vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk...

15

Transcript of vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk...

Page 1: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

� ��������� ���� ���������� ������� ����� �!�"#�$��% & �'��)(+*, �.- �/�$�����.��01� ��23�

4�57698:69; 4�<=69>=?@5BA >C>.D#EGFIH.E7FJ<=A KMLN6:O=OPA <=QRDSE

T�U@VXW'Y[Z]\/U@^_Z$`�a�b�^dc�ef^dU@U=Y]ef^gcihSj@efU@^gj@Uk�^deflmUPY]n[efZpoi`�arqts#au` YCv7wXqts#au`�YCv�q�x.y�z|{r}gwdk�~��

� VJj@V7wXW � ���tY]`��J`�Z]n@� `+sB� W j|� �d��_�m�|�����m� �m�|�r�p�#� �#���S�N��� �����_�N���|�g�S�+�_�|�

��� �@¡@¢'£X¤�¡|¥/¦�§ U)`��S¨©U@j=Z]eflmU�` aªZ § e«nt¬�`�Y]��e«n­Z]`iW �gZ]`|\�W'Z]efj+W�®f®¯o°U@n�Z]ef\�W Z]U.Z § UZ[Y]e¯au`_j@W�®�Z]U@^gn[`�Y�W�^dvIauU+W'Z]�gY]U�j@` Y[Y]U@n[VJ`|^dvgU@^gj@U@n.` l|U=Y.e«\�W c|U@n�Z[Y]efVd®fU=Z]n@wN�d^XvSU=Y�g^gY]U@n�Z[Y]efj=Z]U+v.j+W�\/UPYCW�\/` Z]e«`�^dn�W ^Xv�j § W�^dc�U@n ef^)ef^_Z]U=Y]^dW�®#VXW'YCW�\/U=Z]U=Y]n �JUPZ©¬�U=U@^l#efU=¬�n@� ¦ `$Z § efn±U@^dv�¬�UªU=s#Z]U@^Xv�W�VgY]U@l#ef`|�gnG¬�e«vgUª�XW n[U@®fe«^gU$²+³pl#efU=¬´W ®fc|`�Y]e¯Z § \µZ]`z'³pl#efU=¬�n@� ¦�§ U�W ®fc|`�Y]e¯Z § \¶e«n��dW�n[U+v�`|^!U@n�ZCW��g®«efn § e«^gc�auU@W Z]�gY]U�j=`�Y[Y]U@n[VJ`�^XvgU=^dj@U@n�JU=Zp¬�U@U=^ l#e«UP¬�n�Z]`�c|U=Z § U=Y�¬�e¯Z § W § `�\/`|c YCW�V § o°¬ § efj § U@^dW��g®«U=n)W!lSefU=¬�VJ`�ef^#Zef^#l|W'Y]e«W�^_Z)W ·/^gefZpo¸n[j=`�Y]U|� ¦�§ U�e«^gVd�SZ�e«n�Z § U�Z § Y]U@U/ef\�W�c�U@n@w�W�^dvIZ § U/`��gZ]Vg�gZZ § UtZ[Y]e¯au`_j+W ®7Z]U=^dn[`�Y�W ^Xv�ef\�W�c|Utj@`�Y[Y]U=n[VJ`|^XvSU@^dj=U@n@wg¬ § efj § ef^iZ]�SY]^iauW�j@ef®fe¯ZCW Z]U�WVSY]` ¨©U@j=Z]eflmU�Y]U@j@`�^dn�Z[Y]�djPZ]e«`�^R`�aNZ § U�j+W \/U=YCW�n�W�^dv!n[j@U=^dU|�¹¸U!W ®fn[`ºef^#lmU@n�Z]efc|W Z]U/Z § Uivge¯Y]U@jPZ�j@`�\/Vd�SZCW Z]ef`|^ ` a$Z § U/au�g^XvgW�\/U@^_ZCW�®r\�W Z[Y]e¯sa:`�Y�l#efU=¬»VdW�e¯Y]n@wBW ^XvRZ § U�Z[Y]e¯au`_j+W ® Z]U@^dn[` Y�au` Y­l#efU=¬¼Z[Y]efVg®«UPZ]n@wJa:Y]`|\MZ § U § `�\/`�³c YCW�V § efU@n­W ®«`�^dU|� ¦�§ efnt\/UPZ § `#v!efntn[�dj@j@U=n[n�au�d®½wJ�g�gZ�^d` ZtW�n�o_U=ZtW�n�W�j@j@�SYCW Z]U.W�nj@`�\/Vd�SZCW Z]ef`|^ia:Y]`|\MVJ`�e«^_Z�j@` Y[Y]U@n[VJ`|^dvgU@^gj@U@n@�¾±ef^XW ®f®fo_w±efZ)efn)n § `+¬�^ Z § W Z.Z § U�z'³¿lSefU=¬ÀW�®fc�`�Y]e¯Z § \ÁW�®f®f`'¬�n.Y]U@j@`�^dn�Z[Y]�djPZ]e«`�^´`�az T¶VJ`|ef^_Z]n@wN®fef^[email protected] ^Xv¸j+W \/U=YCW�n�a9Y]`|\ÂWRvSe«n[VdW YCW'Z]Uin[UPZ)` a­y|y�lSefU=¬�n@�±Ãt®f®�Z § UW ®«c�`�Y]e¯Z § \/n § W+lmU$�JU=U@^�ef\/Vd®fU@\/U@^_Z]U+v.W�^dv�W n[n[U@n[n[U+v/`|^�Y]U@W�®def\�W c|U@n@wmW�^Xv)VgY]`�³j@U=n[n[e«^gc/efntW �gZ]`�\�W Z]efj­Z § Y]`��dc § `|�SZ+�

Ä ÅdÆ�ÇJÈBÉ�Ê)Ë.ÌNÇBÍ]É�Æ

Î)Ï A <I>P57AÐ;GDSOC>FBA�? DgFJAÑD#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQÔOI57D Ï AÖÕGA�A E×FJA Ï A 8:ÓS;NA�FØK�576:?@5×OC6:QiÙ78«>@D#EBA�ÓSÙ7OP89Ú?'ÓSQR;BÙB>PAIÛ�A�D_>=ÙB<=A¸? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSE7FBA E7? A�O�DSE7FÜ>=5BA A ;B6:;GÓg8:DS<!ÒgA ÓgQ�A >P<=ÚÖÕNA'>]K�A A�EÝ;7DS69<@O!Ó#Û69QÔD#ÒgA�O�Þ ß#à7áPß#â#ã©äGD#E7FIÛ�A�D#>PÙB<=Ai? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSE7FBA E7? A�O­D#E7F¸>=5BA/>=<P69Û�ÓJ? D#8ªÒSA�ÓSQRA'>=<PÚ°ÕNA'>]K�A A�E>P<=69;B8:A'>@O�ÓSÛN6:QÔD#ÒSA|O�Þ ßSåmã�æSç­5BA|OCA�DS89ÒgÓS<=6«>=5BQÔO$D#<=A­<PÓgÕBÙ7OC>�D#E7FR<=A 8:6:DSÕB8:A�D#E7F�<=A�èdÙB6:<PA­ÓSE789Ú69EJÛ�Óg<PQÔD#>P6:ÓSE!FBA <=6 Ï A�F/Û�<=ÓSQM>P5BA­6:QRDSÒSA|O æmé[E�;7D#<P>P6u?'ÙB8uD#<�EBÓ�6:EJÛ�ÓS<=QÔD_>P6:ÓSE�ÓSEi>P5BA�?�D#QRA <@D69Ed>PA�<PEGD#8d;7D#<@D#QRA'>=A <@OrÓg<�?�D#QRA <@D�QRÓ#>=69ÓgEiEBA�A�FiÕGA�OPÙB;B;B8:69A|F æ_ê�Ó_K�A Ï A <|á'>P57A�DS89ÒgÓS<=6«>=5BQÔO<PA|ègÙ769<=AºD<=A�OC>P<=6:?'>PA|FÜ? D#QRA�<=DQRÓS>P6:ÓSEëD#EGFÜ896:QR6«>=A�Fµ?@57D#EBÒgAÔ69Eµ69Ed>=A <=E7D#8t;7D#<@D#QRA'>=A <@OÕGA >]KtA�A E Ï 69A�K�O æ#é�ÛN>P57A�OPA�<PA|O]>=<P6u?+>=69ÓgE7O$D#<=A­EBÓ#>�O=D_>=6:OCì7A|Fi>=5BA E�>=5BA.D#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P57QRO�K�6:8987Û¿D#6:8pæé[E!;B<=A Ï 6:ÓSÙ7OªK�ÓS<=í�K�A�57D Ï A�A'îX>PA�E7FJA|F!ßmï Ï 69A�KÝD#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P57QROr>PÓ�A EGD#ÕB8:A�Û�A|D_>=ÙB<PA­QÔD_>@?@5B6:EBÒD#E7FÒgA ÓgQ�A >P<=ÚºA|O]>=69QÔD_>=69ÓgE´ÕNA'>]K�A A E´>]KtÓºèdÙB69>PA�FJ6uOC;7DS<=D#>PA Ï 6:A K�O�ðòñPóô6:FJA!Õ7DSOPA 8:6:EBAO]>=A <=A ÓRQÔD_>=?@5769EBÒdõIÞ9ö�à#ã©æJóÐA/<=A Ï 69A�KØ>=5B6:O.D#;B;B<=ÓgDg?@5°6:E OPA�?'>P6:ÓSEßJæ

é[E/>P5B6uO�;7D#;NA <�K�AtA îd>=A E7F/>P5B6uO�KtÓg<Pí�69Ei>]KtÓ)K�DmÚJO�÷'ì7<@OC>�á_D�QÔD_>@?@5B6:EBÒ)DSE7F/ÒSA�ÓSQRA'>=<PÚA�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:ÓSE´DS89ÒgÓS<=6«>=5BQÂ6uO.FJA Ï A 8:ÓS;NA�FIÛ�Óg<�>P57<PA�A Ï 6:A K�O�æGç­57A/69EB;7ÙJ>)6uO�>=5B<PA�A/69QÔDSÒSA�O�Ó#ÛDÜOP? A EBA´Dg? èdÙB6:<PA|FëÛ�<=ÓSQøÙBEB<=A�OC>P<=6:?'>PA�F Ï 69A�K�;GÓg69Ed>@O á�DSE7F¼K�6«>=5ôÙBEB<=A�OC>P<=6:?'>PA|Fµ?�D#QRA <@D

Page 2: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

69Ed>PA�<PEGD#8�;7DS<=DSQ�A >PA�<=O�æ�ç­57AÓSÙJ>=;BÙJ>Ô6:OÔDÑOPA'>°ÓSÛ�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJ6:EBÒÖ;GÓg69Ed>RÛ�A�D#>PÙB<=A�OÔDSE7F>P5BA�A�OC>P6:QÔD_>PA|FÔ>=<P69Û�ÓJ? D#8N>=A E7OPÓS<�Þ«ögöSá'ö|âBáPßSù_ãNÛ�ÓS<t>P5BA Ï 69A�Kô>P<=6:;B89A >�æJç­5B6uO�6:O­FJA|OP? <P6:ÕGA|F°6:EOCA|?+>P6:ÓSE àBæ

ç­5BA)OPA�? ÓSE7FºA'îX>PA�E7OC6:ÓSEº6:O­D#EID#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQúÛ�ÓS<�ßmï Ï 69A�KØD#E7FIà_ï Ï 69A�KôÒSA ÓgQRA'>P<=Ú�A�OC>P6:Q!ïD_>P6:ÓSEÝK�5B6:?@5¼FJÓXA�O�EBÓS>!<=A�èdÙB6:<PAI;GÓg69Ed>û¿?'Óg<PE7A <+ü�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|O æªé[Eë>=5B6:OR?�DSOPA°>P57AÛ�ÙBE7FBDSQ�A�Ed>=D#8$QÔD#>P<=6«îýDSE7F>=<P69Û�ÓJ? D#8�>=A E7OPÓS</DS<PA�?'ÓSQR;BÙB>PA�FÐFJ6:<PA|?+>=89ÚÛ�<=ÓSQ�;78:DSE7D#<�5BÓSïQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5769A|O æmç­5BA­D#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQ×6uO�DS;B;B8:6:?�D#ÕB8:A�>=Ó�69QÔD#ÒgA�OªK�5BA <=At? ÓS<=EBA <�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|OD#<=A�EBÓ#>$D Ï D#6:8:DSÕB8:ASá Õ7ÙJ>ª;B8uD#EGD#<�5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�?�D#E�ÕNAt? ÓSQR;BÙJ>=A�FiÕdÚ�ÓS>P5BA�<ªQRA�DSE7O�á ASæ Ò7æÛ�<PÓgQÁ8:6:EBA!? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSE7FBA E7? A�O�æGç­5B6uO.6uO)6:FJA|D#8:89ÚOPÙB69>PA�F>PÓ¸;B69A|?'A�K�6:OPA�;B8uD#E7DS<�O=?'A�EBA�O!Þ å_ã©æç­5BA�D#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQþ6uO�FJA|OP? <P6:ÕNA�FI69EOPA�?+>=69ÓgEIÿGæ

