspensionand Drive trainAttachments

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion16

VITL May 14, 2023

Electrical Interconnects Block Diagram

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion17

VITL May 14, 2023

Friction Analysis• Required Coefficient of Friction

Europatotalw gmF

)cos()cos( inclineEuropatotalinclinewN gmFF

)sin()sin( inclineEuropatotalinclinewslide gmFF

slideinclineEuropatotalsNsf FgmFF )cos(

)tan()cos()sin(

inclineinclineEuropatotal

inclineEuropatotal

N

slides gm

gmFF

)tan( inclines

φincline

Fslip

FfFw

FN

• μs = 0.36397– Difficult to design to

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion18

VITL May 14, 2023

Penetration Analysis• Spike Penetration

– Easy to design to– Fspike > Fslide

– mrover = 70 kg– 20° Inclination– α < 70°

φincline

αFslide

F Fspike

FN

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion19

VITL May 14, 2023

Design System Calculations• Equivalent Earth Inclination

hw

roll 2tan 1

θroll

w

h

)sin( ,inclineEuropatotalwheelfwheelEuropa gmrFr

EarthEuropa

)sin()sin( ,, EarthinclineEarthtotalwheelEuropainclineEuropatotalwheel gmrgmr

)sin(sin ,

1, Europaincline

Earth

EuropaEarthincline g

g

• Rollover Angle

φinclination,Earth = 2.62°

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion20

VITL May 14, 2023

Structures Load Analysis – Load Distribution

Science Payload

TEM Power (dummy mass)

Min FOS = 22

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion21

VITL May 14, 2023

CDR Prototyping• Traction tests

– Surface hardness– Spike penetration– Slippage

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion22

VITL May 14, 2023

Acronym List• ADC: Analog to Digital Converter• C&DH: Command and Data Handling• COTS: Commercial Off The Shelf• CPU: Central Processing Unit• EDMU: Engineering Design and Manufactured Unit• RF: Radio Frequency• RHU: Radioisotope Heater Unit• RTG: Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator• RX: Receiver• TEM: Theoretical Europa Mission• TX: Transmitter• WBS: Work Breakdown Structure

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion23

VITL May 14, 2023

References• Trudy Schwartz• SolidWorks 2005• Vable, Madhukar. Mechanics of Materials.• www.onlinemetals.com• www.matweb.com• www.analog.com• www.pcb.com• www.thomasnet.com• www.globalspec.com• www.servosystems.com• www.sensotech.com• www.omega.com• www.powerelectrics.co.uk• www.quadratureencoders.com• www.panasonic.com• www.powerstream.com• www.all-battery.com• www.media.popularmechanics.com• www.maxon.com• www.nasa.gov

Vehicle for Icy Terrain Locomotion24

VITL May 14, 2023

Quick Links• Objectives Overview• Theoretical Europa Mission (TEM)• Top Level System Requirements• EDMU Preliminary Layout• Electrical Interconnects Block Diagram• CDR Prototyping