Î E7?'A�>P57A�>P<=6«Û�ÓJ?�D#8J>=A E7OPÓS<$6uO�D Ï D#6:8:DSÕB8:AtÛ�Óg<$>P57<PA�A Ï 6:A K�O�6«>�OPÙB;B;NÓS<P>=O�>=5BA.DSÙJ>PÓgQRD#>P6u?QRD#>=?@5B6:EBÒµÓ#Ûi8:69E7A�O¸D#E7F ?'ÙB< Ï A|OýÞ9ö � ã�á­D#E7F A E7DSÕB89A|OI? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSEGFJA E7? A�OR>=ÓµÕNAÐA�OC>=D#ÕBï896uOC57A�F¼Ó Ï A�<°DÑ8:DS<PÒgA OPA'>°ÓSÛ Ï 6:A K�OÔÕXÚ¼?'ÓSEG? D_>=A E7D#>P6:EBÒÐ>P<=69;789A >ºQÔD_>=?@57A�OÞ ßJá��Já'ö|ß_ã©æ�é�>6:O�>=5BA EÑ;NÓgO=OC6:ÕB8:AR>PÓ<=A�? ÓSE7OC>P<=Ù7?+>�O=?'A�EBA�O�á Ó#Û­ÕBÙB6:8:FB69EBÒdO�Û�ÓS<iA'îBD#QR;B8:ASá�Dg? èdÙB6:<PA|F´Û�<=ÓSQQRDSEXÚ�FJ6uOP;7D#<@D_>=A Ï 69A�K�O�ð OCÙ7?@5IDSO�DiOCA >tÓ#Û�;75BÓ#>=ÓSÒS<@D#;757O�ð DSE7F°DS8:OPÓiFJA >PA <=QR69E7A�>P57AÏ 6:A K�;NÓS6:Ed>�Ó#Û$A�Dg?@5 69QÔD#ÒgASæBç­5BA�<PA/5GD Ï A/ÕNA A EDREXÙBQ!ÕGA�<.Ó#Û�<=A�?'A�Ed>�;B5BÓ#>=ÓSÒg<=DSQ�QRA >P<=ÚD#;B;B8:6u? D_>=69ÓgE7OtK�5BA <=A)OPÙ7?@5°K�6uFJA�Õ7DSOPA 8:69E7A.QÔD_>@?@5B69E7Òi6uO�<=A�èdÙB6:<PA|F´Þ âBá=ßgßJáCß��|ã�ædç­5BA|OCA�D#;Bï;B896u? D#>P6:ÓSE7O�DS<PA�ÒgA EBA�<=DS898:Ú°D#6:QRA�F D_>�<=A�?'ÓgE7OC>P<=Ù7?+>=69ÓgE°Û�<=ÓSQ Q!ÙB89>P6:;B89A Ï 6:A K�O�áJK�5BA <=A�>P57AÕ7DSOPA 8:69E7A)6uO�8uD#<=ÒSA.>PÓ�69QR;B<=Ó Ï A.>P5BA�DS?�?'ÙB<@DS? Ú!ÓSÛr<=A�?'ÓgE7OC>P<=Ù7?+>=69ÓgE°ÓS<­D!OPQÔD#8:8GEXÙBQ!ÕGA�<­Ó#ÛÏ 6:A K�O�6uO­Ù7OPA�Fº>PÓR?'Ó Ï A�<�DS898 DgOC;NA�?'>=O­Ó#Ûr>P5BA�ÓSÕ��]A�?+>|æ��tÙB<=<PA�Eg>=89ÚR>=5BA�OPA�D#;B;B8:6u? D_>=69ÓgE7O­D#<=AÓSEB8:ÚI;GD#<P>P8:Ú¸DSÙJ>PÓgQRD#>PA|F áGDSE7F<=A�èdÙB6:<PA�OPÓSQRA�Óg<)D#8:8ª? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSEGFJA E7? A�O�>=ÓºÕNA!OPÙB;B;B8:69A|FÕdÚi57D#E7F�æ_é[E�? ÓSEd>P<@DSOC>�á�>P5BA�DS89ÒgÓS<=6«>=5BQÔOªÓSÛ7>=5B6:O�;GD#;NA <�A E7DSÕB8:A­DSÙJ>PÓgQÔD_>P6u?�?'ÓSQR;BÙB>=D_>=69ÓgEÓ#Û�? DSQ�A�<=DgO/D#E7FÑàÂ;NÓS6:Eg>�D#E7FÐ8:69EBAIO]>=<PÙ7?'>PÙB<=AÔÓ Ï A�<�DOCA >iÓ#Û­K�6uFJA°Õ7DgOCA�896:EBA Ï 69A�K�O æç­5B6:O�6:O�FJA�QRÓSE7OC>P<@D_>=A�FI69EOPA�?+>=69ÓgE åBæ

� �� rÌ����)Í]ÇBË�����ÇBÍ]ÉtÆÂÉ��ºÇ��� Ç��ÐÉ���Í� ���Ì�� �

!�"$# %'&�(*)$+-,/.103254768&�)*) 9�&�4:.;)*(*<=.1&�)$>�0�,/(@?7A=6

ç­5BA$ì7<@O]>rOC>PA�;/Ó#ÛJD#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQÔO OPÙ7?@5�DSO�Þ ßSàBáPßgåJáCß#â#ãS6uO >PÓ�A|O]>@D#ÕB8:6uOC5/D�OPA'>�ÓSÛX6:Ed>PA�<PA|O]>�;NÓS6:Ed>?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'A�O�Dg?'<=ÓgO=O Ï 6:A K�O�æ é�>i6uO/EBÓS>�EBA�? A�O=OPDS<PÚ>=57D_>iDS898�Ó#Û­>P5BA|OCA°? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSEGFXïA E7? A�O�DS<PAÔ?'Óg<P<=A�?'>�á OP69E7? AÔ<PÓgÕBÙ7OC>/A�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:ÓSEÑ6uO/Ù7OPA�F á�Õ7ÙJ>!D OC6:ÒSE76«ìG?�D#Ed>/;B<=ÓS;NÓS<P>P6:ÓSEQiÙ7OC>�ÕNASæCBtO]>@D#ÕB8:6uOC5B6:EBÒ.>P5BA|OCA­?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|O <PA|O]>@O�ÓSE/>]K�Ó�DgOPOPÙBQR;J>=69ÓgE7O ÷�ì7<@O]>|á|>P57D#>>P5BA/6:Ed>PA EGOC69>]Ú°Ó#Û�D'E;F�G/HJILKNM:FPOCQ3GSRCTLK*FUQ�VJOCV$K*RCQÔ69QÔDSÒSA�EBA 6:ÒS5XÕNÓSÙB<=5BÓXÓJFBO­D#<=ÓSÙBEGF°6:QRDSÒSA|OÓ#Û�D¸àþ;NÓS6:Eg>iDS<PAÔOP69QR6:8:DS<�æ'�t<=ÓgO=OCï�? ÓS<=<PA�8:D#>P6:ÓSE ÓSEÐ>P57A�OPAÔ69Ed>PA�E7OP6«>]Ú´E7A 6:ÒS5XÕGÓgÙB<=5BÓXÓXF7O>P5BA�E¸;7<PÓ Ï 6uFJA�O�D#E D/WÔEB69>]Ú°QRA�DgOCÙB<=A)>PÓÔFJ6uOPDSQiÕB6:ÒSÙ7D#>PA�69QÔDSÒSA�;GÓg69Ed>�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|OÕGA >]KtA�A E Ï 69A�K�O ä�OPA�? ÓSE7F á±>=57D_>i>P5BAÔ6:QÔD#ÒSAR;NÓS6:Ed>�Q�ÓS>P6:ÓSEÐ6:O�896:QR6«>=A�FÑÕNA'>]K�A A E Ï 69A�K�O æç­5B6:O�8:D#>C>PA�<iDSO=OPÙBQR;J>P6:ÓSEÑA EGD#ÕB8:A�O�D¸<=A�OC>P<=6:?'>PA|FÐOPA�DS<=?@5Ð<=A ÒS6:ÓSEÖ>PÓÕNA°FJA ì7EBA�F�árK�5B6u?@569EI>PÙB<=E¸896:QR6«>@O�>P5BA�EXÙBQiÕNA <­ÓSÛr;GÓS>PA�Eg>=6:DS8 QÔD_>=?@57A�O�áXDSE7FÔ>=5XÙ7O­89A|OPOPA EGO�>=5BA�<PA�896uD#EG?'A.ÓgE>P5BA�FJ6uO=D#QiÕ769ÒgÙ7D_>=69EBÒ�;NÓ_KtA�<�Ó#Ûr>=5BA�D/WÔEB69>]ÚºQRA|DSOPÙB<PAgæ

XtÓS>P5ÑÓ#Û­>=5BA�OPA°DSO=OCÙ7Q�;B>P6:ÓSE7O�DS<PA Ï 6:ÓS8uD_>=A�FÐK�5BA EÑ>=5BA <=AÔ6uO�OC6:ÒSE76«ìG?�D#Ed>i?@57DSEBÒSAÔ6:EA 69>P5BA�<R>P5BA 6:Eg>=A <=E7D#8�?�D#QRA <@Dý;GD#<@D#QRA'>=A <@OiÓg<RDÑOP69ÒgEB69ìG? DSEg>RQRÓ#>=69ÓgEÝÕNA'>]K�A A E Ï 69A�K�O æ�tÓSE7OP6:FBA <iD?�D#QRA <@D QRÓ#>P6:ÓSEë? ÓSE7OP6uO]>=69EBÒÓSÛ�D¸>P<@D#E7OP8:D#>P6:ÓSEÑ;7DS<=DS898:A 8$>=Ó >P5BAI69QÔDSÒSAZYBïD_îJ6:O�áGÛ�ÓS8:89Ó_K�A�FÕXÚDS[gù\�<PÓS>=D_>=69ÓgE´?'8:ÓJ?@ídK�6uOPA!D#ÕNÓSÙB>.>P57A�?�D#QRA <@D°;B<=6:E7?'6:;7D#8�D_îJ6uO!û¿6pæ ASæDÔ<PÓS>=D#>P6:ÓSEK�69>P5ýD#îX6uO�;NA <=;NA E7FJ6u?'Ù78:DS<.>=ÓÔ>P5BA�6:QRDSÒSA�;78:DSEBA|ü'æ��t<=ÓgO=O]ï[?'Óg<P<=A 8uD_>=69ÓgEºÓSÛ$DSE

ß

Page 3: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

69Ed>PA�E7OP6«>]ÚÖEBA 6:ÒS5XÕNÓSÙB<=5BÓXÓJFýK�6:898�Û¿D#6:8.û�ÕNA�?�D#Ù7OPAÔÓ#Û�>P57A°<PÓS>=D#>P6:ÓSEGü�D#EGFý>=5BA°;NÓgOP6«>=69ÓgEÑÓ#ÛD#EÔ6:QRDSÒSA|F!;NÓS6:Ed>t? DSERQ�Ó Ï A�A Ed>P6:<=A 8:Ú�Dg?'<=ÓgO=Or>=5BA.6:QÔD#ÒgASá#Agæ ÒGæSHØ;NÓS6:Ed>�ÓSE�>P57A.8:A'Û½>tOP6:FBAÓ#Û�>P5BA/6:QÔD#ÒSA�K�6:898�QRÓ Ï A)>=Ó�>P5BA�>=ÓS;�æ

!�"]! ^_(*.�`bac0�($<�?d($<�e�&�,/(*&�<�?f&�gh<=(@?�ij6h.;&�47+',/.XtÓS>P5ÔÓSÛN>=5BA�OPA�;B<=ÓSÕ789A�QRO�D#<=A�?'ÓS<=<=A�?+>=A�F!ÕXÚ!Ù7OP6:EBÒiD�5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚºûpD/;B8uD#EBA�;7<PÓ��]A�?+>=6 Ï A>P<@D#E7OCÛ�ÓS<=QÔD_>P6:ÓSENüG>PÓ.QÔDS;�ÕGA >]KtA�A E�>=5BAt6:QÔD#ÒgA�O�æ:�tÓSEd>P6:EXÙB6:EBÒ.K�69>P5/>=5BAtDSÕGÓ Ï A$A'îBD#QR;B8:ASáD�5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚ�K�576:?@5�;7<PÓ Ï 6uFJA�OªD�[Sù�\�<=Ó#>=D#>P6:ÓSE/K�6:898d<=A'>PÙ7<PE/>=5BAtOP69>PÙ7D#>P6:ÓSE/>=Ó�>P57AtOPQRDS898Õ7DSOPA 8:69E7A­? ÓSE7FB6«>=69ÓgE7O æ#H»? ÓS<=<PA|?+>P6:ÓSE!Ó#ÛG>P5B6uO�>]ÚX;GA�6uO�Õ7DgOCA|FiÓgEB89ÚiÓSE!>P5BA�? DSQRA <@D.QRÓ#>=69ÓgED#E7F 6uO.OP69QR6:8:DS<�>=Óº?'8uDSO=OC6u? DS8�<=A�?+>=6«ìN? D_>=69ÓgE K�5BA <=A�6:QRDSÒSA|O�D#<=A�;B<=ÓC�]A|?+>P6 Ï A�89ÚIK�DS<P;NA�FI>=ÓD#8:69ÒgER>P5BA)A ;B6:;GÓg8:DS<�8:69EBA|O�K�69>P5I?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJ6:EBÒ/OP?�D#EJï�896:EBA|O ædç­5B6:O�K�698:8NÕGA)<PA Û�A <=<PA|Fi>=Ó!DgOA QR;B8:Ó_Úd6:EBÒÔDZkClmR�n�O/lJ5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75dÚgæ

ê�Ó_K�A Ï A�<�áNÒS8:ÓSÕGD#8�5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5B6:A�O)K�6:898$EBÓS>�D#8:K�DmÚJO)ÕGA°OPÙ�W°?'6:A Ed>�OC6:E7? A�69Û�>=5BA <=AR6:ODÔOC6:ÒSEB69ìG?�D#Ed>.?@57D#E7ÒSA/6:E;GA�<=OP;GA|?+>=6 Ï A/AUo±A�?+>@O�ÕNA'>]K�A A�E¸6:QÔD#ÒgA�O�áJ>P5BA!?'ÓS<=<=A�?+>�QÔD#;7;B69E7Ò6:O�D!5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚ�69E7FBÙ7?'A|FºÕXÚR>P57A)>@D#EBÒgA Ed>­;B8:DSEBA�Ó#Û�>=5BA/OCÙ7<CÛ¿Dg?'A�D_>­>P5BA/à ;NÓS6:Ed>�Ó#Û69Ed>PA�<PA|O]>|æJç­5B6:O­6uO�D�OP? A EBA�FJA ;NA EGFJA Ed>�5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚSáXD#EGFºOPA Ï A�<=DS8'lmR7p�O/lX5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75B69A|OQRDmÚºKtA�898 ÕNA/<PA|èdÙB69<=A�FºÛ�ÓS<�D�;7DS<C>=6:? ÙB8uD#<­;7D#6:<�Ó#Û�6:QRDSÒSA|O æ

ç­5dÙGO á7>P5BA�OCQÔD#8:8�Õ7DSOPA 8:69E7AiD#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQÁ6uO)DSÙBÒSQRA Ed>=A�F K�69>P5ýDº5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚ°K�5B6u?@56:O�ÙGOCA|F°Û�Óg<­>]KtÓ�Û�ÙBE7?'>P6:ÓSE7O

öSæ�ç­5BAR5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚ¸;B<PÓ Ï 6uFJA�O.>P57A�QÔDS;ýÕNA'>]K�A A EÐ6:Eg>=A <=A�OC>�;NÓS6:Ed>�E7A 6:ÒS5XÕGÓgÙB<=5BÓXÓXF7OÛ�ÓS<­>=5BA�?'<=ÓgO=O]ï[?'Óg<P<=A 8uD_>=69ÓgE°D/WÔEB69>]Ú°QRA�DgOCÙB<=ASæ

ßJæ�ç­5BA­5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚ�6:O�D#8uOPÓ.Ù7OPA�Fi>PÓ)>P<@D#E7OCÛ�A <�>=5BAt;NÓS6:Ed>�Û�<PÓgQ¶ÓSEBA�69QÔDSÒSAt>PÓ�D#EBÓS>P5BA�<69EÔÓg<=FBA <$>=Ó�FJA'ì7E7A�>P5BA)?'A Ed>=<PA�ÓSÛN>=5BA.OPA�DS<=?@5�<PA�ÒS6:ÓSE�ægHØOC6:QR698uD#<�6:FJA|D�6:O�Ù7OPA�F�69E´Þ ÿ#ãÛ�ÓS<­>=5BA�? DgOCA�Ó#Û$FJA�E7OCA/OC>PA�<PA�Ó�QÔD#>=?@5B6:EBÒ7æ

qBÓS<iÕGÓS>P5ÑÛ�ÙBE7?'>P6:ÓSE7O�>P5BAº5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚ´EBA�A�FÐÓSEB8:ÚÑD#;B;B<=ÓmîJ69QÔD#>PA�>P5BAº;GÓg69Ed>Cï©>PÓSï©;NÓS6:Ed>QRDS; ÕGA >]KtA�A E¸>P5BAi69QÔD#ÒgA�Otð K�A�D#<=A�ÓSEB8:ÚIOPA A�íX69EBÒ�>=ÓÔ69QR;B<=Ó Ï A�>P57A�FJ6:O=D#Q!ÕB6:ÒSÙ7D#>P6:ÓSE;GÓ_K�A <­Ó#Û$?'<=ÓgO=OCï�? ÓS<=<PA�8:D#>P6:ÓSE°D#EGFº<=A�OC>P<=6:?'>­>P5BA�OPA�DS<=?@5I<PA�ÒS6:ÓSE�æ

ç­5BAt;7<PÓgÕB89A�Q¶Ó#ÛNK�6:FJA­Õ7DgOCA�896:EBA­O]>=A <=A Ó)QRD#>=?@5B6:EBÒ�6:O�>=5XÙ7O�<PA|FJÙ7? A�F/>=Ó)57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚA�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:ÓSEÖÛ�ÓS8:89Ó_K�A�FÖÕXÚýOPQRDS898�Õ7DSOPA 8:69E7A�QÔD#>=?@5B6:EBÒ7æ�HþOP6:EBÒS8:Aû�ÒS8:ÓSÕGD#8½ü.57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚQRDmÚIOCÙ�W°? ASáBÓg<­DROPA'>�ÓSÛ�8:ÓJ? D#8 57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�OtQRDmÚºÕGA/<=A�èdÙB6:<PA|F æ

!�"sr tu(*v=._9=&w47.;)*($<'.147?7.�,/.;0x6h&�?7yzA=(*<=>x&�)*>30w,/(*?7A=6ç­5BA�D#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQÂ? ÓSE7OP6uO]>@O­Ó#Û�àRQÔDS69E O]>=A ;7O�÷

öSæ|{ +'?7036h&�?:(*y�&w)*)@i}>�.;<=.,/&�?:.~&���4:.?b0325)*0�y&�)���a�)*&�<=&�,�A=036h0�>�,/&�a�A'($.�4"HúÒS8:ÓSÕ7DS8ª5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75dÚ¸QÔDmÚ ÕGAÔ?'ÓgQR;BÙJ>PA|F´ÕXÚ´OC>=D#EGFBD#<@F;XÚX<=DSQ�6uFýOPA�DS<=?@5 >=A�?@5JïEB6uègÙ7A�O�Þ9öSá�[#ã©æ Î Û½>=A EDÔOP69QR6:8:DS<P69>]ÚR>P<@D#E7OCÛ�ÓS<=QÔD_>=69ÓgEIOPÙ�W°?'A�O�æ��ÓJ? DS8iû¿O=?'A�EBA'ï[FJA�;GA�E7FJA Ed>+üÔ5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5769A|O!QÔDmÚ¼ÕGAÖ?'ÓSQR;BÙB>PA�F»ÙGOC6:EBÒëQÔD_>@?@5B6:EBÒ>PA|?@5BEB6uègÙ7A�OROC6:QR698:6uD#<�>PÓÐ>P57ÓgOPAIÙ7OPA�FÝ69E¼QRÓJFJA 89ï©ÕGDSOPA�Fë<=A�? ÓSÒgEB6«>=69ÓgE Þ9ö ÿ#ã�æ qBÓg<�A îXïD#QR;B8:ASáªÙ7OC6:EBÒ Û�A|D_>PÙ7<PA ïpÛ�ÓJ?'ÙGO°Þ à#ã�>PÓ6uFJA�Eg>=6«Û�ÚÑD#EGFÑQRD#>=?@5ÜFJ6uO]>=69EG?+>P6 Ï Aº69QÔD#ÒgA�Û�A�D_ï>PÙB<=A�O�æ|é[EIÞ9ö�à_ãdÛ�ÓSÙ7<Cï�896:EBAtÒS<=ÓSÙB;B6:EBÒdO�D#<=A�QÔD_>@?@5BA�F�ÕGA >]KtA�A E�6:QÔD#ÒSA|O æmê�ÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75B69A|OD#<=A�>P5BA�E ? ÓSQR;BÙJ>=A�FIÛ�<=ÓSQþ>=5BA�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJ6:EBÒ�896:EBA�O�æ

à

Page 4: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

ßJæ %-0�,�.;&�yzA�A=036h0�>�,/&�a�A�i�>�.;<=.,/&�?:.�&�4:.�?}032_($<�?7.�,/.;4�?}ac0�($<�?}6h&�?7yzA'.;4"é[Ed>PA <=A�OC>I;NÓS6:Ed>IQÔD_>@?@5BA�OID#<=Aý?'ÓgE7OP6:OC>PA�Eg>IK�6«>=5Ø>P57Aý5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚë69ÛiÕNÓ#>=5ô>P5BA�69<;GÓdOC69>P6:ÓSEÐD#E7Fý69Ed>=A E7OP6«>]Ú EBA�69Òg5XÕGÓgÙB<P57ÓdÓJF´DS<PA�OC6:QR698uD#<�D_Û½>=A <�QÔD#;B;769EBÒ¸ÕXÚ¸>P5BAR5BÓSïQRÓSÒS<@D#;75dÚgæ

àBæ|� 47?7($6h&�?:.b?7A=.f2J+'<=v'&w6h.;<�?7&�)�6h&�?7,/(@��&w<'vhy0�<=4:(*47?7.;<�?�y�0�,:,/.;47ac0�<=v=.�<=y�.;4"� A'>@O/Ó#Û�QÔD_>=?@57A�O/D#<=A�ÒSA E7A <@D_>PA|FÛ�<=ÓSQ A|DS?@5Ð89ÓJ?�D#8$5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚD#EGF´>=5BA EÜ?'ÓgQ�ïÕB6:EBA�F æ�ç­5BA Û�ÙBE7F7D#QRA Ed>=DS8.QÔD_>=<P69î á �±á�D#E7F»? ÓSE7OP6:OC>PA�Ed>°QRD#>=?@5BA|O°D#<=A A�OC>P6:QÔD_>PA|FÙ7OP69EBÒi>P5BA���H�� � H��MÞ � ãN<=ÓSÕBÙGO]>�A�OC>P6:QRD#>PÓg<t6:E°>=5BA)QÔDSEBEBA <�Ó#Û >=5BA�OCQÔD#8:8±Õ7DSOPA 8:6:EBAD#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQÔO!Þ ß#ÿ#ã�û½>P57A���H�� � H��¶OPDSQ�;789A�?'ÓSEGOC6uO]>@O�ÓSÛ��Ô? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSE7FBA E7? A�O�6:E´>=5B6:O? DgOCAmü+æBHÀQÔD_îJ69Q!ÙBQÂ8:69ígA 8:6957ÓdÓJFIA�OC>P6:QÔD_>PA�ÓSÛ'�°D#EGF°>=5BA�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|O�6uOt>P5BA�EÓSÕJ>@D#6:EBA�F Ï 6:DÔD�<=ÓSÕBÙGO]>�EBÓgEJï©8:6:EBA�DS<�QR6:EB6:Q�6m��D#>P6:ÓSE�æ

qBÙB<P>P5BA�<�FJA'>@D#6:8:O.D#<=A)Òg6 Ï A E¸69EÜÞ9ö�à_ã�æ

� �_�­Ç� rÆ��XÍ]ÉtÆ ÇJÉ Ç���È� � ���Í� ��j������È7Í��@É�Ì�� ��Ç� rÆ��dÉ�È} '�SÇBÍ¡ ���ÇBÍ]ÉtÆ

ç­5BAOCQÔD#8:8­Õ7DSOPA 8:6:EBAº>=<P69Û�ÓJ? DS8�A�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:ÓSE¼D#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQ Þ¢�XáPßgåmã�6uORA'îX>PA�E7FJA�FÝ>PÓÜDÖK�6:FBAÕ7DSOPA 8:69E7A/69EDÔOP69QR6:8:DS<�QÔD#EBEBA�<�>PÓR>=5BA/;B<=A Ï 6:ÓSÙ7O�OPA�?'>P6:ÓSE�æG4�ÓS6:Eg>�? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSE7FBA E7? A�O­D#<=A5BA <=A�<=A�èdÙB6:<PA|F/Ó Ï A�<�>=5B<PA�A Ï 6:A K�O�á|DSE7F�DSÒgD#6:E�5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75B69A|O�A�E7D#ÕB8:A�>=5BA­OCQÔD#8:8XÕ7DSOPA 8:6:EBAD#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQÔOt>PÓÔÕNA/Ù7OPA�F æ

ç­5BA)DS89ÒgÓS<=6«>=5BQ Û�Óg<�OP6:QiÙB89>=DSEBA ÓgÙ7OC8:ÚRA�OC>P6:QÔD_>P6:EBÒi>P5BA)>P<=6«Û�ÓJ?�D#8G>PA EGOCÓg<�á;£ÔáXD#E7FI?'ÓSEBïOC6uO]>=A Ed>.à_ï Ï 69A�KØ;NÓS6:Eg>.? ÓS<=<PA|OC;NÓSEGFJA E7? A�Ot57DSO�>P5BA�Û�ÓS8:8:Ó_K�69EBÒÔOC>PA�;7O ÷öSæ�¤ .;<'.�,/&�?7.PA'036h03>w,/&�a�A'($.;4�¥ �tÓSQR;BÙJ>=A�D�ûpOCA >rÓ#Û=ü�5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5B6:A�O±ÕNA'>]K�A A�E Ï 6:A K�O

ö�¦úßBáBD#E7F ß�¦ à�Ù7OP69E7Ò!>=5BA/QRA'>=5BÓJFBO�Ó#Û$OPA�?+>=69ÓgE ßBæ à7æßJæ !§e�($.�`¨y0w,z,/.;4�a©0�<=v'.;<=y�.;4¥ �tÓSQR;BÙJ>=Aº6:Eg>=A <=A�OC>i;NÓS6:Eg>R?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|O°û¿DSE7F

>P5BAºÛ�ÙBE7FBDSQRA Ed>=DS8tQÔD_>=<P69î7ü�ÕNA'>]K�A A E Ï 6:A K�Oºö�¦�ßJá�D#E7Fµß1¦ à´Ù7OP69E7Ò>P5BAIK�6:FBAÕ7DSOPA 8:6:EBA¸OC>PA�<PA�ÓÐDS89ÒgÓS<=6«>=5BQ æ=BtDS?@5¼?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'Aº5GDSORD#E¼DSO=OCÓJ?'6uD_>=69ÓgEëK�69>P5»D5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚSæ

àBæ|ª +-?:&�?7(*e�.�?7A',/.�.~e�(*.�`«y0w,z,/.;4�ac03<=v'.;<=y�.;4�¥ �tÓgQ�;7ÙJ>PA�DÔOPA'>.ÓSÛ�6:Ed>PA�<PA|O]>�;NÓS6:Ed>?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|O)Ó Ï A <�>P57<PA�A Ï 6:A K�O�ÕXÚf�]Óg69E769EBÒ¸>=5BAºßmï Ï 69A�K QÔD_>@?@5ÑOPA'>@O ÷�à#ï Ï 6:A KQÔD_>=?@57A�O�D#<=A�Û�ÓS<=QRA�FRÛ�<=ÓSQ >P5BÓdOCA�ßmï Ï 69A�K¼QÔD#>=?@5BA|FÔ;GÓg69Ed>@O�>=57D_>�OC5GD#<=A.Di? ÓSQRQRÓSE;GÓg69Ed>�6:E ÓSEBA�Ó#Û�>P57A/69QÔD#ÒgA�O�æ

ÿ7æ|¬S{�­¯®�{f° ,/0w9�+=4�?1.;4�?:(*6h&�?7(*03<©¥ Ó#Û©£3Õ7DSOPA�FýÓSEÐOPDSQ�;789A|O)ÓSÛ � ;GÓg69Ed>/?'Óg<P<=A�OCï;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|O æ

åJæ|± &���($6�+=6³²©(@´3.�)$(*A=0�0�v � 4�?:(*6h&�?7(*03<�� ± ² � �/¥ ÕXÚ¸Q�6:EB6:QR6N��69EBÒI<PA�;B<=ÓC�]A�?'>P6:ÓSEA <=<PÓg<�áJ<=A'ï�A�OC>P6:QÔD_>=AP£ÔáGDSE7F ;NA <PÛ�A�?+>=89Ú ?'ÓgE7OP6:OC>PA�Eg>�?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'A�O�áXÛ�<=ÓSQ D#8:8�>P57AQRA�DSOPÙB<=A�F¸?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|Ot? 8:DgOPOP6«ìGA�F¸DSO­6:EB896:A <@O�æ

� æ�¤ +'($v'.;vj6h&�?:y:A=(*<=>'¥ q7ÙB<C>=5BA <­6:Ed>PA <=A�OC>�;GÓg69Ed>�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|O�DS<PA�FJA'>=A <=QR69EBA|FÙ7OP69EBÒ´>P5BAIA�OC>P6:QRD#>PA|Fµ£°æª4�ÙJ>=D#>P6 Ï AÔ>]K�Ó Ï 69A�K QRD#>=?@5BA|OiDS<PA°ÓgÕJ>=DS69E7A�FÐÛ�ÓS< Ï 6:A K�Oö�¦3ßJá D#E7F´>P5BA�E Ï A <=6«ìGA�F´ÙGOC6:EBÒ Ï 6:A K àBæ�¶$A <=6«ìN? D_>=69ÓgEý6:E Ï ÓS8 Ï A|O�>]K�Óº>=A�OC>=O�÷Nì7<=OC>�á>P5BA�<PA­6uO$D�>=5B<=A�OP5BÓS8uFiÓgEi>=5BA­69QÔDSÒSA­FJ6:OC>=DSE7?'A­ÕNA'>]K�A A�Ei>=5BA­Q�A|DSOPÙB<=A�F�;NÓS6:Ed>$69E�>P57A>P5B6:<@F Ï 69A�K/ádDSE7FR>P57A);NÓS6:Ed>�>P<@D#EGO]Û�A�<P<=A�F�ÕXÚZ£¶Û�<=ÓSQú6«>@O�>]K�Ó Ï 6:A KôQÔD_>@?@5�ädOPA�? ÓSE7F�á>P5BA�<PA.6:O�D�>=5B<=A�OP5BÓS8uFRÓSE�>P57A.D/WÔEB69>]ÚiQRA�DgOCÙ7<PA�? ÓSQR;BÙJ>=A�FRÙ7OP69E7Ò�>P5BA�57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚDSO=OCÓJ? 6:D#>PA�FºK�6«>=5 >P5BA�>]K�Ó#ï Ï 69A�KØQÔD_>@?@5�æ

ç­5BA�8uDSOC>�>P5B<=A AtO]>=A ;7Oª? D#E/ÕNA�69>PA�<=D#>PA|F�ÙBEd>P6:8#>P57A�EXÙBQiÕNA <ªÓ#ÛB?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|O±6:OªO]>@D#ÕB8:ASæ

ÿ

Page 5: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

¶Mù ¶þö ¶ ß ¶Mà

¶¶ÿ ¶ å ¶ � ¶��

¶Mâ ¶·[ ¶þö�ù ¶þögö

¶þö|ß ¶úö|à ¶þö�ÿ

%|($>-"C#3"�¸ O/lmn¹RCQwQ�F�K]ºZO�k�FLI�»

å

Page 6: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

r�"$# ¬ .�4:+=)@?74

çª<=69;B8:A'> ¼gÓS6:EBA�F¸4$D#6:< é[EB8:69A�<=O £¾½�ÙB6uFJA|F é[EB896:A <@O ¿´D#>=?@5BA|O�D_Û½>=A <¿ýD_>=?@57A�O >=Óf£ ¿´D#>=?@5BA|O >=Óf£ é�>=A <@D_>P6:ÓSE

à�ÿºå �Jö � ù �Xö � ÿ ö|ùgßÿ°å � [Sÿ [Sù âgå �#ß ö|ù�[å � � [gâ [gß ö�ùgß âBö ö|à#ÿ� ��â ÿ � ÿdß ÿgâ à�[ â#ÿ�!âZ[ �#ù å � � ß ÿgâ å�âZ[¸ö�ù ö�ù[ �#å �#ß ÿgà �#ß[¸ö�ù¸öSö ö|ßSù ö�ù � öSö�ù â � ö|à��ö�ù¸öSö�ö|ß ö�â[ öz�Sß ö � [ ö ÿSÿ ö|âgåöSöRö|ߺö�à ß#ù;� ö�â;� ö�âgå ö|å#ù ßBö7[ö|ßIö�àIö ÿ ö7[7ö ö � ÿ ö � å ö�àgå ßSù�[

À &�9�)*.j#3"�Á� T¹F¹F�Ã:K*F�ÄźZO/VÆp  K]Q�k�ÇUR/T�V$TLK È�lNFUV$I©Ç�T¡RCºÉV  F ¸ OClNn�R/QwQ�FdI�FUV�Ê�I�F�F�D'k�Ë�T¡FLIdÌH�Í�ÎC» Á� FfÏ�R/K]Q�F¹G_Ð|O/K]T�ѯO/VÆp  FUIfOCT¡FZV  FfºbOCVJp  FUI|ÇUR/TLºZF¹G�nUÒÓVÆO7ÔCK]Q�kbÈ�RCK]QwV$I�K]QhV  FIUF�p�R/Q�GÕK]ºbO7kF¯Ä  K*p Âh O/Ã/F�n�F�FUQ�ÈwO/K]T¡F�GxÄ K]V  ºZO/VÆp  FLIÓK]QÖn�R/V  V  F�DcT�I�VPOCQ3GÕV  K]T¡GK]ºbO7kFUI�»;×�QZFUI�V�K]ºZO/VÆF|R�Ç=£�KsI©V  FUQfp�R/º�È3Ë�VÆF�G�Ë;ILK]Q;k|Ø�×5Ù�Ú�×dÛ=ÜwV  F�Q�Ë�ºbn�F�T©R�Ç©K]QwlÝK*F�T�IVJR~V  KsI�I�RClÝË�V$K*RCQjOCT¡Fdk�K]Ã/FUQ�» Á� F�£ßÞ�Ë�K*G�F�GÓѯOCVJp  FUI�O/T¡F�ÇUR/Ë�Q�G~Ë;ILK]Q;k1V  FSºbF�V  R7GG�FUIUp�TLK*n�F�GxK]Q�I�F¹p�V�K*R/Q§à» Á� F_ѯOCVJp  FUI1O�Ç�VJF�TZáLVÆFUT¡OCV$K*RCQ�O/T¡F�ÇURCË�Q3Gµn�Ò�K]VÆF�T¡O/V�K]Q�kxV  FkCË�K*GF¹GSºZO/VÆp  K]Q�k_O/Q3GST¡F�H�FLILV�K]ºbOCV$K*RCQÕR�Ç|£S»=Ú�F�FdG/KsI�pUË;I�ILK*R/QÕK]Q~I�F�p�V$K*RCQ�à»]Ì»

çªDSÕB89A.ötOP5BÓ_K�O±>P57A�EXÙBQiÕNA <�Ó#Û7? ÓS<=EBA <ª?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'A�O Û�ÓS< Ï DS<P6:ÓSÙ7O�>P<=69;789A >=OªÓ#ÛJ>P57A¶�D#8:ÕGÓgEBEBA�69QÔD#ÒgAiOPA'>Ôû¿OP5BÓ_K�E´6:Eì7ÒSÙ7<PAIö|ü+æ çtÚX;B6:?�D#8ªA'îBD#QR;B8:A�O)Ó#Û�¶�DS89ÕNÓSEBE7Ai>=<P6:;B8:A'>=OD#<=A�ÒS6 Ï A�E¸6:Eì7ÒgÙB<=A!ßJæ3qBÙB<P>P5BA�<.A îJDSQR;B89A|O�ÓSÛ�D#ÙJ>=ÓSQÔD_>=6:?�D#8:89ÚIA�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:EBÒÔ>=5BA�>=<P69Û�ÓJ? D#8>PA EGOCÓg<�D#E7F¸?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|O�DS<PA�OP5BÓ_K�EºÛ�Óg<�FJ6NoNA�<PA�Eg>.O=?'A�EBA�O­6:E¸ì7ÒSÙ7<PA|O�àdâ°ÿGæ

óÖAÖì7<@O]>´FJA|OP? <P6:ÕGAÐQÔD_>@?@5B69E7Ò¼DÝ>P<=69;789A >¸Û�<=ÓSQ >=5BAx¶�D#8:ÕGÓgEBEBAÜOPA'>Üû½ì7ÒgÙB<PA¼ö|üI6:EÒS<=A�D_>=A�FIFJA ;J>=5´D#E7Fº>P57A EFJ6uOP? Ù7OPO�>=5BA/<=A�OPÙB8«>@O�Û�ÓS<­>=5BA/A Ed>P6:<=A�OCA >­ÓSÛª>=<P6:;B8:A'>@O æ

À ,/(@a�)*.�?�^¯#3#Cã�^¯#�r é[E´Óg<=FBA <�>=ÓI? 8:DS<P69Û�Ú¸>P5BA!<PA|OCÙB89>=O)Ó#Û�ç�D#Õ789AIöSáNKtA!A'îBD#QR6:EBAiA|DS?@5O]>@D#ÒSA�ÓSÛª>=5BA/QÔD_>=?@5769EBÒR;B<=ÓJ?'A|OPO�Û�Óg<­>P5BA�>=<P6:;B8:A'>5¶iögö�¶iömß!DSE7F�¶iö�àû�>P5BA�ìG<=OC>�>P<=69;789A >Ó#Û�ì7ÒSÙB<=A/ßSü+æ

ã ç­5BAê.DS<P<=6:OR? ÓS<=EBA <RFJA'>=A�?'>PÓS<Þ9ö�ù#ã­6uORÙ7OPA�FÝ>PÓÖì7E7F�[��#ùBá�[��#ùBá$D#E7F}[�� � ? ÓS<=EBA <@O<PA|OC;NA�?'>P6 Ï A�89Ú°6:E¸>P5BA�>=5B<=A A�69QÔDSÒSA�O�æ

ã ½�89ÓgÕ7D#8BOP6:Q�6:8uD#<=6«>]Ú�>=<=DSE7O]Û�Óg<PQÔD#>P6:ÓSE7Or>P57D#>�D#;B;B<=ÓmîJ69QÔD#>PA 8:Ú�<PA�ÒS6uO]>=A <�>P57A�6:QÔD#ÒgA�O�D#<=A?'ÓgQ�;7ÙJ>PA|FIÕNA'>]K�A A�E ;7D#6:<=Oä¶!öSö�¦·¶!ö|ßJáBDSE7F_¶iömßd¦�¶iö|àBæ

ã ç­5BA�K�6uFJA ÕGDSOPA 8:69EBA)O]>=A <=A Ó/QÔD_>@?@5B69E7ÒiD#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQ K�6«>=5°ÒS8:ÓSÕGD#8B5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75B69A|O�ÒS6 Ï A|Oà��Sß°?'Óg<PE7A <.QÔD#>=?@5BA|O.ÕNA'>]K�A A�E¯¶iögöd¦¾¶!ö|ßBáNDSE7Fýà � ßRQÔD_>@?@5BA�O)ÕNA'>]K�A A E�¶iömßf¦¶iö|àBæ

ã ç­5BA��]ÓS6:E Ó#Ûª>P5BA/;7DS69<�QÔD#>=?@5BA|O­ÒS6 Ï A�O�ßSù���>P<=69;789A >�QRD#>=?@5BA|O æ

Page 7: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

¶þöSö ¶úömß ¶þö|à

¶�� ¶Mâ ¶å[

%|(*>'"z!�"f^�&�)@9c03<=<'. À ,/(@a�)*.�?74 » Á� F�V�TLK ÇUR7p�OCl�VÆFUQwI�R/T§KsI�FUI�V�K]ºZO/VÆF¹G·Ë;ILK]Q�kæp�R/TLQ3F�TºbOCVJp  FUI�O/Q�GÓO�k�lNRn¹OCl  R/ºZR¹kCT¡O�È Â Ò1O�ç8Q�K]V$ÒSI�p¹RCT¡F:»'ècK]ÃzFSR�Ç�V  FdºZO/VÆp  F�GPÈ�RCK]QwV$I�O/T¡FI  R/Ä Q�VÆR¡k�FUV  F�TfÄ K]V  V  FUK]TÓp¹RCTLT¡FUI$ÈwR/Q�G/K]Q;kµFJÈ�K È�RClNO/TÓlÝK]Q�FLIfK]Q�V  FSI�F¹p�RCQ3GxO/Q�G~V  K]T¡GK]ºbO7kFUI�» Á� F�FJÈ�K È�RClNO/T�k�F�R/ºZFUV�TLÒZKsIPG�F�VJF�TLº�K]Q3F�G5Ç�T¡RCºéV  F�FLILV�K]ºbOCVJF�GbV�TLK ÇUR:p¹OCl-VÆFUQwI�R/T�»Á3 F�V$TLK ÇUR:p�O/l�kF�RCºbF�V$TLÒSKsI�K]l]lÝË;ILV$T¡OCVJF�GSK]Q�V  KsI�ºZO/Q�Q3F�T�K]QxOCl]l�R�Ç�V  FäÇUR/l]lNRCÄ K]Q�kÓV�TLK È3lmFUVD'k�Ë�T¡FLI�» Á� FPQwË�ºZn�FUT�R�Ç�ºbOCVJp  F�G�È�RCK]QwV$I ÇURCT�V  FUIUF�F¹E�OCº5È�lNFUI�KsI5k�K]Ã/FUQ�K]Q¯VÆO�n�lNFdÌ»

Page 8: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

ù � þömß

%|(*>'":r-" ± 0-v'.;)µA=0�+=47.é?�,/(@a�)*.�? » Á� F�V$TLK ÇUR:p�O/lZVÆFUQwIURCT8KsI§p¹RCº5È�Ë�VJF�GxÇ�T¡RCº¨ÈwR/K]QwVºbOCVJp  FUI�ILË:È�ÈwR/TLVÆF�G_n�ÒSV  T¹F¹FdlNR:p�O/l  RCºbR¹kCT¹O¹È  K*FLI|ÇUR/T�V  FbO�ç}QwK]V�ÒfI�p�R/T¡F:»cÌ�ê�ëPÈwR/K]Q�V*IO/T¡F}ºZO/VÆp  F¹GåRCÃzF�T8V  Fjà�K]ºbO7kFUI�» Á� F}lNR:p�O/l  RCºbR¹kCT¹O¹È  K*FLI�O/T¹Fjp�RCº5È�Ë�VJF�G�Ç�T¡R/ººbOCVJp  F�G8lÝK]Q3FÓk�T¡R/Ë:È�K]Q�kCIU»�áLQÖV  F�DcT�I�V$Ü�I�F�p¹RCQ3G}O/Q3G8V  K]T¡G8Ã7K*F�Ä�I~V  F�T¡FxO/T¡F¯Í�ì/ÜdÍ�ÌO/Q3G8àë8T¡FUI$ÈwF�pUV�K]Ã/FUlÝÒ�ÇUR/Ë�TLHÆlÝK]Q�F�k�T¡R/Ë:È�K]Q�kCI�» Á� T¡F�F_kCT¡RCË:È3K]Q;k/I�OCT¡F~ºZO/VÆp  F�G8n�F�V$ÄcF�F�QÃ7K*F�Ä�I�ídë_îÅí�ïzÜ©O/Q3GSÃ:K*FUÄ�I�íbïSîÅí�Ì/ÍCÜ�O/Q3G�È3T¡RCÃ7K*GF�V  FdlNR7p�OCl  RCºbR¹k�T¡O¹È  K*FUIU» Á� FO/Q�k�lNF�n�FUV�ÄcF�FUQ�Ã7K*F�Ä�I�ídë�O/Q3G�í�Ì/ÍSKsIPO�È�È3T¹R�EK]ºbOCVJF�lÝÒ � ù\�»

ã H�E¼69E76«>=6:DS8�A�OC>P6:QRD#>PA Ó#Ûð£Ôá$ÒSA�EBA <@D_>=A�FÜÛ�<=ÓSQ >=5BA 69E76«>=6:DS8t>=<P6:;B8:A'>ÔQÔD_>@?@5BA�O�Ù7OP69E7Ò��H�� � H��)á75GDSO�ö�â;�/QÔD#>=?@5BA|O�DSO­6:EB896:A <@O�æ

ã�ñ OP69E7ÒÔ>P5B6uO)A�OC>P6:QRD#>PA�ÓSÛ�£°á7ÒgÙB6uFJA�F QÔD_>@?@5B6:EBÒÔì7E7F7O�ö�âdå�QÔD_>=?@57A�O�á7Ó#Û$K�5B6u?@5Üö|åSùD#<=A�69EB8:6:A <@O�>PÓÔDÔOCA|?'ÓgE7FºA|O]>=69QÔD#>PA�Ó#Û £úÙ7OC6:EBÒZ��H�� � H��)æ

ã H�Û½>=A <)Û�ÙB<C>=5BA <�69>PA <@D_>=69ÓgE7O�ÓSÛ�ÒSÙB6uFJA|FQÔD_>=?@5769EBÒGáGDSE7F<=A'ï�A�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:ÓSEÓSÛ £ºáNDÔì7E7D#8ßJö:[!DS<PA�Û�ÓSÙ7E7F æ

ò ($47y+'4:47($0�< é[EÐA îBD#QR69E769EBÒ >@D#ÕB8:AöÔ5BÓg<P6m� ÓgEg>@D#8:89Úgá 6«>�? D#EÑÕNAºOPA A EÐ>=57D_>/Û�Óg<iD#8:8�ÕBÙJ>>]KtÓ�Ó#Û�>=5BA�>P<=69;789A >=O/û@¶��7â;¶�[�D#E7F�¶)â/â�¶iö|ùgü$>P5BA�EXÙBQiÕNA <­ÓSÛªQÔD_>@?@5BA�O�;B<=ÓJFJÙ7?'A|FºD#Û½>PA <<PA�;GA|D_>PA|F�6«>=A <@D_>P6:ÓSE�Ó#ÛN>P57A�ÒSÙB6uFJA|F!QÔD#>=?@5B6:EBÒ/6uO$ÒS<=A�D#>PA <�>=57D#E�>P57A�EXÙBQiÕNA <$ÓSÛ±QÔD#>=?@5BA|O;B<PÓJFJÙG?'A�FµÕXÚÓ�]ÓS6:EB6:EBÒÐ>P5BA ;7DS69<RQÔD_>@?@5¼OPA'>@O æ�ê.Ó_KtA Ï A <|áª>P5BA|OCA¸>]K�Óý>=<P6:;B8:A'>=OÔDS<PAI>P57AÓSEBA|O�K�6«>=5Ö>=5BA°OPQRDS898:A�OC>�;B<=ÓS;NÓS<P>P6:ÓSEÖÓ#Û�? ÓS<=<PA|?+>��]ÓS6:EBA|FÖ;GD#6:<�QÔD#>=?@5BA|O°û¿DgO�69E7FB6:?�D_>PA|FÕdÚ¸6:EB896:A <@O­>=ÓS£iü+æ�½�ÙB6uFJA�F QÔD_>@?@5B6:EBÒ°6uO�;B<=ÓXFBÙ7?+>=6 Ï A/ÕGA|? D#ÙGOCA�;7ÙJ>=D#>P6 Ï A�QÔD_>@?@5BA�O�>P57D#>57D Ï A�;7<PA Ï 6:ÓSÙGOC8:Ú)ÕNA A�EiA�896:QR69E7D#>PA|F�DSO)ñC8:Ó Ï A ïp>=<P6uD#EBÒg89A|OPõ�Þ9öz�|ãJD#<=A�EBÓ)89ÓgEBÒSA�<rA�<P<=ÓSEBA�ÓSÙ7OP8:ÚA'îB?'8:Ù7FJA|F æ

B$îBD#QR6:EB69E7ÒÜ>P5BAÖ>=DSÕB8:A Ï A�<C>=6:?�D#8:89Úgá�69>¸6uOIA Ï 6:FBA Ed>º>=57D_>¸>P5BAÖEXÙBQiÕNA <¸Ó#ÛiQÔD#>=?@5BA|O;B<PÓJFJÙG?'A�F�ÕNA'>]K�A A�Ei>=<P6:;B8:A'>=O�6:O$;7<P6:QÔD#<=698:Ú�<=A 8uD_>PA|F�>=Ó�>P5BA.OC>=DSÕB6:8969>]Ú�Ó#Û ?'Óg<PE7A <@OªÕNA'>]K�A A�E69QÔD#ÒgA�O�æ7H.O�>P5BA�? DSQ�A�<=DRQRÓS>P6:ÓSE 6:O.69EG?'<=A�DSOPA�F�áBQRÓS<=Ai?'Óg<PEBA�<=O­ÕNA�? ÓSQRA�ÓJ? ? 89ÙGFJA�FDSE7FEBA KM? ÓS<=EBA <@O�D#<=A�6:Eg>=<PÓJFJÙG?'A�F K�576:?@56:E7?'<=A�DgOCA|O­>P57Ai8:69ígA 8:695BÓXÓJF Ó#Û$QR6uOCQÔD_>@?@5BA�O�æGH.8:OPÓ7á>P5BA°QÔD#>=?@5B6:EBÒ´D#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P57Q 6:O!FJA ;NA EGFJA Ed>iÙB;NÓSEÑ>=5BAºOC>=DSÕB698:69>]ÚýÓ#Û�>P57Aºê.DS<P<=6:Oi?'ÓS<=EBA�<=O�æç­5BA¸OC>=DSÕB6:8969>]ÚÑÓ#Û�>P57A¸? ÓS<=EBA <@O�6uO!FBA'>PA�<PQR6:EBA�FÝÕXÚÖ>=5BA¸<PA|OCÓg89ÙJ>=69ÓgEÝD_>�K�5B6u?@5Ý;7D#>=?@5BA|O69Eý>P5BA�KtÓg<P8uF´DS<PA!69QÔD#ÒgA�FëÞ9ö|å_ã©á±?'Óg<PE7A <@O�Û�ÓSÙ7E7F´6:EýÓgEBA!6:QÔD#ÒgA!D#<=AiQRÓg<PA!896:íSA�89Ú¸>PÓ¸ÕNA89ÓdO]>ºDgO�>P5BAý?�D#QRA <@DÖ6:OZ��ÓXÓSQRA�F¼QRÓS<=AOC6:ÒSEB69ìG?�D#Ed>P8:ÚSá�Óg<R>P5BA´OPÙB<PÛ¿DS? A Ï 6:A K�A�F¼D_>ºDSE69E7? <PA|DSOP69E7ÒS8:ÚÔÓSÕB8:6:èdÙBA/DSEBÒS8:ASæ

â

Page 9: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

óÂö óúß óúà

%|(*>'"7ô'"©õ1&�ac.;)_��yzA'&�ac.;)��¯?�,/(@a�)*.�? » Á� FÓV�TLK ÇUR:p¹OCl|VJF�Q�I�RCTSKsI_p�R/º�È3Ë�VÆF�GÕË;ILK]Q�kSÈwR/K]QwVºbOCVJp  FUIdO/Q�G�OdkClNRn�O/l  R/ºZR¹kCT¡O�È Â ÒÓO�ç8Q�K]V$ÒZI�p�R/T¹F7»�ï/ÍPÈwR/K]Q�V*IPOCT¡FdºbOCVJp  F�G_R/Ã/FUT�V  FV$TLK È�lNFUVÆ»

ö ÷ØÍCÈ� rÌNÇh -�gÇBÍ� ø��ÇBÍ]É�Æ É��f��Í� �� Èw -����ÇBÍ]É�Æ��x�@ÈBÉc  �.Éc úÉ�ù�È������)Í� -�

ç­5B6:O¸OPA�?+>=69ÓgE FJA|OP? <P6:ÕGA|O°5BÓ_K 5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75B69A|O°D#8:ÓSE7AÖ? DSEôÕGAÐÙ7OPA�F»>=ÓÝ?'ÓgQR;BÙJ>PAÖ>P57AÛ�ÙBE7FBDSQ�A�Ed>=D#8 QÔD#>P<=6«îIDSE7Fº>P<=6«Û�ÓJ? DS8±>PA�E7OCÓg<�æJç­5B6uO­6uO­Ù7OCA Û�ÙB8�6:E¸OP69>PÙ7D#>P6:ÓSE7O­K�5BA�<PA�;NÓS6:Ed>?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'A�O)D#<=A!E7Ó#>/D Ï DS698uD#Õ789AgáNÕ7ÙJ>/K�5BA <=A!57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O.DS<P6uOP69EBÒºÛ�<PÓgQ�KtÓg<P8uF;B8:DSEBA�O�?�D#E¸ÕGA�? ÓSQR;BÙJ>=A�F æ

ô-"$# ú_47($<'>Õa�)*&�<=.;4�?70µy�036µa�+-?:._?7A=.~2J+'<=v'&w6h.;<�?7&�)ä6h&�?7,z(*�

� ÙB;B;NÓgOPA�>=5BA <=A.D#<=A­>]K�Ó�;B8uD#EBA|O áû5üÐDSE7Fbû5ý�ád6:EÔ>P5BA)OP? A EBAgádDSE7F�>P5BA|OCA);B8uD#EBA|O�6:E7FJÙ7? A5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�áLþ�üIDSE7F�þ�ý<PA|OC;NA�?'>P6 Ï A�89Úgá ÕNA'>]K�A A E�>]K�Ó Ï 69A�K�O æ|ç­5BA E�>P5BA�57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚþÅÿ þ � �ý þ;ü 6uOºDëQRDS;B;B6:EBÒëÛ�<=ÓSQø>P57A´ì7<@O]>I69QÔD#ÒgA´ÓSEd>=ÓÜ6«>@OCA�8«Û�K�69>P5ô>=5BA´Û�Óg898:Ó_K�6:EBÒ;B<PÓg;GA�<C>=69A|O ÷

ã þ6:O/DI;B8uD#E7DS<)57ÓSQRÓS8:ÓSÒgÚÑûpOCA�AÞ ßBöSáCß � ã½ü'æ é�>�5GDSO�Dº8:6:EBARÓ#Û�ì7îXA|F´;NÓS6:Ed>=O�á K�5B6:?@5Ö6:O>P5BAº69QÔD#ÒgA°Ó#Û­>=5BA°6:Eg>=A <@OCA|?+>=69ÓgEÐÓSÛ­>P5BAÔ>]K�Ó;B8uD#EBA|O á�D#E7FÜDFB6:OC>P6:E7?+>!ìBîJA�FÑ;NÓS6:Ed>K�5B6u?@5¸6uO�>P57A/A ;B6:;GÓg89A . 69E¸>P57A�ì7<=OC>�69QÔDSÒSASæ

ã H ;B8uD#E7DS</5BÓSQRÓS8:ÓSÒgÚ1þý57DgO�>]KtÓ A|ègÙGD#8$A 6:ÒSA�E Ï DS89Ù7A�O�æ�ç­5BA°?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJ6:EBÒ¸A 6:ÒSA EBïÏ A|?+>PÓg<=O­FJA ì7EBA�>=5BA/896:EBA�Ó#Û�ìBîJA�FI;NÓS6:Eg>@O æGç­5BA�A 6:ÒSA E Ï A�?+>=ÓS<�?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJ6:EBÒi>PÓR>P57AEBÓSEBï�FJA�ÒSA�EBA <@D_>=A)A�69ÒgA E Ï D#8:ÙBA�6:O�>=5BA/A ;B6:;NÓS8:A/69E¸>P576:O�?�DSOPASæ

ç­5BADS?+>=69ÓgEÝÓSÛ�>P5BA 5BÓgQRÓS8:ÓSÒSÚÑ6uOÔOC57Ó_K�EÝ6:EÝì7ÒgÙB<=A¸åJæ�ç­57AºÛ�ÙBEGFBD#QRA Ed>@D#8�QÔD_>=<P69îë6:O?'ÓSQR;BÙB>PA�F DgO/û¿OPA AÔÞ«ö:[_ã�ü

�Zÿ¶Þ þ�� . ã���þ�� Û�Óg<�=ÿ�×Óg< � û]ömü

ô-"]! ú_47($<'>Õa�)*&�<=.;4�?70µy�036µa�+-?:._?7A=.1?�,/(*2J0�y&�)ä?7.;<=470�,

� 69QR6:8:DS<P8:ÚSá�>=5BA >P<=69Û�ÓX?�D#8­>=A E7OPÓS<°?�D#E¼ÕGAA|O]>=69QÔD_>=A�FµÛ�<=ÓSQ >]K�ÓÑ;B8:DSEBA�ORK�576:?@5»6:E7FJÙ7? A5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�Ó Ï A�<�>P5B<=A A Ï 6:A K�O�æ�)A EBÓS>PA­>P57A�OPA�5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�ÕXÚPþ ü ��� á�þ ý ��� á#ÕNA'>]K�A A�E>P5BA�ì7<@OC>�DSE7F OCA|?'ÓgE7F Ï 6:A K�O�áBD#E7F�þ ü ��� á�þ ý ��� áBÕNA'>]K�A A EI>P57A�ì7<=OC>.D#EGF°>=5B69<@F æ

[

Page 10: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

�π π

��

� ��

����

��

��

%|(*>'"���"�Á� FdO�p�V$K*RCQ�R�ÇðV  F�ºZO¹È�þZÿ�þ � �ý þ ü R/Q¯OðÈ�RCK]QwV � ü K]Q1V  F D�T�ILV�K]ºZO�k�FUÜ�KsI�VÆRD�T�ILV|V$T¹O/Q�I@ÇUF�TPK]V|VÆR ��� OzI�V  R/Ë�k  K]V|ÄcOzIdV  FZK]ºbO7kFfR�ÇPV  Ffà7í�ÈwR/K]QwV�� ü Ü|OCQ3G_V  F�QºbO�È}K]V�n�O�p�Ô_VÆR_V  F|D�T�ILV5K]ºZO�k�FSO/IdV  R/Ë�k  K]V5ÄcO/IdV  FbK]ºZO�k�FSR�Ç�V  FZà7í�ÈwR/K]Q�V�� ý »Ð|R/K]Q�V*I�K]Q�V  F©DcT�ILVcK]ºZO�k�F�RCQ�V  FPK]ºZO�k�FZR�Ç�V  FPK]QwVÆFUT�I�F�p�V$K*RCQxR�Ç�V  F�V�ÄcRðÈ�lNO/Q�FLIdÄ K]l]ln¹FdºZO¹ÈÈ�F�G�VJRSV  F�ºPI�F�lÝÃzFUI�ÜcI�R_O/T¡FäD'E;F�GðÈwR/K]Q�V*I�Ë�Q�G�F�T�V  KsI�O�p�V�K*R/Q3» Á� FbFJÈ�K È�RClNF . KsIO/l¢I�R_O5D'E;F�G�ÈwR/K]Q�V©Ë�Q�G�F�T�V  KsI�ºZO¹È�»

ç­5BAi>=<P69Û�ÓJ? DS8ª>=A E7OPÓS<�6uO/FJA'>=A <=Q�6:EBA|F´6:E7FJ6:<PA|?+>P8:ÚÛ�<=ÓSQ >=5BA�?�D#QRA <@D°QÔD#>P<=6:? A�O�æ±ç­57Aà��!ÿ/? DSQRA <@D/QÔD_>P<=6u?'A�O$Û�ÓS<t>P5BA.>P5B<=A A Ï 6:A K�O�QRDmÚ�ÕNA.K�<=6«>P>PA EºÙ7OC6:EBÒ/>=5BA.57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚ69E7FBÙ7?'A|FIÕXÚÔ>=5BA�ì7<@O]>�;78:DSEBA/DSO

� ÿMÞ! #"%$Bã'& � � ÿ¶Þ þ ü ��� " . � ã(& � � � ÿ¶Þ þ ü ��� "*) . � � ã ûpßgü� 69EG?'A)>P5BA�A ;B6:;NÓS8:A�O�á . � D#E7F . � � áX? D#EºÕGA�ÓSÕJ>@D#6:EBA�F°Û�<PÓgQú>P5BA)>]KtÓ Ï 69A�Kô5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�áDSO­FJA�O=?'<=6:ÕGA|FIDSÕGÓ Ï ASáXÓSEB8:ÚR>P57A�OP?�D#8:A.Û¿Dg?+>PÓg< )¸6:O­ÙBE7ídE7Ó_K�E�æBç­5B6uO�OP?�D#8:A.Û¿Dg?+>PÓg<�? D#E¸ÕNA?'ÓSQR;BÙB>PA�FÐÛ�<=ÓSQ >P5BAI5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5XÚ6:E7FJÙ7? A�FÑÕXÚý>=5BAºOPA�? ÓSE7FÐ;B8uD#EBAgæ'q7ÓS</>=5B6:Oi5BÓSQRÓSïÒS<@D#;B5XÚR>PÓRÕNA�?'ÓgE7OC6uOC>PA Ed>�K�69>P5¸>P57A�ì7<=OC>�áX>=5BA�Û�ÓS8:8:Ó_K�69EBÒR<=A 8uD_>=69ÓgE7O�QiÙ7OC>�ÕGA�O=D_>=6:OCì7A|F ÷

þ ý ��� ÿ�þ ü ����+ . � e-, ûpàgü þ ý ��� ÿ§þ ü ����+ ) . � � e., û�ÿdüç­5BAà_ï Ï A�?'>PÓg< e 5BA�<PA <=A ;B<=A�OPA Ed>@O�>=5BA;B8uD#EBAÓû ý 69E¼>=5BA;B<=ÓC�]A�?'>P6 Ï AIÛ�<=DSQRA FBA'ì7EBA|FÕdÚô?�D#QRA <@DSO � DSE7F � � æ Î E7? A e 57DgOºÕNA A�EôÛ�ÓSÙ7E7FôK�AÖ? DSEô>P57A E ? ÓSQR;BÙJ>=A/)ræ­ç­57A?'ÓSQR;BÙB>=D_>=69ÓgE7D#8 ;7<PÓJ?'A|FJÙB<=A)6uO­>=5BA�Û�ÓS8:89Ó_K�6:EBÒöSæ � ÓS8 Ï A�Û�Óg< e ÙGOC6:EBÒ´û¿àdü+æ

ã çªÓ°OCÓg8 Ï A.Û�Óg< e DÔO=? DS89A)Û¿DS?'>PÓg< 0ÜQiÙ7OC>�ÕNA/A'îJ;B8:6:? 6«>=89ÚI69E7? 89ÙGFJA�Fþ ý ��� ÿ�0tû*þ ü ���1+ . � e-, ü

ã � Óg8 Ï A)Û�Óg< 0ÜÕXÚº;B<=A'ï�QiÙ78«>=69;B8:ÚX69E7Ò�ÕNÓ#>=5OC6uFJA�O­ÕXÚýÞ . � ã � ÒS6 Ï 6:EBÒ

Þ . � ã � þ ý ��� ÿ20tÞ . � ã � þ ü ���

ö|ù

Page 11: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

ã � Óg8 Ï A)Û�Óg< e ÕXÚÔ>=DSíd6:EBÒ�>P57A�OP?�D#8uD#<­;B<=ÓXFBÙ7?+>�ÓSE¸>=5BA/89A Û½>�K�6«>=5 . � ÒS6 Ï 6:EBÒe ÿMû@þ ý ����3 054�þ ü ��� ü , . � 3 "6" . � "6" �

ßJæ5½�6 Ï A E e FJA'>=A <=QR69EBA7) Û�<PÓgQ û�ÿXü+æã ç­5B6uO�;B<PÓJ? A A�F7O�6:EÔ>P5BA�O=D#QRA.QÔD#E7EBA <�DSO�D#ÕNÓ Ï A�K�69>P5ºD!OP?�D#8:A�Û¿Dg?+>PÓg<18�áXÒg6 Ï 6:EBÒ

) e ÿMû*þ ý ����3 894�þ ü ��� ü ,�. � � 3 "!" . � � "6" �àBæ��tÓSQR;BÙJ>=A�>P5BA�?�D#QRA <@D!QRD#>P<=6:? A�O � á � � á � � � æÿ7æ�ç­5BA´>=<P69Û�ÓJ? DS8�>PA�E7OPÓS<º6uOº>P5BA�E ?'ÓgQ�;7ÙJ>PA|F»Û�<PÓgQ >P5BAý>P5B<=A Aý?�D#QRA <@DÜQÔD_>=<P6u?'A|OºDgO

FJA�O=?'<=6:ÕGA|FI6:EÑÞ«ögö'ã�æ

ô-"sr ¬ .�4:+=)@?74� 47?7($6h&�?7($0�<80�2 �ôç­5BA�5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�Ù7OCA|F°>=Ó�? ÓSQR;BÙJ>=A��°DS<PA)ÒSA�EBA <@D_>=A�FÔÕXÚÔÙ7OP69E7Ò��H�� � H��þÓgEë>=5BAÑö|å#àýK�6:FBA Õ7DgOCA�896:EBA ;GÓg69Ed>ÔQÔD_>@?@5BA�O!>PÓÐ;B6u?@íëÓSÙB>!>=5BA¸>]KtÓÐ8:DS<PÒgA�OC>OCA >=O)Ó#Û$;GÓg69Ed>@O)? ÓSE7OP6:OC>PA�Ed>.K�6«>=5´5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5769A|O­Û�<PÓgQ >=5BAi;GD#6:<��ùS¦¾ � ï­OP5BÓ_K�E6:Eì7ÒSÙB<=A � æ7ç­57A/5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�áþ ü á�þ ý áG?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FÔ>=ÓR>P5BA/;B8uD#E7A�O­Ó#Û�>P57A/5BÓSÙ7OPA/K­D#8:8D#E7FIÒS<=ÓSÙBEGF æ

ñ OP69EBÒ¸>=5BA�OPAÔ5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5B6:A�O�A|O]>=69QÔD_>=A�FÐ6:E7FJA ;NA EGFJA Ed>P8:ÚSár>P5BAÔQÔD#>P<=6«îÕþ�ÿæþ � �ý þ ü57DSO/A�69ÒgA E Ï D#8:ÙBA�O�ï@öSæ ÿ;�JáNï�ù7æ [gàBá±ï[ùBæ [�[Bæ ç­5B6uO/6:E7FJ6u? D#>PA�O/>P57D#>�>P5BAÔQÔD#>P<=6«îÐ6:O�? 89ÓdOCA�>=Ó´D5BÓSQRÓS8:ÓSÒgÚ´û½Û�Óg<�K�5B6u?@5º>=5BA�8uDSOC>�>]K�ÓRA 6:ÒSA�E Ï DS89ÙBA|O­KtÓgÙB8uFºÕNA/A'îBDS?'>P8:ÚºA|ègÙGD#8½ü+áJÕBÙJ>.>P57D#>>P5BA¸>]K�ÓÐ57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�OiDS<PA¸EBÓS>RA îBDS?+>=89Úµ?'ÓSEGOC6uO]>=A Ed>RK�6«>=5µ>=5BA A ;B6:;NÓS8uD#<RÒSA�ÓSQRA'>=<PÚgæç­5BA.EBA îX>�OC>PA ;º6:O�>PÓ!A�OC>P6:QRD#>PA.>P5BA)5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�OPÙ7?@5Ô>=57D_>t>P5BA�ÚÔD#<=A.?'ÓgE7OC6uOC>PA Ed>|áSK�A<PA >PÙB<=Eº>=ÓR>P5B6uO�6:E¸OPA�?'>P6:ÓSE � æ

� 47?7($6h&�?7($0�<�032;: ç­5BA!5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5B6:A�O­ÙGOCA|F¸>PÓ°A|O]>=69QÔD_>=AP£ÂDS<PA�FJA >PA�<PQR6:EBA�F áN6:E´DOC6:QR698uD#<�QÔDSEBEBA <�>PÓºDSÕGÓ Ï ASáJÕXÚIÙGOC6:EBÒf��H�� � H��Ø>PÓº;B6:?@íIÓSÙJ>.>P5BA/>]K�ÓÔ8uD#<=ÒSA�OC>.OPA'>=O�Ó#Û;GÓg69Ed>=Ot?'ÓgE7OC6uOC>PA Ed>�K�69>P5Ô57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�Û�<=ÓSQú;7D#6:<=Oc)ù�¦å � ádD#E7FZ � ¦åiömßJæSç­57A�OPA;GÓg69Ed>=O.D#<=A�OP5BÓ_K�E¸69E¸ì7ÒgÙB<PA � æ

qª6:ÒSÙ7<PAf�IOC5BÓ_K�O)>=5BA°DS?�?'ÙB<@DS? Ú¸ÓSÛä£ÁÕXÚýFJ6uOC;78:DmÚX6:EBÒº>=5BAÔA ;769;NÓS8uD#<�8:69EBA|O°û¿FBA <=6 Ï A�FÛ�<PÓgQþ>P5BA�>=<P69Û�ÓJ? DS8±>PA EGOCÓg<@ütÛ�Óg<�;GÓg69Ed>=O­8:ÚX69E7Ò�ÕNÓ#>=5 ÓSED#E7FIÓCoý>P5BA/;B8uD#E7A�O�æ

< = ��ÇBÌw�)ÍCÆ�ù��$Æ.Ê È� ṟÉ�Æ��SÇJÈ7Ë)ÌNÇBÍ]É�Æ3É-�© �Èj  Ë��[ÇBÍ����� ���Í� ��}�

óô5BA EQRÓS<=A�>P5GD#E >P57<PA�A Ï 69A�K�O�D#<=A�D Ï D#6:8:DSÕB89AgáJ>P57A/>P5B<=A A Ï 6:A KÀQÔD_>@?@5BA�O�DSE7F¸>PA�E7OPÓS<@O? D#ERÕNA�69Ed>=A ÒS<@D_>=A�F!69Ed>=Ó�D�? ÓSE7OP6uO]>=A Ed>�<PA|?'ÓgE7O]>=<PÙG?+>P6:ÓSE!Ó Ï A�<�D#8:8 Ï 6:A K�O.Þ �mã©æSç­576:O$A�E7D#Õ789A|O>P5BAi?�D#QRA <@DSO�Û�ÓS<.DS898 Ï 6:A K�O�>PÓ°ÕNAiFJA >PA <=QR69E7A�F 6:E >P5BAiO=D#QRAi? ÓXÓS<@FJ69EGD_>PA/OPÚJO]>=A Q áGDSE7FÛ�ÓS<�DS?�?'ÙB<@D_>=A�àÂOC>P<=Ù7?+>=ÙB<PARA|O]>=69QÔD_>=69ÓgEÑÕdÚýQ�6:EB6:QR6N��69EBÒ<=A ;7<PÓ��]A�?+>=69ÓgEýA�<P<=ÓS<�Ó Ï A�<�DS898Ï 6:A K�O­6:E K�5B6u?@5 D!Û�A|D_>PÙ7<PA/D#;7;GA|D#<@O æ

ç­5BA.>=A E7OPÓS<@O­D#E7F¸?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|OtDS<PA�FJA'>=A <=QR69EBA|F°Û�Óg<­>P<=69;789A >=O�Û�<=ÓSQ�öSö�6:QRDSÒSA|OÓ#Û�>=5BAb¶�D#8:ÕGÓgEBEBAÔOCA >Rû�ì7ÒSÙ7<PA ömü�Ù7OP6:EBÒº>=5BAÔD#8:ÒSÓg<P69>P5BQ ÓSÛ�OPA�?+>=69ÓgEÖà7æ±ç­57AROC>P<=Ù7?'>PÙB<=A?'ÓSEd>@D#6:E7O­àBö � ;GÓg69Ed>@O æ ñ OC6:EBÒ!>P5BA�8:69EBA�QÔD_>@?@5B6:EBÒÔD#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQ Ó#Û � ?@5BQR6uFÖÞ9ö � ã©ád>PÓgÒSA >P5BA�<K�6«>=5Ý>=5BA´?'ÓgQ�;7ÙJ>PA|Fµ?�D#QRA <@D´QÔD_>=<P6u?'A|O á [dß´8:69E7A�OÔD#<=A¸<PA|?'Ó Ï A�<PA|F æ-¶)69A�K�ORÓ#Û)>P5BAà�;GÓg69Ed>=O�áX896:EBA|O�DSE7Fº?�D#QRA <@DSO�D#<=A)OP5BÓ_K�EI69Eºì7ÒSÙB<=A�âBæXç­5BA�896:EBA�O­DS<PA)Ù7OCA|FÔ>=Ó�? <PA|D_>PA)>P57A;GÓg89ÚXÒSÓgE7D#8rQ�ÓJFJA�8ªOP5BÓ_K�E6:E ì7ÒSÙB<=A�[Bá7K�5B6:?@5ý6:O�>PA'îX>=ÙB<PAiQRDS;B;NA�F¸Û�<=ÓSQ3>P5BA!ÓS<=69Òg69E7DS869QÔD#ÒgA�O�æ

ögö

Page 12: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

Mù �

þö|ß �

%|(*>'"?>-" è'R/TfF�O�p  K]ºbO7kF�È�OCK]T�Üäí�ë�î�í�ïzÜ5OCQ3G�í�ï�î�í�Ì/Í�Ü5V  FfV�ÄcR  RCºbR¹k�T¡O¹È  K*FUIÄ K]V  ºZRzILVcI�Ë:ÈÈ�RCTLV©O/T¹F�I�F�O/T¡p  F�G5ÇURCT�O/ºZR/Q�kCILVcV  F�ºbOCVJp  FUIðT¹FLILË�lÝV�K]Q�k|Ç�T¹R/ºéV  F�Ä K*G�Fn¹O/I�FUlÝK]Q�F�ILVJF�T¡F�R1ºZO/VÆp  K]Q�k�»©è'R/T�F�Op  È�OCK]TSV  F�ÈwR/K]QwV$I�p�R/Q�V$TLK*n�Ë�V$K]Q;k~VÆR¯V  F�DcT�ILV  RCHºbR¹kCT¹O¹È  ÒfO/T¡FðT¡FÆÈ3T¹FLI�F�QwVÆF¹GZn�Ò�p�K]T¡p�lNFUI�OCQ3GdV  FUK]T�p�R/Q�ÃzF¹E  Ë�l]l�KsI�G/T¡OCÄ Q1K]Q_Ä Â K]VJFUÜ�O/Q3GV  FcÈ�RCK]QwV$Iðp�R/Q�ILKsILVÆFUQ�V Ä K]V  V  FðI�F�p�R/Q3G  R/ºZR¡k�T¡O¹È  ÒfO/T¹F�T¡FÆÈ3T¡FUI�FUQ�VJF�GbnUÒPIA@UËwOCT¡FLI�O/Q3GV  FUK]TPp�R/Q�ÃzF¹E  Ë�l]l�KsIdGCT¡O/Ä Q�K]QÕn�lNO�p�Ô»

ù � !ö|ß

%|(*>'"�B�" ѯR:G�F�l  R/Ë;I�F�V$TLK È�lNFUVÆ» Á� F�V�TLK ÇUR7p�OClwVÆFUQwIURCT|KsI�p¹RCº5È�Ë�VJF�GcÇ�T¡R/ºæV  F  R/ºZR¹kCT¡O�È Â HK*FLI�T¡F�lNO/V�K]Q�k�V  F�È3lNOCQ3FUI�I  R/Ä Q�K]QdD'k�Ë�T¡F�ïC»

ömß

Page 13: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

ûpDgü û�ÕGü

%|(*>'"?C-"P¸ K*F�Ä�IbR�ÇPT¹F¹p�RCÃzF�T¡F�GÓà7í�ÈwR/K]Q�V�O/Q�G_lÝK]Q3FbI�V�TLËwp�V$Ë�T¡FbOCQ3G1p�O/ºZFUT¹OzI�» Á� FUT¡F�O/T¡FàÌï|ÈwR/K]Q�V*I�O/Q�G7D�ÍblÝK]Q3FUI�»�Ê�O�ÎdO|È3lNOCQ�Ã:K*FUÄjR�Ç5V  Fðp  Ë�T¡p  OCQ3GPV  F�p¹F�QwVÆF�T�I5R�Ç�p�O/ºZFUT¹OzIp¹RCº5È�Ë�VJF�G�Ç�T¡R/ºÉÌÌfÃ:K*FUÄ�IdR�Ç�V  FPI�p¹F�Q3F:»�Ê�n�ÎfO_p�lNRzI�FdË:È�ÜcK]Q�pUl ËwG/K]Q�k�V  FbG/K]T¹F¹p�V�K*R/Q�IdR�ÇV  Fdp�O/ºZF�T¡OFE I�È�TLK]Q3p�K È�OCl=O�E;FUI�»

ûpDgü û�ÕGü û¿?�ü

%|(*>'"?G-"S¸ K*F�Ä�IÓR�ÇSV  FPÈ�K*F�p¹F�Ä KsI�F�È�lNO/Q�O/TÓºbR:G�F�l�kF�Q3F�T¡OCVJF�G�Ç�T¡R/º V  FÓà7í ÈwR/K]Q�VPO/Q3GlÝK]Q3FfILV$TLËwp�V$Ë�T¹F�I  R/Ä Q}K]QSD'k�Ë�T¡FHD» Á� FSºbR:G�F�l  OzISn�F�FUQhVÆF¹E�V�Ë�T¡F�HƺbO�È�ÈwF�GÓË;ILK]Q�k1V  FR/TLK k�K]Q3O/l=K]ºZO�k�FLI�Ç�T¡RCº�V  F ¸ OClNn�R/QwQ�F�I�F�V©H�D'k�Ë�T¡FdÌ�»

ö|à

Page 14: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

I ÷ØÍ¡�XÌ Ë��;�XÍ]É�Æ

óÖA 57D Ï AIFJA�Q�ÓgE7OC>P<@D_>PA|FÜ>=57D_>°DÖ<PA|?'ÓSEGO]>=<PÙ7?'>P6:ÓSEëÓSÛ�?�D#QRA <@DSO�D#E7Fµà� O=?'A E7A OC>P<=Ù7?'ï>PÙB<=A)?�D#E°ÕNA)ÒgA EBA�<=D#>PA|FÔD#ÙJ>=ÓSQÔD_>=6:?�D#8:89Ú!Û�<PÓgQþD�OCA >tÓSÛªFJ6uOC;7DS<=D#>PA Ï 6:A K�O�ædç­K�Ó/>]ÚX;NA�OtÓ#ÛD#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQÔO�57D Ï A�ÕNA A�EÜA EBÒg69E7A A <=A�F�á ÓSEBAÔÕ7DgOCA|FÐÓSEÑ69Ed>=A <=A�OC>�;GÓg69Ed>i?'Óg<P<=A�OP;NÓSE7FJA�E7?'A|O>P5BA)Ó#>P57A <�ÓSEºFJ6:<=A�?+>­?'ÓgQ�;7ÙJ>=D#>P6:ÓSERÛ�<=ÓSQ ;B8uD#E7DS<�5BÓgQ�ÓgÒS<@D#;B5769A|O æSç­57A.;NÓS6:Eg>�Õ7DSOPA�FºD#89ïÒSÓS<=69>P5BQÀ6:O�>P5BAtQRÓS<=A�QÔD_>PÙ7<PAgá�D#EGF�DS?@5B6:A Ï A�O±>=5BAtOPÙBÕJï�;B69îJA 8gDg? ? ÙB<=Dg?'Ú)Ó#ÛBOCQÔDS898dÕ7DSOPA 8:6:EBAD#8:ÒSÓS<=69>P5BQÔO�æ

ç­5BA�FJ6:<PA|?+>�A�OC>P6:QÔD_>=69ÓgEIÛ�<=ÓSQ 5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O­6uO�QRÓS<=A�;B<PA�896:QR69EGD#<=ÚºD#E7F OC>=DSE7FBD#<@F;B<PÓgÕB8:A QÔO.DS<P6uOC6:EBÒÔ6:E´QiÙ78«>=69;B8:A Ï 6:A K¶<=A 8uD_>=69ÓgE¸A|O]>=69QÔD#>P6:ÓSEýDS<PA�OC>P6:898ª>PÓIÕGA�OCÓg8 Ï A�F æ3qBÓg<A'îBD#QR;B8:ASá DIQRD#îJ69Q!ÙBQ�896:íSA�896:5BÓXÓJF´A|O]>=69QÔD_>=69ÓgEýÓSÛc�ëû�Óg<�£!ü�Û�<=ÓSQ >]K�Ó¸;B8:DSEBA�O)K�ÓSÙB8uF69E Ï Óg8 Ï A�QR69E769QR6m� 6:EBÒ�>=5BA!ñP<PA�;B<=ÓC�]A�?'>P6:ÓSE7õ­A�<P<=ÓS<rÕGA >]KtA�A E�QRA�DgOCÙ7<PA|F/;GÓg69Ed>@OªDSE7F�?'Óg<P<=A�?'ï>PA�FI;NÓS6:Eg>@O�QRDS;B;NA�F°Ù7E7FJA <�>=5BA�5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5XÚSádOCÙBÕ��]A�?+>�>PÓ!>P57A)5BÓgQRÓS8:ÓSÒSÚÔ? ÓSE7OP6:OC>PA�E7?'Ú?'ÓSEGO]>=<=DS69Ed>=O�ÓgEI>=5BA�>]K�Ó!5BÓgQRÓSÒS<@D#;75B69A|O æ

H�EBÓS>P5BA�<�;7<PÓgÕB89A�Q >P57D#>/<PA|ègÙ769<=A�O)QRÓS<=Ai6:E Ï A�OC>P6:ÒgD#>P6:ÓSE´6uO�69EÖÓSÕJ>@D#6:EB6:EBÒIA|O]>=69QÔD#>PA�OÓ#Û��»ÓS<_£ K�5BA E 5BÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O°DS<P6uOP69EBÒëÛ�<PÓgQøQRÓS<=A>=57D#Eô>]K�ÓÝK�ÓS<=8uFµ;78:DSEBA�O¸D#<=AD Ï DS698uD#Õ789AgæSé[E°>=5BA�? DSOPA.ÓSÛrA�OC>P6:QÔD_>=69EBÒi>P5BA|OCA�ßmï Ï 69A�KØD#E7FIà_ï Ï 6:A K»<=A 8uD_>=69ÓgE7O�Û�<=ÓSQ ;NÓS6:Ed>?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'A�O$ïª69>t6uO�K�A 8:8GÙBEGFJA <@O]>=ÓXÓXFR57Ó_K¼ÕNA�OC>�>=Ó�Ù7OPA.QRÓS<=A�>=57D#ER>=5BA.QR6:EB69Q!ÙBQEdÙ7QiÕNA <$Ó#Û±?'Óg<P<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA�E7?'A|Or>=Ó�69QR;B<=Ó Ï At>P5BA­A|O]>=69QÔD_>=A­Ó#ÛN>P5BA Ï 69A�KÝ<=A 8uD_>=69ÓgE�á_ÕBÙJ>$>=5B6:O57DSO­ÚgA'>­>PÓÔÕNA�Û�ÓS<=QiÙB8uD_>=A�FºÛ�ÓS<­>=5BA/A�OC>P6:QÔD_>P6:ÓSEIÛ�<=ÓSQ 57ÓSQRÓSÒg<=DS;B5B6:A�O�? DSOPASæ

H ìGE7D#8�A'îX>=A E7OP69ÓgEýÓSÛ�>P576:O�K�ÓS<=í 6:O�>=57D_>/Ó#ÛtA�OC>P6:QRD#>P6:EBÒ 5BÓSQRÓgÒS<@D#;B5B6:A�O�Û�ÓS</O=?'A E7A>]Úd;NA�O�K�5BA <=A�ÓgÕJ>=DS69EB6:EBÒ�;NÓS6:Ed>�ÓS<t896:EBA�?'ÓS<=<=A�OP;GÓgE7FJA EG?'A�O�QÔDmÚ!EBÓ#>�ÕGA);GÓdOPOP69Õ789A�Agæ ÒGæ#Û�Óg<D!<=ÓXÓSQÂK�69>P5 ÙBEd>=A'îX>PÙB<=A�F¸K­D#8:8:O�æ

×�p�Ô/Q�R/Ä�lNF�G�k�F�ºbF�QwV$I óÐAýD#<=AÒS<@D_>=A'Û�ÙB8.Û�ÓS<I69QÔD#ÒgA�OÔ;7<PÓ Ï 6uFJA�F¼ÕXÚj��ÓSÕNÓ#>¡¶)6:Oºé�����é]H� ÓS;B576:D�H�Ed>=69;NÓS8:6:O�á#D#EGFdq7<=DSÙBEB5BÓSÛ�A <�é�½�iá#DSE7FiÛ�ÓS<�ì7E7DSE7?'6uD#8BOPÙB;B;NÓS<P>�Û�<PÓgQ·B ñ H���ç �4�<=ÓC�]A�?'>ð¶�DSEBÒSÙGD#<@FýD#QÔF � 57DS<P;x�rDSÕ7O�Ó#Û�B�ÙB<=ÓS;NASæ±óÐA°D#<=A�DS8:OPÓ 69E7FBA ÕJ>=A�FÖ>PÓ1¼gA�OP;GA�<½KJÓS<@D#E7O=OCÓgE°Û�Óg<­>P5BA�OPÓ#Û½>]K­D#<=A)ÙGOCA|Fº6:E¸>P5BA/;NÓgOC>Cï�;B<=ÓX? A�O=OC6:EBÒ�Ó#Ûª>P5BA�à¶QRÓXFBA 8©æ

�j -�¹ rÈ� rÆ.Ì� '�

y|��b$� L)�gÃ�vSU@®fn[`|^�W�^Xvi{±� }g��Mª�gY[Z+�ONp\�W�c|U­vdW ZCW.j@`|\/VSY]U@n[n[ef`|^i¬�efZ § Z § U­®«W Vd®«W�j@e«W ^RV_oSYCW \/e«v7�Np^QPSRUT'PUVXW'wdVdW�c|U=n�²_yZYZ[S²|² zSw y]\?YSy��

²#��{±�SM�U+W'YCvgn[®fU=o_w�{ � ¦ ` Y[Y+w$W ^XvÐÃ��.^Befn[n[U=Y]\�W ^G�Ýz�Tþ\/`#vSU@®�W�jZ__�ge«n[e¯Z]ef`|^Ña9Y]`|\�U=s#Z]U@^dvgU+vef\�W c|U°n[UZ__�dU@^gj@U@n@�`Np^aP-bdcZegfihkjljm7wlnpokq$hµyZrtstuwv_yZrts�x#w�VdW�c|U=nKs?Y�zg[ws?\�x_��hSVgY]ef^gc|U=Y[³yrU=Y]®«W�cSwGy]\?\tsS�

zS�z��{qt�{M�`|®f®fU@ntW�^dv7z��XL�` YCW��XvB� z T�{�q;|gÃÜZ § Y]U@UP³©vSef\/U@^dn[ef`|^dW�®BVXW'Y[Z$`�Y]efU@^_ZCW'Z]e«`�^�n�oSn�Z]U@\R�Np^ ¦ �|~�W�^XW�vgU|w�U+vSefZ]` Y+w~}p�Xbd���l�������������ct���?�Sm*������ct�gw|VdW�c�U@nrz?\?\Z[wu�xtrS�S~�®f�_¬�U=YªÃ�j+W|vSU@\/efj{��d�g®fe«n § U=Y]n@w7yZ\?Y?�#�

ug��{±�Gb$�NT­U=�JU@lmU@j|w�qt�G}g� ¦ W@oS®«` Y+w±W ^XvI}g�O�RW ®fe«�J����`#vSU@®fe«^gc°W�^dv°Y]U@^dvgU=Y]ef^gcÔW Y]j § e¯Z]U@j=Z]�SY]Ua9Y]`|\»V § ` Z]`|c�YCW V § n]|mà § oS�SY]e9v�c�U@`|\/U=Z[Y[o#³7W ^Xv)ef\�W c|U=³7�XW n[U+v�W VdVSY]`mW�j § ��Np^�P-bdcZe����d�t���X�t���� j����XTA�k�SR � PS��wdVdW�c|U=n.y�y�[S²ArSw±y]\?\tsS�

x#�.q)� T��S¾dW��dc�U=YCW�n�W ^Xvi¾���n7�dn�Z]\�W�^7�O��` Z]ef`|^ÔW ^Xv�n�Z[Y]�dj=Z]�SY]U�a:Y]`�\×\/`�Z]ef`|^!ef^�W.VdefU@j@U=¬�efn[UVg®«W�^XW'Y�U=^Sl#e¯Y]`|^g\/U@^_Z+�KT�������b����t����cA���?�-�XcA��b����t�lc' ¡P1�A������b��¢R1�de�c��t��������ct�£�A��� � b���� ¤Se¥���?�T��{���¥��� �¦�w����e��PwX²X| u?Y�xZ[XxtrtYSw�yZ\tY?YS�

ö�ÿ

Page 15: vgg/publications/1998/Pritchett98b/... · PDF filed_>p6:ÓseÝk 5b6:?@5¼fjÓxa o ebÓs>!

sS�¡�I�mÃ.�|¾±efn[j § ®«UPY�W ^Xv§z��wqt��M�`|®f®fU@n@�%ztW�^dvg`|\ôn]W \/Vd®fU$j@`�^dn[U@^gn[�dn]|_ÃÖVXW YCW�vgefc|\ôa:`�Yª\/`#vgU@®¨ Z[Z]ef^dcR¬�e¯Z § W�VdVg®fe«j@W Z]ef`|^gn�Z]`ºef\�W c|U!W�^XW ®¯ogn[efn/W ^XvW �gZ]`|\�W'Z]U+v j+W'Y[Z]`|c�YCW V § o_�©j�ct�§��f� j��ÔwX²gu�ª�s?«�| ztYSy�[#z?\?x#w�yZ\tYSy���#��Ã��+¹»�|¾±efZ]�=c|ef�d�J`�^�W�^dv�Ã��t^Befn[n[U=Y]\�W ^G�gÃt�SZ]`|\�W Z]efj�j@W�\/U=YCW�Y]U@j@`'lmU=Y[o�a:`�Yrj@®f`|n[U+v)`�Y�`|VJU=^ef\�W c|U�n[UZ__�dU=^dj@U@n@�FNp^QP-bdcZegf*hjljm7wgVXW�c�U@n�zSy�y�[#z|²ts#w yZ\?\tYS�YS�o.��¬�U=`�Y]c|efn@wp�I�X{±U=Z[Y]`|�7wJW�^dvR}g�d~�efZ[Z]®fU=Y+��b�Y[Y]` Y­c��de«vgU+v�vgU@n[efc|^Ô` arW/z|v�l#efn[ef`|^Ôn�oSn�Z]U@\R�T'h�h�h­}O®�P � �KTCwX²tr�| zts?sg[_z��A\Sw%u�y]\?\?Y#�\S��¾���¬�®«W��@UPY+w%¬)�{ztU=oS^g`|®«vgn@wgW�^dv�{±�dÃt^XW ^XvgW�^G��hSj@U@^gU­\�W Z]j § ef^gc��_o § efU=YCW'Y]j § e«j@W�®Nj=`�Y[Y]U@®«W ³Z]ef`�^G�FN©^KPlb'cZegfljm�PSR�wgVXW c|U@n1umz|²Z[�u?ugy�w±yZ\tY|z#�

y]rS�¡qt�±}g�OL�W Y[Y]efn�W ^Xv¢�I�rh_Z]U@V § U@^dn@�RÃÀj@`�\��def^gU+v¸j@` Y]^dU=Y�W�^dv U+vgc�U!vSU=Z]U@j=Z]` Y+�QN©^ � � ¯t��°m*������ct�5j�cA�Z Zf«wSVdW�c|U=n.y¥uw�Z[dygx_y|w±y]\?Y?Y#�

y�y|�z���NC��L�W Y[Z]®fU=o_��û®fef^dU+W'Y­\/U=Z § `#v!au` Y�Y]U@j@`�^dn�Z[Y]�gj=Z]ef`|^Ôa:Y]`�\ ®fef^dU@n�W�^dvRVJ`|ef^_Z]n@��Np^±P-bdcZegfTAjljm7wSVXW c|U@n1Y?Y|²Z[wY?Y��_w yZ\t\�x#�

y+²#�.hJ��nGW+lmU+W��7���1�dct������b�°Kc' ;�²��°t�������³c( k´µe��t����bd�t�¥f�}p���dctb�°A�U�����������A����ct���-�t������¶�¶�� ��e��t®����ct���]�ª{ § T¼Z § U=n[e«n@w{N(o�z�N©Ã.wByZ\t\?s#�

y@zS��{±�N{�Y]e¯Z]j § U=Z[Z)W ^Xv¸Ã��O^Jefn[n[U=Y]\�W�^7��¹Üe«vgU/�XW n[U@®fef^dU�n�Z]U=Y]U@`Ô\�W'Z]j § e«^gcg�²Np^5P-bdcZegfSTAjljmGwVdW�c�U@n��?xAug[��As?rSw7}|W�^#�XW'Y[oIy]\?\?Y#�

y¥ug�¡qt��zt` Z § ¬�U@®f®½wBÃ.��^Befn[n[U=Y]\�W ^GwJT��J¾d`�Y]n�o#Z § wXW�^dvÔ}g�*���d^dvSo_��{�®«W�^XW'Y­`��S¨©U@j=Z­Y]U@j=`|c|^ge¯Z]e«`�^�gn[ef^dc�VSY]` ¨©U@j=Z]eflmU�n § W VJU­Y]U@VgY]U=n[U@^_ZCW Z]ef`|^7�lT���jm7w7yZs{ª¿²t«PwGy]\?\?x#�

yZx#�¡qt�|h#j § \/e9vBwZz�����` § Y+w�W�^dv§qt�tM�W �djC� § W�c�U|��q�`|\/VXW'Y]ef^dctW�^Xv.U@l�W�®f�XW'Z]e«^gc�ef^_Z]U=Y]U@n�Z VJ`�ef^#Z]n@�Np^QP-bdcZegfpTAjljmGwSVdW�c|U=n�² z?rZ[S²�z?x#w y]\?\?Y#�

y]sS�¡qt�ªh#j § \/e«výW ^Xv´Ã.�S^Jefn[n[U=Y]\�W�^7�ÖÃt�gZ]`�\�W Z]efji®«ef^gU�\�W Z]j § ef^gcIW j=Y]`|n[n�l#efU=¬�n@�·N©^¸P-bdcZegfjm�PSR�wSVdW�c|U=nists?sg[ws��_y|w yZ\t\��_�

yZ�#� n��$hJ��h § W�Vge¯Y]`g� �O¹ ��� � ���?� °A���6�±c' �T����Z�w�Q�%�dº¥������e����]� { § T Z § U@n[efn@w$kt^deflmU=Y]n[e¯ZpoÖ` aqts#a:`�YCv7wgb�^dc�®9W ^XvBwNyZ\t\|z#�

y]YS��Ã���h § W�n § �dWS� ¦ Y]ef®fe«^gU+W Y]e¯ZpoÜef^Ýl#efn[�XW ®�Y]U@j@`�c|^gefZ]ef`�^µ�_oÐW�®fefc|^d\/U=^#Z+�2Np^©Plb'cZegfihkjljmGwl|`|®f�d\/U.y|wXVdW�c�U@nUuw�t\Z[wu?Ytugwp�RW@oºyZ\t\tug�

y]\S��T)�BhSef^gj@®«W�e¯Y+w�L)��q § Y]efn�Z]U@^gn[U@^GwBW ^Xv±qt��z�`�Z § ¬�U@®f®���ktn[ef^dc�Z § U�Y]U@®«W'Z]e«`�^°�JU=Z©¬�U@U@^°W/Vd®«W�^gUVSY]` ¨©U@j=Z]efl#e¯Z©o�W�^Xv�Z § U�a:�d^dvdW�\/U=^#ZCW ®B\�W Z[Y]e¯sB�ªh�q.N�Ã�wByZ\?\?x#�

²ArS�¡�I�Jb��7h#VJU=Z]n]W��#efn­W ^XvÔ}g�JÃt®f`|ef\/`|^g`|n@��h#Z[Y]�gj=Z]�gY]U�a9Y]`|\ \/`�Z]ef`|^Ô�gn[e«^gc�®«ef^gU)j@` Y[Y]U@n[VJ`|^dvS³U=^dj@U@n@�.T���jm7w{u�ª�z�«�|fyZ�#y�[dyZY�zSw�yZ\t\?rS�

²_y|�¡qt�db$�Jh#VgY]ef^dc�U=Y+� �1�dct�²����b�°��t��� � ���?� °A����� c' 1P-bdc(»Z��e¥���6¯t�¡�?¶���e����]��¾gY]U@U@\�W ^GwByZ\tstug�²�²#�¡qt� ¦ W@og®f` Y+w7{ �XT­U@�JU@lmU=j|wBW�^dvÔ}g�p�RW�®fef�J�kz�U@j@`�^dn�Z[Y]�djPZ]e«^gc�VJ`|®¯o § U+v#YCW�®±\/`#vSU@®fn�`�a�W Y]j § e¯³

Z]U=j=Z]�gYCW ®Gn[j@U=^dU@n$a:Y]`�\MV § ` Z]`|c YCW�V § n@�FN©^KPlb'cZegfphkjljmG�XhSVSY]ef^dc|UPY[³�yrU=Y]®«W�cSwGy]\?\tsS�² zS��{±��L)�BhJ� ¦ ` Y[Y�W ^XvRT��g¹»�*���gY[YCW@o_�tq��SZ]®«efU=Y�vgUPZ]U@j=Z]ef`|^°W ^XvR\/`�Z]ef`�^Ôn[U@c|\/U@^_ZCW'Z]e«`�^G�1N©^

P-bdcZe �XPST'h©�%���{��ctbi¼*�X����ct�am%TCwgVXW c|U@nUumz|²Z[�u?umz#w*M�`|n�Z]`�^GwJhSU@VºyZ\?\�zS�²gug��{±�.L)��hJ� ¦ `�Y[YRW�^dvÜÃ.�1^Jefn[n[U=Y]\�W�^7�À{±UPY[au`�Y]\�W ^dj@Uºj § W YCW j=Z]U=Y]ef�+W'Z]`|^Ý`�a.au�d^dvdW \/U@^_ZCW�®

\�W'Z[Y]e¯sU@n�Z]ef\�W Z]ef`|^Ö�d^dvgU=Y�e«\�W c|UÔvSU@c�YCW�vdW'Z]e«`�^G�a�#��e��X�����¸mp�6����ct�a�t��� � ¶�¶�� ��e��t����ct�{�Cw\X| zm²#y�[#z�z|zSw y]\?\?�#�

²tx#��{±�XL.�ghB� ¦ `�Y[Y�W ^XviÃ.�{^Jefn[n[U=Y]\�W�^7�~z�`|�d�gn�Z$VXW'YCW�\/U=Z]UPY]e«�@W Z]ef`|^�W�^Xv�j@`�\/Vd�gZCW'Z]ef`|^i`�aNZ § UZ[Y]e¯a:`_j+W�®7Z]U@^dn[` Y+�lT����Z�w�;�A���5mp������cA�5j�ct�i¶��X�����w��wGyZxX| xt\#y�[ws?r�x_w�yZ\?\?�#�

²AsS� n��lyªW�^½¬�`_`|®½wi�I��{�Y]`_U=n[\�W�^dn@w�W ^XvÝÃ.�1^Jefn[n[U=Y]\�W�^7�¾¬tY]`��dVdef^gcÐW ^XvÜef^Sl�W Y]e«W ^#Z]n!�dn�³ef^gc/Vd®«W�^dW Y § `|\/`�®«`�c|efU@n@��N©^À¿ÁctbdÂA�'�{c�¶·ct�·�1�dct�²����b���e��?�p�#cZ���¥� ���X�Á�A���²T��{¯A�tb����t�����S ]ctbj�cA�i¶��X����bQm*������ct�d�gx�e«vSe9W ^Rk�^geflmU=Y]n[e¯Z©oi{ Y]U@n[n@wNy]\?\?x#�

²t�#�¡qt�.^JU@®f®fU=Y+�ÃP-bdc�»g�de¥����¯t��� �F¹ �%�K�t���±hl�{e]� ���w�d�t�Àj��?� ��Ä¥bd�A����ct�£���Àj�ct�i¶��X���/m*������ct�Ã�A����6�{� � ¶�¶�� ��e��t����cA�·c' Q}p�Xb������k���²���{����ct���t�~P1��bde���¶�����cA�d��{ § TÀZ § U@n[efn@w�zt`��J`�Z�y�efn;¬tY]`|�gVGwN�oiz1N�ÃÝhS`�V § e9W'³pÃt^_Z]efVJ`|®fefn@wNyZ\t\?s#�

²AYS�¡^±�?^ § W�^gcgwAz.� T­UPY]e«j § U�wmq)��¾XW �dc�U=YCW�n@wmW�^Xv;Å)�tnG�g`|^dcS�gÃýY]`|�g�dn�Z Z]U@j § ^ge¦_#�gUªa:`�Yr\�W Z]j § ef^dcZp¬�`��g^dj+W ®fe«�SYCW Z]U+vRef\�W c|U@n�Z § Y]`��dc § Z § U­Y]U@j=` l|U=Y[o�` a Z § U��g^d�#^d`+¬�^�U=VdefVJ`|®«W Ytc|U=`|\/U=Z[Y[o_�� b���� ¤Se¥���?��T������¥��� �¦�w����e��Pw%�tYX| Y��Z[dy|y]\Sw yZ\t\�x_�

ömå